Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dominic Lawson, in his October 31, 2010, Times of London piece entitled, “Gene
by gene, we turn back into brutes,” provides a most readable exposition on
matters that should trouble many somewhere deep down.
He describes the:
dispiriting reductionism in the high fashion of popular science, which
now seems to amount to little more than a concerted attempt to explain
every action we take in terms of our genes
Lawson puts the potential horrors of this materialist reductionism in plain view in
a mad pendulum swing across two short paragraphs:
The notion of homosexuality as genetic destiny won plaudits among
those who thought that described the origins of their own sexual
identity; but the discovery or belief that there is a simple and
Page 1 of 2
identifiable genetic cause of certain behavioral traits can have deeply
unpleasant consequences.
Toward the end of Lawson’s article in which he makes clear his critique and
counterpoint is a paragraph remarkably consonant with the critique of scientism
found in New World Encyclopedia‘s original statement of purpose:
Increasingly, what was once moral discourse is being superseded by a
form of scientism, which manifests itself in the notion that the only
truths worth knowing are those which have been peer-reviewed in
scientific publications. This tendency has also seen neuroscience annex
the territory that was once the province of philosophy, in a hubristic
attempt to describe everything about human consciousness in purely
chemical terms.
Page 2 of 2