Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Back to Basics or Business as Usual?
Responsible Lending, Responsible Borrowing and
the Christian Response to the Great Recession
9.30 – 3.30, Saturday 12th December
St Paulʼs Onslow Square London SW7 3NX
Introduction
I think my approach will differ considerably to that of the last speaker, Andrew Dilnot.
However, I completely agree with him that one shouldnʼt exaggerate the scale of the recent
crisis, itʼs certainly not the end of capitalism, and in the end weʼll probably see it as only a
relatively minor blip. However, that doesnʼt mean that as Christians we shouldnʼt be taking
this very seriously and it doesnʼt mean that it doesnʼt reveal to us certain very crucial things.
Unlike the last speaker I think it would be quite wrong to say that this is just a manifestation
of natural human behaviour and the natural cycle of ups and downs. I think it would also be
wrong to say that the current economic crises is somehow straightforwardly a manifestation
of human greed; because on the contrary, itʼs the consequence of people behaving precisely
in the way that theyʼre supposed to behave, according to our current economic system.
I donʼt think itʼs a manifestation of something merely natural, because these kinds of crises
are quite specific to a capitalist economy. Of course since the dawn of human history, there
have always been economic crises, but theyʼve had to do with natural disasters, failures of
harvests, failure of ethos, failure of people to work hard and be productive. Whatʼs
completely different and peculiar about the crises of capitalism is that they tend to be crises
of speculation, crises caused not by concrete physical factors, nor by solely human factors,
but precisely failures of the abstract mechanisms of the system itself. You donʼt have to be
anti-capitalist to recognise this phenomenon. Plenty of completely pro-capitalist economists
recognise it as well. So ever since the dawn of the capitalist era, weʼve had these kinds of
crises, think of the south sea bubble in the 18th Century. So these crises are recurrent. Itʼs
Organisers
The event was jointly organised by the Faith & Public Policy Forum, Kingʼs College London;
St Mellitus College (the diocese of London and Chelmsfordʼs theological and ordination
training institute); and the Centre for Contextual Theology (CTC). Kingʼs, St Mellitus and
CTC have an established relationship and are already working together in a variety of ways
to resource and equip the church in London in its mission and ministry through theological
education. This event was designed to initiate a conversation about the way beyond the
economic crises, one framed by theological considerations rather than economic ones, and
build relationship between bankers, theological educators, church leaders and policy makers
within a church rather than a political setting.