Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RECOGNITION AGREEMENT
wIr NEg $ Er H:
WHEREAS' on.Iuly 18, 2006,ESDC adopted that certain General Pro-iectPlan,
and on December8, 2005, and .Iuly 23,20A9, ESDC adopted those sertain Modified General
ProjectPlans(the "MGPP") for the Atlantic Yards Land Use Improvement and Civic Project
(the"DevelopmentProject"), eactrin accordancewith the New York State Urban Development
CorporationAct;
WHEREAS, the project site (the "Project Site") occupies an approximately ?'7-
acreareagenerallybounded by Ftratbushand 4n Avenues to the West, Vanderbi-It Avenue to the
East,Atlantic Avenue to the North, and Dean and Pacific Streetsto the South and includes tlre
approximately 9-acre (including the land under the 6thand Carlton Avenue Bridges) below-gr:r,Je
LongIslandRail Road Vanderbilt StorageYard;
WHEREAS, pursuant to (a) the Third Amended and RestatedLeasehold and Fee
Mortgage,Assignment of Leasesand Rents, Security Agreement and Financing Statement,dated
as of the date hereof, among Developer, certai.n Afhliates of Developer and Mortgagee (the
"First Mortgage") and (b) the Second Arne*ded and Restated Subordinate Leasehold and Fee
Mortgage,Assignment of Leasesand Rerfs, Security Agreement and Financing Statement,dated
as of the date hereof, among Developer" sertain Affiliates of Developer and Mortgagee (the
"SecondMortgage" and together with the First lvfortgage,the "Mortgages")" which Mortgages
have been (or simultaneously herewith, wiil be) recorded in the City Register, Mortgagee and
Developerhave (or simultaneously herewidh,will) amendedand restatedthe Original Mortgages
to encumber Developer's leasehold estates under the Interim Leases and certain fee simple
estatesof those certain Affiliates of Developer party to the Mortgages'
WHEREAS, ESDC has agreedto recognize and grant certain rights to Mortgagee
with respect to the Interim Leases and any New Leases, in each case, as Inore particularly
describedin this Agreement.
(b) Words of the masculine, feminine or neuter gender shall mean and
include the correlative words of the other gendersand words importing the singular number shall
mean and include the plural number and vice versa.
1.3 Ca$ti.ons. The captions under the article and section numbers are for
convenienceand referenqeonly and in no way define, limit or describethe scope or intent of this
Agreementnor in any way affect the interpretation or meaning of this Agreernent.
ARTICLE II
2.3 Estoppel. Mortgagee does hereby certify to ESDC, with the knowledge
that suchcertificationwill be relied upon by ESDC, the following:
(a) The Certified Mortgage is in fuIl force and effecf as of the date
hereof. Except as attached as Exhibit B, the Certified Mortgage has not been amended,
modified or otherwise supplemented.
(c) The stated maturity date for the amounts secured by the Certified
Mortgage (after giving effect to all extension options in favor of Developer and its Affiliates
thereunder,if any) is February 11,2012.
ARTICLE III
ARTICLE IY
ESDC agrees that, notwithstanding the terrns of the Interim Leases and
DevelopmentAgreement, solely as between Mortgagee and any SuccessorLeasehold Owner on
theonehand and ESDC on the other hand the following principles shall govercreertain aspectsof
therelationshipof ESDC on the one hand and Mortgagee and any Stlccessorl-easehold Owner
on the other hand with respect to the Interim Leases or any New Leases; it being agreed that
neitherDeveloper nor Developer's Affiliates nor any successoror assign o'f Developer (other
than Mortgagee or any Successor Leasehold Owner succeeding to tenanl's rights under an
InterimLease or acquiring a New Lease, in each case by reason of a Foresl,osureEvent) shall
havethe benefit of the principles articulated in this Article IV.
(a) Subject to the conditions set forth in this Section 4.1(a), the Term
of eachInterim Lease shall be extended,as necessary,and on a cumulative basis, as follows:
provided, in all casesthat the extensionsafforded by this Section 4.1(a) shall in no event extend
ih" Tet- at any of the Interim Leases,for a period greaterthan ninety-nine (99) years following
the Project Effective Date.
(b) In the event that (i) Mortgagee foreeloses upon the certified
Mortgage and (ii) construction of the Arena has not been commencedin aecordancewith the last
sentence of Section 29.3(a) of the Interim Leases, then subject to co'r,npliance with all
Requirements, ESDC and Mortgagee shall each work diligently and in goo'd f,aith to find an
expeditious solution to allow the Developrnent Project to proceed in a rnanner that is rnindful of
and consistent with Mortgagee's need to recoup its investment in those portio*rs of the Froject
Site encumberedby the Certified Mortgage, as well as the development goals of ESDC and the
City.
(c) For purposes of this section 4.5, the term "Ternnination Prieen'
meansthe lesserof
(ii) the fair market value of the leasehold interests under all
Interirn Leases, Development Leases and New Leases taking into acccunt the
developrnent rights, hurdens, cbligations and the restriqtions (othet than the Arena
Cornrnen""*"rriRestrictions) associatedwith such leasetptrdinterests under the MGFP
and the Project Documents and applicable to a Successcrlrasehold Owner thereunder,
subject to this Agreement (the 'nFair Market Value'n), determined as set fonh on
Appendix B
ARTICLE V
LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
ESDC agrees that notwithstanding the terms of the Interim Leases and
DevelopmentAgreement, solely as between Mor[gagee and any SuccessorI-easehold Owner an
the one hand and ESDC on the other hand the fotrtowing principles shall govenl the relationship,
from and after Mortgagee's commencement of'foreclosure proceedings wittr respect to the
Certifred Mortgage, of Mortgagee and any SuccessorLeasehold Owner on the one hand and
ESDC on the other hand with respectto the liquidated damagesdescribed in Seetion 5.3 below
in lieu of the liquidated damagesthat are payable to ESDC pursuant to the terrns of the Interim
Leasesand Development Agreement; it being agreed that neither Developer nor Developer's
Affiliates nor any successor or assign of Developer (other than Mortgagee o.'f,any Successor
LeaseholdOwner succeedingto Mortgagee'srights, in each case following a Fo,reclosureEvenQ
shallhave the benefit of the principles articulated in this Article v.
10
York Server3,A- MSW
719327.08=New
squarefootage perrnitted by the applicable severedDeveloprnent Lease{s) (which has not
yet been accagnted for in Section 5.2(dxi) above as a Substantially CornptretedPraject
-Building)
and (II) the maximum gross square footage that may be constsucted on such
severed-parcel(s)(which has not yet been accounted for in Section 5"2{dxi} above as a
Substantially Completed Froject Building) pursuant to Exhibit C of the MG?P and (B)
the denorninator of which shall be the sum of (I) the numerator, (Ii) the rnaxirnwn gtoss
square footage that may be constructed on the remaining prernises dernised under ttre
Arena Block Interim Lease per the MGPP and (III) the maximum gross square footage
that may be cans'tructedon Site 5 per the MGPP; or
53 Liquidated Damases.
11
719327.08-NewYork Server3A - MSW'
MOR.TGAGEE (ON BEHALF OF ITSELF AF{D ANY
PERSON CLAIMING BY OR TT,{ROUGII MORTGAGEE {INCLUDING ANiY FT]TURE
PERMITTED DEVELOPER AND SUCCESSOR LEASE}XOLD OWNER} AGREES
THAT (I) THE AMOUNT OF ACTUAL DAMAGES TO BE STISTAINEII tsY ESDC IN
THE EYENT THE PHASE r MPROVEMENTS (AS MOIIIFIED BY SECTIOI'{S 4.4
AI\D 5.2 ABOVA) HAVE NOT BEEN SUBSTANTIALLY COMPLETED ON OR PRIOR
TO THE MORTGAGEE OUTSII}E COMPLETION }ATE WCIULD BE MATERIAL,
BUT INCAPABLE OF PRECISE CALCULATION AIYD NOT REAX}ILY
ASCERTAINABLE, (II) THE AFdOUNTS SET FORTI{ IN SECTION 5.3(a}" ARE
REASONABLE IN PROPORTION TO THE PROBABLE DAMAGES LII(BLY TO tsE
SUSTAINED By ESDC, 0II) MORTGAGEE HAS HA.D THE, ADYICE CIF COT.TTNSEL
OF ITS OWN SELECTION WIIO REVIEWED TI.IE PROVISION FOR THE
PAYMENT OF THE AMOUI{TS SET FORTH IN T}TIS SECTICN 5.3(A} IN
CONNECTION WITH THE EXECUTION AND DELXVERY OF' THIS ITGREEIWENT'
(ID THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT WERE NEGOfiATED AT ARFTS L.ENGTH,
AND (\r) THE AMOUNTS SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION s.3{n} ARE NOT
INTENDED TO, AND DO Ir{OT, CONSTITUTE A PENA.LTY Os[ PUNITTVE
DAMAGES FOR AFIY PURPOSES"
(c) All arnotints payableto ESDC purmrantto this Secfion 5.3 shall be
payable in United Sates currency, ilr a single lump sum, by' wire transfer cf irnroediately
availablefunds to the account designatedat suchtime by ESDC.
(d) In the event the amounts set forth in Seetion 5.3{a} above are not
paid to ESDC when the same shall be due and payable, then sueh fuilure strhatrl cor'wtitute a
monetary Event of Default under each of the lnterirn Lease and under the DeveloXrment
Agreement,and as a consequencethereof the landlord under each of the Interim Leases, and
gSOC under the Development Agreenaent, shall have atrl of the ri$ts and relrrcdi:es granted to
eachof them as a result of an monetary Event of Default, including, without lirnitation, th,eright
to terminatethe applicable agreement.
t2
York Server34 - MSW
719327.08-New
by such party under this Agreement, the Developrnent .A"greement,any of the Interim Leases or
anyother Project Docurnent.
AII.TICLE VI
l3
719327.08-NewYork Server3,4 - MSW
ARTICLE VII
(c) Authority. Mortgagee, in its capacity as agent for itself and its
assignsand participants, (i) is the legal owner and holder of all interest in the Certified Mortgage,
analil; has full power, right and authority to enter into this Agreement on behalf of all itself and
its assigns and participants, (iii) bV virtue of Mortgagee's execution and delivery of this
Agreement,Mortgagee and its assigns and participants are bound by the terms hereof, and (iv)
thit the Person whose signature appeuusbelow on behalf of Mortgagee has the right, power and
t4
York Server3A - MSW
719327.08-New
APPENDD( C
F:-..-..-- _.=J...-....'__.*..-__-._._-.r___
iTie.aggfegqtegros-s..squaire,'foq!"ag.eF'gf-thSliindividudt:buildi'riqs
arb.
maxi'rnqm'g.qiiarb:foiara'S+:thet.wonJd,b:b
l(ji'p'aidi:1h:aii.the rjeieitope.d.jh
gqg!piesgJg-s[eg&l:hdrvr-Q-u-e!-ssnere&eles-e-sbgqses.
- --
Scenarios:
AIl ScenariosAssume that Site 5 is not part of the Collateral and the 1.3M GSF
Requirementapplies
1. If no Developrnent Parcelshave been severedfrom the Interim Lease then the Successor
LeaseholdOqrnerwill be requiredto build 1,300,000GSF.
919,313
GSF
Calculation:
1,300,000GSF- 380,687GSF(Substantially
Completed):919,313GSF
780,313GSF
Calcalation:
AppendixC-l
71932?.08-New
Yo* Scrver3A - MSW
b) 343,632GSF (numerator)/ (343,632GSF+ i,106,009GSF+ 824,629GSF)
(denominator)
: 15.1lYo @ercentage)
multiplied by 919,313GSF : 138,904GSFreduction
AppendixC-2
York Scrver3A - MSW
719327.08-New
Exhibit B
CertifiedMorteaee
"Certified Mortgage" shall mean,collectively, the following:
2. \\at certainMortgage SpreaderAgreementamorg Ay 35-37 Sixth, LLC, a New york limited iiabilitv
company ("35'37 Sixth"), AY 487 Dean,LLC, aNew York limited liability company ("487 Dean"), A*
489 Dean, LLC, a New York limited liability company("489 Dean") and (iv) AyDi Interim Deveioper,
LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (,,InteU!0_Dgl'elSEI" and togetier with 3S-37 Sixth, +gZ
Dean and 489 Dean, collectively, the 'Msrtgap$") und Mortgagee, dated as of the date hereof, aad
relating to a loan in the original principal amountof $152,821,234.
4. That certain Third Amended and RestatedLeaseholdand Fee Mortgage, Assignment of Leasesand
Rents, Security Agreementand Financing Staternentamong Mortgagors and Mortgagee, datedas of the
datehereof.
5' That certai:rMortgage SpreaderAgreementamong Mortgagors and Mortgagee, dated as of the date
hereof, and relating to a loan in the original principal ?mountof $37,362,050.
uS\DANIENOV525135.1
E)(HIBIT C
ProjeetRequirementsAllocationSchedule
Acknowledged:
Mortgagee Developer
' Subjectto (a) thetermsof the Are.naParkingEasement, and(b) thatneitherMortgageenor any Successor
LeaseholdOwner
shallhaveanyobligationto fund the costof creatingandoperatingthe temporaryArenaParking,
Exhibit C-1
719327.08-New
York Ssver 3A,- MSW