Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J. Tyler Stokes, , Carl T. Redmond, Daniel G. Panaccione, Christopher L. Schardl, and Daniel A. Potter
Abstract:
Survival, development, and feeding preference of the black cutworm Agrotis ipsilon
(Hufnagel) were compared on perennial rye grass Lolium perenne sp. Four strands of
grass were used: wild type, infected with Lp1 hybrid endophyte (Neotyphodium lolii X
Epichloe typhina), DMAT mutant endophyte, which produced no ergot alkaloids, LPS1
mutant endophyte, which produced no ergovaline, and the control, which was uninfected
L. perenne. Feeding preferences were shown against all three endophytic grasses, when
compared to uninfected grass, for both first and fifth-instar cutworms. When the wild
type was compared to the mutant strands, there was a significant feeding preference
towards the mutant strands. Survival to seven days, and fourteen day larval weight of the
black cutworm grown on wild type grass was reduced to less than one third of cutworms
grown on the control grass. The mutant grasses showed some significant effects in
development and weight, but differences in survival of cutworms grown on these grasses
was not as apparent as the wild type. This study suggests that ergot alkaloids, in
particular ergovaline, play a key role in insect defense. Also, the success of the wild type
grass to lower survival and development of the black cutworms may lead to applications
of this grass on turf lawns, and other places such as golf courses.
Many cool season grasses, including perennial rye grass Lolium perenne sp. have been
(Clay 1991). Endophytes, such as Neotyphodium lolii sp., which are common in
perennial rye grass produce four classes of alkaloids: Ergot, loline, indolediterpene, and
paramine (Rowan and Latch 1994; Siegel and Bush 1997; Popay and Rowan 1994). This
endophyte, and many similar ones that grow in tall fescue have been of particular interest
to many in the cattle and horse industries due to the devastating effects the alkaloids have
on their livestock (Coleman et al. 2000; Ball et al. 2003). Ergot alkaloids, in particular,
have come under the closest scrutiny, due to the widely held belief that these are the
alkaloids most largely responsible for the livestock problems (Panaccione et al. 2001;
Wang et al. 2003). The aim to remove Egrots from grasses such as tall fescue and
perennial rye grass has led to the creation of transgenic grasses containing altered levels
of alkaloids.
typhina sp. endophyte contains almost no lolines, but increased levels of paramine and
ergot alkaloids (Panaccione et al. 2001). Two mutant strands of Lp1: LPS1, and DMAT
have been created by direct and indirect methods of gene manipulation to create L.
disables the gene responsible for the first committed step to ergot alkaloid biosyntheses.
LPS1 disrupts enzyme formation required for ergovaline, therefore allowing any ergots
created after activation of the DMAT gene, but before the LPS1 gene is needed
(Panaccione 2001).
Many studies have shown that Endophyte infected grasses provide natural
defenses against insects, such as fall armyworm, and some coleopteran species (Braman
et al. 2002, Clay 1991, Popay and Rowan 1994). Studies however, on the black
have proved inconclusive (Williamson and Potter 1997). The black cutworm is an
important pest of many turf grasses, including golf course tees, fairways, and greens
(Potter 1998). We hope that this study will provide some insight into possible
applications to tufgrasses, such as golf courses, that use L. perenne on many of the areas
plagued by the black cutworm. In addition, this study may provide direct evidence on the
effects of specific classes of alkaloids, e.g. ergots, and specific ergots, e.g. ergovaline, on
Four strands of genetically engineered Perennial Rye grass were used. The grasses,
provided by Dr. Chris Schardl (University of Kentucky, Kentucky, U.S.A), were wild
type (E+), that contained a full strength strand of the hybrid fungus Neotyphodium lolii x
containing no ergovaline, and a control (E-) strand with no endophyte in the grass. The
grasses were grown in a green house in a soil mix of three parts Pro-Mix BX to one part
sterile top soil , in 41/2" pots , under no pesticide or herbicide pressure. Fertilization was
with Peters 20-10-20 peat-lite fertilizer, approximately every fourteen to seventeen days,
depending upon the condition and needs of the plants. Watering was once daily or
as needed. The greenhouse temp was 25°C day and 23°C night with a sixteen hour day .
The caterpillars used were freshly hatched first instar black cutworms A. ipsilon. Leaf
blades cut from the basal part of the blades were cut into 1.25 inch length pieces. Width
of blades did not differ significantly between strands, Means (SE) were: Wild-type: 2.79
(0.08) mm, DMAT: 2.83 (0.10) mm, LPS1 2.75 (0.09) mm, and Control: 2.96 (0.09) mm
respectively (n = 15 blades measured for each grass. A pair wise choice test was created,
placing six blades, three blades of each strand in a pair wise combination in 90mm radius
x 20mm tall Petri dishes in a radial, or pinwheel formation, with alternating blades. The
grass blades were chosen randomly from a bag containing blades from twenty to thirty
plants of the same strand. Petri dishes contained Whatman #1 90mm filter paper bottom,
wetted with distilled water. Ten caterpillars were placed in the center of the pinwheel
formation. Petri dishes were then sealed with parafilm. All dishes were placed in an
incubator at 26°C+-1°C with 14h/10h (L/D). Ten reps of each pair wise combination. At
both twenty four and forty eight hours the dishes were removed and the damaged
assessed. The data was analyzed qualitatively by two people, independently judging
For the fifth-instar test, the same radial formation of alternating blades was used
in pair wise combinations. The container was a Styrofoam bowl with a 120mm bottom,
covered with Whatman #1 110mm filter paper. The blades were cut at a length of 4.75
cm. For this test, to keep the blades in place, as large cutworms have the ability and
tendency to move blades, the blades were pinned in place using straight pins. A
Richmond Dental standard dental wick, wetted with distilled water was placed in-
between two blades, on the filter paper, to keep the humidity levels relatively high. The
bowls were wrapped in clear plastic wrap, and incubated as in the first-instar choice test.
The bowls were checked every three hours. The cutworm was removed from each bowl
when either, two of the three blades of one of the grasses had been eaten, or twelve hours
elapsed. The bowls were placed in a cooler at 4°C until as the cutworms were removed
until the twelve hours had elapsed. The damage was analyzed independently by two
people, rating the damage to the nearest ten five percent of each blade.
A small pile, approximately 25mm in diameter, of each strand of grass was put in the
middle of separate Petri dishes. Petri dishes contained filter paper, wet with distilled
water. Ten first-instar caterpillars were then put in the middle of the Petri dishes and the
dishes were sealed with parafilm. Eight reps of each grass and cutworms were made.
The clippings were replenished every two days, and frass removed as necessary. At
seven days, all dishes were inventoried for living caterpillars, and the caterpillars were
weighed, and each caterpillar’s instar was recorded. The caterpillars were then separated
the original dishes in this rearing study) was made for each grass, with 1 caterpillar per
dish. The caterpillars used were from the original caterpillars initially used for this
rearing study. For the control grass, there were 69 survivors, 4 first-instars, 38 second-
instars, and 27 third-instars. From this group we used the percent survivors of each
instar. For this example it was 5.8% first, 55.1% second, and 39.1% third. When these
second-instars, and 8 third-instars. These same parameters were used to determine the
representative samples for all four grasses, and their cutworms. At fourteen days the
Blades were cut from the basal section of the leaf blade and mixed with blades from
twenty to thirty plants of the same strand. They were then stored at -80°C in paper bags.
The blades were freeze dried, then analyzed by Dr. Dan Panaccione’s lab for ergot
For Paramine analysis, the same sample of blades used for ergot analysis were sent to Dr.
Results
grass in all pair wise test. When compared to the E-, the E+, DMAT, and LPS1 grasses
were eaten significantly less, with all alkaloid containing grasses having <5% damage at
24h. All three trends remained significant at 48h. In a pair wise comparison between E+
and LPS1, a significantly larger amount of LPS1 had been eaten at both 24h and 48h.
This was also the case when comparing DMAT to E+, with DMAT having significantly
more damage than E+. The only pair wise comparison with no significant damage was
that of LPS1 and DMAT, with only slightly more damage on LPS1 at both 24h and 48h.
(Figure 1)
Feeding preference of fifth-instar black cutworm
The fifth-instar cutworms showed the exact same trends as those of the first instars.
Like the first-instar test, there are significant differences between the E- and the other
three grasses. When compared to the E+, the DMAT and LPS1 grasses both showed less
feeding, but no statistical significance was found. As in the first-instar test, the
comparison between the two mutants, DMAT and LPS1 showed a slight preference for
The survival rate of the instars varied greatly depending on their particular grass. Larva
reared on E- grass had about an 85% chance of survival to seven days, compared with
only about 24% survival of those on the E+ grass. The mutant grasses, DMAT, and
LPS1 were very similar with 60% and 64% survival, respectfully. Survival of the
caterpillars reared between seven and fourteen days was much less significant, with the
lowest survival rate being E+ at 88.8%, and the highest being LPS1 at 100%. The mean
larval weight of the seven day rearing group was significantly different only for the E-
grass, producing caterpillars weighing much more than any of the other three strands,
which were all relatively close. At fourteen days this changes only slightly, as the E-
grass still produced by far the largest larva; however E+ produced significantly smaller
caterpillars than either DMAT, or LPS1. The mean instar of the caterpillars is almost
identical after seven days, at right around second. This changes however, between seven
and fourteen days, and at fourteen days, there is a significant difference, LPS1 produced
significantly earlier instars than E-, and E+ produced significantly earlier instars than
(Table 2)
Discussion:
Our results showed us very clear differences in both the feeding preference, and the
growth and development of the black cutworm when reared on different strands of
grasses. The most obvious result is the survival rate of the first-instars on E+ grass,
which is much lower than any of the other three grasses. This shows clear data
supporting that ergovaline and ergine, both of which are in the wild type exclusively,
have anti-biosis effects. Other than the ability to eradicate the black cutworm, the Lp1,
and mutant infected grasses also show data that could be used to implement an Integrated
Pest Management, or IPM program. The black cutworm has been shown to be most
susceptible to predation at earlier instars (Lopez 2000). As the rearing study shows, the
E+ and LPS1 grasses produced significantly lower instars at fourteen days, when
compared to the E-. Another fact that could have IPM strategy implications is the
weight, and subsequent size of larva. At both seven and fourteen days, the larva of all
three endophyte infected grasses was significantly lower in weight. This reduction in
weight and instar may presumably allow for more casualties, either from predation or
other methods, to the survivors raised on endophyte infected grass, when compared with
The feeding preferences showed significant, and consistent trends away from the
endophyte infected grass, if the control (E-) was available. There was also significant
preference at early instars away from the E+ grass, compared to the mutants and control
grass. This also can directly play into applications for an IPM strategy, with reservoirs of
endophyte free, or mutant endophyte grass in less vital areas, leading cutworms in that
direction.
These two findings differ from work done by Williamson 1997, which found no
free grass) on the black cut worm. The difference may lie in the endophytes used. The
grass type used for this study, L. perenne infected with Lp1 hybrid (E+) has been found
to contain less loline, and more ergot and paramine alkaloids than the L. perenne infected
with N. lolii used in Williamson 1997, or mutant Lp1 endophyte, (DMAT, LPS1), which
has more paramine and less lolines than Williamson 1997. (Siegel and Bush 1997).
Although these findings are very promising for places such as golf courses, and
other turf lawns, the implications into other areas such as livestock are less apparent.
Problems that devastate the livestock industry are caused by the same ergots that this
study has shown to deter herbivory the most. This study however does show some
preferences, and even some significant differences in weight, survival, and instar, when
comparing the mutant LPS1 and DMAT grasses with the control. These mutant grasses
contain simpler and less ergots(LPS1), and no ergots (DMAT). The reduction in survival
and development of the black cutworm raised on mutant grasses, as shown here, when
combined with the possible reduction in toxicosis, current insect control methods, and
general increase in grass health, compared to uninfected grass, could provide substantial
7 d after neonate cohorts confined with grass 1 Status of selected survivors after 14 d2
Mean no. Mean larval Mean No. Mean larval
Grass alive wt (mg) instar alive wt (mg) Mean instar
Control (E-) 8.5 0.4 a 6.8 0.3 a 2.3 0.1 a 19/20 150 11 a 5.8 0.1 a
DMAT 6.0 0.8 b 2.5 0.3 b 2.1 0.1 a 18/20 90 12 b 5.0 0.2 ab
LPS1 6.4 0.9 ab 1.9 0.3 b 1.9 0.1 a 20/20 73 11 b 4.7 0.2 bc
Wild type (E+) 2.4 1.1 c 1.5 0.4 b 1.9 0.2 a 16/18 40 12 c 3.9 0.2 c
1
Based on eight initial replicates of 10 larvae apiece; No. alive: F = 8.67; df = 3, 28; P < 0.001; Larval wt: F = 57.8;
df = 3,24; P < 0.001; Mean instar: F = 2.31; df = 3,24; P = 0.10.
2
After 7 d, 20 representative survivors from each treatment (18 for wild type; the rest had died) were individually
reared on the same grasses for another 7 d (14 d total); Larval wt: F= 15.8, df = 3,69; P , 0.001; Mean instar: Kruskal-
Wallis nonparametric ANOVA and mean comparisons based on ranks: P < 0.001
Within columns, means followed by the same letter do not significantly differ (LSD, P < 0.05)
Table 2. Alkaloid analysis. Concentrations of ergot alkaloids in leaf blade samples fed to insects. The first
set of numbers represents mean for each alkaloid in g/g dry weight plant material standard error; in the
second set (in parentheses), mass data have been converted to mol/kg.
Endophyte ergovaline ergine 6,7-secolysergine chanoclavine
Wild type 1.24 0.12 0.12 0.02 0.77 0.08 1.43 0.19
(7.1). (6.7)
Fig. 2. Results of paired choice tests with fifth-instar black cutworms offered
combinations of E- (CON), Wild-type (WT) E+ (N. lolii typhinum) and genetically-
modified (LPS1, DMAT) perennial ryegrasses. Each comparison based on 10 replicates.
Larvae were starved overnight, held individually in flat-bottom poly foam soup bowls,
and provided six 4.75 cm-long blade sections (three of each grass) in an alternating radial
arrangement. Asterisks denote significant differences (one-tailed paired t-test, P < 0.05).
e a t e n
g r a s s
75 75 75
Co n t r o l Co n t r o l Co n t r o l
o f
W ild Ty pe E+ L PS1 DM A T
ne n t a g e
50 50 50
25 25 25
aet re c
*
eP
*
0
* * 0
* 0
*
g r a s s
24 h 48 h 24 h 48 h 24 h 48 h
75 75 75
L PS1 DM AT DM A T
o f
25 25 25
*
* *
0 0
* 0
24 h 48 h 24 h 48 h 24 h 48 h
70
50
40
30
20
* *
10 *
0
CO N v s . W T CO N v s . LPS1 Con v s . DM AT
60
Per c enta ge ofgr as s eate n ( 12 h)
50
40
30
20
10
0
LPS1 v s W T DM AT v s . W T LPS1 v s . DM AT
References Cited:
Ball, D.M., S.P. Schmidt, G.D. Lacefield, C.S. Hoveland, W.C. Young III. 2003. Tall
Salem, OR.
Braman, S.K., R.R. Duncan, M.C. Engelke, W.W. Hanna, K. Highnight, D. Rush.
2002. Grass Species and Endophyte Effects on Survival and Develpment of Fall
Sons, Inc.
Coleman, R.J., J.C. Henning, L.M. Lawrence, G.D. Lacefield. 2000. Understanding
Lopez, R., Potter, D.A., 2000. Ant Predation on Eggs and Larvae of the Black Cutworm
Panaccione, D.G., Johnson, R.D, Wang, J., Young, C.A., Damrongkool, P., Scott, B.,
Popay, A.J., Rowan, D.D. 1994. Insect-Plant Interactions Volume V. CRC Press.
London
Potter, D. A. 1998. Destructive Turfgrass Insects: Biology, Diagnosis, and Control. Ann
Williamson, C.R., and Potter,D.A. 1997. Turfgrass Species and Endophyte Effects on