Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/233784413
CITATIONS READS
10 3,446
1 author:
Mary V. Seeman
University of Toronto
510 PUBLICATIONS 6,408 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mary V. Seeman on 31 May 2014.
Author's Copy
1
Parenting
Abstract
Aim: To understand the scope of the issue, to learn about the subjective
experiences of mothers and children, to appreciate the impact of psychotic
illness on children at various ages, and to review the necessary components of
intervention programs.
2
Parenting
Introduction:
The general impression in the medical community is that schizophrenia
always takes the form of a mental illness so severe and persistent that it all but
precludes “good enough” parenting. [1, 2] Because of the pessimism, mothers
with schizophrenia are given relatively little opportunity to establish their
parenting competence. Child welfare agencies, whose mandate is the safety
and well-being of children, are quick to intervene and remove a child from the
home of a mother with a psychotic illness. This is understandable since
children’s rights must take precedence over those of adults, children being
vulnerable and defenseless in the face of potential neglect or harm. Mothers
however, can be vulnerable as well, especially when they are ill, isolated, and
socially and economically disadvantaged, as happens frequently in association
with schizophrenia.
The nature of this illness is such that patients may not be aware they are ill.
This, too, is a vulnerability since symptoms are attributed to factors other than
illness and medical help is shunned.
Even those women who are in active treatment may stop taking antipsychotic
drugs once they become mothers because they equate “taking pills” with being
perceived as ill and, therefore, open to losing custody of their child. [3] They
stop treatment, hoping to impress child agencies by the fact that they are no
longer “on pills.” Agency staff, from their perspective, see this as “non-
compliance.” Another reason for stopping treatment is the sedation induced by
antipsychotic medications. Mothers, especially new mothers, want to stay
vigilant and so they discontinue sedating medications in order to be more
attentive to their infants’ cries, a paradox since, as a result of being good
3
Parenting
Also studied has been the risk of inherited psychiatric illness. This last
concern loomed large in the mid 20th century, with many countries in the
Western world and in Asia passing sterilization laws targeted at the mentally
ill. This was an attempt to stop inheritance of “the schizophrenia gene.” In the
1930s and 40s, between 200,00 and 400,000 mentally ill and mentally
disabled persons were sterilized in Germany, but also 65,000 Americans, 3000
Canadians and more in Scandinavian countries [6,7] and in Switzerland. The
numbers in Japan, China, and Korea are harder to ascertain. Sterilization of
less than perfect individuals was considered progressive during the first half of
the century, a scientific way of “purifying the race.”
4
Parenting
inheritance; they are mainly about safety and about the adequacy of mothers to
ensure optimal emotional and cognitive development of children.
Are these concerns warranted? What is the evidence about women with
schizophrenia, parenting ability and child outcome?
In the days when psychiatric patients were locked in asylums, there was little
chance for pregnancy. Nowadays, though individuals with schizophrenia in
most parts of the world still have fewer offspring than the general population,
the gap is quickly closing. The fertility ratio for those with schizophrenia (in
comparison to the general population) in a Swedish birth cohort for the years
1915-1929 was 0.42. [8] A two cohort (1918-1927 and 1932-1941) study, also
from Sweden, found the ratio to be 0.30 for men and 0.50 for women. [9] A
more recent birth cohort study (1950 to 1959) from Finland reported a ratio of
0.44 for men and 0.83 for women. [10] Though fertility for men with
schizophrenia remains relatively low, women with this diagnosis today are
parents almost as often as are other women. Approximately 30% of patients
with a first episode psychosis are already parents prior to their first admission
and, presumably, prior to receiving any treatment. [11] Treatment with the
older antipsychotics reduced fertility but this is no longer the case; [12]
women treated with newer drugs now have nearly as many children as women
who are free from this illness. Approximately half of all women with
schizophrenia are mothers. [13]
Despite the fact that they bear children as often as anyone else, mothers with
5
Parenting
schizophrenia may not end up being their children’s primary care providers.
[14] Some give their children up for adoption, though less so now than in the
past. Nowadays in North America, Children’s Aid agencies often apprehend
children when the mother is ill and (sometimes) return them when she is
better. Mothers may not always know how to get their children back. [15] All
parents with a diagnosis of serious mental illness are vulnerable to losing
custody of their children, most studies reporting rates of custody loss of about
60%. [16] In a study of nearly 5000 Medicaid-eligible women in Philadelphia,
mothers with serious mental illness (schizophrenia and major affective
disorder) were found to be almost three times as likely as other mothers to be
involved in the child welfare system or to have children placed outside the
home. [17] The reason for the high rate of child apprehension may be because
women with psychotic illnesses are inadequate mothers, but it may also be
because they are treated with unwarranted suspicion by child welfare agencies.
[18]
When mothers do retain legal custody, the children may, in reality, be brought
up by grandmothers, fathers, or other relatives and be consequently at risk for
inconsistent rearing by a succession of intermittent caregivers. Custody
awarded to grandparents is becoming increasingly commonplace in this
population [19]. This may work well, but may also be problematic because of
the grandparents’ age, health, and economic situation. Rates of disturbance for
children in kinship care are reported as being high, but not as high as for
children in foster care. [20-22] Children in foster care, and this bears
emphasis, are at higher risk of mental health problems than children reared by
their mentally ill mother. [23]
6
Parenting
The concerns raised about parenting in the context of schizophrenia are, first
and foremost, safety. Will the mother be able to ensure the physical care and
safety of her child? Will her symptoms or medication side effects – delusions
about neighbors, for instance, or apathy, or cognitive distortion, or sedation –
prevent her from being diligent in her care?
7
Parenting
illness and its optimal treatment, her strengths and challenges with regard to
parenting, and stages of child development as they apply to her child. An
important part of the assessment is direct observation of mother and child
interaction and an inquiry into the availability of social supports. [26]
8
Parenting
speak to the many obstacles that stand in the way of the goal: stigma of mental
illness, poverty, lack of support, lack of resources, role strain, cognitive
problems, ill health, side effects of medication, shame and guilt at decisions
impulsively taken. [34, 35]
Chernomas et al. [36] report that many women suffering from psychotic
illness face contradictory choices. They feel their isolation but do not initiate
friendships for fear of rejection. They crave intimate relationships but are
frightened into immobility lest they be taken advantage of, as that has been
their experience. They worry about taking antipsychotic drugs, especially
during pregnancy, but are afraid of what might happen if they stop. They
rejoice in motherhood (the love they feel, the sense of renewed purpose, the
positive identity of being a mother rather than “a schizophrenic,” the new
support they attract) but are often overcome by stress, exhaustion, fear of not
having enough money, fear of loss of custody, and also a vague angst that
their children are too much like them and may end up, like them, developing
schizophrenia. Several women interviewed for the Chermonas et al. study, had
lost their children to foster care or adoption and spoke of their deep and
unending grief and anger. The particular conditions of the mother-child
separation (degrees of choice, control, and the opportunity for ongoing
communication) can be crucial in determining the extent of psychological
harm to the mother. [37]
Dipple et al. [38] describe the experience of 58 mothers who were patients of
the psychiatric rehabilitation services in Leicester, U.K., 68 % of whom were
permanently separated from at least one of their children and subsequently lost
almost all contact. These authors, too, point to the prevalence of grieving and
9
Parenting
loss in this group of women. In a larger sample of mothers with serious mental
illness (N=379), Oyserman et al. [39] emphasize the joy their participants
experienced at being able to parent, although there was also the
acknowledgement of added burden. The burden was that of all mothers: new
tasks and schedules; child disobedience or misbehavior; difficulty of child’s
eating and sleeping routines; the need for respite; illness (their own or their
child’s). But the burden weighed more heavily because of lack of financial and
economic resources and because of the requirements of mother’s psychiatric
illness (appointments, medication taking, need for stress-free quiet time,
interpersonal discomfort).
10
Parenting
Because of all these factors, there are significantly increased risks for preterm
delivery, low birth weight, and small-for-gestational-age among the offspring
of women with schizophrenia. The rate of still birth and infant death is twice
as high in this population as in the general public. [43-47] Some studies find
mortality risks for children of schizophrenia mothers to be elevated from birth
through early adulthood. [48]
11
Parenting
Because of the many factors just described, the infants of women with
schizophrenia are described as poorly developed relative to comparison infants
[2, 49-51] Attachment difficulties have been postulated. Attachment refers to a
protective bond between an individual and a caregiver. It means that closeness
to the caregiving person is instinctively sought whenever danger looms. When
separated from the mothering person, securely attached young children show
only slight distress, which tends to readily respond to comfort or distraction.
Those with insecure attachment may appear indifferent to the mother’s leaving
or to her reappearance or, in contrast, may desperately cling to their mothers at
the point of separation and, at reunion, may again cry and cling (this is called
anxious attachment). Infants of psychotic mothers and of depressed mothers
have been shown to demonstrate more insecure attachment than infants of
manic mothers during the first year of life. [5] At 1 year of age, children of
mothers with schizophrenia have been found to display anxious attachment
more often than comparison children. [52] The personality attributes of
mothers, as well as their child-rearing behaviors appear to be the main drivers
of toddlers' insecure attachment. [53]
12
Parenting
whose parents was diagnosed with schizophrenia, Somers [56] found that the
majority were indistinguishable from children of well parents in terms of
physical health, positive family feelings, friendships, hobbies and household
tasks. The at-risk children did, however, suffer more often from psychiatric
disturbance, have more problems associated with school, less contact with
relatives and more at-home time. It is important not to attribute the problems
that these children face to poor parenting. The children are, by definition,
genetically at-risk for developmental problems and, furthermore, may be
negatively affected not only by social circumstances, but also by prenatal
exposures, and mental health and substance use problems in the father. Factors
associated with mother’s illness, such as her absences due to hospital
admission, [57] the inconsistencies in parenting that may then result, and the
extra responsibilities that children of ill mothers often assume, [58] may also
contribute to the problems they experience. Most studies concur that the
diagnosis of schizophrenia in the mother has less impact on her parenting
style than do the many associated factors.
13
Parenting
Duncan and Browning [60] studied current attachment issues in 23 adults who
were raised by parents with schizophrenia. These interviewees describe a
range of difficulties in forming secure adult attachments, particularly in the
areas of trust and intimacy.
It is clear that adult children who speak out about their experiences of growing
up with a mother with schizophrenia have many unhappy stories to tell. What
is not clear is how representative these stories are nor how these complaints
compare with the retrospective accounts of children growing up under
analogous conditions of poverty, single parenthood, and ill health.
these children to be 7-16%. [61-64] In addition, they show that the offspring
are vulnerable to a variety of other mental health problems. [65] In the
Copenhagen study, 25 children were reared by their mothers and 25 were
reared apart from their mothers. Counterintuitively for some, more
psychopathology was found in those reared away from their mothers. The
explanation may lie in the fact that more severely ill mothers were more likely
to have lost custody; nevertheless, this finding underscores the fact that
rearing by a mother with schizophrenia is not necessarily the main risk factor
for psychopathology. [66] Severing the relationship between child and
primary caregiver places the child in jeopardy. Remaining in the home of an
ill mother is also a hazard, but can be countered by effective intervention.
Interventions
Some studies find that the mere fact of reducing maternal symptoms helps
mother-child relations, [67] but a recent review emphasizes that this is not
enough. [68]
15
Parenting
variable. [69] It is, therefore, not surprising that there is no hard evidence for
their effectiveness. [70] In-home interventions are presently being evaluated.
[71]
16
Parenting
In a wraparound system, there is a single point of entry for the many services
that are provided. Among these are attention to mother and child health, [83]
substance abuse counseling, case management, liaison with schools, the legal
system, welfare, crisis management, housing, transportation, vocational help,
spiritual, cultural, and recreational guidance, and respite care. Ideally, the
service are open ended and sensitive to the stigma associated with mental
illness, unfortunately a fact of life for parents with mental illness and their
children.
17
Parenting
Conclusions
References
18
Parenting
19
Parenting
20
Parenting
21
Parenting
22
Parenting
23
Parenting
24
Parenting
80. Winters NC, Metz WP. The wraparound approach in systems of care.
Psychiatr Clin North Am 2009;32:135-51.
26
Parenting
82. Bruns EJ, Walker JS. Defining practice: Flexibility, legitimacy, and the
nature of systems of care and wraparound. Eval & Program Planning 2009;
(Epub ahead of print)
27