Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contents
Acknowledgements 3
Introduction 4
Agenda 5
Introductory Talk 6
Shri. Tenzing Norbu Thongdok, H’MLA Rupa- Kalaktang and
Chairman, State Pollution Control Board
ANNEXURES:
2
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Acknowledgements
Shergaon Forest Division would especially like to express our gratitude to our
guest of honour, Shri. Tenzing Norbu Thongdok, Honorable Member of
Legislative Assembly, Rupa - Kalaktang and Chairman, Arunachal Pradesh
State Pollution Control Board for his eloquent speech that served to open the
workshop. His energy and enthusiasm shaped the events that formed the
main thread of the proceeding.
Shergaon Forest Division would like to thank Shri. J.L. Singh, IFS, Principal
Chief Conservator of Forests (Wildlife), Government of Arunachal Pradesh for
providing financial sanction for this workshop. We are grateful to Shri. G.N
Roy, IFS, Chief Conservator of Forest, Western Arunachal Circle for being the
constant source of encouragement throughout the entire process. The role of
Shri. P. Ringu, DCF is hereby duly acknowledged for sowing the initial idea of
such a workshop.
Special thanks are addressed to Dr. Ramana Athreya, Kaati Trust, Shri. Indi
Glow, Bugun Welfare Society and Shri. PK Dutta, WWF – India for taking part
in the workshop as resource persons. Their sincere role as central pillars of the
entire proceeding was instrumental in ensuring evolution of tangible products
out of the gathering. We thank the DFO, Bomdila Forest Division and the
staff especially Shri. Dechen, Range Officer, Bomdila for helping us with
logistical support.
We also thank the participants and other well wishers and friends for their
encouragement and inputs for the success of the programme.
3
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Introduction
The community lands surrounding the protected areas thus serve critical
ecological support functions and are biologically significant lands containing
high priority species and habitats. Both the landscapes are inter-dependent in
terms of habitats: the rich biological diversity of the protected areas on the
surrounding community lands and the communities on the rich ecological
benefits of the protected areas. There is a need for all stakeholders including
the local communities, government departments, NGOs and scientific
communities to seek, evaluate, use and create information especially with
regard to thorough biological inventories of the fringe lands, awareness, and
livelihood issues of neighboring communities; so that wildlife conservation
needs could be addressed in an ecological landscape context.
The present workshop thus sought to involve, inform, and raise awareness
about conservation of wildlife among responsible agencies like the public
leaders, district officers, officials, Gaon Burahs, members of the public, Army
and NGOs.
4
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
AGENDA
5
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Introductory talk
Shri. Tenzing Norbu Thongdok,
H’MLA Rupa- Kalaktang and
Chairman, State Pollution Control Board, Chief Guest
Arunachal Pradesh has many rare and endangered species which are
disappearing due to human interference. Leave alone the unaware villagers
but we educated people are also not concerned about this. It is we, the people,
who have to think of solutions. The ideas given by researchers and think tanks
must be propagated to every village to be implemented by the villagers and
forest dwellers. We generally talk in terms of global issues while discussing
environmental and conservation issues but we need to look into ourselves and
think locally in order to make a difference. Moreover rules and law unless
enforced properly will remain frozen in the statute books. My suggestion to
6
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
the forest department is to take such awareness programs to the villages and
educate the people on conservation issues, the laws supporting these issues
and ecological and legal implications of destroying forests and wildlife. Village
level institutions too need to assist the forest department in implementing
these laws.
Recently the Arunachal Pradesh Government has taken a decision to stop the
killing of birds. This is a step forward in the right direction. The sale of air-
guns should be stopped. Birds have virtually vanished from certain pockets in
the state due to rampant hunting with air-guns and sling shots. Bhalukpong
was full of hornbills now you can see them only if you are lucky. If we continue
with this complacent attitude regarding forest and wildlife we will have to face
dire ecological consequences.
In the end I sincerely appeal to all present here to save forests and wildlife and
thank Shergaon Forest Department for inviting me and giving me an
opportunity to be part of this program.
7
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
The vegetation types found along the altitudinal gradient are given below:
TROPICAL VEGETATION
TROPICAL EVERGREEN FOREST
Mesua, Terminalia, Michelia, Calamus, Musa, Dipterocarpus etc.
TROPICAL SEMI EVERGREEN FOREST
Anthocephalus, Bombax, Terminalia, Dioscorea, Gmelina, Ficus etc.
SUB-TROPICAL VEGETATION
SUBTROPICAL BROAD LEAVED FOREST (900-1200m)
Magnolia, Berberis, Castanopsis, Clerodendrum, Oak etc.
SUBTROPICAL PINE FOREST (1200-1800m)
Rhododendron, Pine, Alnus, Betula, Oak, etc.
TEMPERATE VEGETATION
TEMPERATE BROAD LEAVED FOREST (1800-2800m)
Alnus, Rhododendron, Castanopsis, Poplus, Prunus, Rubus, Illicium, Oak etc.
TEMPERATE CONIFER FOREST (2800-3500m)
Rhododendron, Betula, Ilex, Cupressus, Rosa, Mahonia, Potentila etc.
Some of the rare and threatened plants found in the region are:
1. Aconitum Spp.
2. Cirsium verutum
3. Picorhiza kurroa
4. Rheum nobile
5. Saussurea gossypiphora
6. Satyrium nepalense
7. Swertia chirata
8. Cordyceps spp.
Rhododendrons:
The State of Arunachal Pradesh has 61 species, 17 sub species and 12 varieties
of Rhododendron, which contributes 84.7% of the country's total
rhododendron species. Out of these, 9 species and 1 variety of rhododendrons
are found to be endemic to the state. From Western Arunachal Pradesh so far
8
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Bird diversity:
From WAL, five Important Bird Areas (IBA) have been identified
IBA Site Name Criteria
Pheasant diversity:
Globally 50 species have been recorded. From Arunachal Pradesh 13 species
have been recorded. In India Arunachal Pradesh has the maximum diversity
of pheasants. Himalayan Monal, Blood pheasant, Satyr Tragopan, Kalij
Pheasant and Blyth’s Tragopan are some of endangered pheasants in the
region.
Black Necked Crane and Brahminy Shelduck are other endangered birds.
9
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
10
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
1. Pakke tiger reserve (Arunachal): 862 km2; alt. 100m – 2000m; lowland
evergreen and semievergreen forests; subtropical forests; successional
grassland and forests on the floodplains of the rivers.
2. Nameri tiger reserve (Assam): 349 km2; alt. 50 - 150m; “terai” forest
including swamp forests, riverine woodland, and successional grassland and
forests on the floodplains
3. Sonai rupai wildlife sanctuary (Assam): 175 km2; alt. 50 - 150m; with
vegetation similar to Nameri
4. Sessa orchid sanctuary (Arunachal): 100 km2; alt. 1000 - 3100m;
subtropical and temperate broad-leaved forests and bamboo.
5. Eaglenest wildlife sanctuary (Arunachal): 218 km2; alt. 500 - 3250m;
lowland evergreen and semi-evergreen forests; subtropical forest; temperate
broad-leaved and conifer forests; bamboo at all elevations.
6. Surrounding blocks of Reserved Forests of Papum, Doimara, Amortola and
Shergaon forest division which total another 2000 km2 of forests of variable
quality but which form an important buffer zone especially for the movements
of elephants.
11
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
In all, this complex encompasses over 3500 km2 of diverse types of forests
covering 3300m of elevation from lowlands to well into the temperate regions.
This complex, the largest such in western Arunachal Pradesh, has by far the
most critical role in the conservation of biodiversity in that area and should be
the focus of conservation strategies there.
Eaglenest wildlife sanctuary was legally notified in 1989 along with Sessa
orchid sanctuary. The area has traditionally been claimed by the Sherdukpen
tribe of Rupa though they have never had any settlement inside the
boundaries of the sanctuary. Doimara (outside and below Eaglenest) used to
be a thriving settlement during the days of commercial logging operations (up
to 1998) but is now going to seed with less than a dozen farming families
permanently stationed there. Access into Eaglenest from the north is through
the community lands of the Bugun tribe which has its principal settlement at
Singchung near Tenga. A good fraction of Sessa has traditionally been claimed
by the Buguns as part of their territory. Eaglenest apparently derives its name
from Eagle regiment of the Indian army which used to be posted in that area.
The Eaglenest Biodiversity Project yielded several new taxa and globally rare
taxa. At the same time, the surrounding regions outside the purview of these
PA complex harbor potentially rich biodiversity. Conservation is equally
crucial in the fringe regions because ecosystems do not understand legal
boundaries.
Very small fraction of total area in Even smaller fraction of total area
rest of country
Small fraction of total area in Large fraction of total area in
Arunachal Arunachal
“Insurance policy” for wildlife Resource for both wildlife and people
… too many restrictions … only if utilised wisely
12
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Water
• Forests regulate water flow
• Reduce floods during rainy season
• Prevent drought during dry season
Agro diversity
• New food and medicinal species
• Varieties of known species with special characters like resistance to
drought, humidity and temperature
Tourism
• Easy to get legal clearance to set up tourism facilities
• More control for local communities
• Bird tourists come to Eaglenest from all over the world, but spend more
time outside PA’s in Lama Camp, Dirang, Sela and Khellong.
Hence livelihood and income generation opportunities increase for
locals.
Forest Produce
• More construction timber, fire wood and medicinal plants
• “Forest Agriculture” could include tubers, mushroom, orchids etc.
13
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
For the toilet as well as the kitchen, portable tents can be used for the walls
and roof, which can be folded and kept away when not in use. All other
requirements can be ferried in by the tour party.
Marketing is the most crucial aspect. For initial stages, the tourists to Tawang
and Bomdila could be targeted through good documentation of camp sites,
web pages in the internet, liaising with tourist agencies in Guwahati / Kolkata
There are two main negative consequences that one can expect from
ecotourism; which is cutting of trees for fuel and construction material and
the domination of few powerful people in the venture. Moreover, the youths
engaged today in such ventures do not want to work hard and leave the job
after a few months. Such ventures need time to grow and cannot give over
night benefits
14
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
One can mitigate this with awareness creation to locals. One can ban the use
of firewood as in Kangchendzonga and have all parties ferry in their own
stoves and fuel (gas or kerosene).
To avoid few prominent persons from the community corner much of the
profits from tourism in common resources, highly coordinated efforts and
initiatives from village councils, are required.
Home stays are an inexpensive and easy way by which locals can give
ecotourism facilities. We are planning to send our youths on an exposure visit
to Kalimpong and Sikkim.
15
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 is an act for the protection of wild animals,
birds and plants.
16
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Penalties for various acts related to different species covered under the 6
schedules were deliberated upon.
17
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Demarcation of 2 CCAs:
1. Thembang Bapu CCA – 31,200 ha
2. Pangchen Lumpo Muchat CCA – 9,800 ha
Achievements:
• Baseline Surveys and listed important, rare and threatened Flora and
Fauna.
• CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT FOR MANAGEMENT OF CCA
• Two local boys working with WWF-India for training on
management of CCAMC
• Basic office infrastructures (Bikes and Computers) have been
provided to CCAMC to do their day today activities
• Appointed local boys who attended various training workshop
organised by WWF-India and other organisations
• Field Training for local villagers on biodiversity survey
technique organised
18
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
PROJECT IMPACT:
3. Porter 29,750.00 13
TOTAL 2,21,736.00
19
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
5. Donation 1,000.00
TOTAL 51,444.00
20
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Wild life seen years ago and not seen nowadays in this region - disappeared
wildlife: Musk Deer was the most vociferously voted animal seen aplenty 15 –
20 years ago and very rarely seen nowadays. Otters, wild dogs and red panda
also figured in the discussions as one of the diminishing wild animals.
Leopards were also sighted commonly by elders a decade ago.
Reasons for decline in wildlife: Forest reduction and habitat destruction was
unanimously declared as the most prominent reason behind disappearance of
wildlife. Hunting and Forest fires also caught the attention of the audience as
a major contributing factor. Some villagers argued that hunting by locals is
done sustainably and can not be a reason for the decline. However, they
opined that hunting by government officers is a major concern especially due
to the uninhibited access and modern weapons. Their main victims include
small game like squirrels, monkeys and birds. Road construction has affected
migration of animals especially bears. Moreover, the road network has created
islands of forests accessible from all around for the sake of hunting.
21
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
Who hunts the most: Government Officers were voted the dominant hunters.
Their victims included mostly small game through modern arms and vehicles
because they lacked the barefoot skills for hunting large game. Winters,
festivals, weekends and holidays were the common periods of hunting. Town
people figured as the next important group of people indulged in hunting
mainly because of the modern arms. Students hunt birds, reptiles and frogs
through catapults. Tourists and Army officers never indulged in hunting.
Reasons for hunting: Government Officers hunt for fun & thrill, while villagers
hunt for consumption. Community hunting happens due to cultural reasons as
part of traditions. After settling community shares, remaining meat is
sometimes sold in market.
Ideas to reduce hunting: Air rifles / guns and ammunition should be banned;
as already done in many parts of the state. Awareness should be spread
through partnerships with schools and colleges about dangers of catapult
hunting. The charm for hunting should be reduced through social
disincentives in village councils. The local councils should be encouraged to
pass local laws regulating hunting. Certain regions should be mapped and
some species shall be identified with the help of Forest department and local
bans should be enforced against hunting in select regions and select species.
Stringent punishment should be meted out especially for government officers.
Religious heads should be actively involved in creating mass awareness and
moulding public opinion.
People who hunt for fun: Local laws by councils to hand over stringent
punishment especially for government officers. Forest Department
should be more vigilant.
22
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
ANNEXURE – I
3. Wild life seen years ago and not seen nowadays in this region:
disappeared wildlife
23
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
ANNEXURE – II
My Name: ____________________________
Wild life seen years ago and not seen nowadays in this region: ________________________________
24
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
ANNEXURE – III
25
Proceedings of the One day Workshop on
Wildlife Conservation: Values and Incentives
ORGANISING TEAM
OFFICE OF THE DIVISIONAL FOREST OFFICER
SHERGAON FOREST DIVISION
RUPA, ARUNACHAL PRADESH
OCTOBER 2010
26