Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Life is the object of biology yet its definition is somewhat elusive! What does it really mean to be alive? Scientists
generally agree that there are 6 criteria for being considered alive.
While these criteria help us understand whether something is alive or not, there is certainly some question as to how
many of these criteria must be met before something is considered alive. Today, you will be placed into the role of a
judge, a prosecuting attorney, or a defense attorney charged with deciding, once and for all, is a virus alive?
Judge
Your task is simple: Listen to the evidence presented by each side and render a decision. As with any judicial
decision, your verdict must be based on the evidence presented by each lawyer. Be prepared to not provide a
decision but also to provide reasons why you chose to render the verdict that you did. In other words, provide an
evidence based answer to the question: Are viruses alive?
Example:
This court finds that viruses are alive because…
Or
This court finds that a virus is not alive because…
Attorneys
Your task is also simple: Convince the judge that he should decided in your favor by providing explanations,
examples, analogies, and information that support your argument.
Both sides should begin their arguments with the same introduction:
“May it please the court. My name is ______________ and I represent the prosecution/defense in this case.
Obviously, you are looking to find as many ways as you can that viruses to do not meet these criteria. The fewer they
meet, the less likely they are to be considered alive.
Preparation of Argument: Keep your presentation short: 3 to 4 minutes. Always start with your strongest argument.
Find comparisons of things that meet some of the criteria but are not considered alive. Cite specific websites or
organizations that support your side of the argument:
Citing well known sources or experts in the field will lend authority to your position and make your argument more
believable to the judge.
Obviously, you are looking to find as many ways as you can that viruses to meet these criteria. The more they meet,
the more likely they are to be considered alive.
Preparation of Argument: Keep your presentation short: 3 to 4 minutes. Always start with your strongest argument.
Find comparisons of things that don’t meet all of the criteria yet are considered alive. Cite specific websites or
organizations that support your side of the argument:
Citing well known sources or experts in the field will lend authority to your position and make your argument more
believable to the judge.
Judge Notes:
Research Time: Your time will be spent researching both sides of this argument. In particular, pay attention to the
elements/criteria of living things:
Trial Proceedings: Your job is extremely important. After listening to both sides of the argument, you will need to
render a verdict: Is a virus alive or not? Treat this as if it were a criminal case and the personal freedom of a person
rested upon your decision. Carefully listen to both sides of the argument, take notes on what each attorney presents,
and after serious consideration of the research you performed, provide an evidence-based answer to our central
question.
Your decision should not be based on which attorney you like better or your research alone. It should be based on the
quality of the information provided by the attorney.
Research Notes: