Criteria Excellent (3) Satisfactory (2) Unsatisfactory (1)

Table of Contents Table of Contents is Table of Contents is No Table of Contents

complete and agrees present and one or and papers have a
with the locations of two items are out of confusing
all work/artifacts. order. arrangement.
Artifacts The presentation of The portfolio includes The portfolio’s
artifacts is convincing, appropriate artifacts materials and artifacts
with strong support for that support the are not appropriate
the course’s learning demonstration of and/or adequate, and
outcomes. learning outcomes. are not supported by
the presentation
Appearance and • Outstanding in • Contents are clean • Portfolio is not
Organization appearance. and neatly arranged suitable for
• Suitable for • Portfolio is in presentation.
presentation. overall good • Artifacts are poorly
• Cover is attractive condition displayed.
and appropriate for • Cover identification • No identification on
the purpose. is appropriate to the cover.
• Personal portfolio purpose.
identification is
clear/neat.
Reflection/Critique Reflections illustrate Reflections illustrate Reflections illustrate
the ability to an attempt to critique a minimal ability to
effectively critique work, and to suggest critique work.
work, and to suggest alternatives.
constructive practical
alternatives.
Overall Items are clearly Items are introduced Items are not
Presentation introduced, well and somewhat introduced and lack
organized, and organized, showing organization.
creatively displayed, some connection
showing connection between items.
between items.

Rating: ______________
 Criteria Exceeds Meets expectations Does not meet
expectations (3) (2) expectations (1)
Artifact Selection • All artifacts are A majority of There is little or no
and Placement well-chosen. artifacts are suitable effort in the selection
• Student for portfolio of artifacts.
incorporates presentation.
feedback.
Artifact Reflections • All reflections are One reflection is Two or more
included. missing or does not reflections are
• Reflections are support the chosen missing or do not
well-written and skill. support the chosen
presented in final skill.
draft form.