Goals and objectives: problem description
Description the topic is relevant, very
useful but not very ambitious.
it is material and we would like
it to be ideational
Nadine I think this is very relevant and
useful for the students. it seems
ambitious and there is a good
initiative behind this.
Mathias Relevant and useful for many
students.
Nicklas JEspersen Hmm i could see it being good
for the school atmosphere to
have some place outside of the
classrooms. benefits all students
Is the problem well-defined,
and shows a thourough
investigation of the relevant
field? is it built on
informaiton and references?
do they argue properly for
their cause?
the problem is rather obvious
and understandable but there
is no investigation. they do
argue properly for their cause
and I do think they give some
information and references to
there not being a place to sit
and put their tea/coffe on the
window sill.
Obvious problem, but vaguely
argued for.
not that good a problem
description or explanation of
how the project will solve the
problem but in their defense it
is pretty simple. I wouldn't say
they argue well for their case
(they try though).
Nicklas Andersen Appears to be relevant as it
benefits all students.
Frederikke The topic is relevant and very
useful.
Very vague problem
description and slightly unclear
in its wording. However,
despite that, it does seem
clear what the issue is -
although it could've been
elaborated further.
The problem is investigated
thouroughly, but is not based
on analysis and needs of the
targetgroup. Maybe use
interviews or surveys to back
up your identification of the
problem.
project goal and objectives sustainability target group

Do they show specific
objectives that can be
measured and monitored? do
they have an overall
development objective or aim
they will tap into? is it based
on a specifically usefull
methodology?
how is the follow up plan
described? does it seem
realistic? does it seem
ambitious enough? how will it
be reported to STUDEM? do
they have a monitoring plan?
do they have an evaluation
plan? If so, is it satisfyng?
Is the chosen target group
relevant and in the scope of
STUDEM? Does it reflect a
cooperation within the council
or few relevant active
members?

they show no specific objectives
that can be measure or
monitired, there is no overall
development objective but there
seems to be a clear aim: comfort
for students and a possible place
to learn before classes.
the follow up plan described is It is relevant and in the scope of
based solely on putting pictures STUDEM through development
on their facebook page and and the socialization of students.
commenting about it. it does This does not verify if this reflects
seem realistic and ambitious cooperation (demcoratic voting)
enough. its a simple request and within the council or its active
an obvious need for benches. the members.
monitoring is unclearn and
evaluation are unclear. it is
satisfying enough by posting
pictures and seeing comments to
how beneficial this might be to
their school environment,
education and social system

The messure for the succes of
the project is unclear since the
solution and goal seems to be
the same. It's a good goal, but
not meaningfully messurable.
Evaluation in form of promotion Large group will be able to both
on social media. The follow-up use and benefit from the project.
would to build more benches
which seems like a good idea but
an evaluation is needed to
actually know that.

Hmm no, it is a simple material To also install outdoors. Not that Wide group, it will benefit all
improvement to the environment. ambitious. their form of evaluation students
is to post pictures to facebook of
people sitting on them.
As it's a simple material To also install benches outdoors As it's aimed at all students it's a
improvement, there is no clear seems to be a logical and realistic wide group, all within the scope of
timeline or set of objectives to be goal, although not very ambitious. the STUDEM project as it
monitored or folowed up on. encourages socialising and
therefore the formation of
communities - although it isn't
directly relevant to the
establishment of democratic
structures..

The goal is well reasoned but not There is no plan for maintenance the target group is relevant and is
distinguished from the of the benches. included well in the reasoning.
development objective. Try to The promotion plan is good, but
divide the overall aim from how it mre effort could be put to how to
taps into a elaborated promote it on the school.
development of the learning
ability. The reasoning of rest as a
necessity for learning ability is
good, use more time to elaborate
on this.
budget activity plan funding or not

Are the amounts based on
investigations? does it seem
realistic? are there any post of
expenditures that seem
unnecessary?
is it well scheduled and prepared? Yes' or 'no'
does it seem realistic? Is it
thought through? do they
consider all relevant phases of
analysis, implementation,
facilitation and reporting?

yes, they attached a bill for how It seems realistic and for sure though Yes
much the benches are projected through, minus the delivery service
to cost which seems realistic. fee. they need to improve on the
there seems to no expenditures analysis and reporting a bit more.
but im curious if there will be an
additional shipping cost that is not
factured in.

Seems good and reasonable with Realistic, though there are lacking
the bill attached, but it is unclear considerations as meantioned.
what the process was to get this
price and the other options.

No it doesn't seem that way. Seems realistic but because it is Yes

Though it seems resemable that pretty simple. hmm as far as i can
they found a price of 6000lei and see they haven't thought about
would pay for the rest themselves. delivery or how to get them from the
store to the school
It seems that they've found a It seems that the means of transport (m)
price for the benches, although it hasn't been considered - but from
isn't really clear how or where brief mention of transport in the
they intend to buy them. application this isn't clear.

Yes, very good idea to attach the The activity is not including a
bill! preparation phase in which prices
and companies are considered in
terms of quality. it seems realistic but
the analysis could be better
described.