Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TRADING ORDER
flow with market
profile p. 12
STRADDLES VS.
STRANGLES
p. 20
SPREADING
your charting
options p. 26
TRADING
PULLBACKS
with options p. 30
News
Gensler approved as CFTC head . . . . . .32
Nominee Gary Gensler convinces a couple of
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6
senators to vote in his favor by proposing a new
direction for derivatives regulation.
Market Movers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8
Futures market roundup. Penny Pilot Program’s
future uncertain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .33
Trading Strategies Mixed results leave questions about how to
Trading order flow with proceed with the option penny-pricing program.
Market Profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .12
How to interpret Market Profile charts. CME Group combines
By Robin Mesch NYMEX trading floors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .33
The CME takes the next step in assimilating the
Another look at straddles NYMEX by moving the energy and metals trading
and strangles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20 pits onto a single floor.
A common dilemma for volatility traders is
continued on p. 4
whether to trade an options straddle or strangle.
This second excerpt from Guy Cohen’s book
Volatile Markets Made Easy: Trading Stocks and
Options for Increased Profits compares both
approaches.
By Guy Cohen
eSignal NinjaTrader
Guy Cohen has extensive experience in the options stock markets, and
his clients include NYSE Euronext, the largest stock exchange in the world.
Cohen is also the creator of Flag-Trader, OptionEast, and Illuminati-Trader.
Specializing in trading applications, he has developed comprehensive trading
A publication of Active Trader ® and training models. Cohen has an MBA in finance from Cass Business
School, London.
For all subscriber services:
www.futuresandoptionstrader.com
Thomas Stridsman (optisizer@gmail.com) is a private
trader, trading-strategy developer, and lecturer. Previously, he
Editor-in-chief: Mark Etzkorn
metzkorn@futuresandoptionstrader.com was the senior researcher for Rotella Capital in Chicago, a com-
modity trading advisor with more than $1 billion under man-
Managing editor: Molly Goad agement. He also is a long-time contributing editor for Active
mgoad@futuresandoptionstrader.com
Trader magazine and a former editor at Futures magazine. He has authored
two books: Trading Systems that Work (McGraw-Hill, 2000) and Trading Systems
Senior editor: David Bukey
dbukey@futuresandoptionstrader.com and Money Management (McGraw-Hill, 2003). He has a degree in macro eco-
nomics from Uppsala University, Sweden.
Contributing editor:
Keith Schap
Robin Mesch has worked with traders worldwide, pro-
Associate editor: Chris Peters viding market education for the professional trader based on
cpeters@futuresandoptionstrader.com the RMA Methodology. Her innovative methodology and
analysis of the market have been featured on CNBC and have
Editorial assistant and
webmaster: Kesha Green
been profiled in books such as Bloomberg’s New Thinking in Technical Analysis;
kgreen@futuresandoptionstrader.com Bulls, Bears, and Millionaires; The Outer Game of Trading; The Day Traders
Advantage; The Tao of Trading; Women of the Pits; and most recently,
Art director: Laura Coyle
Breakthroughs in Technical Analysis: New Thinking from the World’s Top Minds.
lcoyle@futuresandoptionstrader.com
Mesch’s proprietary software is currently licensed to a select group of trading
President: Phil Dorman firms and fund managers with offices in Chicago and New York. In addition,
pdorman@futuresandoptionstrader.com Mesch serves as a unit trust portfolio consultant for Van Kampen
Investments. Mesch is a Brown University graduate and currently resides in
Publisher,
Ad sales East Coast and Midwest: Portland, Ore.
Bob Dorman
bdorman@futuresandoptionstrader.com Steve Lentz (advisor@optionvue.com) is a well-estab-
lished options educator and trader and has spoken all over the
Ad sales
West Coast and Southwest only: U.S., Asia, and Australia on behalf of the CBOE’s Options
Allison Chee Institute, the Options Industry Council, and the Australian
achee@futuresandoptionstrader.com Stock Exchange. As a mentor for DiscoverOptions.com, he
teaches select students how to use complex options strategies and develop a
Classified ad sales: Mark Seger
seger@futuresandoptionstrader.com consistent trading plan. Lentz is constantly developing new strategies on the
use of options as part of a comprehensive profitable trading approach. He
Volume 3, Issue 6. Futures & Options Trader is pub- regularly speaks at special events, trade shows, and trading group organiza-
lished monthly by TechInfo, Inc., 161 N. Clark St.,
Suite 4915, Chicago, IL 60601. Copyright © 2009 tions.
TechInfo, Inc. All rights reserved. Information in this
publication may not be stored or reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher.
Jim Graham (advisor@optionvue.com) is the product
The information in Futures & Options Trader magazine
is intended for educational purposes only. It is not manager for OptionVue Systems and a registered investment
meant to recommend, promote, or in any way imply
the effectiveness of any trading system, strategy, or advisor for OptionVue Research.
approach. Traders are advised to do their own
research and testing to determine the validity of a trad-
ing idea. Trading and investing carry a high level of
risk. Past performance does not guarantee future
results.
������������
����������������������������������������
�������������������������������������
���������
�������� �� ���������������������������������
������������������������������������
�����������������������������������
����������������������� ��������������������������������������
�������������������������������������
� � � � � � ����������� � � �������������������������������
��������������������������
�������������������������
��������������������
������������������������
����������������������������������������
�������������
��������������
����������������
�����������������������������������������
������������� �����������������������������������������
���������������� ����������������������������������������
������������������� �����������
����������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
���������������������������
��������
�������������������������������������������������
������������������
�����������������������������������������������
MARKET MOVERS
Metals
After some sloppy trading in April — and despite the
continued stock-market rally — precious metals swung
to the upside in May. July silver (SIN09) paced the group
with a nearly 36-percent gain from the April 20 low of 11.77
to the June 1 high of 15.97. June gold
(GCM09) posted a more modest gain
Energy of approximately 15 percent during
the same period, but nonetheless
Crude oil, gaso- traded to a three-month high of
line, and heating 988.10 as June trading began.
oil shot higher in Meanwhile, July copper (HGN09),
May, with July which had begun rallying in late
crude (CLN09) February, consolidated for much of
making a strong May but burst out to the upside on
move above $60 June 1, tagging 2.3285 and reaching
and eventually its highest level since October 2008.
topping $68 by
June 1. A choppy
natural gas market
was the odd man
out; the July con-
tract (NGN09) ral-
lied sharply in
early May, but
gave back almost
all its gains
toward the end of
the month before
bouncing again.
Grains
Grains were another
strong sector in May,
with wheat and corn
catching up to an already strong
soybean market. July beans (SN09)
were closing in on the teens by
June 1, trading as high as 1227,
while July wheat (WN09) hit 677
and July corn (CN09) topped 445.
SIZE
N
MATTERS.
Introducing Forex E-Micro Futures.
1/10 the contract size, 1/10 the risk exposure.
TRADE THEM AT E*TRADE
NO FEE Futures Platform
powered by Trading TechnologiesTM
DIRECT ACCESS to Every Secure
& Regulated U.S. Market
FREE EDUCATION & Dedicated
Customer Service
Important Note: Futures and options transactions are complex and carry a high degree of risk. They are intended for sophisticated investors
and are not suitable for everyone. For more information, please read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options and the Risk
Disclosure Statement for Futures and Options available by visiting etrade.com/options and etrade.com/futures or by calling 1-800-ETRADE-1.
New Accounts claim based on internal E*TRADE FINANCIAL Corp. metrics for average daily gross new E*TRADE Bank and E*TRADE Securities accounts between 3/1/08–2/28/09.
Net new accounts were in excess of 150,000 over the same period.
1. The new account holder will be charged 99¢ (per side, per contract, plus exchange fees) futures commissions for each futures trade executed once a qualified account is opened and
funded and deposited funds have cleared. After the 90 day offer period, each futures trade is $2.99 (per side, per contract, plus exchange fees). This offer is not valid for IRAs, other
retirement, business, trust or E*TRADE Bank accounts. Excludes current E*TRADE Securities customers, E*TRADE FINANCIAL Corp. associates and non-U.S. residents. Offer only applies
to new E*TRADE Futures Accounts opened with a $10,000 minimum deposit. Account holders must maintain minimum funding in all accounts ($10,000 minus any trading losses) for
at least six months or credit may be surrendered. Limit one new E*TRADE Futures account per customer. We reserve the right to terminate this offer at any time. In addition to the $2.99
per contract per side commission, futures customers will be assessed certain fees including applicable futures exchange and NFA fees, as well as MF Global floor brokerage charges for
execution of non-electronically traded futures and futures options contracts. These fees are not established by E*TRADE Securities and will vary by exchange.
E*TRADE Securities LLC and Trading Technologies are separate and unaffiliated companies.
CME Group does not offer or provide any investment advice or opinion regarding the nature, potential, value, suitability or profitability of any product or investment strategy. The Globe
Logo, CME Group and Forex E-micros® are trademarks of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.
Securities products and services are offered by E*TRADE Securities LLC, Member FINRA/SIPC/NFA.
Futures accounts are carried by MF Global, an unaffiliated company.
System response and account access times may vary due to a variety of factors, including trading volumes, market conditions, system performance and other factors.
©2009 E*TRADE FINANCIAL Corp. All rights reserved.
MARKET MOVERS
Meats
After regaining
nearly all their
losses from the
Fiber
immediate aftermath of the and wood
swine-flu outbreak, pork futures
turned back down in mid-May Cotton pulled back from its
and were still selling as June robust rally in the latter
arrived. July lean hogs (LHN09) half of May. After hitting 61.67 on May 12, the July contract
pushed to fresh contract lows (CTN09) retreated to 54.16
below 63.00 on June 2, while July on May 28 before bounc-
pork bellies (PBN09) wallowed ing back to 58 on June 1.
near their contract nadir. August July lumber (LBN09)
live cattle futures (LCQ09) were continued to swing in a
challenging their March and wide trading range,
February lows at the end of May falling to the level of its
and beginning of June. March and April lows
around 170 on May 21
before bouncing back
above 200 before the end
of the month.
Softs
Coffee’s 27-per-
cent rally from late
April to early June
paced the soft-com-
modity market. July coffee
(KCN09) rallied to 142.90 on
June 2 after trading as low as
112.75 on April 21, while July Treasuries
sugar (SDN09) remained near
the upper end of its May trad- T-note and T-bond
ing range and a relatively futures sold off sharply
weak July cocoa contract in late May and opened
(CCN09) managed to jump on June with more selling.
the bullish bandwagon in mid- The June 10-year T-note
May. July orange juice (OJN09) contract (TYM09),
extended its rally to 97.55 on which traded above 126
May 29 after falling as low as on March 18, broke
87.20 in mid-May. below the 120 level deci-
sively in late May and,
Stock after a two-day bounce,
traded below 117 on
indices June 1.
Source: CQG
Trading profile
Now that we have an overview of the complete market
cycle, we can try to put what we’ve learned together in a
trade strategy. Figure 7 shows a long-term profile of the
March 2005 S&P 500 futures (SPH05) from Jan. 19 to Jan.
25, 2005. During that period, the S&P ranged from 1192
to 1164, and the value area was between 1179 and 1166.
What step do you think the S&P is and where would
you expect it to develop next? Actually, Figure 7’s shad-
ed area is a step 4, which is still underdeveloped. In this
profile, we would not expect a directional move to occur
until the entire profile reverts into a more fully devel-
continued on p. 16 Source: CQG
Source: CQG
Trading a completed
bell-shaped pattern
Figure 9 shows when the data is put into a
composite profile, the market has formed a
completed bell-shaped curve. Finally, the cup
is full and ready to spill. The market has
formed a complete bell-shaped curve and step
4 is ready to become a new step 1. But in which
direction?
At this point, our strategy must shift away
from buying the bottom and selling the top of
the value area. The steps of market activity
show us when to use a congestion trading
strategy (Figure 8) vs. a trend-following strate-
gy (Figure 9).
When trading the steps of market activity,
don’t lose sight of the larger picture, which
will start to influence market direction once
Source: Capital Flow Software 3.85
continued on p. 18
Another look at
straddles and strangles
BY GUY COHEN
Note: The following article is the second installment of a chapter ate gambler. My game plan is to buy low volatility and sell
adapted from the book Volatile Markets Made Easy: Trading higher. It isn’t to buy high volatility and hope it’ll get high-
Stocks and Options for Increased Profits (FT Press, 2009). er still. I should emphasize that what I’ve just described is
The first article, published the May 2009 issue of Futures & completely different from buying a stock that is reaching
Options Trader, described the mechanics of two non-directional new highs — that’s okay if it breaks out of a consolidation
options strategies — straddles and strangles. For a review of how pattern such as a flag (see “Flag patterns”).
these positions work, see “Straddle and strangle components.”
This excerpt compares the benefits and drawbacks of both Breakeven points
approaches. The expiration breakeven point of the trade is something of
a moot point because we never hold on to expiration any-
Strangle
Essentially the strangle is identical to the straddle, except that the put has a lower
strike, the call has a higher strike, and the stock price is typically in between,
preferably equidistant between the two. The (long) strangle involves two steps:
The strangle can expose us to significant time decay because we are long OTM
calls and puts, which have no intrinsic value. Because of this, the strangle is
cheaper than the straddle where the calls and puts are ATM. The other significant
difference is the risk profile has two turning points, one for each of the strikes.
From the outset, the put strike is typically below the stock price, and the call
strike is typically above the current stock price (Figure B). In order to have direc-
tion neutrality from the outset of the trade, preferably both put and call strikes are
equidistant from the stock price when the trade is initiated. In most cases, stran-
gles will have wider breakevens to straddles, and this is something we need to
compare thoroughly when assessing whether to take the straddle, strangle, or
both.
Bull flag
With bull flags, our entry is a buy FIGURE Y — BEAR FLAG
order, and our stop loss is a sell order
(see Figure X). We anticipate a rising
stock price and enter your buy order
at either point A or B. Point A is at the
level of the top of the flag. This is the
most conservative entry point
because it is where the price is mak-
ing new highs. You must make sure
volume is increasing as the new high
is made. Increasing volume means
there is conviction behind the move,
which makes it more likely to be sus-
tainable. Point B is where the price
breaks out of the flag itself. This is
more aggressive than point A and Source: TC2000.com. Courtesy of Worden Brothers Inc.
again requires increasing trading vol-
ume to demonstrate conviction in the move. loss is a buy order to close the position (Figure Y). We antic-
If the entry is activated, then you need a stop loss. Point C ipate a falling stock price. We enter our sell (short) order at
is the level where, if you were already in the trade, you’d exit either point A or B. Point A is at the level of the bottom of the
with a small loss. This is your basic trading plan for a bull flag flag. As such it is the most conservative entry point because
within the context of an upward trend. it is where the price is making new lows. Point B is where the
price breaks below the flag itself.
Bear flag
With bear flags, our entry is a sell (short) order, and our stop
personal quirk due to my past experience. There are times of shorter ranged bars. The hope is that this consolidation
when the stock moves enough to make the straddle prof- will be followed by a resumption of increased volatility,
itable (owing to the tighter breakevens), but the strangle hopefully in a decisive manner one way or the other. In
doesn’t quite get there, so at least I’m hedged to an extent other words, I want the stock to explode up or down and
in that my straddle pays for the strangle in such circum- then keep going in that direction.
stances. The implied volatility of the options is more complex.
There are scenarios where the stock is consolidating, yet the
Expected volatility implied volatility of the options is increasing. This seems
On a similar theme, in order to consider the strangle, I also counterintuitive, and it is. Surely if the stock price is con-
like to have evidence that the expected volatility of both the solidating and the historical volatility is decreasing, the
stock and the options will increase after I’ve put on my implied volatility of the options should follow suit. Not
trade. In terms of the stock itself, I like to see well-formed necessarily … otherwise this would all be too easy. It’s not
flag patterns with a good flag pole followed by a few days uncommon for implied volatility to rise sharply, say, a few
Time decay
Time decay is the enemy of the FIGURE 2 — TECHNE CORP.
long volatility trader. We
already know time decay
increases exponentially during
the final month before expira-
tion, and you don’t want to
own straddles during that final
month. Therefore, look for
option expirations where (a)
your planned exit is timed well
before the start of the final
month and (b) where time
decay wouldn’t be a huge fac-
tor between the time you place
the trade and the planned exit
date.
Source: TC2000.com. Courtesy of Worden Brothers Inc.
Straddle cost
Of course, the lower the cost of the straddle, the lower the tion. Again, it’s all about buying low and selling high and
risk, the tighter the breakevens, the greater the probability obeying the criteria that conform.
of profit, the greater potential percentage profit, and so on. Let’s look at two charts and see which is “prettier”
However, don’t think that going for cheap front-month (Figures 1 and 2). The object of the exercise is to see which
straddles is the answer — it’s not. The “front month” is the chart is easier on the eye and from which you could identi-
nearest expiration month, which can range from four weeks fy a chart pattern and form a trading plan. It shouldn’t be
to a single day. Either way, the front month is subject to the too difficult to notice that Figure 1 is much prettier; the bars
most extreme ravages of time decay, and that’s no good for are steady with the occasional big jump. We can see it tends
long volatility traders. to move in steps and flags and it’s currently forming a con-
solidation pattern. In the following three weeks (not
Stock chart patterns shown), Apollo Group (APOL) jumped to a peak of $65, an
Before entering into a volatility trade, you want to see an increase of 25 percent. By contrast, Figure 2 is messy. There
easily identifiable chart pattern. This can often represent the is no discernable trend or pattern, and the bars are highly
calm before the storm of volatility that may ensue after inconsistent in terms of their length.
you’re in the trade. Ideally, you want to see evidence in the
past that the stock can make a sharp move in either direc- For information on the author see p. 6.
Spreading
your charting options
How do you trade options effectively? Know which strategies go with different market conditions.
Here’s how to use chart patterns to determine the best option strategy to use in a particular situation.
BY THOMAS STRIDSMAN
Note: A version of this article originally appeared in the July 2000 issue rise, but you still want some protection against a potential
of Active Trader magazine. drop. Instead of just buying a call option, you could buy
one call option and sell one call option with a higher strike
Straddling volatility
A vertical debit spread is a useful position when you have a
fairly clear opinion about what the market will do next. But
what about when you’re not so sure — when you think it can short side.
take off in either direction? Now let’s take a look at the kinds of chart patterns that
That’s when a long straddle would come in handy. A long offer trading opportunities for the option strategies we’ve
straddle consists of one or more long calls and an equal discussed.
number of long puts with the same strike price. (See
“Trading volatility,” Active Trader, June 2000, p. 52). The Chart patterns and directional bias
green line in Figure 3 shows what this position will look like When you get right down to it, there are only four types of
compared with the performance of an individual long put chart patterns: those that favor a strong move either up or
and long call. As you can see, the straddle will make money down; those that favor a more modest move up or down;
if the market makes a substantial move in either direction, those that imply a strong move in either direction; and
but will lose money if volatility decreases and the market those that don’t favor a move in either direction (i.e., price
drifts in a narrow trading range will continue to move sideways).
As with the vertical debit spread, the straddle allows you Most traders are probably better off avoiding the last
to get rid of the side of the position that loses money once type. The profit potential is very limited, unless you’re a
the market takes off; the more options you use for the initial trader who specializes in volatility plays without any
position, the more flexibility you’ll have as the price action regard to the actual price of the underlying market.
unfolds. Figure 4 shows what a long straddle (initially con- Among the patterns that favor strong moves in a certain
sisting of two call options and two put options) would look direction are top and bottom formations such as head-and-
like after selling one of the put options. As you can see, it’s shoulders, double tops and bottoms, and wedges. In Figure
now slightly easier to earn a profit on the long side than the continued on p. 28
5, the formation during the fall of 1998 is an example of a between the two lows of the pattern, which also happens to
double bottom with its most important resistance (often coincide with the bottom of a consolidation pattern preced-
referred to as the “neckline”) at point 1 (the relative high ing the double bottom).
An upward sloping wedge, which
FIGURE 5 — CHARTING YOUR OPTIONS STRATEGIES implies a potential top and trend reversal,
consists of two upward sloping, converg-
The various support and resistance levels that developed over an 18-month
ing trendlines. In Figure 5, this pattern is
period in the S&P 500 provide clues to the direction and magnitude of price
moves. This information can then be used to select appropriate option strategies forming between trendlines 5 and 8. A
at different points. downward sloping wedge formed
between trendlines 4 and 7.
Other patterns with a strong directional
bias are consolidation patterns within
trends, such as flags and pennants (See
“Waving the pennant,” Active Trader, May
2000, p. 60). Because these occur within
the context of an established uptrend, the
consolidation patterns at points 2a, 2b,
and 2c in Figure 5 all favor a break (con-
tinuation) to the upside — in the direction
of the previous trend. (Such patterns are,
in fact, often referred to as continuation
patterns.)
For these patterns, the magnitude of the
subsequent move depends not only on
other support and resistance levels pres-
ent in the market, but also on the move
leading into the pattern. To get a rough
estimate, look for the move out of the pat-
tern to be similar in size to the move lead-
ing into the pattern. That turned out to be
fairly accurate for the patterns in Figure 5.
Source: TradeStation
The patterns on this chart all represent
support or resistance of one degree or
FIGURE 6 — OPTION STRATEGY MAP another. The next step is to consider which
A breakdown of different options strategies based on the expected price option strategies to use to capitalize on the
direction and level of volatility. price action they imply.
Different chart patterns and the option strategies to use to capitalize on them.
the pullback, giving you two outright long options. test both support at about 1,300, and trendlines 4 and 5. It
In the event of a failed breakout, you have two choices: also would have been possible to add a vertical debit call
Stay with your recently modified position, or scale it back spread to this position in anticipation of a breakout through
further so it consists of one long and one short option, which the resistance at trendline 6 and the wedge at trendline 7.
you can sit on in anticipation of a second breakout attempt. No matter how you might have handled the outcome and
When the market is about to test a major trendline or sup- modified the positions as the market unfolded, these two
port or resistance level without any other kind of formation strategies would have positioned you to profit from sizable
(such as any of the ones mentioned here) to indicate possi- moves.
ble direction, price is equally likely to take off in either Given the apparent longer-term wedge developing
direction — and usually in a rather swift move with large, between trendlines 5 and 8, it could (at the time this was
short-term profit potential for the correctly positioned trad- written) be a good place for a vertical debit put spread in
er. The magnitude of the move is usually limited to previ- anticipation of a breakthrough of trendline 5 and a move
ously defined support or resistance levels and the other back to support at 1,350. This would be an acceptable move
extreme of the price channel, such as the ones marked by if the market continued down over the next couple of days.
trendlines 9a and 9b in Figure 5. But if this test failed the first time, the market would be
Another directionally unbiased pattern is the (preferably very close to the meeting point of trendlines 5 and 10 — a
symmetrical) triangle, which forms with the intersection of more neutral pattern that would call for a long straddle.
two major trendlines, such as trendlines 5 and 10. Figure 6 and Table 1 give you a quick overview of how and
Directionally neutral patterns like this are opportunities to when to place these and a few other basic option strate-
put on straddles. gies.
One excellent opportunity to place a long straddle
occurred in October 1999, when the market attempted to For information on the author see p. 6.
Seven-day momentum =
(close today-lowest(low,7))/
(highest(high,7)-lowest(low,7))
opened at 710.20 on March 3, and the system purchased one • ATM is defined as the call option with the most time
March 710 call with 17 days remaining to expiration. To premium.
simply break even, the underlying must rally 19.05 points • Daily closing prices were used. Trades were executed
(2.68 percent) during the next eight days, assuming volatil- at the bid and ask, when possible. Otherwise,
ity doesn’t change; otherwise, the position will lose money. theoretical prices were used.
The trade’s odds of success are just 34 percent. • Commissions were $5 plus $1 per option trade.
Trade rules: Test data: System was tested on the CME’s S&P 500
futures options.
Buy one ATM call in the first expiration month with at least
10 days remaining on the next day’s open when: Test period: March 23, 2001 to March 11, 2009.
1. Today’s low is below yesterday’s low and yesterday’s Test results: Figure 2 tracks the pullback system’s per-
low is below the previous day’s low. formance since March 2001. It remained profitable, but
2. Today’s high is below yesterday’s high and endured a large drawdown of $53,608 from late July 2008 to
yesterday’s high is below the previous day’s high. early March 2009.
3. Today’s close is below yesterday’s close, yesterday’s Statistically, if you buy an ATM call, you should make
close is below the previous day’s close, and the money only 33 percent of the time, but this system gained
previous day’s close is below the close the day before ground more often than expected (55 percent). This sug-
that. gests it has a trading edge, although traders need to figure
4. Today’s low is at least 2 percent below the low two out how to manage the risk of its large drawdowns, a
days ago. dilemma we addressed in the August issue of Active Trader.
5. Take up to five consecutive signals.
Note: This test included minimal commissions, but larger fees and
6. Exit when the seven-day momentum calculation is
bad fills will likely affect performance.
0.75 or higher.
7. Exit any remaining open positions after 10 days on — Steve Lentz and Jim Graham of OptionVue
the close.
Option System Analysis strategies are tested using OptionVue’s
Test details:
BackTrader module (unless otherwise noted).
• Continuous daily chart for E-Mini S&P 500 futures If you have a trading idea or strategy that you’d like to see tested,
was used to generate entry and exit signals. please send the trading and money-management rules to
• The initial account size was $95,000. Advisor@OptionVue.com.
Cap-and-trade regulation
Approved by the House Committee on Energy and
Commerce on May 21, the Waxman-Markey bill, also known
Any senator can delay a Senate vote by placing a “hold” on as “The American Clean Energy and Security Act,” could pro-
a confirmation hearing, prompting further discussion. Sen. vide Gensler and the CFTC with the means to turn many of
Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., who issued a hold on Gensler’s nomi- his regulatory goals into reality. The bill, which outlines a
nation vote, said he did so because of Gensler’s 18 years framework for a U.S. carbon cap-and-trade system, takes new
working as an executive with Goldman Sachs and for his role strides in permitting CFTC oversight of energy derivatives
in deregulating the financial services industry during his markets. A cap-and-trade system places a limit on the amount
tenure at the Treasury Department, where he worked as of carbon pollution a business can emit, but allows them to
Under Secretary of Domestic Finance, from 1999 to 2001. buy permits to exceed these limits from other businesses that
“I did not believe that Mr. Gensler was the right person at emit less than the pollution threshold.
the right time to help this country out of the financial crisis we Scheduled for a full house vote by the end of the summer,
are in today,” Sanders said in a statement he released on the the bill would extend CFTC authority to all energy derivatives
day of Gensler’s approval. Sanders’ hold had been seconded transactions, including swaps and OTC transactions, and
by Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash. would render any energy-market exemptions issued prior to
The senators eventually lifted their holds after Gensler the enactment of the bill null and void. Also, unless a transac-
addressed several key issues in discussions with Sanders. In tion is granted exemption from the CFTC after the bill is in
his response, Gensler wrote, “I believe we must urgently place, all transactions will be settled and cleared through
move to enact a broad regulatory regime that covers the entire CFTC-regulated exchanges.
over-the-counter-derivatives marketplace.” The CFTC would also be charged with setting position lim-
Gensler also suggested several reforms for derivatives- its and publicly publishing the names of entities that exceed
dealer regulation, including conservative capital and margin those limits. Furthermore, the bill would completely ban
requirements, and stricter requirements for record keeping naked credit default swaps, which are transactions involving
and reporting. Gensler also stated he would work to mandate entities that do not have an actual stake in the corresponding
the registration of hedge-fund advisors, review all previously market — one of the smoking guns of the 2008 financial col-
granted registration exemptions, and close the “London loop- lapse. The bill would also extend the CFTC’s new authority to
hole” by requiring foreign futures exchanges operating in the foreign exchanges transacting U.S. energy derivatives.
U.S. to comply with U.S. position limits and
adhere to the same reporting and transparency
MANAGED MONEY
Top 10 option strategy traders ranked by April 2009 return.
PFG buys Alaron (Managing at least $1 million as of April 30, 2009.)
April 2009 YTD $ under
T
results.
he current option Penny Pilot Program, which test-
ed trading equity option in penny increments, was
scheduled to expire in March, but termination was
pushed back to July because of differing opinions about its
tomer volume growth has generally lagged overall volume
growth.
Based on these results, the CBOE’s report suggests intro-
ducing penny pricing for all option contracts, but reducing
the penny-quote threshold from $3 to $1. According to the
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) initiated CBOE, expanding the program with the original $3 thresh-
the program in January 2007 with 13 equity options in a old would flood the exchanges with quote data and would
move to tighten spreads and reduce transaction costs. be detrimental to the industry: “[I]n this time of economic
Options priced below $3 began being quoted in pennies, unrest and uncertainty, CBOE believes that an aggressive
while those costing more than $3 were quoted in nickels. expansion of the Pilot Program in its current form, as some
Stocks have been quoted in penny increments since 2001. are recommending, would be imprudent and could have a
Initial results were promising, and the program expand- potentially long-term negative impact on the options indus-
ed over time to include more than 60 stocks and exchange- try.”
traded funds. However, the NYSE Arca, an options trading arm of
However, according to the Chicago Board Option NYSE Euronext, which reported similar results in its
Exchange’s (CBOE) March report on the program, results reports on the program, has requested the SEC continue the
are mixed. For example, although the exchange found the program as-is, and to also add the top 300 most actively
program had a positive impact on spreads in the review traded option classes not already in the program. This plan
period from August 2008 through January 2009, liquidity at would be implemented by phasing in 75 new classes at a
best bid/offer prices actually decreased. The report also time over four quarters beginning in July.
stated that volume increases in the program’s participating The SEC is accepting comments on the NYSE’s propos-
options has mostly come from market makers, while cus- al.
Covered call: Shorting an out-of-the-money call option Intrinsic value: The difference between the strike price
against a long position in the underlying market. An exam- continued on p. 36
ple would be purchasing a stock for $50
and selling a call option with a strike
price of $55. The goal is for the market
to move sideways or slightly higher
and for the call option to expire worth-
less, in which case you keep the premi-
um.
of an in-the-money option and the underlying asset price. A tains more long puts than short ones. The short strikes are
call option with a strike price of 22 has 2 points of intrinsic closer to the money and the long strikes are further from the
value if the underlying market is trading at 24. money.
For example, if a stock trades at $50, you could sell one
Naked option: A position that involves selling an unpro- $45 put and buy two $40 puts in the same expiration month.
tected call or put that has a large or unlimited amount of If the stock drops, the short $45 put might move into the
risk. If you sell a call, for example, you are obligated to sell money, but the long lower-strike puts will hedge some (or
the underlying instrument at the call’s strike price, which all) of those losses. If the stock drops well below $40, poten-
might be below the market’s value, triggering a loss. If you tial gains are unlimited until it reaches zero.
sell a put, for example, you are obligated to buy the under-
lying instrument at the put’s strike price, which may be well Put spreads: Vertical spreads with puts sharing the same
above the market, also causing a loss. expiration date but different strike prices. A bull put spread
Given its risk, selling naked options is only for advanced contains short, higher-strike puts and long, lower-strike
options traders, and newer traders aren’t usually allowed puts. A bear put spread is structured differently: Its long
by their brokers to trade such strategies. puts have higher strikes than the short puts.
Naked (uncovered) puts: Selling put options to collect Simple moving average: A simple moving average
premium that contains risk. If the market drops below the (SMA) is the average price of a stock, future, or other mar-
short put’s strike price, the holder may exercise it, requiring ket over a certain time period. A five-day SMA is the sum of
you to buy stock at the strike price (i.e., above the market). the five most recent closing prices divided by five, which
means each day’s price is equally weighted in the calcula-
Near the money: An option whose strike price is close tion.
to the underlying market’s price.
Straddle: A non-directional option spread that typically
Open interest: The number of options that have not consists of an at-the-money call and at-the-money put with
been exercised in a specific contract that has not yet expired. the same expiration. For example, with the underlying
instrument trading at 25, a standard long straddle would
Out of the money (OTM): A call option with a strike consist of buying a 25 call and a 25 put. Long straddles are
price above the price of the underlying instrument, or a put designed to profit from an increase in volatility; short strad-
option with a strike price below the underlying instru- dles are intended to capitalize on declining volatility. The
ment’s price. strangle is a related strategy.
Parity: An option trading at its intrinsic value. Strangle: A non-directional option spread that consists of
an out-of-the-money call and out-of-the-money put with
Physical delivery: The process of exchanging a physical the same expiration. For example, with the underlying
commodity (and making and taking payment) as a result of instrument trading at 25, a long strangle could consist of
the execution of a futures contract. Although 98 percent of buying a 27.5 call and a 22.5 put. Long strangles are
all futures contracts are not delivered, there are market par- designed to profit from an increase in volatility; short stran-
ticipants who do take delivery of physically settled con- gles are intended to capitalize on declining volatility. The
tracts such as wheat, crude oil, and T-notes. Commodities straddle is a related strategy.
generally are delivered to a designated warehouse; T-note
delivery is taken by a book-entry transfer of ownership, Strike (“exercise”) price: The price at which an under-
although no certificates change hands. lying instrument is exchanged upon exercise of an option.
Premium: The price of an option. Support and resistance: Support is a price level that
acts as a “floor,” preventing prices from dropping below
Put option: An option that gives the owner the right, but that level. Resistance is the opposite: a price level that acts
not the obligation, to sell a stock (or futures contract) at a as a “ceiling;” a barrier that prevents prices from rising
fixed price. higher.
Support and resistance levels are a natural outgrowth of
Put ratio backspread: A bearish ratio spread that con- the interaction of supply and demand in any market. For
Legend day moves, 20-day moves, etc.) show the per- cent means the current reading is larger than
Volume: 30-day average daily volume, in centile rank of the most recent move to a cer- all the past readings, while a reading of 0 per-
thousands (unless otherwise indicated). tain number of the previous moves of the cent means the current reading is smaller than
same size and in the same direction. For the previous readings. These figures provide
OI: Open interest, in thousands (unless other-
example, the rank for 10-day move shows perspective for determining how relatively
wise indicated).
how the most recent 10-day move compares large or small the most recent price move is
10-day move: The percentage price move to the past twenty 10-day moves; for the 20- compared to past price moves.
from the close 10 days ago to today’s close. day move, the rank field shows how the most Volatility ratio/rank: The ratio is the short-
20-day move: The percentage price move recent 20-day move compares to the past term volatility (10-day standard deviation of
from the close 20 days ago to today’s close. sixty 20-day moves; for the 60-day move, the prices) divided by the long-term volatility (100-
60-day move: The percentage price move rank field shows how the most recent 60-day day standard deviation of prices). The rank is
from the close 60 days ago to today’s close. move compares to the past one-hundred- the percentile rank of the volatility ratio over
The “rank” fields for each time window (10- twenty 60-day moves. A reading of 100 per- the past 60 days.
This information is for educational purposes only. Futures & Options Trader provides this data in good faith, but it cannot guarantee its accuracy or timeliness. Futures & Options
Trader assumes no responsibility for the use of this information. Futures & Options Trader does not recommend buying or selling any market, nor does it solicit orders to buy
or sell any market. There is a high level of risk in trading, especially for traders who use leverage. The reader assumes all responsibility for his or her actions in the market.
38 June 2009 • FUTURES & OPTIONS TRADER
OPTIONS RADAR (as of May 28)
MOST-LIQUID OPTIONS*
Indices Symbol Exchange Options Open 10-day move / 20-day move / IV / IV / SV ratio —
volume interest rank rank SV ratio 20 days ago
S&P 500 index SPX CBOE 155.4 1.26 M 2.59% / 56% 3.80% / 15% 27.8% / 24.8% 32.7% / 32.6%
S&P 500 volatility index VIX CBOE 80.8 1.36 M -5.88% / 6% -12.22% / 42% 85.2% / 82.3% 68.4% / 75.5%
Russell 2000 index RUT CBOE 44.5 474.0 4.32% / 20% 0.15% / 0% 37.1% / 35.1% 43% / 44.4%
E-Mini S&P 500 futures ES CME 36.5 117.7 2.23% / 40% 4.14% / 13% 27.8% / 29.4% 32.8% / 36.8%
Nasdaq 100 index NDX CBOE 14.1 147.1 6.01% / 75% 2.74% / 14% 28% / 26.4% 33.4% / 30.6%
Stocks
Citigroup C 635.3 12.69 M 7.62% / 15% 17.63% / 42% 110.4% / 94.6% 124% / 158.7%
Bank of America BAC 334.8 3.57 M 2.63% / 0% 30.18% / 39% 76.6% / 108.1% 127.5% / 171.3%
General Motors GM 130.6 2.22 M -7.44% / 40% -38.12% / 76% 257.5% / 177.2% 218% / 143.6%
General Electric GE 97.5 2.55 M 2.17% / 13% 7.94% / 8% 52.4% / 52% 62% / 79.2%
Wells Fargo WFC 75.5 1.24 M 2.36% / 13% 24.04% / 28% 68.7% / 95.7% 106.9% / 123.6%
Futures
Eurodollar ED CME 151.1 5.54 M 0.08% / 10% 0.27% / 70% 81.5% / 68.9% 55.7% / 40.1%
10-year T-notes TY CME 50.9 651.9 -3.36% / 100% -3.20% / 98% 10.4% / 6.9% 8.7% / 6.4%
E-Mini S&P 500 futures ES CME 36.5 117.7 2.23% / 40% 4.14% / 13% 27.8% / 29.4% 32.8% / 36.8%
10-year T-notes TY CME 31.4 653.6 -3.30% / 100% -3.14% / 95% 10.9% / 8.5% 8.6% / 7.8%
Corn C CME 31.3 529.8 0.52% / 0% 6.83% / 33% 40.5% / 36% 43.7% / 34%
VOLATILITY EXTREMES**
Indices - High IV/SV ratio
S&P 100 Index OEX CBOE 11.9 80.7 1.84% / 44% 3.86% / 24% 26.9% / 22.1% 32% / 29.3%
S&P 500 futures SP CME 9.9 60.1 2.24% / 40% 4.14% / 13% 28.2% / 23.4% 32.9% / 31%
Dow Jones index DJX CBOE 5.2 144.5 1.44% / 44% 2.66% / 11% 25.1% / 22.1% 29.7% / 29%
S&P 500 index SPX CBOE 155.4 1.26 M 2.59% / 56% 3.80% / 15% 27.8% / 24.8% 32.7% / 32.6%
S&P 100 index (European style) XEO CBOE 3.6 43.8 1.84% / 44% 3.86% / 23% 25.7% / 23.7% 30.9% / 31.1%
in all markets failed to reach historical extremes (i.e., readings of 100 or -100). c2 = ((b2 - a2)/ b2 ) * 100
Options Watch: S&P telecom industry index stocks (as of May 27) Compiled by Tristan Yates
The following table summarizes the expiration months available for the 21 stocks in Standard and Poor’s telecommunications industry index
(SPSITE), the best-performing market year-to-date among the S&P’s 19 industry indices (as of May 18). It also shows each stock’s average bid-
ask spread for at-the-money (ATM) June options. The information does NOT constitute trade signals. It is intended only to provide a brief synop-
sis of potential slippage in each option market.
Aug.
Dec.
Nov.
July
Jan.
Jan.
Oct.
Closing of underlying
Stock Ticker price Call Put price
Qualcomm Inc. QCOM X X X X X 42.43 0.03 0.03 0.06%
Verizon Communications VZ X X X X X 28.95 0.02 0.02 0.06%
AT&T Inc. T X X X X X 24.07 0.02 0.02 0.07%
Cisco Systems CSCO X X X X X 18.22 0.02 0.02 0.08%
Motorola Inc. MOT X X X X X 5.92 0.02 0.02 0.34%
American Tower Corp. AMT X X X X X 30.63 0.13 0.10 0.37%
Juniper Networks JNPR X X X X X 24.14 0.10 0.09 0.39%
F5 Networks Inc. FFIV X X X X X 30.03 0.11 0.13 0.40%
Corning Inc. GLW X X X X X X 14.62 0.06 0.09 0.51%
Polycom Inc. PLCM X X X X X 17.25 0.10 0.10 0.58%
Crown Castle Intl. Corp. CCI X X X X X 23.70 0.16 0.11 0.58%
Leap Wireless International Inc. LEAP X X X X X 41.05 0.23 0.30 0.64%
MetroPCS Communications Inc. PCS X X X X 17.00 0.14 0.11 0.74%
Harris Corp. HRS X X X X X X 30.79 0.26 0.34 0.97%
NII Holdings Inc. NIHD X X X X X X 18.79 0.16 0.21 1.00%
Brocade Communications Systems BRCD X X X X X 7.19 0.06 0.09 1.04%
SBA Communications Corp. SBAC X X X X X X 24.87 0.30 0.26 1.13%
Sprint Nextel Corp. S X X X X X X 5.07 0.06 0.09 1.48%
Tellabs Inc. TLAB X X X X X X 5.41 0.08 0.10 1.62%
Telephone & Data Systems TDS X X X X 30.78 0.59 0.55 1.85%
TW Telecom Inc. TWTC X X X X 11.82 0.23 0.21 1.85%
Legend:
Call: Four-day average difference between bid and ask prices for the front-month ATM call.
Put: Four-day average difference between bid and ask prices for the front-month ATM put.
Bid-ask spread as % of underlying price: Average difference between bid and ask prices for front-month, ATM call, and put divided by the underlying's closing price.
E*TRADE FINANCIAL has released E*TRADE Mobile Pro CME Globex electronic trading platform. Grain calendar spread
for Apple’s iPhone and iPod touch. The application provides options will be available on CME Globex and on the trading
many of the same interface, security, trading, and banking fea- floors in the corn, wheat, soybean, soybean meal, and soybean
tures available on etrade.com to customers via their iPhone or oil options pit. These contracts are listed with, and subject to, the
iPod touch. The application is available at no additional cost to rules and regulations of the Chicago Board of Trade.
all E*TRADE Securities customers via the Apple App Store.
Mobile Pro reduces the steps needed to perform various tasks IntercontinentalExchange (ICE) has introduced a
and provides customers with confirmation of transactions one-minute tradable marker facility for ICE Brent Crude futures
before they are completed. Mobile Pro functionality includes and the ICE Gasoil futures contracts during the Asian trading
access to bank and brokerage account details; free real-time day. The new markers are the Singapore Brent and Singapore
streaming stock and options quotes; the ability to trade stocks Gasoil markers. Timing of the markers will be the minute pre-
and options, including conditional orders; and the ability to ceding 16:30 local Singapore time (08:30 GMT/09:30 BST) and
transfer funds between brokerage and bank accounts, including will be tradable for the front-three contract months. A marker
transfers from outside financial institutions. To learn more and price called the “Singapore Minute marker” for both Brent and
see a demo of the platform, visit http://www.etrade.com/ Gasoil futures will be a volume trade weighted average price of
iphone. trades executed between 16:29:00 and 16:29:59 hours local
Singapore time (08:30 GMT/09:30 BST), and will be published
Open E Cry, LLC, a direct access brokerage firm, launched for the front-three contract months. Singapore marker trades
OEC FX, an online foreign exchange trading service. With OEC executed up to and including 16:29:59 local Singapore time will
FX, Open E Cry now supports futures, futures options, and forex be named “one minute Singapore Brent Marker Trades” and
trading on a single platform. GAIN Capital provides Open E Cry “one minute Singapore Gasoil Marker Trades” and will be
with forex clearing and custody services. Open E Cry’s propri- reflected in both the ICE Electronic Trading System (ETS) and
etary trading software, OEC Trader, provides streaming quotes, the Trade Registration System (TRS) in a format similar to settle-
depth of market, more than 15 advanced order types, and built- ment trades. In addition to the markers, ICE is introducing a
in charting tools. End user access is achieved through a down- facility to allow premium and discount trades to be applied to
loadable software interface or through a proprietary API. the markers, mirroring what is currently in existence for Trade at
Traders can register for a free trial of OEC trader at Settlement trades. ICE is also launching a tradable U.S. Gasoil
https://www.openecry.com (click on Software > Free Practice marker at 19:30 UK time (14:30 EDT). A premium and discount
Account). trade facility will also be enabled for the London 16:30 Brent
Crude futures tradable marker in response to customer demand.
Charles Schwab announced new options trading capabil-
ities for active traders with several upgrades to its trading plat- TraderInterviews.com, an online media site that fea-
forms, including new charting and screening tools. New features tures audio interviews with active traders, is offering a member-
include: several new charting studies for options-specific techni- ship product. Members get access to more than 100 audio inter-
cal data (Implied Volatility and Put/Call Ratio); new options views in the archives as well as free reports on setting profit tar-
screening capabilities for the Customizable Options Screener gets and improving price forecasting skills. Recent interviews
including covered call, delta, and implied volatility screening; include a discussion with news trader Peter Farmer. Others
new historical option price charts and strategy profit/loss include a discussion of popular chart indicators a hedge-fund
charts; and multi-leg trading enhancements, including No Bid manager is using during the volatile first and last hour of trad-
and Good Till Canceled multi-leg orders. For more information ing, and an options trader who uses Excel spreadsheets to help
about the active trading services at Charles Schwab, visit determine which expiration month and strike price to buy or
http://www.schwabat.com. sell. Visitors can sample free interviews and transcripts at
http://www.TraderInterviews.com.
CME Group has launched clearing services for five new
petroleum swap futures contracts, new national balancing point TraderPlanet.com, an interactive social networking site
Henry Hub swap futures and options contracts, a new PJM for active traders and investors, has partnered with
Western Hub 50 MW peak calendar month real-time LMP swap Barchart.com to expand TraderPlanet’s offering of educational
futures contract, and calendar spread options for corn, wheat, resources. The content provided by Barchart.com consists of
soybeans, soybean meal, and soybean oil futures. The petroleum charts and market quotes. In exchange, TraderPlanet.com is pro-
swap futures contracts and their commodity codes will be: viding Barchart.com with market commentary from Jim
ethanol (Platts) T1 FOB Rotterdam excluding duty (2M); ethanol Wyckoff and Darrell Jobman, senior analysts at
(Platts) T2 FOB Rotterdam including duty (Z1); Singapore TraderPlanet.com. The commentary will also be syndicated for
Mogas 92 unleaded (Platts, 1N); Singapore Mogas 92 unleaded InsideFutures, a subsidiary of Barchart.com.
(Platts) BALMO (1P); and FAME 0 (Argus) biodiesel FOB
Rotterdam (2L). Henry Hub commodity codes will be E2 for the Note: The New Products and Services section is a forum for industry
futures contract and V1 for the options contract. The PJM businesses to announce new products and upgrades. Listings are adapted
Western Hub 50 MW peak calendar month real-time LMP swap from press releases and are not endorsements or recommendations from
code is 4SN. These contracts are listed with, and subject to, the the Active Trader Magazine Group. E-mail press releases to
rules and regulations of NYMEX, and will be available on the editorial@futuresandoptionstrader.com. Publication is not guaranteed.
TRADE
TRADE SUMMARY
P/L
Date Contract Entry Initial stop Initial target IRR Exit Date Point % LOP LOL Length
5/7/09 YMM09 8423 8479 8306 2.09 8543 5/8/09 -120 -1.42% 10 -130 1 day
Legend: IRR — initial reward/risk ratio (initial target amount/initial stop amount); LOP — largest open profit (maximum available profit
during lifetime of trade); LOL — largest open loss (maximum potential loss during life of trade).
TRADE
EVENTS