You are on page 1of 21

using.

some point in our lives, most of us will be diagnosed health care needs of individuals, families, and aggregates are
with a chronic illness or develop some type of disability.
We may be lucky enough to get early diagnosis and treat- access for all ages and abilities are also discussed.
ment of our health conditions so that they can be easily

tated, unable to manage our daily lives, and needing assistance


from others. We can hope our ability to resume more nor-
mal activities will return swiftly. An estimated 54 million
Americans (almost 20% of the population) live with some What does the word disabled mean to you? What thoughts
ongoing level of disability (U.S. Department of Health and come to mind when you think about the word as it applies to
Human Services [USDHHS], 2005b). In 2006 alone, over
34 million persons reported limitations in their usual activ-
ities as the result of chronic conditions (USDHHS, 2008).
The human costs associated with disabilities aside, the cost with inability,
of direct medical care and indirect annual costs related to something, whatever the reason, but usually through incom-
disability have reached almost $300 million in the United
States alone. Morehead, 1995). is explained in the same volume
In the Final Review of Healthy People 2000 (USD- is
HHS, 2001), the rates of some disabling conditions, such as any illness that is prolonged, does not resolve spontaneously,
significant hearing and vision impairments, decreased and is rarely cured completely; these diseases are often pre-
between 1991 and 2000. The rates of many other conditions
however, either remained stable or increased during that tality, morbidity, and cost (Centers for Disease Control and
same decade. In the ensuing years, disabilities and chronic
a decidedly negative connotation, similar in nature to the typ-
public costs. The results of the Midcourse Review: Healthy ical societal view faced daily by people with disabilities.
People 2010 (USDHHS, 2005a) demonstrate both positive Challenges differ from one individual to the next and
require different degrees of accommodation. Fortunately,
long-held negative views of disabled persons and their con-
sionals. For instance, arthritis remains the leading cause of ditions are being replaced with new and more positive
disability in the United States. It affects approximately 43 approaches that view individuals and their challenges from
million individuals and more than 20% of the adult popula- a more holistic standpoint.
tion. Asthma remains a national health concern for all ages,
most particularly for those under 18 years of age, and rep-
resents one of the four most common causes of chronic ill-
ness in children. Although asthma death rates for persons
over 65 years have declined, racial and ethnic disparities One such change in thinking about disability and chronic ill-
persist. End-stage renal disease continues to increase, with ness was expressed in
over 45% of all new cases attributed to type 2 diabetes. tioning, Disability, and Health (ICF), published by the
Back pain will impact the lives of a staggering 80% of all World Health Organization (WHO) in 2001. This document,
the result of 5 years of work, replaced International Classi-
ethnicity, and occupation. Osteoporosis is estimated to be fication of Impairments, Disabilities, and Handicaps
present in 10% of all persons over the age of 50 (USDHHS, (ICIDH) (World Health Organization [WHO], 1980). Even
2005a), with the additional risk of serious injury or death the change in terminology in the title showed the dramatic
following a fall. The need to address health issues of dis- shift in thinking by the World Health Assembly; both
ability and chronic illness is vital to the well-being of impairments and handicaps were removed. In the revised
document, serves as a broad term for impair-
health of the country. ments, activity limitations, or participation restrictions. It is
This chapter discusses important and necessary health linked with , a term that encompasses all body
promotion and preventive efforts at every level. Although functions, activities, and participation.
treatment of chronic conditions has long been a mainstay of
health care in the United States and globally, limited atten- cation system with standardized language and a way to view
tion has been paid to the additional health promotion the domains of health from a holistic vantage point. It took
required to maintain and improve overall well-being of indi- into account body functions and structures, activities and
viduals with chronic conditions. Nor has enough attention participation, environmental factors, and personal factors.
been directed to those same needs for people with physical or
psychological disabilities. This chapter begins with an circumstances in terms of functioning, disability, and health.
overview of disabilities and chronic illnesses, then discusses
the current national and global trends in addressing these
issues. The various organizations that focus on improving the biopsychosocial approach for assessing people with disabili-
well-being of those affected, the impact on families, and the ties, emphasizing the observation that no two people with the
role of the community health nurse in addressing the chronic same disease or disability have the same level of functioning.
The purpose of the ICF reaches far beyond simply cat- is involvement in a life situation,
egorizing the health status of people with disabilities. The including personal and interpersonal roles and
activities.

may have in executing activities.


studying health and health-related states, outcomes, are problems an individ-
and determinations ual may experience when involved in life
Establish a common language for describing health
situations.
and health-related states to improve
make up the physical,
communication between different users such as
social, and attitudinal environments in which peo-
health care workers, researchers, policy makers,
ple live and conduct their lives.
and the public, including people with disabilities
Permit comparison of data across countries, health background, life, and living that are not part of a
care disciplines, services, and time
health condition or health status, such as gender,
Provide a systematic coding scheme for health
information systems
habits, upbringing, coping styles, social
The document provides a roadmap for using the ICF, based background, education, profession, past and current
on experience with the ICIDH for more than 20 years. Table experience, overall behavior pattern and character
26.1 shows the current and potential uses of the document style, individual psychological assets, and other
by various entities ranging from insurance companies and
health care providers to policy makers and educators. in disability at any level.
For the community health nurse, the ICF facilitates
ity and functioning, the following definitions serve to assessment of an individual client based on a wide range of
explain the ICF in terms of health (WHO, 2001, p. 10):
factors. Disability or disease is just one factor to be consid-
are the physiologic functions of ered in planning and implementing a care plan for clients in
body systems and include psychological functions. the community. Two individuals may have the same disabil-
are anatomic parts of the body ity, such as a below-the-knee amputation, but their health
such as organs, limbs, and their components. and well-being can be quite different. One may have a more
are problems in body function or positive outlook, one may have more social support than the
other, or one may suffer more than the other from additional
is the execution of a task or action by an health issues that impede rehabilitation. The community
individual. health nurse must always consider the totality of the situa-
tion, including the biologic, psychological, sociocultural,
and environmental realms. Diseases and disabilities are con-

designation should be avoided: a disease or disability is


something one has, not something one is. Figure 26.1
depicts the interactions among the various components
addressed by the ICF in the evaluation and assessment of
clients with disabilities. It can serve as a useful model for
community health nursing practice in the overall assessment
of people with disabilities.

The 2002 release of the annual report by the WHO (The


World Health Report 2002: Reducing Risks, Promoting
Healthy Life) set a new standard for addressing global
health. It challenged the world community to focus more
attention on unhealthy behaviors that lead ultimately to
chronic disease, disability, and early mortality. The report
stressed that, although infectious diseases and malnutrition
require ongoing vigilance because they continue to plague
many parts of the world, they are not the only threat. It is
increasingly clear that lifestyle choices play a major role in

alike, and intervention at all levels (local, national, and inter-


national) is a high priority. With this new reality in mind, this
document had a twofold purpose: to quantify the most
important risks to health, and to assess the cost-effectiveness
Health condition
(disorder or disease)

Body functions
Activities Participation
and structures

Environmental Personal
factors factors

of interventions designed to reduce those risks. The overall (Display 26.1). A shift in focus from the most high-risk indi-
viduals to the general population is essential. Primary and
risks and raise the healthy life expectancy of their popula- secondary prevention as the main focus is the approach that
public health care professionals have stressed for decades.
No longer can health care providers across the globe
continue to address acute illness by itself; lifestyle and a shift in emphasis to health promotion efforts, it will be
behavior must be considered because of the impact they
have on healthy years of life. The risks to health that the
WHO report focused on include some that are the direct
result of poverty, but many can be more aptly linked to appropriate for the years ahead.

ing health risks are (1) underweight, (2) unsafe sex, (3) high
blood pressure, (4) tobacco consumption, (5) alcohol con-
sumption, (6) unsafe water, sanitation, and hygiene, (7) iron

lesterol, and (10) obesity. Globally, these 10 health risks are


responsible for more than 33% of all deaths and untold dis-

can be directly related to lifestyle and behavioral choices. research, improved surveillance systems, and better
Nutrition is vital to health; nutritional imbalances can access to global information
lead to severe chronic illness, disability, and premature Development of effective, committed policies for
the prevention of health risks such as tobacco con-
sumption, unsafe sex associated with HIV/AIDS,
high cholesterol, and obesity (WHO, 2002). The prevalence and unhealthy diet and obesity
of obesity worldwide is estimated at more than 1 billion Implementation of cost-effectiveness analysis to
identify the most cost-effective and affordable inter-
ically obese (WHO, 2008). In stark contrast, there are 170 ventions to reduce priority health risks
million underweight children in poor countries, more than Collaborative efforts (intersectoral and
3 million of whom will die each year from malnutrition. international) to reduce major extraneous risk to
Being overweight increases the risk of coronary heart dis- health caused by unsafe water, poor sanitation, or
ease, stroke, diabetes, and some types of cancer. Malnutri- lack of education
tion and the lack of important nutrients can lead to a wide Supportive and balanced approach in addressing
array of preventable disabilities. For instance, the leading these major health risks that includes government,
community, and individual action
ciency, and the leading cause of mental retardation and brain Empowerment and encouragement of individuals to
make positive, life-enhancing health decisions (such
as eliminating tobacco use, excessive alcohol
ity. If countries can make even minimal strides toward consumption, unhealthy diet, and unsafe sex)
improving the health of their citizens, a dramatic improve- Adapted from World Health Organization. (2002). The world health
ment in health outlook can occur within those countries and report 2002: Reducing risks, promoting healthy life. Geneva,
worldwide. Governments must take a proactive role in Switzerland: Author.
addressing the preventive health care needs of their citizens
Taken together, the ICF and the 2002 WHO report set viewed as a positive step in the progress toward equality. It
a standard for health care in the 21st century. Chronic dis- should be noted that the National Council on Disability
ease and disability prevention are vital to world health. The (NCD) has taken an approach to the convention that is pro-
cost of health care treatment is high, but the cost in terms of
lost productivity and decreased quality of life is even higher.
Without control of preventable disability and chronic dis- provide a baseline standard much lower than that provided for
in the ADA, the NCD still urged the signing of the treaty. In a
March 2007 letter to the President, they argued that signing

cil on Disability [NCD], 2008a, Preamble).


An estimated 650 million people live with disabilities world-
wide (United Nations [UN], 2007a). Factoring in the nearly 2
billion family members affected by the disability, the WHO
stressed that almost one-third of the world population is
directly impacted by disabilities. The sheer magnitude of this States, Healthy People 2010
issue, and the recognition that people with disabilities are a areas of health and well-being that are most in need of atten-
tion. With its clearly delineated and measurable objectives,
world, led to the United Nations (U.N.) Convention on the Healthy People 2010
Rights of Persons with Disabilities in 2006. The Convention and state health initiatives, health care policy, research priori-
was opened for signature in March 2007 and, as of May 2008, ties, and funding. In terms of disability and chronic illness,
Healthy People 2010 has placed added emphasis on conditions
convention include (United Nations [UN], 2007b):
Respect for inherent dignity and individual auton-
providers, insurance companies, public health agencies, and
health care facilities of the need to act proactively to avoid the
choices and independence of persons
Nondiscrimination economic toll that lack of attention can produce.
Full and effective participation and inclusion in Healthy People 2010 (USDHHS,
2000) without some mention of Healthy People 2000 (USD-
society
Respect for difference and acceptance of persons HHS, 1991). A comparison of the two documents reveals
some striking differences regarding disabilities and chronic
with disabilities as part of human diversity and
conditions. Increased attention has been given to the growing
humanity
national need to reduce the incidence of disability and
Equality of opportunity
chronic disease and improve the health of people affected by
Accessibility
them. In Healthy People 2000, only one priority area was
Equality between men and women
Respect for evolving capacities of children with devoted to disability and chronic illness. Priority Area 17,
disabilities and respect for the right of children
diabetes, with only limited attention to the broader range of
with disabilities to preserve their identities
other disabilities (asthma, chronic kidney disease, arthritis,
The convention, once entered into force, will be serviced by deformities or orthopedic impairments, mental retardation,
both the U.N. Department of Economic and Social Affairs peptic ulcer disease, visual and hearing impairments, and
overweight). In contrast, almost half of the Healthy People
Human Rights (Geneva). The United States was not one of the 2010 focus areas directly address chronic illness and disabil-
signatories of the convention, joining countries such as ity, and almost all of the focus areas can be related to these
Pakistan, the Russian Federation, Saudi Arabia, Switzerland,
Ukraine, and Zimbabwe. Although the United States was an
active participant in committee work on the convention and most relevant to people with disabilities.
Healthy People 2010 is
signing the document appeared related to issues of sover- somewhat different and more explicit than that used in the
eignty. In a December 2006 press release from Ambassador
Richard Miller, U.S. Mission to the U.N. (2006), the follow- represent the interactions between individuals with a health

the rights and dignities of persons with disabilities is embod- 2000, p. 25). Moreover,
ied in our vast array of strong national laws, notably the his-
toric Americans with Disabilities Act. . . . The United States
believes that the most effective way for states to improve the
real world situation of persons with disabilities from a legal This change in emphasis between the two documents
perspective is to strengthen their domestic legal frameworks was noted in Healthy People 2010 (USDHHS, 2000), which
cited lack of parity between disabled and nondisabled popu-
of the convention will only be realized in the coming years. lations in terms of several selected objectives: leisure-time
Building on the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA, activity, use of community support programs, and receipt of
discussed later in this chapter) the convention can only be
that the percentage of people with disabilities who reported
some type of leisure-time activity was the lowest of any of
the groups identified (including those older than
65 years of age and low-income persons). On the positive
side, the percentage of people with disabilities who reported
no leisure-time physical activity actually declined from the
1985 level of 35% to 29% in 1995, although it was still far
short of the 2000 target of 20%. Additional disparities noted
for people with disabilities included increased likelihood of
being overweight, adverse effects from stress, and reduced
rates of preventive services (e.g., tetanus boosters, Pap tests,
breast examinations, and mammograms). Recognition that
the health needs of disabled persons were not receiving
needed attention resulted in increasing the priority of
improving the health of people with disabilities.
Improving the health of the nation requires a multifac-
eted approach to improve parity among all individuals.
Healthy People 2010
munity across the nation deserves equal access to compre-
hensive, culturally competent, community-based health care
systems that are committed to serving the needs of the indi-

p.16). The goal of Healthy People 2010

prevent secondary conditions, and eliminate disparities


between people with and without disabilities in the U.S. pop-

tives have been selected to measure progress toward this goal


Healthy
People 2010
emphasis on healthy life-years and improved quality of life,
similar to the recommendations by the WHO (2002).
Although the issues of function stressed in the ICF (WHO,
2001) were not as explicit in Healthy People 2010, the 13
objectives indicate a growing emphasis on a holistic approach
that recognizes that life satisfaction is just as important to
health and well-being as preventive services. It also indicates
a growing realization that healthy life-years for persons with
disabilities equate to decreased health costs at local, state, and
national levels, just as they do for persons without disabilities.
Building on the Healthy People initiative, in 2005, then
current Surgeon General Richard Carmona released a Call
to Action to Improve the Health and Wellness of Persons with
Disabilities (USDHHS, 2005b). This document cited ongo-
ing challenges faced by persons with disabilities and their
families. Four major goals were proposed:
People nationwide understand that persons with
disabilities can lead long, healthy, productive lives.
is unique to this document; this approach is increasingly
Health care providers have the knowledge and tools
emphasized in health promotion education and will very
to screen, diagnose, and treat the whole person
likely be an important feature in efforts to reduce health care
with a disability with dignity.
costs.
Persons with disabilities can promote their own
The development of Healthy People 2020: The Road
good health by developing and maintaining healthy
Ahead is due for release in January 2010. This document
lifestyles.
will include the vision, mission, goals, focus areas, and
Accessible health care and support services promote
objectives for the next decade. Utilizing an extensive review
independence for persons with disabilities (p. 2).
of current and evolving research and national surveys, as
well as public and professional input, the document will pro-
accessible, comprehensive health care that enables persons
with disabilities to have a full life in the community with of the 21st century. This document will likely include insight
gained from the earlier Healthy People 2010 effort and the
Healthy People 2010 goals in this area. The emphasis placed Midcourse Review released in 2005. One emerging issue
on personal responsibility for maintaining a healthy lifestyle noted in the Midcourse Review was the recognition of
rights are protected and that legal recourse is available if such
level data to locate and evacuate persons with disabilities, protection is denied. But, as is true for other issues of equal-

(USDHHS, 2005a, p. 6-7). Of additional concern was the taken. The struggle for civil rights for disabled persons in this
country is still in its infancy, although it has begun to gain the
gets. A 7% increase occurred in the proportion of adults who level of attention that racial and gender equality receive.
expressed that negative feelings were impacting their lives; The (ADA) was
32% in 2003 versus the 28% level reported in 1997. With signed into law in 1990 to protect the civil liberties of the
respect to employment, the proportion of adults with dis- many Americans living with disabilities. This legislation
abilities who were employed dropped to between 1997 and
2003. As with the recession of 2001, the disproportionate with disabilities and their advocates made their voices heard
impact of the economic instability of 2008 on persons with by repeatedly demanding an end to inferior treatment and
lack of equal protection under the law, which impeded their
the employment goals set for 2010. Although the national daily lives. The ADA set the standard for a number of sub-
health priorities are not yet established, clearly, issues of sequent laws that, together with pre-ADA legislation, offer a
depression, employment parity, and disaster preparedness broad spectrum of protections for disabled persons. These
will need to be addressed. In addition, as noted in the 2005 additional laws are listed in Table 26.3 and cover a variety of
Call to Action, personal responsibility for issues, including telecommunications, architectural barriers,
lifestyle choices will very likely have increasing emphasis. and voter registration.

basis of disability in employment, state and local govern-


ment, public accommodations, commercial facilities, trans-
Policies such as Healthy People 2010 are important features portation, and telecommunications [and] also applies to the
of an overall plan to address the health of people with dis-
abilities and chronic diseases in the United States. Although tice [USDOJ], 2005, p. 3). For an individual to be protected
under the ADA, she must have a disability or some type of
programs initiated, policy alone cannot assure individuals relationship or association with an individual who has a
with disabilities that the needed services and accommoda-
tions are or will be available. As has often been the case, an
mental impairment that substantially limits one or more In a report on the enforcement history of the ADA
major life activities, a person who has a history or record of between its inception and 1999, the National Council on Dis-
such an impairment, or a person who is perceived by others ability (NCD) noted that many of the federal agencies charged
with protecting the civil rights of disabled persons suffered
ing of the specific impairments covered under the law is
notably absent, leaving open a broad range of interpretations national strategy (NCD, 2000). The NCD recommendations
and legal challenges with respect to who is actually covered.
Although there is ongoing debate as to who is actually for evaluating agency performance and thereby serve to
protected by the ADA, an equal amount of confusion exists as improve the full expression of the law as it was intended. These
to who is actually required to comply with the provisions of 11 elements or criteria are (1) proactive and reactive strategies,
(2) communication with consumers and complainants, (3) pol-
is a short summary of the ADA. All employers, including reli- icy and subregulatory guidance, (4) enforcement actions,
gious organizations with 15 or more employees, are subject to (5) strategic litigation, (6) timely resolution of complaints,
the act, as are all activities of state and local governments (7) competent and credible investigative processes, (8) techni-
irrespective of size. Before 1994, the act applied only to cal assistance for protected persons and covered entities,
employers with 25 or more employees. Public transportation, (9) adequate agency resources, (10) interagency collaboration
businesses that provide public accommodation, and telecom- and coordination, and (11) outreach and consultation with the
munications entities are all required to provide access for indi-
viduals with disabilities. It is important to note that the ADA Impact Study, progress was noted in the following areas:
does not override federal and state health and safety laws.
However, successful legal challenges to those statutes have Telephone relay services are being used at high
levels, and changes in technology are making
been made when they were clearly outdated or when it could
usage higher.
be argued that the public safety was not actually at risk in a
Public transit systems in the United States have
made dramatic progress in becoming more accessi-
ADA, leaving open the prospect of challenges by those who
are subject to the law and those who are protected by it. ble, especially to wheelchair users.
Individuals who believe that their legal rights under the The percentage of Americans with disabilities vot-
ing in 2004 increased dramatically.
The education gap between people with disabilities
and people without disabilities is shrinking, and
people with disabilities are attending
postsecondary institutions in record numbers.
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission field
People with disabilities are experiencing less
discrimination in employment (NCD, 2005, p. 3).
istration, or (4) the Federal Communications Commission.
It is important to those with disabilities and the profes-
many seek the assistance of attorneys, legal aid societies, or sionals who serve them that a structure be in place to
various private organizations, some of which are discussed provide protection under the law, but this does not prevent
later in this chapter (see Display 26.2). discrimination, nor does the existence of such a structure
suggest that immediate remedies will be available. Laws
aside, the most difficult aspect of change comes when
attempts are made to alter the perceptions and misunder-
standings of others about people with disabilities. The per-
spective of one community member offers one such exam-
ple (see Perspectives: Voices from the Community).
The responsibility of the U.S. Department of Justice,

of alleged violations of the Americans with Disabilities


Act (ADA). An example of one of those complaints
involved a 22-year-old Connecticut woman with cerebral Although the impact of civil rights legislation cannot be
palsy. She had been placed in a nursing home because of underestimated, it did not come about without demands for
changes in her living situation and health care status and change from the chorus of voices from all those who deal on
wanted to move back into the community. The OCR a daily basis with the issue of disability (the individuals
intervened to ensure that the woman secured appropriate themselves, their families, coworkers, employers, and advo-
housing and that counseling and intensive case manage- cates). Without the hard work of those individuals and
ment services were in place when she moved back into groups, it is unlikely that the efforts envisioned and accom-
the community. Without the protection afforded under plished by legislation would have occurred. Much of the
the ADA, the outcome could have been much different. credit for the legislative focus belongs to advocacy groups.
Source: USDHHS (2006, September). Delivering on the promise: The following section provides an overview of some of the
. Retrieved groups that advocate for the disabled and chronically ill and

complianceactiv.html. offer others an opportunity to learn more about the lives and
struggles of disabled persons. Each of the organizations
disabilities or chronic illnesses.
The National Association of the Deaf (NAD), head-

ization that was established in 1880. As the oldest U.S.


I was always such an active and healthy person, so when organization serving this population, it has the stated mis-
I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis it hit me like a
ton of bricks. Here I was with two small children and I
activities that NAD is involved with include advocacy, cap-
and applied for one of those disabled parking stickers. tioned media, certification of
The doctor had to approve it, and he said it was a good (ASL) professionals and interpreters, legal assistance, and
thing to help me save my energy for the important policy development and research (NAD, 2008a). ASL uses
things, like taking care of my family. I hated to use it,
but I was just getting so tired. What is so awful are the primarily in America and Canada by the deaf community
(Grayson, 2003). Display 26.3 offers a brief summary of
sign languages.
The National Organization on Disability (NOD), head-
quartered in Washington, D.C., has as its mission statement

54 million men, women, and children with disabilities in all

Pat N., Tampa, Florida 2008, p. 1). An important contribution of NOD is the 2004
NOD/Harris Survey of Americans with Disabilities, which
sought to quantify the gaps between people with and with-
out disabilities in terms of employment, income, education,
listed offers a wide range of information, some of which can health care, access to transportation, entertainment or going
be accessed via the Internet. For community health nurses, out, socializing, attending religious services, political par-
these organizations provide a starting point for exploring spe- ticipation/voter registration, life satisfaction, and trends

valuable information for clients and families to access on by NOD since it was first initiated in 1986. Although
their own. Families who cannot afford Internet service or improvements in all indicators have been demonstrated over
computers can use them at public libraries, most of which this 18-year period, progress is described as both slow and
now offer this service. Many Internet sites are not reliable or
accurate, so it is important for the nurse to prescreen any spe- likely than nondisabled persons to have low incomes, are

The NCD is an independent federal agency tasked with mak-


ing recommendations to the President and to Congress about
issues that face Americans with disabilities. The NCD has 15
Sign languages are not universal
and procedures that guarantee equal opportunity for all indi-
viduals with disabilities, regardless of the nature or severity gestures to communicate ideas or concepts
of the disability, and to empower individuals with disabilities American Sign Language is a unique language with
its own rules of grammar and syntax
American Sign Language is primarily used in
2008b). In its 1986 report, Toward Independence, the NCD America and Canada and is the natural language
proposed that Congress should enact a civil rights law for of the deaf community
people with disabilities; the result was the 1990 ADA. International Sign Language (Gestuno) is composed
of vocabulary signs from various sign languages for
use at international events or meetings to aid com-
munication
Systems of Manually Coded English (i.e., Signed
English, Signing Exact English) are not natural lan-
eases. Many of the better-known organizations such as the guages but systems designed to represent the trans-
American Heart Association and the American Cancer Asso- lation of spoken language word for word
ciation are discussed in other chapters of this book and From Grayson G. (2003). Talking with your hands, listening with
therefore are not covered here. Instead, examples of groups your eyes. A complete photographic guide to American Sign Lan-
that deal most directly with disability and chronic illness are guage. Garden City Park, NY: Square One Publishers.
described. The reader is encouraged to search the Internet or
twice as likely to drop out of high school, are more likely to assistive technology; improved employment opportunities; and
go without needed health care, and they report considerably increased accessibility of technology. In addition, AFB houses
lower satisfaction with life than persons without disabilities. the Helen Keller Archives, which contain her correspondence,
The NOD Web site connects visitors to a rich variety of photographs, and various personal items and documents
sources on community involvement, economic/employment (American Foundation for the Blind [AFB], 2008).
topics, and access issues (http://www.nod.org). The Obesity Society has as its mission to promote
The American Council of the Blind (ACB) was founded
prevent, and treat obesity and improve the lives of those

cil of the Blind [ACB], 2008, p. 1). Services advertised by addresses such issues as the need for attention to the impact
the organization include information and referral, scholar- of obesity on death and disability and for increased research,
ship assistance, public education, and industry consultation, improved insurance coverage, and elimination of discrimi-
as well as governmental monitoring, consultation, and advo- nation and mistreatment of people with obesity. The organi-
cacy. Some of the major issues currently being pursued by http://www.obesity.org) offers informa-
the organization include improved education and rehabilita- tional literature covering topics that range from the global
tion for the blind and increased production and use of read- problem of obesity to treatment of obesity-related disability.
ing materials for the blind and visually impaired. With growing awareness that, in many cases, human

ization established to train and make available guide dogs for syndrome (AIDS) is a chronic condition, the long-term
the visually impaired (Guide Dogs for the Blind, 2008). The needs of those impacted by this disease are gaining atten-
dogs and services are free, and the organization relies on tion. Hundreds of websites and organizations are available to
donations. It currently has two training sites, one in California provide information, assistance, and support. One website,
and one in Oregon, with puppy raisers located throughout the The Body: The Complete HIV/AIDS Resource (2008) offers
Western states. The organization can be reached through its state-by-state links to a variety of resources. The site also
Web site at http://www.guidedogs.com.
Another organization dealing with issues affecting the Indians and Alaskan Natives. The website can be accessed at
blind and visually impaired is the National Federation of the http://www.thebody.com/index/hotlines/other.html.
Begun in the aftermath of World War I, the Disabled
American Veterans organization has provided free services to

tion of the Blind [NFB], 2008, p. 1). Citing the need for assis- injuries (Disabled American Veterans, 2008). The organiza-
tance to the more than 1.1 million people in the United States tion is not a government agency and receives no federal funds,
instead providing services through membership dues and pub-
public education, information and referral, and support for lic contributions. The mission of the organization is to help
increased availability of materials in (Display 26.4). disabled veterans build better lives for themselves and their
The oldest organization devoted to eliminating barriers families. With the growing number of military injuries result-
for the blind and visually impaired is the American Foundation
for the Blind (AFB), which was founded in 1921. The AFB
advocates for the visually impaired through increased funding provide transportation to Veterans Administration (VA) med-
at the federal and state levels in areas such as rehabilitation ical facilities and provide ongoing service at VA hospitals,
research for older, visually impaired persons; improved liter-
acy for the visually impaired, including use of Braille and accessed at http://www.dav.org/.

Braille takes its name from Louis Braille, an 18-year-


old blind Frenchman who created a system of raised Healthy People 2010 as it relates to
dots for reading and writing by modifying a system
used on board sailing ships for night reading. Persons ential aspects of the document is its emphasis on a change in
experienced in Braille can read at speeds of 200 to 400 thinking within the health care community about the health
words per minute, comparable to print readers. Braille promotion needs of people with disabilities. This shift is
consists of arrangements of dots to form symbols. The needed because the lack of health promotion and disease pre-
text can be written either by hand with a slate and sty- vention activities for this population leads to an increase in
lus, with a Braille writing machine, or with the use of the number and extent of
specialized computer software and a Braille embossing
device attached to the printer. problems that a person with a disabling condition likely
Source: National Federation of the Blind. (2003). What is Braille and what
does it mean to the blind? Retrieved May 19, 2008, from http://www. health needs of disabled persons from the traditional stand-
nfb.org/images/nfb/Publications/fr/fr15/Issue1/f150113.html. point of asking what medical, rehabilitative, or long-term
care is needed has failed to reduce illness or improve the
overall well-being of the disabled or chronically ill. More- basic elements to maintain health. Those elements are the
over, a number of misconceptions have resulted that impede same all over the world and include clean air and water, a safe
progress in this area: (a) that all people with disabilities have place to live, sunshine, exercise, nutritious food, socializa-
poor health, (b) that public health activities need to focus
only on preventing disability, (c) that there is no need for a self-evident as these health promoting elements may seem,
for the millions of persons who deal with disability, chronic
public health practice, and (d) that environment does not play disease, or both, such basic needs seem too often to take sec-
ond place to other issues. It is equally problematic that pre-
ventive measures, most notably at the primary and secondary
disabled persons as well as needs that are universal to all) levels, are often nonexistent or lacking (see Evidence-Based
should greatly improve the outlook. This change of focus is Practice).
used in The issue of missed opportunities in health promotion
Healthy People 2010: and prevention is depicted in Figure 26.2. The focus of the
a healthy environment to prevent medical and other second- health care delivery system is increasingly skewed toward
ary conditions, such as teaching people how to address their secondary and tertiary prevention efforts, and limited
health care needs and increasing opportunities to participate emphasis is placed on the health promotion and primary pre-
vention needs of the population. Although this is a concern
for all persons, it is of particular importance for persons
with disabilities and chronic illnesses, because they are
more likely to have these needs ignored altogether. As
Figure 26.2 shows, an entire area of issues may be addressed
with a basically healthy person but not with a disabled or
In this age of rapid growth in technology, it is easy to forget chronically ill individual. Some areas of secondary and ter-
that clean water is a far more important commodity than hav- tiary prevention unique to persons with disabilities or
ing the latest prescription drug or surgical procedure. All of chronic illnesses may be completely ignored. This nonre-
us, whether healthy, disabled, or chronically ill, require some ceipt of health promoting or preventive education or actions

as immunization, and that guidance should be clear, accu-


study of children with chronic illnesses. The 274 children rate, and up-to-date.

complications as a result of their illness. The study sam-


ple was obtained from the over 5,000 children (younger As this study emphasizes, children who are most at risk for
than 14 years of age) who presented at an emergency

conditions such as asthma, chronic pulmonary disease, the results of the 2005 National Health Interview Survey
hemodynamically significant cardiac disease, chronic showing that children with current asthma had a vaccina-
metabolic disease, sickle cell anemia, and HIV infection. tion rate of only 29%. Although this rate was higher than
The study involved a parental questionnaire regarding the reported rate for children without current asthma, it
underscores the need to reduce barriers to vaccination in
years, and parental perceptions of the need for vaccina- these children. One such method that can be utilized by the
community health nurse is to vigorously promote the need
contacted by phone to complete a separate survey regard-
with parents of children with chronic health conditions.
high risk children. The researchers found that children
with asthma or cardiac disease showed the lowest rates of
References:
Brim, S.N., Rudd, R.A., Funk, R.H., Callahan, D.B., &

season. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 56(09),


for improved vaccination rates for high risk children
Esposito, S., Marchisio, P., Droghetti, R., Lambertini, L.,
pediatricians points to the need for increased professional
coverage among children with high-risk medical
cian for guidance on health promoting interventions such conditions. Vaccine, 24,
100
Individuals with disabilities/chronic illness health professionals and the public alike.
Healthy individuals It is likely that disability or chronic illness serves as the
Approximate percent of focus

care community, including the community health nurse. As


a result, the disability or illness often drives the selection of
50 prevention efforts, to the possible exclusion of other, equally
important health issues. For example, for an individual with
a primary diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, secondary prevention
Missed opportunities efforts often center on that disease (e.g., screening for dia-
betic retinopathy). The need to refer the client for a Pap test
or a baseline mammogram may be overlooked. Likewise, the
treatment plan may include a consultation with a dietitian
0 but fail to address the basic needs for leisure-time activities,
Health Primary Secondary Tertiary
Promotion Prevention Prevention Prevention regular physical activity, a varied and interesting diet, fresh

prevent the development of depression, a common result of


chronic illness. Display 26.5 offers several examples of
missed opportunities in the areas of primary and secondary
prevention. It is of particular concern to the practice of com-
vital to the health and well-being of those with disabilities or munity health nursing that the broad range of health promo-
chronic illnesses is of grave concern. For example, issues tion and prevention needs of all clients be addressed.
such as sexuality are often not explored with the disabled or A study by Wei, Findley, and Sambamoorthi (2006)
chronically ill. This skewed view of the lifestyles, behaviors, demonstrated the risk for missed opportunities for clinical
preventive services among women. Of the 3,183 individuals

atitis A, because he lives in a high-risk area of the western

active all of her life, has developed severe arthritis. She One year later, at his regularly scheduled visit, it becomes
encounters a health care system that far too often focuses clear that he never received his immunizations. Apparently,

placed squarely on her tertiary health promotion needs,


often at the expense of health-promoting or lifestyle-
enhancing needs. The result is a failure to recognize that the were provided, but clearly not in a manner appropriate for
this individual. With additional explanation and follow-up,
issue for her than for a sighted person. She receives the perhaps the outcome would have been quite different.
same medication therapy as a sighted person but may not be
offered a physical therapy program due to her disability. A 34-year-old woman who has been severely obese since the
Her need for physical therapy is no less important, but birth of her last child (4 years ago) has not had a gynecologic
locating an appropriate, safe, and easily accessible program examination since that birth. She is aware of the need to have
requires some additional work on the part of her provider. regular examinations, yet she cannot bring herself to make an
At issue is that options potentially discussed with a sighted appointment. The reason is that she knows she will have to be
person are more apt to be omitted completely, which may

courage to call for an appointment and tells the clerk that she
A 20-year-old man with learning disabilities, who is
employed at a local factory, receives a regularly scheduled
physical examination with a new provider. He lives in a makes the appointment but does not keep it. This situation
, which is an out-of-home facility that could have been handled in a compassionate manner, recog-
provides housing for people with disabilities in which rotat- nizing the painful experience that weighing is for many indi-
ing staff members provide care for 16 or more adults or any viduals and suggesting alternatives, one of which could have
number of children/youth younger than 21 years of age. It been simply to bypass the scales until after the interview and
excludes foster care, adoptive homes, residential schools, examination. At that point, the woman may have been more
correctional facilities, and nursing facilities (USDHHS, amenable to the measurement and a more discreet area could
have been offered. In this case, the opportunities to provide
for a tetanus booster and should also begin the series for hep- primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention were lost.
sampled in this study, 23% were disabled. When compared tion for selected groups is of real concern in addressing the
to the other study participants, the disabled women were less ongoing needs of those individuals. Although neither study
likely to receive cancer screening (mammograms and Pap
smears) within the recommended intervals. Interestingly, explored further.
It is discriminatory practice when an individual
cholesterol screening, and colorectal screenings as recom- receives unequal, inappropriate, or limited services com-
mended. The researchers found that, overall, having a usual pared with those offered to others. Although the difference
source of care and health insurance were predictive of pre- in treatment is often due to lack of understanding of the
ventive service receipt. They stressed the need for improving needs of disabled persons, it is nonetheless discriminatory.
Such bias may not be intentional, but it can dramatically
risk and targeting efforts to reduce disparities. affect the health of clients and must be changed.
The good news is that the incidence of unequal and
inappropriate practices can be reduced with education and
training of health care providers, agency staff, and insurance
It is a growing concern to those who are disabled, and to their carriers. A crucial aspect of community health practice is to
families and advocates, that the type and quality of the ensure that those individuals with disabilities or chronic ill-
health-related services, referrals, and care that they receive nesses are afforded the best possible care, treatment options,
may not be appropriate to their circumstances. This results in
increased illness and disability and potentially decreased as are provided for nondisabled persons and those who do
quality or length of life. One pointed example of this dispar- not suffer from chronic illness.
ity involved a national sample of low-income female Medic- Health promotion and primary, secondary, and tertiary
aid recipients. Women with disabilities in this sample had prevention activities are essential aspects of quality care for
lower rates of receipt of medical services, and were much all persons. Those with disabilities require specialized atten-
less likely to receive cervical cancer screenings (Parish & tion to needs resulting from or related to their disabilities,
Ellison-Martin, 2007). Although the women each had similar yet they also require the same attention to health and well-
access to health care services, the disparities were of con- being as the rest of the population. Community health nurses
cern. Not surprisingly, those women with disabilities were are in a prime position to advocate needed changes for those
less likely to report satisfaction with their care. with disabilities and chronic illnesses. Such changes can
The issue of health care access was one of a number of include increased attention to health promotion and disease
elements explored in a study involving 932 independently prevention needs, accessible and appropriate delivery of
living Massachusetts adults with a major disability (Wilber those services, and specialized treatment plans that incorpo-
et al., 2002). The purpose of the study was to determine
whether factors such as having a consistent primary care (see Perspectives: Student Voices).
provider, access to health promotion or disease prevention
programs, and accessible transportation were related to the
number and severity of secondary conditions experienced.

vidual and the fewer obstacles faced, the fewer secondary

secondary conditions in Healthy People 2010; the most Families that have a member with a chronic illness or dis-
ability face many challenges. They are required to navigate
depression, spasms, and chronic pain. a health care system that they know little about and with
Additional disparities may exist in services received by which they often feel at odds. They serve as advocates for
those with chronic illness and disabilities. Racial and ethnic their member in need (whether child, spouse, or parent) and
differences in immunization rates were found in a study ana- often feel tired and frustrated from their efforts, especially if
lyzing data from the National Health Interview Survey of they have been less than successful in meeting their goals.
almost 2,000 individuals with diabetes (Egede & Zheng, Many are forced to ask for or demand assistance from health
2003). Even after controlling for access, health care cover- care agencies, social services, or transportation sources to
achieve the level of care needed by the family member.
pneumococcal immunization were lower for certain Many are required to open their home to others (e.g., com-
racial/ethnic groups, primarily Blacks. What is not known munity health nurses, social workers) to access the services.
from these results is whether the depressed immunization Families may have little understanding of what services they
rates resulted from client acceptance issues, from differen-
tial provider recommendations, or from some combination policies, or disjointed service delivery.
of these factors. The community health nurse is usually not the first
A qualitative in-depth survey by Becker and Newsom health care professional that the family encounters. They
(2003) that examined the issue of disparities found that eco- may already have been through a lengthy struggle to receive
nomic status also appeared to affect dissatisfaction with assistance. In these circumstances, the nurse often is con-
health care among chronically ill African Americans. In this fronted by a frustrated family that distrusts yet another

the quality and the quantity of their care than were middle- dence of the family by practicing consistency, following
income respondents. The potential impact of low satisfac- through with promised actions, and always being truthful.
certainly areas that can be addressed by the community
health nurse in a practical way.
Wong and Heriot (2007), found somewhat similar
results in their study of 35 parents of children with cystic

For as long as I can remember, I have wanted to work with and friends experienced less emotional distress than those

gram, I was so disappointed when I learned that we would


only have 7 weeks in our pediatric rotation. Then, I found used self-blame as a coping strategy were also more likely to
out about an opportunity to work with children at a school report experiencing depression and were more likely to
report lower levels of mental health in their children. Sug-
gestions to assist the family include parental counseling to
ments, and performing hearing checks. Then I found out
that I would actually be working with school-aged children goals, and providing information on available supportive
with disabilities and their parents in a special after-school social networks. With the current median life expectancy of
health promotion program. The nurse I was assigned to patients with CF well above 30 years, the issue of long-term
asked me to come in before the program started, so that she family support is vital.
One major obstacle for families with a disabled or chron-
ically ill member may be obtaining needed
Then she asked me something that made me worried; she Healthy People 2010 as
asked if I had ever worked with a child who used a wheel-
chair, or had a continuous insulin pump, or had seizures. I
told her that I had some experience in the hospital, and that to increase, maintain, or improve the functional capabilities of
I was sure that I would be prepared for any health care

alternatives. Just because the technology exists does not mean


made me a bit worried. She explained to me that many that it can be obtained. Often, the insurance carrier, whether
private or governmental, sets limits on which products can be
obtained or which brands are acceptable. The overriding issue
parents about their child. She suggested that one way to
give me a bit of information was to go home and do some ily to learn about options and legal rights through a process of
reading and look at some websites she recommended. One trial and error. Intervention by the community health nurse
in particular, the National Organization on Disability can greatly reduce the burden on the family. With so many
product lines available on the Internet, the nurse can assist
families in this area, especially those without access to or
help with the kids and their parents. She also directed me understanding of computer technology. It is equally helpful
to the Easter Seals Disability Services (http://www.easter- for the nurse to intervene with insurance providers if coverage
seals.com), which has a great deal of information on pro-
grams that are currently available for children and adults. I ing for the equipment from private agencies if possible. Refer-
even learned that this organization used to be called the ring families to community groups or organizations that pro-

they changed the name. that share similar struggles can provide a vital link to needed
services and can be contacted through self-help groups or
Eileen S. other sources. Here, the community health nurse can provide
expertise on available community resources.
Respite care is another area of great importance for
families of the disabled and the chronically ill. It can be emo-
tionally draining to meet the daily needs of a member who
Not all problems that the family faces can be remedied, and cannot perform self-care. This often leads to caregiver
even for problems that do have solutions, time and effort fatigue and increased stress. It is also important to recognize
may be needed to obtain the desired result. the effect of the situation on noncaregivers in the family, par-
ticularly nondisabled siblings of a disabled child. With focus
placed on the needs of one member, children may feel that
their own needs are not as important. This can lead to behav-
A literature review of the needs of parents with chronically ioral and health-related problems. Respite care offers some
ill children reported a number of common themes in the needed relief to the family and allows for uninterrupted
studies surveyed, among them the need for normalcy and attention to the nondisabled children. This service can occur
certainty, the need for information, and the need for partner- within the home or at an outside facility. Respite care may be
ship (Fisher, 2001). Although these needs were associated provided by a private organization at little or no cost to the
with the presence of a chronically ill child in the family, the
same needs are likely to occur in other families. These are the insurance company or by the family itself. Whatever the
discussed with the insurance carrior to address the needs of
Anna Lopez is a mother of three children aged 2 to 9 years the mother as caregiver.
old. The eldest, Ernesto, was diagnosed with severe Down
The community health nurse will discuss with the client
total care, and remains at home with his mother and her concerns about her overall physical and mental health
and discuss some self-care options that may improve her
works long hours as a computer repairman for a large com- well-being: improved nutrition, physical activity, leisure
pany. The have health insurance, but it does not cover addi- time options, and adjustment of family schedule to accom-
tional expenses, such as day care for Ernesto. The family modate more free time for self-care.
they receive periodic visits from you, the community health
nurse, to evaluate his condition and check on the feeding
tube used for his nourishment. Physically, Ernesto is stable, for an evaluation, but after thinking it over for a week and
but you notice that Anna has been increasingly withdrawn discussing it with her husband, she did so. Her husband was
at the visits, rarely offering information, but responding to
relieved that she had suggested the appointment, because he
questions appropriately. She seems less engaged with her was growing increasingly concerned over her withdrawal
other children as well, only occasionally smiling at them. but did not know how to bring up the subject. The family
physician referred Anna to a psychologist for evaluation of
the depression. The insurance carrier agreed to increase
1. At risk for depression related to ongoing caregiver home visits on a short-term basis but did not have a respite
demands and lack of respite care care option available for Ernesto. Fortunately, a local faith-
2. At risk for altered health status due to limited focus on based community group was able to provide limited assis-
self-care needs
had raised children with similar disabilities and were willing
to stay with Ernesto and the other children once a week for
4 hours. This allowed Anna some free time to make appoint-
The community health nurse will discuss with the client the ments with her psychologist, shop, or visit friends. After
need for a thorough physical assessment, including an eval- several months, Anna has begun to smile more and seems
uation for depression. The community health nurse will much more relaxed at the home visits. The children are all
contact the insurance provider to discuss day care/respite
options for Ernesto. If unavailable, local community organ- least the next 6 months. The need for ongoing attention to
izations will be contacted for appropriate referrals. In addi- her own self-care needs is emphasized with Anna by the
tion, the need for more frequent visits to the family will be community health nurse.

Another study explored the relationship between welfare


health and should be a priority in the overall treatment plan status, health insurance status, and the health and medical care
of the family (see Using the Nursing Process). received by children with asthma (Wood et al., 2002). The
With the enactment of the 1996 welfare reform legisla-
tion (the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Rec- been denied Temporary Assistance for Needy Families
(TANF) experienced more severe asthma symptoms and had
mented that potentially affect families with a chronically ill more acute care visits than children in families that did not
child, especially those living in poverty. Changes included access the welfare system, (b) children of recent TANF appli-
the stipulation of a 5-year lifetime limit on receipt of bene- cants were more likely to be uninsured or transiently insured
than those who had not applied, and (c) recent TANF appli-

growing concern within the public health community. Smith, this study is that it demonstrated the high-risk status of those
Wise, and Wampler (2002) explored this issue in a study of families with a chronically ill child and the need to provide
knowledge of welfare reform among families with a chroni- access to health insurance and health services.
cally ill child. They found that respondents often had incom- Even for families that are ineligible for public assistance,
plete knowledge of work requirements, even if they were
entitled to exemptions because their children received Sup- Employment options may be quite limited when a family has
plemental Security Income. In those cases, 37% of the a member with special needs. The family may have to remain
in a particular location to access needed health and social
exemptions, and 70% had not applied for the exemptions. services, reducing the possibility of increased earning poten-
This indicates that eligible families might not be receiving
the exemptions to which they are entitled, adding additional The working family members may choose less favorable
and unnecessary burdens to families already at risk. employment options because the position is convenient or has
time position at a local convenience store that does not pay
particularly well in preference to a higher-paying, full-time is the design of products and environments
factory position because the store is close to home and allows to be usable by all people, to the greatest extent possible,
for frequent adjustments in schedule.
Having a chronically ill family member often means that
working individuals must take time off from work. Although Mace, founder of the Center for Universal Design (North
some legal protections are provided under the Family and Carolina State University). Mace, who had suffered from
Medical Leave Act of 1993, the Act does not apply in all sit- polio as a child, died suddenly in 1998, leaving behind a long
uations. More importantly, it allows only for time off; it does legacy of advocacy on behalf of accessibility in design.
not mandate payment during those periods. The choice For those who live with a disability or chronic disease,
becomes an issue of taking unpaid time off or continuing to and their family members, the issue of access is of utmost
work and deal with the needs of the family member as best importance. As was noted earlier, the cost to a family to
one can. Some individuals choose to work part-time or not to accommodate the needs of a disabled person can be enor-
work at all, so that they can care for family members. At a mous. Consider, that, as the U.S. population ages, more and
more of us will have need of accessibility in housing, busi-
cial commitments, these families may have to rely on only one ness, and recreation in order to remain active and healthy as
long as possible. Accessibility was taken one step further in
one considers the myriad needs of the disabled and chroni- the concept of universal design, making tools, houses, and
cally ill, many of which may not be covered by insurance. workplaces accessible to all. The cost of building our envi-
Caregiver health needs and mental health status are yet ronments in a way that promotes access for all can be far less
another area of concern for families who must provide for a than the cost of remodeling those environments after the fact.
disabled or chronically ill member. One of the largest longitu- The issue of accessibility is not new. The ADA (dis-
cussed earlier) addresses issues of access in employment,
provided the data for an investigation of the impact of informal governmental building, and public accommodations. The
caregiving on the mental health status of caregivers (Cannuscio Fair Housing Accessibility Guidelines (HUD, 2008) pub-
et al., 2002). Using data collected over a 4-year period lished in 1990 provides for design and construction of mul-
tifamily dwellings (four or more units) in accordance with
more hours per week of care for a disabled spouse were six
times more likely than noncaregivers to report depressive or Public use and common use portions of the
anxious symptoms. The frequency of symptoms was elevated dwellings are readily accessible to and usable by
but less dramatic if the women cared for a disabled or ill parent persons with handicaps;
All doors within such dwellings which are
attention to the needs of caregivers, the majority of whom are designed to allow passage into and within the
women. A follow-up study by Cannuscio and colleagues (2004)
found that higher weekly time commitment to informal care persons in wheelchairs; and
was associated with an increased risk of depression, regardless All premises within such dwellings contain the fol-
of level of social support. For those with few social ties and lowing features of adaptive design:
high spousal time commitment, the level of depressive symp- 1. An accessible route into and through the dwelling;
2. Light switches, electrical outlets, thermostats,
appear to have an impact on depressive symptoms of care- and other environmental controls in accessible
givers. Access to social ties was, however, strongly correlated locations;
with more positive health outcomes in the caregivers (Cannus- 3. Reinforcements in bathroom walls to allow later
cio et al., 2004). Poor health outcomes, both physical and men- installation of grab bars; and
tal, are of growing concern as the population ages and the need 4. Usable kitchens and bathrooms such that an
for family caregiving rises. Recognizing that caregivers within individual in a wheelchair can maneuver about
a family are at increased risk for poor health outcomes, the the space.
community health nurse must select appropriate interventions
Universal design incorporates access, but access does not
to address the health needs of the other family members.
necessarily imply universal design. The design of a commu-
Families of individuals with a disability or chronic ill-
ness are at increased risk for a number of negative conse-
a role in the overall health and well-being of those living
quences. Although families do not all have the same level of
there. Universal design and access play a key role in this dis-
risk or disruption, the community health nurse should recog-
cussion, but the importance of accessible design is more far-
reaching. According to the CDC, the built environment
culties, poor physical or mental health, and a variety of other includes all of the physical parts of where we live and work
challenges. They are often ill prepared to deal with the com- (e.g., homes, buildings, streets, open spaces, and infrastruc-
plicated systems that must be accessed to obtain needed care.
The community health nurse is in an optimal position to physical activity. For example, inaccessible or nonexistent
interpret those systems to the families and to advocate for the sidewalks and bicycle or walking paths contribute to seden-
needed care, services, and equipment. The nurse must view tary habits. These habits lead to poor health outcomes such
the family holistically, recognizing additional needs that may as obesity, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and some types
develop as a result of the situation they currently face. of cancer. (2006, p. 1)
For those with existing disabilities, assuring ease of
access to all manner of recreation and exercise options is of single issue with a client, the community health nurse serves
paramount importance. For those who may develop disabili- in a variety of roles and at different levels.
ties or chronic illnesses, having the opportunities for healthy Consider as an example of the variety of roles and mul-
participation in physical activity may forestall or prevent the tilevel practice that the community health nurse assumes
development of illness. For the community, having an envi- with respect to a 55-year-old female client who uses a
ronment that promotes rather than restricts a healthy lifestyle
can be economically advantageous. Even schools have a role examination because of the lack of accessible examination
to play (CDC, 2008a). Building new schools away from res- tables at the local clinic; as a result, she has not had an
idential areas decreases opportunities for exercise and after- examination for more than 20 years. Recognizing the need
school activities. As parents are increasingly forced to drive for a complete examination, the community health nurse
their children to school, the children remain sedentary, the
pollution from cars is increased, and the risk of automobile will aid the client in receiving the needed examination, pos-
accidents increases. Community design is a complicated and sibly by ensuring that additional personnel are provided
evolving issue, but the point remains: a healthier population
may be achieved with attention to the environmental barriers Because this solution is temporary and less than optimal,
that impede healthy lifestyles for all persons. the nurse contacts a number of clinics in neighboring com-

nation table. Unfortunately, this clinic is 1 hour away. The


nurse then contacts a number of other community health
This chapter has discussed a number of areas in which the
community health nurse plays a key role. It is important to of women clients with this problem who have not received a
review those roles in the context of the individual, the fam-
ily, and the community as prime areas for nursing interven- Community Level).
Through a coordinated effort with a local transporta-
that the professional nurse takes on within the community. It tion company and the clinic, the nurse is able to arrange a
is helpful to review those roles and think about their appli- twice-yearly gynecologic screening program for the women
cation to disabled and chronically ill clients, their families, in the community who require special accommodations
and the communities in which they live.
Information sheets that discuss the need for annual gyneco-
examples of the roles that community health nurses assume logic examinations and advertise the program are distributed
in relation to disabilities and chronic illnesses. Take note of to area public health nurses, employers, and health clinics
each role that you participate in or observe while complet-
examinations provided over the next few years shows a 65%
the various roles at each level, perhaps you can interview a increase in the number of women with special needs who
community health nurse during your clinical experience and have received a gynecologic examination within the past
find examples of how she performs activities in each of
This is not an uncommon scenario in the practice of chronic conditions are not universally debilitating and that
community health nursing. Often, the needs of an individual the overall well-being and health of these individuals must
open the door to areas of concern for many in a community be a priority.
Legislation is but one step toward equality for those
population. affected by disabilities and chronic illnesses. The ADA has
Like nursing practice in general, the role of the com-
munity health nurse with respect to disabilities and chronic legal protections for the disabled, but it is only the beginning.
illness requires broad and holistic practice. The complexity Discrimination can occur at many levels; some is hurtful and
of issues surrounding these conditions requires creativity, intentional, but most results from misunderstanding of the
tenacity, honesty, and, most of all, knowledge. Community needs and desires of disabled persons and their families. This
health nurses who are informed about the issues that affect may even occur in relation to the provision of health care
the disabled and chronically ill at local, state, and national because of lack of education. Improvement can be found only
levels are prepared to offer assistance to their clients and to with increased community education programs for profes-
their communities. Knowledge of civil rights for these indi- sionals and the public that target the myths and misunder-
viduals is crucial in serving as advocates. standings about those with disabilities and chronic illnesses.
The issues facing individuals and families with disabil- Community health nurses are in a prime position to
ities require strong and sustained efforts to achieve results. advocate for the health needs of the disabled and chronically
Although successes at the individual level are laudable, the ill. With a long history of serving those who are most vulner-
extent to which the health and well-being of those affected able, community health nurses can help make needed changes
is improved must be the ultimate goal. Community health at the individual, family, and community levels. Although it is
nursing is in a prime position to initiate and support efforts often easier to focus on the needs of the individual, those
to improve the health status of those populations. We can needs are most often shared by many others. Nurses have long
either leave the issues to other professionals or use our recognized the need to collaborate with other professionals in
expertise and long history of caring for those less fortunate reaching the goal of improved health care for their clients; this
to make major and lasting changes. It is up to us. continues to be an important aspect of successful efforts on
behalf of the disabled and the chronically ill. It will take the
concerted efforts of many to implement the changes neces-
sary to improve the lives of those most affected, their families,
The issue of disability and chronic illness is of growing and the communities in which they live.
importance in community health, both nationally and inter-
nationally. Through the efforts of the WHO, the interna- unusually heavy or struggle to open the lid of a jar or feel
tional community has been challenged to provide increased that you were treated differently than someone else in the
attention to health promotion and disease prevention. Even receipt of services, take a moment to think. Think about the
in less developed countries, behavioral patterns linked to challenges, struggles, and pain that face so many citizens.
excesses in consumption (overweight and tobacco/alcohol Consider the impact of universal design at improving your
use) have an impact on the quality and quantity of healthy life or the life of a family member or friend. Although many
years of life. The ICF provides a universal classification argue against improving accessibility of city streets and
system that standardizes language and takes into account sidewalks because of the expense, those same people may
the biopsychosocial realms in health assessment and well-
being of disabled persons. Along with the World Health curb that is just a bit too high.
Report 2002, this document now places the emphasis
squarely on prevention of disease and disability. This
means, of course, that the health promotion and disease pre-
vention needs of the disabled and chronically ill must be
given the same emphasis as the needs of those who are not
disabled or ill.
1. Arrange to interview an individual with a disability
The aging of the U.S. population and the rise in
(e.g., hearing, vision, mobility) about the challenges
lifestyle-related illnesses such as diabetes and obesity are
that he has faced in interactions with nondisabled
often linked with increasing rates of disability. Prevention of
persons.
disability and disease is emphasized in Healthy People
2010, which serves as a wake-up call to Americans about the 2. Visit some of the nongovernmental sites listed
need to give serious attention to health promoting and dis- under Internet Resources and read some of the per-
ease prevention activities. In this current edition of Healthy sonal stories that are included.
People, unique emphasis is placed on health promotion and 3. Take an inventory of your house or apartment and
disease prevention needs of those with disabilities and
chronic illness. It is no longer acceptable that these individ-
uals be treated solely for tertiary health needs. Research has chair. Would you even be able to stay in your cur-
shown that when health promoting (lifestyle) issues are rent residence?
addressed with these clients, the rates of secondary condi- 4. As part of your regular clinical assignment in com-
tions are reduced, including medical, social, emotional, munity health nursing, look at those clients and
mental, family, and community problems. Like the ICF, families who are dealing with either a disability or
Healthy People 2010 takes the position that disability and
Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.nad.org/
chronic illness and assess how often you or other ASLposition.
community health nurses have addressed health National Association of the Deaf. (2008b). Inside NAD: Mission
promotion activities (e.g., healthy eating, physical statement. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.nad.
activity, leisure-time activities) with those clients. org/mission.
5. Review your family history for chronic health con- National Council on Disability. (1986). Toward independence: An
ditions. Are you at risk? If so, what have you done assessment of Federal laws and programs affecting persons
with disabilities: With legislative recommendations. Retrieved
to reduce your risk over the past 12 months?
August 19, 2008 from http://www.ncd.gov/newsroom/
publications/1986/publications.htm.
National Council on Disability. (2000). Promises to keep: A
decade of Federal enforcement of the Americans with Disabili-
American Council of the Blind. (2008). . ties Act. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.ncd.gov/
newsroom/publications/2000/promises_1.htm.
American Foundation for the Blind. (2008). About AFB. National Council on Disability. (2005). NCD and the Americans
Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.afb.org/. with Disabilities Act: 15 years of progress. Retrieved August
Becker, G., & Newsom, E. (2003). Socioeconomic status and dis- 19, 2008 from http://www.ncd.gov/newsroom/publications/
satisfaction with health care among chronically ill African 2005/pdf/15yearprogress.pdf.
Americans. American Journal of Public Health, 93 National Council on Disability. (2008a). Finding the gaps: A com-
Cannuscio, C.C., Colditz, G.A., Rimm, E.B., Berkman, L.F., parative analysis of disability laws in the United States to the
Jones, C.P., & Kawachi, I. (2004). Employment status, social United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Dis-
ties, and caregivers mental health. Social Science & Medicine, abilities (CRPD). Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.
ncd.gov/newsroom/publications/index.htm.
Cannuscio, C.C., Jones, C., Kawachi, I., Colditz, G.A., Berkman, National Council on Disability. (2008b). National Council on Dis-
L., & Rimm, E. (2002). Reverberations of family illness: A .
longitudinal assessment of informal caregiving and mental Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.ncd.gov/.
American Journal of National Federation of the Blind. (2003). What is Braille and what
Public Health, 92, does it mean to the blind? Retrieved August 19, 2008 from
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2006). Impact of the http://www.nfb.org/images/nfb/Publications/fr/fr15/Issue1/
built environment on health. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from f150113.html.
http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/publications/factsheets/Impactof National Federation of the Blind. (2008). About the NFB. Retrieved
theBuiltEnvironmentonHealth.pdf. August 19, 2008 from http://www.nfb.org/nfb/Default.asp.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2007). Chronic dis- National Organization on Disability. (2004).
ease prevention. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www. NOD/Harris Survey documents trends impacting 54 million
cdc.gov/nccdphp/. Americans. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.nod.org/
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2008a). index.cfm?fuseaction Feature.showFeature&FeatureID 1422.
health and the built environment. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from National Organization on Disability. (2008). About us & quick
http://www.cdc.gov/healthyplaces/healthtopics/children.htm. links. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.nod.org.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2008b). Summary Obesity Society. (2008). About the Obesity Society. Retrieved
health statistics for the U.S. population: National Health Inter- October 14, 2008, from http://www.obesity.org/about/
view Survey, 2006. Washington, DC: Government Printing Parish, S.L., & Ellison-Martin, M.J. (2007). Health-care access of
women Medicaid recipients: Evidence of disability-based dis-
nchs/data/series/sr_10/sr10_236.pdf. parities. Journal of Disability Policy Studies, 18,
Disabled American Veterans. (2008). Building better lives for dis- Smith, L.A., Wise, P.H., & Wampler, N.S. (2002). Knowledge of
abled American veterans and their families. Retrieved August welfare reform program provisions among families of children
19, 2008 from http://www.dav.org/. with chronic conditions. American Journal of Public Health,
Egede, L.E., & Zheng, D. (2003). Racial/ethnic differences in 92,
adult vaccination among individuals with diabetes. American The Body: The Complete HIV/AIDS Resource. (2008). United
Journal of Public Health, 93, States HIV/AIDS organizations. Retrieved August 19, 2008
Esposito, S., Marchisio, P., Droghetti, R, Lambertini, L, Faelli, N., from http://www.thebody.com/index/hotlines/other.html.
United Nations. (2007a). Relationship between development and
children with high-risk medical conditions. Vaccine, 24, human rights. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from
http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/enable/convinfodevhr.htm.
Fisher, H.R. (2001). The needs of parents with chronically sick United Nations. (2007b). Secretariat for the Convention on the
children: A literature review. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 36, Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Retrieved August 19, 2008
from http://www.un.org/disabilities/default.asp?id 17.
Grayson, G. (2003). Talking with your hands, listening with your U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (1991). Healthy
eyes. A complete photographic guide to American Sign People 2000: National health promotion and disease prevention
Language. Garden City Park, NY: Square One. objectives (S/N 017-001-00474-0). Washington, DC: U.S. Gov-
Guide Dogs for the Blind. (2008). About us. Retrieved August 19,
2008 from http://www.guidedogs.com. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2000).
Mace, R. (n.d.). About universal design: The Center for Universal Healthy People 2010: Understanding and improving health.
Design. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://design.ncsu.
edu/cud/index.htm. August 19, 2008 from http://www.health.gov/healthypeople/
Morehead, P., & Morehead, A. (Eds.). (1995). The new American Document/.
Webster handy college dictionary. New York: Penguin Books. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2001). Healthy
National Association of the Deaf. (2008a). American Sign . Retrieved August 19, 2008 from
Language: Position statement National Association of the Deaf. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hp2000/hp2k01.pdf.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2005a). Brown, S. (2007). Universal design and me. Inside MS, 25(4),
Midcourse review: Healthy People 2010. Washington, DC:
Chen, Y., Yi, Q., Wu, J., & Li, F. (2007). Chronic disease status,
http://www.healthypeople.gov/data/midcourse/. self-perceived health and hospital admissions are important pre-
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2005b). The Vaccine, 25
Cohen, R.M. (2008). Strong at the broken places: Five voices of ill-
wellness of persons with disabilities. Washington, DC: ness, one chorus of hope. New York: Harper Collins, Publishers.
Downing, M.J. (2008). The role of home in HIV/AIDS: A visual
http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/disabilities/calltoaction/ approach to understanding human-environment interactions in
calltoaction.pdf. the context of long-term illness. Home and Place, 14,
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2006). Deliver- Dunlop, D.D., Song, J., Manheim, L.M., Daviglus, M.L., &
Chang, R.W. (2007). Racial/ethnic differences in the develop-
munity integration. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www. ment of disability among older adults. American Journal of
hhs.gov/ocr/complianceactiv.html. Public Health, 97,
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2008). Fair Edwards, L. (2008). A life disrupted: Getting real about chronic
housing accessibility guidelines. Washington, DC: Government illness in your twenties and thirties. New York: Walker &
Company.
Fan, A.Z., Strine, T.W., Jiles, R., & Mokdad, A.H. (2008). Depres-
U.S. Department of Justice. (2005). A guide to disability rights sion and anxiety associated with cardiovascular disease among
laws. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.usdoj.gov/ persons aged 45 years and older in 38 states of the United
crt/ada/cguide.htm. States, 2006. Preventive Medicine, 46
U.S. Mission to the United Nations. (2006). Explanation of Position Gee, G.C., Spencer, M.S., Chen, J., & Takeuchi, D. (2007). A
by Ambassador Richard T. Miller, U.S. Representative to the UN nationwide study of discrimination and chronic health conditions
Economic and Social Council, on the Convention on the Rights of among Asian Americans. American Journal of Public Health, 97,
Persons with Disabilities, Agenda Item 67(b), in the General
Assembly. [USUN Press Release # 396(06)]. Retrieved August Grabar, S., Lanoy, E., Allavena, C., Mary-Krause, M., Bentata,
19, 2008 from http://www.usunnewyork.usmission.gov/press_
releases/20061213_396.html. illness and subsequent survival before and after the advent of
Wei, W., Findley, P.A., & Sambamoorthi, U. (2006). Disability and combined antiretroviral therapy. HIV Medicine, 9,
receipt of clinical preventive services among women. Gruman, J. (2007). Aftershock: What to do when the doctor gives
Health Issues, 16, New
Wilber, N., Mitra, M., Walker, D.K., Allen, D., Meyers, A.R., & York: Walker & Company.
Tupper, P. (2002). Disabilities as a public health issue: Findings Herwig, O. (Ed.). (2008). Universal design: Solutions for a barrier-
free living. Basel, Switzerland: Birkhauser.
Conditions. The Milbank Quarterly, 80, Jordon, W.A. (2008). Universal design for the home: Great-looking,
Wong, M.G., & Heriot, S.A. (2007). Parents of children with cys- great-living design for all ages, abilities, and & circumstances.
Child: Care, Beverly, MA: Quarry Books, Inc.
Health and Development, 34 Lehmann, I., & Crimando, W. (2008). Unintended consequences
Wood, P.R., Smith, L.A., Romero, D., Bradshaw, P., Wise, P.H., & of state and federal antidiscrimination and family medical leave
Chavkin, W. (2002). Relationships between welfare status, health legislation on the employment rates of persons with disabilities.
insurance status, and health and medical care among children Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 51
with asthma. American Journal of Public Health, 92, Lutz, B.J., & Bowers, B.J. (2003). Understanding how disability is
Rehabilitation
impairments, disabilities, and handicaps. Geneva, Switzerland: Nursing, 28,
Author. Qui, Y., & Li, S. (2008). Stroke: Coping strategies and depression
among Chinese caregivers of survivors during hospitalization.
functioning, disability and health. Geneva, Switzerland: Author. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 17,
World Health Organization. (2002). The World Health Report 2002. Richardson, L.C., Wingo, P.A., Zack, M.M., Zahran, H.S., &
Reducing Risks, promoting healthy life. Geneva, Switzerland: Author. King, J.B. (2008). Health-related quality of life years in cancer
World Health Organization. (2008). Obesity and overweight. survivors between ages 20 and 64 years. Cancer, 112(6),
Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.who.int/
dietphysicalactivity/publications/facts/obesity/en/print.html. Sun, H., Zhang, J., & Fu, X. (2007). Psychological status, coping,
and social support of people living with HIV/AIDS in Central
China. Public Health Nursing, 24,
Thomsett, K., & Nickerson, E. (1993). Missing words. The family
Bartlett, J.G., & Finkbeiner, A.K. (2006). Guide to living with handbook on adult hearing loss. Washington, DC: Gallaudet
HIV infection: Developed at the Johns Hopkins AIDS Clinic. University Press.
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. White, R.T., & Pope, C. (2008). The globalization of AIDS. Oxford,
Becker, G., & Newsom, E. (2005). Resilience in the face of seri- UK: Taylor & Francis, Inc.
ous illness among chronically ill African Americans in later Zhao, G., Ford, E.S., Li, C., & Mokdad, A.H. (2007). Compliance
life. Journal of Gerontology, 60B with physical activity recommendations in U.S. adults with dia-
Berke, E.M., Koepsell, T.D., Moudon, A.V., Hoskins, R.E., & betes. Diabetic Medicine, 25
Larson, E.B. (2007). Association of the built environment with
physical activity and obesity in older adults. American Journal
of Public Health, 97,
Blomquist, K.B. (2007). Health and independence of young American Council of the Blind: http://www.acb.org
adults with disabilities: Two years later. Orthopaedic Nursing, American Diabetes Association: http://diabetes.org
26, American Foundation for the Blind: http://afb.org
American Heart Association: http://www.americanheart.org National Organization on Disability: http://www.nod.org
Center for Universal Design (NC State University): http://www. Obesity Society: http://www.obesity.org
design.ncsu.edu/cud/ http://www.
Disabled American Veterans: http://www.dav.org/ omhrc.gov
Easter Seals Disability Services: http://www.easterseals.com/site/ Robert Wood Johnson Foundation: http://www.rwjf.org
PageServer The Body: The Complete HIV/AIDS Resource:
Family Health International: http://www.fhi.org/en/index.htm http://www.thebody.com/index/hotlines/other.html
Guide Dogs for the Blind: http://www.guidedogs.com United States Access Board: http://www.access-board.gov/
National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance: http://naafa.org
National Association of the Deaf: http://www.nad.org Rights: http://www.hhs.gov/ocr
National Center for Health Statistics: http://www.cdc.gov/nchswww U.S. Department of Justice (Americans with Disabilities Act
National Council on Disability: http://www.ncd.gov Home Page): http://www.usdoj.gov/crt/ada/adahom1.htm
National Federation of the Blind: http://www.nfb.org Universal Design Alliance: http://www.universaldesign.org/
National Institute of Diabetes & Digestive & Kidney Diseases: Women with Disabilities (The National Health Information
http://www.niddk.nih.gov Center): http://www.4woman.gov/wwd

You might also like