Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psychological effects of
breastfeeding on children and
mothers
comparing children who were exclu- other environmental factors such as peer observations using the Home Observa-
sively breastfed to children who received influence and parental intellectual stim- tion Measurement of the Environment
mixed feeding (formula combined with ulation may become better predictors of (HOME) [26]. Similarly, when control-
human milk), the exclusively breastfed cognitive function. ling for socio-economic status and gesta-
children displayed a consistent increase There is, however, some evidence to tional age, von Stumm and Plomin [27]
in their intelligence scores from age 1 demonstrate that breastfeeding experi- report only a marginal impact of breast-
to age 7. Critically, another large-scale ence during infancy impacts cognitive feeding experience on girls’, but not boys’,
longitudinal study has shown that even abilities well beyond infancy, even into IQ at 2 years of age and no impact at a fol-
when controlling for the intelligence adulthood. For example, Mortensen et al. low-up visit at 16 years. More generally,
of the mother, intelligence benefits as [4] investigated cognitive performance in due to the high number of potentially
a function of exclusive breastfeeding two different cohorts using different in- confounding factors and the difficulty of
experience can be seen among children telligence tests. This study showed that controlling for all of them effectively in
[21]. across cohorts and measurement instru- one study, cautionis needed whendesign-
The initiation of breastfeeding imme- ments, longer duration of breastfeeding ing and interpreting studies investigating
diately after birth has also been argued during infancy was positively associated the effects of breastfeeding on cognitive
to play a role in reducing the risk for with cognitive performance as adults [4]. development [28, 29]. For a systematic
cognitive impairment among children. Similarly, recent findings from another and informative review of the role of con-
For example, a clinical study compared cohort revealed that the duration of ex- founding variables in breastfeeding re-
the breastfeeding histories of 4- to 11- clusive breastfeeding was positively asso- search, see [30]. Nonetheless, the existing
year-old children diagnosed with specific ciated with increased intelligence, educa- evidence reviewed in this section points
language impairment (SLI) to those of tional attainment, and income at 30 years to a beneficial effect of breastfeeding, es-
neurotypically developing children and of age [24]. In fact, there is also work to pecially prolonged exclusive breastfeed-
observed that those with SLI were signifi- show that breastfeeding duration during ing, on children’s cognitive (intellectual)
cantly less likely to have been breastfed di- infancy is positively associated with read- development.
rectly after birth [22]. While this suggests ing ability at 53 years of age, as measured This raises the question of what mech-
a correlation between early breastfeed- by the National Adult Reading Test [25]. anism underpins these effects of breast-
ing experience and the development of It is crucial to highlight that the afore- feeding on cognitive development. One
a specific cognitive impairment, it would mentioned studies controlled for a large possible mechanism may relate to specific
be premature and problematic to assign range of potentially confounding mater- nutrients such as the long-chain polyun-
any causal influence to the lack of early nal variables, including but not limited saturated fatty acids (LC-PUFAs), which
breastfeeding on a specific cognitive im- to education, employment, income, age, are present in human milk but usually
pairment. method of delivery, cigarette consump- absent in formula [31]. Two major LC-
More compelling evidence relating tion during pregnancy, and infant birth PUFAs are docosahexaenoic acid (DHA)
breastfeeding to cognitive outcomes weight. Indeed, one large-scale study, and arachidonic acid (ARA), which are
comes from a randomized controlled which included a multitude of poten- involved in neurodevelopment by con-
intervention study including over 13,000 tial confounds in their analysis such as tributing to healthy neuronal growth, re-
mother–infant dyads [7]. In this study, maternal intelligence quotient (IQ), so- pair, and myelination [32]. Importantly,
mothers were randomly assigned to an cial class, and education level, as well myelination predominately occurs post-
exclusive breastfeeding promotion in- as less commonly included confounding natally within the first 18 months of life
tervention, which led to a seven-fold variables such as maternal psychopathol- [33, 34]. Infants produce a small quan-
increase in exclusive breastfeeding at ogy, attachment, and exposure to pollu- tity of DHA during the first 2 weeks of
3 months of age. In this study, chil- tants, still found a robust and indepen- life, but are then unable to produce suf-
dren were longitudinally followed and dent positive impact of prolonged exclu- ficient amounts on their own until about
those children who had prolonged exclu- sive breastfeeding duration on neuropsy- 6 months of age [34]. This suggests
sive breastfeeding experience as infants chological function in children [16]. Yet, the possibility of a window in develop-
showed higher intelligence scores and it is important to acknowledge that not ment during which human brain and cog-
higher teacher ratings of academic profi- all studies find such clear associations be- nitive development may be particularly
ciency at the age of 6.5 years [7]. A recent tween breastfeeding and cognitive out- sensitive to LC-PUFAs supplied through
follow-up study with the same cohort come measures when controlling for po- breastfeeding.
of children at 16 years of age revealed tential confounds. For example, a study There is evidence to support the im-
a persistent impact of prolonged exclu- by Jacobson et al. found an initial im- portance of LC-PUFAs as contributors
sive breastfeeding experience on verbal pact of breastfeeding on children’s intelli- to cognitive development. For example,
abilities, but not on any other neurocog- gence scores at both 4 and 11 years of age, Caspi et al. [35] investigated how indi-
nitive measures [23]. The authors of this but this effect was much reduced when vidual differences in the ability to me-
study suggest that over time, the effects adjusting for maternal intelligence and tabolize and produce LC-PUFAs influ-
of breastfeeding may be “diluted”, and parenting skills assessed during home ences the impact of breastfeeding on cog-
[33, 37–39]. For example, in a cross- Taken together, these findings regard- significantly greater amounts of hostile
sectional design, Deoni et al. [33] in- ing brain development suggest that ele- (aggressive) behavior in adults who were
vestigated white matter maturation from ments of breast milk itself, particularly not breastfed as infants compared to
10 months to 4 years of age and found LC-PUFAs, likely contribute to enhanced those who were breastfed [44].
a positive association between the dura- patterns of myelination in the develop- Furthermore, there is accumulating
tion of exclusive breastfeeding and the ing brain, but they do not fully account evidence to suggest that the absence or
development of white matter tracts. This for the reported effects of breastfeeding short duration of exclusive breastfeeding
study reported breastfeeding-related in- on brain development. Therefore, there might be associated with the devel-
creases in white matter in regions that must be additional factors that contribute opment of autism spectrum disorder
typically mature later in development, to the seen effects of breastfeeding. Such (ASD), a neurodevelopmental disorder
including frontal and temporal regions. factors could potentially be aspects of characterized by social impairments.
Furthermore, this study reported that the interaction between mother and in- A recent meta-analysis of over 2000
breastfeeding was associated with white fant such as touch and warmth, or other children reports that those diagnosed
matter in tracts commonly associated substrates contained in the breastmilk with ASD were significantly less likely
with higher-order cognition and socio- such as hormones that are not present in to have been breastfed than neurotyp-
emotional functioning, including the formula. ical children [45]. Furthermore, it has
superior longitudinal fasciculus [33]. been reported that children with over
Another critical follow-up study from Breastfeeding and social and 6 months of exclusive breastfeeding or
the same group of researchers assessed emotional development in formula supplemented with DHA exhibit
changes in white matter volume in a lon- children the lowest probability (measured as odds
gitudinal design [39]. In this study, ratios) for subsequently being diagnosed
breastfed children displayed a prolonged In addition to the effects reported on with ASD [46]. Along the same lines, Al-
window of white matter development children’s cognitive and brain develop- Farsi and colleagues observed that exclu-
between 16 months and 2 years, resulting ment, there is evidence that breastfeeding sive breastfeeding duration significantly
in an overall myelin increase detectable also impacts social and emotional de- reduced the likelihood for developing
by 2 years of age that persisted through velopment in children. There is work ASD. This study further reported that the
childhood. These findings corrobo- to suggest that breastfeeding experi- late initiation of breastfeeding increases
rate the EEG spectral power analyses ence is associated with differences in likelihood for developing ASD, possibly
presented above [36], suggesting that infant temperament. For example, at related to the limited or lacking con-
breastfeeding influences the timing and 3 months of age, breastfed infants are sumption of colostrum or first milk by
duration of myelination processes in reported to show greater negative affect the newborn infant, which is particularly
infancy. In comparison, formula-fed in- than formula-fed infants [40]. Similarly, rich in antibodies, immune cells, and
fants displayed a significantly slower rate negative temperament, such as fussiness, protein content [47].
of white matter development between 1 has also been found to be associated with It is important to emphasize that
and 2 years of age, and the overall volume a prolonged duration of breastfeeding in some studies have not found an im-
continued to remain below the volume infancy [41]. In contrast, another study pact of breastfeeding on ASD diagnosis.
measured for the breastfed infants. Fur- found that breastfed infants were re- For example, in a large phone survey
thermore, Deoni et al. [39] compared the ported to have more “vigor” at 3 months of parents of 2- to 5-year-old children,
brain development outcomes of infants of age, characterized by greater approach ASD diagnosis was not associated with
fed different types of formula. Notably, and activity, than formula-fed infants any measure of breastfeeding history,
infants fed with formulas with the high- [42]. Thus, the evidence concerning including exclusive breastfeeding du-
est levels of DHA and ARA showed the the association between breastfeeding is ration [48]. It is also critical to note
white matter development most similar mixed and may depend on the specific that it is problematic to assign a causal
to breastfed infants, albeit on a smaller temperament characteristic examined. role to breastfeeding in the development
scale. This suggests that adding DHA There is also research indicating a neg- of ASD because infants later diagnosed
and ARA to formula can help reduce the ative association between breastfeeding with ASD as children may already display
effect that the absence of breastfeeding experience and aggressive behavior. For certain characteristics that make breast-
has on white matter development during example, duration of breastfeeding ex- feeding more difficult for the mothers.
infancy. At the same time, this study perience has been shown to correlate A study by Lucas and Cutler reports
also shows that adding DHA and ARA negatively with parent-reported antiso- “dysregulated” breastfeeding patterns in
to formula cannot completely restore cial and aggressive behavior in children infants later diagnosed with ASD, and
the effects of breastfeeding, suggesting from 4 to 11 years of age [43]. These cite potential mechanisms for atypical
that there are other factors at play that effects on antisocial behavior appear to feeding patterns such as reduced joint
contribute to the effects of breastfeeding extend well beyond childhood into adult- attention during social interactions [49].
on brain development. hood. A longitudinal study following More generally, large prospective lon-
adults from 20 to 40 years of age found gitudinal studies that measure social
Table 1 Working modela of how breastfeeding may impact neurocognitive and socio-emotional outcomes in children and mothers
Breastfeeding Source Purported Mechanism Outcome
substrate
Child
Neuro- LC-PUFAs (i. e., Breast milk Neuronal growth and repair Extended rate and duration of myelina-
cognitive DHA and ARA) Genetic variation Myelination tion
Increased whole brain volume and corti-
cal thickness
Increased white matter volume
Heightened cognitive performance (i. e.,
IQ, executive function)
Socio- Oxytocin Breast milk Facilitated social perception Heightened attention to positive emo-
emotional Endogenous release due to touch, Prosocial behavior tional expressions
warmth, and eye contact during Bonding Reduced antisocial and aggressive behav-
social interaction Anxiolytic effects ior
Genetic variation Interaction with other hormones Reduced likelihood of ASD diagnosis
and neurotransmitter systems
Mother
Socio- Oxytocin Milk ejection reflex Facilitated social perception Reduced subjective stress
emotional Endogenous release due to touch, Prosocial behavior Reduced physiological stress (i. e., cortisol
warmth, and eye contact during Bonding levels, cardiac vagal tone modulation)
social interaction Anxiolytic effects Mother–infant attachment
Genetic variation Interaction with other hormones Heightened neural sensitivity to infant
and neurotransmitter systems cues
Reduced postpartum depression
Heightened positive affect
LC-PUFAs long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, DHA docosahexaenoic acid, ARA arachidonic acid, IQ intelligence quotient, ASD autism spectrum
disorder
a
Here we outline potential mechanisms underlying the main psychological effects observed in this review. Please note that this list is not exhaustive and
only serves to highlight potential underlying processes and mechanisms
reduced sleep disturbance [59]. Criti- nal oxytocin levels during breastfeeding infants more [68], are more responsive
cally, breastfeeding also impacts mothers’ [63]. More evidence in support of this to their infants [69], and spend more
responses to emotions in others and may notion comes from a recent study which time in mutual gaze with infants dur-
thereby improve social interactions and revealed that mothers’ genetic variation ing feedings than bottle-feeding moth-
relationships. More specifically, recent in oxytocin (as indexed through the CD38 er–infant dyads do [70]. Moreover, in
work shows that prolonged durations rs3796863 SNP) impacts the rate at which a prospective longitudinal study of 675
of exclusive breastfeeding are linked to cortisol decreases during a breastfeed- mother–infant dyads, increased duration
facilitated responses to inviting (happy) ing session. Specifically, mothers with of breastfeeding was associated with ma-
facial expressions and that more frequent the non-risk genotype, associated with ternal sensitive responsiveness, increased
breastfeeding on a given day is linked higher oxytocin levels, showed a steeper attachment security, and decreased at-
with reduced responsivity to threatening reduction in cortisol. Strikingly, this dif- tachment disorganization when infants
(angry) facial expressions [60]. ferential reduction in cortisol was found were 14 months of age [71]. Brain imag-
In summary, there is research show- in their infants as well [64]. It is thus ing work also provides evidence for a pos-
ing that breastfeeding has beneficial ef- likely that the positive effects of breast- itive influence of breastfeeding on the
fects on mothers’ own mood, affect, and feeding on the measures reviewed above mother–child relationship. For exam-
stress, and also that breastfeeding facil- have a physiological basis in an upreg- ple, in a functional MRI (fMRI) study,
itates responses to positive emotions in ulation of endogenous oxytocin levels it was found that exclusively breastfeed-
others. Similar effects on affect and stress among breastfeeding mothers. ing mothers exhibited greater brain ac-
as seen here for breastfeeding are also tivation in several limbic brain regions
observed in studies administering oxy- Breastfeeding and mother–infant when listening to their own infant’s cries
tocin intranasally compared to a placebo attachment as compared to exclusive formula feed-
[61, 62], suggesting that breastfeeding ers, suggesting greater involvement of
may affect (increase) endogenous oxy- Breastfeeding is also thought to facilitate emotional brain systems in breastfeed-
tocin levels in the mothers. This is in maternal sensitivity and secure attach- ing mothers [72].
line with the known role of oxytocin ment between mother and child [65–67]. In this context, it is important to note
during breastfeeding and supported by There is research to show that moth- that breastfeeding has not always been
research documenting a rise in mater- ers who breastfeed tend to touch their found to be directly linked to attachment
development at 2 and 3 years of age in the EDEN supplementation on means-end problem solving
Compliance with ethical Mother-Child Cohort. J Pediatr 163:36–U414 in 9-month-olds. Child Dev 80:1376–1384
guidelines 14. Fenson L, Marchman VA, Thal DJ, Dale PS, 32. Guesnet P, Alessandri JM (2011) Docosahex-
Reznick JS, Bates E (2006) The MacArthur-Bates aenoic acid (DHA) and the developing central
communicative development inventories user’s nervous system (CNS)—Implications for dietary
Conflict of interest. K.M. Krol and T. Grossmann guide and technical manual, 2nd edn. Paul H. recommendations. Biochimie 93:7–12
declare that they have no competing interests. Brookes Publishing Co Inc, Baltimore 33. Deoni SC, Dean DC 3rd, Piryatinksy I,
15. Squires J, Potter L, Bricker D (1999) The ASQ user’s O’Muircheartaigh J, Waskiewicz N, Lehman
This is a review article of already published research guide for the ages and stages questionnaires: K et al (2013) Breastfeeding and early white
that has been conducted according to the guidelines a parent-completed child-monitoring system, matter development: a cross-sectional study.
imposed by the respective journals in which the re- 2nd edn. Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co Inc, Neuroimage 82:77–86
search was published. Baltimore 34. Cockburn F (2003) Role of infant dietary long-
16. Julvez J, Guxens M, Carsin AE et al (2014) A chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, liposoluble
Open Access. Thisarticleisdistributedundertheterms cohort study on full breastfeeding and child vitamins, cholesterol and lecithin on psychomotor
of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International neuropsychological development: the role of development. Acta Paediatr Suppl 92:19–33
License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ maternal social, psychological, and nutritional 35. Caspi A, Williams B, Kim-Cohen J et al (2007)
4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, factors. Dev Med Child Neurol 56:148–156 Moderation of breastfeeding effects on the IQ by
and reproduction in any medium, provided you give 17. Quinn PJ, O’Callaghan M, Williams GM, Najman genetic variation in fatty acid metabolism. Proc
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the JM, Andersen MJ, Bor W (2001) The effect of Natl Acad Sci USA 104:18860–18865
source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, breastfeeding on child development at 5 years: a 36. Jing HK, Gilchrist JM, Badger TM, Pivik RT (2010)
and indicate if changes were made. cohort study. J Paediatr Child Health 37:465–469 A longitudinal study of differences in electroen-
18. Dunn LM, Dunn LM (1981) Peabody picture cephalographic activity among breastfed, milk
vocabulary test-revised. American Guidance formula-fed, and soy formula-fed infants during
References Service, Circle Pines the first year of life. Early Hum Dev 86:119–125
19. Wechsler D (1974) Manual of the Wechsler Intel- 37. Isaacs EB, Fischl BR, Quinn BT, Chong WK, Gadian
1. Hinde K, German JB (2012) Food in an evolutionary ligence Scale for children-revised. Psychological DG, Lucas A (2010) Impact of breast milk on
context: insights from mother’s milk. J Sci Food Corporation, New York intelligence quotient, brain size, and white matter
Agric 92:2219–2223 20. Jedrychowski W, Perera F, Jankowski J et al development. Pediatr Res 67:357–362
2. Figueiredo B, Canario C, Field T (2014) Breastfeed- (2012) Effect of exclusive breastfeeding on the 38. Kafouri S, Kramer M, Leonard G et al (2013)
ing is negatively affected by prenatal depression development of children’s cognitive function in Breastfeeding and brain structure in adolescence.
and reduces postpartum depression. Psychol Med the Krakow prospective birth cohort study. Eur J Int J Epidemiol 42:150–159
44:927–936 Pediatr 171:151–158 39. Deoni SC, Dean DC III, Joelson S, O’Regan J,
3. Raju TN (2011) Breastfeeding is a dynamic 21. Kanazawa S (2015) Breastfeeding is positively Schneider N (2018) Early nutrition influences
biological process—not simply a meal at the associated with child intelligence even net of developmental myelination and cognition in
breast. Breastfeed Med 6:257–259 parental IQ. Dev Psychol 51(12):1683–1689. infants and young children. Neuroimage. https://
4. Mortensen EL, Michaelsen KF, Sanders SA, Reinisch https://doi.org/10.1037/dev0000060 doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.12.056
JM (2002) The association between duration 22. Diepeveen FB, van Dommelen P, Oudesluys- 40. Lauzon-Guillain B, Wijndaele K, Clark M et al (2012)
of breastfeeding and adult intelligence. JAMA Murphy AM, Verkerk PH (2017) Specific language Breastfeeding and infant temperament at age
287:2365–2371 impairment is associated with maternal and family three months. PLoS One 7:e29326
5. Oddy WH (2002) Long-term health outcomes factors. Child Care Health Dev 43:401–405 41. Taut C, Kelly A, Zgaga L (2016) The association
and mechanisms associated with breastfeed- 23. YangS,MartinRM,OkenEetal(2018)Breastfeeding between infant temperament and breastfeeding
ing. Expert Rev Pharmacoecon Outcomes Res during infancy and neurocognitive function in duration: a cross-sectional study. Breastfeed Med
2:161–177 adolescence: 16-year follow-up of the PROBIT 11:111–118
6. Oddy WH, Kendall GE, Blair E, de Klerk NH, Silburn cluster-randomized trial. PLoS Med 15:e1002554 42. Kielbratowska B, Kazmierczak M, Michalek J, Preis
S, Zubrick S (2004) Breastfeeding and cognitive 24. Victora CG, Horta BL, de Mola CL et al (2015) As- K (2015) Temperament and the mother-infant
development in children. Adv Exp Med Biol sociation between breastfeeding and intelligence, dyad: associations with breastfeeding and formula
554:365–369 educational attainment, and income at 30 years of feeding with a bottle. Infant Ment Health J
7. KramerMS, AboudF, MironovaEetal(2008)Breast- age: a prospective birth cohort study from Brazil. 36:243–250
feeding and child cognitive development—new Lancet Glob Health 3:E199–E205 43. Shelton KH, Collishaw S, Rice FJ, Harold GT, Thapar
evidence from a large randomized trial. Arch Gen 25. Richards M, Hardy R, Wadsworth ME (2002) A (2011) Using a genetically informative design to
Psychiatry 65:578–584 Long-term effects of breast-feeding in a national examine the relationship between breastfeeding
8. Daniels MC, Adair LS (2005) Breast-feeding birth cohort: educational attainment and midlife and childhood conduct problems. Eur Child
influences cognitive development in Filipino cognitive function. Public Health Nutr 5:631–635 Adolesc Psychiatry 20:571–579
children. J Nutr 135:2589–2595 26. Jacobson SW, Chiodo LM, Jacobson JL (1999) 44. Merjonen P, Jokela M, Pulkki-Raback L et al (2011)
9. Ludington SM, Hadeed A, Anderson G (1991) Breastfeeding effects on intelligence quotient in Breastfeeding and offspring hostility in adulthood.
Cardiorespiratory, thermal and state effects of 4- and 11-year-old children. Pediatrics 103:e71 Psychother Psychosom 80:371–373
Kangaroo Care for preterm infants—randomized 27. von Stumm S, Plomin R (2015) Breastfeeding and 45. Tseng PT, Chen YW, Stubbs B et al (2017) Maternal
control trial. Pediatr Res 29:A223–A223 IQ growthfromtoddlerhoodthroughadolescence. breastfeeding and autism spectrum disorder in
10. Bayley N (1933) Mental growth during the first PLoS ONE 10:e138676 children: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
three years. A developmental study of sixty-one 28. Jain A, Concato J, Leventhal JM (2002) How Nutr Neurosci 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1080/
children by repeated tests. Genet Psychol Monogr good is the evidence linking breastfeeding and 1028415X.2017.1388598
14:1–92 intelligence? Pediatrics 109:1044–1053 46. Schultz ST, Klonoff-Cohen HS, Wingard DL et al
11. Guxens M, Mendez MA, Molto-Puigmarti C et al 29. Der G, Batty GD, Deary IJ (2006) Effect of breast (2006) Breastfeeding, infant formula supplemen-
(2011) Breastfeeding, long-chain polyunsaturated feeding on intelligence in children: prospective tation, and autistic disorder: the results of a parent
fatty acids in colostrum, and infant mental study, sibling pairs analysis, and meta-analysis. survey. Int Breastfeed J 1:16
development. Pediatrics 128:E880–E889 BMJ 333:945–948a 47. Al-Farsi YM, Al-Sharbati MM, Waly MI et al (2012)
12. Leventakou V, Roumeliotaki T, Koutra K et al (2015) 30. Walfisch A, Sermer C, Cressman A, Koren G (2013) Effect of suboptimal breast-feeding on occurrence
Breastfeeding duration and cognitive, language Breast milk and cognitive development—the role of autism: a case-control study. Nutrition
and motor development at 18 months of age: rhea of confounders: a systematic review. BMJ Open 28:e27–32
mother-child cohort in Crete, Greece. J Epidemiol 3:e3259 48. Husk JS, Keim SA (2015) Breastfeeding and autism
Community Health 69:232–239 31. Drover J, Hoffman DR, Castaneda YS, Morale SE, dpectrum disorder in the National Survey of
13. Bernard JY, De Agostini M, Forhan A et al Birch EE (2009) Three randomized controlled trials Children’s Health. Epidemiology 26:451–457
(2013) Breastfeeding duration and cognitive of early long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acid