NIAGARA REGIONAL POLICE SERVICE
Chief of Police Bryan MacCulloch, MOM, BA, MA
March 29, 2019
Heather Clemenceau
Dear Ms. Clemenceau:
am responding to your request, pursuant to the Municipal Freedom of Information and
Protection of Privacy Act (the Act), for access to information, our Information and
Privacy File No.: 2019.
‘You have requested access to information regarding a motor vehicle collision involving
a horse and carriage on February 23 or 24, 2019 in Niagara-on-the-Lake.
Enclosed please find a copy of the General Occurrence Report generated in conjunction
with Motor Vehicle Collision Report #2019-16574.
You have been granted partial access to the enclosed report, the personal information of
involved parties having been severed from it pursuant to Section 14 of the Act. ‘The
relevant subsections are as follows:
Sub-Seetion Reason
Disclosure would constitute an unjustified invasion of personal privacy as Section 14 of
the Act applies to this information. The relevant subsections are as follows:
140) A head shall refiuse to disclose personal information to any person other
than the individual to whom the information relates except,
@ upon the prior written request or consent of the
individual, if the record is one to which the individual is
entitled to have access;
o if the disclosure does not constitute an unjustified
invasion of personal privacy
5700 Valley Way * Niagara Falls, ON # L2E 1X8 * Te: 905-688-4111 * Toll Free: 1-888-668-3911 * www.niagarapolie.ca |NIAGARA REGIONAL POLICE.
GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY
MVC - PERSONAL INJURY]
Narrative: MOTOR VEH ACCIDENT - 1
Subject: Malachowsky 9370
Author: 09370 MALACHOWSKY, MICHAEL
Related date/time: Tuesday, 2019-Feb-26 15:58
MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENT
This text page is required for all MVA reports submitted by MRE. The
following value must be entered to ensure the MTO form is correctly
generated
If location is other than actual address:
Ri (Traffic way) [King street ]
R2 (Reference Point) [Picton Street ]
MVA Synopsis (if required):
[on Saturday, February 23rd, 2019,Sentineal Carriages were operating as per
usual located at the corner of King Street and Picton Street in front of
the Prince of Wales Hotel in Niagara on the Lake
From a witness account, At approximately 6:30pm, there were two carriages
operating. One was stationary parked at the corner of King and Picton
Street. The other carriage had just pulled behind the other and let off
some patrons. The driver of the carriage that just pulled in stated to the
other carriage driver that she was going to go around again. when pulling
back out onto the road, the witness stated that the carriages had clipped
each other causing the horse to startle. The other account was from the
carriage owner that the shaft attaching the horse to the carriage broke
off. :
The horse then went diagonally toward the median on King Street hitting the
curb and the horse then bucked its hind legs 3-4 times .
The horse then turned 90 degrees and went directly toward the front of the
Prince of Wales hotel (on Picton Street) where the carriage struck a parked
(unoccupied) vehicle in the valet stand area. The driver of the carriage
fell off the carriage and the horse came to rest and sat on the ground
adjacent to the struck vehicle.
The owners of the horse and carriages attended and removed the horse and
carriage within minutes.]
*** CONFIDENTIAL *#*NIAGARA REGIONAL POLICE
GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY
GO# 2019-16574 MYC - PERSONAL INJURY]
Narrative: SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT - 1
Subject: Malachowsky 9370
Author: 09370 MALACHOWSKY, MICHAEL,
Related date/time: Thursday, 2019-Feb-28 11:28
On Monday, February 25th, 2019, police contacted the provincial prosecutors office to discuss the collision that
took place involving the horse and carriage and a parked vehicle, Afier much deliberation, it was concluded that
there would not be any charges laid in this collision,
Police also spoke to NRPS licencing unit who is responsible for licencing the carriages. The driver of the
carriage was properly licenced to be operating the carriage. The company, Sentineal Carriages where properly
licenced as a business and also properly insured with all of the paperwork being reviewed
On Tuesday, February 26th, 2019 at approximately 12:30pm, police contacted the owner of the carriages, Laura
Sentineal. She confirmed that the driver, stained only minor injuries and followed the
procedures that Laura had put in place in the event of an incident. kept the horse seated as trained and an
emergency reach out to Laura were made and arrived within minutes to tend to and
the horse. The horse named "Ethan" was uninjured according to Laura and was looked at by the veterinarian the
next moming and she reported that there was no injury sustained,
This was an unfortunate incident which luckily did not not involve any injury to human or animal.
= CONFIDENTIAL ***