Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COMPASS
Leading the way for liberty in Illinois.
Flip this
state!
A Liberty Agenda for Illinois
ALSO INSIDE:
The Surprising Truth About
School Choice
Fall 2008
From the CEO
11 Political Radar: To Con-Con or Not We aim to provide a consistent, interesting, and persuasive road
To Con-Con map that leads toward liberty—and, ultimately, a better Illinois
for all citizens. At the Illinois Policy Institute, our focus is to
12 Transparency Update & Institute in transform the principles of liberty into marketable public policies
the News
that become law.
2 COMPASS
front of the book
Flip this State!
ILLINOIS: FALLING BEHIND The Illinois Policy Institute presents an
Illinois may not be faring as well as you agenda to make our state a better place
think. When compared with the other to live and work for all citizens.
50 states, Illinois ranks:
Illinois is competing with 49 other states–as well as
with the rest of the world–for entrepreneurs, investors,
48th in economic performance businesses and workers. It is losing this competition
42nd in economic outlook badly, and the impact can be felt by all Illinois
47th in employment growth residents.
3rd highest in outward migration Study after study, including the recent “Rich States,
Highest in sales tax burden Poor States” by the American Legislative Exchange
4th highest in gas tax burden Council, documents that Illinois has quietly entered
the beginning stages of a downward economic spiral.
7th highest in median property taxes These serious economic warning signs echo the
early economic doldrums of our neighboring state,
Michigan, and are rooted in state policies that are all
too often geared against businesses
and families.
What does a LIBERTY AGENDA look like?
That’s the bad news. The good news
A few sample policies from our “Liberty Agenda for Illinois:” is that the Illinois Policy Institute,
together with our partners across
• Eliminate the Illinois cap on charter schools; the state, is working for better public
• Expand the state’s educational tax credit; policy for a better Illinois. And by
“working,” we don’t just mean thinking
• Open the Illinois insurance market to all fifty states; and writing. Our goal is to promote
liberty-based public policy so that it
• Increase government transparency... can become law in the state of Illinois.
...and more! See page 7 for more details, or visit our website to
download the full Liberty Agenda policy brief. This fall, we’ve unveiled our Liberty
Agenda for Illinois, a set of
innovative, non-partisan policies
that will kickstart the process of making Illinois a
better place for businesses, families, and citizens from
all walks of life. These are
practical, achievable strategies–
and we believe that they’re also
Want the inside winning strategies. To check
scoop? Sign up for out the full Liberty Agenda,
our e-letter today! visit our website at
Log on to www.illinoispolicyinstitute.org.
www.illinoispolicyinstitute.org.
Over the next year, we’ll be
developing and promoting
more of these policies. Stay tuned for more updates on
our emerging Liberty Agenda. Together, we can work
for a better, more prosperous Illinois.
COMPASS 3
policy in action
Let the sunshine in
6 COMPASS
to college. I remember sitting across from that banker government review back to the people. With greater
who told my mother, “Janet, your children will never transparency, bad officials will start to self-censure,
go to college because you will not have the money.” knowing that all their activities go online. Meanwhile,
Well, her seven children have eleven college degrees, good people will not cave into temptations.
my brother graduated from Harvard Law School, and
eventually, my brother and I started a company–Amer- I titled my transparency effort the “Open Book
ican Marketing & Publishing–which employs over 200 Revolution,” and it must be built person by person,
people. from community to community. I have focused on
school districts as the government unit that will be most
Campaigne: What was one of your first experiences responsive to transparency–and momentum to change
promoting liberty and/or transparency? What drove Illinois is building within our education establishment.
you to act?
Campaigne: What successes have you had with the
Andrzejewski: While I ran my company, I kept my “Open Book Revolution?”
head down and wanted to be left alone. After my
brother bought out my share, however, I started to Andrzejewski: Our first set of transparency victories
explore the function and results of our state. What I occurred in rapid succession. In a significant victory
found was disheartening: Illinois is underperforming on for DuPage County taxpayers, the College of DuPage,
almost all of the challenges we face. the Midwest’s largest single campus community college
with a budget of $238 million, passed the “Open
I felt I had an obligation to let Illinois citizens know Book Test.” Working with Trustee David Carlin, the
what I had found. Last fall, I made a commercial of college posted its
the “Inconvenient Illinois Facts” and ran it on Fox, check registry within
CNN, MSNBC and the Discovery Channel. That is 12 hours of board
when I met John Tillman, CEO of the Illinois Policy approval. Over the
Institute. We are both committed to an exceptional next 2 weeks, the
Illinois. Elmhurst school
district posted, and
Campaigne: Why do you think citizen action at the my home district of
local level is important? If someone wants to get Herscher voted for
involved, what do you suggest they do first? transparency as well. We’ve had many other districts
commit, so watch for frequent announcements.
Adam, who Andrzejewski: Throughout ForTheGoodOfIllinois.org, home of the Illinois School
American history, a few District Honor Roll, showcases those transparent
is part of the districts. Already, we have highlighted twelve school
committed citizens have
Institute’s always been the catalysts for districts representing more than $1 billion in education
Liberty Leaders change. I suggest adopting spending on our Honor Roll.
program, has the philosophy of “Not
helped to make On My Watch!” and doing Campaigne: What have you enjoyed about working
something now, starting with the Illinois Policy Institute as a Liberty Leader?
$367 million of
where you are. One way
taxpayer money Andrzejewski: The Illinois Policy Institute not only
to get started is to join
transparent. our effort to make school possesses the raw brainpower, but also the will to
districts more transparent to achieve tangible results. I have always believed actions
taxpayers. Ask your local school district to become open speak louder than words, so our relationship has been
and transparent by posting its check register online. very strong. From history, my favorite sculpture is The
The proposal is costless, takes less than ten minutes to Thinker by Rodin. The man is deep in thought, but
do, and allows us to see how our tax dollars are being certainly a muscled man of action. In my opinion,
spent. Online transparency shows simple respect to leadership is best executed by a well thought-through
the taxpayer. ForTheGoodOfIllinois.org and the Illinois strategy, followed by action, and henceforth results. The
Policy Institute provide a simple road map to do this. people at Illinois Policy Institute are not only very
smart, but also have that critical action orientation.
Campaigne: What are your thoughts about
transparency in government? Since I have my own 501(c)4 organization,
ForTheGoodOfIllinois.org, the relationship I enjoy
Andrzejewski: Transparency returns the power of with Illinois Policy Institute has been one of maximized
Continued on back cover
COMPASS 5
movers and shakers
School choice luncheon
“It’s Not Just About Saving Money…It’s About Saving Lives.”
On June 11th, the Illinois Policy Institute held its first
luncheon dedicated to school choice, which gathered
a sell-out crowd of over 72 attendees to discuss better
educational options for the children of Illinois.
6 COMPASS
policy update
INSTITUTE IN FOCUS:
SCHOOL CHOICE
. This
. year, the Institute has focused
extensively on school choice, covering a
variety of policies—including education
tax credits (raising the Illinois tax credit Announcing the Liberty Agenda
to $4000, our education specialist Collin
In August, the Illinois state GOP released an
Hitt argues, would actually save the state
“Agenda for Action,” prescribing policies
billions of dollars) and charter schools
including a government “jobs” program (via a
(including our efforts to lift Illinois’s
$25 billion construction bill), more education
arbitrary cap on the number of charters,
spending (above the current record levels),
which was endorsed and featured in the
mandatory Internet monitoring of social
August 22 Chicago Tribune).
networking sites, and more proposals that
can only be described as “Liberal Lite.” Our
Next up: the release of several educational
response? The Liberty Agenda for Illinois.
primers on the impact of privatization on
The Liberty Agenda offers context on our state’s
public schools, together with an emerging
economic decline, provides an overarching
media series on the impact of charter
theme of making Illinois a better place for
schools on Illinois families. Stay tuned!
business, families, and all citizens, and then lays
out proposals that, if put into law, would place
Illinois among the most economically competitive
states—instead of our current ranking, which is
Health Care: Mandate Mania in the bottom ten.
Keeping Us Safe…
From Ugly Wallpaper
By Paul S. Detlefs
License to kill...businesses? Illinois’s safety, and welfare.” I don’t know about you,
but I’m not living in fear of a renegade interior
state regulations for professionals designer who recommends the wrong color
like barbers and interior designers for my bathroom or a landscape architect who
squelch opportunities on many levels. selects the wrong plantings for my garden. In
prior times, barbers used to perform surgery,
bloodletting and extract teeth. They haven’t done
The last time you got a haircut or did some most of these things since the 18th century.
redecorating, did you check to make sure your But they have been regulated by Illinois since
barber or interior designer was properly licensed 1917.
by the State of Illinois?
“Rent-Seeking” and Economic Theory
No? If not, how do you know it was safe to see If not to protect the public, why do these
them? regulations exist? Over 35 years ago, George
Stigler, a Nobel-winning University of Chicago
Never fear. Our state’s political class is dedicated economist, explained why. Interest groups often
to keeping us safe from the dangers of rogue band together, lobbying the government to
barbers or interior designers—all to the tune shape laws and
of around $112 million a year. The Illinois regulations that
Department of Financial and Professional benefit them—a
Regulation (IDFPR), which is projected to process also
employ 800 staff members in 2009, exists “to known as “rent
protect consumers of financial and professional seeking.” These
services by ensuring the integrity and standards regulations
of regulated industries and professionals.” Today, create barriers to ...and so must landscapers
around 219 different professions are regulated entry, allowing these
and nearly 1,000,000 individuals and firms are groups to charge rates above those that would
licensed in Illinois. come with free competition.
Certainly, some professions need licensing—we Consumers and potential competition, ultimately,
don’t want just anyone performing surgery or pay the price—but they also have little incentive
designing bridges. to fight these regulations, since the cost of
Less clear, fighting them far exceeds the benefit for any
however, is the individual.
need for licensing
of barbers, Stigler’s theory, also known as “regulatory
manicurists, capture,” is easy to see in practice in Illinois.
cosmetologists, Professions routinely lobby for practice legislation
Barbers must have certification...
interior designers, (what one is allowed to do), titling legislation
landscape (what one is allowed to call him/herself ), and
architects, shorthand reporters, home inspectors, other barriers to entry. Legislators, meanwhile,
geologists, and auctioneers. typically go along with the “status quo” for fear
of political reprisal. Illinois’s Regulatory Sunset
State regulation laws nearly all begin with lofty Act, which allows professional regulation only
language regarding protecting the “public health, Continued on next page
8 COMPASS
to protect the public from “significant and
discernable harm or damage,” sets dates for the
“sunset” of professional regulation, but these dates An Action Plan
are routinely extended. Regulation of a profession
like interior design—whose regulation was
recently extended to 2012—is rarely ended, given
for Illinois
that the “boards” which advise on regulation are Illinois legislators and regulators need to take
made up almost exclusively of licensed members real action to reduce unnecessary professional
of the profession. regulation, which ends up hurting consumers,
potential business owners, and, most of all,
the poor and disadvantaged. Here are some
Many of these regulations fall especially hard
potential steps they could take:
on the poor and disadvantaged, who often lack
the resources to meet the set standards. The • Use the Regulatory Sunset Act that is already
Institute for Justice (www.ij.org), a non-profit on the books
public interest legal organization, has successfully
litigated cases to strike down regulation of • Require hard, objective evidence of “significant
activities in other states including African hair and discernable harm or damage” to the public
braiding (requiring a cosmetology license) and the to justify regulation
sale of caskets (could only be sold by a licensed
funeral home). Here in Illinois, however, many • Eliminate the practice of routinely extending
restrictive regulations still stand. sunset dates
Paul Detlefs, an IPI Liberty Leader, has lived in Glenview, Illinois for over 25 years, and has been
a consultant and advisor to small businesses in Illinois for over 30 years. He has an undergraduate
degree in economics from DePauw University and an MBA from the University of Chicago.
COMPASS 9
liberty leader profile
Gus Makris
By Richard Lorenc
Like the other forty-seven Liberty Leaders recruited
Liberty Leader Gus Makris of Chicago isn’t new to since May, Makris has varied political interests. Among
the ideas of liberty and limited government. In fact, as his top interests is school choice. “We would have never
a newly-minted lawyer specializing in tax law, Makris accepted the setup of the government school system for
is keenly aware of the issues that impact prosperity and anything else,” says Makris. “Imagine being told where
freedom. to shop for groceries, for instance. We like to have the
choice of where and what to buy.”
However, he only recently found a way to translate his
principles into action. “I was of the sort who was happy Makris believes that moving education reform forward
to sit at home and read a book,” says Makris. “But is simply a matter of good communication. “When
there’s no substitute to making something happen.” building a political movement, it’s easiest to convince
people that your position is one that they already agree
Searching for a way to get involved, with,” he says.
Makris e-mailed the author of an article “When building
on RealClearPolitics.com and asked for a political So, with Liberty Leaders popping up
some advice. The response pointed him in movement, statewide and citizens craving change
the direction of the Illinois Policy Institute it’s easiest to of politics as usual, where does Makris
and its CEO, John Tillman. “I shot John see Illinois in 20 years? “I can’t really
convince people
an e-mail and we met,” says Makris. “We say whether Illinois will be any better or
talked about how it would be helpful to
that your position worse than it is now,” he says. “But it’s the
know the margins of victory for legislative is one that they uncertainty that motivates me to try to
candidates, and I took it upon myself to already agree make it the freest, most prosperous place it
do the research and it get it back to the with.” can be.”
Institute.”
When asked what advice he would give to others who
Two weeks and twenty hours of work later, Makris seek to become Liberty Leaders in their areas, Makris
returned a series of data-filled spreadsheets to the says he has a new appreciation for the classic Nike
Institute, giving a boost to the pool of knowledge slogan: “Just do it.”
being used to plan a liberty-based public policy agenda
for Illinois. He also earned a spot in the Institute’s The Illinois Policy Institute is developing a team of
new Liberty Leaders program, a project designed to Liberty Leaders to work for accountable government
assemble a team of liberty-minded volunteers who are in Illinois. From issues ranging from budgeting to
committed to holding politicians accountable around transparency to education reform, Liberty Leaders
are organizing around the issues that are important to
the state. them…and they are making an impact! Help us make
Illinois a better place by becoming a Liberty
With no experience in politics or political research, Leader. To learn more, contact Richard Lorenc
Makris gave up a small amount of time to contribute a at richard@illinoispolicyinstitute.org.
great deal of value.
10 COMPASS
be in a foul mood come this November–a foul mood
political that may make a con-con a pretty exciting event.
t he
Right-leaning proponents of the Illinois constitutional
convention are promoting the reforms that could come
with the convention, including recalling office holders,
term limits, more open elections, and binding referenda.
Meanwhile, those who might find themselves on the
RADAR
wrong side of these populist reforms–business groups,
party regulars, and many elected officials–are lining up
to oppose the convention.
COMPASS 11
Continued from page 5 Institute In The News
synergy. Many of our strengths are complimentary and The Institute has been making headlines across the state.
my efforts are stronger and sharper because of our affiliation. Here are some of our more recent highlights. For more, visit
our website at www.illinoispolicyinstitute.org.
Campaigne: You’re a proud father. What do you hope
to see change in Illinois so your children have a better
future?