You are on page 1of 16

98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 1

OF THE
FRIENDS EARTH
www.foe.org | Volume 35, Number 3 | Fall 2005 N E W S M A G A Z I N E

Is Nuclear Power
Making a Comeback?

Chemical Weapons
The Secret Time Bomb

Mountain Gorillas
on the Brink
CFC
#0908 Shell Oil Project
Threatens Wildlife
98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 2

PRESIDENT’S COLUMN ■

Hurricane Damage Highlights


Environmental Injustice in the Gulf
FRIENDS OF THE EARTH extends our injustice of not providing faster and
deepest sympathies to the victims of more comprehensive relief is a terri-
Hurricane Katrina. Hundreds of ble commentary on the values of the
thousands of people continue to Bush administration.
experience numerous hardships in As the science of climate change
the aftermath of the hurricane. As has become more precise in recent
we move forward, it is critical that years, the latest research indicates
we learn from past mistakes. that the intensity of hurricanes is
The channeling of the Mississippi growing. An MIT study this year sug-
photo credit: Lisa Matthes

River from its natural course coupled gests a dramatic increase in hurricane
with rampant oil and gas exploration intensity in the last 30 years. Global
in Louisiana have radically under- warming may well be bringing us
mined wetlands. This has created stronger hurricanes as well as many
environmental conditions for hurri- other kinds of violent weather events.
cane destruction that were most We must address our nation’s
Brent Blackwelder, President
dangerous for the least powerful. global warming emissions, as well as
Indeed, this disaster is the most Unfortunately, the problem does return critical coastal areas to their
devastating example of environmen- not end with water projects. natural state. Unfortunately,
tal injustice ever experienced in the Congress is handling national policy President Bush has failed at a
United States. The inundation of on energy and transportation the national level to push energy legisla-
New Orleans and the resulting same way. The energy bill and the tion that would put the country on
human misery have laid bare the transportation bill passed by track for a clean energy future.
unsettling links between human Congress this summer don’t repre- Instead, Bush has spearheaded legis-
inequity and the environment sent coherent policy, but rather a lation that subsidizes nuclear power.
around us. string of subsidies and handouts to As the cover story of this issue
For 36 years, Friends of the Earth influential lobbies. details, wind power stands in stark
has been working to prevent these So where has this haphazard, pork contrast to the environmental and
types of disasters. We have cam- barrel-driven development taken us? public health threats posed by an
paigned against faulty flood control In the case of the Gulf Coast, federal increase in the use of nuclear power.
projects built by the Army Corps of and state governments have repeat- I concluded my summer vacation
Engineers and other federal agen- edly encouraged and allowed con- with a tour of wind development in
cies, which have undermined the struction and development in sensi- western New York State and Kansas.
safety of Louisiana and other Gulf tive areas. Taxpayer money has been While Congress has doled out billions
Coast residents. But standing in the spent on projects in hazard zones, to the nuclear industry with the sign-
way of real reform has been the destroying or compromising marsh- ing of the energy bill, wind energy is
ever-present power of the pork bar- lands, mangroves, sand dunes, and quietly emerging as power source
rel. Most water resource projects are barrier islands—all natural defenses that is both affordable and clean.
not approved and built based on any against storm surges. As a result, we It is critical that we reduce our
merit or need; rather, they are built have more and more damage, loss of global warming emissions to stem
because influential constituents and life, tragedy and suffering. the tide of severe weather events
campaign contributors, including The suffering is particularly tragic and the other adverse impacts of
the construction lobby, want them, in the case of New Orleans, where rapid climate change. Now is the
and because members lack the we have witnessed the plight of poor time to demand that our leaders act.
courage to critique projects in other and minorities trapped in flood
members’ districts. waters. The obvious environmental

2 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005


98906mvpR2 10/19/05 10:42 AM Page 3

CONTENTS ■

OF THE
FRIENDS EARTH
www.foe.org
Volume 35, Number 3
N E W S M A G A Z I N E Fall 2005

Is Nuclear Power Recipes for a Clean House . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14


Making a Comeback? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Shell Oil Project
The Secret Time Bomb Threatens Wildlife . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
– Chemical Weapons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Now is the Season
Campaign News. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 for Workplace Giving! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

Mountain Gorillas of Changing of the Guard … . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16


Central Africa On the Brink . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

Friends of the Earth (ISSN: 1054-1829) is published quarterly by Friends of the Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave., NW, Suite
600, Washington, DC 20036-2008, phone 202-783-7400, fax 202-783-0444, e-mail: foe@foe.org, website: www.foe.org.
Annual membership dues are $25, which include a subscription to Friends of the Earth. The words “Friends of the
Earth” and the FoE logo are exclusive trademarks of Friends of the Earth, all rights reserved. Requests to reprint articles
should be submitted to Lisa Grob at lgrob@foe.org. Periodicals postage paid at Washington, DC.

Our Mission: Friends of the Earth defends the environment and champions a healthy and just world.

Board of Directors Bluewater Network Staff Affiliates


Dan Gabel, Chair; Arlie Schardt, Vice Chair; Harriett Marsha Mather-Thrift, Managing Director Africa: Earthlife Africa; Australia:
Crosby, Secretary; David Zwick, Treasurer; Whitey Danielle Fugere, Global Warming Campaign Director Mineral Policy Institute; Australia:
Bluestein; Jayni Chase; Clarence Ditlow; Michael Herz; Julie Rinard, Development Coordinator Rainforest Information Centre; Brazil:
Ann Hoffman; Marika Holmgren; Doug Legum; Carl Schneebeck, Public Lands Campaign Director Amigos da Terra Amazonia -
Russell Long; Garrett Loube; Patricia Matthews; Avis Teri Shore, Clean Vessels Director Amazônia Brasileira; Brazil: Grupo de
Ogilvy Moore; Charles Moore; Edwardo Lao Rhodes; Friends of Trabalho Amazonico; Canada: Blue
Doria Steedman; Rick Taketa; Alicia Wittink. Consultants/Advisors
Brian Dunkiel Bill Freese the Earth Planet Project; Czech Republic: CEE
International Bankwatch; Japan: Peace Boat; Middle
Staff John W. Jensen Dorothee Krahn East: Friends of the Earth Middle East;
Brent Blackwelder, President Fred Millar Netherlands: Action for Solidarity, Equality,
Norman Dean, Executive Director Environment and Development Europe; Netherlands:
Lisa Archer, Campaigns Coordinator, Health & Member Groups
Argentina, Australia, Austria, Bangladesh, Belgium, Stichting De Noordzee (North Sea Foundation);
Environment Program Netherlands: Corporate Europe Observatory;
Elizabeth Bast, International Policy Analyst Belgium (Flanders), Bolivia, Brazil, Bulgaria, Cameroon,
Canada, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Croatia, Curacao, Netherlands: Wise Europe; United States: Corpwatch;
Richard Bell, Media Director United States: International Rivers Network; United
Michelle Chan-Fishel, Green Investments Project Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, El Salvador, England-
Wales-Northern Ireland, Estonia, Finland, France, States: Rainforest Action Network
Director
Hugh Cheatham, Chief Financial Officer Georgia, Germany, Ghana, Grenada, Guatemala, Haiti,
Rosemary Greenaway, Director of Membership and Honduras, Hungary, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Japan,
Marketing Korea, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Macedonia,
David Hirsch, Program Director Malaysia, Mali, Malta, Mauritius, Nepal, Netherlands, R
LIED P I NTING
AL

Cheryl Johnson, Receptionist/Office Assistant New Zealand, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Norway, Papua New UNION
TRADES LABEL COUNCIL
WA S
HI NGTON

Lisa Matthes, Executive Assistant Guinea, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Scotland,
Michelle Medeiros, Senior Campaigner, International Sierra Leone, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Sri Lanka,
Swaziland, Sweden, Switzerland, Togo, Tunisia, Friends of the Earth is printed with soy ink on
Financial Institutions 100% recycled paper, 30% post-consumer
Chris Pabon, Director of Foundation Relations Ukraine, United States, Uruguay.
content. Bleached without chlorine.
Colin Peppard, Transportation Coordinator
Erich Pica, Director, Domestic Program
David Waskow, Director, International Program
Chris Weiss, Director of D.C. Environmental Network
Anne White, Development Director Earth Share giving campaigns allow you to designate a donation
Sara Zdeb, Legislative Director
to Friends of the Earth. Federal employees can donate through
Publications Staff the Combined Federal Campaign by marking #0908 on their
Lisa Grob, Editor
Design by JML Design pledge forms. To set up an Earth Share campaign at your work-
place, contact Rosemary Greenaway at 202-222-0722.

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 3


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 4

COVER STORY ■

Is Nuclear Power

By Elizabeth Bast, International Policy Is Nuclear Power “Clean”? reduce greenhouse gas emissions that
Analyst, Friends of the Earth & Erich lead to global warming and other air
In the late 1990s, the nuclear power
Pica, Director, Economic Programs, pollution. The ads, sponsored by the
industry began efforts to buy a new
Friends of the Earth trade group Nuclear Energy Institute
reputation through misleading adver-
(NEI), hyped nuclear power as a clean,
FOR MORE THAN 30 YEARS, safety tising and public relations campaigns.
emission-free energy source.
concerns and the failure of the The industry presented nuclear power
Environmental groups filed a com-
nuclear industry to prove itself eco- as a clean source of energy that would
plaint with the Federal Trade
nomically viable have kept nuclear
Commission, which ultimately ruled
power from expanding. No new
that the ads were inaccurate.
nuclear power plants have been Since 1948, the Undeterred, the most recent ad cam-
ordered in the United States since
1978. But with the help of a multi-mil- federal government paign released by NEI contains the
tag-line,“Nuclear. The Clean Air
lion dollar ad campaign and
increased political support from the has spent $73.4 Energy.”
Despite the marketing efforts of
White House and Congress, the
nuclear power industry could make a billion on research the nuclear power industry, the sim-
ple reality is that nuclear power is
comeback – offering nuclear energy
as the answer to both global warm- and development not clean energy. Generating nuclear
power produces radioactive waste
ing and the nation’s growing need for
electricity. for the nuclear that must be stored and managed
for millennia, and there is still no
power industry. long-term storage system in place
for the radioactive waste we have

4 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 5

COVER STORY ■

Making a Comeback?
already produced. Radioactive mate- warming pollution from the electric- government’s Sandia National
rials used at nuclear power plants ity sector by 47 percent by 2025, Laboratory identified worst case sce-
still pose safety concerns, and acci- while saving $36 billion annually in narios that could cost more than
dents at nuclear power plants are electricity costs and cutting U.S. $300 billion. Despite these govern-
still a serious possibility. reliance on nuclear power by nearly ment handouts, no nuclear power
Construction of new plants seems half. plants have been ordered since 1978,
particularly inappropriate consider- and more than 100 reactors have
ing the heightened concern over ter- The Numbers Still Don’t been canceled, including all ordered
rorist attacks in a post-9/11 world. Add Up after 1973. When asked in May about
Nor is nuclear power a solution to Nuclear power plants cost more the prospect of financing a new
global warming. According to a than $4 billion to construct, creating nuclear power plant, Thomas Capps,
Massachusetts Institute of substantial start up costs for new chairman of Dominion, one of the
Technology (MIT) report, it would plants. Since 1948, the federal gov- nation’s largest producers of energy,
take the construction of more than ernment has spent $73.4 billion on replied, “Standard & Poor’s and
1000 new nuclear power plants research and development for the Moody’s would have a heart attack,
worldwide to significantly affect nuclear power industry. Congress and my chief financial officer would,
global warming. Building nuclear also passed the Price-Anderson Act, too.”
reactors on this scale would exacer- In spite of this, the nuclear power
bate safety issues and create massive industry went to Congress and the
amounts of radioactive waste. The energy bill Bush administration to seek addi-
Adding to this, many new plants tional federal help to change the
would likely produce a shortage of contains more economic picture for nuclear power.
uranium supplies by the end of the The energy bill, passed by Congress
century, requiring the development than $12 billion and signed into law by President
of another power option in the next Bush this summer, attempts to pick
100 years. In addition, uranium min- in subsidies for up where Wall Street investors have
ing, milling and enrichment rely on left off, offering substantial subsidies
fossil fuels, meaning that nuclear the construction for the construction of new nuclear
power production would still emit power plants.
greenhouse gases. and operation of The energy bill contains more
A recent report conducted for the than $12 billion in subsidies for the
U.S. Public Interest Research Group new nuclear construction and operation of new
by Synapse Energy Economics shows nuclear power plants. The bill pro-
that the U.S. can substantially power plants. vides loan guarantees, which reduce
reduce global warming pollution the financial risk of private invest-
while reducing its reliance on ment in new plants, shifting the bur-
nuclear power. The report concluded which caps the liability of the den to the taxpayer instead. The bill
that modest investments in energy nuclear power industry at $10 billion provides nearly $6 billion in produc-
efficiency and renewable energy in the event of an accident, even tion subsidies for new plants that
would allow the U.S. to reduce global though studies conducted by the
(continued on page 6)

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 5


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 6

COVER STORY ■

(continued from page 5) concluded: “…an electric utility with There are Real Solutions
will make the plants more profitable a nuclear exposure has weaker cred-
to Climate Change
in a shorter period of time. In addi- it than one without and can expect
Overlooked and ignored by Congress
tion, it protects the nuclear power to pay more on the margin for cred-
and nuclear power proponents are
industry from being financially it. Federal support of construction
the truly clean and cost effective
liable in the case of an accident. The costs will do little to change that
solutions to the global warming cri-
bill also authorizes spending of reality. Therefore, were a utility to
sis. Renewable energy and energy
more than $1.5 billion for more embark on a new or expanded
efficiency are viable alternatives to
research and development. nuclear endeavor, Standard & Poor’s
conventional energy technologies,
This funding may not be enough would likely revisit its rating on the
and many state and local govern-
to convince Wall Street to invest in utility.” While it is too early to deter-
ments are supporting these tech-
new nuclear power plants. In previ- mine whether the provisions in the
nologies, in spite of the failure at the
ous legislative attempts to fund the energy bill are enough to revitalize
federal level.
construction of new nuclear power the nuclear power industry, these
Wind power is becoming a more
plants, Standard & Poor’s, the world’s new subsidies certainly open the
cost effective means of producing
leading provider of independent door for a nuclear comeback.
electricity every year, and it now rivals
credit ratings and risk evaluation,

Wind energy is catching on in Gray County, Kansas. This installation is now generating 110 megawatts of power.

6 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 7

COVER STORY ■

conventional sources of energy in ing global warming emissions – by gy sources. Several cities, including
terms of cost per kilowatt hour. Wind some estimates, energy efficiency Washington, D.C., and San Francisco,
is an abundant source of energy that only costs 2 cents per kilowatt hour, CA have also passed renewable port-
can be produced on an industrial well below the market price of elec- folio standards. Several states are
scale and fed into the grid—the tricity. Some states are passing ener- also working to reduce global warm-
nation’s system of electricity genera- gy efficiency legislation, promoting ing emissions from cars and trucks –
tion, transmission and distribution. efficiency in light bulbs and other where most of our global warming
The United States has more than appliances that can save electricity emissions come from.
8,000 gigawatts of raw wind poten- and can also cost the consumer less It is this sort of leadership in pro-
tial – nearly 10 times the total over the life of the product. moting renewable energy and ener-
installed electric generating capacity States and cities throughout the gy efficiency that the federal govern-
in the United States in 2001. Solar country are also passing renewable ment must show in order for the
power, although more expensive than energy standards. Nineteen states United States to effectively reduce
wind, is also growing at rapid rates. have passed legislation requiring global warming emissions, not the
Energy efficiency measures are that a certain percentage of electrici- promotion of outdated and costly
the most cost effective way of reduc- ty be produced from renewable ener- nuclear power.

CAMPAIGN NOTES

Friends of the Earth Blocking the


Nuclear Comeback around the World
United States
Friends of the Earth successfully lobbied the House of Representatives to
pass an amendment prohibiting the U.S. Export-Import Bank from financ-
ing nuclear power projects in China. The Export-Import Bank made a pre-
liminary commitment of $5 billion to Westinghouse Corporation for con-
struction of four nuclear reactors in Zhejiang and Guangdong Provinces.
The amendment blocking funding for these plants won on a broad, bipar-
tisan basis 313 – 114. The same amendment failed in the Senate but will be
considered this September by a House-Senate conference committee.
Friends of the Earth and the Nuclear Information and Resource Service
(NIRS) launched a web campaign (www.nukeretro.com) focused on opposing
nuclear power subsidies in the energy bill before the Congress. The cam-
paign featured a comic animation set to a retro music score from the
1970s, when nuclear power was in its heyday. The energy bill ultimately
passed and the nuclear industry stands to gain billions in subsidies.

Europe
Global 2000, the Friends of the Earth member group in Austria is leading
a campaign by Friends of the Earth Europe to phase out nuclear power in
Europe. They intend to collect one million signatures on a petition to
European Union decision makers. The campaign will mobilize national
environmental organizations across Europe and include a major action
day on April 26, 2006, the 20th anniversary of the Chernobyl accident.

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 7


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 8

SECURITY ■

The Secret Time Bomb – Chemical Weapons


Environmental, Public Health, and Security Threats
By Paul F. Walker
Legacy Program Director
Global Green USA
www.globalgreen.org
UNBEKNOWNST TO MOST
AMERICANS, chemical weapons
remain one of the largest, most dan-
gerous, and costly legacies of the Cold
War and continue to threaten public
health, the environment, and security.
Fortunately, most nations, including
the United States and Russia, have
agreed to abolish their chemical
weapons stockpiles, but the challenge
of safe demilitarization remains a
slow, politically contentious, and tech-
nically complex process. In the mean-
time, over 60,000 tons of deadly Russian artillery shells filled with VX nerve agent stored at Shchuch'ye, Kurgan Oblast, in Siberia.

chemical agents, stored in millions of doors, broken windows, and holes in joined the CWC, of which four addi-
weapons potentially subject to leak- the roof. tional ones – Albania, India, Libya, and
age and proliferation, remain in sev- Shortly thereafter, at our discrete South Korea – have declared much
eral countries. urging, the U.S. began negotiations smaller CW stockpiles ranging in size
The first time I visited an existing with Russia to help secure and safely from a few tons to some 500 or more.
chemical weapons (CW) stockpile was destroy this stockpile. Today, over a These six declared CW possessor
in 1994 when I was a member of an decade later, a mammoth destruction states are obliged to abolish their
official on-site inspection of one of facility is 50 percent constructed at stockpiles by April 2012 at the latest
Russia’s largest stockpiles. This was a the Siberian site, not far from the vil- (which includes a five-year extension
U.S. delegation including both con- lage of Shchuch’ye (pronounced to initial 2007 CWC deadlines).
gressional and executive branch “Shoo-Shee”), midway between the However, the process of demilitariza-
members to visit the easternmost of cities of Chelyabinsk and Kurgan in tion has been much longer, more
seven declared Russian CW arsenals. the Kurgan Region. costly and more complex than the
We flew three hours east from This Siberian site, housing 5,400 countries involved had first imagined.
Moscow and spent a full day inside a tons of Russian VX nerve agent, is one
remote chemical weapons depot in of sixteen CW stockpiles in the U.S. Despite Destruction
Siberia, just north of Kazakhstan, and Russia now in the process of Schedule, Stockpiles
inspecting some two million artillery demilitarization and remediation. Remain
and missile warheads filled with VX Russia and the U.S. have declared The U.S. has declared nine stockpiles
nerve agent. What struck us most at 40,000 and 31,500 tons of chemical with 31,500 tons of chemical
the time were two things: the enor- weapons respectively to the weapons. Over the past fifteen years
mous size of this arsenal, represent- Organization for the Prohibition of the U.S. has destroyed about 35 per-
ing about 14 percent of the Russian Chemical Weapons (OPCW), the cent of this arsenal. Russia has
CW arsenal; and the very poor securi- inspection and verification regime declared seven stockpiles with
ty of the stockpile, housed in old established by the 1993 Chemical 40,000 tons of chemical weapons. To
above-ground, corrugated metal Weapons Convention (CWC), in The date, Russia has destroyed slightly
buildings with bicycle padlocks on the Hague. Another 171 countries have

8 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 9

SECURITY ■

over 2 percent of its arsenal – about In addition to declared stockpiles,


850 tons – with only one facility both the U.S. and Russia, along with
operating at Gorny. Two more facili- many other nations, have dumped
ties are scheduled to begin operat- chemical agents and weapons on
ing next year. land and sea over the last century.
The U.S. had originally planned The U.S. alone suspects some 250
over twenty years ago to finish “nonstockpile” dump sites in three
destruction by 1995. This deadline has dozen states, Puerto Rico, and the
been pushed back several times and District of Columbia. While these
now is projected to be 2012, the final sites pose little security risk, they
CWC deadline. Russia has been very have been shown to be dangerous to
slow to begin destruction, opening its health and the environment, espe-
first facility at Gorny in December cially if accidentally unearthed.
2002. It still hopes to meet the 2012 One of the greatest concerns with
CWC deadline for 100 percent destruc- chemical weapons is the risk of
tion, but this will be difficult. theft, diversion, and proliferation.
The U.S. initially projected a total Russian missile warhead filled with VX nerve Terrorist groups such as Aum
agent, stored at Shchuch'ye, Kurgan Oblast,
program cost of $2 billion. This has in Siberia.
Shinrikyo in Tokyo in 1995 have used
now skyrocketed to about $40 bil- chemical weapons, and others such
lion. Likewise, Russia had planned on Environmental, Public as Al Qaeda have vowed to obtain
$2-3 billion, but now projects $7-10 Health and Security weapons of mass destruction. While
billion in total costs to destroy its U.S. CW arsenals are quite secure
CW arsenal. Because of these enor-
Threats from theft, Russia’s stockpile security
mous and unplanned costs, it is Most chemical weapons, in storage leaves much to be desired. Many of
important that the West, through for over three decades, have been the CW stockpiles are also vulnera-
the G8 Global Partnership, help subject to leakage and release of live ble to attack such as we experienced
Russia to cover these costs. The U.S., agent into their protected bunkers; on September 11, 2001.
through its Cooperative Threat some of this agent has leaked out-
Reduction (CTR or “Nunn-Lugar”) side, but in relatively small amounts. The Future
Program, has committed over $1 bil- Accidents have also happened dur- While 173 countries have joined the
lion to Russian CW destruction. ing disassembly, but no one has yet Chemical Weapons Convention
One of the major causes in sched- been killed by leakage or accident; since it opened for signature in
ule delays and cost escalation has there have been minor worker January 1993, nine states remain
been disagreement and uncertainty injuries at stockpile sites. non-signatory and another twelve
on the most appropriate technolo- There is also concern over have not yet ratified it (as of August
gies. Given that a minute amount of gaseous, solid, and liquid toxic waste 29, 2005). The most worrisome are
chemical agent can cause immedi- generated by the incineration and Egypt, Israel, Lebanon, North Korea,
ate death, and that many of them neutralization demilitarization Somalia, and Syria, because they are
are packaged with explosives, most processes. The high thermal process- suspected of chemical weapons
technologies of destruction have had es generate thousands of tons of activities. These states must eventu-
to be both robotic and able to con- atmospheric waste daily; although ally be brought into the CWC
tain explosions. Incineration has permitted by federal and state regu- regime.
been the technology of choice of the latory agencies, these smokestack The bottom line is that we all
U.S. Army, while chemical neutraliza- emissions contain an undetermined need to support the timely and safe
tion with hot water (in the case of amount of pollutants which drift destruction of this secret and ticking
mustard agent) or with caustic uncontrolled downwind. Neutralized time bomb – chemical weapons
reagents such as sodium hydroxide liquid wastes also contain slightly stockpiles and dump sites – but we
(in the case of VX, sarin, and soman toxic substances, but can be held, must make sure that we do no harm
nerve agents) has been chosen by tested, and only then released (or to either the environment or public
Russia and four U.S. states. retreated) and are much more man- health in the process.
ageable.

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 9


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 10

IN BRIEF ■

Campaign News
Rice Farmers in Missouri ous winter use studies showed that Green Mountain National
the best way to protect resources and
Stand Up to Ventria Forest Protected
wildlife is to eliminate snowmobiles.
Friends of the Earth and Anheuser- Calling the Forest Service’s decision
The Bush administration rejected
Busch aided Missouri rice farmers in to log 300 acres of the Green
these studies. Thanks in part to a legal
May by helping chase Ventria Mountain National Forest “arbitrary
challenge by Bluewater Network – a
Bioscience out of Missouri. Ventria and capricious,” the U.S. Second
division of Friends of the Earth, the
planned to grow pharmaceutical- Circuit Court of Appeals handed a
Interior Department must seek addi-
producing genetically engineered solid victory to environmentalists in
tional public input before it can move
rice in Missouri. Anheuser-Busch June. The ruling vacates a decision to
forward with any plans to turn our
threatened to boycott Show-Me first national park into a motorized log pristine, unique and rugged por-
state rice if Ventria was allowed to amusement park. tions of the national forest in the
plant. Now, Ventria’s in North towns of Chittenden and Rochester,
Carolina, growing 75 acres near a In Landmark Decision, Vermont. Friends of the Earth, Forest
rice germplasm facility, against the Federal Court Recognizes Watch, and the Forest Conservation
advice of rice breeders there. Council joined forces in 2003 to stop
Harm Caused by Global
Most of the few ongoing bio- the Old Joe Timber Sale because of
pharm field trials, however, now uti- Warming shared concerns about the impacts
lize non-food crops (like tobacco) or In a groundbreaking case, a federal of logging on recreation, water qual-
marginal food (safflower) crops. judge in California ruled recently ity and wildlife. Vermont’s Federal
Corn, once the favorite crop for this against the Bush administration and District Court denied the lawsuit on
reckless experimentation is little allowed a Friends of the Earth global March 16, 2004. The groups appealed
used now, thanks in part to Friends warming lawsuit to proceed. The the District Court’s decision to the
of the Earth’s efforts. landmark decision is the first time Court of Appeals for the Second
that a federal court has specifically Circuit and the District Court’s deci-
granted legal standing for a suit that sion was reversed.
challenges the federal government to
account for impacts on the Earth’s cli-
mate. The case, brought by Friends of
the Earth, Greenpeace, and four
California and Colorado cities, charges
that the Export-Import Bank (Ex-Im)
and the Oversees Private Investment
Corporation (OPIC) have financed oil
Yellowstone National Park
and other fossil fuel projects around
photo credit: Mike Wells/Friends of the Earth

the world without first evaluating the


Protecting Yellowstone & projects’ global warming impacts to
Grand Teton the United States. The judge noted
The Department of the Interior recent- that the “projects supported by OPIC
ly announced that it will begin a third and Ex-Im are directly or indirectly
study of the impact of winter recre- responsible for approximately 1,911
ation on Yellowstone and Grand Teton million tonnes of carbon dioxide and
National Parks. These two parks, which methane emissions annually, which
are located primarily within equals nearly eight percent of the
Environmental groups accuse shipping com-
Northwestern Wyoming, are the world’s emissions and is equivalent to panies of behaving like pirates in the control
crown jewels of the system. Two previ- one third of the total carbon emis- they exert over the IMO.
sions from the United States in 2003.”
10 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005
98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 11

IN BRIEF ■

Shipping Pollution Protest bipartisan majority in the House of


Representatives to approve the high-
Bluewater Network called for an end
est level of funding in years. In the
to ship pollution piracy at the doors
face of budget cuts across the board,
of the London-based United Nations
this shows a significant commit-
body charged with regulating global
ment by Congress to the benefits of
shipping. The International
an environmentally friendly trans-
Maritime Organization (IMO) has
portation choice.
failed to protect people and the
planet from dirty diesel emissions Challenging Gas Guzzling
spewed by ship smokestacks.
Unfortunately, the IMO is dominated
Volvos
by so-called “flag-of-convenience” Volvo has long enjoyed a reputation
nations such as Panama and Liberia as a leader in making cars safer for
that are known for registering ships passengers and the environment. But
without regard for public health and since being purchased by the Ford
the environment. A single cargo ship Motor Company – which ranks dead
coming into port releases as much last in fuel economy among major
Bluewater Network recently ran this full-page
pollution as 350,000 current-model- ad in The New York Times, and Mother Jones automakers – Volvo has added a new
online. lineup of gas-guzzling SUVs to its fleet
year cars in one hour. The action
helped convince the IMO to begin and not a single new model averages
ways to travel. So when the Bush
negotiating stronger international more than 26.1 miles per gallon.
administration zeroed out Amtrak’s
air pollution standards for ships. Bluewater Network recently published
yearly budget in February, Friends of
an ad in The New York Times asking
the Earth began an intensive cam-
Friends of the Earth paign to stop the elimination of
Volvo to stand up to Ford by again
Leading on Amtrak building cars that will protect the
America’s rail system. Leading the
planet’s fragile environment. Visit the
Amtrak is one of the most fuel effi- environmental community, Friends
Bluewater web site at www.bluewater-
cient and environmentally friendly of the Earth was able to convince a
network.org to send a letter to Volvo.

United States Postal Service Statement of Ownership, Management, and Circulation


1. Publication Title: Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 2. Publication Number: 0882-300 3. Filing Date: 9/16/2005 4. Issue Frequency: Quarterly 5. Number of Issues Published Annually: 4 6. Annual Subscription
Price: $25 7. Complete Mailing Address of Known Office of Publication: Friends of the Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 Contact Person: Lisa Grob Telephone: 202-783-7400 x744
8. Complete Mailing Address of Headquarters or General Business Office of Publisher: Friends of the Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 9. Full Names and Complete Mailing
Addresses of Publisher, Editor, and Managing Editor: Publisher: Friends of the Earth Editor/Managing Editor: Lisa Grob, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 Editor: Lisa Grob, Friends of the
Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 Managing Editor: Lisa Grob, Friends of the Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 10. Owner: Friends of the Earth,
1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW #600, Washington, DC 20036 11. Known Bondholders, Mortgagees, and Other Security Holders Owning or Holding 1 Percent or More of Total Amount of Bonds, Mortgages, or Other
Securities: None 12. Tax Status: Has Not Changed During Preceding 12 Months 13. Publication Title: Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 14. Issue Date for Circulation Data Below: October 2005
15. Extent and Nature of Circulation Average No. Copies Each Issue During No. Copies of Single Issue Published
Preceding 12 Months Nearest to Filing Date
a. Total Number of Copies (Net Press run) 20,200 20,000
b. Paid and/or (1) Paid/Requested Outside-County Mail Subscriptions Stated on Form 3541. 19,000 19,000
Requested (2) Paid In-County Subscriptions Stated on Form 3541
Circulation
(3) Sales Through Dealers and Carriers, Street Vendors, Counter Sales, and Other Non-USPS Paid Distribution
(4) Other Classes Mailed Through the USPS
c. Total Paid and/or Requested Circulation 19,000 19,000
d. Free (1) Outside-County as Stated on Form 3541 400 500
Distribution (2) In-County as Stated on Form 3541
by Mail
(3) Other Classes Mailed Through the USPS
e. Free Distribution Outside the Mail 200 250
f. Total Free Distribution 600 750
g. Total Distribution 19,600 19,750
h. Copies not Distributed 600 250
i. Total 20,200 20,000
j. Percent Paid and/or Requested Circulation 96% 96%
16. Publication of Statement of Ownership: Publication required. Will be printed in the Volume 35, No. 3 issue of this publication.
17. Signature and Title of Editor, Publisher, Business Manager, or Owner

I certify that all information furnished on this form is true and complete. I understand that anyone who furnishes false or misleading information on this form or who omits material or information requested on
the form may be subject to criminal sanctions (including fines and imprisonment) and/or civil sanctions (including civil penalties).

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 11


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 12

SPOTLIGHT ON WILDLIFE ■

Mountain Gorillas
of Central Africa
On the Brink
photo credit: ©Greenpeace/Daniel Beltrá

By Michelle Medeiros, the Bwindi Impenetrable Forest hundreds of yards or more in a day.
Campaigner, Friends of the Earth National Park in Uganda. The families will stop to relax,
Mountain gorillas are sometimes watching the group’s young as they
THE GREAT APES – chimpanzees,
portrayed as chest-pounding, hulk- frolic playfully in their jungle home.
orangutans, and gorillas – are man’s
ing wild animals, eliciting unwar- After a long day of traveling and eat-
closest relatives in the animal king-
ranted fear. These gorillas are quite ing the family makes a nest out of
dom, with a genetic make up that is
large: the adult male can reach 400 vegetation, either in treetops or on
96-99 percent identical to that of
pounds, while females can reach the ground, and will spend the night
humans. The gorilla’s genetic make-
in this spot only to start their jour-
up is 97.7 percent the same as ours:
ney once again in the morning.
we have physical similarities, our
social habits are similar, and we Gorillas are actually Gorillas are actually the smartest
of the primates and exhibit human
express our emotions similarly. The the smartest of the emotions like happiness and sad-
only significant difference between
gorillas and humans is the ability to primates and exhibit ness. Scientists have discovered that
gorillas are able to learn sign lan-
communicate through spoken lan- human emotions like guage to communicate words, and
guage. The world’s forests are home
to these majestic animals, but the happiness and sadness. some gorillas have even put words
together to form simple sentences.
pressures of deforestation, illegal
Koko - the world’s most renowned
hunting, and regional conflict
about 200, and the lead male in a gorilla - was rescued as a baby and
threaten their very existence. The
group of gorillas, known as the sil- has been taught sign language dur-
mountain gorilla of Central Africa is
verback, is very protective of his ing her years living with humans.
perhaps one of the most endan-
brood and will pound his chest Koko now has a vocabulary of over
gered of the great apes, with only
when the family is threatened. 1,000 words and has become an
about 600 remaining in the wild.
However, these gorillas are generally ambassador for the great apes,
These gorillas live in the eastern
quite peaceful and gentle. Typically, demonstrating to the world the
mountains of Africa between the
gorilla families will spend most of intelligence of the mountain gorilla.
Virunga Mountains of the
their time searching for food such as Sadly, even though we have
Democratic Republic of Congo and in
stems, leaves and fruits, covering learned so much about the intelli-
12 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005
98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 13

gence and majesty of these animals, the gorillas. These hardwood trees are about 4 pounds, and require substan-
man remains the biggest threat to often used in the U.S. for flooring, tial care and protection. As their habi-
the existence of this species. The paneling, and high-end furniture. The tat is destroyed, gorillas have less area
habitat for mountain gorillas is logging roads open up access to to roam, isolating them into smaller
shrinking at an alarming rate, as the forested areas for poaching, bush- groups and making them more sus-
forests of eastern Africa are claimed meat hunting, agriculture expansion, ceptible to extinction due to the loss
by human refugees forced to flee and illegal logging. It is estimated of genetic diversity.
their communities after years of vio- that if the current trends continue, Friends of the Earth’s work recog-
lent conflict. War in Rwanda, Uganda nizes that it is critical that we con-
and the Democratic Republic of tinue to work with governments and
Congo (DRC), has resulted in the Even with immediate communities to create land use
deaths of millions of people – over plans and regulations that allow
3.5 million alone in DRC – and has action it will not be both forest dependant communities
also destroyed and infringed on the easy to save gorillas and the mountain gorilla access to
gorillas’ habitat. the forests and offer protection from
Gorillas are also being killed for from the looming the threats of logging, agricultural
their meat, often referred to as bush- threat of extinction. expansion, and the commercial
meat. Though forest communities bushmeat trade. Friends of the Earth
have hunted great apes for food for has begun a new campaign that
thousands of years, increased demand the remaining wild apes of Africa will calls for the ecologically sustainable
of the exotic bushmeat has commer- be gone within the next few decades. and socially just use of the
cialized this once traditional hunting Even with immediate action it will Democratic Republic of Congo’s vast
ritual. The commercial bushmeat not be easy to save gorillas from the natural resources located in the
trade threatens gorillas, chimpanzees looming threat of extinction. Gorilla Congo Basin region of Central Africa,
and bonobos with extinction. populations recover slowly, as the the world’s second largest rainforest.
The expansion of industrial log- female generally has only two to six For updates on this campaign, sign
ging in the lush jungles full of hard- offspring in her lifetime. Newborn up for Friends of the Earth news and
wood trees is another key threat to gorillas are weak and tiny, weighing email alerts at http://www.foe.org.

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 13


98906mvpR2 10/19/05 10:43 AM Page 14

ENVIRONMENTAL LIVING ■

Recipes for
a Clean House
THE PRODUCTS WE BUY to scrub,
sterilize and beautify our houses are
often anything but healthy. In fact,
household cleaners are responsible
for nearly 10 percent of all toxic
exposures reported to U.S. Poison
Control Centers. In addition to
indoor pollution these products
take a toll on the environment.
Cleaning products pass through
municipal treatment plants after
being poured down household
drains and subsequently enter our
waterways. Although most of the  Liquid soap refers to castile soap,
All-purpose disinfectant: To be used
ingredients break down into harm- although coconut oil soap is a
in the bathroom, the kitchen or
less substances during treatment, fine alternative.
wherever. Combine two teaspoons
some do not, threatening water  Vinegar means distilled white
borax, four tablespoons vinegar and
quality and wildlife. vinegar, which has a slight odor
three to four cups hot water in a
You can make your own cleaners when wet, yet leaves no smell
spray bottle. (For extra cleaning
easily and inexpensively using once dry.
power, add 1/4 teaspoon liquid soap
ingredients found in your kitchen.  Washing soda and borax, though
to the mixture).
Keep the following tips in mind natural can irritate skin, so use
General dusting: In a bowl, mix one
when concocting your own cleaners: gloves. Borax can be toxic when
teaspoon olive oil per 1/2 cup vine-
 Be sure to label your mixtures to swallowed, so keep out of reach
gar. Apply with a soft cloth.
avoid confusion of children.
Detergent booster: Adding baking
soda or washing soda reduces the
amount of laundry detergent you
need to use by softening the water
and thus increasing the detergent’s
power. For liquid detergent, add 1/2
cup of soda at the beginning of the
wash. For powdered detergent, add
1/2 cup of soda during the rinse cycle.
Air freshener: Combine one tea-
spoon baking soda, one teaspoon
vinegar or lemon juice, and two
cups hot water in a spray bottle.
Baking soda absorbs odors, while
vinegar deodorizes.
Sources:
The Green Guide
http://www.thegreenguide.com/green-cleaning-products/
Children’s Health Environmental Coalition
http://www.checnet.org/HealtheHouse

14 Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine | Fall 2005


98906mvp 10/13/05 10:57 AM Page 15

INTERNATIONAL ■

Shell Oil Project Threatens Wildlife


By Elizabeth Bast (EBRD), and Japan Bank for
International Cooperation (JBIC).
SAKHALIN IS A LONG NARROW island
This first phase included the con-
in the Pacific Ocean, several miles off of
struction of a drilling platform off
the coast of Russia. Comprised of three
the coast of Sakhalin. Residents of
parallel mountain chains, the island
Sakhalin say that since the construc-
has 60,000 streams and rivers and is
tion of this first platform, there have
covered with forests.The seas off the
been fewer and lower quality fish in
coast of the island are among the
the waters. Plans for phase two are
most productive areas of ocean in the
much more extensive, and worries of
world with abundant fish and shell-
environmental and social impacts
fish, and local communities rely on
have increased.
these waters for their livelihoods.The
Shell is currently negotiating
area off the island is also a feeding
again with the Japan Bank for
ground for the Western Pacific grey
International Cooperation (JBIC) and
whale, an endangered species with an
the U.S. Export-Import Bank – a U.S.
estimated 100 surviving individuals.
government agency that lends
A consortium of oil companies led
money to U.S. companies for overseas
by Shell is now building two 500-
projects – to finance the project.
mile pipelines, two offshore drilling
Two recent developments should
platforms, four undersea pipelines,
Friends of the Earth and a coalition of groups slow financing and construction of
and a massive liquefied natural gas ran this ad in the Financial Times, criticizing the project. In July, Shell announced
plant off the shores of Sakhalin the Shell project.
that the project would be delayed
Island. The pipelines will cross 21
However, Credit Suisse First Boston and that estimates for project costs
seismic faults and over 1000 rivers
(CSFB), by providing financial advising are now on “the order of $20 billion.”
and streams on the island, including
for this harmful project, is violating Originally estimated to cost $12 bil-
salmon spawning grounds. The proj-
its own commitment to the Equator lion, Sakhalin II was described as the
ect is also located near the Western
Principles – a set of environmental largest single integrated oil and gas
Pacific grey whales’ feeding grounds.
guidelines for banks that require sub- project currently being undertaken,
Any oil or gas accidents or leaks
stantial safeguards for projects with and this new estimate puts Sakhalin
could wreak havoc on the island, its
this degree of environmental risk. II off the charts.
wildlife and the surrounding waters.
The Sakhalin II project is currently Later in the month, citing environ-
But in spite of the risks, financing for
in its second phase of financing and mental concerns, a Russian court
the project is expected and construc-
construction. In 1994, Shell, upheld a decision rejecting an envi-
tion is proceeding.
Mitsubishi and Mitsui established ronmental impact review conducted
Local indigenous communities
the Sakhalin Energy Investment by Royal Dutch/Shell’s Sakhalin
maintain that their livelihoods based
Company, which signed a production Energy Investment Corporation,
on fishing and reindeer herding have
sharing agreement with the Russian meaning that the company will have
already been adversely impacted by
government to develop the Sakhalin to halt construction of the plant
oil development, and are staunchly
II oil and gas deposits. In 1998, Shell until its review is approved by the
opposed to the project. In January of
began the first phase of the Sakhalin Russian courts.
this year, indigenous residents
II project, with $116 million in financ- Friends of the Earth will continue
endured minus 30-degree tempera-
ing each from the U.S. Overseas its campaign in solidarity with local
tures to peacefully blockade the
Private Investment Corporation communities to fight this environ-
Sakhalin II mega-project and protest
(OPIC), the European Bank for mentally and socially harmful proj-
the negative impact it will have.
Reconstruction and Development ect.
Expected profits from oil and gas
are driving Shell and its partners.

Fall 2005 | Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 15


98906mvpR1 10/19/05 8:22 AM Page 16

WHAT YOU CAN DO ■

Now is the Season for Workplace Giving!


MANY EMPLOYERS SPONSOR work- state or local level, you can support Share, Friends of the Earth will receive
place giving programs to encourage Friends of the Earth directly. a percentage of all undesignated gifts
employees to support organizations given to Earth Share.
important to their communities. Earth Share Earth Share now participates in
Employees can donate a small portion Earth Share, a nation- campaigns at hundreds of govern-
of their salary to a specific charity wide network of ment and corporate workplaces,
through payroll deduction. Friends of America’s leading non- including the federal government’s
the Earth participates in hundreds of profit environmental and Combined Federal Campaign (CFC).
these campaigns directly and in many conservation organiza- Find out if Earth Share participates at
places through Earth Share. Our desig- tions, works to promote environmental your workplace and to get more infor-
nation number is 0908. education and charitable giving mation visit www.earthshare.org
If your employer participates in the through workplace giving campaigns.
For more information contact Rosemary Greenaway,
Combined Federal Campaign, United You can make your gift directly to director of membership, 202-222-0722 or
Way or other giving campaigns at the us or as a national member of Earth rgreenaway@foe.org

MEMBER NOTICE ■

Changing of the Guard


AT THE JUNE 24 MEETING of the Friends of the Earth has been a life since its inception also. He has served
Friends of the Earth Board of Directors long environmentalist, activist, and on the Friends of the Earth Board since
Dan Gabel was elected Chairman of researcher. Gabel, President and CEO, 1995. Gabel served as treasurer of the
the board. He succeeds Avis Ogilvy Hagedorn & Company, has been board for ten years during Friends of
Moore. Moore, a charter member of involved with Friends of the Earth the Earth’s early years.

A copy of the latest Financial Report and Registration filed by this organization may be obtained by contacting us at Friends of the Earth, 1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW Suite 600, Washington DC 20036-2008. Toll-free
number: 877-843-8687. Or, for residents of the following states, by contacting any of the state agencies: CALIFORNIA – A copy of the Official Financial Statement may be obtained from the Attorney General’s Registry
of Charitable Trusts, Department of Justice, P.O. Box 903447, Sacramento, CA 94203-4470 or by calling 916-445-2021. FLORIDA - A COPY OF THE OFFICIAL REGISTRATION AND FINANCIAL INFORMATION MAY
BE OBTAINED FROM THE DIVISION OF CONSUMER SERVICES BY CALLING TOLL-FREE, WITHIN THE STATE, 1-800-435-7352. REGISTRATION DOES NOT IMPLY ENDORSEMENT, APPROVAL OR RECOMMENDA-
TION BY THE STATE. Florida registration # CH960. KANSAS Annual financial report is filed with Secretary of State #258-204-7. MARYLAND For the cost of copies and postage: Office of the Secretary of State, State
House, Annapolis, MD 21401. MICHIGAN MICS 10926. MISSISSIPPI – The official registration and financial information of Friends of the Earth, Inc. may be obtained from the Mississippi Secretary of State’s office by
calling 1-888-236-6167. Registration by the Secretary of State does not imply endorsement by the Secretary of State. NEW JERSEY INFORMATION FILED WITH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL CONCERNING THIS CHAR-
ITABLE SOLCITATION MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY BY CALLING 973-504-6215. REGISTRATION WITH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DOES NOT IMPLY
ENDORSEMENT. NEW YORK Office of the Attorney General, Department of Law, Charities Bureau, 120 Broadway, New York, NY 10271. NORTH CAROLINA FINANCIAL INFORMATION ABOUT THIS ORGANIZA-
TION AND A COPY OF ITS LICENSE ARE AVAILABLE FROM THE STATE SOLICITATION LICENSING BRANCH AT 1-888-830-4989. THE LICENSE IS NOT AN ENDORSEMENT BY THE STATE. PENNSYLVANIA – The
official registration and financial information of Friends of the Earth may be obtained from Pennsylvania Department of State by calling toll-free within the state 1-800-732-0999. Registration does not imply endorsement.
UTAH – Permit #C495. VIRGINIA State Division of Consumer Affairs, Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, P.O. Box 1163, Richmond, VA 23218; 1-800-552-9963. WASHINGTON - Charities Division,
Office of the Secretary of the State, State of Washington, Olympia, WA 98504-0422; 1-800-332-4483. WEST VIRGINIA West Virginia residents may obtain a summary of the registration and financial documents from
the Secretary of State, State Capitol, Charleston, WV 25305. Registration does not imply endorsement.

PERIODICALS
POSTAGE PAID AT
WASHINGTON, DC
AND ADDITIONAL
Fall 2005 | Volume 35, Number 3 MAILING OFFICES
1717 Massachusetts Avenue, NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20036-2008

You might also like