Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Curtis Lanham
President, Baker Instrument Company
Before making a logical decision about what Contamination: A chemical deposit on the
kinds of testing should be done on motors to windings that causes deterioration of the
predict electrical failures, it must be understood insulation.
what makes these failures occur. It is important
to understand the different insulation groups, the Mechanical: Vibration or movement within the
aging process of the insulation, and review windings or the motor which wears the
typical failure scenarios. Only then can insulation system.
decisions be made as to which tests should be
included. Normal thermal aging: The slow deterioration
of the insulation over the windings natural life
II. The Insulation Groups through normal operation.
The insulation system of a motor consists of the Early thermal aging: Excessive winding
groundwall insulation, the phase-to-phase temperatures causing premature failure.
insulation and the turn-to-turn insulation. In a
typical induction motor the groundwall Overvoltage spikes: High Voltage surges caused
insulation is the slot liner paper that protects the by switching, lighting, and VFD designs.
insulated copper to ground. The Phase-to-Phase
is often a sheet of insulation paper that is laid All five of these should be considered when
between the phases. The weakest link in the designing a test program. We will look at the
insulation system is often the turn-to-turn normal thermal aging process and how it is
insulation. This is the enamel on the copper of a effected by Mechanical, Early thermal aging, and
random wound motor or the enamel and tape the Overvoltage spikes. For this paper we will
found on form coils. This insulation’s purpose is not deal with the contamination problems.
to protect from copper to copper failures.
IV. What makes motors fail?
To properly test the total insulation system
several different tests must be performed. The
1
Depending on which study is referred to; Mechanical abrasion within the winding is
electrical failures are responsible for 35% to 40% another deterioration mechanism operating on
of all motor failures. These same studies often the motor’s insulation. At start up a squeezing
show that many of these winding failures begin action caused by the magnetic forces will cause
as turn-to-turn shorts caused by steep-fronted wear between the moving components4. The
surges due to switching2. These studies date magnetic fields changes 120 times a second
back to 1936. Measurements of these surges causing this squeezing to occur each time. Even
began as early as 1960 showing spikes of .5 though wear does exist between the winding and
micro-seconds at up to 5 pu. the ground insulation, studies show that less than
17% of the ground insulation can be worn away
When discussing dielectric strength and voltage due to this movement. It is the turn-to turn
spikes in this paper the measurement of “pu” will insulation that is most affected by the abrasion.
be used. One per unit (pu) is the peak line to
ground voltage. As stated above, the potential difference turn-to-
turn during normal operation is not enough to
These steep-fronted surges are caused by a cause a failure of the turn-to-turn insulation in a
variety of sources. The most common and main motor. Only the spikes will have a voltage level
cause of breakdown of the inter-turn insulation is high enough to cause this kind of problem.
switching surges.3 These switching surges can Adding to this turn-to turn stress is the non-linear
occur both when opening and closing the distribution of voltage across the phase. In a
contacts. Restriking will create multiple surges. study conducted by Christiansen and Pedersen,5
it was concluded that the rise time of the spikes
Studies show that these surges will range from 1 will determine how the voltage propagates over
to 5 pu with rise times of .1 to 1 micro second. the windings. As shown in figure 2, the faster
A 4160V motor will see surges of up to the rise time the less linear the voltage divides
17,000V. over the coil.
Figure 2
2
motor windings. Instrument readout is provided
in megohms.
3
Vline. At each step up to this voltage, leakage
current in microamperes in read and plotted
against the corresponding dc test voltage.
D. Surge Test
4
maintenance tool, the test does not require the insulation with no regard for the turn-to-turn.
comparison of two wave forms. A simpler test is The Surge test is the only test that looks at the
performed that looks for a shift to the left by the turn-to-turn insulation. The turn-to-turn
waveform of the phase being tested. This shift insulation is the root cause of a high number of
indicates that the dielectric strength of the turn- the electrical failures. This test simulates
to-turn insulation has deteriorated to a level characteristics of a surge at start up, making it an
below that of the switching surges. Once the appropriate test for early detection of weak
insulation has weakened to this point, decisions insulation.
need to be made concerning the future of the
motor. With today’s digital technology it is
possible to acquire data of the phase under test at References:
several voltage levels and nest them together.
This technique is valuable in detecting and 1. Schump, David E., “Predict Motor
documenting this shift to the left. Failure With Insulation Testing, “Plant
Engineering Magazine, September,
1996.