Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/seppur
Received 9 March 2001; received in revised form 15 August 2001; accepted 22 August 2001
Abstract
Adsorption capacity and bioactivity of a novel mesoporous activated carbon (IIT Carbon) and bioactive (BACIIT)
catalyst produced from papermill sludge were evaluated. Conversion of paper mill sludge to useful activated carbons
and biocatalysts is a significant process since it reduces environmental problems associated with disposal of waste
sludge, enhances wastewater treatment using carbons produced from industrial waste itself, and promotes conserva-
tion of the naturally available primary resources currently used to make activated carbons. Analysis was conducted
using synthetic wastewater containing phenol and a commercially available activated carbon, sorbonorite 4 (used as
reference carbon). Phenol removal was accomplished in batch and fluidized bed reactors containing mesoporous
activated carbon, sorbonorite 4, and the produced bioactive catalysts. Isotherm adsorption data indicated that
mesoporous activated carbon has a higher adsorption capacity and molecular surface coverage than sorbonorite 4 for
phenol concentrations less than 10 mg/l. The mass transfer limitation was accounted for the lower adsorption capacity
of the microporous carbon (sorbonorite 4) in dilute solutions. The fluidized bed reactor study, however, indicated
similar but slightly lower phenol removal capability for the produced mesoporous carbon. While phenol removal
efficiency of the carbons studied was in the range 65–70%, the produced bioactive catalysts were able to remove up
to 97% of phenol during first few hours of operation. These results suggest that mesoporous carbon will feasibly be
a good substitute for other commercially available activated carbons produced from natural resources, not only in
physical adsorption processes, but also in fluidized bed bioreactors (FBB), used in biodegradation processes. © 2002
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
1383-5866/02/$ - see front matter © 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 1 3 8 3 - 5 8 6 6 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 1 8 4 - 8
296 N.R. Khalili et al. / Separation/Purification Technology 26 (2002) 295–304
carbon is known to be a superior adsorbent and on the surface of the carbon, reactor and process
catalytic support because of its excellent surface configuration (flow rate, temperature, pH), and
properties, i.e. large surface area, porous structure finally, AC and pollutant characteristics [10–14].
and high degree of surface reactivity. Recent stud- For example, the productivity of a continuous
ies have shown that ACs can be used successfully culture can be increased if the system utilizes a
in solvent recovery, gas refining, air purification, biofilm instead of freely suspended microbial cells.
exhaust desulfurization and deodorization pro- Furthermore, a biofilm is more stable to varia-
cesses [1–4]. tions in flow rate and to sudden concentration
In the early seventies, some studies reported increases of toxic substances. Fan et al. [10]
that proliferated bacteria in AC filters could be showed that in FBB reactors used to remove
responsible for the extended removal of organics phenol from wastewater, phenol does not adsorb
from wastewater. Therefore, it was suggested that on the biofilm, but rather diffuses through the
biological elimination of dissolved organic com- biofilm. The estimated diffusion coefficient of
pounds within activated carbon particles could phenol within the biofilm was reported to vary
enhance the extent of organic removal by simple between 13 and 39%, based on the configuration
adsorption process [5– 7]. of the system. It was also shown that the perfor-
The mechanics of organic removal by biodegra- mance of the FBB system relies significantly on
dation-adsorption processes on activated carbon factors such as bacterial accessibility for biodegra-
was further investigated using fixed and fluidized dation, specific biofilm characteristics, system
bed bioreactors (FBB) [8– 11]. The recent review configuration, organic loading, and flow rate. The
by Sutton and Mishra [8] showed that over 80 ratio of biofilm surface area to culture volume has
commercial media-based FBBs have been in- been successfully demonstrated to affect the phe-
stalled in North America and Europe. Due to the nol reduction capacity of a solid support medium
environmental importance of this application, a using a continuous culture of Pseudomonas putida
variety of organizations such as US EPA, na- (ATCC 11172) [15,16].
tional laboratories and non-profit research institu- To promote adhesion and biofilm formation by
tions have extensively focused on research and Pseudomonas putida, a suspended carrier should
development activities involving AC-based FBB be used in the bioreactors. In FBBs, however,
systems. The single largest commercial application surfaces are subjected to different shear levels,
for these is the aerobic treatment of groundwater therefore, according to the specific carbon surface
contaminated with petroleum hydrocarbons. properties, the extent of biofilm formation could
These studies have shown that fluidized bed vary significantly with the characteristics of the
reactors are very efficient in terms of volumetric suspended carrier, e.g. activated carbon particles.
degradation capacity. Tang et al. [9,12] demon- Most of the activated carbons used in the FBBs
strated the efficient use of the three-phase are microporous carbons, which are made from
fluidized bed bioreactor in the organic (phenol) bituminous coal, coconut shell, wood, coal,
removal process. Their study also showed that petroleum, lignin, and lignite. In recent years the
although the adsorptive capacity of ACs could possibility of using bio-solids for the production
decrease with repeated usage in FBB systems, of activated carbons has been explored. Jeya-
these systems are still preferable over simple ad- seelan et al. [17], Lu [18] and Martin et al. [19]
sorption processes because the thermal regenera- have all begun to identify processes by which
tion of activated carbons in conventional bio-solids can be transformed to AC. Our recent
adsorption systems is very costly. work showed that carbonaceous waste material
The performance of the FBBs can be signifi- can be economically and efficiently converted to
cantly influenced by the characteristics and extent ACs with specifically engineered surface proper-
of biofilm formation, mass transport coefficients ties [20,21]. Accordingly, by controlling the
and diffusion of oxygen and pollutants across the method of production, it became possible to pro-
biofilm, characteristics of the biofilm developed duce pure, mesoporous (80% meso and macropo-
N.R. Khalili et al. / Separation/Purification Technology 26 (2002) 295–304 297
rous structure) activated carbon from paper mill tor, (4) analysis of the adsorption capability of the
sludge with surface area as high as 1020– 1700 produced carbons, and (5) determination of the
m2/g. Paper mill sludge was selected for the pro- kinetics of adsorption and biodegradation for the
duction of activated carbon instead of biosolids produced carbon. The reference carbon, Sor-
since this waste has shown less level of contami- bonorite 4, is a commercially available carbon,
nants and more uniform chemical composition. which is produced from coal.
The main purpose of this study was to investi-
gate if the cost-effective carbon synthesized from 2.1. Production of a pure, mesoporous acti6ated
paper mill sludge can produce results comparable carbon from paper mill sludge
(for removal of organics from contaminated wa-
ters) to those obtained for the most commonly A pure, mesoporous activated carbon was pro-
used carbon based sorbents (such as Sorbonorite duced following the procedure developed by Wal-
4), and if the unique surface properties of the hof [20] and Khalili et al. [21]. The main steps in
produced carbons offer an economically attractive the process for carbon production are presented
support system for the formation of the biofilm in in Fig. 1. The paper mill sludge was the final
FBBs. The synthesized carbons were, therefore, sludge produced at wastewater treatment facility
used as adsorbent and bio-carriers in laboratory and milling processes. The chemical analysis indi-
scale FBBs, and the extent of phenol removal for cated that sludge contains 20% ash, 34% C, 5% H,
a synthetic wastewater was investigated on a bi- 0.24% S, and 41% O2 with C/H ratio of 6.74.
ofilm of Pseudomonas putida formed on the sur- Following the outlined procedure, the raw ma-
face of the produced activated carbon (IIT terial (sludge) was first dried in an oven at 110 °C
carbon) and sorbonorite 4 (reference carbon). The for 24 h, then crushed mechanically using a roller
surface characteristics and adsorption properties mill. Crushing provided smaller particles with in-
of the carbons were determined in addition to creased surface area and also enabled more effi-
identifying the comparative effectiveness of these cient chemical activation of the raw material.
carbons for biodegradation of phenol. Samples were sieved after mechanical crushing to
Conversion of waste sludge to carbon-based obtain a particle size smaller than 600 mm. This
catalyst is a novel and environmentally friendly particle size range was found to be the most
process. It results in production of effective and suitable for the chemical activation process.
cost-efficient catalyst (due to negative cost associ-
ated with the raw material) from waste, and offers 2.1.1. Chemical acti6ation
significant potential for reducing the cost of In the chemical activation process, the dried
sludge treatment, which is commonly required material was impregnated with zinc chloride using
prior to its disposal. The environmental damage a ZnCl2 to sludge mass ratio of 3.5. About 100 ml
that could result from uncontrolled disposal of of H2O was mixed with 17 g of dried, crushed
the waste can also be minimized by converting and sieved sludge and a sufficient amount of
sludge to other useful products. ZnCl2 to maintain the specified ZnCl2 to sludge
ratio. The slurry was mixed with a magnetic stir-
rer at 85 °C for 8 h. Upon drying, the activated/
2. Materials and methods dried sludge was crushed again into a fine powder
and exposed to light and humidity for 22 h.
The experimental section consisted of (1) pro- Activation results in the production of activated
duction of activated carbon with a pre-defined carbons with an enhanced surface area. The
surface structure from paper mill sludge, (2) aforementioned steps promote uniform carboniza-
preparation of the culture and medium required tion reactions during the pyrolysis.
for the biodegradation study, (3) production of
active biocatalyst (culture growth within the car- 2.1.2. Pyrolysis
bon structure) using a specially designed bioreac- The dried, chemically activated, and light and
298 N.R. Khalili et al. / Separation/Purification Technology 26 (2002) 295–304
humidity treated sludge was placed into a quartz 2.2. Preparation of the culture medium
reactor. The pyrolysis was carried out under a
flow of nitrogen gas (70 ml/min) at 800 °C for 2 The microbial species used in this study was
h. The temperature was reached at a rate of Pseudomonas putida (c1172). This aerobic bac-
approximately 20 °C per min. Nitrogen gas was terium is often used for bioremediation because of
used to provide an inert atmosphere and to carry its ability to consume phenol. This culture was
volatile matter away from the heating zone. Upon obtained from American Type Culture Collection
completion of the pyrolysis, sample was removed (ATCC 11172). The freeze-dried culture was used
from the reactor and crushed using mortar and to prepare three different types of cultures: long
pestle. term stock culture, frozen culture to be used every
month, and culture for inoculation and produc-
tion of biocatalysts.
2.1.3. Rinsing
The cell suspensions were prepared as follows.
After pyrolysis, the carbonized material was
Commercially available freeze-dried stock culture
washed with 500 ml of 1.2 M HCl, followed by
stored at − 70 °C with glycerol was inoculated in
washing with 500 ml of distilled water to extract
a sterile Nutrient Broth (NB, 15:85) and incu-
residual organic and mineral materials. The pro-
bated at 25 °C for 24 h. One portion of this
duced activated carbon was then placed in a
solution was stored at − 70 °C and a second
drying oven for 8–12 h (110 °C). After drying,
portion of the solution was transferred to nutrient
the sample was transferred to a 20 ml vial for agar (NA, Difco) at 25 °C. The 3-day-old
storage. To produce pure activated carbon colonies of P. putida on agar were used to inocu-
without any mineral substrate, the produced car- late 10 ml of IPM solution in a baffled flask (the
bon was treated with hydrofluoric acid (HF) for 1 IPM solution composition is provided in Table 1).
h, filtered, and then rinsed with distilled water Resulting suspension was held at 25 °C for 16– 24
until a pH between 6 and 7 was achieved in h, and 1 ml of this primary culture was trans-
washwater. The produced activated carbon was ferred to 20 ml IPM solution and mixed for 16 h
dried and stored in 20 ml vials prior to surface at 25 °C for the inoculation of the bioactive
analysis. carbons.
Fig. 1. Steps involved with the production of activated carbon from paper mill sludge.
N.R. Khalili et al. / Separation/Purification Technology 26 (2002) 295–304 299
Table 2
Surface properties of the activated carbons
Surface area Total pore Micro- Meso- Micro-pore Meso-pore Average pore
(m2/g) volume porous porous surface area surface area radius (A, )
(cm3/g) structure (%) structure (%) (m2/g) (m2/g)
carbon, and C0 and Ce are the initial and equi- By using the chemical bond lengths and molec-
librium concentrations of phenol. The estimates ular structure of the phenol molecule, the actual
of K and 1/n are presented in Table 3. These data dimensions of the surface covered by one phenol
suggest that carbon produced at IIT has a higher molecule and number of activated carbon rings
capacity (K values in Table 3) for adsorption of covered by each phenol molecule were estimated
phenol and stronger affinity (1/n) for phenol than in this study. The area of each activated carbon
sorbonorite 4. The IIT carbon also shows far aromatic ring was found to be 5.25× 10 − 20 m2.
better performance than sorbonorite 4 at low The activated carbon pore area occupied by one
phenol concentration (Ce less than 10 mg/l). The mole of phenol was found to be 3×105 m2
higher adsorption capacity of the IIT carbon was [5.25× 10 − 20 × 9.5× 6.02× 1023 (Avogadro’s
related to its mesoporous structure and access-
number)].
ibility of the pores to the adsorbate (meso-
Assuming that the adsorbed molecules form no
porous structure enhances diffusion– adsorption
more than a monolayer of coverage, the mass-
processes).
based solid concentration of phenol was then
3.3. Estimation of the surface co6erage converted to a new parameter, surface coverage,
parameters S, using Eq. (2).
4. Conclusion