Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Hiromi Nakamura-Thomas, Leah R. Van Antwerp, Moses Ikiugu, Patricia J. Scott and Tore Bonsaksen
T
he title indicated that an light and reflect on some of the
emphasis of the institute issues that were raised during the
was on the application institute, and that have been of
of Kielhofner’s model (Kielhofner, particular interest to us – however,
2008) in diverse practice contexts. it represents only a small part of
Second, it indicated that such the Institute and should be read
application required collaborative bearing that limitation in mind.
efforts from academia and practice
in partnership. The co-chairs of the A TRIBUTE TO GARY KIELHOFNER
institute, Patricia J. Scott (Indiana A tribute to Gary Kielhofner set
University) and Renée R. Taylor Dr. Patricia J Scott, and AOTA President the tone for the Institute. This
(University of Illinois at Chicago), Dr. Virginia Stoffel are promoting the tribute was made to commemo-
stated that the aim of the institute conference. rate the fifth anniversary of his
was «to advance theory and evi- untimely death in 2010. There
dence-based practice using MOHO was a stark similarity to the
through showcasing the latest commentary by Florence Clark,
developments in MOHO research, then president of the American
education and clinical application» Occupational Therapy Asso-
(MOHO Web, 2014). In reaching for ciation (AOTA), who said the
this aim, 77 abstracts from scho- following in her 2010 tribute to
lars based in fifteen countries were Gary Kielhofner: «Evidence of
selected for presentation. the influence of Gary’s vision to
The presentations were promote large-scale change and
concerned with one or more of to increase the power of occupa-
the four major topics highlighted tional therapy in health care was
during the institute: Collaborative evident at the First International
partnerships, MOHO in broader Institute on the Model of Human
perspective, international colla- Occupation. […] Dr. Kielhofner
borations, and teaching MOHO to influenced the thinking of current
support translation into practice. and future occupational therapy
The aim of this article is to high- Gary Kielhofner, the founder of MOHO.
62 Ergoterapeuten #6–2015
– AKTUELT –
Ergoterapeuten #6–2015 63
– AKTUELT –
64 Ergoterapeuten #6–2015
– AKTUELT –
al., 1986). The original instrument medical setting, were presented by the OMP. These other models
had two parts: Part I indicated (Bonsaksen & Scott, 2015), as was become complementary models
the person’s roles in the past, at the ongoing psychometric study of practice (CMPs). An example
present, and in the future, whe- on the instrument (Forsyth & Pri- would be the use of MOHO as the
reas Part II indicated the value or, 2015). The psychometric study OMP to enable return to parti-
placed on each of the roles. The is based on a general population cipation in valued roles. In the
extension of the Role Checklist sample of more than 800 persons process of restoring participation,
into Part III and Part IV was initi- living in the UK, USA, Switzerland, a biomechanical approach to
ated due to Scott’s observation Japan, Sweden, and Norway. The restore skill deficits could be used
that having more valued roles aim of this study is to examine the as a CMP to enable occupational
was not necessarily perceived as cross-cultural conceptual validity performance. Furthermore, the
positive among clients, and that of the Role Checklist, initially process is dynamic and as the
the impact of roles depended on assuming that it measures only therapeutic situation changes,
a person’s level of functioning. one underlying concept, namely the OMP can become the CMP or
To understand the significance of participation. even be dropped altogether and
roles in a person’s life, one also a CMP can assume primacy as the
has to consider role performance INTEGRATING THE MOHO WITH OMP momentarily.
(role functioning) and satisfaction OTHER CONCEPTUAL MODELS In a research study, Ikiugu
or dissatisfaction with roles. One of the sessions focused on and Smallfield (2011) found that
The symposium on the RC v2 integrating MOHO with other teaching students how to use this
reported about the ongoing work occupational therapy theoreti- framework helped improve their
on establishing a procedure for cal conceptual practice models. clinical skills overall and raise
scoring the extended instrument One of the presentations was their level of confidence in the-
(Scott & Latham, 2015). There was Ikiugu’s eclectic framework for ory application. The presentation
also a report about the tremendo- combining theoretical concep- on this framework generated a
us interest among MOHO scholars tual practice models in clinical spirited discussion about whet-
around the world in translating decision-making (Ikiugu, 2015), a her MOHO should be considered
the instrument into their respecti- presentation based on several of invariably as the overall guide to
ve languages. More importantly, his previous works (Ikiugu, 2007; therapy, or any “occupation-fo-
perhaps, guidelines for how such Ikiugu & Smallfield, 2011; Ikiugu, cused” model can be the OMP
translation procedures should Smallfield, & Condit, 2009). This while other models (known by
be carried out, was explicated framework was developed ba- some as frames of reference) are
(Haglund & Scott, 2015). Later in sed on the strategic eclecticism incorporated as CMPs (Wong &
the Institute Kristjana Fenger and principles in psychology, to guide Fisher, 2015). Others questioned
Leah Van Antwerp presented a systematic, logical, and dynamic whether eclecticism was viable as
feasibility study on the implemen- combination of strategies from a a competent form of practice, or
tation of these translation guide- variety of theoretical conceptual whether it was what could be ter-
lines into Icelandic (Van Antwerp practice models, so that thera- med “eclectic nothingness”. Many
& Fenger, 2015). This study is also pists practicing eclecticism could people in the audience thought
being carried out by Fengyi Kuo clearly explicate their theoretical that the idea of an eclectic fra-
examining the feasibility of the reasoning. The process consists mework to guide application of
translation guidelines in Mandarin of choosing, based on the client’s theory in occupational therapy
Chinese contexts. Scott’s group presenting issue, an organizing made sense, even if used in a
of researchers investigating the model of practice (OMP) to act modified form as suggested by
RC v2, known as the Internatio- as a lens through which the Wong and Fisher (2015). In view
nal Role Alliance for the study of client’s occupational performan- of the Institute being specifically
Participation (IRAP; Scott, 2015), ce concerns can be understood. dedicated to the promotion and
is also underway with several As assessment and intervention dissemination of work related
studies. Two clinical case studies, continues, strategies are chosen to the MOHO, it was also noted
exploring the use of the RC v2 from other theoretical models to that Ikiugu’s presentation of his
in a psychiatric hospital and in a cover gaps that are not addressed eclectic framework epitomized
Ergoterapeuten #6–2015 65
– AKTUELT –
the overall tone of the Institute. ments of the profession – although of Human Occupation, Indianapo-
Participants celebrated MOHO as with a dominance from the acade- lis,USA.
Haglund, L., & Scott, P. J. (2015).
the most widely used occupati- mic segment. As during the pre-
Translation Guidelines for MOHO
on-based model in the world, yet ceding years, much work is being Assessment: Role Checklist v2. Paper
kept an open mind as to the place put into developing and validating presented at the The 4th Internatio-
of CMPs to compliment MOHO in tools for practice and research. nal Institute on the Model of Human
guiding interventions. More recent developments seem to Occupation, Indianapolis, USA.
be focused on using the MOHO as Ikiugu, M. N. (2007). Integrating concep-
INTEGRATING THE MOHO INTO a theoretical viewpoint from which tual models of practice. In M. N. Iki-
THE CURRICULUM to address social issues of global ugu, Psychosocial conceptual practice
models in occupational therapy:
The symposium on the integration importance. The model appears to
Building adaptive capability (pp. 307-
of MOHO across the curriculum contribute to the integration of oc- 314). St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier.
explored the use of MOHO to cupational therapy as a profession Ikiugu, M. N. (2015). Using Theory as a
promote best practice in teaching, – the many participants from many Guide to Clinical Decision-Making in
learning, and clinical learning for different corners of the world cle- Occupational Therapy: An Eclectic
occupational therapy students. arly indicate that there are strong Framework. Paper presented at the
Jakobs (2015) presented a cur- and unifying elements to it that The 4th International Institute on the
ricular model using video-taped occupational therapists across the Model of Human Occupation, Indian-
apolis, USA.
simulated interviews utilizing world can relate to and value. An
Ikiugu, M. N., & Smallfield, S. (2011).
the Occupational Performance open-minded relationship towards Ikiugu’s ecclectic method of combi-
History Interview II (OPHI-II) to other models, as demonstrated at ning theoretical conceptual practice
facilitate discussion of MOHO this Institute, may challenge the models in occupational therapy.
concepts during normative and MOHO. However, such intellectual Australian Journal of Occupatio-
critical life events in transitional challenge is a necessary, and the- nal Therapy, 58(6), 437-446. doi:
case studies. Many presentations refore welcomed, part of scientific 10.1111/j.1440-1630.2011.00968.x
in both the symposium and other progress and is ultimately in the Ikiugu, M. N., Smallfield, S., & Condit, C.
(2009). A framework for combining
sessions explored the challenges best interest of the clients served
theoretical conceptual practice mo-
and benefits of integrating MOHO by our profession. dels in occupational therapy practice.
throughout an entire occupational Canadian Journal of Occupational
therapy curriculum. Examples of References Therapy, 76(3), 180-188.
MOHO-based curriculum were pre- Jakobs, U. (2015). How to Teach an
sented from Switzerland (Jakobs, Bonsaksen, T., & Scott, P. J. (2015). Clini- Applied Approach to Understanding
2015), Chile (Vottero Mas & Aceve- cal Applications of the Role Checklist the Model of Human Occupation - The
v2. Paper presented at the The 4th Occupational Performance History
do, 2015), the UK (Yazdani, 2015),
International Institute on the Model of Interview II in Simulated Client
China (Zhang, 2015), Norway
Human Occupation, Indianapolis, USA. Interviews to Novice Students of the
(Magne & Eerola, 2015), and the Fisher, G., Forsyth, K., Harrison, M., Bachelor in Occupational Therapy at
USA (O’Brien & Tumbleson, 2015), Angarola, R., Kayhan, E., Noga, P., . . . the University of Applied Sciences
speaking to the impact of MOHO Irvine, L. (2014). Residential Environ- Zurich (ZHAW), Switzerland. Paper
on the education of students in a ment Impact Scale (REIS), Version presented at the The 4th Internatio-
range of countries across geograp- 4.0. Chicago, IL.: University of Illinois nal Institute on the Model of Human
hical and cultural regions. at Chicago. Occupation, Indianapolis, USA.
Fisher, G., & Kayhan, E. (2010). Develo- Kielhofner, G. (2005). Scholarship and
ping the Residential Environment practice: Bridging the divide. Ameri-
CONCLUSIONS
Impact Survey Instrument through can Journal of Occupational Therapy,
Five years after the passing of Gary Faculaty-Practitioner Collabo- 59(2), 231-239.
Kielhofner, his Model of Human Oc- ration. Occupational Therapy in Kielhofner, G. (2008). A Model of Human
cupation is still robust. Worldwide Health Care, 26(4), 224-239. doi: Occupation. Theory and Application.
the MOHO is the most researched 10.3109/07380577.2012.723152 (4 ed.). Baltimore, MD: Lippincott
and practiced model of occupati- Forsyth, K., & Prior, S. (2015). Psycho- Williams & Wilkins.
onal therapy (Lee, 2010), and the metric Properties of the Role Che- Lee, J. (2010). Achieving Best Practice: A
cklist. Paper presented at the The 4th Review of Evidence Linked to
recent Institute demonstrated sub-
International Institute on teh Model
stantial interest in it from all seg-
66 Ergoterapeuten #6–2015
– AKTUELT –
Occupation-Focused Practice Models. Scaffa, M. (2001). Occupational therapy on the Model of Human Occupation,
Occupational Therapy in Health Care, in community-based practice settings. Indianapolis, USA.
24(3), 206-222. Philadelphia, PA: F.A. Davis. Vottero Mas, C., & Acevedo, M. J. (2015).
Magne, T. A., & Eerola, M. C. (2015). Te- Scott, P. J. (2015). The Role Checklist Challenges in Undergraduate Edu-
aching MOHO in Trondheim, Norway - Version 2: Quality of Performance. cation in the Training of the Model
From Concept to Therapeutic Process. Retrieved 19.01.2015, from http:// of Human Occupation (MOHO) in
Paper presented at the The 4th www.rcv2qp.com/ Chile. Paper presented at the The 4th
International Institute on the Model of Scott, P. J., & Latham, K. (2015). The International Institute on the Model of
Human Occupation, Indianapolis, USA. Role Checklist v2: Development of a Human Occupation, Indianapolis, USA.
MOHO Web. (2014). Model of Human scoring system. Paper presented at Wong, S. R., & Fisher, G. (2015). Compa-
Occupation - Theory and Application. the The 4th International Institute ring and using occupation-focused
Retrieved 26.10.2015, from https:// on the Model of Human Occupation, models [early online]. Occupational
www.cade.uic.edu/moho/default.aspx Indianapolis, USA. Therapy in Health Care, 1-19. doi:
O’Brien, J., & Tumbleson, J. (2015). Taylor, R. R., Davidson, D., Forsyth, K., 10.3109/07380577.2015.1010130
Teaching Students to Apply Model of Scott, P. J., De las Heras, C. G., Pepin, Yazdani, F. (2015). Shift towards Spiral
Human Occupation to Occupational G., & Tsang, H. (2015). Keynote & Curriculum: Integration of the Model
Therapy Practice. Paper presented Panel on MOHO: Impact on Global of Human Occupation across the Oc-
at the The 4th International Institute Social Issues. Paper presented at the cupational Therapy UG Course. Paper
on the Model of Human Occupation, The 4th International Institute on the presented at the The 4th Internatio-
Indianapolis, USA. Model of Human Occupation, Indian- nal Institute on the Model of Human
Oakley, F., Kielhofner, G., Barris, R., & apolis, USA. Occupation, Indianapolis, USA.
Reichler, R. (1986). The Role Che- Van Antwerp, L., & Fenger, K. (2015). Zhang, J. (2015). The Role of Students in
cklist: Development and empirical Proposed Translation Guidelines for Occupational Therapy Development:
assessment of reliability. Occupatio- the Role Checklist Version 2: Quality A Report from Mainland China. Paper
nal Therapy Journal of Research, 6(3), of Performance: A Feasibility Study in presented at the The 4th Internatio-
158-170. Iceland and China. Paper presented at nal Institute on the Model of Human
the The 4th International Institute Occupation, Indianapolis, USA.
Ergoterapeuten #6–2015 67