Professional Documents
Culture Documents
& dfljomar Binay against Romulo tle proclamation of Fena and order the district of Makati. werc disenftanchised to be NulyMisrcad (SOV) for 85 out of the 235 clusterer
2019 congressionalracein the lstDistxict cast ald other election documents in all Board ofCanvassers winner in Makati's Mor€o\,€4 the campoftheformervice elections.
of Makati citv prwincts
the 235 protested cluster lst consressional district consressional r#:1"ili'#i#frT*HifrJ""iffiH
,"rfrL"f :"if!;;?i$#ilH*:T#
"of
for as a result several cincts, citing the following grounds:
the failure of
lote+ountingmachinesffCMs)inmany . Various electionirregularities
cluster€dprecincts to hansmitthe actual frauds andrampantviolations ofelectior
election results. laws, rules and regulations committer
. Per the Certilicate of Canvass of by Pefia and his allies on the day of thr
Votes, Fena garnered 71,035 roies against elections;
Binay's 65,229 votes, or a presumptive . Wdespread brownouts of suspi
margin of5,806 votes. cious causes tlat occurred simultane
?he electoralprotest 3tatea tnat ttre ously in the barangays of San Antonic
vo0esin contesta.re "suciallydetermina- Bangkal, and San Isidro on or about 5:3r
tive" ofthe true representative ofMaka- pm to 6:30 pm. Watchers have atteste(
ti's first district, considering the "slim tiat the brownouts affected the frrnction
margin" beh,!€en their vote counts. ing of the VCMs and reduced the abilib
"As it is, the proclamation of (Pena )I of the watchers to observe the activitier
was based on figuTs plagued by mys- \ inside the precincts, among others.
o pAQa -qv