Professional Documents
Culture Documents
United States
In This Issue…
10 Firming demand for space this year helped arrest the slide in rental rates. The average
9 asking rate for logistics space offered on the market at mid-year 2010 was $3.78 per
square foot per year, triple net, which was nearly unchanged from $3.79 at year-end
8
2009. Since peaking at $4.21 at the end of 2007, asking rates have slipped by 10 percent
7
’00 ’01 ’02 ’03 ’04 ’05 ’06 ’07 ’08 ’09 ’10
Logistics Market Trends Robert Bach Joan Burress Grubb & Ellis Company
is a newsletter published Senior Vice President, Manager, Research Field Services 1551 N Tustin Avenue
semi-annually by Grubb & Ellis Chief Economist 586.573.8717 Suite 300
Company. To obtain additional 312.698.6754 Erin O’Leary Santa Ana, CA 92705
copies or other Grubb & Ellis Tim Feemster Manager, Affiliate Research Services e-mail: research@grubb-ellis.com
publications, please contact: Senior Vice President, 312.698.6789 www.grubb-ellis.com
Director of Global Logistics
972.450.3225
www.grubb-ellis.com 1
© 2009 Grubb & Ellis Company. Some of the data in this report has been gathered from third party sources and has not been independently verified by Grubb & Ellis. Grubb & Ellis makes no warranties or representations as to the completeness or accuracy thereof.
Class A Logistics Market Vacancy and Rental Rates
Note: Vacancy and rent data refer to Class A logistics buildings with minimum size thresholds of 100,000 square feet. Inventory includes multi-tenant, single-tenant and owner-occu-
pied space. Rental rate data refer to space that is available for lease on the market at the end of the quarter. Rates are per square foot, quoted on a triple net basis. Rates for each build-
ing are weighted by the amount of available space within the building.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 2 4 6 8
Top 10 Site Selection Factors Oscillating fuels costs, new laws and regulations, fewer state and local incentives due to
public budget constraints, and an aging infrastructure have corporate managers rethink-
ing their strategy for site selection. While corporate planners have no control over these
Rankings 2009 2008 factors, they do have control over the design of their distribution network. By creating a
1. Labor costs 96.7 91.4 (2)* flexible, robust distribution network that takes a long term view, they can alleviate poten-
2. Highway accessibility 92.9 95.4 (1)
tial problems that may pop up.
5. Corporate tax rate 87 85.3 (8) • What markets will the new site serve?
6. Availability of skilled labor 86.9 87.7 (6) • Should the site be a larger facility that supports multiple regions or should we build
7. Occupancy or construction costs 86.7 90.4 (3) more distribution centers that are smaller and closer to customers?
8. State and local incentives 84.9 87.2 (7) • What are our transportation options at those new sites, especially if our customers
change their strategy?
9. Availability of advanced ICT 83.2 55.5 (21)
services • What is our service to the market likely to be in the future: three-day, two-day or
10. Inbound/outbound shipping 81.7 N/A same/next-day?
costs
• Will our client’s order patterns change to require more frequent and smaller ship-
Source: Area Development magazine
ments to reduce inventory at their end of the supply chain?
To figure out what markets you will serve can be as easy as looking at a map or as compli-
cated as hiring a site selection consultant to perform a service area study. One way to gain
insight on this question is to contact nearby distribution facilities; ask them why they are
there, how they view the transportation infrastructure and whether they are meeting the
cost and service targets that were set before they located to the area.
Supplies If you are worried about reaching out to other distribution fa-
2%
cilities in the area, don’t be! There are plenty of opportunities
Admin. Other Warehouse
Rent 3% to speak with representatives from those sites. Begin a dis-
1%
4%
cussion on a social networking platform like LinkedIn. Attend
Customer Service
8% local professional meetings hosted by SIOR, WERC, NAIOP,
CSCMP, etc. Attend a national conference hosted by one of
the professional organizations. One reason to attend local
Labor meetings and conferences, especially in the logistics and sup-
10% Transportation ply chain field, is to discover best practices and issues that
50%
could plague your distribution facility. Another reason is to be
able to benchmark against competitors. Keep your trans-
portation options open. Look for sites that provide a mix of
options from air and rail to truck and ocean shipping. Your
Inventory
22% customers’ business strategies are changing as fast as
teenagers. If your customer changes plans a year after you
Source: Establish, Inc/Herbert W. Davis and Company start operations and expects you to deliver to another region
in the country or to another country altogether, can you re-
ceive and send shipments using a combination of shipping
methods? And don’t forget about the potential to expedite orders. While FedEx and UPS have their place in supporting your strategy, the
cost of this service must be included in your total cost analysis. Being located near a combined heavy weight/small package air hub can
make a difference.
Take the time to understand any long term plans that could alter the mix of products and how that will impact your shipping methods
and service delivery. And remember that transportation is typically over half the cost of a company’s supply chain with labor running
around 17 percent. Rent, taxes and maintenance typically are less than 10 percent of supply chain costs.
Be sure to consider your company’s growth potential and with which customers. Will the business grow or decline over the next five
years? Will it expand or reduce overseas operations? Having multiple smaller distribution facilities will speed delivery to customers and
lower fuel and trucking costs, but it will be harder to manage the inventory and consolidate deliveries if something changes.
At the same time, don’t fall into the one-size-fits-all approach. If your company provides a range of products and services, locating a large
cold storage facility, for example, in a central location to support all those customers may make sense. The larger facility will have higher
costs associated with transportation – longer routes, slower delivery and higher fuel usage – but lower costs when taking other factors
into consideration such as work force training, lower inventory levels and ability to consolidate orders.
The old saying that the top three elements of a good commercial real estate site are “location, location, location” is changing. Today we
need to look at the 3 “Ls” as “logistics cost, labor and love.” Logistics cost and labor are major elements in the total cost of your network as
outlined above. The love comes from the local and state governments that must embrace the investment your company will make in
their community. Without a true desire for the type of investment you will make, the local market may limit or offer no incentives, which
will make smooth operation of your facility difficult or more expensive.
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA/ recovery is expected to continue at a have improved. From June 2009 to June
PACIFIC NORTHWEST measured pace through the rest of the 2010, total import cargo volume at the
Oakland-East Bay: Container traffic at year and into 2011… Stockton: Kyoho ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach in-
the Port of Oakland surged during the Manufacturing California shut down in creased 15 percent, driven mostly by in-
first half of this year, totaling 1.09 mil- April. The 260,000-square-foot auto ventory restocking among retailers.
lion containers. That is up by 12.9 per- parts plant was a supplier to the Recent weakness in retail sales suggests
cent from the first half of 2009. Traffic in NUMMI plant in Fremont, Calif., which that demand for logistics space could
June was 21 percent higher than June also closed. But the vacancy rate for dis- soften again as retailers finish their re-
2009. Port officials say they are waiting tribution space has dropped over the stocking. One positive indicator is that
to see if the upswing lasts beyond the last two quarters, a trend that is ex- total container traffic at the ports is pro-
inventory restocking cycle, which drove pected to continue. Occupiers have jected to expand by 14 percent this year
traffic earlier in the year as manufactur- emerged to capitalize on both lease and with another 5 percent gain likely in
ers, wholesalers and retailers replen- purchase opportunities. Currently a 2011… Orange County: In the largest
ished inventories that were depleted handful of tenants are searching for sale of the second quarter, Frick Family
during the recession. A $433 million spaces in the 500,000-square-foot range Properties, LLC, a packaging supply com-
dredging project completed late last in the San Joaquin Valley. If these deals pany, consolidated from two Los Ange-
year deepened the Oakland harbor from close, they will significantly reduce the les County sites, acquiring a
42 feet to 50 feet… Portland: United Sta- market-wide vacancy. 246,732-square-foot distribution facility
tioners recently leased 190,000 square in Orange for $22.2 million.
feet for a new distribution facility that SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
will consolidate several smaller facilities MOUNTAIN/SOUTHWEST
Inland Empire: Southern
throughout the area. Portland saw the
California is the gateway to the world’s Denver: Pent up demand
delivery of a significant amount of new
economy where 44 percent of all con- for retail goods drove a rise in consumer
space in 2007 and 2008, but absorption
tainerized cargo enters the U.S. On aver- spending and subsequent need for
has been slow, and tenants can still get
age, half of this is bound for local manufacturing and warehousing ac-
great deals… San Jose-Silicon Valley:
markets to serve the basin’s 18 million tivity across the board. In the second
Though it is not a logistics hub, Silicon
residents. After years of rampant specu- quarter, warehouse-distribution prop-
Valley does have about 20 million
lative construction, the Inland Empire is erties absorbed nearly 600,000 square
square feet of logistics space. Vacancy is
very attractive to logistics operators feet… Phoenix: Logistics properties ab-
currently balanced at 10.1 percent over-
seeking first-generation, Class A space sorbed nearly 1 million square feet in
all and just 6.4 percent for Class A prod-
at highly competitive rental rates. The the second quarter. Companies such as
uct. Many of the occupiers are locally
vacancy rate for Class A logistics space Staples, Home Depot, Tower Automo-
based technology companies such as In-
in buildings of 100,000 square feet-plus tive, Big O’ Tires and Wal-Mart occu-
termolecular, which recently took
was 13.0 percent in the second quarter pied the space, taking advantage of
130,000 square feet in the second quar-
2010, down 260 basis points from one lower lease rates and better conces-
ter’s largest deal… Seattle: The local lo-
year ago… Los Angeles: The Logistics va- sions. Vacancy held steady in the sec-
gistics market began to rebound in the
cancy rate currently stands at 4.4 per- ond quarter, which was good news
first half of 2010 with year-to-date posi-
cent, 110 basis points higher than the considering all of the new space added
tive net absorption of 912,000 square
vacancy rate for the overall industrial in late 2009 and early 2010.
feet. Improvements are being driven by
market. With retail sales being hit hard
healthy gains in port volume (Port of
by the recession, logistics operators
Seattle TEUs were up 93 percent year-
have felt the pinch in the form of re-
over-year in June) and increasing confi-
duced demand for space. But conditions
dence among manufacturers. The
NORTHEAST/ Demand has increased among logistics dustrial Park. These and other recent ex-
MID-ATLANTIC companies seeking large blocks of pansion projects will bring 5,200 new
Baltimore: In this tenant-friendly mar- space. Existing, cost-effective buildings jobs to the region… Jacksonville: There is
ket, many Baltimore companies have are winning out over build-to-suit op- still an ample supply of logistics space
been able to secure the perfect space portunities. Because large blocks of con- available. The port continues to increase
that lets them optimize fuel costs, ceil- tiguous space are hard to find, users are its container traffic, which is expected to
ing height, trailer storage, power and willing to look farther afield in locations reduce the vacancy rate in these facili-
other factors crucial to supply-chain effi- such as Fredericksburg, Md. and the Bal- ties by the end of the year… Memphis:
ciency… New Jersey: An uptick in de- timore-Washington Corridor. Virtually Market conditions are improving
mand for warehouse space in Northern no new logistics buildings are in the slowly… Miami: Activity continues to in-
and Central New Jersey translated into construction pipeline. Some large air crease. DHL Global Forwarding Americas
more than 3.1 million square feet of ab- freight companies are making strategic recently inked a lease for 201,000
sorption during the second quarter of expansions, betting on increasing air square feet at the Miami International
2010, which countered the 2.6 million freight volume and gains in market Commerce Center in the Airport West
square feet of losses recorded one year share from weaker competitors. submarket. The company took advan-
ago. Current market conditions have en- tage of historically high market avail-
couraged a flight to quality among ten- abilities and low lease rates to
SOUTHEAST
ants seeking to upgrade their space consolidate its operations. Econocaribe
Atlanta: Developers broke Consolidators, a Miami-based forward-
needs while locking in favorable leasing
ground in July on a new inland port in ing and logistics company, signed a
packages… Philadelphia-Eastern Penn-
Cordele, Ga. The $8.6 million intermodal 144,000-square-foot lease… Richmond:
sylvania: Demand is being driven by
project will facilitate transport of cargo The market experienced an uptick in ac-
3PLs as retailers outsource supply-chain
trucked in from nearby states onto tivity with major trucking companies ex-
management in order to mitigate risk
trains headed for the Port of Savannah. panding and looking for new facilities.
associated with fluctuating consumer
The goal is to entice shippers away from Activity at the Port of Virginia has in-
spending. Contract rents are at levels 25
the port facilities in Mobile, Ala. The creased both in containers and in bulk
to 35 percent lower than pre-recession-
project is expected to generate 2,500 commodities.
ary rates due to the glut of supply on
jobs… Charleston: Last fall Boeing chose
the market. The abundance of available
the region as its location to manufac-
space resulted from over-development
ture the 787 Dream Liner aircraft. The
rather than demand deterioration…
company is building a 700,000-square-
Pittsburgh: The airport area is attracting
foot facility on a long-term land lease at
logistics operations. Chapman Proper-
the Charleston International Airport.
ties broke ground on a 300-acre distri-
This is in addition to the 600,000 square
bution park located on the new toll
feet of space that the company cur-
road, I-576, which connects I-376 to
rently occupies in the market. Boeing’s
Route 22, the first leg of the planned
expansion is attracting interest from a
beltway around Pittsburgh. Trammel
number of other companies looking at
Crow continues to promote a planned
the Low County for expansion opportu-
600,000-square-foot distribution devel-
nities. TBC Tire Kingdom is building a
opment on the airport’s “Northfield” site
new 1.2 million-square-foot East Coast
next to Dick’s Sporting Goods’ new
distribution center in the Rockefeller In-
world headquarters… Washington, D.C.:
Seattle
WA Kalispell
Portland MT ME
ND Fargo
OR Bozeman MN VT
WI NH
Waupaca Portsmouth
Boise Bedford
ID SD
Minneapolis Wausau Green
Bay NY MA
Boston
Appleton
MI CT RI
WY Milwaukee Grosse Pointe Wappingers Falls
CA Madison Detroit Stamford
Sacramento
Walnut Creek IA Rosemont
Skokie PA Philadelphia
San Mateo Roseville Reno
Cheyenne
NE Omaha Chicago Mishawaka/ Cleveland King of Prussia NJ New York (Midtown)
San Francisco NV South Bend OH Pittsburgh Edison
Lincoln Marlton
San Francisco
Peninsula
Stockton
UT Denver IL Indianapolis
Columbus DE Wilmington
Cincinnati Tysons
San Jose Fresno
CO Lawrence
Kansas City IN WV Corner
Baltimore
Visalia
KS MD Bethesda
Colorado Springs St. Louis/Clayton VA Richmond
Los Angeles Las Vegas Wichita
MO KY Raleigh
Washington, D.C.
Downtown
North (Sherman Oaks)
East (San Gabriel)
South Bay (Torrance) Ontario Santa Fe Tulsa Bentonville TN
Nashville Chapel Hill
NC
West Santa Ana AZ Albuquerque Oklahoma City
Memphis
Anaheim OK AR Chattanooga Greenville SC
Columbia
Newport Beach Phoenix
NM Atlanta
North Little Rock Myrtle Beach
Temecula
AL GA Charleston
San Diego Tucson Las Cruces
Dallas MS
El Paso
Mobile
Ciudad Juarez TX LA Gulfport Jacksonville
Austin
Houston
San Antonio Orlando
Tampa Melbourne
Corpus Christi Ft. Myers FL
Boca Raton
Miami
McAllen
Monterrey
Reynosa
AK
San Luis Potosí
Honolulu
HI
© 2010 Grubb & Ellis Company. Some of the data in this report has been gathered from third party sources and has not been independently verified by Grubb & Ellis. Grubb & Ellis makes no warranties or representations as to the completeness or accuracy thereof.