You are on page 1of 39

WIRES AND TRANSPOSED CABLES IN TRANSFORMERS

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller

ESSEX Germany GmbH

TRANSFORM Partner
Vita

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller

Studies at University

„Metallurgy with focus metal forming“ at RWTH Aachen

PhD at RWTH Aachen

Professional Carreer

Quality Engineer at Kabelwerke Rheydt

Project Engineer at Lackdraht Union GmbH, Arolsen

Head of R&D Lacroix & Kress GmbH, Bramsche

Head of R&D Essex Germany GmbH, Arolsen

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 2


Continuous Transposed Cables

Energy Efficient Transformers

CTC
Continuous Transposed Cable
Source: Siemens AG

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 3


A brief history

1912 Ludwig Roebel invents single insulated and


transposed strands to replace the large
cross-section conductors that were currently
in use within generator designs

Since 1940 Transformer designs using the idea of


Ludwig Roebel

new challenges relating to efficiency, profitability and


environmental compatibility

CTC requirements

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 4


Why do we use CTC?

high flexibility Fast and efficient


winding of the active
part of the
power transformer
length due to transposition.
compensation

reduced electrical Reduced impact of S e1


I
losses magnetic field by A1
increased surface due E
to single isolated strips B
and transposition. A2

improved cooling (skin + proximity effect) e2

S i

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 5


Requirement to wires in Transformer

Conductivity
Conductor

Mechanic strength
Varnish-insulation
Chemical strength

Cable-insulation
Electric strength

Construction
Lifetime

Windability Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 6


CTC construction

CTC – build up Properties influenced by

Conductor

Cost pressure
Insulation
Insulation
Bond Coat
Bond Coat
Construction
Construction
Process
Reel-type
Process

Reel-type

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 7


Conductor

Varnish-insulation

Cable-insulation

Construction

Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 8


Conductor: Material

Rod

Soft Cu-ETP1
Copper Cu-OF1
Hard E.g. CPR1, CPR2, CPR3

CuAg 0,03
Conductor Copper alloys Hard
CuAg 0,10

+ low cost
Aluminium - low conductivity and stiffness

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 9


Conductor: Material

Copper Aluminium CCA* (15 %)

Aspect red-orange metallic Bi-Metall


% of geosphere 0,01 % 7,75 % ---
Density 8,92 g/m³ 2,70 g/m³ 3,63 g/m³
Melting point 1083 ºC 658 ºC 658 ºC
Linear heat expansion 17,0 x 10-6 1/K 23,5 x 10-6 1/K
Young-modulus 13,0 x 104 MPa 7,1 x 104 MPa
Thermal conductivity 385 W/mK 230 W/mK 240 W/mK
Electric conductivity > 58,58 m/(Ω mm²) > 35,67 m/(Ω mm²) > 37,35 m/(Ωmm²)*
Price (15.04.2013) 5,741 € / kg 1,416 € / kg metall+forming
General remarks ↑ welding ↓ welding ↑ welding
↑ forming high oxidation rate ↓ recycling
low oxidation rate ↓ bending ↓ bending
↓ plastic flow * ↑ = copper @ 5 MHz

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 10


Page 10
Conductor: Material

Electric Conductivity
Conductivity
60  Copper > 58,58
Cd
Ag, Zn  pure Copper ≈ 60
55 Sn  Silver ≈ 62
electric conductivity [m/Omm²]

AL
 Aluminium ≈ 36
50 Mn

Impurities reduces conductivity


45
Silver has less impact to conductivity
Co
40
Hardening reduces conductivity
Fe
35 Cu-ETP1 and Cu-OFE 99,99 %
P
copper content
30
0 ,0 0 0 ,0 2 0 ,0 4 0 ,0 6 0 ,0 8 0 ,10 0 ,12

m ixture in m ass-%
source: DKI

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 11


Conductor: Material

Mechanical strength
creep behavior of materials after
1.000 h
OF-Cu Ag
material begins to anneal with
temperature
impurity silver enhances
mechanical behavior without
dramatic impact to the
conductivity

OF-Cu
Typical alloy CuAg0,03 and
CuAg0,10

source: DKI

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 12


Conductor: Material

Copper Rod Production

Metallurgy Electrolyse Continuous Rod Casting

Up-Cast Verfahren

Source: Aurubis Source: Aurubis

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 13


Conductor: Material

Rectangular Wire Production

Pre-material Drawing Rolling

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 14


Conductor: Material

Conform Technology

Advantage Disadvantage
• Direct production from rod to square • “Slow” production process
size • Sensitive to cleanness off pre-material
• No annealing necessary • Soft material sensitive to scratches and
• Clean surface of the pressed material oxidation
(no fat, flaks, …) • Increased copper scrap
• Set up times low
• Flexible in dimension and shape
• No emulsion necessary

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 15


Conductor

Varnish-insulation

Cable-insulation

Construction

Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 16


Varnish insulation: Material

Polyvinylacetal Excellent adhesion, flexibility and oil resistance

Polyesterimid + Increased heat resistance


Polyamidimid Comparable with impregnation varnishes

strand
Standard Concentric
Epoxy-
Bond coat Improved Partial

PET- foil, Aramid- paper,


Specials Prepreg, glass yarn, …

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 17


Varnish insulation: Material

Electric Insulation Insulation types

today 90 % PVA - class 120 Introduction of isolation types


break down voltage > 50 V/µm
reduced contact failure
insulation resistance > 500 M km 240°C Polyimid 1958
Polyamidimid 1964
Polyesterimid 1962
better workability
higher temperature class Polyester 1955
higher abrasion withstand
higher bond strength Polyurethane 1950
120°C Polyvinylacetal 1938

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 18


Varnish Insulation: possible solutions

Polyvinylacetal Polyurethan T. Poly. (imid) Polyamidimid Polyimid


+
Polyamidimid
Temperature-index Temperature-index Temperature-index Temperature-index Temperature-index
120 ºC 180 ºC 200 ºC 220 ºC 240 ºC
Heat shock Heat shock Heat shock Heat shock Heat shock
155 ºC 200 ºC 220 ºC 240 ºC 260 ºC
Resoftening temp. Resoftening temp. Resoftening temp. Resoftening temp. Resoftening temp.
> 215 ºC > 250 ºC > 340 ºC > 400 ºC > 500 ºC
soldering Soldering soldering soldering soldering
no yes no no no
Chem. Resistance Chem. Resistance Chem. Resistance Chem. Resistance Chem. Resistance
very good good good very good very good

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 19


Varnish insulation: Material

Bond Coat (Epoxy) Mechanical strength


(bond coat)
increased strength at working 6000

condition (5 x stiffness @ 120 °C) 5000


bonded

4000

Force [N]
compatibility with transformer oil 3000

2000

hardening during drying process 1000 not bonded

(start @ 90 °C depending on type 0


0,0 0,5 1,0 1,5 2,0 2,5 3,0 3,5 4,0
Bending [m m ]
in hot air or vapour phase)
30
different application possible:
25 26,6

Stiffness factor
24,8
20
all around radial bond
15
simple usage 12,5
10

shelf life min. 6 month depending 5 7,8


6,4

bond type and climate 0


20°C 60°C 80°C 105°C 120°C
Temperatur

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 20


Varnish insulation: Application

Process Product
~ 26 m

Isolation increase:
~ 0,10 mm
10 layers with 0,005 mm
thickness
Bdv > 2 kV
Source MAG

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 21


Conductor

Varnish-insulation

Cable-insulation

Construction

Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 22


Cable insulation: Material

smooth But to but wrapping


Cellulose
Micro crepe staggering

High thermal resistance, high mechanic strength,


Aramid Resistance against oil,

Protection
Without wrapping paper *
Without inter column separator

Continuous Perforated* Aramid Gap


Transposed Cable

Cordex * PET Filament

Diamond* Aramid

* Essex Patente
Specials Glass yarn, …

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 23


Cable insulation: Material

Electric Insulation Paper types for electric insulation


advantage: Papertype Remarks

- thick insulation Kraft- Paper 5A2-1H1, paper with high purity


- dielectric strength Kraft- Paper, calendared 5A4-1M2, high density and break down voltage
in oil
Thermo stabilized 5A2-1M1, increased thermal resistance

different types: Thermo stabilized, 5A4-1M2, high density and break down voltage,
calendared increased thermal resistance
- Cellulose Thermo stabilized, Paper with high mechanical strength, used for outer
- Aramid calendared, crepe layers
Epoxy coated,
Bondable outer layers
Thermo stabilized
disadvantage:
Aramid High thermal resistance, used for traction transformers
- cooling behavior
- thermal aging Epoxy coated Aramid Bondable outer layers for traction transformers

Transformer- Pressboard P 2.1, inter column separator

Glass woven fabric Winding used for resin cast transformers

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 24


Cable insulation: Material

Electric Insulation CTC with improved cooling (low voltage winding)


for low voltage perforated Paperless CTC diamond Cordex
winding with
increased heat
transfer
increased filling
factor
reduced cooling

higher efficiency
in power transformers

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 25


Cable insulation: Process

Paper wrapping process Typical paper set up for CTC


application of inner layers
2 outer layers, 50 % staggering
inner layers but to but, ~ 30 % shifted

outer layer

inner layer

CTC

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 26


Conductor

Varnish-insulation

Cable-insulation

Construction

Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 27


Cable insulation: Construction

d n 1
pitch SR Radial Size HR = a E Z
n (odd numbers) 2
SR n 2
Transposing factor fR Radial Size HR = a E Z
b (even numbers) 2
d = Winding diameter Axial Size BA = 2 b E I Z
n = number of strands
n 1
b = width of conductor Intercolumn Paper I = b E
c = crank length (min. 8 mm) 2

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 28


Cable insulation: Construction

Dimension range of strands in CTC Limits of Transposed Cable

Transposition head

3,10 12,50 Radial size mm < 79


3,50
3,15 Axial size mm < 26
3,00
thickness [mm]

2,50
3,5 … 39 mm² Crank length mm 15 - 50
2,00
1,50 Geometry
1,00 1,00
Transposing factor >5
0,50
0,00 ratio width/thickness <8
1,00 3,00 5,00 7,00 9,00 11,00 13,00
width [mm]
Other dimension on request possible

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 29


Cable insulation: Construction

Limits of Transposed Cable Limits of Transposed Cable


the crank length increases with the the radial size is depended from
width of the strand ratio pitch / crank length
CTC with a high ratio width / Small transposing factors
height incline to tilt increases the radial size
c

HR

b SR/c

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 30


Conductor

Varnish-insulation

Cable-insulation

Construction

Process

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 31


CTC Production Process

Pay off Transposing Paper Wrapping Caterpillar Winder


head

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 32


CTC Production Process

Work principle

Stack pusher

Production
Counter holder*

Strand pusher

Rotation

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 33


Test and specification

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 34


Tests and specification

specification

Copper DIN 1977


Aluminium DIN EN 573-3
Rectangular magnet wire – general requirements IEC 60317-0-2
Magnet wire – specific requirements IEC 60317-..
Magnet wire – test method IEC 60851-..
Magnet wire – temperature index IEC 60172
Cellulosic paper IEC 60554
Aramid - Paper IEC 60819
Pressboard IEC 60641
Drums and spools DIN 46391/1, IEC 60264

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 35


Product test

Shorts in CTC

Bonding Elongation

Sizes Spring Back

CTC
Snap test Yield strength

Abrasion tan delta

Break Down
Adhesion
Voltage
Staggering;
Heat Shock
bulging

Oil Compatibility El. Resistance

Softening
Temperature
Test depending to magnet wire

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 36


Summary

Continuous Transposed Cable look simple but are a “high tech”


product
Continuous Transposed Cable are a customized product
A lot of things are possible with a close work together of the CTC
producer and the transformer producer

If the others belief, you're at the end,


now you really have to start.
Konrad Adenauer

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 37


Superior Essex

23 plants in 9 countries
in
America, Europe and Asia

Cable for telecomunication


Round and flat enameled wires out of
copper and aluminium
Covered products
Continuous Transposed Cables
Isolation varnishes
Copper – Rod

Member of the LS-Cable Group

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 38


Thank you very much
for your attention

Dr. Stefan Beckmöller, Essex Germany GmbH 06.06.2013 Page 39

You might also like