You are on page 1of 2

January 6, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — Extensions of Remarks E25

‘fortunately,’ he told me, are covered oric has been laudable in some instances, THE WALK FOR HEALTHCARE:
through the state (ACCESS program). He their ‘‘Cut-as-you-go’’ rule is riddled with loop- HEALTHCARE STORIES FROM
seemed calm as he explained this predica- MARYLAND AND WASHINGTON,
ment. ‘My wife just got diagnosed with Lyme holes. For instance, it allows tax cuts for cor-
porations to be deficit financed, while pro- DC, COLLECTED BY OGAN
disease, though—a tick-bite right here in our
back yard.’ Eyes perked up among the others grams like child tax credits must find offsets. GUREL, M.D.
sitting about the grocery. He told me, ‘We’re In fact, these rules forbid eliminating even the
paying cash for the lab bill.’ It had originally
narrowest special interest tax loophole to find HON. DENNIS J. KUCINICH
been $307 but they were able to get it dis- OF OHIO
counted to $187. ‘The doctor’s bill was $80— revenue for effective government programs.
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
and that’s just for the diagnosis,’ he added. The most casual glance at the origin of this
‘For the actual treatment, we’re dependin’ Thursday, January 6, 2011
country’s debts illustrates the fallacy of their
on free samples.’ ’’ Mike—Harrisonville, 7/21/ Mr. KUCINICH. Mr. Speaker, I submit the
2009 approach. Without finding a dime to offset the
following stories, collected by Dr. Ogan Gurel.
‘‘Martin has been out-of-work since last cost to our Nation, these rules make it pos-
year. ‘Obviously I have no insurance,’ he ‘‘Tamara told me, ‘She was lucky having
sible to both make permanent the 2001 and health insurance.’ Knowing generally that
said. He has insulin-dependent diabetes and 2003 Bush tax cuts for the highest-income tax-
gets some healthcare through the Pennsyl- lack of insurance was a problem, she didn’t
vania ACCESS card. He explained that, ‘If I payers and to repeal the Affordable Care Act, have any particular personal stories to
go back to work, however, I’ll lose my med- which not only saves nearly $150 billion during share. But when I asked about health reform,
ical care.’ That’s a disincentive to work, I she said, simply enough, that, ‘More should
the next 10 years, but reduces healthcare
said. ‘Sure is . . . I need to stay under twen- be done.’ ’’ Tamara—Hagerstown, 7/22/2009
costs by nearly a trillion dollars during the fol- ‘‘Patrick has been on and off insurance all
ty hours a week to get medical care. If I
work more, there’s no job, no way I could
lowing decades. his life. ‘More off than on,’ he further clari-
fied for me. ‘My credit rating is trashed be-
pay for the healthcare and medicines. I can’t In no way do these rules result in the type
just drop the insulin.’ ’’ Martin— cause of medical stuff.’ And in the 80s he had
of prudent budgeting that my Republican col- a skull injury. ‘I actually had insurance but
Harrisonville, 7/21/2009
‘‘ ‘I would call myself a fiscal conserv- leagues campaigned on, nor does it resemble not everything was covered so I just couldn’t
ative,’ Jim told me as we sat together dis- anything like what any hardworking American pay.’ He seemed relaxed for someone for
cussing healthcare in his living room. ‘I be- family must do. At a time when the Republican whom the system seemed not to work—
lieve that health savings accounts, HSAs, forced into debt, even with insurance, and
majority is pledging greater openness, the now suffering the consequence of ruined
and patient involvement in the decisions will
Rules are also anti-democratic by depriving credit. But perhaps one gets used to such
be important to bring costs under control.’
He added that in his experience, once health 600,000 taxpaying D.C. residents of their abil- predicament.’’ Patrick—Hagerstown, 7/22/2009
benefits are provided, it’s ‘very difficult to ity to have their voice heard in the Committee ‘‘Tiffany doesn’t have a job, nor does she
backtrack.’ He’s worked in government for have health insurance. As a single mom, her
of the Whole. daughter gets assistance through the state.
32 years and is currently retired. ‘Personally,
I think the government plan, if made avail- The Rules package also undermines oppor- For herself, she did have to go to the emer-
able to all, would work well. I think that tunities to continue investing in America. gency room one time last year but as she
would be easy to implement. It allows didn’t fill out the form for medical assist-
By eliminating the point of order guarding ance in time (there was a three-month time
choice, there’s already a mechanism to col-
lect premiums and there could be some in- Highway Trust Fund balances this Republican limit), she ended up owing $4,000. Now she’s
come tiering.’ ’’ Jim—Bedford, 7/21/2009 majority threatens investments in communities being taken to court by the hospital, Wash-
‘‘ ‘I think that it’s possible to have a very ington County. ‘I get phone calls every day
large and small across the country. Histori- from the bill collectors,’ she tells me. ‘And
basic plan as a public good.’ Jo told me she’s cally, this point of order ensured that Con-
seen examples of that and she ‘believes it’s a I’m scared to go back to the doctor for any-
good use of taxpayer money.’ But she also re- gress delivered on the transportation invest- thing including my frozen shoulder.’ With
alizes how it could get out-of-hand. ‘It all de- ments promised in the transportation author- some trepidation, she told me she knew
pends on how and what ‘‘basic’’ is defined as,’ ization, and that States and communities could somebody who was threatened with jail for
she said. ‘Sometimes that’s too abstract.’ ’’ not responding to court summons for a med-
count on the long-term commitments made in ical bill. ‘It’s not a good situation to be in,’
Jo.—Bedford, 7/21/2009
that legislation. By removing this point of she told me. Despite her unhappy troubles,
f Tiffany insisted on smiling when I took her
order, and allowing Highway Trust Fund bal-
RULES OF THE HOUSE ances to accrue and mask the actual deficit, picture.’’ Tiffany—Hagerstown, 7/23/2009
‘‘I met Terry at the Oriole Club, a local bar
the Republicans are engaging in budget gim- where I stopped in during a ferocious thun-
SPEECH OF
mickry that undermines our economy and the derstorm to take a water break. Terry be-
HON. EARL BLUMENAUER safety of our communities. lieves in preventative medicine, eating right,
OF OREGON exercising—being positive. She doesn’t have
Organizations from the Chamber of Com- insurance and with two kids, she’s busy pro-
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
merce to the American Association of Highway viding them with a home and feeding them
Wednesday, January 5, 2011 Transportation Officials have expressed their right. Last year she got very sick but nobody
Mr. BLUMENAUER. Mr. Speaker, I am strong concern about destabilizing transpor- would take her. Because she has no primary
deeply disappointed in the Rules package as- care doctor, it costs $250 just to get in the
tation funding, and have urged the Republican
door. The others seated along the bar gave
sembled by my Republican colleagues. In their Conference to make changes. I join with these knowing looks. She told me she prayed a lot,
campaigns, they promised to improve trans- organizations in expressing my concern and especially when her temperature hit 104. ‘But
parency and to reduce the deficit. These disappointment. I survived,’ she said with a smile. ‘But, if you
Rules break those promises. don’t have insurance,’ she told me, ‘you’re
Under these Rules, the new Republican ma- At a time when the need to invest in our treated different.’ ’’ Terry—Middletown, 7/23/
jority will enact a draconian budget without a communities is higher than ever, these rules 2009
single hearing, without any input from the will make it possible for the Republican Con- ‘‘Sonny told me the story of a girl in town.
Budget Committee, without any outreach to gress to decrease our investment in infrastruc- Many of the others seated at the bar recog-
nized her plight. ‘She’s worked for ten years,
Congressional Democrats, and without a direct ture, undermining efforts to rebuild and renew without insurance,’ Sonny told me. And she
vote by the House of Representatives. Merely communities across the country. In addition to got sick with a gallbladder problem and,
by entering a statement into the record, the the new rule regarding the Highway Trust ‘probably because she couldn’t work on ac-
Budget Chairman can subject all spending be- Fund, these Republican rules also limit the count of her illness,’ she was laid off. She
yond whatever levels he deems appropriate to ability of the House to raise revenue for the needs a gallbladder removal but the doctor
keeps putting her off. ‘Nobody wants to treat
pwalker on DSKD5P82C1PROD with REMARKS

a point of order. This level of concentrated au-


Highway Trust Fund. At a time when our her,’ he added. ‘And she went to see the spe-
thority runs contrary to the premise of trans-
parency that Republicans campaigned on, needs are greater than ever, and individuals cialist but he wanted $300 up front.’ Karen,
and, given its disregard for scrutiny, runs the and organizations across the country are call- sitting alongside, squirmed in disapproval.
ing on Congress to upgrade our Nation’s ‘Everyone’s giving her the run-around . . .
risk of greatly damaging our economy and the And there seems to be no way out of her situ-
welfare of millions. roads, bridges, and transit systems, limiting ation.’ ’’ Sonny—Middletown, 7/23/2009
The rules themselves make a mockery of our options—as these Rules do—is short- ‘‘Chris works at the Days Inn in Frederick.
prudent budgeting. While the Republican rhet- sighted and foolhardy. He’s an insulin-dependent diabetic (that’s his

VerDate Mar 15 2010 05:43 Jan 07, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00011 Fmt 0626 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K06JA8.011 E06JAPT1
E26 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — Extensions of Remarks January 6, 2011
supplies he’s proudly showing me). He has in- to a Palliative Care unit and though he was nity Regional Medical Center Foundation and
surance but ‘it sucks, only covers so much,’ put on a morphine drip, he survived for two many generous members of the community, a
he told me. ‘They don’t cover even the sup- more tortuous months. All during this time, family dream has become a reality.
plies I have here. And if you go to the hos- people from the hospital kept coming by
pital for low blood sugar, or see a specialist,
Mr. Speaker, I applaud Terry’s House and
telling his already grieving wife that she
it costs several hundred dollars.’ He was pre- would be responsible for the bill. ‘The total its many supporters for their efforts to create
viously under his parent’s coverage but now bill is $69,000 and still going up,’ she said.’’ a facility which keeps families together during
his own insurance, which ‘bad as it is,’ he Brenda—Gaithersburg, 7/24/2009 times of need. I ask my colleagues to join me
added, has been further downgraded because ‘‘Shayla’s been newly enrolled in a PPO. in commending Tom Richards and the com-
of the economy. ‘But,’ he said, ‘I don’t have Supposedly better than an HMO, she had munity members of Fresno who have worked
much choice unless I get another job, and high expectations. ‘But,’ she told me, ‘I don’t unremittingly to make the opening of Terry’s
that’s not at all easy these days.’ ’’ Chris— understand why it’s so good. First, you pay
Frederick, 7/23/2009
House possible.
more,’ she explained, ‘and second, you still
‘‘Frank’s story centers around his fiancée. get a bill AFTER the co-pay.’ And then she f
She’s a breast cancer survivor. The chemo- told me about the prescription plan, which
therapy, according to Frank, ‘cured the can- THE WALK FOR HEALTHCARE:
requires you to mail away for the medica-
cer but devastated her body. She continues tions and it often takes 4 to 6 weeks for de- HEALTHCARE STORIES FROM IL-
to have health problems,’ he told me. These livery. She shook her head. ‘That just LINOIS AND INDIANA COL-
include diabetes and psoriatic arthritis for doesn’t make sense!’ ’’ Shayla—Gaithersburg, LECTED BY OGAN GUREL, M.D.
which she is treated with methotrexate and 7/25/2009
Enbril injections. She had been getting her
medications through PAC (Physicians As-
‘‘Keith is one of the founders of the ubiq-
uitous Food Not Bombs organization. His or-
HON. DENNIS J. KUCINICH
sistance Care of Maryland) but, as Frank ex- ganization has protested around the world OF OHIO
plained to me, ‘Only the diabetes medicines and now he’s in front of the White House de- IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
qualified and those she got through this pro- livering his message to all those gathered.
gram were less effective than what she was Thursday, January 6, 2011
His story is simple: he’s got fibromyalgia,
previously taking.’ Now that she is working, which he says he acquired after being tor- Mr. KUCINICH. Mr. Speaker, I submit the
she is no longer eligible for the program tured by the CIA during one of his several in- following stories, collected by Dr. Ogan Gurel.
(which requires an income of less than $1,400 carcerations for illegally delivering free
a month). Her new job offers health insur- ‘‘Martha finds it shameful that America
food. With his income and this sort of pre-ex- can’t provide basic health care for its citi-
ance but, ‘the premiums are so high that if
isting condition, he can never get health in- zens, like any other developed country does.
she gets the policy, there’d be no money for
surance.’’ Keith—Washington, 7/26/2009 ‘Civilized nations care for those in need,’ she
anything else.’ Getting health insurance,
‘‘Doris, from New York, is here in DC vis- said. She especially noted that the connec-
would ‘make it impossible for her to live,’
iting. ‘No insurance, can’t afford it.’ She tion of health care insurance to employment
Frank told me. ‘And, even with the policy,
said, ‘and doesn’t ever go to a doctor. I’m status was a big problem. ‘It doesn’t make
the medications would be too expensive. Ba-
otherwise lucky,’ she said, with a smile and sense. If you get sick, you have a greater
sically,’ Frank summarized for me, ‘without
went off with her friends.’’ Doris—Wash- chance of being unemployed.’ ’’ Martha—Chi-
healthcare, she has pain and suffering, can’t
ington, 7/26/2009 cago, 6/27/2009
get out of bed and so could lose the job.’
That’s terrible, I said. ‘Oh, it could be worse f ‘‘Addison, on the right, is Martha’s older
I guess,’ he replied, shaking his head.’’ son. He’s a student in college who, with evi-
Frank—Frederick, 7/23/2009
CELEBRATING THE GRAND dent pride, told me that in the past election
‘‘I met Howard and Tauyna over breakfast OPENING OF TERRY’S HOUSE he had just voted for the first time. As he
at the Days Inn. Howard told me that embarks on study abroad in Italy this com-
they’ve generally been OK, but even with in-
surance, ‘deductibles have been increasing
HON. JIM COSTA ing fall, he is, despite his glowing patriotism,
embarrassed that health care for all, as he
OF CALIFORNIA
and out-of-pocket expenses also going up.’ has learned is the case in Italy, doesn’t exist
But Howard wished to share a story from IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES here in America.’’ Addison—Chicago, 6/27/2009
twenty years ago. ‘It actually relates to Thursday, January 6, 2011 ‘‘I met Ron along Martin Luther King
what’s happening today,’ he told me. He was Drive. He was working at painting a fence.
between jobs, he explained, having left a po- Mr. COSTA. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to He waved his hand towards the south side
sition with health insurance for a higher- recognize Community Regional Medical Cen- streets beyond and said, ‘Yes, there’s many
paying job that did not, however, offer ter on the occasion of the grand opening of people here without health insurance.’ With
health benefits. Soon after, his wife had a Terry’s House, a new, state-of-the-art facility in a serious look, he turned back towards me.
tubal pregnancy and with the hospital bills downtown Fresno, California, which will pro- ‘Yes, without health care.’ He shared a story
he ended up having to taking out a loan for of an old lady from the neighborhood. She
vide much needed support and housing to
$8,000 (‘a huge chunk of change in those had a change in coverage that now made it
days,’ he added). The doctor forgave his fee
allow families to stay close to sick and injured too expensive to get her insulin for her dia-
and he was able to negotiate a half-price loved ones in the hospital. Located in the betes. ‘It was all very fishy business,’ Ron
with the anesthesiologist. ‘I sure don’t know heart of the Fresno medical district, this new told me. This lady, on Medicare, was in the
what would happen if it were today.’ ’’ How- 15,874 square-foot, two-story family house hospital for some time. An insurance sales-
ard—Frederick, 7/24/2009 with twenty guest suites will be the first hospi- man came to her hospital bed and convinced
‘‘Brenda’s story is about her father who tality house in the Greater Fresno Area. her to change her coverage (Ron couldn’t re-
died two months ago. She told her story with This residential facility is named in honor of call the exact name but he told me it sound-
a mix of disbelief and quiet anger though she ed, ‘Something like Well Care’). What hap-
Terry Richards who suffered and survived a
was heartened to be able to share with others pened was that this ‘new’ plan didn’t cover
what she felt was a true health insurance serious trauma at the age of five when he was the old lady’s particular type of insulin so,
horror story. Her late father had diabetes injured in a car accident. For nearly five with her ‘brand-new’ private supplemental
since 1995. His illness was complicated by months, his mother was forced to travel nearly insurance plan in place, she ended up now
neuropathy and multiple foot infections re- 80 miles a day to see her son while he was spending $129 a month, out-of-pocket, for her
sulting in an amputation of one great toe. recovering in the hospital. Currently, family medication. The insurance salesman is gone
Earlier this year, his insurance company, members of patients must seek accommoda- and now she’s struggling, Ron tells me, on
Group Health, told him that they were drop- tions miles from the hospital, and many who top of her fight to stay well, to piece to-
ping him for medical noncompliance al- gether her wrecked insurance and financial
cannot afford lodging sleep in waiting rooms,
though Brenda, who’s a nurse, said this was situation.’’ Ron—Chicago, 6/27/2009
patently a lie and they had medical proof, in- in their cars or try their best to find a spot in ‘‘Stopping by the Chicago Baptist Insti-
cluding doctor’s attestations, that he was in a busy hospital. Often, patients’ loved ones tute, I met Rev. Joseph Felker, the Chair-
compliance. And then he had a stroke, which have no alternative but to leave the hospital man of that organization. A crowd was gath-
was compounded with multiple complica- and make the long drive home. Now families ered and they were hosting an outdoor
tions. He came down with sepsis, had to have have Terry’s House, their home away from event—a ‘Healthy Walk’ event actually. He
pwalker on DSKD5P82C1PROD with REMARKS

another amputation, this time below-the- home, while their loved ones receive care. told me, ‘We should have had health care for
knee. Though the MD said everything was Terry’s House was made possible by the the uninsured years ago. It is a travesty, a
OK, the operation was, in fact, a ‘was a dis- true travesty, but hopefully the change we
tireless work of Terry Richards’ brother, Tom
aster,’ Brenda told me. It turned out he was are seeing is a start.’ ’’ Joseph—Chicago, 6/27/
left unattended in the hallway, coded in re- Richards, a local community developer and 2009
covery, had a head bleed, was given CPR, put CEO of the Penstar Group. With the dedica- ‘‘Sitting next to Rev. Felker was Rev. Dr.
on a ventilator and admitted to the ICU. He tion of Tom Richards, Leta Ciavaglia, the Ter- Tyler. He concurred, saying that, ‘Health
never regained consciousness. He was taken ry’s House Development Council, the Commu- care reform is long overdue. With the wealth

VerDate Mar 15 2010 05:43 Jan 07, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00012 Fmt 0626 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\K06JA8.012 E06JAPT1

You might also like