Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Received: 16 January 2004 Returned for revision: 1 May 2004 Accepted: 15 August 2004 Published electronically: 26 November 2004
Background and Aims Selaginella is the largest genus of heterosporous pteridophytes, but karyologically the genus
is known only by the occurrence of a dysploid series of n = 7–12, and a low frequency of polyploids. Aiming to
contribute to a better understanding of the structural chromosomal variability of this genus, different staining
methods were applied in species with different chromosome numbers.
Methods The chromosome complements of seven species of Selaginella were analysed and, in four of them, the
distribution of 45S rDNA sites was determined by fluorescent in situ hybridization. Additionally, CMA/DA/DAPI
and silver nitrate staining were performed to investigate the correlation between the 45S rDNA sites, the hetero-
chromatic bands and the number of active rDNA sites.
Key Results The chromosome numbers observed were 2n = 18, 20 and 24. The species with 2n = 20 exhibited
chromosome complement sizes smaller and less variable than those with 2n = 18. The only species with 2n = 24,
S. convoluta, had relatively large and asymmetrical chromosomes. The interphase nuclei in all species were of the
chromocentric type. CMA/DA/DAPI staining showed only a weak chromosomal differentiation of heterochromatic
bands. In S. willdenowii and S. convoluta eight and six CMA+ bands were observed, respectively, but no DAPI+
bands. The CMA+ bands corresponded in number, size and location to the rDNA sites. In general, the number of
rDNA sites correlated with the maximum number of nucleoli per nucleus. Ten rDNA sites were found in S. plana
(2n = 20), eight in S. willdenowii (2n = 18), six in S. convoluta (2n = 24) and two in S. producta (2n = 20).
Conclusions The remarkable variation in chromosome size and number and rDNA sites shows that dramatic
karyological changes have occurred during the evolution of the genus at the diploid level. These data further suggest
that the two putative basic numbers of the genus, x = 9 and x = 10, may have arisen two or more times
independently. ª 2004 Annals of Botany Company
Key words: Pteridophyta, Selaginella, chromosome number, fluorochrome staining, silver nitrate staining, in situ
hybridization, 45S rDNA.
All the samples were collected in the Brazilian state of Pernambuco, except S. plana, which is from the state of Rio de Janeiro.
A B C D
E F G H I
J K L
F I G . 1. Chromosome complement (A–G), interphase nuclei (H and I) and number of NORs and nucleoli (J–L) observed in species of Selaginella:
(A) S. willdenowii (2n = 18) with two satellites (arrows); (B) Selaginella sp. (2n = 18) with three satellites (arrows); (C) S. simplex (2n = 18);
(D) S. muscosa (2n = 18); (E) S. plana (2n = 20); (F) S. producta (2n = 20); (G) S. convoluta (2n = 24); (H and I) chromocentric interphase nuclei of
S. plana and S. willdenowii, respectively; (J) prometaphase cell showing NORs (arrows); (K and L) prometaphase cells showing chromosomes associated with
nucleoli (arrows) in S. plana (K) and S. convoluta (L). The bar in A = 5 mm.
with sheep anti-digoxigenin antibody conjugated to [S. muscosa Spring, S. simplex Baker, S. willdenowii
fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) (Boehringer Mannheim (Desv. ex Poiret) Baker and Selaginella sp.], 2n = 20
no.1207741) and FITC-conjugated rabbit anti-sheep [S. producta Baker and S. plana (Desv. ex Poiret) Hieron.]
(Dakopatts F135, DAKO). The technique was based on and 2n = 24 [(S. convoluta (Arnott) Spring] (Fig. 1A–G).
Moscone et al. (1996), with some modifications (denaturation Among the species with 2n = 18, S. willdenowii and
at 80 C and the post-hybridization washes in 01 · SSC at Selaginella sp. exhibited the largest chromosomes, most
42 C). The hybridization mixture contained 60 % forma- of them meta- to submetacentric. The chromosomes in
mide, 5 % dextran sulfate, 2 · SSC, 001 % salmon sperm S. willdenowii varied between 144 and 248 mm (Fig. 1A),
DNA, and probe at a final concentration of 12–30 ng mL1. In and showed up to six satellites: two on the short arms and
most hybridization experiments, a 5S rDNA probe obtained four on the long arms of submetacentric chromosomes. In
from total genomic DNA of Passiflora edulis Sims (Melo and Selaginella sp. the chromosome size varied between 135 and
Guerra, 2003) was added to the mixture but no clear signal was 232 mm and three satellites were observed: two on a meta-
observed. Slides were stained with DAPI (2 mg mL1) and centric pair, and a third on a submetacentric chromosome
mounted in Vectashield (Vector). (Fig. 1B). On the other hand, S. simplex and S. muscosa had
The best cells were captured with a CCD Cohu camera on much smaller chromosomes, varying, respectively, between
a Leica DMLB microscope, or photographed using Kodak 085 and 126 mm and 080 and 162 mm (Fig. 1C and D).
Imagelink HQ ASA 25 film for bright field, or Kodak ASA The species with 2n = 20 had smaller chromosomes,
400 film for fluorescence photography. ranging from 070 to 104 mm in S. plana, and 078 to
143 mm in S. producta (Fig. 1E and F). The position of
the centromere could not be observed in any of these four
species, mainly due to the small size of their chromosomes.
RESULTS Satellites were also not clearly identified.
The seven species of Selaginella analysed in the present In the only species with 2n = 24, S. convoluta, the
work showed the following chromosome numbers: 2n = 18 morphology of the chromosomes seemed to vary from
274 Marcon et al. — Cytogenetic Variability in Species of Selaginella
T A B L E 2. Variation in number of chromosomes, rDNA sites and nucleoli per nucleus in four species of Selaginella
Species 2n Number of rDNA sites No. of cells analysed Range Most frequent numbers
metacentric to acrocentric. Chromosome size varied labelled, at the terminal position, in the two populations.
between 070 and 177 mm and satellites were not observed These two signals were always remarkably distinct in inter-
(Fig. 1G). phase nuclei (Fig. 2K), whereas up to ten signals were
In all species analysed, the interphase nucleus structure observed in the interphase nuclei of S. plana (Fig. 2L).
was granulated, with small chromocentres, corresponding to
the chromocentre type, according to the classification
of Tanaka (1971). Some species showed larger and more DISCUSSION
sharply outlined chromocentres (Fig. 1H and I). The chromosome numbers and the structure of interphase
Staining with silver nitrate revealed that the maximum nuclei reported in the present work are compatible with
number of nucleoli per nucleus varied among species the karyological data known for the genus Selaginella
(Table 2). In S. producta the maximum number of nucleoli (Kuriachan, 1963; Jermy et al., 1967; Ghatak, 1977;
per nucleus was two, whereas in the other three species Takamiya, 1993). Of the seven species examined, only
investigated, the maximum number ranged between six S. plana and S. willdenowii had been analysed previously.
and ten, although most nuclei exhibited only three nucleoli. The chromosome numbers observed for these species
Selaginella willdenowii exhibited a variation of one to ten agreed with the previous counts.
nucleoli per interphase nucleus and up to ten NORs were With regard to chromosome size and morphology, there
observed in prometaphase (Fig. 1J). In S. convoluta and is a strong trend to conserve the karyotype symmetry, with
S. plana, it was not possible to identify NORs, but six to predominance of metacentric and submetacentric chromo-
ten prophase or prometaphase chromosomes associated somes. The species with 2n = 20 analysed in this sample
with nucleoli were observed (Fig. 1K and L). were more stable in chromosome size than those with 2n =
A high number of metaphase cells was obtained from 18. Takamiya (1993) found similar results among species
S. willdenowii, S. plana, S. producta and S. convoluta mak- with x = 10 and x = 9. A higher number of meta- and
ing it possible to analyse the chromosomes with fluoro- submetacentric chromosomes was observed in the karyo-
chromes and in situ hybridization. Staining with CMA/ type of all species analysed, and appears to be a common
DA/DAPI revealed differentiation of bands only in trend in this genus (Takamiya, 1993), and in other hetero-
S. willdenowii and S. convoluta. The chromosomes of the sporous pteridophytes (Kuriachan, 1979, 1994). On the
other species stained deeply and homogeneously with both other hand, acro- and telocentric chromosomes are more
CMA and DAPI, even when counterstained with distamy- frequent among homosporous pteridophytes (Kawakami,
cin A. In prometaphase cells of S. willdenowii, up to eight 1982; Takamiya et al., 1992; Marcon et al., 2003).
CMA+/DAPI terminal bands were observed (Fig. 2A and In situ hybridization with 45S rDNA revealed the most
B). In S. convoluta (2n = 24), six terminal CMA+/DAPI prominent structural variation between species. One species
bands were localized in three chromosome pairs (Fig. 2D with 2n = 20, S. plana, displayed ten sites of 45S rDNA
and E). No DAPI+ bands were observed in these two spe- whereas another one with the same chromosome number,
cies, while the CMA+ bands were often negatively stained S. producta, exhibited only two. On the other hand,
with DAPI. S. willdenowii with 2n = 18, showed more rDNA sites
In situ hybridization of 45S rDNA in chromosomes of (eight) than S. convoluta (six) with 2n = 24. In angiosperms
S. willdenowii revealed the presence of terminal sites on the a similar variation has been widely reported. In Passiflora,
long arms of two chromosome pairs and on the short arms of for instance, the number of 45S rDNA sites varied from one
another two chromosome pairs (Fig. 2C). In two populations to three pairs among diploid species (Melo and Guerra,
of S. plana analysed, five submetacentric pairs were labelled 2003). In Paeonia (Zhang and Sang, 1999), five diploid
terminally: three pairs on the long arms and two pairs on the species (2n = 10) exhibited three to ten pairs of rDNA
short arms (Fig. 2H and I). While in one of the populations it sites. Variation in the number of rDNA sites among angios-
was not possible to observe clearly the smaller site, for this perm species of the same ploidy level has been attributed to
stains weakly, in the another population analysed the ten chromosome rearrangements, transpositional events and
sites of 45S rDNA were clearly labelled (Fig. 2I). In gene silencing (Moscone et al., 1999). Likewise, similar
S. convoluta there were four sites on two apparently acro- mechanisms may be acting in Selaginella species.
centric pairs and two sites on a submetacentric pair (Fig. 2F). In S. plana, S. convoluta and S. producta there was
In S. producta (Fig. 2G and J) only one chromosome pair was a perfect correlation between the maximum number
Marcon et al. — Cytogenetic Variability in Species of Selaginella 275
A B C
D E F
G H I
J K L
F I G . 2. Distribution of the CMA/DAPI bands and 45S rDNA sites in species of Selaginella: S. willdenowii (A and B) and S. convoluta (D and E), stained with
CMA (A and D) and DAPI (B and E), respectively. Arrows in A, B, D and E indicate the CMA+/DAPI– bands. 45S rDNA sites (C and F–L) in S. willdenowii
(C), S. convoluta (F), in two populations of S. producta (G and J), and in two populations of S. plana (H and I). Interphase nuclei of S. producta (K), showing the
two sites of 45S rDNA and of S. plana (L), showing up to ten sites. The bar in L = 5 mm.
of nucleoli (10, 6 and 2, respectively) and the number of 45S fusion of nucleoli, as observed in angiosperms (Moscone
rDNA sites. The wide variation in the number of nucleoli et al., 1995).
per nucleus observed in all species examined, with a higher Curiously, S. willdenowii, although having up to
frequency of nuclei with few nucleoli, is probably due to the ten NORs, displayed only eight 45S rDNA sites and six
276 Marcon et al. — Cytogenetic Variability in Species of Selaginella
chromosomes with satellites. This apparent lack of correla- Jermy AC, Jones K, Colden C. 1967. Cytomorphological variation in
tion between NORs and rDNA sites may be due to a pair of Selaginella. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 60: 147–158.
Kawakami S. 1982. Karyomorphological studies on Japanese Pteridaceae.
rDNA sites very reduced in size, not detected by FISH. The IV. Discussion. Bulletin of Aichi University of Education (Natural
number of satellites observed, on the other hand, is often Science) 31: 175–186.
lower than the number of rDNA sites (see, for example, Kawakami SM, Kondo K, Kawakami S. 1999. Analysis of nucleolar
Guerra et al., 1996), and in some cases they are not observed organizer constitution by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH)
at all, as in S. convoluta, S. plana and S. producta. in diploid and artificially produced haploid sporophytes of the fern
Osmunda japonica (Osmundaceae). Plant Systematics and Evolution
The CMA/DA/DAPI staining revealed only CMA+/DAPI 216: 325–331.
bands in S. willdenowii and S. convoluta. The number of Kramer KU, Green PS. 1990. The families and genera of vascular plants.
CMA+ bands was positively correlated with the number of Vol. I. Pteridophytes and gymnosperms. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
rDNA sites and the maximum number of nucleoli observed Kuriachan PI. 1963. Cytology of the genus Selaginella. Cytologia 28:
in these species. Similar results were found in the homo- 376–380.
Kuriachan PI. 1979. Interspecific origin of Salvinia molesta Mitchell:
sporous genus Acrostichum (Marcon et al., 2003), suggest- evidence from karyotype. Indian Journal of Botany 2: 51–54.
ing that these three features are also positively correlated in Kuriachan PI. 1994. Karyotype of Regnellidium diphyllum Lindm.
pteridophyte chromosomes. No previous report of CMA Caryologia 47: 311–314.
bands in pteridophytes was found in the literature. Marcon AB, Barros ICL, Guerra M. 2003. A karyotype comparison
between two closely related Acrostichum L. (Pteridaceae) species.
Jermy et al. (1967) proposed that the primary basic num- American Fern Journal 93: 116–125.
ber of Selaginella would be x = 10, characteristic of species Melo NF, Guerra M. 2003. Variability of the 5S and 45S rDNA sites
growing in dense tropical and subtropical forests (see also in Passiflora L. species with distinct base chromosome numbers.
Kuriachan, 1963). However, later karyological analyses Annals of Botany 92: 309–316.
(Takamiya, 1993), as well as morphological, anatomical Mishima M, Ohmido N, Fukui K, Yahara T. 2002. Trends in site number
change of rDNA loci during polyploid evolution in Sanguisorba
and paleobotanical data (Mukhopadhyay, 1998) suggest (Rosaceae). Chromosoma 110: 550–558.
that the basic number of the genus would be x = 9, gen- Moscone EA, Klein F, Lambrou M, Fuchs J, Schweizer D. 1999.
erating successive dysploids with n = 10, 11 and 12 on one Quantitative karyotyping and dual-color FISH mapping of 5S and
hand and n = 8 and 7 on the other. Takamiya (1993) pro- 18S-25S rDNA probes in the cultivated Phaseolus species
(Leguminosae). Genome 42: 1224–1233.
posed that dysploidy might have occurred repeatedly in Moscone EA, Loidl J, Ehrendorfer F, Hunziker AT. 1995. Analysis
different evolutionary lines within each subgenus. Indeed, of active nucleolus organizing regions in Capsicum (Solanaceae) by
the remarkable variation in chromosome number and in size silver staining. American Journal of Botany 82: 276–287.
and number of rDNA sites, seems to indicate that structural Moscone EA, Matzke MA, Matzke AJM. 1996. The use of combined
FISH/GISH in conjunction with DAPI counterstaining to identify
variation is rather common in the genus and that its
chromosomes containing transgene inserts in amphidiploid tobacco.
karyological evolution may be far more complex, with Chromosoma 105: 231–236.
each basic number arising two or more times. Mukhopadhyay R. 1998. Cytotaxonomic observations on Selaginella
Beauv. Phytomorphology 48: 343–347.
Ran Y, Murray BG, Hammett KRW. 1999. Karyotype analysis of
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS the genus Clivia by Giemsa and fluorochrome banding and in situ
hybridization. Euphytica 106: 139–147.
The authors are very greatful to Dr Iván Valdespino from Rufas JS, Giménez-Abián J, Suja JA, Garcia De La Vega C. 1987.
University of Panama, for species identification, and to Chromosome organization in meiosis revealed by light microscope
Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientı́fico e analysis of silver-staining cores. Genome 29: 706–712.
Tecnológico (CNPq) and Fundação de Amparo à Ciência Schweizer D, Ambros PF. 1994. Chromosome banding. In: Gosden JR, ed.
Methods in molecular biology, Vol. 29. Totowa: Humana Press, 97–112.
e Tecnologia do Estado de Pernambuco (FACEPE) for Stace CA, Bailey JP. 1999. The value of genomic in situ hybridization
financial support. (GISH) in plant taxonomic and evolutionary studies. In: Hollingsworth
PM, Bateman RM, Gornall RJ, eds. Molecular systematics and plant
evolution. London: Taylor & Francis, 199–210.
LITERATURE CITED Takamiya M. 1993. Comparative karyomorphology and interrelationships
Fabri F. 1963. Primo supplemento alle tavole cromosomiche delle of Selaginella in Japan. Journal of Plant Research 106: 149–166.
Pteridophyta di Alberto Chiarugi. Cariologia 16: 237–335. Takamiya M, Osato K, Ono K. 1992. Karyomorphological studies on
Ghatak J. 1977. Biosystematic survey of pteridophytes from Shevaroy Woodwardia sensu lato of Japan. Botanical Magazine 105: 247–263.
Hills, South India. Nucleus 20: 105–108. Tanaka R. 1971. Types of resting nuclei in Orchidaceae. Botanical
Greilhuber J. 1995. Chromosomes of the monocotyledons (general Magazine 84: 118–122.
aspects). In: Rudall PJ, Cribb PJ, Cutler DF, Humphries CJ, eds. Tryon RM, Tryon AF. 1982. Ferns and allied plants—with special
Monocotyledons: systematics and evolution. Kew: Royal Botanic reference to tropical America. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Gardens, 379–414. Unfried I, Gruendler P. 1990. Nucleotide sequence of the 58S and 25S
Guerra M. 1983. O uso de Giemsa na citogenética vegetal—comparação rRNA genes and of the internal transcribed spacers from Arabidopsis
entre a coloração simples e o bandeamento. Ciência e Cultura thaliana. Nucleic Acids Research 18: 4011.
35: 191–193. Unfried I, Stocker U, Gruendler P. 1989. Nucleotide sequence of the 18S
Guerra M. 1993. Cytogenetics of Rutaceae. V. High chromosomal rRNA gene from Arabidopsis thaliana Co10. Nucleic Acids Research
variability in Citrus species revealed by CMA/DAPI staining. 17: 7513.
Heredity 71: 234–241. Walker TG. 1984. Chromosomes and evolution in pteridophytes. In:
Guerra M. 2000. Patterns of heterochromatin distribution in plant chromo- Sharma AK, Sharma A, eds. Chromosome evolution of eukaryotic
somes. Genetics and Molecular Biology 23: 1029–1041. groups. Vol. II. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 103–141.
Guerra M, Kenton A, Bennett MD. 1996. rDNA sites in mitotic and Zhang D, Sang T. 1999. Physical mapping of ribosomal RNA genes in
polytene chromosomes of Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. and peonies (Paeonia, Paeoniaceae) by fluorescent in situ hybridization:
Phaseolus coccineus L. revealed by in situ hybridization. Annals of implications for phylogeny and concerted evolution. American Journal
Botany 78: 157–161. of Botany 86: 735–740.