Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Part 1#
Replacement Theology is the view that because Israel rejected her
Messiah, God has replaced her with the Christian Church & is finished with
Israel. It supposes that the Church is Israel & that only Christians can be called
Israel, because they are called “Spiritual Israel”. For this view to be maintained
certain facts must be ignored. There are also some inherent problems & even
hazards with this view.
Was Jeremiah a prophet to the literal nation of Israel in his day? (Yes / No).
(II) God promised to preserve the generation / race of the Jews (Matthew 24: 32-
35).
The word translated as “generation” can also be translated as “race”
according to the Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible(Greek 1074
derived from 1085). Even in English usage the word Generation has a few different
uses of meaning. A) a whole body of individuals born about the same time (rising
generation); B) The age or average lifetime of a generation in terms of years
(commonly thirty) accepted as the average difference of age between one generation
of a family and the next. One of the other meanings in this same Macquarie
Dictionary (3rd edition) is, “the offspring of a given parent or parents…”.
God promised to preserve the nation of the Jews. It is obvious from the context
of Matthew 24 that all the prophecies of the scriptures have not already been
fulfilled so therefore it would be referring in this instance to the race of the Jews.
(See also Luke 3:7-8; 7:31; 9:41; 11:29;Acts 2:40). Israel will exist also in eternity
& will never pass away. The end of the world is at least after the millennial reign
of Jesus Christ upon the earth.
Qn) IF Israel has been replaced by the church then was it the early church which
he described as not having a heart towards God?
UNSAVED JEWS AS WELL AS UNSAVED GENTILES, NEED THE 2ND
BIRTH! BEING A BLOODLINE JEW / ISRAELITE NEVER MEANT THAT
ONE AUTOMATICALLY WENT TO PARADISE (HEAVEN). A JEW STILL
HAD TO BE SAVED / JUSTIFIED BY FAITH ALONE IN THE MESSIAH WHO
HAD TO COME, JESUS CHRIST OF NAZARETH.
NOW BOTH JEW & GENTILE MUST BE BORN AGAIN BY FAITH IN JESUS
CHRIST ALONE, FOR SALVATION!
(SEE GENESIS 15:6; HABAKKUK 2:4; JOHN 1:10-17; MATTHEW 3:7-10;
LUKE 13:3; ACTS 2:40; ROMANS 3:19-29; 5:1-2).
The Mystery of the Christian church is that Jews & Gentiles are made
fellow heirs in the same body & of the same promise. The fellowship of this
mystery was from the beginning of the world hid in God, who created all things
by Jesus Christ, until, of course after the first advent of our Lord Jesus Christ
(Ephesians 3:1-10). The Church which is built upon the foundation of the
apostles (of the New Testament) as well as the prophets of the Old Testament
(Ephesians 2:20) was only brought into existence during Jesus` earthly ministry
for it wasn’t fully built before then (Matthew 16:18; 18:15-20-21; Ephesians
2:20). Fifty days after the death & resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ, the
church was then empowered on the Day of Pentecost (Acts 2) where more than
just two or three apostles & disciples were gathered all of one accord (Note
Matthew 18:20).
(V) “For what if some did not believe? shall their unbelief make the faith of God
without effect?” –Romans 3:3.
The Jews were called to be a light to the Gentiles but they continually failed. In
Romans 3:1-3, the apostle Paul who was writing to the Christians in Rome spoke
of the Jews (in the present tense) as having advantage over the Gentiles because
it was unto them that the oracles of God were firstly given. Paul also said that the
unbelief of some (or even many) of the Jews shall never make our Christian
faith, the Faith of God, without effect!
(VI) In Romans 9:1-5, Paul was writing to the Christians. In explaining his deep
love for his kinsmen “according to the flesh” whom he called “Israelites” and he
wished himself accursed (unsaved) instead of them.
Qn) If a person is accursed, it means that they are under God’s wrath /
judgement. Is the church accursed, or is it that Paul is saying that unbelievers
are under God’s wrath? (Note: John 3:18, 36; Romans 2:8-12; Galatians 1:6-9).
Would this mean, according to the CONTEXT in Romans 9 that the ones who do
not believe the Gospel are accursed & are they unbelieving Jews?
(VII) The Church of Christ (Christians) are not the ones who are ignorant of
God’s righteousness & going about trying to establish their own righteousness. It
is the unbelieving Jews as is pointed out in Romans 10:1-4.
(VIII) God would use those who are of a different nation to provoke the Jews to
anger & Jealousy (Romans 10:17-21).
Is it Israel or the Christian church that would get provoked?
(IX) According to Romans 11:1-6, Paul who was writing to the church said that
God hath NOT cast away his people which He foreknew?
• Was Israel blinded or was it the church? Who are the Elect?
(X) According to Romans 11:25-29 it is Israel who is blind, and it is Israel in her
unsaved state that are enemies (opposed) to the Gospel … BUT they still ARE
BELOVED for the fathers` sakes.
(XI) Replacement Theology also ignores the fact that the New Testament refers
to 3 literal groups of people, now existing at the same time even till this day.
These three groups are: Unsaved Jews, Unsaved Gentiles, & the Church of God
(which is made up of saved Jews & Gentiles). This is also very clearly pointed out
in 1Corinthians 10:13.
“Give none offence, neither to the Jews, nor to the Gentiles, nor to
the church of God:..” -1Corinthians 10:32.
(XII) The Church was a mystery hidden to those living in Old Testament times
(Ephesians 3:1-9).
Israel was the nation chosen by God to be a light to the Gentiles, so that (like
Abraham) the Gentiles would also turn away from their vain idols & their own way,
& turn unto the True God, Yahweh the God of Israel.
(XIII) There are other distinctions that exist between Israel & the Church that
clearly make it impossible to identify the church as Israel & having replaced
Israel. The church can be called spiritual Israel but it has not taken the place of
Literal Israel. Listed in the comparative table below & on the next page are some
examples of these other distinctions.
(viii) The Death of Christ Guilty Nation -to be saved Perfectly saved by it
by it. NOW.
(x) Governing Principle Mosaic Law System GRACE, The law of the
Spirit of Life In Christ
Jesus.
These clear contrasts, which show the distinction between Israel & the Church,
make it impossible to identify the church as the (only) Israel or having replaced
the literal nation of Israel.
Those who espouse any type of Post tribulation rapture / rescue theory for the
church, must identify the church as Israel & having replaced the old nation of
Israel, in order to maintain that the church goes through the 70th week (the
Tribulation Period / the time of Jacob’s trouble mentioned in Jeremiah 30:4-7).
ALSO
This Roman Catholic website in October 2005 taught that the rapture of the
Christians is a false doctrine invented in the 1800`s by John Nelson Darby. (See
below).
Why is it so that the Roman Catholic theologians believe & teach that this is the
case?
It is because they teach that Israel has been replaced by their `church` & that the
`Church` as they understand it must go through her final trial. They believe that
after the seven year tribulation period … only then, will the `church` be
delivered / rescued at the 2nd Advent of Jesus Christ. You will find this
information in St Paul’s Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Article 672 in the second sentence says, “According to the Lord, the present time
is the time of the Spirit and witness, but also a time still marked by “distress”
and the trial of evil which does not spare the church & ushers in the struggles of
the last days.
days. It’s a time of waiting and watching.”
Article 676 says, “The Antichrist’s deception already begins to take shape in the
world every time the claim is made to realize within history that messianic hope
which can only be realized beyond history through the eschatological judgement.
The church has rejected even modified forms of this falsification of the kingdom to
come under the name of millenarianism,
millenarianism, especially the “intrinsically perverse”
political form of a secular messianism.” (Note also Articles 677 & 769).
The Bible says that God takes the wise in their own craftiness
“He
“He taketh the wise in their own craftiness: and the counsel of the froward is
carried headlong.” –Job 5:13.
I`VE CUT & PASTED IT ONTO THE NEXT PAGE (There’s not enough space
on this one) …
Please read this whole quote, straight from the horses` mouth …
The question I wish to ask is, “IF the pre- tribulation rapture view of
eschatology has only been around for less than 250 years THEN how
could it have been condemned by the Roman Catholic hierarchy in
431 A.D. at the Counsel of Ephesus as “a deviation & a fable”& then
denounced again in 1516 at the 5th Lateran Council?
The first emperor of the “Holy” Roman Empire was Otto I, crowned in 962 A.D.
The last was Francis II, who abdicated and dissolved the Empire in 1806 A.D
during the Napoleonic Wars. It was officially known as the Holy Roman Empire
of the German Nation.
When Zionist leader Theodore Herzl met with Pope Pius X in January
1904 he asked the Roman Church to alleviate the suffering of European
Jews & to support Jewish aspirations for a return to their traditional
homeland in Israel. The pope was blunt in his reply saying, "The Jews
have not recognised our Lord, therefore we cannot recognise the
Jewish people."
http://www.christianhistorytimeline.com/DAILYF/2001/12/daily-12-30-2001.shtml
Documents discovered by Jewish groups show that at the height of World War II
Pope Pius XII warned against making Palestine a homeland for the
«Hebrew race» and had no complaints about the Nazi occupation of Rome.
Hier said it was clear the Vatican did not want the rescue of the Slovakian Jew-
ish children to be considered an endorsement of Zionism, and he added:
«The pope made a pronouncement against a helpless people at the height of the
Holocaust. If only he had written Hitler a private letter attacking his
policies against Jews. I am outraged that he did nothing of the kind»
Below, is part of the content of a Papal letter to his Bishops and priests in «The
Holy land of Palestine».Redemptoris Nostri Crucitatus
“Encyclical of Pope Pius XII, on the Holy Places in Palestine. To the venerable
Brethren, the patriarchs, primates archbishops, Bishops and other Ordinaries.
9. We have never ceased to pray repeatedly for this enduring and genuine peace. And
to the end that it might be brought to fruition and permanence at
the earliest possible moment, We have already insisted in Our Encyclical letter In
Multiplicibus, that the time has come when Jerusalem and its vicinity,
where the previous memorials of the Life and Death of the Divine Redeemer are pre-
served, should be accorded and legally guaranteed an “international” status, which in
the present circumstances seems to offer the best and most satisfactory protection for
these sacred monuments.”
12. Not a few of these places have suffered serious loss and damage owing to the up-
heaval and devastation of the war. Since they are religious memorials of such moment
– objects of veneration to the whole world and an incentive and support to Christian
piety – these places should also be suitably protected by definite statute guaranteed by
an “international” agreement.”
Given at Rome, St. Peter’s the fifteenth day of the month of April, Good Friday, in the
year 1949, the eleventh of Our Pontificate.
See this Link to the 1949-document on the official web site of the Vatican:
http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_xii/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-
xii_enc_15041949_redemptoris-nostri-cruciatus_en.html
The present pope at the tomb of Pius XII,
praying and pushing for his sainthood.
Adolf Hitler wanted to create the third «Holy Roman Empire». Like the Messian-
ic age that is going to last for 1000 years, the Nazi-leader promoted an empire that
was going to last for 1000 years.
“Gott Mit Uns” is German for “God with us.” Hitler was a very religious man. He
thought that He was the saviour of human race. That’s why he wrote «Gott mit uns»
on the belt of his soldiers (Photo of belt buckle on the right). Hitler in his delusions of
grandeur saw that there was only one problem in the pipeline, hindering his dream
that he had to deal with and that was the Jews. Hitler was convinced that he did a
good thing for God by killing Jews. Just like Hamas does today. This is a fulfilment of
what Jesus warned His disciples about in John 16:1-4.
“These things have I spoken unto you, that ye should not be offended.
They shall put you out of the synagogues: yea, the time cometh, that whosoever killeth you will think
that he doeth God service.
And these things will they do unto you, because they have not known the Father, nor me. {16:4} But
these things have I told you, that when the time shall come, ye may remember that I told you of them.
And these things I said not unto you at the beginning, because I was with you.”
-John 16:1-4.
Adolph Hitler said, "I am personally convinced of the great power and deep significance of Chris-
tianity, and I won't allow any other religion to be promoted. That is why I have turned away from
Ludendorff and that is why I reject that book by Rosenberg. It was written by a Protestant. It is not a
Party book. It was not written by him as a Party man. The Protestants can be left to argue with
him ...As a Catholic I never feel comfortable in the Evangelical Church or its structures. That is
why I will have great difficulty if I try to regulate affairs of the Protestant churches. The evangel-
ical people or the Protestants will in any case reject me. But you can be sure: I will protect the rights
and freedoms of the churches and not let them be touched, so that you need have no fears about the fu-
ture of the Church."
*Hitler was born of Roman Catholic parents, Klara Hitler, born Klara Polzl
(August 12th 1860 – December 21st 1907) & Alois Hitler [his father, born Alois
Schickgruber (June 7th 1837 – January 3rd 1903).
They were devout Roman Catholics & received Roman Catholic burials on
Roman Church property. To Adolph Hitler “Christianity” was Roman
Catholicism as was taught to him. He served Pius XII very faithfully.
*During the holocaust, additional papal decrees forbade Jews, non Catholics &
true Christians from owning real estate, selling new goods, or living with or near
Roman Catholics. (This was also enforced in Jerusalem during the Crusades).
The three big defenders of the Roman Catholic faith were Hitler, Mussolini, and
Franco. All three had concordats with the Vatican. When the Nazi war machine
swept through the Balkans on the way to attack Russia, Yugoslavia had become
a Nazi occupied country.
The Nazi party's insignia, the Swastika originated from India, but was adopted
by those within the Jesuit order. The Swastika is also used as a Masonic symbol.
To pay off the Vatican, Mussolini (of Italy) signed a Concordat * making Roman
Catholicism the only religion allowed in Italy & its territories. Mussolini
re-established the `temporal power` of the `Pope` & gave the clergy complete
power over the life of that nation. Italy became a major power under their
Catholic fascist dictator, Mussolini.
(See – The Secret History of the Jesuits – by Edmond Paris, page 126).
Like Italy, Germany signed a concordat with the Vatican in Rome, 1933.
Signing the concordat is Cardinal Pacelli (later to become Pope Pius XII). By 1933 he
was the Vatican Secretary of State. Second from left is Franz von Papen, a sinister
Nazi and devout Roman Catholic who was Hitler's ace diplomat and the Vatican's
agent in helping to bring Hitler to power. Standing at the far right can be seen the
little-known Vatican prelate, Montini, later to become Pope Paul VI.
From a poster
proclaiming Nazi –
papist solidarity.
All of these associates including Pacelli, the man who later became Pius the 12th,
had some Jewish blood in their veins but were not Jewish in faith. Hitler & his
associates all had one thing in common – They were all Roman Catholics. (Secret
History of the Jesuits -by Edmond Paris, page 128). When it became known that
`Pope` Pius XI supported Hitler, the Roman Catholic vote swept Hitler into
power in 1933. The world then faced a terrible machine called the Third Reich,
in which the Vatican would become the masters.
Of course after years of trying to sweep all evidence under the carpet, the
Vatican tries to blame the holocaust on those within the Roman Catholic system.
Yet it was implemented by the hierarchy of the Vatican (and her henchmen)
which are NOT real Christians, according to Jesus ` own words in John 16:1-3.