Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10
In Essay No. 10, James Madison addressed a popular complaint by the anti-federalists about the
proposed constitution. Anti-federalists were concerned that interest groups would take control over
government. These groups would look out for their best interests, which may not be in the best interest
Madison admitted that these interest groups (factions) did exist and have been a detriment to
other governments. Interest groups existed in the U.S. then and were the main cause of the public
distrust of government. All the same, factions are a necessity and an unavoidable issue if people live and
think freely.
Man is essentially faulty. He may be unreasonable, unwise or selfish. At the very least, a man’s
passions will taint his objectivity. It is only natural that men with varying opinions would divide.
Additionally, rich and poor men would have different views on issues, resulting in two classes.
Therefore, the remedy is not to withdraw liberty, but rather to work with what comes naturally to men.
The main goal of government should be to have all interests considered in policies and
judgements. A true democracy would only be successful with a small group. The more people, the less
control they would have, thereby allowing the majority to oppress the minority. A republic would then
be best for the U.S. The people would elect representatives of the best quality, those who would best be
able to officiate over the public. The key to this particular republic would be in balancing the number of
people with the number of representatives. The constitution breaks this down into local, state, and
A large republic would be even better at controlling factions than a small one, i.e. a union would
be better served than a state. A faction may be able to control a small area, however, the more people
that you govern, the more diverse the opinions will be. Therefore, a faction is more likely to meet with
resistance within a large population. This evens the playing field and works to a greater good for all.
Federalist Paper No. 51
James Madison writes this essay to persuade anti-federalists that a federal government as
outlined would not be too powerful. Admittedly, men would rule by self-interests rather then public
good. A division of power would be needed to put forth a system of checks and balances to avoid such
an issue. The constitution outlines a separation of powers. There would be an executive, a legislative,
and a judicial branch. It would be ideal to have these branches chosen and maintained completely
independently of each other including their salaries. (With some qualifications; The judicial branch
requires a very select people and therefore should be chosen by qualified individuals.)
As in Essay No. 10, Madison reminded readers that men are human and will error in judgement.
The government needs to work with human nature and our propensity to argue. It needs to be able to
control the people as well as itself. The separation of powers would allow for disagreement and
Within a large republic, an absolute separation, although ideal, would not be perfect. The
legislature, representing the vast population would dominate. This would in turn make the executive and
judicial departments too weak. Absolute veto power to the executive branch would likewise provide too
much power. The legislature should be divided in to two separate bodies, one by population and one by
state. Additionally, the people would have two separate governments; state and federal. Each
government, operating independently, would control the other. Likewise, the separate departments in
each government would help to control the government itself. Thus the complex constitution as
The job of the government, according to Madison, was to protect the people from each other.
Unlike a monarchy though, in a large republic the people would hold the power. The numbers and
diversity would be so great that an overpowering majority would be nearly impossible. A central
government with judicial power to hold all groups accountable would be necessary for a federal republic