ICC Project Evaluation

Integrated Project Evaluation - Rubrics 709710044
Integrated Project Evaluation - Rubrics Weightage Scale Score

Requirement Analysis Document 10 Excellent 10
Design
Work
Design Documents - Low Level & High Level 10 Competent 8
Test Plans - UTP & ITP 10 Competent 9
Source Code Development 10 Excellent 10

Development
Coding Standards 5 Competent 4

Code
Code Review - Self & Peer 5 Excellent 5

Testing - Unit & Integration 10 Excellent 10
Integration and built 5 Excellent 5
Deployment
Project
Project Execution 5 Excellent 4

Bugs and Crashes 5 Competent 4
Meets SRS 5 Competent 3
Team Work 4 Excellent 4
Soft Skills
Leadership Quality 4 Excellent 4

Team Interaction 4 Competent 3
Tracking Team Activities 4 Excellent 4
Project Presentation 4 Excellent 4
Total 100 91
Excellent 3
Competent 2
Scope for Improvement 1
Needs Efforts 0
709713051 709713054
Scale Score Scale Score
Excellent 10 Excellent 10
Competent 7 Competent 7
Scope for Improvement 1 Excellent 4
Competent 3 Excellent 4
Excellent 4 Scope for Improvement 1
83 84
709713017 709713046 709732055 709713023
Scale Score Scale Score ScaleScore Scale
Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excell 10 Excell
Competent 8 Competen 8 Compe 8 Compe
Scope for Improvement 2 Scope fo 3 Scope 2 Scope
91 91 93 87
709713023 709713032 709713036 709713035 709713041
Score ScaleScore ScaleScore ScaleScore Scale
10 Excel 10 Excell 10 Excel 10 Excel
8 Comp 8 Compe 7 Comp 7 Comp
7 Comp 7 Compe 8 Excel 9 Comp
4 Comp 3 Excell 4 Comp 3 Comp
3 Comp 3 Scope 2 Comp 3 Excel
3 Comp 3 Excell 4 Scope 2 Comp
2 Scope 2 Excell 4 Excel 4 Scop
3 Comp 3 Compe 3 Excel 4 Comp
4 Comp 3 Compe 4 Comp 3 Comp
87 85 89 88 84
709713041 709713038 709713015 709713049 709713040
Score ScaleScore Scale Score Scale Score Scale
10 Exce 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent
7 Com 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent
3 Com 3 Competent 4 Excellent 5 Competent
3 Scop 2 Scope for 2 Scope for 2 Scope for
1 Scop 1 Excellent 4 Competent 3 Scope for
3 Com 3 Excellent 4 Competent 3 Competent
84 82 91 88 82
709713040 709713082 709713082 709713082 709713082
Score Scale Score Scale Score Scale Score Scale
10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent
7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent
2 Scope for 2 Scope for 2 Scope for 2 Scope for
1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1 Scope for
82 82 82 82 82
709713082 709713082 709713025 709713011
Score Scale Score Scale Scor Scale Sco
10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10
7 Competent 7 Competent 9 Competent 7



2 Scope for 2 Competent 3 Competent 3
1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1
82 82 85 84
709713028 709713012 709713016 709713034
Scale Sco Scale Sco Scale Sco Scale Sco
Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 9 Excellent 9
Competent 7 Competent 9 Competent 5 Competent 7


Scope for 1 Competent 3 Scope for 1 Scope for 1


83 92 76 82
709732046 709713001 709713021 709713050
Scale Scor Scale Sco Scale Scor Scale Sco


Scope for 1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1 Scope for 1


90 82 79 79
709713043 709713008 709713045 709713039
Scale Scor Scale Scor Scale Scor Scale Scor




83 86 87 87
709713048 709713006 709713037 709713061
Scale Score Scale Sco Scale Scor Scale Sco




82 86 88 85
709713053 709713047 709713014 709713001
Scale Scor Scale Scor Scale Scor Scale Score

84 86 88 86
709713019 709713022 709713042 709713031
Scale Scor Scale Scor Scale Score Scale Score
Competent 10 Competent 7 Excellent 10 Excellent 10

Competent 3 Competent 3 Excellent 5 Excellent 5
Competent 3 Excellent 5 Competent 3 Competent 3
Competent 3 Excellent 5 Competent 3 Competent 3
Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Scope for 1
Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Competent 3
Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Scope for 1 Excellent 4
90 91 89 88
709713056 709713058 709732042
Scale Score Scale Score Scale Score
Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10
Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent 7
Competent 7 Competent 7 Excellent 10

Excellent 3 Excellent 3 Competent 3
Excellent 4 Competent 3 Competent 3
87 86 91
709732006 709713030 709713020 709713018
Scale Score Scale Score Scale Score Scale
Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent
Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent
Competent 7 Competent 7 Excellent 10 Competent
Competent 3 Excellent 5 Competent 3 Excellent
86 88 89 88
709713018 609713001 709713057 709713007
Score Scale Score Scale Score Scale Score
10 Competent 7 Competent 7 Excellent 10


10 Excellent 10 Competent 7 Excellent 10
5 Excellent 5 Competent 3 Excellent 5

5 Competent 3 Competent 3 Excellent 5
3 Competent 3 Excellent 4 Excellent 4

88 83 79 89
709713013 709713026 709713005

Excellent 3 Competent 3 Excellent 3
Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Scope for 2
Excellent 4 Competent 3 Scope for 1
Competent 3 Excellent 4 Competent 3
89 83 79
709713009 709713059 709713004
Competent 7 Excellent 10 Competent 7

Scope for 3 Scope for 3 Scope for 3
78 81 78
Integrated Project Evaluation - Guidelines for Using RubricsSc
Excellent Competent
Requirement
Design Documents
Captures both functional and non- Captures only functional and one/two
Analysis Document
functional requirements non-fn
Design Documents - All the modules are identified with one or two modules are not identified
Low Level & High description of input/output which leads to Re-work on the
Level parameters and algorithm design design
Captures all the test cases for both Captures the test cases for
Test Plans - UTP &
functional and non-functional as functional and few non-functional as
ITP
identified in RA document identified in RA document
functionality is implemented functionality is implemented

capturing all the validations;code is capturing all the validations; Re-
optimized as per code tuning usability is achieved but only one or
techniques; Code Re-usability is two code tuning techniques is
Source code applied applied
Code Development
Naming variables, Header-footer for Naming variables, Header-footer for

file and for every function, proper file and for every function, proper
Coding Standards documentation and Indentation is documentation is written but
followed followed Indentation is not appropriate
Code Review - Self & COMPLETE code review is done
Peer along with ALL considerations GOOD Code review is done
All test cases written in UTP and ITP All major test cases in UTP and ITP
are tested and fixed the defects; are tested but cosmetic defects are
Defect tracking sheet is maintained not fixed; Defect tracking sheet is
Unit & Integration to log all defects and defects are maintained to log all defects and
testing fixed defects are fixed
front end connects with back end and
front end connects with back end and exe is generated; it takes more time
Project Deployment
Integration and built exe is generated; for integration;

Output is perfect with no errors or Output is perfect with no errors and
project Execution warnings there are few warnings
NO Bugs and Crash Free project NO Bugs and with some incedents of
Bugs and Crashes development crashes
Implements both functional and non- Implements functional and one or
functional requirements as captured two non-functional requirements as
Meets SRS in RA document
Better quality work than expected captured in RA document
with significant and in time Good quality work as per
Team Work
contribution. expectations with timely contribution
Demonstrates EXCELLENT
Leadership Quality
leadership qualities Good in leading the team
Possess Listening Skills and
Soft Skills
Possess Listening Skills and communication among teammates,

Team Interaction communication among teammates, Needs improvements on
Participates in brainstorming, Open brainstorming and acceptance to
for new ideas and feedback new ideas and feedback
Keeps the team on track by giving
Tracking Team
specific, timely, and constructive Keeps the team on track by giving
Activities
feedback
EXCELLENT documentation, specific and timely feedback
GOOD communication and
communication and presentation presentation Skills with good
Project Presentation
Skills documentation skills
Excellent Competent
delines for Using RubricsScales
Scope for Improvement Needs Efforts
could not capture functional
captures only functional requirements as given in the project
requirements specification
more than 2 modules are not Complete Re-work on the design

identified which leads to Re-work document
Test cases are not complete as per
Captures the test cases for functional the validations given in the project
requirements specification
functionality is not implemented as

functionality is implemented per the validations given in the
capturing all the validations with Re- project specification; No code tuning
usability; No code tuning techniques techniques is applied and Re-
is applied; usability
Naming variables, Header-footer for
file and for every function, proper
documentation and Indentation is not
appropriate No coding standards followed
PARTIAL code review is done NO code review is done

All test cases written in UTP and ITP
are tested and fixed the defects;
Defect tracking sheet is maintained No test case has passed; Defect
to log all defects and only one or two tracking sheet is not maintained to
defects are fixed log all defects
front end connects with back end but integration has many errors and
exe is not generated warnings
Output is partially correct with no
errors and there are few warnings No output;
Project is not in Executable stage
FEW Bugs and crashes due to Bugs and crashes
Implements only functional
requirements as captured in RA
document
Good quality work as per Both are not implemented
expectations without meeting NO quality work and without meeting
timelines timelines
Average leading abilitites with scope
for improvement NO Leadership Qualities
Possess Listening Skills and needs Needs improvement on Listening
improvement on communication Skills and communication among
among teammates,brainstorming and teammates,brainstorming and
acceptance to new ideas and acceptance to new ideas and
feedback feedback
Gives specific feedback, not on

timelines
Needs Improvement in NO feedback
communication and presentation POOR communication and
Skills, presentation Skills
Scope for Improvement Needs Efforts

ICC Project Evaluation

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

ICC Project Evaluation

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Integrated Project Evaluation - Rubrics 709710044

Integrated Project Evaluation - Rubrics Weightage Scale Score

Design Documents - Low Level & High Level 10 Competent 8

Test Plans - UTP & ITP 10 Competent 9

Source Code Development 10 Excellent 10

Coding Standards 5 Competent 4

Code Review - Self & Peer 5 Excellent 5

Project Execution 5 Excellent 4

Leadership Quality 4 Excellent 4

Project Presentation 4 Excellent 4

Competent 8 Competen 8 Compe 8 Compe

Competent 8 Competen 8 Compe 8 Compe

Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excell 10 Excell

Competent 4 Competen 4 Compe 4 Compe

Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excell 5 Excell

Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excell 10 Excell

Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excell 5 Excell

Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excell 5 Excell

Competent 4 Competen 4 Compe 4 Compe

Competent 3 Competen 3 Compe 4 Compe

Scope for Improvement 2 Scope fo 3 Scope 2 Scope

Competent 3 Competen 3 Compe 4 Compe

Competent 4 Competen 3 Compe 4 Compe

Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excell 5 Excell

Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excell 5 Excell

8 Comp 8 Compe 7 Comp 7 Comp

7 Comp 7 Compe 8 Excel 9 Comp

10 Excel 10 Excell 10 Excel 10 Excel

4 Comp 3 Excell 4 Comp 3 Comp

5 Excel 5 Excell 5 Excel 5 Excel

10 Excel 10 Excell 10 Excel 10 Excel

5 Excel 5 Excell 5 Excel 5 Excel

5 Excel 5 Excell 5 Excel 5 Excel

3 Comp 3 Scope 2 Comp 3 Excel

3 Comp 3 Excell 4 Scope 2 Comp

2 Scope 2 Excell 4 Excel 4 Scop

3 Comp 3 Compe 3 Excel 4 Comp

4 Comp 3 Compe 4 Comp 3 Comp

4 Excel 4 Excell 4 Excel 4 Excel

4 Excel 4 Excell 4 Excel 4 Excel

7 Com 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent

7 Com 7 Competent 10 Competent 8 Competent

10 Exce 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent

3 Com 3 Competent 4 Excellent 5 Competent

5 Exce 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

10 Exce 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent

5 Exce 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

5 Exce 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

4 Com 3 Competent 4 Competent 3 Competent

3 Scop 2 Scope for 2 Scope for 2 Scope for

1 Scop 1 Excellent 4 Competent 3 Scope for

3 Com 3 Competent 3 Competent 3 Competent

3 Com 3 Excellent 4 Competent 3 Competent

4 Exce 4 Excellent 4 Excellent 5 Excellent

4 Exce 4 Excellent 4 Excellent 4 Excellent

7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent

7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent 7 Competent

10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent

3 Competent 3 Competent 3 Competent 3 Competent

5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent 10 Excellent

5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent 5 Excellent

3 Competent 3 Competent 3 Competent 3 Competent