You are on page 1of 132

City Development Plan of

Mathura

Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban


Renewal Mission

Final Report

September 2006

Prepared by:

INFRASTRUCTURE PROFESSIONALS ENTERPRISE (P) LTD


C - 2, Green Park Extension, New Delhi - 110016.
Phone: +91 (011) 26568607/ 08, 26562636
Fax: +91 (011) 26969478
Email: ipe@infrastructureindia.com
Website: http://www.infrastructureindia.com

Offices: Bangalore, Agra, Ghaziabad,


Lucknow, Bhubaneshwar and Kolkata
TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................ I

INTRODUCTION................................................................................. VIII
1 Background .............................................................................................. viii
2 Objectives of the Consultancy................................................................ viii
3. Scope of Work ............................................................................................ ix
3.1 City Assessment: Analysis of Existing Situation.................................................................. ix
3.2 Development of Strategic Agenda and a Vision for the City................................................. x
3.3 Evolving Strategies for Development ................................................................................... x
3.4 Developing a City Investment Plan and Financing Strategy................................................ xi

4. The JN-NURM – Heritage Context ............................................................ xi

SECTION A: MATHURA REGIONAL CONTEXT ................................. 1


A1 THE IMPORTANCE OF MATHURA CITY AND ITS HERITAGE................ 1
A1.1 Introduction..........................................................................................................................1
A1.2 Mathura at the Core of the MVA ..........................................................................................1
A1.3 The Heritage of Mathura......................................................................................................1
A1.4 The Need for a Mathura Vision ............................................................................................3

A2 THE CONTEXT FOR THE MATHURA CITY VISION AND ITS CDP.......... 3
A2.1 The Broader Objectives .......................................................................................................3
A2.2 The Contextual Framework..................................................................................................5

A3. THE STATE, DISTRICT AND MVA DETERMINANTS FOR THE


MATHURA VISION AND CDP ..................................................................... 5
A3.1 The State Context................................................................................................................5
A3.2 Agra Division .......................................................................................................................6
A3.3 Mathura District ...................................................................................................................7
A3.4 The District Profile ...............................................................................................................7

A4. THE MVA PLAN-2021 AND MATHURA CITY........................................... 11


A4.1 Institutional Imperatives .....................................................................................................11
A4.2 The Statutory Master Plan for The MVA – 1981-2001 as Extended to 2021......................11
A4.3 Objectives of the MVA Plan - 2021 ....................................................................................13
A4.4 The Proposed Extended MVA - Phase I ...........................................................................14
A4.5 The Proposed Extended MVA – Phase II ..........................................................................14
A4.6 The Basis for a Mathura City Rapid Assessment...............................................................15

SECTION B: MATHURA CITY: A RAPID APPRAISAL...................... 16


B1. OVERVIEW: MATHURA CITY ................................................................... 16
B1.1 Approach and Methodology Adopted : City Assessment ...................................................16
B1.2 City Profile .........................................................................................................................17
B1.3 History and Growth ............................................................................................................17
B1.4 Mathura Nagar Palika ........................................................................................................18
B1.5 Population Growth and Projections....................................................................................19
B1.6 Economic Growth ..............................................................................................................20
B2. THE CONSULTATIVE PROCESS ............................................................. 21
B2.1 Key Consultations..............................................................................................................21

B3. CITY INFRASTRUCTURE AND SERVICES DELIVERY .......................... 24


B3.1 Water Supply System ........................................................................................................24
B3.2 Sewerage System..............................................................................................................27
B3.3 Drainage System ...............................................................................................................32
B3.4 Solid Waste Management..................................................................................................35

B4 TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION ......................................................... 36


B4.1 Road Network....................................................................................................................36
B4.2 Existing Traffic Situation: ...................................................................................................38
B4.3 Parking ..............................................................................................................................39
B4.4 Issues & Challenges ..........................................................................................................40
B4.5 Street Lighting ...................................................................................................................40

B5 ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES....................................................................... 42
B6 HERITAGE & TOURISM ............................................................................ 43
B6.1 Existing Situation ...............................................................................................................43
B6.2 Issues & Constraints:.........................................................................................................45
B6.3 Key Heritage Actions .........................................................................................................45
B6.4 Identified Heritage Sites/Monuments .................................................................................46

B7 HOUSING AND SLUMS ............................................................................. 47


B7.1 Housing .............................................................................................................................47
B7.2 Urban Poor & Slums ..........................................................................................................49

B8 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK & GOVERNANCE................................. 53


B8.1 Organizational Structure of Mathura Nagar Palika Parishad (NPP) ...................................53
B8.2 Functional Departments of Mathura - NPP ........................................................................54
B8.3 Current Institutional Responsibility Matrix ..........................................................................56
B8.4 Issues & Challenges ..........................................................................................................56

SECTION C: SWOT ANALYSIS AND THE EMERGING MATHURA


VISION ................................................................................................. 57
C1. THE MATHURA URBAN RENEWAL AREA ............................................. 57
C1.1 Citizen Concerns: ..............................................................................................................57
C1.2 Mathura NPP as nodal agecy ............................................................................................57

C2. FINANCIAL PROFILE – MATHURA NPP ................................................. 58


C2.1 Finances of Mathura NPP..................................................................................................58

C3. SWOT ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 59


C4. LIVABILITY RATE OF THE CITY .............................................................. 61
C5. THE MATHURA VISION 2021 AND ITS CDP ........................................... 62
C5.1 The Requirements of the Mathura Vision Plan...................................................................62
C5.2 The Key Emerging Issues for the Mathura CDP ................................................................62
C5.3 Emerging Key Planning and Development Issues .............................................................63
C5.4 The Renewal Strategy .......................................................................................................64
C5.5 The Basic Mathura NPP Area Vision .................................................................................65

SECTION D: THE CITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP


JURISDICTION .................................................................................... 66
D1 THE BROAD LAND USE PATTERN ......................................................... 66
D1.1 The Mathura NPP ..............................................................................................................66
D1.2 The Structure Plan.............................................................................................................66

D2. URBAN RENEWAL THROUGH THE DOWN-TOP PROCESS. ............... 68


D3. THE MUNICIPAL WARD AS THE BASIC URBAN RENEWAL UNIT ...... 68

SECTION E: PROJECTS IDENTIFICATION FOR CAPITAL


INVESTMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP ....................................... 70
E1. Project Levels ............................................................................................ 70
E2. Project Sectors .......................................................................................... 70
E3. List of Projects .......................................................................................... 70
E3.1 Regional Level Projects .....................................................................................................71
E3.2 City Level Projects .............................................................................................................74
E3.3 Ward Level Projects...........................................................................................................75

E4. SUMMARY OF THE PROJECTS ............................................................... 76


E4.1 Water Supply .....................................................................................................................76
E4.2 Sewerage ..........................................................................................................................77
E4.3 Drainage ............................................................................................................................78
E4.4 Solid Waste Management..................................................................................................78
E4.5 Roads, Traffic & Transportation .........................................................................................79
E4.6 Street Lighting ...................................................................................................................79
E4.7 Urban Environment............................................................................................................80
E4.8 Heritage & Tourism............................................................................................................80
E4.9 Urban Governance ............................................................................................................80
E4.10 Basic Services for Urban Poor - District Urban Development Authority (DUDA)...............81

SECTION F: THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA


NPP AREA........................................................................................... 82
F1 CIP CRITERIA ............................................................................................ 82
F2 PROJECT INVESTMENTS......................................................................... 82
F2.1 Water Supply .....................................................................................................................83
F2.2 Sewerage System..............................................................................................................84
F2.3 Drainage System ...............................................................................................................86
F2.4 Solid Waste Management System.....................................................................................87
F2.5 Road & Traffic / Transportation..........................................................................................89
F2.6 Street Lighting ...................................................................................................................91
F2.7 Urban Environment............................................................................................................91
F2.8 Heritage & Tourism............................................................................................................92
F2.9 Urban Governance ............................................................................................................93
F2.10 Urban Poor & Slum............................................................................................................94

F3 PROPOSED CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN (CIP) FOR MATHURA ...... 96

SECTION G: FINANCIAL OPERATING PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP98


G1. FINANCIAL OPERATING PLAN................................................................ 98
G2. CASH FLOW MATHURA NPP................................................................. 102
List of Maps

Map A1 Mathura Parikrama Marg


Map A2 State of Uttar Pradesh within India
Map A3 Location of Mathura District in Agra Division
Map A4 Tehsils & Blocks of Mathura District
Map A5 Blockwise Density of Population: Mathura District
Map A6 Trunk Rail and Road Linkages to Mathura
Map A7 Proposed Taj Expressway
Map A8 MVA Master Plan area 1981-2001 within the districts
Map A9 Landuse for MVA 1981-2001 with Pie-Diagram
Map A10 Extended MVA – 1997
Map A11 MVA as further extended 2001
Map A12 The extent of Development Plan area for MVA -2021

Map B1 Municipal Wards – Mathura NPP


Map B2 Sewerage Zones, Mathura and surroundings
Map B3 Drainage Zones, Mathura and surroundings
Map B4 Slum Zones, Mathura NPP
Map B5 Slum Pockets, Mathura NPP

Map C1 Mathura NPP within the MVDA Plan area

Map D1 The Mathura NPP jurisdiction


Map D2 Mathura NPP Structure Plan 2021
Map D3 Mathura NPP, Ward Jurisdiction, Mixed Use

Map E1 Mathura NPP, JNNURM Basic Services Priorities - 2021


Map E2 Transportation Priorities - 2021
Map E3 Heritage Priorities - 2021

List of Tables

Table 1A Tehsils and Blocks of Mathura District


Table 1B Tehsil and Block Populations / Densities – 2001
Table 1C Population Projections MVDA – 2021
Table 1D Proposed Landuse distribution MVDA – 2021
Table 1E Population Estimates for Proposed Extended MVDA – 2021

Table 2A Decadal Growth Rates – Mathura UA


Table 2B Population projections for Mathura UA – 2021
Table 2C Percentage of small scale industries , Mathura NPP
Table 2D Details and performance indicators for water supply, Mathura NPP
Table 2E Expenditure incurred on water supply by NPP
Table 2F Works in Mathura NPP under YAP-I
Table 2G Expenditure incurred on drainage , NPP
Table 2H a. Solid Waste Management, NPP
b. Expenditure on Solid Waste Management, NPP
Table 2I a. Percentage of roads maintained by different agencies, Mathura NPP
b. Distribution of road R/W- NPP
c. Expenditure incurred on urban roads R/w’s – NPP
Table 2J Registered Vehicles, RTO
Table 2K a. Types of street lighting, 2006 NPP
b. Expenditure on street lighting, 2006 NPP
Table 2L Pollution survey, Mathura UA
Table 2M Ambient Noise Level, Mathura UA
Table 2N Tourist Arrivals, Mathura NPP
Table 2O a. Monuments protected by ASI-NPP
b. Monuments protected by State Dept. in NPP area
c. Festivals of Mathura
Table 2P Slum Population and literacy, 2006 - NPP
Table 2Q Basic Infrastructure in slums, Mathura, NPP
Table 2R a. Status of Infrastructure in slums , Mathura NPP
b. Community facilities in slums- Mathura, NPP

Table 3A Income Expenditure of Mathura NPP 2001-06


Table 3B SWOT analysis – Mathura NPP
Table 3C Goals & Objectives from SWOT analysis
Table 3D Goals & Strategies from SWOT analysis
Table 3E Livability rate , Mathura NPP

Table 4A Mathura NPP, ward level details

List of Annexes

Annex A List of key officials, institutions, NGOs and citizens who were consulted for
Mathura CDP
Annex B Press cuttings and media coverage – Mathura CDP
Annex C Heritage priorities for Mathura by Braj Bhoomi, INTACH
Annex D1 Slum Zones in 45 wards of Mathura NPP
Annex D2 Slum Pockets in 45 wards – Mathura NPP
Annex E Detailed Revenue & Expenditure profile of Mathura NPP
Annex F Zone wise population for waste water generation 2039
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Executive Summary

Overview

The City Development Plan (CDP) Report of Mathura has been structured into seven
section (Section A- G). The Section A covers the regional context of Mathura its importance
and heritage, vision and its CDP, the state, district and Mathura Vrindavan determinants for
the vision and CDP, the MVA Plan -2021 and Mathura city. The Section B, brings the Rapid
Appraisal of the city , with an city overview, the consultation process, city infrastructure and
services delivery, traffic and transportation, environmental issues, heritage & tourism,
housing & slums, institutional framework & governance. The Section C, details out the
SWOT analysis and the emerging Mathura vision. The section provides details of the
Mathura urban renewal area, the financial profile of Mathura NPP, SWOT analysis, livability
rate of the city, the Mathura Vision 2021 and its City Development Plan.

The Section D, provides details of the City Development Plan for Mathura NPP jurisdiction.
The section gives details regarding the broad land use pattern, the urban renewal process
through the down-top process, municipal ward as the basic urban renewal unit. The Section
E, gives details regarding the project identification for Capital Investment Plan for Mathura
NPP. The section details out the project levels, project sectors, list of projects and summary
of the projects under various sectors. The Section F, brings out the Capital Investment Plan
for Mathura NPP area. The section provides details regarding the CIP criteria, projects
investments. The last Section G, provides details regarding the Financial Operating Plan for
Mathura, NPP.

The JN-NURM – Heritage Context


Initially launched for 60 cities in 2005 as a 7-year programme, currently there are 63 cities in
the Mission. Of these 8 are classified as Heritage Cities-viz:-
o Mathura, Mysore, Puri, Bodhgaya, Ajmer-Pushkar, Ujjain, Haridwar and
Nanded (Primarily of Cultural - Historical or Pilgrimage Tourism significance).
Two others are of tourism significance – viz Srinagar and Nainital. Of the other
53 cities, 35 are metros (including Varanasi and Amritsar) and 18 are State
Capitals. These too have heritage to be conserved, including the metros of
Amritsar and Varanasi.
Initially a single toolkit was issued for all 63 cities. However, a supplementary toolkit is being
devised by MoUD and INTACH for heritage conservation and where :
o Heritage conservation is the main component (as in the 8 cities above,
including Mathura)
o Heritage enhancement is a major concern (as in the other 55 cities
The CDP for Mathura has accordingly been restructured to fit into the draft
supplementary toolkit without losing the renewal focus of Mathura.
The Regional Context
Mathura– the birthplace of Lord Krishna is one of the prime destinations for pilgrimage in
India. The contiguous settlement of Vrindavan is intrinsically related to this pilgrimage. Also
a majority of devotees visit Goverdhan in its vicinity. Accordingly, catering to a floating
population with focus on the river Yamuna is a major requirement in a plan for Mathura. At
the same time, this group of settlements is strategically located. The national expressway
(North-South corridor) cuts through the area and practically the entire southbound rail traffic
from Delhi and North West India is dispersed at Mathura Junction for both goods and

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. i


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

people. Rail traffic to Rajasthan via Alwar and to central UP via Hathras also converges on
Mathura. The proposed Agra-Noida Expressway east of the Yamuna would further add to
the accessibility of Mathura.

Therefore along with pilgrim convergence and related religious-cultural tourism, enhancing
the importance of the river Yamuna, national transportation dispersal of goods and people
by road and rail, the proper operation of Mathura refinery, its ancillaries and other
industries, placed on the authorities a heavy responsibility of regulated development in a
major and growing concentration of regular inhabitants and floating population within a
major district of U.P. Along with this, the growing gap in civic infrastructure required
coordinated actions by the urban and rural local bodies of Mathura District working in unison
with the Mathura Vrindavan Development Authority (MVDA) and District Authorities. These
issues were addressed in the Perspective Plan proposed for the Mathura Vrindavan Area
with a 20 year perspective (2000-21) by the MVDA.

Mathura - Core of the MVA

Though the established foci of the expanded MVA are the religious settlements of a)
Mathura, b) Vrindavan and c) Govardhan requiring the footprints of these to be protected
and enhanced along with their temples, parikramas, kunds and other benchmarks along
with river Yamuna and its bunds, the proposals herein are for Mathura city and which has a
Nagar Palika Parishad (NPP) within the larger MVA region. This priority is justified due to
Mathura City being at the core of the Braj Boomi and the entreport of this group of
settlements. Accordingly its environment needs serious renewal for the benefit of both – its
residents and the accelerating floating population of pilgrims regional, national and
international to the larger Mathura-Vrindavan area and also to Goverdhan.

The Planning & Consultation Process

The preparation of the Mathura CDP involved extensive consultations, throughout its
preparation period. The consultative strategy involved interaction with various stakeholders
like: Senior Citizens, Departments, Institutions / Groups, Industrialists, Citizens at ward
level, and local elected representatives, media. The process was facilitated by the media, to
impress upon the general citizens about the objectives of JNNURM and CDP for Mathura.
During the preparation of the CDP, two workshops were held apart from regular
interdepartmental consultations, and ward level discussions. Press meetings were held
regularly during the plan preparation phase.

All the concerned government departments and institutions were consulted during the three
month CDP process. Meetings were held individually with various departments. It involved
site visits for further discussions. The ward level consultations involved discussions with
senior citizens, local residents about the issues and challenges regarding the infrastructure,
services delivery and developmental issues. Besides the consultation process, the
extensive visits to 45 wards of the city was completed by the consultants with the help of
local elected representatives and ward level senior citizens. The former elected councilors
of the municipality were also contacted about the development issues required in various
sectors (at present there are no elected representatives in place) . The ward level visits to
slum areas were also done with the help of the District Urban Development Agency
(DUDA). Slum issues were mapped and discussed with various representatives like CBOs,
RCVs, and citizens. The women’s participation and development issues were also
discussed and were sensitized about the programmes for the development process at the
ward level under JNNURM .

The press and media played an important role during the entire plan preparation. The
citizens were sensitized regularly through newspapers, local channels about the JNNURM

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. ii


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

and city development processes. The citizens were encouraged to send suggestions and
come forward for further discussions with the team regarding their needs at local and city
level. Heritage and tourism was a basic issue of the Mathura CDP, consultations were held
with INTACH Delhi and the Braj Bhoomi Chapter of INTACH at Mathura. Several views
emerged and this has helped shape the CDP. The listing done by INTACH has 428 entries.

The open consultation process involved interaction with citizens in the municipality NPP
office for the draft CDP prepared by the consultants. The presentations regarding the city
assessment in terms of the infrastructure, service delivery , governance , urban poor and
slums were exposed along with the vision and development strategies. Based on these
consultations and the field level visits and other consultations, the projects were identified
and put for regional, city and ward level development.

The Emerged Vision for Mathura

The City Development Plan for Mathura

Based on the city’s needs and the emerging vision and strategy, the CDP projects have
been identified and structured at three levels:

x Regional Level;
x City Level;
x Ward Level.

Urban Infrastructure & Governance

x Water Supply
x Sewerage
x Drainage
x Solid Waste Management
x Roads, Traffic and Transportation

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. iii


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

x Street Lighting
x Urban Environment
x Heritage & Tourism
x Urban Governance

Basic Services to Urban Poor

x Water Supply
x Sewerage
x Drainage
x Solid Waste Management
x Roads, Streets and Lanes
x Street Lighting
x Basic Amenities ( Public Conveniences, etc)
x Community Halls/ Training Centres
x Housing for BPL
x Training & Capacity Building

The following are the list of projects that have emerged out of the key consultative process,
rapid assessment, the emerging city vision and strategies for the Mathura City Six year
CDP.

Regional Level Projects

Sr. No. Sector Projects


1 Urban Full utilization of Gokul Barrage’s 100 mgd capacity for Mathura UA
Services for along with improved water treatment plant facilities
Mathura UA Feasibility report and financial closure of new Barrage north of
(NPP + Cant) Vrindavan for MVDA’s needs other than Mathura UA.
Desilting of the Yamuna
Refer Map D4 New Land fill site in Trans Yamuma for Mathura UA
2. Transportation Construction of 2 no. Interstate Bus Terminals (near NH2 and trans
Yamuna) along with Transport Nagar
Refer Map D5 Improvement at entry points to NH2 and NOIDA – Agra Corridor
including improved access to the corridor.
3. Heritage and Lord Krishna Theme Park in trans Jamuna including ropeway access.
Tourism River cruisers with jetties to link Mathura and Vrindavan river front
New Mathura Museum near NH2 in lieu of current location
Refer Map D6

City Level Projects


Sr. Sector Projects
No.
1 Water Supply Consultation and upgradation of network for UA area complete with
upgradation and replacement of pumping system, storage facilities
and new feeder mains.
Replacement of existing tube wells and provision of new tube wells as
per networks plan.
Strengthening system of maintenance, leak reduction and improved
collection of user charges
2. Sewerage Replacement of existing outdated inner city network and construction
of new system on basis of networks plan, inclusive of pumping and
construction of new STP’s and renovation of existing ones) including
convergence to and upgrading at sewage farm as existing
3. Drainage Desisting of the existing and closed drains
Construction of new closed drains and repairs to existing and closed

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. iv


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Sr. Sector Projects


No.
drains and interception at outfalls to the Yamuna/ STP’s as per
networks plan
4. Solid Waste SWM capacity building as per SWM Master Plan including provision of
Management various size bins, collection, conveyance, separateion, disposal and
awareness campaigns.
Separate treatment for hospital and industrial waste.
5 Roads/ Traffic Widening, repair and upgradation of existing city roads and
and upgradation and improvement of crossings, junctions etc.
Transportation Construction of flyovers, crossings/ sub-ways;
Construction of multi-storied parking; and
Construction of new parking bays.
Construction and provision of bus stops, shelters, Auto/ Taxi stands.
Provision of appropriate street / traffic infrastructure (Street furniture,
signage’s, hoardings, etc)
6 Street Lighting Upgradation of existing street light points. Provision of street lighting
system in un-serviced areas. Upgradtion and provision of underground
cable for street lights.
Provision of high mast lights at key locations and junctions. Provision
of basic infrastructure for operation and maintenance of street lights
(light restoration ladder enabled cranes, safety equipments etc)
7 Urban x Rehabilitation and construction of modernized slaughter house.
Environment x Restoration and construction of Dhobi ghats.
x Rehabilitation and construction of modernized dairy cattle centres.
x Environmental improvement of river front development along the
Yamuna river.
x Desilting and restoration of twelve kunds with landscaping, lighting
and other improvement.
x Construction of public conveniences system.
x Urban greening, beautification and landscaping.
x Including development of city parks / city squares.
8 Heritage & x Official Listing of Sites, Remains, Ruins, Monuments, Buildings
Tourism and landscapes of Archaeological, Architectural, Historical,
Cultural and ecological value
x Development of Mathura Parikrima marg including Restoration,
conservation and beautification of ghats.
x Renovation, restoration and conservation of heritage buildings.
x Night illumination of important, heritage buildings, sites, kunds,
ghats.
x Construction and development of heritage haat (on the lines of
Delhi Haat), Art Gallery, auditorium, etc.
x Construction and beautification of new ghats on trans Yamuna
side.
x Light and sound shows / facilities along Ghats, Tourist information
and display centres, signage, etc
9 Urban x Resource Mobilization and Financial Management System of
Governance / urban local body / development agencie
Institutional x Municipal Services and Performance Measurement.
Development / x Business process re-engineering
Organizational x Computerization, e-Governance, GIS & MIS
Strengthening
x Training & Capacity Building
10 Basic Services to x In situ construction of housing for BPL.
Urban Poor x Water supply lines in un-serviced areas. Provision of hand pumps
/ community based water supply system. Desilting of the existing
sewerage lines / drainages. Restoration, repair of damaged sewer
and drainage lines. Construction of new sewer lines & drains in
un-serviced areas.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. v


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Sr. Sector Projects


No.
x Provision of infrastructure for municipal solid waste management.
x Upgradation and construction of approach roads, street lanes in
the existing and un-serviced areas.
x Installation of electric poles, light points in un-serviced areas and
upgradation of existing street lighting points.
x Construction of community halls and training centres.
x Basic amenities like public convenience, parks, etc.

Ward Level Projects


Sr. Sector Projects
No.
1 Water Supply x Water supply augmentation network lines at ward level
x Rain Water Harvesting & Recharging
x Supply and laying of additional conveyance system
x Construction & Repair of OverHead Water Tanks
2 Sewerage x Restoration of the damaged sewerage lines.
x Provision of sewer lines in un-serviced areas.
x Provision of decentralized sewerage system at ward level.
3 Drainage x Restoration of existing damaged drains.
x Construction of drainage lines in un-serviced areas and streets.
4 Solid Waste x Door to door collection of municipal solid waste
Management x Provision of appropriate infrastructure for municipal solid waste
management (cycle rickshaws, wheel barrows, garbage bins,
street cleaning equipments etc)
x Public awareness and campaign/ IEC.
5 Roads / Street x Upgradation and improvement of existing streets and lanes.
Lanes / Traffic and x Constriction of new streets and lanes and approach streets/ roads.
Transportation x Provision of street infrastructure like signage’s, hoardings, etc
6 Street Lighting x Upgradation of street light points.
x Provision of street lighting in un-serviced areas.
x Upgradtion and provision of underground cable for street lights.
x Basic infrastructure for operation and maintenance.
x Complaint Redressal System.
7 Urban Environment x Upgradation and construction of ward level community managed
parks.
8 Heritage & Tourism x Development of heritage ward precincts.
x Basic infrastructure facilities around important heritage areas at
ward level including Street furniture & parking system.
9 Urban Governance x Community Participation.
/ Institutional x Neighborhood Committees.
Development / x Ward Level Committees.
Organizational x Resident Welfare Associations.
Strengthening x Report Card System.
10 Basic Services to x Community based infrastructure amenities like water supply,
Urban Poor public conveniences, parks, sanitation etc.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. vi


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Capital Investment Plan

Total
Yearly Investment Required (Rs. in Crores)
Investm-
Sr. ent 2006- 2007- 2008- 2009- 2010- 2011- GoI GoUP ULB
Sector
No. Required 07 08 09 10 11 12 (80%) (10%) (10%) *
(Rs. in Year Year
Crores) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4
5 6
109.7
1 Water Supply 320.00 86.00 62.40 41.30 15.60 5.00 256.00 32.00 32.00
0
2 Sewerage 304.00 49.00 69.00 65.00 55.00 41.00 25.00 243.20 30.40 30.40
Drainage / Storm
3 228.00 78.00 63.00 44.00 25.00 10.00 8.00 182.40 22.80 22.80
Water Drainage
Solid Waste
4 76.57 15.82 29.45 28.45 1.45 0.90 0.50 61.26 7.66 7.66
Management
5 Street Lighting 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.30 6.25 3.35 45.00 5.63 5.63
Urban Roads &
6 367.30 94.07 96.56 80.31 52.01 25.30 19.05 293.84 36.73 36.73
Traffic
Heritage &
7 269.00 56.20 85.15 57.30 38.80 18.00 13.55 215.20 26.90 26.90
Tourism
Urban Poor and
8 132.56 26.51 26.51 39.77 19.88 13.26 6.63 106.05 13.26 13.26
Slums
Municipal
9 10.25 2.90 2.65 2.35 1.20 0.65 0.50 8.20 1.03 1.03
Governance
Urban
10 66.50 14.50 21.50 21.25 4.75 3.00 1.50 53.20 6.65 6.65
Environment
459.1 414.2 133.9
Total 1830.43 494.27 245.69 83.08 1464.34 183.04 183.04
5 8 6

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. vii


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

INTRODUCTION
1 Background

The Government of India’s Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM),
focuses on (i) improving and augmenting the economic and social infrastructure of cities; (ii)
ensuring basic services to the urban poor including security of tenure at affordable prices;
(iii) initiating wide-ranging urban sector reforms whose primary aim is to eliminate legal,
institutional and financial constraints that have impeded investment in urban infrastructure
and services; and (iv) strengthening municipal governments and their functioning in
accordance with the provisions of the Constitution (Seventy-Fourth) Amendment Act, 1992.

The objective of the JNNURM are to ensure that the following are achieved in the urban
sector:
x Focused attention to integrated development of infrastructure services in cities;
x Establishment of linkages between asset-creation and asset-management through a
slew of reforms for long term project sustainability;
x Ensuring adequate funds to meet the deficiencies in urban infrastructure services;
x Planned development of identified cities including peri-urban areas, outgrowths and
urban corridors leading to dispersed urbanization;
x Scale up delivery of civic amenities and provision of utilities with emphasis on
universal access to the urban poor;
x Special focus on urban renewal programmes for old city areas to reduce congestion;
and
x Provision of basic services to the urban poor including improved housing, water
supply and sanitation, and ensuring delivery of other existing universal services of
the government for education, health and social security.

JNNURM comprises of two sub-missions, namely (i) Sub-Mission for Urban


Infrastructure and Governance, and (ii) Sub-Mission for Basic Services to the Urban
Poor.

The Government of India has proposed substantial assistance through the JNNURM to the
selected Mission cities. In Uttar Pradesh, seven cities have been identified for
assistance under the Mission viz, Lucknow, Kanpur, Allahabad, Agra, Varanasi and
Meerut. In addition Mathura has been selected as a major heritage city of India.

In order to apply for grant assistance under JNNURM, the Government of India requires
eligible cities to (i) formulate a medium term City Development Plan (CDP); (ii) prepare
project proposals based on the CDP; and (iii) draw up a time-frame for implementing the
urban sector reforms.

As one of the eligible Mission cities, Mathura has to formulate a CDP that meets the
requirements laid down in the guidelines prescribed by Government of India (Ministry of
Urban Development and Ministry of Urban Employment and Poverty Alleviation).

2 Objectives of the Consultancy

The City Development Plan provides the starting point for the reform by identifying core City
challenges, a Perspective and Vision for the future development of the City, its present
stage of development and current status. This lead to the directions for change.

The CDP is to focus on the development of economic and social infrastructure, policies and

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


viii
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

programmes addressing the specific issues of urban poor, strengthening of municipal


governments, and their financial management and accounting processes, promoting
transparency in their functioning, and pointedly strengthening Mathura, as a pilgrim / tourist
destination.

The CDP also provides a direction for cities and State Governments to undertake certain
urban sector reforms which will facilitate flow of investments into city based infrastructure.
This makes it imperative for cities to systematically determine how they wish to shape their
future.

Therefore, the basic objective of the Consultancy is to formulate a City Development Plan
(CDP) for Mathura City, in consultation with all the relevant stakeholders, in accordance
with the guidelines issued by the Government of India. As the funding for infrastructure
under JNNURM is contingent upon the City having a CDP, which must be cleared by the
Government of India (GoI), an important aspect of the consultancy is to ensure that the
CDP as prepared meets the requirements and appraisal standards of the GoI. The CDP
shall, inter-alia, provide the basis within which projects will be identified for funding under
JNNURM and the details of such projects.

3. Scope of Work

This CDP prepared in the context of the toolkits, guidelines and instructions provided by the
MOUD and MOUEPA of the GoI and the Department of Urban Development (DoUD)
Government of Uttar Pradesh (GoUP)/ SRC from time to time.

The CDP was prepared as a multi-stage exercise involving the following:

(i) City assessment: Analysis of existing situation.

(ii) Development of strategic agenda and vision for the city

(iii) Evolving strategies for development

(iv) Developing a City Investment Plan and Financial Strategy

3.1 City Assessment: Analysis of Existing Situation

These encompass:-

o An analysis of the existing situation focusing on demographic analysis and economic


activities, land use, urban infrastructure and urban services (like transportation,
parking, water supply, sanitation, sewerage, solid waste management, drainage)
heritage and environment slum upgrading and financial and managerial implications;

o The financial status of the City Government and parastatals and other agencies
dealing with the service provision including an analysis of their credit worthiness,
effectiveness and efficiency of the institutional frameworks;

o Critical assessment as well as projections of the population growth, floating


population, tourism infrastructure needs and resource requirements in the short-
term, medium term and long-term perspective;

o Urban poverty, characteristics of slums e.g social set up, availability of urban basic
and social services and on-going slum improvement programmes;

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


ix
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

o Areas of inner city (urban renewal) which needs to be redeveloped; an analysis of


present status of availability of urban basic services including the condition of the
infrastructure;

o Identification of existing nature of commercial and industrial establishments and


identification of those industries and commercial establishments which are not in
conformity to the broadly existing land-use planning and zoning regulations in the
inner city areas.

o Heritage conservation as the major thrust of Mathura. This encompasses both, the
natural and manmade heritage.

o To highlight the “Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats” (SWOT


Analysis) of the City Government/ parastatal agencies and related Government
departments in the City’s specific context to provide an understanding of the factors
responsible for inefficient and inadequate production and delivery of urban services,
their managerial deficiencies and financial constraints and to highlight critical factors
which calls urgent remedial measures at the city and State governments level.

o Situational analysis in consultation with all the stakeholders and civil society at the
city level.

3.2 Development of Strategic Agenda and a Vision for the City

Based on the outcomes of the City Assessment, the second stage envisages:-

o Development of City Vision to guide the future development of the city highlighting
the direction of change and working out an Action agenda with a specific timeframe.
This is to be in consultation with all the stakeholders and civil society in the city. The
consultations focus also on broad assessment of municipal resources, possible
impact on the municipal budget and the proposal for reform to support development.

o Based on the Vision, strategies focusing attention on growth management,


redevelopment of the inner-city, urban infrastructure and basic services, slum
improvement, housing for the poor, and provision of basic and social services for
them, consultation of heritage areas, preservation of water bodies, and
redevelopment of inner city areas;

o A strategy identifying key strategic issues, risks and opportunities facing the city with
focus on reform and reform priorities;

o Defining outcomes and milestones on the Vision and ensure these are measurable
and have a timeframe;

3.3 Evolving Strategies for Development

This element of work involves highlighting interventions to operationalize the Vision and
future development of the city. This includes:
o Identification of options and strategies and their evaluation keeping in view their
contribution to the goals, objectives and the reform agenda of the JNNURM.
o Translating the strategies into programmes and projects and
o Identifying the programmes which have maximum / optimum contribution to the
achievement of city’s Vision and medium term perspectives.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


x
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Prioritization of the strategies, programmes and projects needs to be done on a consultative


process with all the stakeholders.

3.4 Developing a City Investment Plan and Financing Strategy

Preparation of City Investment Plan (CIP) which includes:-

o The level of investment requirements to implement the CDP by adopting the


financial norms or standards for service provision and their upgradation, restoration,
relocation etc, and directly estimating the cost of implementing the reform agenda.

o Evaluation of financial options and strategies for financing the Vision as enumerated
in the CDP.

o Areas in which city government could finance by mobilizing resources or in


association with other tiers of government or financing institutions, access to capital
market or enlist the private sector participation and the steps needed to facilitate its
participation etc.

o Broad strategies for financial viability of the proposed investments and improving
financial sustainability. This would includes options for PPP in service delivery and /
or O&M, wherever relevant. The investment schedule lay out the costs and revenue
estimates of all priority projects in the next seven years of the Mission period. The
preparation of CIP would be an iterative process requiring the adjustments and
rescheduling to make the whole package work financially.

4. The JN-NURM – Heritage Context

Initially launched for 60 cities in 2005 as a 7-year programme, currently there are 63 cities
in the Mission. Of these 8 are classified as Heritage Cities-viz:-
o Mathura, Mysore, Puri, Bodhgaya, Ajmer-Pushkar, Ujjain, Haridwar and
Nanded (Primarily of Cultural - Historical or Pilgrimage Tourism significance).
Two others are of tourism significance-viz Srinagar and Naini Tal. Of the other
53 cities, 35 are metros (including Varanasi and Amritsar) and 18 are State
Capitals. These too have heritage to be conserved, including the metros of
Amritsar and Varanasi.
Initially a single toolkit was issued for all 63 cities. However, a supplementary toolkit is being
devised by MoUD and INTACH for heritage conservation and where.
a) Heritage conservation is the main component (as in the 8 cities above,
including Mathura)
b) Heritage enhancement is a major concern (as in the other 55 cities)
The CDP for Mathura has accordingly been restructured to fit into the draft supplementary
toolkit without losing the renewal focus of Mathura.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


xi
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION A: MATHURA REGIONAL CONTEXT


A1 THE IMPORTANCE OF MATHURA CITY AND ITS HERITAGE

A1.1 Introduction

Mathura– the birthplace of Lord Krishna is one of the prime destinations for pilgrimage in
India. The contiguous settlement of Vrindavan is intrinsically related to this pilgrimage. Also
a majority of devotees visit Goverdhan in its vicinity. Accordingly, catering to a floating
population with focus on the river Yamuna is a major requirement in a plan for Mathura. At
the same time, this group of settlements is strategically located. The national expressway
(North-South corridor) cuts through the area and practically the entire southbound rail traffic
from Delhi and North West India is dispersed at Mathura Junction for both goods and
people. Rail traffic to Rajasthan via Alwar and to central UP via Hathras also converges on
Mathura. The proposed Agra-Noida Expressway east of the Yamuna would further add to
the accessibility of Mathura.

Therefore along with pilgrim convergence and related religious-cultural tourism, enhancing
the importance of the river Yamuna, national transportation dispersal of goods and people
by road and rail, placed on the authorities a heavy responsibility of regulated development
in a major and growing concentration of regular inhabitants and floating population within a
major district of U.P. Along with this, the growing gap in civic infrastructure required
coordinated actions by the urban and rural local bodies of Mathura District working in unison
with the Mathura Vrindavan Development Authority (MVDA) and District Authorities. These
issues were addressed in the Perspective Plan proposed for the Mathura Vrindavan Area
(MVA) with a 20 year perspective (2000-21) by the MVDA.

A1.2 Mathura at the Core of the MVA

Though the 3 established foci of the expanded MVA are the religious settlements of a)
Mathura, b) Vrindavan and c) Govardhan requiring the footprints of these to be protected
and enhanced along with their temples, parikramas, kunds and other benchmarks along
with river Yamuna and its bunds, the proposals herein are for Mathura city and which has a
Nagar Palika Parishad (NPP) within the larger MVA region. This priority is justified due to
Mathura City being at the core of the Braj Boomi and the entreport of this group of
settlements. Accordingly its environment needs serious renewal for the benefit of both – its
residents and the accelerating floating population of pilgrims-regional, national and
international to the larger Mathura-Vrindavan area and also to Goverdhan. However, the
census considers the Mathura NP and Mathura Cantonment as a common Urban
Agglomeration (UA). Thus for purposes of bulk urban services, the cantonment would also
be considered in this programme.

A1.3 The Heritage of Mathura

The religious city of Mathura has a railway junction, which is the entry point to this group of
settlements. A long line of ghats with their steps leading to the edge of the Yamuna,
arched gateways and temple spires extending along the western bank of the River Yamuna,
emphasize the sacred character of Mathura. An ancient settlement with origins embedded
in history, Mathura was strategically located at the cross roads of various trade routes that
went to West Asia and the Roman Empire; to Central Asia, via Taxila, Pushkalavati and
Purushapur and the Silk Route and eastwards to China. This ensured its position as a
centre of trade and a meeting point for varied cultures.
Today, it is a city of temples and shrines with thousands of devotees who come each day to
visit the city of Lord Krishna. An imposing temple at the Katra Keshav Dev marks the spot

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


1
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

that is believed to be the Shri Krishna Janmasthan – the birthplace of Lord Krishna. Another
impressive shrine, the Gita Mandir located on the Mathura-Vrindavan Road has a fine
image of Lord Krishna in its sanctum. The whole of the Bhagwad Gita is inscribed on the
walls of the temple. A popular shrine is the
Dwarikadhish Temple to the north of the town,
dedicated to Lord Krishna and built in 1815.
The settlement stretches along the west bank
of the Yamuna and the continuous line of
ghats along the river are best viewed from the
opposite bank. The ghats are believed to
have been built at the sites of ancient
ashrams, where the great sages performed
their penances on both the west and east
banks. These are pilgrimage spots today
especially the west bank which are centres of
religious and cultural activity, where the Holi Gate ( Tilak Dwar) : 1847
people come to have their ritual dips in the
holy river. Of 37 identified Ghats in Mathura
24 are of significance of which the most important is the Vishram Ghat, where according to
legend, Lord Krishna took his rest after killing Kansa.
It is at Vishram Ghat that the traditional Braja Mandala parikrama (circumambulation of all
the important religious and cultural spots of the settlement) starts and ends. The 12 ghats to
the north of Vishram Ghat include the Ganesh Ghat, Dashashwamedh Ghat with its
Neelakantheshwar Temple, Saraswati
Sangam Ghat, Chakratirtha Ghat,
Krishnaganga Ghat, Somatirth or Swami
Ghat, Ghantagharan Ghat, Dharapattan Ghat,
Vaikuntha Ghat, Navtirtha or Varahkshetra
Ghat, Asikunda Ghat, and Manikarnika Ghat.
To the south, there are 11 ghats - the
Guptatirth Ghat, Prayag Ghat marked by the
Veni Madhav Temple, Shyam Ghat, Ram
Ghat, Kankhal Ghat, the site of the
Janmashtami and Jhula festivals, Dhruva
Ghat, Saptrishi Ghat, Mokshatirth Ghat, Surya
Ghat, Ravan Koti Ghat, and Buddha Ghat.
Some of Mathura's most important shrines Potra Kund : Krishna Janam Bhoomi
are found around Vishram Ghat - the Mukut,
Radha-Damodar, Murli Manohar,
Neelkantheshwar, Yamuna-Krishna, Langali Hanuman and Narasimha temples. The
baithak of the great Vaishnava, Shri Chaitanya, is also near by.

History tells us that this important site was


ravaged and patronized in equal measure over
the ages. It was badly damaged during early
invasions but two Vaishnavite saints, Keshav
Kashmiri and Vallabhacharya restored its
sanctity during the time of Sikander Lodhi. It
received patronage during the rule of Akbar
when the temples were repaired and
embellished but again time and events took
their toll.

View of Vishram Ghat from Yamuna River

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


2
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

No pilgrimage to Mathura is complete


without a visit to its kunds. Tradition has
it that there were 159 ancient kunds. Of
these only four survive today. There is
the elegant Shiv Tal, the more famous
Potara Kund associated closely with
Lord Krishna besides the Balbhadra and
Saraswati kunds. Since then, the Braj
Foundation have identified another eight
kunds that are worthy of being restored.
These are Talab Wali Dharamshala,
Yogmaya, Mahavidya, Gokarneshwar,
Chamunda, Kankali, Chaktra Teerth and
Naag. Dedicated efforts are required to
restore and beautify these kunds

The city has a number of Shaivite


temples as well. The chief among these
are the Bhuteshwar Mahadev Temple in
the west of the town, the Gokarneshwar
Temple in the north, the Rangeshwar
Mahadev Temple in the south and the Pipaleshwar Mahadev Temple to the east. The
Mathura parikrama, and the bunds in relation to the river is highlighted in Map A1.

The Parikramas of Goverdhan and Vrindavan are of equal importance. They all come within
the larger Braja Mandala Parikrama. Of these religious historical areas, only the Mathura
Nagar Palika Parishad area of the Mathura UA area is currently part of the JNNURM. It is
therefore analyzed for urban services, urban renewal projects, basic services for the urban
poor, urban reforms and strengthening of the local body through a Vision Plan and City
Development Plan (CDP) and City Investment Plan (CIP).

A1.4 The Need for a Mathura Vision

A city development plan for Mathura NPP area has to sit within a 20 year spatial
vision that is different from that of other metropolitan areas or state capitals.
Conservation becomes a central part of the development process in Mathura. Thus a
synergy emerges between a cultural-historical tourism magnet as a pilgrim centre
catering to an increasing number of pilgrims of modest to low income levels. In this
process the relationship of Mathura NPP, Mathura Cantonment, the Mathura MVDA
and Mathura district assumes significance.

A2 THE CONTEXT FOR THE MATHURA CITY VISION AND ITS CDP

A2.1 The Broader Objectives

With the 73rd (rural) and 74th (urban) constitution amendment acts (CAA’s), several states
have focussed on State Development Vision Plans (20 years) e.g. Jharkhand, Chattisgarh.
In the State of Uttar Pradesh (UP) however a state vision gets blurred due to the sheer size
of the state. Nonetheless, several state level sectoral vision documents have been prepared
notably in terms of agriculture, tourism, housing and transport. These would undoubtedly
be integrated in the State Spatial Strategy Plan when prepared. In the meanwhile, the
Development Authorities of the large urban agglomerations of UP have prepared Vision
Plans for their operational areas. It is envisaged that such vision or guidance plans would

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


3
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

be processed as broad brush Spatial Strategy Plans for the development authority areas.
For the MVDA jurisdiction, within Mathura district, this is of particular significance as it looks
at three municipalities (nagar palikas), eight Nagar Panchayats and one cantonment, within
all the three Tehsils of Mathura District and in all its 10 Blocks. Therefore the Draft District
Development Plan (DDP) as required under the 73rd CCA and legislatively catered to
under State Acts, can advantageously be addressed so as to make its interface with
the MVA Prespective Plan meaningful. The specific vision plan for Mathura City
would fit well in this DPC framework. It would also facilitate the Mathura CDP. This
fact is underlined upfront in this report as unlike a majority of the other 63
settlements in the mission, Mathura UA would not be a candidate for a Metropolitan
Planning Committee (MPC) for a very long time.

Thus Mathura UA and NPP within Mathura DPC has to deal with several negative impacts.
These include:

x Increasing mixed traffic and resultant congestion, pollution and


environmental degradation;
x Encroachments on environmentally sensitive areas (particularly the
Yamuna banks, water bodies (Kunds), areas round religious buildings,
forests and orchards and
x Increasing demand for urban services, particularly the supply of potable
water and power and the treatment of wastewater, collection and disposal
of solid waste and improved drainage.

These impacts are broadly addressed in the approved MVDA Plan 2021 through.

x A viable spatial framework for social and economic investments over a 20-
year period.
x To a recognition and building on the distinctive characteristics of the MVA
particularly in terms of its religious and cultural values, history and natural
systems.
x Stress on a continual improvement for good governance through
transparency, participation, accountability and effective management.

Thus in the MVDA Plan 2021 implicitly for Mathura UA (NPP + Cant.), the key focus has
been on:

x Proposals catering to a religious-cultural tourism based on its growing


floating pilgrim population due to Braj incorporating Mathura, Vrindavan,
Goverdhan, the Yamuna and its ghats and the Kunds;
x Small- scale pilgrim related industrial growth;
x The impact of the North South expressway that cuts through the district;
x The impact of the Taj Expressway linking Agra to Noida east of the
Yamuna, and
x The rapid growth of Mathura as a key railway junction for goods and
people;
x The sanitization of low income pockets and / or their insitu reconstruction
where access to livelihoods is of importance.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


4
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

A2.2 The Contextual Framework

In the case of the MVA, assessment of the District and its three Tehsils were the essential
starting points for a development strategy for the MVA. In this process the MVDA mobilised
and engaged the state and its offices, central government departments pertaining to rail,
road, defence needs, refinery, etc., the various participating local bodies, the religious,
social, cultural and business, trade and manufacturing interests, the community, NGOs,
CBOs and other stakeholders within a wider participatory process. The rapid appraisal of
the Mathura Nagar Palika had taken into account this contextual framework by the MVDA
for the Braj region.

Also, over the last decade there has been a critical change in the roles and functions of
urban development agencies. This has led to serious concerns about the functioning of
urban local bodies in people centric programmes and for which there are no alternatives to
local government and their disaggregated wards as a basic unit of urban governance. For
this, urban local bodies have to set themselves with a vision for the development of their
geographic area. For this, the Mathura Vrindavan Development Authority’s (MVDA) 20-year
perspective plan 2021, programmed into five yearly phases for a balanced and integrated
urban development of the wider Mathura Vrindavan area provides the basis. On this the
Mathura NPP is to flesh out its vision plan over a 20 year framework and enfold its City
Development Plan (CDP) for 5 years to be extended by another 2 years. Therefore, unlike
other exercises under JNNURM, the Vision, CDP, CIP and projects for the Heritage
City of Mathura has perforce to sit into the larger perspective for Braj as projected in
the perspective plan 2021 for the MVDA and which has undergone an intensive
consultative process over the past two years. In this exercise, the basic urban
services needs of the cantonment is also considered.

In a subsequent exercise a vision and CDP for Vrindavan could be enmeshed in this form of
synergetic sustainable development for this prime cultural historical area of Braj.

A3. THE STATE, DISTRICT AND MVA DETERMINANTS FOR THE MATHURA
VISION AND CDP

A3.1 The State Context

Map A2 shows the geographic location of the


State of UP within India. It is the central
component of the great north Indian alluvium
through which the Ganges and Yamuna and
various tributaries meander. Some of the
busiest rail and road routes pass through this
largely agrarian state with accelerating
success stories towards industrialisation and
improving infrastructure. The belt has a better
ground water base than most parts of India.

Uttar Pradesh is the most populous State of


the country (166.52 million in 2001). In area
(0.24 million sq.km.) however it is smaller
than Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh,
Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh. The high
decadal growth of population of the State -
25.80 per cent between 1991-2001 against
the national average of 21.34 per cent in this
period is a cause for concern. In fact, UP is
Map A2: State of Uttar Pradesh within India

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


5
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

one of the few states where the decadal growth rate has been higher in 1991-2001 than in
the previous decade of 1981-91 (25.55 per cent – UP but 23.86 per cent – All India). Also,
the sex-ratio of 898 in 2001 has been lower than the All India average of 933 and the
literacy rate in this period was just 57.36 per cent against the national average of 65.38 per
cent. Worse still, the female literacy rate has been a low 42.98 per cent against the all India
average of 54.16 per cent. These disadvantageous comparisons offer a challenge to the
State and which has nearly a 17 per cent representation in the National Parliament (nearly
one in every seven).

In 2001, barely 20.78 per cent of the population of the State were in urban areas (against
27.78 per cent at the All India level). However, this population spread over 633 urban
settlements, accounted for 12.72 per cent of the national urban population and which was
just behind Maharashtra with 14.38 per cent (largely round the Mumbai region). Primarily
population shifts in UP are intra-state from rural to urban. There is also substantial
movements outside the state notably to the mega city of Delhi and even Mumbai.

A3.2 Agra Division

The state is divided into 70 districts as


per the census 2001. These are
grouped into 17 divisions. Seven
districts comprise of Agra division.
These districts as per census 2001 are
Agra, Mathura, Aligarh, Hathras,
Ferozabad, Etah and Mainpuri (refer
map A3)

The divisional headquarters are at Agra


and which at the urban agglomeration
level is one of the 35 metropolitan areas
of India. The division has three of the
Major 20 development authorities of the
State viz. Agra, Mathura-Vrindavan and
Aligarh. The river Yamuna passes
through the division and which is an
integral part of the flat north Indian
alluvium. It is therefore rich in agriculture
produce. More importantly, the Yamuna
contributes to its religious and
pilgrimage fervour especially in the
western districts of Mathura and Agra.
Historical-cultural tourism is a major
economic activity in Agra District just
as pilgrim tourism makes Mathura-
Vrindavan a destination. Therefore
substantial central and state
government resources have been
allotted for infrastructure improvements
in the division – notably in the national
expressway (as a tollway) and in
upgrading state and district roads,
railway guage conversion and
doubling/electrification of broad guage
tracks, environmental improvement of
the Yamuna and its tributaries, improved

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


6
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

air connectivity, tourism infrastructure, small scale industries, tertiary sector activities and
other forms of social and physical infrastructure. Laterly, the State Government has
spearheaded the Agra-Noida expressway as the Taj Expressway. This is going to have a
major impact on the growth of the division.

The Commissioner of Agra division is the Chairman of the Mathura-Vrindavan Development


Authority in addition to his other duties.

A3.3 Mathura District

Mathura District is bounded by the State of Rajasthan to its west, the State of Haryana to its
north and the Agra division districts of Aligarh to its east, Etah and Firozabad to its south-
east and Agra to its south (Refer Map No.A4).The district has an area of 3,329.40 sq. kms
and its population was 20.70 lakhs in 2001. In 1991, its population was 16.49 lakhs giving a
decennial increase of 20.00 percent against 25.80 percent for the state as a whole.

As shown on Map A4 the district comprises of three tehsils and ten blocks (Refer table 1A):

Table 1A: Tehsils and Blocks of Mathura District


Sr. No. Tehsil Block Block Area in Sq. Kms
1. Mathura Mathura 415.90
Govardhan 371.60
Farah 272.20
Baldeo 324.30
2. Chhata Chhata 402.70
Nandgaon 332.40
Chaumuha 309.10
3. Mant Mant 270.40
Raya 242.20
Nauhjhil 345.90
Sub Total 3,286.70 sq. kms
Yamuna River Bed 42.70 sq. kms
Total 3,329.40 sq. kms
Source: MVDA Plan 2021

A3.4 The District Profile

A3.4.1 The river Yamuna meanders through the district. The district has 734 inhabited
villages; these are grouped into 89 rural panchayats. It has 16 urban settlements of which
three have nagar palikas viz. Mathura, Vrindavan and Chhata. The other 13 have nagar
panchayats. In 2001, the average density of the District was 622 persons per sq. km (689
for the State). In 1991 the sex ratio was 816 females per 1000 males. In the same period,
the literacy rate was 35.28 percent (approximately 67 percent male and 23 percent female).
In 2001, the literacy rates have improved to be nearly at par with the state but yet, it is far
below the national average, especially the female rate. Thus, though the district is
heavily transversed by train and road, its rural component in particular remains
underdeveloped both socially and economically. The main urban areas however are
comparatively better off due to the large floating (pilgrimage) population throughout the year
and its related economic activities.Table 1B indicates the estimated Tehsil and blockwise
population and density of the District as estimated from the census of 2001 and by the
MVDA.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


7
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
Table 1B: Tehsil and Block Populations / Density – 2001 (estimates)
Approx. Approx
Approx Approx
Block Area Block Tehsil
S.N Tehsil Block Tehsil Block
in Sq. Kms Pop.in Pop. in
density density
lakh lakh
6.02 (UA)
Mathura 415.90 1,944
2.09(rest)
1. Mathura Govardhan 371.60 1.61 12.50 903 434
Farah 272.20 1.19 438
Baldeo 324.30 1.59 490
Chhata 402.70 1.44 358
2. Chhata Nandgaon 332.40 1.06 3.61 346 319
Chaumuha 309.10 1.11 360
Mant 270.40 1.41 522
3. Mant Raya 242.20 1.62 4.59 535 668
Nanjhil 345.90 1.56 451
Sub Total 3286.70 20.70 630
River bed 42.70 nil nil
Total 3,329.40 20.70 622
The density indicated in table 1B above is incorporated in map form (Map A5).
Source: MVDA Plan 2021

Apart from the urban concentration of Mathura-Vrindavan in Mathura block, the overall
density is highest in Mant tehsil and lowest in Chhata tehsil. This indicates that growth is
geared eastwards towards the other districts of UP rather than towards Haryana and
west towards Rajasthan. However, the road and rail system as emerging are at present
governing the growth of the district through the expanded MVA under the MVDA. This
favours Chhata tehsil rather than Mant tehsil east of the Yamuna. However, the proposed
Agra- Noida expressway would
change the growth profile of the
district, towards Mant block of the
District

A3.4.2 Climate

The average annual rainfall of the


district is around 800 mm. 85
percent of this is received during the
south-west monsoon period; the rest
is received during winter. As in most
other districts of northern India, the
summers are dry and hot whereas
the winters are cool. Winds are
generally light and are mainly from
the south-west to the north-east
direction. During the monsoons, the
wind directions often are from the
north-east to the south-east.

A3.4.3 Vegetation

According to the forest department less than 100 sq. kms of land is occupied by forests.
However, vegetation along the river is increasing and the refinery and its townships has
undertaken large forestation programmes to arrest pollution to monuments especially the
Taj Mahal – some 50 kms to its south. It has to be borne in mind that the belt around

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


8
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Vrindavan was at one time the forest associated with Lord Krishna and the need to reforest
this wide tract of land through expertise in natural historical heritage needs to be stressed.

A3.4.4 Agriculture

The soil of the district is reasonably fertile. Substantial agriculture land prevails, where
wheat, maize and barley are mainly grown. The recently announced State Agriculture Vision
requires that land under cultivation, orchards, horticulture, floriculture, pisiculture and dairy
and poultry farming be retained and enhanced in production. Despite this, Mathura District
over the years witnessed a steady decline in produce and resultant outward migration.

A3.4.5 Transportation

Mathura District is one of the most important Districts of India in terms of both destination
and transit of people as also for the transit of goods. This established the centrality of
Mathura City (Refer Map A6). The busy broad guage double track electrified rail line from
Delhi to South India bifurcates at Mathura between west bound (Mumbai) and south bound
(Chennai) transit. Also the line from Agra to Jaipur via Mathura and Alwar has been
converted to broad guage single track. It is expected that this would become an electrified
double track line in due course.

The metre guage from Agra to Hathras / Barielly via Mathura is also expected to convert to
broad guage over the next 10 years. Thus Mathura would not only be a junction for transit
transportation for goods and people
but also a major rail traffic monitoring
centre. It has also to be underlined
that it is a destination for pilgrims from
not only North India but also from
East, West and South India. In fact,
there is a railway surcharge on fares
for Mathura; this is meant for
improving pilgrim facilities in and
around the station.

National Highway 2 passing through


Mathura has since been converted
into the North South Expressway. In
fact from Delhi to Agra it is a six lane
tollway. This has completely
restructured development in the
district. The state highway from
Bareilly to Alwar passes through Mathura
Mathura. This is also being widened
along with other district roads so as to Road
offer better road connectivity to
pilgrims and other tourists over a wide Rail
area.
Map A6: Trunk Rail & Road Linkages to Mathura
There are no prospects of an air strip
at Mathura with the airport of Agra being quite near and the international airport at Palam,
Delhi being reasonably accessible. However, the proposed Taj Expressway project of a 160
km link from Agra to Noida – all east of the Yamuna and totally within UP, would open up
the belt east of the Yamuna for industrial growth. For this the Taj Expressway Industrial
Development Authority (TEIDA) under the UP Industrial Development Act has been set up.
This would require links from the MVA to the Taj Expressway apart from links to the north-

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


9
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

South corridor. These regional transport


determinants are explained in Map No.A7

River transport has no prospects but the


cleansing of the Yamuna and its
environmental improvement is a major
exercise and for which the MVDA have a
major role to play within the Yamuna Action
Plan project, especially along the bunds of
Mathura and Vrindavan due to their special
religious significance.

The refinery adjoining Mathura to its south is


an important activity in terms of import of
crude and its refinement for distribution by
rail and road. The township is self-contained
and there are several ancillary units along
this node. Due to these developments the
MVA area is destined to grow between the
river and on either side of the expressway in
the blocks of Mathura, Govardhan, Farah,
Baldeo in Mathura tehsil and blocks of
Chhata, Nandgaon and Chaumuha in the
tehsil of Chhata. Thereby the tehsil east of
the river is being given less of development
priorities and more of environmental control.

A3.4.6 Services

At the district level, water supply is most crucial. The district relies mainly on ground water.
The Yamuna should have offered a perennial source. Unfortunately Delhi sends the surface
water downstream in a highly polluted state. The industrial belt of Faridabad-Balabgarh-
Palwal in Haryana further compounds the problem. Thus Mathura-Vrindavan receives
unusable water and for which the Central Control Pollution Board (CPCB) has not yet been
able to propose and enforce implementable corrective actions. The district therefore is
heavily dependent on ground water and for which water tables are receding and salinity is
fast creeping in. Agriculture and allied activities are already adversely affected and new
industries are not being attracted. A water management plan is therefore required at the
national and state level with the MVDA as active partners for settlement development. To
increase surface water intake, a barrage across Yamuna, north of Vrindavan is on the anvil,
on lines of Gokul barrage.

Electricity is through the grid and this is regulated at the State level. The refinery and its
township have a captive standby system. For settlements development, the MVDA is
required to seek an enhanced supply.

A3.4.7 Industries

The UP State Industrial Corporation estate in the Kosi Kalan-Nandgaon and Chhata belt
took off well but has now slowed down as Haryana is better placed vis-à-vis the NCT of
Delhi and the central NCR area through the Faridabad-Palwal belt. The refinery is now
programmed for its maximum utilisation. It has generated some ancillaries but household
and cottage industries are a major source of employment in the District. In general,
industrial growth in the district has reached saturation levels; but there is scope for
household and cottage industries. Some hope emerges with the Agra-Noida expressway for

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


10
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

industries in the Mant tehsil. At Kosi-Kalan/Nangdaon and Chhata, revival of vacant


industrial plot is an objective with some guarded expansion based on improved
infrastructure like power and water and timely disposal of waste after environmental
safeguards.

A4. THE MVA PLAN-2021 AND MATHURA CITY

A4.1 Institutional Imperatives

The UP Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 (UPUPD Act’73) under which the
MVDA was established as a Planning and Development Authority for the MVA ensures that
the Authority is vested with the responsibility of preparing and enforcing the development
plan for the MVA. The MVDA is in addition empowered to declare any area within its
jurisdiction as a “Development Area” for
providing serviced land and for carrying
out and permitting development.

However, the 73rd and 74th CAA specifies


new planning responsibilities to LSG. The
12th Schedule of the CAA has listed 18
LSG functions. Most of these are already
included in the list of obligatory and
discretionary functions in the Uttar
Pradesh Municipalities Act 1994 (UPM
Act’94). In the process, the need for a
synergy between the 2nd and 3rd tiers of
governance and planned development
has surfaced. Under this, Building Bye-
laws is an LSG function and not a
Development Authority function just as
development control regulations are
part of the Master Plan/Development
Plan and would accordingly be in the Map A8-MVA Master Plan area 1981-2001 within
purview of the MVDA. the District.

A4.2 The Statutory Master Plan for The MVA – 1981-2001 as Extended to 2021

The State Town and Country Planning Department prepared a plan for Mathura-Vrindavan
for the period 1981-2001 for the MVD Authority. This was processed as an approved plan
by the MVDA covering the nagar palikas of Mathura and Vrindavan, the cantonment of
Mathura and part of the block of Farah (due to the location of the Oil Refinery in Mathura
District). 79 adjoining villages (a few of which are east of the Yamuna) complete the Master
Plan area of approx 215 sq. kms.

Map A8 shows approximately the area covered by the Master Plan. It incorporate 4 of the
10 blocks of the district.

Table 1C shows the population projections of this area.

Table 1C Population projections MVDA – 2021


Jurisdiction Area in Sq. Kms. Population in lakh
2021
1981 2001
estimates
MVDA area 215 5.75 8.10. 14.00
Source: MVDA Plan 2021

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


11
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

In 1981, this area had a population


of 5.75 lakhs and by 2001 it had
8.10 lakhs people, excluding the
regular round the year floating
population and which did not vary
much. It is only during key festival
periods (and which are also
frequent) that there is a population
bulge requiring special
arrangements. A matrix of uses
allowed in each zone with Zoning
Regulations is part of this plan. The
perspective of this plan was
recently extended to 2021 but with
no perceptible change in land use
patterns. This is perhaps due to
the fact that most new areas of
growth (1981-2001) are yet in the
process of being developed. This
plan with the extended timeframe,
has been approved. Mathura
Nagar Palika is at the core of this
Plan. The approved land use plan
is shown as Map A9.

The proposed land use distribution


according to this master plan (1980-
2001) and as extended upto 2021 is
shown in table 1D and the pie
diagram below: Map A9: Land Use for MVA 1981-2001

Table 1D: Proposed Land use Distribution MVDA 1981-2001

Land Use Area (in Hect) Percentage


1. Existing Built up area
a) Urban 1,463 6.80
b) Rural 416 1.93
2. Residential
(including Oil Township) 2,775 12.91
3. Ashram Complex 439 2.04
4. Public and Semi Public 463 2.15
5. Trade and Commerce 200 0.93
6. Restricted zone 384 1.79
7. Industries
a) Service + Small scale 600 2.80
b) Refinery 840 3.91
8. Public Open Space 263 1.22
9. Reserved Forest 286 1.33
10. Traffic and Transportation 565 2.63
11. Sewage Farm 500 2.32
12. Flood Plains 1,804 8.40
13. Agricultural 10,500 48.84
21,498
Total say 215 Sq. Kms. 100.00

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


12
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Nearly half the area is shown as an ‘agricultural belt’. Of the rest, only about a third
comprises of the 1981 existing settlements of Mathura, Vrindavan, Civil Lines and villages -
as mixed uses zones. Large areas have been shown for residential use. The refinery, the
Cantonment and the railways occupy sizable lands. The reserved forest north of Vrindavan
has sparse tree cover but is part of the heritage of the area. The smaller reserved forest
near the refinery has dense foliage through finances primarily by Indian oil. Services,
programmes, projects and financial
Land Use Distribution of MVA, 2001
implications are not pointedly Exist ing Built up area

incorporated in this exercise. Thus, 7%


2%
Rural Area
Resident ial
the plan primarily addressed the Ashram Complex
13%
requirement of land use directions Rest rict ed Zone

and controls. Developments are Trade and Commerce

2% Industries
geared towards NH-2 (now the north- 49% 2% Public and Semi Public
south national expressway) and for 1% Public Open Space

which the plan had proposed a bye- 7% Transportat ion-Road & Rail
Reserved Forest
pass to its west but not found 2% Sewage Farm
1%
necessary now. 3%
1%
Floof Plains
2% Agricult ural belt
8%

A4.3 Objectives of the MVA Plan - 2021

The basic objectives of the approved Plan are to:

x Set limits for urbanisation for the period ending 2021, with links to the
existing surrounding urban settlements, central place villages and other
growth centres;
x Create a stable economic base for urban level activities;
x Remove congestion in the older parts of the city through an integrated
approach of clearance, conservation and rehabilitation;
x Upgrade or resettle slums;
x Improve basic infrastructure (water, sanitation, drainage etc.) and urban
facilities in terms of
education, health, lung
spaces etc. in existing
areas; and
x Improve the
transportation network
in relation to land uses,
so that traffic in the
inner city gets better
organised.

However the synergy between the


MVDA and local government and
line development agencies lacked
coordinated and programmed
actions and growth has largely
occurred by referencing to the plan
but not necessarily following it due
to lacunae in coordination,
implementation and enforcement.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


13
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

A4.4 The Proposed Extended MVA - Phase I

A decision was taken by the


government of UP in 1997 to extend the
jurisdiction of the MVA. This was done
largely along NH 2 towards the Haryana
border on the route to Delhi. The nagar
palika of Chhata and the nagar
panchayats of Chaumuha, Kosi Kalan
and Nandgaon and 37 intervening
villages were added. These accretions
were all in the Chhata tehsil of the
district.

The 215 sq. kms jurisdiction of the


MVDA was in the process extended by
another 59 sq. kms. This total does not
include the intervening agriculture area
other than 37 contingent villages.

The approximate jurisdiction of the


expanded MVDA of approximately 274
sq. kms within Mathura District is
shown in Map A10. No plan has yet
been approved for this extended area.

The government of U.P. has further decided that the MVA would be again extended
so as to include the nagar panchayats of Govardhan and Radhakund and 11
adjoining villages up to Mathura Vrindavan. Thereby, the responsibility of integrated
pilgrim wellbeing is to vest fully with the MVDA. This gives a planned development area
of approximately 350 sq. kms (refer Map No.A11). For this extended area too, no plan has
yet been approved.

A4.5 The Proposed Extended MVA –


Phase II

The Taj Expressway implies access to the


MVA towards its south i.e. via Farah-Baldeo
and its north between Chaumuha and
Vrindavan via Mant. Also the existing link
across the Yamuna to Aligarh would have to
be widened. In addition, all the additional
settlements would have to have a contiguous
plan. This would require approximately
another 100 sq. kms to be added to the
Development Plan. It also requires that all
the 3 tehsils and 10 blocks of Mathura District
are incorporated in part or full in the
Development Plan 2001-21

We would thus have a) Mathura District –


3,340 sq. kms and within it b) MV
development plan area – 450 sq. kms
(approx) – Refer Map A12 Map A12-The Extent of Development Plan
Area for MVA-2021
Due to recent accretions and transformation

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


14
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

in transportation profile only estimates were possible to the extended MVA proposals. The
State TP Department and the MVDA would be making the population projections on the
basis of definite population projections for this area and on the basis of definite
development boundaries to emerge in due course. Therefore empirically it is envisaged that
a population of around 20.00 lakhs by 2021 within about 450 sq. kms. of development plan
area would be a reasonable target to aim at. This excludes floating population round the
year and especially during the several festival and auspicious occasions. This is indicated in
table 1E below.

Table 1E: Population estimates for proposed extended MVDA – 2021


S.No. A Jurisdictions Area in Population in lakhs Remarks
Sq. Km.
1. Area approved 215 5.75 8.10 14.00 Includes Mathura NPP,
MVDA Plan 2021 Vrindavan NPP and Cant
2. Additional areas to 235 2.40 3.90 6.00 Includes Goverdhan,
be added to the (approx) Chhata, Chamuha,
MVDA in 2 Phases Nandgam and Kosi Kalai
Total 450 8.15 12.00 20.00
(approx)
Source: MVDA – Vision Report

In this scenario, Mathura NPP would cater primarily for natural increase and some in-
migration as it is almost exclusively an urban renewal area. There is scope for new
growth in Vrindavan, the cantonment and rest of the MVDA area.

A4.6 The Basis for a Mathura City Rapid Assessment

The above indicates the framework through which the vision for Mathura City (NPP) and its
CDP is to be generated. The MVDA has an approved perspective plan for 2021. An
update of this plan is on the anvil based on extensive consultants with the concerned
authorities, institutions, NGOs and individuals. These are very relevant in the current
exercise for the Mathure City Vision and its CDP through a fresh set of supportive data and
discussions in a form of a rapid assessment as indicated in the subsequent section.

x Mathura NPP has a jurisdiction of 28.5 sq. km. straddled between River Yamuna
(East) and NH2 bye-pass (West)
x Mathura tehsil (incorporating Mathura NPP, Vrindavan NPP and the contonment)
has the highest density in the district. Refer maps A5 and A8.
x It is at the core of the “Braj” religious node incorporating Mathura, Vrindavan &
Govardhan.
x For this jurisdiction, MVDA is to be expanded to about 450sq.km. (out of 3,340
sq.km. Mathura District).
x The regional exercise gives credence to this contextual equation through urban
renewal of Mathura city as the core of the Mathura-Vrindavan region and of which
Vrindavan is an equally important focus for the next traunch of renewal projects.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


15
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION B: MATHURA CITY: A RAPID APPRAISAL


B1. OVERVIEW: MATHURA CITY

B1.1 Approach and Methodology Adopted : City Assessment

The analysis of the existing situation is the first stage in the formulation of a CDP. The
purpose of the analysis is to make a realistic assessment of where the city is, the direction
in which it has been moving and its strengths and weaknesses. This stage is meant to
make an in-depth analysis of the demographic, economic, financial, infrastructural,
physical, environmental, and institutional aspects of the city and the implications thereof for
services delivery, management and governance. As a first step in preparation of City
Development Plan (CDP) for Mathura, the team was mobilized at head office and a series
of discussions were held about the approach and methodology for conducting the
exercise.

Based on the preliminary discussions


and field visits and interaction with the
key stakeholders, the approach adopted
was a four step process for conducting
the Rapid Assessment as a first stage in
the preparation of the City Development
Plan for Mathura. This assessment was
for Mathura UA comprising on Mathura
NPP and Mathura Cantonment.

The first step involved data collection


from various sources including
government departments, previous
studies conducted in the city for various
services, information available from Opening Launch Workshop (12 May) : City
other stakeholders / line agencies Development Plan for Mathura, Seen in the
Photograph from Left to Right: Mr. Pradeep Mathur,
involved in the services delivery and
MLA MVC, Mr. EFN Ribeiro, Team Leader IPE, Mr.
governance. There were very few S.K Singh, Administrator, NPP Mathura, Mr. Pradeep
studies conducted by the departments in Narian, Executive Officer (JNNURM) Mathura
the urban sector except for some
feasibility reports made at departmental level in water supply and sewerage. The data
available was very basic, as no proper MIS has been maintained by the respective
departments. The secondary data at city level was also not available on most subjects
though it was found that some data exists at the district level. No comprehensive data has
been maintained at city level. To discuss this and other issues, a launch workshop was
organized through the local MLA and the JayCees Club to sensitize and orient the people
regarding the CDP.

Based on the identified issues, the second step involved meetings and discussions with all
the stakeholders. The Expert Team visited the key departments and line agencies involved
and met senior officials for feedback on the preliminary issues confronting the city of
Mathura. A general feedback on various issues emerged through discussions, interactions
and official facts and figures provided during the meetings and discussions. The relevant
data related primarily to infrastructure and governance and for which proper records were
not available with the respective agencies especially the municipal body. The discussions
held with the key officials was in accordance to the requirements for the city assessment.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


16
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The third step involved visits to city and


cantonment areas to assess the
condition of various infrastructure
services and governance issues. The
issues related to water supply,
sewerage, drainage, solid waste
management, street lighting, roads,
traffic and transportation, heritage and
tourism, housing, squatter settlements
and governance and administration. The
issues were captured using audio-
visuals. However, meetings with senior
officials of the Cant was not possible.

The fourth step involved the analysis


and synthesis of the data collected and report preparation. Identification of the missing
links and gaps based on the feedback from the client and State Resource Centre (SRC)
and incorporation of the same in the final City Development Plan (CDP) for Mathura.

B1.2 City Profile

Mathura UA comprises of Mathura NPP and Mathura Cantonment. The agglomeration is


situated along the western banks of the river Yamuna, downstream of Delhi at 27o 35'
North and 78° 12’, East. The city is bounded by Govardhan, Chaumuha, Mant, Vrindavan,
Raya, Baldeo and Farah. The NPP has an area of around 28.5 sq. kms. and the Cant has
an area of about 9 sq. km. As per the census 2001, the population of the UA was around
3.23 lacs (3.02 in the NPP area and 0.21 in the Cant). Its floating population on normal
days is between 1.00 to 1.25 lakhs per day, whereas on festive and auspicious days it is
over twice the UA population. A large number of visitors pass through and as casual day
time visitors need facilities for rest, food and shopping. A smaller number of such visitors
need overnight accommodation. For dedicated pilgrim population, however, the average
stay is for 3 days in tents, guest houses, and modest to quality hotels.

Mathura is also a transport node for the agglomeration and district, by both rail and road.
Segregation and interface of inter and intracity road and rail movements of people is a
crucial component of an environmentally acceptable Mathura and which is to facilitate
pilgrim tourism.

B1.3 History and Growth

The city of Mathura is among the seven most important holy cities of India and is one of
the oldest inhabited sites of Uttar Pradesh. For more than a millennium and even prior to
the medieval period (about the twelfth century A.D), the place had been an important
centre simultaneously of the three chief Indian religious systems, the Brahmanical, the Jain
and the Buddhist. Subsequently, it became a stronghold of the Krishna-bhakti cult. It is
believed that Krishna was born in the city of Mathura and passed his early life in its
neighbourhood. Most of the important places in the district are associated with one or
another event connected with the Krishna legend. There is ample evidence to believe that
the district was far more pastoral than agricultural in early times, as indicated by many of
its place names such as Braj (herd of cattle) and Mathura (town of churns).

Mathura continued to hold a prime position in Indian history throughout. The celebrated
poet Kalidas praised the city of Mathura, the river Yamuna, the Goverdhan hill and the
Vrindavan grove. It found mention in the records of Fahien who stayed there. It continued
to hold its religious importance in one of the greatest centres of artistic activity during the

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


17
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

golden age of Indian history, the Gupta age. It again found mention in the records of Hiuen
Tsang (629-645 AD) who stayed there. Mathura then fell in the hands of Mahmood of
Ghazni. It found specific mention in the accounts by Alberuni who came in the wake of
Mahmud’s invasions. Though Mathura lost its political importance in the 12th century, it
was still a city of religious significance. Mahaban was the gathering place for the armies of
Iltutmish (1211-36) in his expeditions against Kalanjar. The jungles of Mathura were the
favourite hunting grounds of the Mughal emperors. It is connected with some important
events in Aurangzeb’s life. His eldest son was born there in 1639. In 1666, Shivaji after
escaping from Aurangzebs army in Agra had come to Mathura. After Mughal rule it came
under the Jats who gave refuge to many from Delhi during Nadirshah’s invasion and also
during the invasion of Ahmad Shah Abdali. Mathura’s environs were important battlefields
when East India Company started coming into power and also during the military moves of
the British forces to take over Bharatpur, Indore, etc. The Jats of Mathura district gave a
good fight to the British forces. Mathura also played an important part in the independence
movement.

B1.4 Mathura Nagar Palika

Mathura has had a Municipality from the late 19th century. This is now called the
Nagar Palika Parishad (NPP) and which is divided into 45 wards, each with a ward
councilor. Currently, the Councilors are not in place due to an issue in court.
However, the ward comprises a legal municipal unit for development, conservation,
and maintenance. Their jurisdictions are shown in Map B1 below:

MAP B1: MUNICIPAL WARDS (45 WARDS)

In Mathura, most community actions are invariably on a ward basis,


irrespective whether an elected councillor is in place or not. At present each
ward has between 5000 to 7000 inhabitants. Density is highest in the inner
core and where mixed use predominates.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


18
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The Agglomeration also incorporates the cantonment which is about 9 kms in area. This
includes an operation area for oil distribution near the railway junction apart from other
operational areas. The sub-area commander is head of the Cantonment Planning Board
(CPB), operating under the Cantonment Board Act, 1924. The development is low
intensity with well appointed education and health facilities. In 1991, the CPB had less
than 7,400 persons but by 2001 it grew to around 20,500. It is now projected to hold about
41,000 people in 2011 and about 72,000 persons in 2021. Therefore, urban services are
to be provided in unison with the NPP. These populations do not include military personal,
emunerated at their command level.

B1.5 Population Growth and Projections

The population of Mathura Agglomeration in 1991 was 2.36 lakhs which increased to 3.23
lakhs in the year 2001.This included the cantonment but not the daytime floating
population which puts additional pressure on the city infrastructure. Refer table 2A below:

Table 2A: Decadal Growth Rates. Mathura UA


Sr. No. Year Population Decadal Growth Rate (%)
1. 1941 0.77 -
2. 1951 0.99 26.61
3. 1961 1.17 18.68
4. 1971 1.32 12.88
5. 1981 1.47 11.71
6. 1991 2.33 47.90
7. 2001 3.23 37.00
Source: Census of India

The UA has witnessed a rapid growth over the past five decades with an average decadal
growth rate of 28.04%. During the period 1981-91 the decadal growth rate has been about
47.90% attributed to a large influx of rural population to the city. However during the past
decade 1991-2001, the growth rate has stabilized with a decadal population growth of
35.30%.

Table 2B shows the population projections for the Mathura UA comprising of the NPP and
the Cant.

Table 2B: Population projections for Mathura UA – 2021


Sr. Description Area in Population Population Decennial Growth Rates
No. Sq. Actual (in projected (in
Km lakhs) lakhs)
1991 2001 2011 202181-91 91-01 01-11 11-21
1 NPP 28.50 2.27 3.02 3.87 4.80
53.70 35.30 30.00 28.00
2 Cant.(approx) 9.00 0.06 0.21 0.41 0.72
-23.10 121.10 100.00 75.00
3 Total UA 37.50 2.33 3.23 4.28 5.52
47.90 35.30 30.00 28.00
(approx)
Source: Census of India for actuals and projections based on MVDA Plan 2021.

The normal day time floating population based on entries by UP Dept. of Tourism and local
police is about 1.00 lakh per day in 2001. This is projected to be 1.50 lakhs in 2011 and
2.00 lakhs in 2021. On auspicious occasions, the floating population could exceed 5 lakhs
and even 10 lakhs on certain days. For this, special arrangements are made for transport,
traffic control, camping, food, water and other ablutions.

Based on the above, the population projections for Mathura UA are as below:

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


19
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

a) 2001: 3.23 + 1.00 lakh day time


b) 2011: 4.28 + 1.50 lakh day time
c) 2021: 5.52 + 2.00 lakh day time

The component of floating population that require overnight stay each day is included in
the census.

The infrastructure requirements for the day time floating population is estimated at half that
of the other population.

In the above projections, the fact is also underlined that for Mathura NPP area, the decadal
growth rate between 2001-11 is 30 percent and between 2011-21 it is 28 percent. For the
Cantonment however, the decadal growth rates are 100 per cent and 75 percent
respectively in these periods. The Cantonment Board however are involved only in
infrastructure upgrading and not in urban renewal, heritage conservation, poverty
alleviation and local body capacity building.

Therefore services were required for 3.73 lakhs in 2001 (3.23 + 0.50) and are required
for 5.03 lakh persons by 2011 (4.28 + 0.75) and for 6.52 lakh persons by 2021 (5.52 +
1.00)

B1.6 Economic Growth

Being primarily a pilgrim city as the birth place of Lord Krishna, religious tourism generates
the economic base of Mathura. The UPSIDC had set up an industrial estate in Mathura
along NH.2. Now that Mathura has come under Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ), power starved
industries using generators or coal have been banned. This has led to industries shifting
out of Mathura to Kosi Kalan, Chatta and Nandgaon and to other states with good
infrastructure. The water supplied to industries is brackish in nature and is not potable
without treatment.

Related to tourism as the main economic base, Mathura’s household industries provide its
main economic base, with a market that extends not only beyond the state of Uttar
Pradesh, but even national boundaries. However the District level industries include heavy,
medium and small scale produce, like: manufacture of taps and cocks, petroleum
products, packaging material, cottage industry, readymade garments etc. Manufacturing
activities are concentrated in four industrial estates spread in the district. In addition many
small units are scattered through the city.

The small scale and household based industry function primarily in the inner city of
Mathura. They cater primarily to the floating population and inner city needs. The main
economic activities are based on cottage industries, sari printing, manufacturing of
garments (temple related), artificial jewellery, copper utensils, stone engraving, statues,
paintings, sweets and offerings. Their percentages are shown in Table 2C below:

Table 2C: Percentage of Small Scale Industries. Mathura NPP


Sr. No. Particulars % age
1 Cottage Industries including sweets / floral offerings/ metal curios 40
2 Sari Printing and Readymade Garments 15
3 Artificial Jewellery 20
4 Stone Cutting 5
5 Sculpting (Idol making) 5
6 Paintings 15
Source: Directorate of Industries – 2006

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


20
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The inner city also has several printing presses whereas metal curios and sari printing are
subject to bulk orders from other states. These activities largely cause inner city pollution.
They could therefore receive incentives for shifting to identified industrial estates.

B2. THE CONSULTATIVE PROCESS

B2.1 Key Consultations

The preparation of the Mathura CDP involved extensive consultations, throughout its
preparation period. The consultative strategy involved interaction with various stakeholders
like: Senior Citizens, Departments, Institutions / Groups, Industrialists, Citizens at ward
level, and local elected representatives and the media. The process was facilitated by the
media, to impress upon the general citizens about the objectives of JNNURM and CDP for
Mathura. During the preparation of the CDP, two workshops were held apart from regular
interdepartmental consultations, and ward level
discussions. Press meetings were held
regularly during the plan preparation phase.

B2.2 Consultations with Organisations

The initial launch workshop in Mathura was


organised by the Mathura MLA in association
with Greater JayCees club on 12 May 2006.
Besides, the citizens and members of the
group, government officials were also invited to
the launch workshop. The objective of the
launch workshop was to sensitize the general
citizens and give orientation about the
objectives and outcomes of the CDP of
Mathura under the JNNURM.

The launch workshop was attended by more


than 80 participants from various walks of life.
During the workshop, Mathura’s current issues
and challenges, its future vision and way
forward for the city’s development were
discussed.

Another workshop was organized on 18 July


2006 following the rapid assessment of the
citys infrastructure and its prospects. The
workshop was organized by Rotary Club of
Mathura and was attended by various
stakeholders from the city. They were briefed
about the outcome of the rapid assessment of
the city. This was through an overview of the
city’s infrastructure and services delivery,
current status, issues and challenges and
discussions regarding future developments.
Important and useful suggestions like water
harvesting, solid waste management, women’s
participation, quality control, coordination
among departments were discussed during the

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


21
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

workshop. Thereafter practical suggestions emerged from the participants, including the
women folk.

B2.3 Consultation with Officials

All the concerned government departments


and institutions were consulted during the
three month CDP process. Meetings were
held individually with various departments. It
involved site visits for further discussions. The
key issues discussed during the meetings
included : past and present progarmmes,
current infrastructure & development issues
and key prioritized development needs the
city.

All the key meetings were presided over by


the department heads and regular
discussions and interactions were held for
identifying the vision, key strategies, and
developmental projects for the city’s short,
medium and long term needs. Besides the
above meetings, various meetings were
organized by the city Administrator for looking
into aspects of infrastructure delivery,
governance and reforms process at city level.
This included the prioritization of the reforms
agenda at city and local level as per the
guidelines of JNNURM.

The high level meetings were chaired by District Magistrate by coordinating all the key
departments and stakeholders about the development strategies and project
identifications. The final meeting was presided by District Magistrate in which all the
stakeholders were present, viz - departments, institutions as organizations, industrialists,
NGOs, press & media, senior citizens etc. All the important issues discussed and
emerging from the meetings were incorporated in the final documents. The departments
consulted during the exercise for preparation of CDP is at in Annex A.

B2.4 Consultations at Ward Level

The ward level consultations involved


discussions with senior citizens, local
residents about the issues and challenges
regarding the infrastructure, services delivery
and developmental aspects. Besides the
consultation process, extensive visits to 45
wards of the city was completed by the
consultants with the help of local
representatives and ward level senior
citizens. The former elected councilors of the
municipality were also contacted about the
development issues required in various
sectors (at present there are no elected
representatives in place).

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


22
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The key issues and challenges faced at ward level included: street lighting, water supply,
sewerage and drainage, solid waste management, traffic congestion, unauthorized usage,
heritage issues and public-private participation.
However, the issues varied based on the terrain,
location, area and land use. Priorities
accordingly varied.

The ward level visits to slum areas were also


done with the help of the District Urban
Development Agency (DUDA). Slum issues were
mapped and discussed with various
representatives like CBOs, RCVs, and citizens.
The women’s participation and development
issues were also discussed and sensitized about
the programmes for the development process at the ward level under JNNURM

B2.5 The Role of the Press and Media

The press and media played an important role


during the entire plan preparation. The citizens
were sensitized regularly through newspapers,
local channels about the JNNURM and city
development processes. The citizens were
encouraged to send suggestions and come
forward for further discussions with the team
regarding their needs at local and city level. The
press and media also played an important role
during the ward level consultations and
highlighted the essence of the development process, city’s needs and expectations from
the citizens. Besides this regular press conferences were organized during the plan
preparation phase including discussions at local cable channel studios for public
awareness and participation. The details of the press cuttings and media coverage is
attached at Annex B.

B2.6 Consultations on Heritage.

As this was a basic issue of the Mathura CDP, consultations were held with INTACH Delhi
and the Braj Bhoomi Chapter of INTACH at Mathura. Several views emerged and this has
helped shape the CDP. The listing done by INTACH has 428 entries. The Braj Bhomi
Chapter have agreed to reduce this list to an implementable number. In the meantime key
entries were endorsed by them to kick-start the conservation of heritage as an on-going
process.

B2.7 The Open Forum Process

The open consultation process involved interaction with citizens in the municipality NPP
office for the draft CDP prepared by the consultants. The presentations regarding the city
assessment in terms of the infrastructure, service delivery , governance , urban poor and
slums were exposed along with the vision and development strategies. Based on these
consultations and the field level visits and other consultations, the projects were identified
and put for regional, city and ward level development.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


23
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B3. CITY INFRASTRUCTURE AND SERVICES DELIVERY

B3.1 Water Supply System

B3.1.1 Existing Situation

In 2001, for 3.23 lakh persons and 50% for day time population, the water requirements
were for 3.73 lakh persons. Thus at 140 lphd,
the requirement works out to 3.73 x 140 = 52.22
mld – say, 53 mld. The availability of water is
the greatest long term problem facing Mathura
UA. The main source for the city is through
ground water and then surface water. At
present the surface water production is 100
MLD at Gokul Barrage, some 15 Kms
downstream from Mathura. However, the
quantity drawn by the NPP is only 10 MLD due
to NPP’s insufficient capacity for storage and
distribution of water. Around 25 MLD of water
is being supplied from ground water. Even the
combined 35 mld is at reduced levels due to
evaporation losses, pilferage and wrong usage.
Due to shortage of funds, the city network has
not been able to tap the full potential of the
Barrage. Around 75% of the population
receives water at varied intervals and durations.
This is partly due to the city’s undulating terrain.
The average per capita water supply received is
therefore around 80 litres per capita per day
(lpcd). The UA really needs about 70 mld by
2011 and 90 mld by 2021 at 140 lpcd. Through
evaporation and other losses the requirement
could be around 80 mld by 2011 and around
105 mld by 2021. Therefore Gokul Barrage would have to be developed at full
capacity primarily for Mathura UA in combination with controlled ground water
usage and better management. A new Barrage is accordingly required for Vrindavan
and other areas. The proposed site for this is upstream of Vrindavan.

B3.1.2 The Agencies involved and their mode of Operations

There are mainly two agencies involved in the water supply production and distribution for
the city of Mathura a) the Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam (UPJN) which is responsible for
construction and production, and b) Nagar Palika Parishad, which is responsible for
distribution, operation and maintenance of the schemes handed over to them by UPJN.
The distribution system for the city is being maintained by the Water Works section of the
NPP. The present setup is run by a Junior Engineer and a staff of 177 including pump
operators and fitters.

B3.1.3 Demand for Water

The average depth of the water table is around 27 meters as per 2001 records. This has
since reduced by around 3.7 metres in the last five years. There are around 73 bore wells
of varying horsepower and around 25 MLD of water is supplied through this system.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


24
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Around 25% of the population is not able to receive, any potable water supply.

There are around 22,000 water connections in Mathura NPP area. The connections are
not metered and there is no categorization of water connections like: residential,
institutional, commercial, industrial, to account for the exact number of connections for
each sector. The actual consumption of water for the respective categories is not
maintained or recorded.

B3.1.4 Treatment Facility

There is no water quality monitoring mechanism except through chlorination. There is


however daily treatment of water by chlorination for both surface and ground water
sources. Chemical tests and bacteriological tests are not being done regularly for checking
the water quality. There are 21 overhead water tanks in the city, of which only 4 are in
reasonably working condition. The rest of the tanks have leakage and other problems. The
treatment of water is carried out at source and at intermediate levels in the city. The water
to be supplied to the users is only chlorinated. The prescribed chemical test and
bacteriological test is not done on a regular basis.

B3.1.5 Storage Transmission and Distribution

After water is brought from Gokul Barrage, it is further treated at the water works at
Bhuteshwar. The desired level of chlorination is done daily to supply water to end users.
There are 39 tube wells which are on contract out of 73 tube wells. The underground
circular Water Reserver’s (CWR) has capacity of around 3000 KL, with around 1500 KL
capacity of CWR at Sadar. The total distribution length of water supply which includes all
size distribution lines accounts for around 250 kms pipeline length. 50% of the city area
has fixed timings for water supply, the rest of the areas do not have any fixed timings, and
receives water sporadically. These details are summarized in tabular form below – Refer
TABLE 2D.

Table 2D: Details and Performance Indicators, for water - Mathura NPP.
Sr. Description Details
No.
1 Total Population of the UA (2001 Census) 3.23 lakhs (required for 3.73 lakhs)
2(a) Surface Water Source Capacity 100 MLD Gokul Barrage
(b) Quantity Drawn 10 MLD
3(a) Ground Water Source Capacity Not assessed
(b) Quantity Drawn 25 MLD
4 Water Table (2001) 27 m.
5 Number of Bore wells 73 ( 7.5 to 30 HP)
6 Total Quantity of Water Supplied 35 MLD (evaporation, leakages etc,
not accounted for)
7 Actual Per Capita Water received About 60 lpcd
8 Water Quality Monitoring Mechanism Chlorination
9 Overhead Water Tanks 21
10 Fully Functional 4
11 Distribution Network (Kms) 250
12 Distribution Coverage 75% (approx)
13 Storage Capacity Adequacy (CWR UG) 3000 KL
14 Water Supply Frequency 50% area has fixed timings, the
rates have
2 hours (average)
50% morning & evening

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


25
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

25% one time (any time)


25% alternate days
15 Public Stand Posts 980
16 Water Supply facility for Public Stand 50% (24 hours)
Posts 50% (3-4 hours)
17 Average Cost Incurred in O&M per year Rs. 275 lakhs
18 Average Per Capita Cost Rs.80
19 Water Tax 12.5% of ARV
20 Water Charge Rs. 6 per month
21 Average Leakage (Unaccounted for 15-20%
Water)
22 Number of Water Connections 22,103
23 Water Staff Strength 187
Source: Mathura NPP & UP Jal Nigam

Table 2E: Expenditure Incurred on Water Supply – by NPP


Sr. No. Year Income from Water Tax Expenditure Incurred on
(Rs. in Lakhs) Water Supply
(Establishment and Other
Works) in Rs. Lakhs
1 2000 -01 56.21 123.12
2 2001-02 48.40 151.01
3 2002-03 60.17 137.96
4 2003-04 80.59 153.46
5 2004-05 66.86 144.88
6 2005-06 63.16 207.82
Source : Mathura NPP

B3.1.6 Issues and Challenges

x Inadequate source of water : The


need of water for the UA is
around 90 mld by 2011 and
around 110 mld by 2021. At
present the city is able to give not
more than 35 MLD.
x Inadequate treatment facilities at
various supply distribution
centres: Only chlorination is
being done, no tests are being
taken at regular intervals.
x Around 15-20% of water leakage
is reported, which is mainly due
to line breakages at various
locations, continuous running of water from stand posts, old sluice valve
leakage problems, inefficient use of domestic connections, unauthorized
connections.
x Storage tank leakages; only 4 overhead water tanks are fully operational out
of 21 such tanks in the city.
x Rising main sluice valve leakage problems are frequent.
x Power cuts remain for around 6hrs a day and in peak summer, its goes upto
10 hrs, affecting the water supply system throughout the city.
x More generators are required to run the water supply distribution efficiently.
x Old lines get regularly choked (50%)

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


26
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

x Extreme ground level variation in the city (around 26 m high level


differences)
x There are no mechanisms for roof water collection system and ground water
recharging system.
x The Yamuna river is getting polluted day by day, as the sewerage and storm
water drains get into the river at various locations.
x Water user collection efficiency is very poor due to the under-valuations of
ARV of property. No system has been adopted for charging as per the water
consumed / category like institutional, industrial, residential, commercial etc.

B3.2 Sewerage System

B3.2.1 Existing Situation

A separate project incorporating sewage


treatment was implemented under Yamuna
Action Plan (YAP) Phase I. The city does not
have a sufficient and effective sewerage
system. Mathura town is an important pilgrim
center located directly on river Yamuna and
thousands of devotees take bath in the river, on
an average day. The number of such bathers
increase by over 1.5 lakhs during certain
festival days. The sewage disposal is through
existing open drains. Approximately 25% to
30% of the inner city is sewered. These
however do not work. Accordingly, the UA is
dependent on septic tanks and open drains.
The septic tanks in the Cant area better
controlled. Pumping stations and sewage
treatment plants are provided for part of the
sewage generated.

The entire wastewater of the town flows through


various open drains to the river. About 30 years
ago an intercepting sewer and some trunk
sewers were laid along the river bank which
intercepted the flow from 13 nos. of drains,
which was then transmitted to a sewage farm
on the other (eastern) side of the river with the
help of two lifting stations. These were located
at Vrindavan gate and Swami ghat. One other
sewage pumping station was located at Bengali
ghat by the side of the railway line.

Due to poor maintenance, the system became


almost defunct and most of the sewage and
septic tank effluent now find their way to
roadside open surface drains which ultimately
discharge into the Yamuna. Besides, there are
six nalas which were not tapped earlier - five on the south of the railway line, and
one Masani Nala on the extreme north of the town. Masani Nala is a major drain and
carries, besides domestic wastewater, substantial industrial effluent from several saree
printing industries.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


27
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The total wastewater flow reaching Yamuna river from Mathura UA is about 26.5 mld
which contributes a pollution load of about 5000 kg/day of BOD to the river.

A chrological background of the sewerage system as prevailing is as below:

Chrological Background
Year Description
1923 The egg shaped brick trunk sewer (22” x 33” size) was laid along the
right bank of river Yamuna in the year 1923. it starts from a lane (Khirki
Bishati) in Shahganj Darwaja area and ends at Bangali Ghat. The
sewer discharges into main pumping station at Bangali Ghat from
where it is pumped to sewage farm located in Trans Yamuna area.
1952-1972 In the year 1952-1972 some sewerage works to tap the three Nalas
namely Ambhakhar Nala, Satrangi Nala and Mahadeo Ghat Nala were
done. Due to inadequate maintenance the pumping station and sewers
became non functional.
1984 In the year 1984, renovation works related to Bengali Ghat pumping
station, Intermediate pumping station of Vrindavan Gate, laying of rising
main from Vrindavan gate pumping station to Lal Darwaza crossing and
to clean sewers and Nalas were done.
Post 1990 Against Yamuna action plan to check the flow of 18 existing Nalas in
the river Yamuna some works of pumping stations, rising mains and
treatment plants were done. The following works exist:

x Bengali Ghat main pumping station


x Vrindavan Gate intermediate pumping station
x Swami Ghat pumping station
x Masani Nala main pumping station
x Chinta Haran Nala pumping station
x Krishna Ganga Nala pumping station
x Cantt. Nala pumping station (dairy farm main pumping station)
x Sadar Bazar pumping station

Sewerage Treatment Plant

14.6 mld (oxidation pond type) sewage treatment plant was constructed in Trans Yamuna
area. Sewage is pumped into it from Bengali Ghat and Dairy farm main pumping station.
The related effluent is used for farming. A sewage of 124 hectare is available off Sadabad
road and is being maintained by Nagar Palika Parishad, Mathura.

A sewage treatment plant (oxidation type) of 13.59 mld capacity was constructed on
Mathura-Vrindavan road near Van Chetna Kendra behind PMV Polytechnic. Mathura
Sewage from Masani Nala main pumping station is being pumped in to this treatment
plant. The treated effluent from this STP is used for irrigation purpose and the excess
quantity is discharged into Yamuna river.

B3.2.2 Works Undertaken in YAP Phase-I

This is explained in tabular form below (table 2F):

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


28
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Table 2F: Works in Mathura NPP under YAP I

Additional Schemes
Type of Works Parameters Original Schemes
(Extended Phase)
Interception & Diversion Length of Sewers Additional Facilities &
3
works (in Km) Rehabilitation Works
Pumping Stations Nos. 5 1
Sewage Treatment 2 (14.5 MLD + 12.5
No. / Capacity STP Pond Lining
Plants MLD)
Low Cost Toilet
No. of Units / Seats 10 / 100 & 30/300 10 / 100
Complex
Crematorium Improved Wood based 8 Platforms Additional Facilities
Plantation Area (in Hectares) Being Implemented Continues
Public Participation and
Various Activities Being Implemented Continues
Awareness
PMIS (Project Computer hardware
Computer Networking
Management Nil installation with web
System
Information System) enabled application
Source: UPJN

B3.2.3 Zoning of the Town

Considering the existing Sewage Treatment Plant (STP), topography of the town and
location of existing railway lines, the whole city is divided in seven sewerage zones. Refer
Map B2. These zones are described as below:

Zone I

This zone consists of Jaisinghpura, Mahavidya colony (part), Arjunpura, ranimandi , Matia
gate, Manoharpura (part) and Gaughat area (part). The design population of this zone
including floating population of 6750 comes out to 1,06,849. The required capacity of STP
for this population is 13.25 mld. About 0.32 mld waste water is expected to come into
sewers from dying industries existing in this area. Thus the existing STP of 13.57 mld will
be sufficient to cater the requirement of this zone upto the design year.

The major Nala of Mathura, Masani Nalla, falls in this zone and a pumping station is
considered for tapping this nala to check its flow into river Yamuna under Yamuna action
plan. Other two number sewage pumping stations of this zone are Vrindavan Gate
pumping station and Krishnaganga pumping station from where sewage is discharged into
Masani Nala through rising mains and ultimately goes to masani main pumping station.
From this pumping station sewage is being pumped into the existing STP of 13.59 mld
behind PMV polytechnic Mathura. these sewage pumping station and treatment plant shall
be used for this zone. Present area of this zone is 271.17 hectare which may go upto 500
hectare at the end of design period.

Zone II

This zone consists of Manoharpura (part), Gali Kanoongoyan (Part), Gaughat 9part), Ghati
Bahalrai, Nagla paisa, Hanuman Tila, Gatashram Tila, Dalpat Khidaki, Chah Khatoti,
Satgharha, Gopalpura (part), Generalganj (part), Dampier Nagar (part) and Ambakhar
(part). The population of this zone including the floating population of 13900 comes as
140257. The total waste water generation of this zone will be 17.42 mld. The discharge of
this zone is being treated at STP of Trans Yamuna having a capacity of 14.60 mld. This is

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


29
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

being pumped to treatment plant through Bengali Ghat main pumping station and Dairy
Farm main pumping station. The capacity of pumping plants and rising main shall be
enhanced as and when required. The present area of this zone is 242.88 hectares which
will remain the same upto the end of design period as there is no scope for its expansion.
The same STP shall be used for this zone.

Map B2: Sewerage Zones, Mathura NPP & its surroundings

Zone III

This zone consists of Laxminagar which comes in Trans Yamuna area. Design population
of this zone is worked out as 46576 in the year 2039. development is taking place in this
area very rapidly along Hatras road, therefore, an additional population of 30000 has also
been considered in this zone which is likely to be include as and when the municipal limits
of Mathura are extended. The sewage of this zone i.e 9.51 mld along with the sewage of
zone II and zone VI shall be treated as Trans Yamuna treatment works by enhancing its
capacity to 35.60 mld from present capacity of 14.60 mld. The land for construction of an
unit of 21.0 mld treatment plant (UASB type) is available at the site of existing STP. The
present area of this zone is 232.88 hectare which may go upto 600 hectare at the end of
design period.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


30
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Zone IV

The present municipal limit of Mathura is upto the present bye pass road, national Highway
No.2. But the development is taking place very rapidly in the trans highway area on urban
pattern. Various colonies have been developed on Goverdhan road, Sonkh road, and at
other places between Gokul restaurant on National Highway no. 2 to refinery township.
The population of this zone is also expected as 72000 in the year 2039. A main sewer of
required size shall be proposed along the NH with some intermediate pumping stations.
Finally the discharge of this zone shall be carried to the proposed UASB type sewage
treatment plant of 9.0 mld near Narholi. Total waste water generation in this zone has been
assessed as 8.94 mld. At present no area is this zone falls within municipal limits but it
may be as 907.12 hectares at the end of design period because many colonies are
developing in this trans highway area which is in about 12 km length. The treated effluent
from this STP shall be used for irrigation purpose in the fields of Narhauli village or near by
village.

Zone V

This zone consists of Shanti Nagar, Sukhdeo Nagar, Pannapur (part) Krishna Nagar,
Radha Nagar, Dampier Nagar (part), Harizan Basti (part), Mahavidya (part) and Naya
Nagla. The population of this zone in the year 2039 has been projected as 256463 and it
includes a floating population of 7600. The sewage of this zone i.e 31.86 mld, is proposed
to carry through sewer of required size at proposed 52 mld UASB STP near the Gokul
barrage w/s treatment works. The present area of this zone within the municipal limits is
824.55 hectare which may increase upto 900 hectare up to the end of design year.

Mathura junction railway station and some industries also fall in this zone. Waste water
generation from these institutions have been taken as 1.20 mld and 1.25 mld respectively
making a total waste water generation of this zone as 34.31 mld.

Zone VI

This zone consists of Maliyan, civil line (part), Gopalpura (part), Generalganj (part) and
Ambakhar (part). The population of this zone is projected as 60228 including the floating
population of 800. The sewage of this zone i.e 8.48 mld including 1.0 mld from Cantt. Area
is proposed to be treated at trans Yamuna STP along with the sewage of Zone II and III.
The area of this zone within present municipal limits is 154.77 hectare which may increase
upto 250 hectare at the end of the design year.

Zone VII

This zone consists of civil lines (part), Pannapur (part), Harijan Basti (part) abd Dhauli
Piyau area. The area between present municipal limit and NH 2 is partly developed on
urban pattern and balance area is in process of development. Sewage facilities shall be
required to this population also. The expected population of this area is assessed as
40000. Thus, the total population of this zone will be 107627 including a floating population
of 950. The total quantity of sewage for this zone is 16.87 mld including 3.50 mld from
Cantt. area shall be treated along the sewage of zone V at the newly proposed sewage
treatment plants. The area of this zone within municipal limits is 379.47 hectare which may
go upto 600 hectare at the end of the design year. The treated effluent from the proposed
52 mld STP shall be carried to the proposed sewage farm near village Koyla Alipur through
pipe line.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


31
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B3.2.4 Issues & Challenges

x Lack of awareness with regard to waste water management.


x Topographical level difference in the city is such that the general slope of the
city of Mathura is from south west to north east towards river Yamuna with
the result that all the drains rising from any point in the city eventually flow
into the river.
x All the 37 drains discharge untreated sewage the river
x Low sewer coverage in the city area, (around 25-30%) with most of the sewer
lines choked and most branch sewer lines discharging the wastewater into
the drains.
x In-adequate sewerage capacity. The city does not have full fledged sewerage
system.

B3.3 Drainage System

B3.3.1 Existing Situation

The drainage services for the UA is being managed


by Mathura NPP and the Cant. Board. Due to the
topographical level difference of the city, the
drainage is the most affected service. During the
monsoons, the storm water drainage severely
affects almost the entire city. There are many areas
where the problem becomes acute due to several
days of water logging. The drainage problem is
more acute towards the southern part of the city
due to its topographical level difference. However,
in the Cant. due to low density, the situation is not
so severe.

There is no adequate provision of underground


storm water drainage system in the city. Most of
the drainage lines provided are open, which often
get choked due to the accumulation of polythene
bags, waste material, and silt. The uncovered
drains become a health hazard to the public. There
are more than 10 locations in the city where the
drainage problems is acutely faced during rains
and around 2 meters of water accumulation has
been reported in some areas. The following are
some of the pockets where the drainage problem is
acutely faced:- Krishna Nagar, Ambedkar Nagar,
pockets of Mohali road, New Bus Stand
Bhuteshwar and areas under bridges.

Due to the inadequate drainage lines, the roads


often get damaged. Around 10% of the road length
has adequate storm water drainage system. About
more than 600 km drainage length is required for
the city to be upgraded. There is no drainage tax or
charges being collected by the Mathura NPP.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


32
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Table 2G: Expenditure Incurred on Drainage NPP


Sr. No. Year Expenditure Incurred
(Rs. in lakhs )
1 2000 -01 169.15
2 2001-02 171.50
3 2002-03 164.62
4 2003-04 213.55
5 2004-05 182.55
6 2005-06 177.75
Source: Mathura NPP

B3.3.2 Drainage Zones

The entire city consisting of trans Yamuna area and trans Highway area (regulated area as
proposed in Master Plan 2021 by MVDA) has been divided into six drainage zones. Refer
Map B3.
Sr. Name of Name of existing Area included Area
No. Zone main drains covered
(ha)
1 Zone – I Masani Nala, Mandi Samiti, Sonkh road, Buteshwar, 606.32
Masani Mahavidya Nala, Jaganathpuri, Deeg Gate, Manoharpura,
Zone Jaisinghpura Nala, Arjanpura, Rani Mandi, Lal Darwaja,
Chakratirath Nala, Krishan Ganga, Jaisinghpur, Gokul
Shahganj Nala, Restaurant, Sarswatikund, Gokul
Octrai Post Nala, Restaurant to Mandi Choraha, Govindpur,
Krishan Ganga Nala Laxmi Nagar, Mahavidya, Ram Nagar,
Bank Colony, Krishna Nagar
2 Zone – II Gaughat Nala, Kachchi sarak, Chauk, Mandi ramdas, 289.80
Bangali Chintaharan Nala, Bharatpur Gate, Manoharpur, Giya Mandi,
Ghat Zone Daula Maula Nala, Shitala Ghati, lala Ganj, Kushak Gali, Gau
Swami Ghat Nala, Ghat, Chintaharan, Swami Ghat, Askunda
Askunda Ghat Nala, Dwarikadeesh, Vishram Ghat,
Vishram Ghat Nala, Bharampura, Chatta Bazar, Bangali Ghat,
Bangali Ghat Nala Dhruv Ghat, Arya Samaj Road, Vali Ka
teela.
3 Zone – III Abmhakhar Nala, Radhika Vihar, Azad Nagar, Sukhdev 741.44
Ambakhar Satrangi Nala, Nagar, Hanuman Nagar, Mansa Puri,
Zone Mahadev Ghat Nala Vishnupur, Pofessor Colony, Mahavir
Nagar, badri Nagar, Bharatpur Gate,
Harijanvasti, Kotwali Road, Holi Gate,
Anta Para, General Ganj, GIC, Barpura,
Ambhakhar, Gali Ahooja, Mahadev Cantt.
Station, Mayur Vihar, Dhauli Piyau,
Chandrapuri, Jai Gurudev, Madhavpuri,
Krishna Vihar
4 Zone – IV Dairy Farm Nala, Cantt. station to Aurangabad, 236.28
Dairy Farm Cantt. Nala Damodarpura, civil lines, officers colony
Zone and all Cantonment area.
5 Zone – V - Laxmi Nagar, Pratap Nagar, Ayodhya 232.88
Trans Nagar, Shivpuri, Ram Nagar, Vinod Vihar,
Yamuna Painth and Trans Yamuna area.
Zone
6 Zone –VI - Sray Azmabad colony, Vishwa Laxmi 600.00
Trans Nagar, Radha nagar, Ganeshra Pulish
Highway Colony, Yamuna Dham, Sriji Dham,
Zone Goverdhan Road, Sonkh Road,
Narohaoli, RTO office, Birjapur, Navada,
Township Tiraha

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


33
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Map B3: Drainage Zones, Mathura NPP & its surroundings

B3.3.3 Issues & Challenges :


x Encroachment : Most of the drains along the commercial areas of the city are
being encroached by the shopkeepers by extending their shops or making
steps towards their shops. This affects the cleaning services by the
respective agencies involved in the service provision.
x Open Drains: Most of the drains are uncovered having more width and depth
than actually required. This creates an opportunity for the sweepers and
passers by to throw waste into these drains.
x Siltation: Since most of the drains are open, lot of silt gets into the drains and
reduces the flow. Choking at culverts, etc. are common:
x Municipal Solid Waste: The municipal solid waste like garbage, polythene,
plastic carrybags etc are seen littered in the drains.
x Inefficient Cleaning: The city has poor capacity in terms of cleaning and
maintaining the drainage lines due to limited resources.
x Clogging of Storm Water Drainage System: This is the biggest problem
reported especially around Railway underpasses where the average water
accumulation is upto 2 m during heavy rains.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


34
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B3.4 Solid Waste Management

B3.4.1 Existing Situation

The Solid Waste Management (SWM) system


along with drainage is the most poorly delivered
service by Mathura NPP, due to the lack of
proper infrastructure facilities and overall day to
day planning and management. At present the
total solid waste generated in the city is around
140 MT per day. Due to the lack of
infrastructure and manpower capacities only
around 54 MT of garbage is lifted per day which
accounts for around 40% of the total waste
generated in the city. The silt from drains, is
often seen lying on the roadside and along the
drains.

The system is better organized in the Cant. but they are required to combine with the NPP
to exploit a common landfill site. Also due to the inefficient SWM handling system, the
wastes often get into the drains. There are more than 200 dairies in the city which
contribute to cow dung waste in large quantities, being directly disposed in open drains
and nallas. There are no other proper landfill sites and presently the waste is dumped in
open sites, away from city outskirts. There are more than 30 nursing homes, and no
arrangement is provided for collection of the biomedical waste from these nursing homes /
hospitals.

There is no segregation of solid waste at


source. The city does not have garbage bins
and often the garbage is thrown on the
roadside. Only two dumper placers are
available with the NPP, and the waste is being
transported in open dumper placers. The
disposal of the garbage is being done in
unscientific way, as the single disposal site is
around 7 kms away from the city. With around
485 permanent sweepers and 265 contractual
sweepers, the NPP, Mathura is still unable to
provide satisfactory services in the solid waste
management sector.

Details of Solid Waste Management in the city is explained in table 2 Ha.

Table 2Ha: Solid Waste Management – Mathura NPP


Sr. Existing Infrastructure Quantity Existing Infrastructure Quantity
No. (Working Condition) (Non-Working Condition)
1 Dumper Placer (3 MT capacity) 2 Septic Tank Cleaning 1
Machine (1T)
2 Tractor Trolley (1 MT capacity) 5 Trolley (1T) 5
3 Garbage Bins Nil Dumper Placer (3 MT) 2
4 Hand Carts (15 kg capacity) 180
5 JCB 3D Excavator Backhoe 2
Source: Mathura NPP

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


35
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Table 2Hb: Expenditure Incurred on Solid Waste Management by NPP


Sr. Year Expenditure Incurred
No. (Rs. in lakhs )
1 2000 -01 3.30
2 2001-02 1.43
3 2002-03 1.08
4 2003-04 1.58
5 2004-05 5.03
6 2005-06 3.27
Source: Mathura NPP

B3.4.2 Issues & Challenges

x The city does not have proper


infrastructure for collecting,
transporting and disposing municipal
solid waste. At present around 40% of
the waste is being collected which
leaves around 60% unattended or
getting into open drains.
x Lack of awareness among citizens and
municipal staff about the segregation
of waste at source and at landfill site.
x The city is not covered with garbage
bins, which keeps the waste littered at
every place and along the sides of
drains.
x Transportation of the waste is done in
open dumper placers.
x Lot of industrial wastes from small
industrial units within the city accounts
to the river pollution.
x Most of the important tourist and
heritage sites has municipal waste
lying around its areas, creating eye
sore and foul smell to the people near
such areas.
x Hospital wastes are not incinerated but
mixed with other wastes.

B4 TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION

B4.1 Road Network

Mathura is on the national expressways map of


India (NH-2). Also the Agra (Taj) Expressway,
linking Agra to Noida has been approved. This
would give a viable alternative link from Mathura
to the Delhi metropolis without relying on regional movements solely through the
neighboring state of Haryana (NH-2). The state highways include SH 39 which passes
through Mathura city. The hierarchy of national highways and state highways when within
the MVA area are programmed to emerge as bypasses or arterial roads.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


36
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The main city level road network mainly


consists of Kotwali road, Sonkh road, BSA
Engineering College road, Mohali road,
Bharatpur road, Cantonment road, Civil lines
road, Vrindavan road, KR college road,
District Hospital road, Parikrima road and
Masani road. The width of the road right of
ways (R/W’s) vary from 3 meters at ward
level, to upto 24 m at city level and more for
bye-passes. The road network inside the city
is dense and because of the concentration of
various commercial and industrial activities
they are heavily congested.

The roads – both at city and ward levels are


poorly maintained by the municipality due to
their financial constraints. The important
roads are taken up by other agencies like
Public Works Department and U.P. Tourism
Corporation. Some of the roads are also
being maintained by the Cantonment Board
within their jurisdiction.

The city does not have adequate parking


facilities. Also road furniture like dividers, road
signs, pedestrian facilities and other street
infrastructure are missing. The floating
population and traffic at peak hours becomes
difficult to manage due to the limited road
widths, encroachments and lack of discipline
among road users.

Only 35% of the roads are considered to be


‘pakka’. 10% are ‘kutcha’ and a very high
55% are badly damaged. Meager resources
keep them in this continually deteriorating
state. Table 2Ia shows the agencies
responsible for roads in the city.

The junctions require improvement and at all places where there are level crossings, road
over bridges (ROB’s) or road under bridges (RUB’s) are required, especially as by 2011 all
rail movements would be by Broad gauge (double or single track). The single motor coach
operated by the Railways between Mathura and Vrindavan is uneconomical due to level
crossings. It is best that the system becomes road based for buses. One suggestion is to
make the present Mathura-Vrindavan road as one way and the rail track converted as a
one way road from Vrindavan to Mathura. Buses could thereby ply and the system could
be a toll system with the Railways sharing in profits.

Table 2Ia: Percentage of Roads maintained by Different Agencies in Mathura UA


Sr. Description % age
No.
1 Nagar Palika Parishad 51 %
2 Mathura Vrindavan Development Authority (MVDA) 20 %
3 District Urban Development Agency (DUDA) 10 %

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


37
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
4 Public Works Department (PWD) 10 %
5 Cantonment Board 7%
6 Uttar Pradesh Tourism Corporation 2%
Source: Local Traffic Police

Table 2Ib shows that nearly 2/3 rds of the roads have R/W’s of upto 3.00 m whereas Table
2Ic shows that expenditure on the maintenance of roads has been varying.

Table 2Ib: Distribution of road right of ways (road R/W’s) - NPP


Sr. Widths of Road right of map Length % age
No. (kms)
1 9 m and above 10 kms 3.5 %
2 6.5 m to 9 m 10 kms 3.5 %
3 3.5 m to 6.5 m 82 kms 29 %
4 3.0 m and less 178 kms 64 %
5 Total 280 kms 100%
Source Local Traffic Police

Table 2Ic: Expenditure Incurred on Urban Road R/W’s - NPP


Sr. Year Expenditure Incurred
No. (Rs. in lakhs )
1 2000 -01 69.21
2 2001-02 67.41
3 2002-03 24.46
4 2003-04 64.80
5 2004-05 35.29
6 2005-06 38.96
Source: Local Traffic Police

B4.2 Existing Traffic Situation:

There are around 5 major traffic


junctions in the city. At present none
of the junctions or crossings are
signalized. No comprehensive traffic
plan has been made by any of the
agencies involved in the traffic
management of the city. No traffic
volumes and counts are available
with the traffic department of the
Police or any other department. The
traffic volume on important roads
and junctions need to be estimated
by the respective departments.

The infrastructure and manpower


available is inadequate to manage
the system. During the festival season, the traffic force and other manpower is being
arranged from other cities like Agra. The traffic department has only 1 crane to lift
unauthorized parked vehicles and for emergency measures during accidents. Besides this
the traffic department have only 3 motorcycles for patrolling the city.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


38
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Table 2J below shows the registered vehicles plying on different roads of Mathura:

Table 2J: Registered Vehicles - NPP


Sr. No. Description Number % age
1 Multipurpose Heavy Goods Vehicles 35 0.02
2 Medium and Heavy Trucks 1737 1.39
3 Light Commercial Vehicles ( 3 wheelers) 419 0.33
4 Buses 455 0.36
5 Mini Buses and other Passenger Vehicles 105 0.08
6 Taxis 100 0.08
7 Three Wheelers and Auto Rikshaws 3150 2.52
8 Two Wheelers 95860 76.34
9 Cars 5136 4.08
10 Jeeps 1080 0.85
11 Tractors 17445 13.89
12 Tractors with Trailers 2 0.01
13 Others 89 0.07
Total 125613
Source: UP RTO, 2006

B4.3 Parking

Mathura has 13 modes of motorized transport – inter and intra – both for transportation of
goods and people. In addition it caters to traffic from outside the city. Therefore traffic
management and channelisation assumes significance. Citizens say that in particular the
inter city bus stands need being relocated. However, 2 new inter-state bus stations are
required-one near NH2 and one in trans-Yamuna. Transport nagars as part of the Stations
would help in segregating inter and intra city traffic.

The city does not have any city bus


service. Autos, chhakadas, and cycle
rickshaws mainly cater to public transport
in Mathura city. Around 70 buses are
being operated by UP Roadways Mathura
depot. Around 364 trips are being made
per day by these buses and of which
around 60 trips alone are to and from to
Agra city. It carries more than 12,000
passengers per day. The UP Roadways
Mathura depot operates from two bus
stations within the city. A new bus station
has also been developed near Mandi
cross roads.

Citizens also say that parking of vehicles at Railway Stations and Bus Stations – both
personal and on hire, plus intracity transport and which is through a variety of modes need
being better organized. In particular, parking in relation to religious nodes and inner-city
needs have also to be better organized. A park and ride system and a Bus Rapid Transit
System would help in easing the present chaotic system. Zoning regulations also require
being strengthened so as to ensure parking within plots, including basements and high
deterrent fees for on-street parking. As the city is congested, multi-level parking lots are
required and several spots were identified where these are possible. These could earn
revenue.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


39
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B4.4 Issues & Challenges

x The city has an inadequate road


network and parking facilities.
The carrying capacity of the roads
is less due to limited road widths
and rapidly increasing vehicular
growth.
x The public transport system is
inadequate. The city does not
have proper taxi stands for
tourists coming from other parts
of the state and from other states.
x Due to the mixed traffic
conditions, which include cycle
rickshaws, bullock carts, trucks,
buses, private vehicles, two
wheelers, the traffic condition
becomes uncontrollable due to
the non awareness and discipline
among people.
x Some of the roads have been
encroached by fruit sellers,
shopkeepers etc, leading to a one
way system in places and general
chaos all round.
x The junctions and crossings are
poorly designed and regulated.
There are no traffic lights and
manpower available at key
locations.

B4.5 Street Lighting

The Mathura NPP is responsible for the provision of


street lighting in the entire city which include major
roads as well as internal streets. The entire
management of street lighting is being maintained by
only one lights inspector though there are 4 sanctioned
posts for such inspectors. The light inspector is being
assisted by 3 assistants / store keepers and one
lineman.

Around 60% of the city area is without street lights.


Only 10% of the area is covered with adequate street
lighting facility of the 40% served area. This leads not
only to public inconvenience but also insecurity and law
and order problems. Around 20 years ago there used to
be separate electric lines for street lighting in Mathura
city. Five lines used to be laid which included 3 phase
lines, 1 street light line, and 1 neutral line. Now only
four line systems is being adopted by the Uttar Pradesh
Power Corporation (UPPC).

Due to festivals, religious fairs and Melas being celebrated throughout the year, the local

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


40
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

body is responsible for providing lighting facilities at


various important locations as well as around the
temple areas, where people do jagran, parikrama etc
during nights. Generators are used for this purpose
and mostly on a contract basis.

Some of the festivals during which special


arrangement is being made for street lighting and
power facility include: Haryal teez, Shivratri,
Navdurga, Abmedkar Jayanti, Parshuram Jayanti,
Gurupurnima, Raksha Bandhan, Janamashtami, Ram
Leela, Diwali, Yumdotia, Mathura Parikrima, Jai
Gurudev etc which range from 2 days to few weeks
and a month.

There are around 4310 light points covering only 10%


of the area of the city. More than 15,000 poles have
no lighting system which includes all major roads,
new areas, colonies, malin basties (slums) etc. Out of
4310 street lights, 61% are Bulbs (100 Watts), 20% are sodium lights (250 Watts), 15%
are tube lights, and rest 4% are bulbs with varying wattages.

More than 500 complaints are being received per month on street lighting issues like no
light, wire breakage etc, which are being redressed within 3 – 15 days time period due to
the inadequate infrastructure and technical staff. Some of the cross roads and other
important locations have been provided with high mast lighting system.

Table 2Ka – Types of Street Lightings – 2006 - NPP


Sr. Type of Lights Number % age
No.
1 Bulbs (100 Watts) 2610 60 %
2 Sodium Lights (250 Watts) 850 20 %
3 Tube Lights 650 15 %
4 Bulbs (200-500 Watts) 200 4.8 %
5 High Mast Lamps 8 0.2 %
Source: Mathura NPP

At present the local body does not have adequate infrastructure like cranes with ladder
facilities. They have only two street lighting ladders, and inadequate safety gloves and
other electric repair and maintenance equipment.

No survey has been done to decide about the provision of adequate street lighting facility
as per the adequate norms for distribution, illumination, lux level, savings in electric
consumptions etc.

Table 2Kb: Expenditure on Street Lighting – 2006 - NPP


Sr. No. Year Expenditure Incurred
(Rs. In lakhs)
1 2000 -01 5.64
2 2001-02 5.58
3 2002-03 3.64
4 2003-04 13.06
5 2004-05 4.11
6 2004-05 8.15
Source: Mathura NPP

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


41
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B4.5.1 Issues & Constraints – Street Lights


x Inadequate infrastructure for operation and maintenance.
x Only 10% of the city area has adequate street lighting facility.
x Newly merged areas are largely not covered by street lighting.
x Due to the less availability of manpower, the complaints are not redressed on
time.
x The use of generators on contract during festivals is a drain on resources.

B5 ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES

Mathura City, suffers from pollution of air, water, ground and noise. The UP Pollution
Control Board (UPPCB) is the key monitoring authority in this regard. The main cause of
air pollution is vehicular emissions. The status of pollution measuring parameters as
against their permissible limits has been given in Table 2L below:

Table 2L: Pollution Survey – Mathura UA 2006


S. Parameter Permissible Limit Existing Status
No.
1 SPM 140 microgram/ m3 Annually 1.5 to 2 times higher
2 RSPM 60 microgram/ m3 Annually 1.5 to 2 times higher
3 3
3 SO2 60 microgram/ m Annually < 60 mg/ m
4 NOX 60 microgram/ m3 Annually < 60 mg/ m3
Source: UPPCB

The main concentration zones of air pollution are the mixed use zones and congested
traffic nodes. The office of the RTO conducts pollution checks in the city with the
assistance of the UPPCB. However, to curb air pollution by industries, the UPPCB grants
the NOC for their operations only when the industries have an air pollution control device.

Main causes of water pollution are domestic sewage, garbage, cattle waste and some
industrial effluents. Noise pollution has also increased in the city in the recent past with the
increase in vehicular traffic. The Ambient Noise Level (dBA) for basic landuses has been
given in table 2M below: -

Table 2M: Ambient Noise Level – Mathura UA 2006


S. Landuse Permissible dBA in Existing dBA in
No. Daytime Daytime
1 Residential 55 65
2 Commercial and Institutional 65 75
3 Industrial 75 75
Source: UPPCB

The main zones of noise pollution are the mixed use zones. However, the RTO with the
assistance of UPPCB conducts quarterly checks where horns of vehicles exceeding the
permissible limits are seized. Moreover, an area of 100 m radius around hospitals and
main nursing homes fall under the category of Silence Zone. However, no substantial
efforts have been made to cut down the pollution levels around educational institutes and
religious sites.

The slaughter house in the inner city is very unhygienic. An alternate site has been
earmarked south of Mathura Cant, but is yet to be developed.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


42
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

The key environmental Issues &


Challenges are
x Open Slaughter House
x Small Scale Water Polluting
Industries (City Core Areas)
x Water Pollution due to Garbage
x Dairy Waste
x Plastics
x Hospital Waste

B6 HERITAGE & TOURISM

B6.1 Existing Situation

Cultural heritage and tourism is the crucial


sector for Mathura City and its future. In fact,
urban renewal centres round this sector.
Mathura is famous for its religious/cultural,
archeological, historical and architectural
heritage. There are many festivals and fairs
held here throughout the year, due to
Mathura being known for Lord Krishna’s birth
place (Krishna Janam Bhoomi). Tourists
arrive throughout the year both foreign and
domestic. More than 62 lakh tourist arrivals
were recorded in 2005 alone, with the foreign
tourist arrival being more than 22,000. Refer
Table 2N below. Once in Mathura, tourists visit Vrindavan and Goverdhan as pilgrims.

Table 2N: Tourist Arrivals – Mathura NPP – 2006 (in lakhs)


Sr. City / Town 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
No.
1 Domestic Tourist Arrival 58.79 59.96 60.20 61.55 62.16
2 Foreign Tourist Arrival 00.21 00.21 00.21 00.22 00.22
Total (Number) 59.00 60.17 60.41 61.77 62.38
Source: Dept of Tourism, Government of UP

Tourism is almost exclusively of the


‘pilgrimage’ category. A large number of
pilgrims do not get registered as tourists and
therefore do not reflect in the above table.
According to police estimates, on several
auspicious days, the daily floating population
could exceed 10 lakhs and for which special
arrangements are made for channelising
people, for traffic control, transportation,
tented accommodation, ablution facilities,
feeding, health care and other facilities and
controls.

The city has 12 ASI protected monuments and 3 state protected mouments. It has a good
collection of artifacts in the Government Museum. Refer Table 20(a). The Museum has
collection of artifacts which date back to 200 BC. The collection includes coins, terracotta,

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


43
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

sculptures, etc. covered in 18 galleries featuring Kushan and Gupta periods. The first
Budha statue found in the world is in these galleries. The museum is world famous. The
building complex is in disrepair and badly located. The citizens are asking for a new
location and building. The city is also famous for its art and culture. There are more than 5
excavation sites where artifacts have been found dating back to first century AD. Around,
only one fourth of the excavation has been completed till date. The ghats like Vishram
ghat, the kunds, temples, kilas, tilas (excavated sites) and heritage buildings within and
outside the city limits are tourist attractions.

Table 2O(a) Monuments protected by ASI – NPP area


Sr. No. Description
1 Aurengzeb Temple
2 Jain Sidh Area, 84 Temples
3 Gayatri Tila and Temple
4 Kankali Tila and Temple
5 Chamunda Tila and Temple
6 Satiburj
7 Jaisinghpura Temple
8 Gosna Tila
9 Palikheda Temple
10 Girdharpur Tila
11 Singartila (Ganesh)
12 Kota Tila

Apart from monuments protected by the ASI, there are 3 no mouments protected under the
state Archaeology Act. Refer Table 20(b) below.

Table 2O(b) Monuments protected by State Dept. in NPP area


1 Potra Kund
2 Kans Kila
3 Govind Nagar temple

There are around 150 recognized hotels, guest houses, dharamshalas and ashrams in
Mathura and around 80 establishments in Vrindavan, and around 50 in Govardan. The
following important Fairs and Festivals have been identified. Also the Mathura parikrama
is world famous and needs being enhanced in value.

Table 2O (c) Festivals of Mathura


Sr. No. Festival Month
1 Basant Panchami February
2 Holi March
3 Akshay Tratiya April
4 Krishna Janamashtami August
5 Nandotsava August
6 Guru Purnima July
7 Sawan Mas July, August
8 Radha Ashtami September
9 Haryali Teej September
10 Phool Bangla April - August
11 Deepawali Oct./ Nov
12 Yumdootiya November
13 Annkoot November
14 Matki Leela September
15 Baldeo Chhat September
16 Aghan Mela December
17 Hindole August
18 Rath Ka Mela March

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


44
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B6.2 Issues & Constraints:

In consultation with the Mathura-INTACH


chapter and other heritage groups and State
Tourism Deptt. officials, the following issues
and constraints have been identified in this
rapid assessment report.
x The surroundings of the heritage
tourism sites and places of visits are
not kept clean. A list of heritage
related priorities for Mathura
formulated by the INTACH convenor
for Brijboomi is at ANNEX C.
x There are no proper signage for
directions to important sites and buildings.
x The infrastructure facilities to monuments like approach road, drainage,
street lighting system is inadequate at most of the places.
x Public transportation system is weak and not enough facilities like city
buses, taxi stands etc exists.
x Tourist information booth have not been provided at key locations and
destinations.
x The heritage buildings, sacred places like Krishna Janam Bhoomi, Vishram
ghat, Potra kund etc are not been illuminated during the nights.
x There is no Master Plan prepared for heritage and tourism management.
x Statutory listing of sites, remains, ruins and buildings of archaeological,
architectural, cultural, historical or ecological value is missing.

B6.3 Key Heritage Actions

x With Heritage conservation in focus,


the Rapid Assessment for Mathura
NPP has endorsed the following key
issues through the Braj Bhoomi
Chapter of INTACH:-
o That Heritage is both Man-
made (moveable & immovable)
and Natural.
o That heritage encompasses
sites, remains, ruins, buildings
and areas of archaeological,
architectural, historical, cultural and ecological significance
irrespective of age. A statutory list is the starting point to recognize
heritage.
o That the list comprises of
ƒ All entries under the Ancient Monuments Act 1958, to be
preserved by ASI
ƒ All entries under the UP state Archaeology Act, to be preserved
by the State Department of Archaeology; and
ƒ All other entries to be conserved by the owners (government or
otherwise)
o That the list is to be statutorily processed under the State TCP Act as
part of the MVDA Plan.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


45
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

o That the list could generate heritage precincts to be conserved,


including the river banks and Parikrama Buildings apart from other
individual heritage buildings.

In fact, INTACH have conducted an exercise of listing sites, remains, ruins and buildings of
archeological, architectural, historical, religious, cultural and ecological significance in
Mathura. There are over 400 entries in this list. They include the above protected
monuments. This list is being reduced to a manageable number for legal mapping and for
recognition of heritage precincts.

B6.4 Identified Heritage Sites/Monuments

The basic heritage list as identified is as below:

(A) Ghats (24 out of 37)


1. Vishram Ghat

North of Vishram Ghat


2. Ganesh;
3. Dashashwamedh;
4. Saraswati Sangam;
5. Chakratirtha;
6. Krishnaganga;
7. Somatirth/Swami;
8. Ghantagharan;
9. Dharapattan;
10. Vaikunta;
11. Navtirtha/ Varahkshetra;
12. Asiakunda’
13. Manikaranika;

South of Vishram Ghat


14. Guptatirth;
15. Prayag;
16. Shyam;
17. Ram;
18. Kankhal;
19. Dhruva;
20. Saptrishi;
21. Mokshatirth;
22. Surya;
23. Ravan Koti;
24. Buddha

(B) Temples and other religious places

1. Jan Bhomi temple


2. Jain Sidh temple complex (of B4 shrima) – ASI protected
3. Jaisinghpura temple – ASI protected
4. Palikheda temple – ASI protected
5. Govind Nagar temple – State (SDA) protected
6. Neelakantheshwar temple (at Dashashwamedh Ghat)
7. Veni Madhav temple (at Prayag ghat)
8. Mukut temple (near Vishram ghat)

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


46
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

9. Radha Damodar temple (near Vishram ghat)


10. Murli Manohar temple (near Vishram ghat)
11. Yamuna – Krishna temple (near Vishram ghat)
12. Langah Hanuman temple (near Vishram ghat)
13. Narasimha temple (near Vishram ghat)
14. Shri Chaitanyas baithak (near Vishram ghat)
15. Bhuteshwar Mahadev temple – west Mathura;
16. Gokarneshwar temple – north Mathura
17. Rangeshwar Mahadev temple- South Mathura;
18. Pipaleshwar Mahadev temple – east Mathura
19. Gayatri tila and temple – ASI protested
20. Kankali tila and temple – ASI protected
21. Chamunda tila and temple – ASI protected
22. Aurangzeb mosque – ASI protected

(C) Kunds, Kilas, Tilas (excavation sites) Burj, etc

1. Shiv Tal Kund;


2. Potara Kund; State (SDA protected)
3. Balbhadra Kund;
4. Saraswati Kund;
5. Talab Wali Dharamshala Kund;
6. Yogmaya Kund;
7. Maharidya Kund;
8. Gokarneshwar Kund;
9. Chamunda Kund;
10. Kankali Kund;
11. Chakra teerth Kund;
12. Naag Kund;
13. Satiburj (ASI protected)
14. Gosna tila (ASI protected)
15. Girdharpur tila (ASI protected)
16. Singar (Ganesh) tila (ASI protected)
17. Kota tila (ASI protected)
18. Kans Kila – State (SDA protected)

The Ghats are all part of the parikrama. Also the temples, entries B 5 to 17 are part of the
parikrama, sites and buildings. Based on this list, heritage precints are to be identified so
that projects for heritage precincts can be prepared. In this consultancy, a heritage project
area is identified for the entire parikrama of Mathura and another project for the Mathura
religious water-front. These require the help of conservation architects. The 12 identified
Kunds for restoration and environmental beautification is also another priority as part of
JN-NURM.

B7 HOUSING AND SLUMS

B7.1 Housing

B.7.1.1 Existing Situation

Housing is in mixed land use zones and primary residential zones.

Nearly 60% of the residential area is located in the old core city where houses are situated

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


47
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

along narrow lanes of 1.5 to 2.0 m widths. The density in this area is over 600 persons per
hectare and at an average of 6.25 persons per dwelling unit. There are many unauthorized
additions and alterations to the housing stock with their accompanying problems. Nearly
75% of the housing is owner occupied, and approx. 40% is inherited. People prefer to buy
developed plots to built houses but in any case want and expect the requisite infrastructure
to be fully operational. Owing to the low elasticity of incomes, the preference as per MVDA
is for smaller plots as the following preference pattern with them shows:-
x 20% less than 100 sq.m
x 26% , 100 -200 sq.m
x 30%, upto 200 sq. m
x 13%, 200-400 sq.m
x 11%, more than 400 sq.m

B 7.1.2 Future Growth & Demand

There is captive demand for housing from NRIs and from residents of States like Gujarat
and Bengal who wish to settle in Mathura / Vrindavan. There are 6 corridors in Mathura
namely Dehi, Agra, Vrindavan, Goverdhan, Aligarh and Baharatpur. Since Vrindavan is, for
all practical purposes an extension of Mathura (in religious terms it is referred to as the
soul of Mathura), it was logical for new housing and other developments to first come up
along or near these corridors. The new developments have shifted along Delhi –Agra
corridor which is NH-2.

For all income groups except those below the poverty line (BPL), there are 3 agencies
providing developed plots/ built housing namely: Mathura Vrindavan Development
Authority (MVDA), UP State Housing Board and private developers. The authority acquires
land from the farmers, develops it and sells it as a developed colony for HIG, MIG, LIG &
EWS categories. It pays compensation to the farmers through the land acquisition officer
under the District Magistrate. The sources of MVDA’s income are proceeds from sale of
developed plots/ built houses, registration fees from architects and engineers, penalties for
violation of building byelaws and stamp duties. In case of requirement of funds the MVDA
borrows it from HUDCO (Housing and Urban Development Corporation).

At present UP State Housing Board does not have any housing project in Mathura. The
organization also acquires land from farmers and pays them compensation. The land
acquired is developed as per MVDA regulations and sold as plots/ built housing. Private
developers are the major players in the field of providing developed plots/ built housing.
They also buy land from farmers in areas approved as residential land use in the Master
Plan and then get their layouts and
drawings approved by MVDA. The lack of
proper infrastructure i.e drainage, good
roads, drinking water, inadequate electric
power, encroachment etc act as
impediments to housing demand as also
willingness to shift out from the old to the
new areas.

In any event, new housing is taking place


only in wards of Mathura NPP area along
NH 2. Generally urban renewal is the key
issue. Accordingly, housing for the poor is
a major area for consideration.
Internal Streets in Urban Slums : Radha
Shyam Colony

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


48
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B7.2 Urban Poor & Slums

B 7.2.1 Existing Situation

The Mathura city has been divided into 18 slum zones within which 68 slum pockets have
been identified. As per statistics from District Urban Development Agency (DUDA), the
total slum population in the city was around 1.44 lakh in 2001. This accounts for more than
40% of the total population of the city. More than 50% of the population in these slums
belong to SC/CT categories.
Refer Map B4 and B5

Refer ANNEX D1 and D2

The slums are mainly concentrated in the north-eastern part of the city limits. They are
also spread along the Yamuna banks and on Trans- Yamuna side. There is a huge gap of
basic physical and social infrastructure in the slums and which requires immediate
attention at policy and programme level.

Map B4: Slum Zones – Mathura NPP

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


49
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Map B5: Slum Pockets – Mathura NPP

Table 2P Slum Population and Literacy – NPP - 2006


Sr. Number of Slum Slum Zones Slum % of Slum Literacy Rate
No. Pockets Population Population
(in lakhs)

1 68 18 1.44 40% 55%


Source : District Urban Development Authority (DUDA)

B7.2.2 Socio – Economic Characteristics

Literacy

The literacy rate of slum population in Mathura Urban Agglomeration as reported by DUDA
office as per census 2001 was about 55%. There has not been any studies or reports
about the dropout rates in the schools in the vicinity of slums. Further, there is not any
available source / information about the percentage of slum dwellers into the labour
market. This is an area to be studied in further depth at detailed project feasibility level.

Communities

Majority of the slum dwellers are Hindus, but Mathura UA is heterogeneous in character
with other communities like Muslims and Christians living there since several decades. A
majority have migrated from different neighboring villages and districts in search of better

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


50
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

employment opportunities in industry and in other informal sector activities related to


religious and pilgrim needs.

Land Status

Slums in the Mathura UA are located on private as well as government lands. Around 50%
of the slums in the 18 slum zones, have land/ownership on private lands, the rest is based
on spontaneous structures on government lands. These spontaneous slum areas have no
legal land status and are therefore suffering from lack of physical as well as social
amenities. With the support from DUDA, it is necessary for these spontaneous settlements
to be given in-situ tenural rights by cooperatising the squatter settlements. Initially these
encourage them to be upgraded in-situ. Over a period of time they could emerge in the
form of in-situ reconstructed units.

Environmental Conditions & Health Status


The environmental infrastructure in the slums is very poor and most of the slums lack basic
civic amenities like proper roads, drainage, sewerage, protected water supply, street lights,
toilets, solid waste management, etc. There are not enough studies available which show
the relation of the slums and disease patterns in these areas. There are only 2 health
centres in the slums. There is also a lack of hygienic community toilets at various
locations. Most of the slum dwellers do not have access to toilets. There is need to
strengthen the basic infrastructure for improving the environmental and health status of
these slums.

B7.2.3 Basic Infrastructure

There is no sewer line as well as no adequate storm water drainage facility in these slums.
Around 40% of the slums have partial coverage of roads and drainage along the roads.
Only, around 5% of the slums have more than 50% adequate road and drain coverage
infrastructure. Around 10% of the slums are affected by water logging due to inadequate
facility for drains. More than 40% of the slums have dilapidated structures. Around 60% of
the slums are covered with water supply facilities. Most of the people have individual hand
pumps rather than piped water connection. Only 1% of the slums are adequately covered
by street lighting facilities. There are however around 9564 pukka buildings in these slums.

Table 2Q Basic Infrastructure in Slums – Mathura NPP

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


51
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Table 2Ra Status of Infrastructure in Slums – Mathura NPP


Sr. Description % age
No.
1 Total Slum Population in number 143540 40% of the total population of
city (approx.)
2 Road Coverage 40% of the pockets
3 Water logged area 10% (approx.)
4 Dilapidated building structures About 40%
5 Water Supply Coverage 60%
6 Street Lighting Coverage 1%
7 Pukka Buildings 9564 Numbers
8 BPL Families (Number) 8721
9 BPL population (43605) 12% of the total population

B7.2.4 Community Facilities

The community facilities in the slums comprise of schools, community halls, etc. No other
amenities are available in the slum areas. The existing community infrastructure facilities in
the slums are presented in table 2Rb below.

Table 2Rb Community facilities in slums Mathura NPP


Sr. No. Description Community Halls Night Shelters Community Toilets
1 Mathura City 2 1 2

Additional Requirements
Sr. No. Description Community Halls Night Shelters Community Toilets

1 Mathura City 10 5 12

B7.2.5 Poverty Reduction Initiatives


The slum development programmes for
poverty reduction is being managed by
District Urban Development Agency
(DUDA) mainly from the central as well as
state sources. Some of the programmes
managed by them in past and at present
are :
x SJSRY (Swarn Jayanti Shahrey
Rozgar Yojana),
x SJSRY (Training), Loaning
(Individual)
x DWACUA (Development of Women
and Child in Urban Areas)
x LCS (Low Cost Sanitation)
x UWEP (Urban Wages and
Employment Programme).

B7.2.6 Key Challenges, Issues &


Constraints

Inspite of various efforts done by the


concerned department (DUDA) with
assistance from central as well as state led
programmes towards poverty alleviation,
there are various key challenges, issues

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


52
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

and constraints in order to address the basic social and physical infrastructure in the slum
areas.

The following are some of the key challenges, issues & constraints regarding the slum
development and poverty alleviation:
x No proper listing of slum dwellers
x Lack of basic physical and social infrastructure
x Basic services are not affordable.
x No access to primary health care.
x Livelihood options not adequate.
x Affordable shelter and land tenure security is lacking.
x Literacy rate is low
x Community empowerment is weak,
x Institutional coordination is also weak.

B8 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK & GOVERNANCE

B8.1 Organizational Structure of Mathura Nagar Palika Parishad (NPP)

There are several agencies and parastatals involved in the urban service delivery process
for Mathura City. These include the state government departments, parastatals and local
bodies. While the departments are part of the government, parastatals are created through
the Acts of legislature or government orders. Local bodies are also created through
legislation. Thus Mathura City has a Nagar Palika Parishad. The NPP is the nodal
agency for this urban renewal project.

At present Mathura city does not have an elected council as the subject is sub-judice in the
state. The Municipality is headed by an Administrator, who is being assisted by an
Executive Officer. A separate post of Executive Officer (JNNURM) has been created by
Government of Uttar Pradesh for the JNNURM project in Mathura. The elected council was
dissolved in Dec. 2005, and presently the entire administration is being handled by an
Administrator and an Executive Officer. The municipality has around 1200 staff, which
looks after day to day activities related to the service delivery and general administration
and management.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


53
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B8.2 Functional Departments of Mathura - NPP

Main Office : Handles records , board meetings, administrative and communications;

Accounts : Salaries, provident fund, establishment, State Finance Commission, Central


Grants, Income –Expenditure etc.;

Records : Property records, tender form issues, registrations;

Health: sanitation (sewerage and drainage), solid waste management, drain


cleaning, workshop maintenance, birth and death registration and
certification;

Revenue: Handles tax, tehbazari, parking, sewage farm, mangal bazaar, redis, etc;

Nazul: Nagar Palika Land, NOC for construction ( New) , Maps records;

PWD: Roads and Drains;

Tax: Collection of taxes from hotels, guest houses, commercial tax, house tax,
water tax, sewer tax, assessment tax (new buildings);

Water Works: Water supply, line maintenance, dug wells maintenance, STP’s;

Street Light: Street lighting facilities;

In the event of town planning/ development control / building permission reverting


to ULBs in Uttar Pradesh, a long term post of Town Planner is necessary. In any
event, the post is required for project formulation/ processing. The engineering
wing has also to be strengthened for both urban services and construction work.
For resource mobilization and transparent accounting systems, the finance wing
has also to be strengthened.

The following sections provides the existing organizational structure of Mathura


Nagar Palika Parishad, and also provides the proposed structure in terms of
strengthening the administrative, engineering, town planning, financial and
institutional segments of the municipality.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


54
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

City Administrator

Executive Officer

Main Office Accounts Records


(handles records, board ( salaries, provident (Property records,
meetings, administration fund, establishment, tender form issues,
and communications) SFC, Central Grants, registrations)
Income – Expenditure
etc)

Health Revenue Nazul


( sanitation, sewerage & ( handles tax, tehbazari, ( Nagar Palika land,
drainage, solid waste aprking, sewage farm, NOC for construction
management, drain mangal bazaar, redis/ (New), Maps
cleaning, workshop laries etc)
maintenance, birth and
death registration)

PWD Tax Water Works


(roads, drains, ( collection of taxes from ( water supply, line
construction and hotels, guest house, maintenance, dug wells
maintenance) commercial tax, house maintenance, STPs)
tax, waer tax, sewer tax,
assessment tax (new
buildings) )

Street Lighting
Street lighting facilities

CEO

EO Accounts Executive Executive Town Planner


(Administration) Officer Engineer Engineer (Planning &
(Finance) (Sanitation) (Public Works) Development)

The above structure need to be supported by appropriate capacity building measures in


areas like Financial and Resource Mobilization, Sanitation, Public Works, Planning &
Development, Information Technology / Computerization etc.
The city is divided into 45 distinct wards.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


55
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

B8.3 Current Institutional Responsibility Matrix

Sr. Particulars Planning and Construction Operation and


No. Design Maintenance
1 Master Plan / Zoning + D.C. TCPD, NPP, Land owners as By concerned
rules MVDA per plan agencies.
2 Building Byelaws MVDA As per bye-laws By concerned
agencies.
3 Water Supply UPJN UPJN NPP, UPJN
4 Sewerage UPJN UPJN, NPP NPP, UPJN
5 Storm Water Drainage UPJN NPP, PWD NPP, PWD
6 Roads, Bridges, Junctions, PWD, NPP, PWD, NPP, PWD, NPP,
Multilevel Parking MVDA MVDA MVDA
7 Traffic control and RTO, Traffic RTO, Traffic RTO, Traffic
management system Police Police POlice
8 Solid Waste Disposal NPP NPP NPP
9 Street Lighting NPP, UPPC NPP, UPPC NPP, UPPC
10 Parks, Playgrounds, NPP, MVDA NPP, MVDA, NPP,MVDA
Beautification of roads, PWD
Road Intersections
11 Air, water, noise pollution UP SPCB UP SPCB UP SPCB
control
12 Slum Upgrading NPP, DUDA NPP, DUDA NPP, DUDA
13 Urban Poverty Programmes DUDA DUDA DUDA
14 Heritage Building INTACH, ASI, ASI, SDA, ASI, SDA, MVDA
Conservation SDA, UPTDC, UPTDC, MVDA
MVDA
15 Tourism Infrastructure UPTDC UPTDC UPTDC
16 Housing for EWS DUDA, UPSHB, DUDA, UPSHB, DUDA, UPSHB,
MVDA MVDA MVDA
17 Public Conveniences NPP, DUDA NPP, DUDA NPP, DUDA

TCPD- Town and Country Planning UPPC – Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation
Department, DUDA- District Urban Development Agency
NPP- Nagar Palika Parishad Mathura ASI - Archeological Survey of India
MVDA- Mathura Vrindavan Development SDA State Department of Archeology
Authority INTACH – Indian National Trust for
UPJN - Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam Architectural and Cultural Heritage
PWD- Public Works Department (UP) UPTDC-Uttar Pradesh Tourism Development
RTO- Regional Transport Office Corporation
UP SPCB - Uttar Pradesh State Pollution UPSHB-Uttar Pradesh State Housing Board
Control Board
The functional overlaps are mainly seen in the roads and side walks construction,
maintenance of roads and drainage. The governance of the city is characterized by
multiplicity of agencies. The critical issues that emerge from the existence of multiple
agencies include : spatial and functional fragmentation, overlapping functions, multiple
accountability lines, high service delivery gaps, and increasing urban poverty. This results
in the lack of inter departmental coordination which is a serious roadblock plaguing local
bodies. Coordination is largely left to the District Magistrate, who has a large number of
other functions and responsibilities.

B8.4 Issues & Challenges


x Inadequate Technical, Managerial and Financial Capacities of NPP.
x Functional Overlaps
x Poor and Weak Urban Governance.
x High Service Delivery Gaps.
x Infrequent - Interdepartmental Coordination.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


56
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION C: SWOT ANALYSIS AND THE EMERGING MATHURA


VISION
C1. THE MATHURA URBAN RENEWAL AREA

C1.1 Citizen Concerns:

The growth of Mathura has been stunted in spite of the fact that various plans and reports
have been prepared over the years to address the problems of the area. The master plan
that has been prepared for the Mathura-Vrindavan area and upgraded have also been
silent on most urban renewal issues. After discussions with several stakeholders, the
following issues emerged:-

x Traffic and transportation is a major problem especially during the festive


seasons since Mathura-Vrindavan has very narrow lanes and no proper
parking facilities for the people who visit the place. Mixed traffic compounds
the problem.
x Drainage in the area is very poor, in spite of the fact that Mathura is situated
along and near riverbanks. The problem here is uncoordinated construction
work by sectoral departments that have encroached till the banks of the river;
x Continuing reclamation of land from the river and tanks by various
authorities involved in the development of the city; (e.g. the dumping of
malba).
x Inadequate revenue generation by the Mathura NPP and their weakness to
sustain themselves and carry out crucial development and renewal activities;
x Unauthorised additions and alterations to buildings and which are never
incorporated in the planning process. According to unofficial estimates over
80 percent of the city has such unauthorised construction.

Among the citizen concerns has also been the lack of coordination between the various
sectoral agencies. Water supply is woefully short. It is largely through ground extraction
as the Yamuna is heavily polluted. Water Management is lacking. Sewerage is in worse
shape. There is a sewerage system for
about 30 percent of the city area - with 2
sewerage disposal works - both
underutilized. However there are better
services in civil lines. Power is largely from
the grid but is also in short supply.

Solid Waste Management is weak in


Mathura city but a little better at Vrindavan,
and the cantonment. Traffic is chaotic;
roads badly maintained and in general,
large scale infrastructure upgradings is
necessary as part of the development
process.

Organisational and financial management by the NPP also needs being strengthened as
part of a vision for Mathura City 2001-2021.

C1.2 Mathura NPP as nodal agecy

The consultation process that led to the rapid assessment was highlighted in the previous
chapter. The entire Mathura NPP area is an urban renewal area and as an ‘inner city’ is

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


57
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

within the larger agglomeration known as the MVA (MVDA being the planning and
development authority). Refer Map C1 for the approved Master Plan for the MVDA – 2021
and within which the Mathura NPP area is highlights.

z The inner city has been the most neglected


area of “Braj”
z It stands out due to overcrowding, decaying
and unregulated building stock, incompatible
mix of uses, unusable/overworked services
networks, mixed traffic, unpaved and narrow
streets, lack of parking spaces, accumulated
solid waste, poor drainage, high pollution
levels and unregulated electricity
connections, hoardings and street furniture.
z At the same time it has heritage buildings,
sites, ghats, a riverfront and other footprints –
to be conserved through a holistic urban
renewal process.

Accordingly, Mathura NPP is the nodal agency for


this N-NURM Project

C2. FINANCIAL PROFILE – MATHURA NPP Map C1: Mathura NPP with the
MVDA plan area

C2.1 Finances of Mathura NPP

The financial profile of the city indicates the state of the city’s finances and the capacity of
the city to be able to manage its finances and mobilize resources for maintaining
infrastructural service at prescribed norms and standards. Therefore financial capacity of
Mathura NPP has been assessed on income, expenditure, debt service and performance.

C2.1.1 Revenue Accounts and Income

The financial accounts of the Mathura NPP is being maintained on “Cash Basis” i.e single
entry system. The following are the various sources of income of Mathura NPP: House tax,
tax on rickshaws, boats, parking fees, taxes from traders and shopkeepers, water tax,
water charges, sewer tax, show tax, transaction tax on house sale, advertisement tax,
tonga fee, energy operated sources, rent from assets, thakta fee, income from nazul
property, income from sewage farm, income from premium, tehbazari, maps, penalties,
interest from savings, etc. Besides this the other sources of income include State Finance
Commission sources, and other sources like MP funds, MLA funds.

It is observed that house tax, water tax, and revenue generated from registration and sale
of property accounts for the largest share of the revenue income generated by the
municipality. For 2005-06, the house tax accounted for 17 % of the total income generated
from own sources, sewer tax accounted for 26%, and registration and sale of property
(fees) accounted for 32% of the total income generated from own sources.

C2.1.2 Revenue Expenditure & Capital Accounts

The municipality spends its resources for establishment, operation and maintenance and
debt servicing of obligatory and discretionary services provided by it. The major heads of
revenue expenditure include general administration, water works, drainage, roads etc.
Most of the capital works are financed by way of loans, grants from State and Central

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


58
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Government. The expenditure incurred on the water works accounts for around 18% of the
total expenditure, and drainage works accounts for also around 18% of the total
expenditure. Refer table 3A.

Table 3A: Income Revenue of Mathura NPP 2001-06


(Rs. In lakhs)
Year Income Expenditure
2000-01 734.66 765.70
2001-02 750.75 720.95
2002-03 988.87 866.18
2003-04 623.82 736.14
2004-05 1143.17 1187.59
2005-06 1327.07 1318.16

Primarily the NPP is dependent on the State Government for meeting its running costs. It
is now necessary for them to increase revenue and to undertaken major renewal projects
under the JNNURM.

The detailed revenue and expenditure profile of Mathura NPP is at ANNEX - E.

C3. SWOT ANALYSIS

The assessment of the status of the various sectors in the city has brought in a set of
issues for city development. While all issues are important, it was considered necessary to
prioritize them in order to address them more effectively. The prioritization of the issues
has been done based on several criteria including stakeholder perception and technical
assessment.

Further, assessment of the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT) of a


city forms a basis for preparation of a relevant City Development Plan (CDP). A city level
SWOT analysis has been done based on an assessment of the status of various sectors in
the city. This sub-section focuses on the consolidation of the issues and describing the
strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats respectively of Mathura NPP area.
Refer table 3B, 3C and 3D.

Table 3B: SWOT Analysis (Mathura NPP)


STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
1. One of the important heritage and 1. Slums are increasing; around 40%
religious cities of Uttar Pradesh & India; population live in slums pockets;
2. Close proximity to one of the largest oil 2. No proper sewerage & drainage system;
refineries of India / Asia; 3. Water source problems and saline water;
3. Good connectivity through bus, train to 4. Congested transport network in core areas;
neighbouring states (Haryana, Delhi, 5. Less carrying capacity of roads;
Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh) and for the 6. No university level technical institutes;
state (Aligarh, Agra, Kanpur, Lucknow 7. No university for other professional and
etc); vocational courses;
4. Heritage City under JNNURM Project 8. No multi-storied parking at congested
declared by the Government of India; places;
5. Pilgrim tourism, small scale industrial 9. Medical facilities are limited;
potential. 10. Unable to attract investors in IT;
11. No proper air transport base;
12. SWM handling, collection, disposal and
transportation weak;
13. Power supply system - inadequate.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


59
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
1. Heritage City of Pilgrimage; can be 1. Floating population is increasing due to the
exploited.; increase in tourism;
2. Expressways, Power Infrastructure; can 2. Pressure on existing infrastructure;
be explored; 3. Delays in implementation of effective plans;
3. International linking for tourism; can be 4. Higher level of traffic congestion due to
explored; urban expansion and floating population;
4. Higher technical educational hub; can be 5. Weak Sustainability of projects.
established;
5. Investments in tourism, education, health,
bio-technology; can be promoted.

Table 3C: Goals and Objectives from SWOT Analysis


Description of Goal Goal designed to address from the SWOT i.e.
a Strength, a Weakness, an Opportunity or a
Threat or a combination
Goal 1
Heritage, Tourism & Pilgrimage promotion; From opportunity to strength
Goal 2
Drainage & Sewerage upgrading; From Weakness to opportunity
Goal 3:
Water Source augmentation and potable From Weakness to opportunity
water supply networks
Goal 4
Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation From Weakness to opportunity
Management System;
Goal 5
Logistics and planning for SWM System From Weakness to opportunity
Goal 6
Establishing Higher technical education From Opportunity to strength
capacity / city as an educational hub
Goal 7:
Basic Services & Infrastructure for Urban From threat to opportunity
Poor

Table 3D: Goals and Strategies from SWOT analysis


Goal 1 Strategies
Heritage, Tourism & 1. To provide and increase the potential of pilgrim, religious, heritage
Pilgrimage promotion based tourism.
2. To develop the areas in and around heritage sites, kunds, Ghats,
temples of high tourism and religious/cultural importance.
3. To strengthen the Mathura parikrama route.
4. To provide adequate infrastructural facilities like basic amenities in
and around such sites/ areas/ zones.
5. To develop alternative routes for Yamuna ghats and development of
Yamuna Ghat on the other bank of Yamuna river.
6. To conserve, restore heritage buildings, sites, kunds, tilas, kilas, etc.
Goal 2 Strategies
Drainage & 1. To prepare a comprehensive drainage and sewerage master plan for
Sewerage Upgrading the entire UA and the expansion areas for next 20 years.
2. To implement and initiate projects with assistance of private
participation.
3. To prepare and implement a GIS based decision support system for
the drainage and sewerage system for the entire city.
Goal 3 Strategies
Water Source 1. To provide adequate water source facilities for Mathura UA.
Augmentation and 2. Provide reliable water supply to entire UA population.
Supply 3. Water service utility to be fully accountable to citizens.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


60
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

4. Financial sustenance.
Goal 4 Strategies
Comprehensive 1. To provide and increase the carrying capacity of the existing road
Traffic Management right-of-ways
System 2. To provide adequate parking facilities for floating and non-floating
population.
3. To increase the multilevel parking system.
4. To facilitate intercity transport around the city including by – pass,
expressways and relocation of inter-settlement activities in relation to
such nodes.
5. To expedite Road Over Bridges and eliminate rail crossings in the
NPP area.
6. To provide a para-transit transport system for city needs.
7. To improve a rapid transit accessibility between Mathura and
Vrindavan by replacing the rail car route with a fast bus route.
Goal 5 Strategies
Logistics and 1. To prepare a comprehensive master plan for the city to tackle the
planning for SWM SWM deficiencies.
System 2. To provide and facilitate the door to door collection system and
segregation of waste at source.
3. To provide proper treatment of bio-medical wastes.
4. To establish and provide with private sector assistance for recycling
waste.
5. To manage the entire system effectively with the help of modern
technology and concepts like GIS / MIS.
6. To provide an effective redressal system in sanitation and solid waste
management.
Goal 6 Strategies
Establishing Higher 1. To provide the state of art higher level technical educational
technical education institutions;
capacity / city as an 2. To compete with the national scenario by investing and attracting
educational hub private sector participation;
3. To promote and provide job oriented small scale industry linked
programmes;
4. To provide affordable education to all.
Goal 7 Strategies
Basic Services & 1. Slum free city.
Infrastructure for 2. 100% basic services to urban poor.
Urban Poor / 3. Community based and access to services.
Slums 4. In-situ slum reconstruction programmes

C4. LIVABILITY RATE OF THE CITY

Based on the perception of citizens and achievable goals and strategies, the livability rate
of Mathura NPP is rated on a scale of 1 (poor) to 10 (excellent) against each of the criteria
is as below. Refer table 3E below:

Table 3E: Livability Rate – Mathura NPP


1. Access to education 6
2. Access to employment 6
3. Access to safe and secure housing (private or public) 6
4. Access to credit for citizens 6
5. Access to clean, safe water 5
6. Access to sewerage services 4
7. Access to solid waste disposal 4
8. Access to affordable, reliable transport 5
9. Access to health care 7

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


61
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

10. Access to an environment that is safe (clean air, water etc.) 5


11. Personal safely 7
12. Capacity to participate in the city’s future development 6

Based on the above, the average rating for livability for Mathura city could improve from
below 4 at present to above 6 over the next 7 years.

C5. THE MATHURA VISION 2021 AND ITS CDP

C5.1 The Requirements of the Mathura Vision Plan

The required plan 2001-21, for Mathura NPP is not to be in the form of a Master Plan and
which has a constricted objective as hitherto in U.P. Nor is it to be in the form of a
development Plan and which does not give due weightage to conservation as part of a
development process. It is, in fact best approached as a 'sustainable development plan'
where services, transport and land use are considered in tandem as an integrated
development opportunity; this however is to be only after looking at forestation, protection
of rivers, water bodies and wetlands, settlement/urban level agriculture and market
gardens and all forms of organized greenery, socio-cultural and religious heritage - both
manmade and natural, as 'positive constraints'. This exercise of 'opportunities and
constraints' in tandem is best addressed through Environmental Management Plans. It
can however for this exercise be called a ‘Comprehensive Development Plan’ so that it is
better understood by all stakeholders. For Mathura this plan has been prepared for the
MVDA area through a perspective plan for 2021

The City Development Plan (CDP) for Mathura NPP through annual budgets that fits into
the MVDA perspective plan is proposed for 6 years, i.e. 2006-07 to 2011-12.

The above arrangements would be in conformity with the 73rd and 74th CAA. Largely for
Mathura NPP, the plans and programmes would be in the form of urban renewal
incorporating environmental and urban upgrading with enhancement of its urban footprints.

C5.2 The Key Emerging Issues for the Mathura CDP

Briefly through consultations, the following issues were identified:-

x Optimally utilize the available natural resources and retainable physical


environment in the development area;
x Ensure planned and coordinated development or redevelopment of the
development area which at present is haphazard;
x Conserve and enhance Mathura’s ancient heritage through statutory listing
and precinct plans.
x Provide the necessary directions and undertake planned development of the
area according to achievable densities;
x Provide housing to various income categories along with adequate
community facilities and amenities, so as to achieve balanced growth.
x Ensure that poverty alleviation programmes are effective and cater to the
housing of the urban poor through in situ upgrading or reconstruction.
x Ensure adequate provision of transportation infrastructure and traffic
orderliness.
x Undertake integrated development of the service industries and commercial
facilities in order to weave them with the existing social structure of the area.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


62
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

x Prioritise facilities that need to be provided in order to achieve the set


targets.
x Provide necessary linkages to existing and proposed land uses and
x Control unplanned development in and around the religious sites and their
parikrama route.

The above issues are to take cognisance of the large pilgrim influx the year round to
Mathura-Vrindavan-Govardhana and largely through Mathura.

C5.3 Emerging Key Planning and Development Issues

The key planning and development issues that have accordingly emerged during
discussions with the concerned government officials and other stakeholders are:

x Encroachments on agricultural land and open areas: Urbanisation has


expanded in an ad hoc manner, often onto the green areas and open spaces. The
rural green (agriculture) belt is also under tremendous development pressure due
to non-availability of developable lands within the existing settlement boundaries.
x Unauthorised colonies without proper infrastructure facilities. A list of
unauthorised colonies in Mathura is available. Most of them are against the
designated (proposed) land use. A few of them which are not against the
designated land use have not got their plans sanctioned by the concerned
departments. For these colonies, regularisation can be done after charging a
penalty and land use change charges. However, some of these colonies are by
groups below the poverty line and policies on in-situ upgrading, reconstruction or
relocation should apply.
x Exploitation of ground water resources: Only about 25% of the city population
presently have access to piped water supply system. Ground water is the primary
source for domestic consumption in new development areas. These have to be
closely regulated and managed and replaced in stages with surface water.
x The Yamuna as a religious-cultural reality. However due to bad usage it enters
Mathura in an impure state. Worse still the steps, bunds and kunds have been
destroyed due to bad upkeep and negligence. Their restoration through citizen
participation is crucial with stringent development actions and monitoring by the
Central Pollution Control Board.
x Floating pilgrim population is a year round phenomenon in Mathura-Vrndavan
and Govardhana. On several festive days there is a bulge and this has not been
adequately catered for.
x No linkage in land-use planning and financial planning: it is necessary to cater
to these linkages. The Nagar Palika Parishad is required to prepare annual and 5
year financial plans for its area. These plans include a list of projects, estimated
costs and budget requirement but do not have any spatial perspective. At present,
it appears that the UP Town and Country Planning Department often prepares
master plans for development areas without incorporating cost implications of
proposed developmental activities. In-depth consultation with concerned
departments has not been a major feature in plan preparation exercise. 5 year
plans are best prepared through wards. For this capacity building is required.
x Lack of sector co-ordination in planning and developmental activities:
Industrial, residential and infrastructure investment decisions are un-coordinated
particularly in the peri-urban areas where pressures for urban expansion are
increasingly pronounced and difficult to monitor and control.
x Synergy between the 2nd and 3rd tier of governance is absent and needs

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


63
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

being strengthened. In general, the progress of plan implementation relating to


residential development is reasonable but proposals relating to widening of
existing roads, construction of new road links, redevelopment of congested areas,
relocation of non-conforming land uses, preservation/conservation of water
bodies/ tanks or sensitive areas and management of cultural heritage require
being strengthened.

C5.4 The Renewal Strategy

x Through a series of discussions with citizens, institutions, and officials


and the rapid appraisal as being highlighted herein, the consultancy
upholds a preliminary Mathura City Vision as below:
o That Mathura junction emerges as a true peoples rail entreport
through only Broad Gauge Electrified traction and enhanced pilgrim
facilities and facilitation including the transfer of the special pilgrim
tax on tickets to a special budget for this purpose.
o That National Expressway and Taj Expressway generates sufficient
access points to the MVA and the intercity bus stations be captured
near these highways. For intra-city and rail station movements be by
personalised vehicles and small capacity Para-transit modes including
the cycle-rickshaw.
o Likewise, inter-city goods vehicles be captured at such nodes for
intra-city distribution of goods by light vehicles other than animal-
drawn.
x The interchange terminals be also availed of for truck terminals, pilgrim
centres, tourist lodges, manufacturing units other than household and the
likes.
x The possibility of replacing the Mathura – Vrindavan Single Carriage
Electric coach by a bus based system be explored.
x With citizen participation, some 5-6 Multi Storeyed Parking Areas may be
identified. But, traffic management through one-way streets, prohibition
of heavy vehicles, deterrent parking fees and the like is a must.
x All level-crossings to be replaced by road under-bridge (RUB) or road
over bridge (ROB) and water logging solutions found, even the cost of
providing and maintaining for such projects. Foot overbridges are
required at several crossings.
x The Yamuna (apart from cleaning under YAP II) should have its waterfront
restored and the Mathura Parikrama (a 14 km stretch encompassing 25
temples and ghats) be improved. Opposite bank should also be enhanced
as a heritage recreation area.
x Several Municipal Wards be earmarked as heritage precincts where
temples, religious buildings, kunds etc be restored through conservation
architects and people’s groups.
x Likewise, listed heritage buildings be conserved through conservation
proposals.
x The Mathura Slaughter-house be immediately shifted and relocated
through a scientific abattoir at an identified site, south of Mathura.
x Ward and Mohalla Committees be activated so that each ward has a plan
for paved pathways, street lighting, proper drainage and ablution
facilities, underground electric cables (even at a cost), proper garbage
management (even through privatised systems).

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


64
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

x Zoning regulations and Building Byelaws be simplified and penalties for


misuse and unauthorised construction be subject to deterrent penalties.
x The Mathura NPP be made viable through adequate resources and staff.
Capacity building and Training is necessary. In particular, ward level
participation be strengthened.
x Through Gokul Barrage, surface water be enhanced as a source through
a structured distribution system and ground water as a source be
minimised in the inner city (The water distribution tanks of 1912 vintage
need immediate repairs).
x Sewerage disposal systems be extended to the entire city and drainage
channels improved (Most of them get choked due to solid waste).
x A second barrage across the Yamuna upsteam of Vrindavan be expedited
after a proper technical assessment.

C5.5 The Basic Mathura NPP Area Vision

o Mathura as a prime Heritage – tourism and religious focus of the Braj


o Improved water quality in the Yamuna, restoration of water front as an
enhanced religious focus
o Slum Free City
o Improving the environmental ambience through sustained maintenance &
strategies by local bodies and others through the active participation of
the people.
o Segration of non-destined uses at the core & periphery so as to
encourage pilgrim tourism to Mathura-International, National, Regional

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


65
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION D: THE CITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP


JURISDICTION
D1 THE BROAD LAND USE PATTERN

D1.1 The Mathura NPP

The fact is underlined that the entire Mathura NPP area of 28.50 sq. km. comprises of the
urban renewal zone of the larger Mathura Vrindavan Development Area Plan as approved
for the period 2021. This is also true of the adjoining Vrindavan NPP area. Thus the two
twin NPP jurisdictions are the core of the Braj heritage; with Mathura serving as the
entreport to the entire Braj sacred ambience. It is also necessary to consider a combined
basic service for Mathura Cant. with the NPP as they are part of a common urban
agglomeration.

Map D-1 shows the geographic area of the Map D1: The Mathura NPP Jurisdiction
Mathura NPP. The jurisdiction is divided
into 45 wards catering to 3.02 lakh people
in 2001 in congested environs. Inmigration
to this area is reducing (unlike inmigration
to neighbouring Vrindavan). The
population of the UA was 3.23 lakh in this
period. However the floating population is
large and estimated at an average of over
1.00 lakh persons per day in 2001.
Therefore for services, the population of
Mathura UA was estimated at 3.73 (at 50
per cent of estimated daily floating
population). On auspicious days, it is
estimated to exceed even ten lakhs. This
puts organizational pressure for additional
services on the District administration and
the Nagar Palika Parishad.

The Mathura NPP is the nodal agency for


the JN-NURM investment driven project, as
they are the best placed for public private
partnerships (PPP’s) as a local body.
However, However, for financial and other
reasons, the NPP lacks buoyancy and are suspect in the eyes of the people. Therefore,
substantial capacity building is required for the NPP and which currently is heavily
dependent on the State Administration through the District Magistrate and who would
continue orchestrating investments through the NPP and other state line agencies
(departments and parastatals). Also, dedicated funds through the Member of Parliament
for Mathura District and the Member Legislative Assembly for Mathura-Vrindavan segment
of this parliamentary constituency would in good measure be meaningfully utilized in the
improvement of the city. The Cantonment has its own local body and planning processes.
However in view of its rapid growth, basic services upgradation is proposed along with that
for Mathura NPP.

D1.2 The Structure Plan

Map D2 shows the broad land use pattern for the Mathura NPP as determined in the
approved MVDA Plan 21. It would be seen from this plan that the most sacred stretch of

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


66
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
the river Yamuna is shared by Mathura and Vrindavan. Thus two separate parikrama’s
punctuate the religious-cultural significance of the place. This calls for major
improvements along the two parikrama routes. With Mathura NPP area in focus in the
current exercise, the temples, ghats and water front relationships of the people with the
river has to be improved and largely restored. This has to be extended all along the route
and where it interfaces with the crowded city. It would also be seen that the bulk of
parikrama Mathura NPP area is a mixed use zone with a rapidly deteriorating ambience,
except for the smaller portion engulfed by Mathura Contonment and which largely houses
the government offices. It would also be seen from this plan that Railway operational land
occupies a large chunk of core land and where through Mathura Railway Junction, the
transportation of goods and people is operationalised and dispersed in all directions –
north to Delhi and beyond, west to meet Alwar and Jaipur, south towards Mumbai,
Chennai and the west Indian peninsula and east towards Hatras and the State of UP and
beyond towards Kolkata. Add to this the convergence of roads-primarily through the Road
Transport Undertakings of primarily UP, Rajasthan, Delhi, Haryana and MP, it would
emerge that transport convergence and dispersal is a crucial component of Mathura city as
it generates inter and intra-settlement traffic and which is chaotic at present. Fortunately,
except for bulk oil due to the Refinery in the area, the city is not a goods distribution centre.
It is in fact a rail-cum-road goods dispersal centre. However, in terms of people, Mathura
is a pilgrim convergence centre. This is compounded by the fact that a majority of people
passing through Mathura also enter the city for a religious visit. In migration to Mathura
NPP area still occurs in non-
mixed land use areas,
primarily along NH2. Also,
operational use in the Cant.
is increasing and this attracts
a large support population
that requires services.

As stated earlier, the


demographic trends for
Mathura UA shows that in
2001, the UA had 3.23 lakh
persons. By 2011 it is
estimated to be around 4.28
lakh and by 2021 around
5.52 lakh. However floating
population is an issue in
planning, in investments
development, in environment
upgrading and in city and
district management.
Accordingly services are
being planned from 3.73
lakhs in 2001, to 5.15 lakhs
in 2011 and 6.67 lakhs in
2021.

The approved MVDA plan


2021 does stress on the
importance of the Mathura
bye-pass i.e. NH2 (now part
of the golden quadrilateral).
They have even proposed a
further westward shift of this

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


67
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
bye-pass but trends indicate that this would not be necessary by 2021. In addition the
regional plan underlines the fact that the NOIDA-Agra bye-pass east of the Yamuna is a
reality and this would give improved access to both Mathura and Vrindavan to their east.
The Indian railways are
also converting the Agra-
Mathura-Hatras line to
broad gauge and the
Mathura-Alwar line is being
electrified and made
double-track broad gauge
so as to link up with the
Delhi-Mumbai rail rapid
corridor via Jaipur, Udaipur
and Ahmedabad. Thereby,
the shifting of inter-state
bus stations, and transport
nagars would be
accelerated leaving
movements within Mathura
city largely to paratransit
and modest personalized
vehicular flows. Even so,
traffic management and
enforcement is a major
issue in this urban renewal
exercise.

From Map D2, it would also be seen that a single large industrial area along the NH2 bye-
pass is now being transformed into small scale service units in place of larger polluting
units which have shifted to Koshi-Kalan, Nandgaon and the Chatta State Industrial Estates
with better production and infrastructure facilities. Thus the city apart from small-scale and
services production and facilities also offers employment through household production in
the inner city. This primarily caters to religious purchases in terms of confectionery,
garments, metal, wooden and other articles. Several inner-city units producing metal
curios and printed sarees could move to these vacated paces with incentives for such
spitning. Packaging and disposal of waste is unorganized and is part of JN-NURM funding
for improvements. Wholesale fruit, vegetable and flower markets are also along NH2.
Even here and in small outlets within the city, waste disposal is an issue. The MVDA plan
2021 does address the broader shifting and inner city renewal aspects but translating such
visions/ perspectives/ projections into implementation projects is part of this exercise.
Accordingly, key projects are addressed sectorally in the sub-sections below.

D2. URBAN RENEWAL THROUGH THE DOWN-TOP PROCESS.


As stated earlier, the entire Mathura NPP is an urban renewal area of the MVDA.
This is also largely true for Vrindavan NPP area. Thus reforms through the down-
top public private participation process (PPP) could be made to work in Mathura
through the ward committees and as stipulated in the 74th CAA.

D3. THE MUNICIPAL WARD AS THE BASIC URBAN RENEWAL UNIT

Under the 73rd and 74th amendments, the third tier of government cannot easily be
superseded. In the state of U.P., elections for the new local bodies are due within a
stipulated period. In such an event, the NPP should be having 45 newly elected/re-elected
ward councilors,each responsible for his or her ward. Map D3 shows the approximate

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


68
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
jurisdictions of the wards. In 2001, each ward had an average of about 7,000 inhabitants
(5,700 to range). Refer table 4A. By 2011 it would be approximating 10,500 (6,500 to
11,000 range), unless the State Election Commission reconstitutes the wards. There is
also a view that the jurisdiction of the NPP should be increased. In general, however, the
population ranges mentioned above are manageable for a city of the size of Mathura. It
requires accountability of elected councilors for the welfare of between 1000 to 1800
families each. Proper ward level mapping and superimposing ward level projects and drill
for maintenance of assets thereof help in transparency and PPP at ward level prior to this
being coalesced at city and regional levels.

Wards in Mathura are of 2 district typologies. The smaller high density core wards, all with
mixed uses, and the more spread out wards of medium density between the core wards
and NH2. Some of these larger wards also have mixed use zones. 9 of the wards (all
core wards) are along the water front. One ward where the District administration is
located is engulfed by the cantonment and at least 9 of the larger wards are along NH2.
The industrial zone along NH2 is in one ward as is Mathura Rail Junction. The sewage
farm in trans-Yamuna is also in one ward. Thus an intrinsic equation envelopes between
the master plan land use zones and the wards. Ground surveys had also shown that
though governance through wards is not very strong in Mathura as in most of urban and
rural areas of the state, yet, remarkably, local leadership and interests narrate and relate
their woes and aspirations in terms of wards. This happens in several settled urban
communities rooted to given locations, kith and kin and therefore are very vocal in
neighborhood deficiencies and needs. If resources are strengthened by and through the
NPP, the participatory process through wards could be strengthened in Mathura through
consistent capacity building in the NPP. The fact has to be underlined that the ward
councilor is the single elected ward representative. It is for him to constitute his
own ward committee and for which NPP level guidelines are required to make such
groups representative of all or most neighborhood views. This applies in equal
measure to Vrindavan NPP as well but not to Mathura Cant. and where the Sub Area
Commander and the Cant. Board understandable dictate local decisions.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


69
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION E: PROJECTS IDENTIFICATION FOR CAPITAL


INVESTMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP
E1. Project Levels

Based on the city’s needs and the emerging vision and strategy, the CDP projects have
been identified and structured at three levels:

x Regional Level;
x City Level;
x Ward Level.

E2. Project Sectors

The following are the sectors identified for projects as part of the Capital Investment Plan
for Mathura city:

Urban Infrastructure & Governance

x Water Supply
x Sewerage
x Drainage
x Solid Waste Management
x Roads, Traffic and Transportation
x Street Lighting
x Urban Environment
x Heritage & Tourism
x Urban Governance

Basic Services to Urban Poor

x Water Supply
x Sewerage
x Drainage
x Solid Waste Management
x Roads, Streets and Lanes
x Street Lighting
x Basic Amenities ( Public Conveniences, etc)
x Community Halls/ Training Centres
x Housing for BPL
x Training & Capacity Building

E3. List of Projects

The following are the list of projects that have emerged out of the key consultative process,
rapid assessment, the emerging city vision and strategies for the Mathura City Six year
CDP.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


70
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
E3.1 Regional Level Projects
Sr. No. Sector Projects Agency
1 Urban Full utilization of Gokul Barrage’s 100 mgd capacity UPJN
Services for for Mathura UA along with improved water treatment
Mathura UA plant facilities
(NPP + Cant) Feasibility report and financial closure of new UPJN
Barrage north of Vrindavan for MVDA’s needs other
Refer Map E1 than Mathura UA.
Refer Annex. F Desilting of the Yamuna UPJN
New Land fill site in Trans Yamuma for Mathura UA Mathura NPP
and Cant Board
2. Transportation Construction of 2 no. Interstate Bus Terminals (near UPSRTC/
NH2 and trans Yamuna) along with Transport Nagar MVDA
Refer Map E2 Improvement at entry points to NH2 and NOIDA – UPPWD
Agra Corridor including improved access to the
corridor.
3. Heritage and Lord Krishna Theme Park in trans Jamuna including UPTDC
Tourism ropeway access. MVDA
River cruisers with jetties to link Mathura and UPTDC
Refer Map E3 Vrindavan river front MVDA
New Mathura Museum near NH2 in lieu of current ASI + UPTDC
location + SDA, MVDA

Map E1

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


71
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Map E2

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


72
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Map E3

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


73
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
E3.2 City Level Projects
Sr. Sector Projects Agency
No.
1 Water Supply Consultation and upgradation of network for UA UPJN + NPP
area complete with upgradation and replacement of
pumping system, storage facilities and new feeder
mains.
Replacement of existing tube wells and provision of UPJN + NPP
new tube wells as per networks plan.
Strengthening system of maintenance, leak NPP
reduction and improved collection of user charges
2. Sewerage Replacement of existing outdated inner city network NPP and
and construction of new system on basis of UPJN, Cant
networks plan, inclusive of pumping and Board
construction of new STP’s and renovation of
existing ones) including convergence to and
upgrading at sewage farm as existing
3. Drainage Desisting of the existing and closed drains NPP
Construction of new closed drains and repairs to NPP
existing and closed drains and interception at
outfalls to the Yamuna/ STP’s as per networks plan
4. Solid Waste SWM capacity building as per SWM Master Plan NPP/ Cant
Management including provision of various size bins, collection, Board
conveyance, separateion, disposal and awareness
campaigns.
Separate treatment for hospital and industrial waste. NPP/ Cant
Board
5 Roads/ Traffic Widening, repair and upgradation of existing city NPP/UPPWD
and roads and upgradation and improvement of
Transportation crossings, junctions etc.
Construction of flyovers, crossings/ sub-ways; NPP/ UPPWD/
Construction of multi-storied parking; and MVDA
Construction of new parking bays.
Construction and provision of bus stops, shelters, NPP/ MVDA
Auto/ Taxi stands.
Provision of appropriate street / traffic infrastructure NPP / Police
(Street furniture, signage’s, hoardings, etc) Dept.
6 Street Lighting Upgradation of existing street light points. Provision NPP/ UPSEB
of street lighting system in un-serviced areas.
Upgradtion and provision of underground cable for
street lights.
Provision of high mast lights at key locations and
junctions. Provision of basic infrastructure for
operation and maintenance of street lights (light
restoration ladder enabled cranes, safety
equipments etc)
7 Urban x Rehabilitation and construction of modernized NPP/ MVDA
Environment slaughter house.
x Restoration and construction of Dhobi ghats. NPP/ MVDA
x Rehabilitation and construction of modernized NPP/ MVDA
dairy cattle centres.
x Environmental improvement of river front NPP/ MVDA
development along the Yamuna river.
x Desilting and restoration of twelve kunds with NPP/ MVDA
landscaping, lighting and other improvement.
x Construction of public conveniences system. NPP/ MVDA
x Urban greening, beautification and landscaping. NPP/ MVDA
x Including development of city parks / city NPP/ MVDA
squares.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


74
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
8 Heritage & x Official Listing of Sites, Remains, Ruins, NPP/UPTDC
Tourism Monuments, Buildings and landscapes of
Archaeological, Architectural, Historical, Cultural
and ecological value
x Development of Mathura Parikrima marg NPP/UPTDC,
including Restoration, conservation and MVDA
beautification of ghats.
x Renovation, restoration and conservation of NPP/UPTDC
heritage buildings. ASI/SDA
x Night illumination of important, heritage NPP/UPTDC
buildings, sites, kunds, ghats.
x Construction and development of heritage haat NPP/UPTDC
(on the lines of Delhi Haat), Art Gallery, MVDA
auditorium, etc.
x Construction and beautification of new ghats on NPP/UPTDC
trans Yamuna side. MVDA
x Light and sound shows / facilities along Ghats, NPP/UPTDC
Tourist information and display centres,
signage, etc
9 Urban x Resource Mobilization and Financial NPP
Governance / Management System of urban local body /
Institutional development agencie
Development / x Municipal Services and Performance NPP
Organizational Measurement.
Strengthening x Business process re-engineering NPP
x Computerization, e-Governance, GIS & MIS NPP
x Training & Capacity Building NPP
10 Basic Services to x In situ construction of housing for BPL. NPP/MVDA/
Urban Poor DUDA
x Water supply lines in un-serviced areas. NPP
Provision of hand pumps / community based
water supply system. Desilting of the existing
sewerage lines / drainages. Restoration, repair
of damaged sewer and drainage lines.
Construction of new sewer lines & drains in un-
serviced areas.
x Provision of infrastructure for municipal solid NPP
waste management.
x Upgradation and construction of approach NPP
roads, street lanes in the existing and un-
serviced areas.
x Installation of electric poles, light points in un- NPP/ DUDA
serviced areas and upgradation of existing
street lighting points.
x Construction of community halls and training NPP/ DUDA
centres.
x Basic amenities like public convenience, parks,
etc.

E3.3 Ward Level Projects


Sr. Sector Projects
No.
1 Water Supply x Water supply augmentation network lines at NPP
ward level
x Rain Water Harvesting & Recharging
x Supply and laying of additional conveyance
system
x Construction & Repair of OverHead Water

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


75
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
Tanks
2 Sewerage x Restoration of the damaged sewerage lines. NPP
x Provision of sewer lines in un-serviced areas.
x Provision of decentralized sewerage system at
ward level.
3 Drainage x Restoration of existing damaged drains. NPP
x Construction of drainage lines in un-serviced
areas and streets.
4 Solid Waste x Door to door collection of municipal solid waste NPP
Management x Provision of appropriate infrastructure for
municipal solid waste management (cycle
rickshaws, wheel barrows, garbage bins, street
cleaning equipments etc)
x Public awareness and campaign/ IEC.
5 Roads / Street x Upgradation and improvement of existing NPP
Lanes / Traffic and streets and lanes.
Transportation x Constriction of new streets and lanes and
approach streets/ roads.
x Provision of street infrastructure like signage’s,
hoardings, etc
6 Street Lighting x Upgradation of street light points. NPP
x Provision of street lighting in un-serviced areas.
x Upgradtion and provision of underground cable
for street lights.
x Basic infrastructure for operation and
maintenance.
x Complaint Redressal System.
7 Urban Environment x Upgradation and construction of ward level NPP
community managed parks.
8 Heritage & Tourism x Development of heritage ward precincts. NPP/UPTDC
x Basic infrastructure facilities around important
heritage areas at ward level including Street
furniture & parking system.
9 Urban Governance x Community Participation. NPP
/ Institutional x Neighborhood Committees.
Development / x Ward Level Committees.
Organizational x Resident Welfare Associations.
Strengthening x Report Card System.
10 Basic Services to x Community based infrastructure amenities like NPP
Urban Poor water supply, public conveniences, parks,
sanitation etc.

E4. SUMMARY OF THE PROJECTS

E4.1 Water Supply


Sr. No. Projects
Short Term Projects
1 Completion of the Mathura Vrindavan water supply scheme
2 Upgradation of pumping system to Manoharpura Zone
3 Additional 20 mld clariflocculator at Gokul Barrage Water Works
4 Replacement of existing pumping plants at different pumping stations
5 Supply and laying of additional conveyance system
6 Construction & Repair of OverHead Water Tanks
Medium Term Projects
7 Replacement of existing tubewells
8 Additional tube wells in Zone IX B

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


76
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
Sr. No. Projects
9 Modernization and automation of existing / proposed works
10 Leak detection equipments
11 Laying of feeder main from take off point of Ganga Jal Project upto existing 100 mld
WTP
Long Term Projects
12 Rain Water Harvesting & Recharging
13 Construction of New Barrage for Mathura and MVDA water supply north on Vrindavan
14 Water Treatment Plant at New Barrage
15 Construction and laying of feeder mains

E4.2 Sewerage
Sr. No. Projects
1 Cost of Works for Zone I
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement,
Crossing of railway line by rising main, Nala crossing (Masani Nala), Renovation and
Strengtheining of existing SPS, Renovation of existing Sewage Treatment Plants,
Pumping Plant for New IPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA, Replacement of
Pumping Plants of existing sewage pumping station.
2 Cost of Works for Zone II
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement,
Crossing of railway line by rising main,Strengthening of Bengali Ghat MPS and Rising
Main and two other existing sewage pumping station, Provision and replacement of
pumping plants Bengali Ghat MPS and other two existing sewage pumping station,
Pumping Plant for New IPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA.
3 Cost of Works for Zone III
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement, IPS &
MPS, Crossing of railway line by rising main (Mathura- Hathras) ,Nala Crossing,
Pumping Plant for new IPS and MPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA,
Special T&P for O&M of sewerage system, Building Works.
4 Cost of Works for Zone IV
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement, IPS &
MPS, Crossing of railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping Plant for new IPS
and MPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.
5 Cost of Works for Zone V
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement, IPS &
MPS, Crossing of railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping Plant for new IPS
and MPS (Dairy farm MPS, Cantt. SPS) , Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA,
Special T&P for O&M of sewerage system, Building Works.
6 Cost of Works for Zone VI
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement, IPS &
MPS, Crossing of railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping Plant for new IPS
and MPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.
7 Cost of Works for Zone VII
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road cutting and reinstatement, IPS &
MPS, Crossing of railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping Plant for new IPS
and MPS , Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.
8 Cost of MPS & Sewage Treatment Plants
Sewage Treatment Plant of following categories (UASB Type) : for Zone II,III, IV,V,VI,VII,
Cost of land for treatment plant for zone II,III,IV,V,VI,VII, Out fall drain for zone II,III,IV,VI
lined, unlined, for zone V and VII (PSC pipe), Special T&P for O&M of sewerage system,
Building Works.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


77
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
E4.3 Drainage
Sr. No. Projects
Desilting of Existing Nalas, Construction / Lining Works of Existing Nalas,
1 Construction of New Drains & Other Infrastructure
Masani Nala, Shahganj Nala, Bangali Ghat Nala, Dhurab Ghat Nala, Ambhakhar Nala,
Satrangi Nala, Mahadev Ghat Nala, Roopam Cinema-Deeg Gate, Krishna Janambhumi
– Deeg Gate, Bhuteshwar – BSA College, Sanjaynagar Nala- Potra Kund, Omnagar,
laxminagar, Govindnagar,E Sector, Ambedkar Nala, Sukdevnagar, Navneet Nagar,
Mohala Road,
Sonkh road drian, Krishna Nagar drain, highway drain, VIP road drain, Deeg Gate drain,
Dhauli Piyau drain, Janakpuri to BSA drain, Mohali road drain, Shriji baba road drain
Octray post Nala, Chakratirath Nala, Krishna ganga Nala, Gau Ghat Nala, Chintaharan
Nala,Daula Maula Nala, Rani Ghat Nala, Swami Ghat Nala, Askunda Ghat Nala,
Vishram Ghat Nala

Mahadev Ghat Nala, Satrangi Nala, Ambhakhar Nala, Dhurb Ghat Nala, Bangali Ghat
Nala, Shahganj Nala, Masani Nala, Proposed New Drains, Pumping Station including
rising main, railway crossing / Highway crossing
Dairy farm Nala, Cantt Nala, Mahavidya Nala
Aurangabad Nala, Trans Highway Nala, Rising mains , Highway / Rly. Crossings
Pumping Stations, Treatment Plants ( Decentralized Level)

E4.4 Solid Waste Management


Sr. No. Projects
1 Containerized tricycle carts (200 Nos.)
2 Containerized handcarts
3 Seamless handcarts for drain cleaning
4 Garbage Bins (2000 Nos.)
5 Containers for waste handling (4000 Nos.)
6 Small vehicles for direct collection of waste (Tempo Dumper - 15 Nos.)
7 Closed dumper placer type containers of 4.5 cu.m capacity (40 Nos.)
8 Containers for harzadous wastes
9 Dumper placer machine for 4.5 / 7.0 cu. M containers (8 Nos.)
10 4.5 cu.m skips for construction waste
11 Skip filters
12 Small vans for hospital/ garden / hotels waste/ collection
13 Inceneration plants
14 Bulldozer
15 Asphalt / concrete flooring under the bins
16 Landfill Site of 150-200 MT waste per day (Trans Yamuna, Highway sides)
17 Equipments and T&P required for landfill site development of 200 MT per day
18 Public Awareness , IEC
19 Provision for supervision and control , MIS etc
20 Provision for construction of sheds for vehicles, workshops, and boundary wall of the
campus
21 Provision for communication system etc
22 JCB Backhoe Machine with rear and front bucket ( 5 Nos.)
23 Tractors (14 Nos.)
24 Hydraulic Trolley for Tractors (16 Nos.)
25 Septic Tank Cleaning Machines (5 Nos.)
26 Litter Bins around markets and important places of tourist interest (1000 Nos. )
27 Cattle/ Stray Animal Catcher (3 No.s)
28 Fogging Machine ( 2 Nos.)
29 Sewer Cleaning Jet Machine ( 5 No.s )

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


78
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
E4.5 Roads, Traffic & Transportation
Sr. No. Projects
1 Construction of Roads/Widening and upgradation of city roads
Approach road to Kailash Nagar, BSA to Radhika Vihar via Dwarika Puri, BSA to
Janakpuri, New Bus stand to Gopal Nagar, Bharatpur Gate to Chowk Bazar, Masani to
Vrindavan Gate via Lal Darwaja, Duke palace hotel to Radheshyam colony, Bhuteshwar
to Machhali Mandi, Bhens Bahora to Bankhandi, Bhens Bahora Road, Kalyan Kroti to
NH-2 via Azmabad, Chamunda Dairy to Saraswatikund, Aligarh Road to Dauji Road via
sewage farm Yamuna par
2 Construction of various streets at ward level
Streets in between Mohali road and BSA road, Goverdhan road and BSA road,
Goverdhan road and Vrindavan road and back side road of Janambhumi to NH-2,
Vrindavan road & katchi sadak, lal Darwaja chowk bharatpur Gate to Deeg gate police
chowki , Streets in between Vrindavan road and katchi sadak, lal darwaja, Masani
Tiraha to Birla Mandir, masani crossing to Gokul restaurant (NH-2), Streets in between
lal darwaja chowk, Bharatpur gate to state bank crossing, Dampir Cantt. Bridge, Krishna
puri Tiraha, Streets in between Jamunapar Aligarh road, Gokul road tiraha, and upto
Shahjadpur Tappa petrol pump, Streets in between Aligarh road, Sadar, Badpura civil
line, Streets in between Agra road, Dhauli piyau, Natver Nagar, Inderpuri and
Chanderpuri colony, Nagla Shivji, Internal Streets of 45 wards.
3 Parikrima Marg (14 kms)
Parikrima marg from Dhorera to Gau Ghat, General Ganj to Quality Hotel tiraha, via
Ambakhar, Brij Nagar to infront of Mohali road , Kankali to Balbhadera kund,
Bhuteshwar to Potra Kund, Mahavidya mandir to Chamunda mandir
4 Developnment of Approoach Road/ Flyover crossings / junctions
Bharatpur Road crossing, Sonkh road crossing, Goverdhan Road crossing, Delhi road
crossinbg, Raya Aligarh road crossing) – 5 No.s
5 RUB/ ROB / Under Pass/ Sub-ways
Naya Bus Adda, Purana Bas Adda, Buteshwar Tiraha, Dhaulipiyau crossing, Murga
Phatak, General Ganj railway crossing, Deeg Gate Janam Bhumi ( 7 No.s)
6 Multi-Storied Parking & Parking Bays ( Holigate, Old Bus stand, Chowk Bazar,
Bharatpur Gate, Deeg Gate, Bhuteshwar, Birla Mandir, Trans Yamuna, Potra Kund)
7 Relocation of Old & New Bus Terminals ( New Inter State Bus Terminal ) – UPSIDC
area & additional Bus Terminal in Trans Yamuna area
8 2 no. Transport Nagar (Cys Highway and Trans Yamuna)
9 Traffic / Transportation Infrastructure
Street furniture, signages, hoardings, parking bays/ shelters, Bus stops/ shelters, Auto/
taxi stands/ parking bays,Stoppers, Icones, Speed Aanlysers, Breath Analysers, etc

10 Traffic Cranes ( 5 Nos.)


11 PCR Vans (5 Nos.)
12 Traffic Contol Bikes (10 Nos.)
13 Battery operated vehicles in no pollution zones
14 City bus for catering tourists within city and outside areas.
15 Replacement of Rail Car between Mathura and Vrindavan by a Frequent Bus System

E4.6 Street Lighting


Sr. No. Projects
1 Underground street lighting cables (LT cables)
2 Street lighting in un-serviced areas.
3 Upgradation of existing street light points.
4 High mast lights at various important locations / junctions (28 Nos.) : Gokul restaurant /
Agrasen chauraha, Deeg gate / Govind nagar chauraha, Bhuteshwar tiraha, Statebank
chauraha, Tank chauraha, Kwality tiraha, Holigate, bharatpur gate, GIC chauraha,
Janambhumi, Dampier, Potra kund, Chowk Bazar, Yamuna Bridge, Laxminagar
Yamunapar, Township, Sadarbazar tiraha, Krishnapuri tiraha, sonkh road, Dhauli piyau ,
dhauli piyau main marg, Lal darwaza, Akshwani Chowraha, Birla Mandir, Bangali ghat,

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


79
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
Krishnagar Choraha, Bhuteshwar parikrama marg.
5 Basic infrastructure in O&M (ladders, safety equipments, tools and tackles)
6 Ladder enabled cranes (5 Nos.)
7 Diesel Generators ( 10 No.s)

E4.7 Urban Environment


Sr. No. Projects
1 Development of modernized slaughter house.
2 Development of Dhobi Ghats.
3 Development of modernized cattle dairy centres.
4 Urban Plantation, Beautification and Landscaping of water bodies / ponds and open
spaces along roads / vacant areas, important public places.
5 Renovation and conservation and restoration of 12 no. Kunds and their beautification.

E4.8 Heritage & Tourism


Sr. No. Projects
1. Listing of Sites, Monuments and Building
2. Development of Mathura Parikrama marg (14 kms)
3. Renovation and conservation of buildings of heritage importance.
4. Renovation, conservation and restoration of Ghats.
5. Beautification of Ghats and Gokul Barrage.
6. Night illumination and lighting facilities on heritage importance buildings, Kunds and
ghats
7. Development of Heritage Urban Haat ( On lines of Delhi Urban Haat) for artisans, local
craft and skills, Art Gallery, auditorium, etc.
8. Ropeway Suspension bridge from Swami Ghat to other side of the Yamuna Bank.
9. Development of new Ghats on other side of Yamuna River (Trans Yamuna)
10. Tourist Information and Display Centres, Central (large scale) and decentralized level -
Gokul restaurant, Goverdhan crossing, Aurangabad crossing, Gokul barrage, Aligarh
raya
11. Light and sound show facilities along Ghats and Yamuna River Bank.
12. Lord Krishna Theme Park with multiple facilities.
13. Construction of new Museum in lieu of existing Mathura museum.
14. River cruises along Yamuna.
15. Basic amenities in and around the Parikrama Marg (Public conveniences, Piyau’s, Claok
Rooms, Information / help desks etc)
16. Tourism signage’s and information displays around various routes, Parikrima Marg etc.
17. Audio Video visual system at information and display centres.
18. Training and development centre for local guides trainings.
19. Entry Gates & Beautifications : From Delhi road , from Agra road, Aligarh entry,
Bharatpur gate

E4.9 Urban Governance


Sr. No. Projects
1 Double Entry Accounting System
2 Financial Management System
3 Municipal Services Performance Measurement System
4 Computerisation, E-Governance /GIS
5 Complaint Redressal System
6 Management Information System
7 Business Process Re-engineering
8 Unified Payment System
9 Property Tax Management System
10 Training & Capacity Building
11 Strengthening of Wards and ward committees

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


80
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report
E4.10 Basic Services for Urban Poor - District Urban Development Authority
(DUDA)

The extent of the areas include:

45 wards of the city, which comprises of 18 zones and 68 slum pockets, besides the areas
up to : Bakalpur, Ganeshra, Satoh, Mandi choraha upto Narholi, Tantura, Damodarpur ,
Aurangabad, Gokul Barrage, Yamunapar, Laxminagar, upto Gokul barrage , Aligarh road
upto Sayyed, Vrindavan road , Dhorera, Akrur, Koel Alipur , Mathura Refinery township,
Saraiazampur.

Sr.
Projects
No.
Short Term Projects
1 Water Supply
Handpumps, upgradation works, distribution lines etc
2 Sewerage
Desilting, construction, community based sewerage system
3 Storm Water Drainage
Desilting, Construction, Upgradation of UG drains, Storm Water Drains
4 Roads
Upgradation of existing roads and construction of new roads, streets, lanes, sub-lanes
5 Street Lighting
Installation of light poles,light points and upgradation of street lighting points
6 Solid Waste Management
Medium Term Projects
7 Community Halls/ Centres, Training Centres
8 Public Conveniences / Community Toilets, Night Shelters
9 In situ construction of housing for BPL
Long Term Projects
10 Training & Capacity Building / Infrastructure

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


81
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION F: THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN FOR MATHURA


NPP AREA
F1 CIP CRITERIA

The Capital Investment Plan (CIP) has been framed looking at the level of investment’s
that would be required to implement the CDP.

The capital investment has been made as a multi-year schedule of improvements of the
existing assets/ infrastructure and of new infrastructure. The phasing of the investments
has been done on the basis of the city’s requirements and the resources that could be
generated from the potential projects to sustain the assets and investments over a period
of years. Though the programme is for 7 years from 2005-06 to 2011-12, the phasing
through the consultative process has been shown for the 5 year period of 2006-07 to
2010-11, anticipating an overspill into 2011-12 but not beyond.

The CIP process involved the following criteria :

x Project Identification
x Project Prioritization
x Capital Investment and Phasing

F2 PROJECT INVESTMENTS

The projects as identified have been assessed to require phased out investments between
2006-07 to 2011-12, as below. This is shown in tabular form in each of the ten sectors.

Total
Investment Yearly Investment Required (Rs. in Crores)
Sr.
Sector Required
No. 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
(Rs. in
Crores) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Water Supply 320.00 109.70 86.00 62.40 41.30 15.60 5.00
2 Sewerage 304.00 49.00 69.00 65.00 55.00 41.00 25.00
Drainage / Storm
3 228.00 78.00 63.00 44.00 25.00 10.00 8.00
Water Drainage
Solid Waste
4 76.57 15.82 29.45 28.45 1.45 0.90 0.50
Management
5 Street Lighting 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.30 6.25 3.35
Urban Roads &
6 367.30 94.07 96.56 80.31 52.01 25.30 19.05
Traffic
7 Heritage & Tourism 269.00 56.20 85.15 57.30 38.80 18.00 13.55
Urban Poor and
8 132.56 26.51 26.51 39.77 19.88 13.26 6.63
Slums
Municipal
9 10.25 2.90 2.65 2.35 1.20 0.65 0.50
Governance
10 Urban Environment 66.50 14.50 21.50 21.25 4.75 3.00 1.50
Total 1830.43 459.15 494.27 414.28 245.69 133.96 83.08

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


82
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.1 Water Supply


Agency
Proposed
Sr. for Agency
Projects Investments Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. Capital for O&M
(Rs.In crores)
Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Balance left over works of Mathura Vrindavan water
1 80.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 UPJN NPP
supply scheme
Upgradation of pumping system to Manoharpura
2 5.00 1.75 1.25 1.00 0.75 0.25 0.00 UPJN NPP
Zone
Additional 20 mld clariflocculator at Gokul Barrage
3 2.00 0.70 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.10 0.00 UPJN UPJN
Water Works
Replacement of existing pumping plants at different
4 10.00 3.50 2.50 2.00 1.50 0.50 0.00 UPJN NPP
pumping stations

5 Supply and laying of additional conveyance system 20.00 7.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 UPJN NPP

6 Replacement of existing tubewells 10.00 3.50 3.00 2.00 1.50 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
7 Additional tube wells in Zone IX B 3.00 1.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Modernization and automation of existing / proposed
8 5.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
works
9 Leak detection equipments 5.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Laying of feeder main from take off point of Ganga Jal
10 10.00 3.50 2.50 2.00 1.50 0.50 0.00 UPJN UPJN
Project upto existing 100 mld WTP
11 Construction & Repair of Over Head Water Tanks 15.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
12 Rain Water Harvesting & Recharging 20.00 7.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Feasibility studies for new barrage for water source
13 10.00 0.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN
augmentation
14 Construction and laying of feeder mains 75.00 26.25 18.75 15.00 11.25 3.75 0.00 UPJN UPJN
15 Internal ward level additional conveyance system 50.00 17.50 12.50 10.00 7.50 2.50 0.00 UPJN NPP
Total 320.00 109.70 86.00 62.40 41.30 15.60 5.00

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 83


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.2 Sewerage System

Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs.in Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Cost of Works for Zone I 30.00 5.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, Crossing of railway line by
rising main, Nala crossing (Masani Nala), Renovation
and Strengtheining of existing SPS, Renovation of
existing Sewage Treatment Plants, Pumping Plant for
New IPS, Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA,
Replacement of Pumping Plants of existing sewage
pumping station.
2 Cost of Works for Zone II 20.00 0.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 2.50 2.50 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, Crossing of railway line by
rising main,Strengthening of Bengali Ghat MPS and
Rising Main and two other existing sewage pumping
station, Provision and replacement of pumping plants
Bengali Ghat MPS and other two existing sewage
pumping station, Pumping Plant for New IPS, Electic
Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA.
3 Cost of Works for Zone III 20.00 0.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 2.50 2.50 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, IPS & MPS, Crossing of
railway line by rising main (Mathura- Hathras) ,Nala
Crossing, Pumping Plant for new IPS and MPS,
Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special
T&P for O&M of sewerage system, Building Works.
4 Cost of Works for Zone IV 32.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 7.00 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, IPS & MPS, Crossing of
railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping
Plant for new IPS and MPS, Electic Transmission
line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 84


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs.in Capital for O&M
crores) Works
5 Cost of Works for Zone V 30.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, IPS & MPS, Crossing of
railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping
Plant for new IPS and MPS (Dairy farm MPS, Cantt.
SPS) , Electic Transmission line, DG Set 100 KVA,
Special T&P for O&M of sewerage system, Building
Works.
6 Cost of Works for Zone VI 18.00 6.00 5.00 4.00 2.00 1.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, IPS & MPS, Crossing of
railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping
Plant for new IPS and MPS, Electic Transmission
line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.
7 Cost of Works for Zone VII 21.00 5.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 UPJN NPP
Main & branch sewer lines, Rising Main for IPS, Road
cutting and reinstatement, IPS & MPS, Crossing of
railway line by rising main ,Nala Crossing, Pumping
Plant for new IPS and MPS , Electic Transmission
line, DG Set 100 KVA, Special T&P for O&M of
sewerage system, Building Works.
8 Cost of MPS & Sewage Treatment Plants 38.00 13.00 9.00 7.00 5.00 2.00 2.00 UPJN NPP
Sewage Treatment Plant of following categories
(UASB Type) : for Zone II,III, IV,V,VI,VII, Cost of land
for treatment plant for zone II,III,IV,V,VI,VII, Out fall
drain for zone II,III,IV,VI lined, unlined, for zone V and
VII (PSC pipe), Special T&P for O&M of sewerage
system, Building Works.
9 Sewerage lines & connections at ward level 95.00 10.00 20.00 20.00 20.00 20.00 5.00 UPJN NPP
Total 304.00 49.00 69.00 65.00 55.00 41.00 25.00

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 85


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.3 Drainage System


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Phase - I
Construction/ Lining work of existing Nalas 98.00 30.00 25.00 20.00 15.00 5.00 3.00 UPJN NPP
Mahadev Ghat Nala, Satrangi Nala, Ambhakhar Nala,
Dhurb Ghat Nala, Bangali Ghat Nala, Shahganj Nala,
Masani Nala, Proposed New Drains, Pumping Station
including rising main, railway crossing / Highway
crossing
Desilting of Existing Nala 7.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Masani Nala, Shahganj Nala, Bangali Ghat Nala,
Dhurab Ghat Nala, Ambhakhar Nala, Satrangi Nala,
Mahadev Ghat Nala
2 Phase- II
Construction / Lining work of Existing Nala 80.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 UPJN NPP
Dairy farm Nala, Cantt Nala, Mahavidya Nala
Construction of New Drains
Aurangabad Nala, Trans Highway Nala, Drain,
Pumping Station, Rising main , Highway / Rly.
Crossing
Desilting / Repairs of Existing Drains 7.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Sonkh road drian, Krishna Nagar drain, highway
drain, VIP road drain, Deeg Gate drain, Dhauli Piyau
drain, Janakpuri to BSA drain, Mohali road drain,
Shriji baba road drain
3 Phase-III
Desilting / Repairs of existing drains
Octray post Nala, Chakratirath Nala, Krishna ganga
Nala, Gau Ghat Nala, Chintaharan Nala,Daula Maula
6.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Nala, Rani Ghat Nala, Swami Ghat Nala, Askunda
Ghat Nala, Vishram Ghat Nala
Construction of New Drain , Trans Highway New
30.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 UPJN NPP
Drains
Total 228.00 78.00 63.00 44.00 25.00 10.00 8.00

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 86


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.4 Solid Waste Management System


Proposed Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
Sr. Agency Agency
Projects Investments
No. for for
(Rs.in 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Capital O&M
crores)
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Works

1 SWM Master Plan 0.15 0.15 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP

2 Containerized tricycle carts (200 Nos.) 0.20 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

3 Containerized handcarts 0.25 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.00 NPP NPP

4 Seamless handcarts for drain cleaning 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

5 Garbage Bins (2000 Nos.) 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

6 Containers for waste handling (4000 Nos.) 0.20 0.05 0.05 0.00 0.05 0.05 0.00 NPP NPP
Small vehicles for direct collection of waste (Tempo
7 0.25 0.05 0.10 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Dumper - 15 Nos.)
Closed dumper placer type containers of 4.5 cu.m
8 0.55 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.00 NPP NPP
capacity (40 Nos.)
9 Containers for harzadous wastes 0.20 0.00 0.10 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Dumper placer machine for 4.5 / 7.0 cu. M containers
10 1.20 0.15 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.15 0.00 NPP NPP
(8 Nos.)
11 4.5 cu.m skips for construction waste 0.03 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

12 Skip filters 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Small vans for hospital/ garden / hotels waste/
13 0.25 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.00 NPP NPP
collection
14 Inceneration plants 1.00 0.00 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

15 Bulldozer 0.40 0.00 0.20 0.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

16 Asphalt / concrete flooring under the bins 1.50 0.00 0.75 0.75 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

17 Landfill Site of 150-200 MT waste per day 50.00 10.00 20.00 20.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
Equipments and T&P required for landfill site
18 5.00 1.00 2.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
development of 200 MT per day

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 87


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Proposed Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)


Sr. Agency Agency
Projects Investments
No. for for
(Rs.in 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Capital O&M
crores)
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Works

19 Public Awareness 2.00 0.50 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 NPP NPP

20 Provision for supervision and control , MIS etc 2.00 0.50 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 NPP NPP
Provision for construction of sheds for vehicles,
21 5.00 1.00 2.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
workshops etc
22 Provision for communication system etc 1.00 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
JCB Backhoe Machine with rear and front bucket (4
23 1.00 0.25 0.25 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Nos.)
24 Tractors (14 Nos.) 0.60 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

25 Hydraulic Trolley for Tractors (16 Nos.) 0.20 0.05 0.05 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

26 Septic Tank Cleaning Machines (4 os.) 1.00 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Litter Bins around markets and important places of
27 0.35 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.05 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
tourist interest (1000 Nos. )
28 Cattle/ Stray Animal Catcher (3 No.s) 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

29 Fogging Machine ( 2 Nos.) 0.30 0.15 0.15 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

30 Sewer Cleaning Jet Machine ( 4 No.s ) 1.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP

Total 76.57 15.82 29.45 28.45 1.45 0.90 0.50

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 88


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.5 Road & Traffic / Transportation


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Construction of Roads/Widening and upgradation of
1 75.00 20.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 NPP NPP
city roads
Approach road to Kailash Nagar, BSA to Radhika
Vihar via Dwarika Puri, BSA to Janakpuri, New Bus
stand to Gopal Nagar, Bharatpur Gate to Chowk
Bazar, Masani to Vrindavan Gate via Lal Darwaja,
Duke palace hotel to Radheshyam colony,
Bhuteshwar to Machhali Mandi, Bhens Bahora to
Bankhandi, Bhens Bahora Road, Kalyan Kroti to NH-
2 via Azmabad, Chamunda Dairy to Saraswatikund,
Aligarh Road to Dauji Road via sewage farm Yamuna
par
2 Construction of various streets at ward level 46.00 15.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 3.00 3.00 NPP NPP
Streets in between Mohali road and BSA road,
Goverdhan road and BSA road, Goverdhan road and
Vrindavan road and back side road of Janambhumi to
NH-2, Vrindavan road & katchi sadak, lal Darwaja
chowk bharatpur Gate to Deeg gate police chowki ,
Streets in between Vrindavan road and katchi sadak,
lal darwaja, Masani Tiraha to Birla Mandir, masani
crossing to Gokul restaurant (NH-2), Streets in
between lal darwaja chowk, Bharatpur gate to state
bank crossing, Dampir Cantt. Bridge, Krishna puri
Tiraha, Streets in between Jamunapar Aligarh road,
Gokul road tiraha, and upto Shahjadpur Tappa petrol
pump, Streets in between Aligarh road, Sadar,
Badpura civil line, Streets in between Agra road,
Dhauli piyau, Natver Nagar, Inderpuri and
Chanderpuri colony, Nagla Shivji, Internal Streets of
45 wards.
3 Parikrima Marg (14 kms) 25.00 8.75 6.25 5.00 3.75 1.25 NPP NPP
Parikrima marg from Dhorera to Gau Ghat, General
Ganj to Quality Hotel tiraha, via Ambakhar, Brij Nagar
to infront of Mohali road , Kankali to Balbhadera
kund, Bhuteshwar to Potra Kund, Mahavidya mandir
to Chamunda mandir

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 89


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
Development of approach roads & flyover crossings /
junctions along NH-2 (Bharatpur road crossing,
4 50.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 PWD PWD
Sonkh road crossing, Goverdhan road crossing, Delhi
road crossing, Raya Aligarh road crossing) – 5 Nos.
RUB / ROB / Flyovers, Sub-ways and Railway
Crossings (Murga Phatak, Naya Bus Adda, Purana
5 Bus Adda, Bhuteshwar Tiraha, Daulipiyau Crossing, 40.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 PWD PWD
Cantonment – State Bank, General Ganj, Deeg Gate
Janam Bhumi) – 7 Nos.
Multi-Storied Parking & Parking Bays ( Holigate,
Chowk Bazar, Bharatpur Gate, Deeg Gate,
6 50.00 10.00 15.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 PVT PVT
Bhuteshwar, Jaysingpura, Birla Mandir, Methodist
Hospital, Trans Yamuna)
Relocation of Old & New Bus Terminals ( New Inter
7 30.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
State Bus Terminal ) - 2 no.s
8 Transport Nagar (Cys Highway, Trans Yamuna) 10.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
Replacement of rail route between Mathura and
9 30.00 5.00 10.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
Vrindavan with frequent bus system
10 Traffic / Transportation Infrastructure
Street furniture, signages, hoardings, parking bays/
shelters, Bus stops/ shelters, Auto/ taxi stands/
10.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 TRAFFIC TRAFFIC
parking bays,Stoppers, Icones, Speed Aanlysers,
Breath Analysers, etc
11 Traffic Cranes ( 5 Nos.) 0.75 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.05 0.05 0.05 TRAFFIC TRAFFIC
12 PCR Vans (5 Nos.) 0.50 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.20 0.00 0.00 TRAFFIC TRAFFIC
13 Traffic Contol Bikes (10 Nos.) 0.05 0.02 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.00 TRAFFIC TRAFFIC
Total 367.30 94.07 96.56 80.31 52.01 25.30 19.05

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 90


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.6 Street Lighting


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Underground street lighting cables (LT cables) 27.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 2.00 NPP NPP
2 Street lighting in un-serviced areas. 15.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
3 Upgradation of existing street light points. 8.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 NPP NPP
High mast lights at various important locations /
4 4.00 0.00 2.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
junctions (27 Nos.)
Basic infrastructure in O&M (ladders, safety
5 0.50 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.05 0.05 NPP NPP
equipments, tools and tackles)
6 Ladder enabled cranes (5 Nos.) 0.75 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
7 Diesel Generators ( 10 No.s) 1.00 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.20 0.20 0.30 NPP NPP
Total 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.30 6.25 3.35

F2.7 Urban Environment


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Development of modernized slaughter house. 20.00 0.00 10.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP PVT
2 Development of Dhobi Ghats. 1.50 0.50 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
3 Development of modernized cattle dairy centres. 15.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Urban Plantation, Beautification and Landscaping,
4 30.00 9.00 6.00 6.00 4.50 3.00 1.5 PVT PVT
Van/ Gardens on Trans Yamuna
Total 66.50 14.50 21.50 21.25 4.75 3.00 1.50

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 91


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.8 Heritage & Tourism


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Renovation, conservation and preservation of
UP
1 buildings of heritage importance, and old 20.00 5.00 10.00 2.00 2.00 0.50 0.50
TOURISM
architecturally valued buildings.
UP
2 Renovation, conservation and restoration of Kunds. 12.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00
TOURISM
UP
3 Renovation, conservation and restoration of Ghats. 20.00 7.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.00
TOURISM
UP
4 Beautification of Ghats and Gokul Barrage. 10.00 3.50 2.50 2.00 1.50 0.50 0.00 NPP
TOURISM
UP
5 Development of Mathura Parikrama marg (14 kms) 20.00 2.00 8.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00
TOURISM
Night illumination and lighting facilities on heritage UP UP
6 5.00 1.75 1.25 1.00 0.75 0.25 0.00
importance buildings. TOURISM TOURISM
Development of Heritage Urban Haat ( On lines of
UP UP
7 Delhi Urban Haat for artisans, local craft and skills, 3.00 1.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
TOURISM TOURISM
etc)
Ropeway Suspension bridge from Swami Ghat to UP
8 20.00 0.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00
other side of the Yamuna Bank. TOURISM
Development of new Ghats on other side of Yamuna UP
9 20.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 2.00 2.00 1.00
River (Trans Yamuna) TOURISM
10 Tourist Information and Display Centres. 5.00 1.00 2.00 1.00 0.50 0.25 0.25 PVT PVT
Lighting and sound show facilities along Ghats and UP UP
11 10.00 3.00 2.00 2.00 1.50 0.50 1.00
Yamuna River Bank. TOURISM TOURISM
Lord Krishna Theme Park (on the lines of Akshardam,
12 Swaminarayan Temple of Gandhinagar, Gujarat), 50.00 10.00 15.00 10.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 PVT PVT
hertiage museum
13 Water sports and cruiser facilities along Yamuna 20.00 5.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 PVT PVT
14 Open air theatre and cultural auditorium. 10.00 3.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 PVT PVT
Basic physical and social amenities in and around the UP
15 5.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.50 0.50 NPP
Parikrama Marg. TOURISM
Tourism signage’s and information displays around UP UP
16 2.00 0.35 0.50 0.40 0.35 0.30 0.10
various routes, Parikrima Marg etc. TOURISM TOURISM

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 92


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores) Works
Audio Video visual system at information and display
17 1.00 0.30 0.20 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.10 PVT PVT
centres.
Training and development centre for local guides UP UP
18 1.00 0.30 0.20 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.10
trainings. TOURISM TOURISM
Youth Hostel, camping facilities for Pilgrims,
19 temporary parking facilities, boarding/ loadging 15.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
facilities with cloak rooms
20 Working womens hostel 2.00 0.00 1.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
21 Recreational, sports and cultural complex 15.00 0.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 PVT PVT
22 Age old homes / hospitality 1.50 0.00 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 NPP NPP
Feasibility study for infrastructure provision in new
23 1.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.50 0.00 0.00 NPP
township
Total 269.00 56.20 85.15 57.30 38.80 18.00 13.55

F2.9 Urban Governance


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores)
No. (Rs. In Capital for O&M
crores Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Double Entry Accounting System 1.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP
2 Financial Management System 1.50 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 NPP
Municipal Services Performance
3 0.25 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.00 NPP
Measurement System
4 Computerisation, E-Governance /GIS 2.00 1.00 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP
5 Complaint Redressal System 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP
6 Management Information System 0.25 0.10 0.15 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 NPP
7 Business Process Re-engineering 0.55 0.10 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.00 0.00 NPP
8 Unified Payment System 0.75 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.05 0.00 NPP
9 Property Tax Management System 0.45 0.05 0.10 0.20 0.05 0.05 0.00 NPP
10 Training & Capacity Building 2.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.25 0.25 NPP
Total 10.25 2.90 2.65 2.35 1.20 0.65 0.50

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 93


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F2.10 Urban Poor & Slum


Proposed Agency
Sr. Investments for Agency for
Projects Investments Required under JNNURM (Rs. in Crores) %age
No. (Rs. In Capital O&M
crores Works
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Water Supply
Handpumps, upgradation
4.88 0.98 0.98 1.46 0.73 0.49 0.24 4 DUDA DUDA
works, distribution lines etc
2 Sewerage
Desilting, construction,
community based sewerage 15.67 3.13 3.13 4.70 2.35 1.57 0.78 12 DUDA DUDA
system
3 Storm Water Drainage
Desilting, Construction,
Upgradation of UG drains, 21.10 4.22 4.22 6.33 3.17 2.11 1.06 16 DUDA DUDA
Storm Water Drains
4 Roads
Upgradation of existing
roads and construction of 32.71 6.54 6.54 9.81 4.91 3.27 1.64 25 DUDA DUDA
new roads
5 Street Lighting
Installation of light
poles,light points and
15.23 3.05 3.05 4.57 2.28 1.52 0.76 11 DUDA DUDA
upgradation of street lighting
points
6 Solid Waste Management 2.70 0.54 0.54 0.81 0.41 0.27 0.14 2 DUDA DUDA
7 Community Halls 6.90 1.38 1.38 2.07 1.04 0.69 0.35 5 DUDA DUDA
Public Conveneinces /
8 Community Toilets, Night 8.90 1.78 1.78 2.67 1.34 0.89 0.45 7 DUDA DUDA
Shelters
Housing for BPL (5000 DUDA/Be
9 23.57 4.71 4.71 7.07 3.54 2.36 1.18 18 DUDA
nos.) neficiaries
Training & Capacity
10 0.90 0.18 0.18 0.27 0.14 0.09 0.05 1 DUDA DUDA
Building / Infrastructure
132.56 26.51 26.51 39.77 19.88 13.26 6.63 100

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 94


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

All Figures in Crores

Training /
Total Project Street Community Basic Housing
Zones Water Supply Sewerage Drainage Roads SWM Capacity
Cost Lighting Halls Amenities BPL
Building
Zone 1 9.16 0.26 0.84 1.35 1.85 1.25 0.15 0.25 0.20 2.96 0.05
Zone 2 5.97 0.15 0.48 1.15 0.98 1.16 0.15 0.25 0.45 1.15 0.05
Zone 3 5.66 0.26 0.83 0.40 1.70 0.85 0.15 0.25 0.40 0.77 0.05
Zone 4 6.99 0.34 1.08 0.65 1.95 1.05 0.15 0.50 0.40 0.82 0.05
Zone 5 2.63 0.15 0.48 0.45 0.45 0.45 0.15 0.00 0.20 0.25 0.05
Zone 6 9.00 0.38 1.20 0.52 2.95 1.35 0.15 0.25 0.30 1.85 0.05
Zone 7 7.13 0.32 1.02 0.95 2.45 1.14 0.15 0.25 0.40 0.40 0.05
Zone 8 5.12 0.24 0.77 0.55 1.65 0.65 0.15 0.25 0.20 0.61 0.05
Zone 9 6.14 0.19 0.60 1.60 1.55 0.60 0.15 0.25 0.20 0.95 0.05
Zone 10 7.01 0.33 1.06 0.78 1.75 0.75 0.15 0.50 0.75 0.89 0.05
Zone 11 7.86 0.28 0.90 1.80 2.45 0.35 0.15 0.25 0.65 0.98 0.05
Zone 12 7.77 0.34 1.10 0.30 2.60 0.70 0.15 0.50 0.65 1.38 0.05
Zone 13 10.31 0.31 0.98 2.50 2.15 0.55 0.15 0.50 0.60 2.52 0.05
Zone 14 8.81 0.27 0.88 1.85 2.10 0.68 0.15 0.00 0.60 2.23 0.05
Zone 15 6.62 0.29 0.93 1.45 1.15 0.50 0.15 0.75 0.45 0.90 0.05
Zone 16 2.95 0.10 0.37 0.50 0.68 0.40 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.40 0.05
Zone 17 9.28 0.28 0.90 1.95 1.45 0.95 0.15 0.75 0.80 2.00 0.05
Zone 18 14.15 0.39 1.25 2.35 2.85 1.85 0.15 1.25 1.50 2.51 0.05
Total 132.56 4.88 15.67 21.10 32.71 15.23 2.70 6.90 8.90 23.57 0.90

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 95


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

F3 PROPOSED CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN (CIP) FOR MATHURA

The proposed Capital Investment Plan (CIP) for Mathura is summarized in tabular form below:
Total
Investment Yearly Investment Required (Rs. in Crores)
Sr. GoUP ULB
Sector Required %age GoI (80%)
No. 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 (10%) (10%) *
(Rs. in
Crores) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Water Supply 320.00 109.70 86.00 62.40 41.30 15.60 5.00 17.48 256.00 32.00 32.00
2 Sewerage 304.00 49.00 69.00 65.00 55.00 41.00 25.00 16.61 243.20 30.40 30.40
Drainage / Storm Water
3 228.00 78.00 63.00 44.00 25.00 10.00 8.00 12.46 182.40 22.80 22.80
Drainage
4 Solid Waste Management 76.57 15.82 29.45 28.45 1.45 0.90 0.50 4.18 61.26 7.66 7.66
5 Street Lighting 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.30 6.25 3.35 3.07 45.00 5.63 5.63
6 Urban Roads & Traffic 367.30 94.07 96.56 80.31 52.01 25.30 19.05 20.07 293.84 36.73 36.73
7 Heritage & Tourism 269.00 56.20 85.15 57.30 38.80 18.00 13.55 14.70 215.20 26.90 26.90
8 Urban Poor and Slums 132.56 26.51 26.51 39.77 19.88 13.26 6.63 7.24 106.05 13.26 13.26
9 Municipal Governance 10.25 2.90 2.65 2.35 1.20 0.65 0.50 0.56 8.20 1.03 1.03
10 Urban Environment 66.50 14.50 21.50 21.25 4.75 3.00 1.50 3.63 53.20 6.65 6.65
Total 1830.43 459.15 494.27 414.28 245.69 133.96 83.08 100.00 1464.34 183.04 183.04

Total 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12


Sr. Investment
Description
No. Required
(Rs. in Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Crores)
1 GOI (80%) 1464.34 367.32 395.42 331.42 196.55 107.17 66.46
2 Govt. of UP (10%) 183.04 45.91 49.43 41.43 24.57 13.40 8.31
ULB, Other Urban
3 183.04 45.91 49.43 41.43 24.57 13.40 8.31
Agencies, Pvt. Sector
Total 1830.43 459.15 494.27 414.28 245.69 133.96 83.08

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 96


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Total Investment
Sr.
Sector wise department wise allocation Required (Rs. in Yearly Investment Required (Rs. in Crores)
No.
Crores)
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
1 Water Supply
UPJN 320 109.7 86 62.4 41.3 15.6 5
2 Sewerage
UPJN 304 49 69 65 55 41 25
3 Drainage / Storm Water Drainage
UPJN 228 78 63 44 25 10 8
4 Solid Waste Management
NPP 26.57 5.82 9.45 8.45 1.45 0.9 0.5
PVT 50 10 20 20 0 0 0
5 Street Lighting
NPP 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.3 6.25 3.35
6 Urban Roads & Traffic
NPP 146 43.75 36.25 30 18.75 9.25 8
PWD 90 20 20 15 15 10 10
PVT 120 28 38 33 16 5 0
TRAFFIC 11.3 2.32 2.31 2.31 2.26 1.05 1.05
7 Heritage & Tourism
NPP 5 0 1.5 1.5 2 0 0
PVT 116 24.3 34.2 27.2 14.6 8.35 7.35
UP TOURISM 148 31.9 49.45 28.6 22.2 9.65 6.2
8 Urban Poor and Slums
DUDA 132.56 26.51 26.51 39.77 19.88 13.26 6.63
9 Municipal Governance
NPP 10.25 2.9 2.65 2.35 1.2 0.65 0.5
10 Urban Environment
NPP 36.5 5.5 15.5 15.25 0.25 0 0
PVT 30 9 6 6 4.5 3 1.5
1830.43 459.15 494.27 414.28 245.69 133.96 83.08

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. 97


City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

SECTION G: FINANCIAL OPERATING PLAN FOR MATHURA NPP


G1. FINANCIAL OPERATING PLAN

A summary of department-wise allocation of the Rs.1830.43 crores which has been envisaged
for achieving the sectoral goals is tabulated hereunder.

Rs in Crores 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12


Department wise Allocation Total Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
UPJN 852 236.7 218 171.4 121.3 66.6 38
NPP 280.57 70.42 79.8 71 29.95 17.05 12.35
PWD 90 20 20 15 15 10 10
TRAFFIC 11.3 2.32 2.31 2.31 2.26 1.05 1.05
UP TOURISM 148 31.9 49.45 28.6 22.2 9.65 6.2
DUDA 132.56 26.98 26.98 40.48 20.24 13.49 6.75
NPP with PVT sector support 316 71.3 98.2 86.2 35.1 16.35 8.85
1830.43 459.62 494.75 414.99 246.05 134.19 83.2

The section on Capital Investment Plan details the basis on how the projects have been
allocated. Department Wise Allocation (Rs. Crores)

UPJN, 852
Some of the projects which full under the
ambit of the Nagar Palika Parishad but NPP w ith PVT sector
can be taken up with private sector support, 316

participation have been segregated and it


is assumed that for these projects 80%
funding will be from GoI and balance 20% DUDA, 132.56

will come from the Private Sector as


Equity and the Operation and UP TOURISM, 148 NPP, 280.57
TRAFFIC, 11.3 PWD, 90
Maintenance will be the responsibility of
the Private Sector who will also be sharing
revenue with the Nagar Palika.

In case of Housing Stock for the poor it is assumed that 10% of the project cost will be borne by
the beneficiaries. Taking into account the above the proposed means of financing for the Rs
1830.43 crores is as under.

Means of Financing Rs in Crores 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12


GOI 1462.46 367.32 395.42 331.42 196.55 107.17 66.46
GoUP 151.21 38.78 39.61 32.81 21.06 11.76 7.42
UPJN 85.2 23.67 21.8 17.14 12.13 6.66 3.8
NPP 28.06 7.04 7.98 7.1 3 1.71 1.24
PWD 9 2 2 1.5 1.5 1 1
TRAFFIC Department 1.13 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.11 0.11
UP TOURISM 14.8 3.19 4.95 2.86 2.22 0.97 0.62
DUDA 13.02 2.65 2.65 3.98 1.99 1.33 0.66
NPP with PVT sector support 63.2 14.26 19.64 17.24 7.02 3.27 1.77
BENEFICIARIES LOW COST
HOUSING 2.36 0.47 0.47 0.71 0.35 0.24 0.12
1830.43 459.62 494.75 414.99 246.05 134.19 83.2

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


98
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

As illustrated above Rs1462.46 Crores will be the contribution of the GoI, Rs 274.36 Crores will
come from GoUP and it’s departments. The balance will come from Nagar Palika Parishad
(Rs.28.06 Crores), Private Sector (Rs 63.20 Crores) and Rs 2.36 Crores from the beneficiaries
of low cost housing.

The GoUP will make provision for Rs. 274.36 crores towards its share over the period of 6 years
till financial year 2011-12. The Nagar Palika Parishad would required financial assistance of
Rs.23 crores as under to meet its contribution (The balance will be from internal sources in the
later years, possible because of fiscal reforms).

S. Financial Year Amount from Revolving Fund


No.
1 2006-07 Rs.8 Crores
2 2007-08 Rs 7 Crores
3 2008-09 Rs 8 Crores

The above funds will be required to be provided to the NPP from the revolving Fund Scheme of
the Urban Development Department of GoUP and will be repaid in 10 equal yearly installments.

While we have explained the sources of funding for the Rs.1830.43 Crores investment the
important aspect is of sustenance of this investment. The financial capacity of the Mathura NPP
is very low. A brief description of the financial situation is detailed hereunder.

In the fiscal year 2005-06 the review sources for the NPP were as under :

Property Tax (House tax/ Water Tax/ Sewerage Tax) Rs.154 lacs
Other Income Rs.162 lacs
Surcharge from Stamp Duty Rs.174 lacs
Premium from Sale of Property Rs.123 lacs
Government Grants Rs.714 lacs

Income from own sources is only Rs 316 lacs (not considering premium from sale of property)
out of the total revenue of Rs.1327 lacs i.e. 23.8%.

The income from sale of property Sources of Revenues (2005-06)


cannot be considered in future (Rs. Crores)
projections and the share from
surcharge on stamp duty will not Property Tax
enhance as the stamp duty rate is (House tax/
proposed to be reduced as per reform Water Tax/
Sew erage Tax),
agenda under JNNURM. With the 1.54
above background we also look at the Other Income,
future requirement of funds by NPP 1.62
necessary to sustain the investment
contemplated under JNNURM.
Government Surcharge from
Grants, 7.14 Stamp Duty, 1.74
The fund requirement for sustaining
the O&M of assets to be transferred to Premium from
NPP is projected as under. Sale of Property,
1.23

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


99
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Rs in Crores 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12


Total Assets
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
under NPP
Water supply 223.00 79.25 59.25 40.00 28.25 11.25 5.00
O&M Cost in Crores 2.77 4.85 6.25 7.24 7.63
Sewerage 304.00 49.00 69.00 65.00 55.00 41.00 25.00
O&M Cost in Crores 1.72 4.13 6.41 8.33 9.77
Drainage 228.00 78.00 63.00 44.00 25.00 10.00 8.00
O&M Cost in Crores 2.73 4.94 6.48 7.35 7.70
SWM 26.42 5.67 9.45 8.45 1.45 0.90 0.50
O&M Cost in Crores 0.20 0.53 0.82 0.88 0.91
Street Lighting 56.25 12.45 14.45 13.45 6.30 6.25 3.35
O&M Cost in Crores 0.44 0.94 1.41 1.63 1.85
Roads and Traffic 146.00 43.75 36.25 30.00 18.75 9.25 8.00
O&M Cost in Crores 1.53 2.80 3.85 4.51 4.83
Heritage and Tourism 18.50 4.50 5.00 4.50 3.00 1.00 0.50
O&M Cost in Crores 0.16 0.33 0.49 0.60 0.63
Urban Environment 16.50 5.50 5.50 5.25 0.25 0.00 0.00
O&M Cost in Crores 0.19 0.39 0.57 0.58 0.58
Total O&M Cost for NURM
assets to be maintained by 9.73 18.90 26.27 31.10 33.89
NPP

To meet the above drastic action has to be taken to improve the fiscal capacity of the NPP. At
present only 35940 households properties in the Nagar Palika Area are assessed and the water
supply requirement that is met is less than 50%. The coverage of sewerage/ drainage is also
only 10% of the NPP Area. Considering that under JNNURM we are envisaging to provide vastly
enhanced coverage of water supply sewerage and drainage we can recover enhanced tax, water
and sewerage tax and water charges.

The assumptions and calculations on this basis for property tax and water charges are as under.

House Tax 2006 - 07 2007 - 08 2008 - 09 2009 - 10 2010 - 11 2011 - 12


Estimated Dwelling Units 75000 80000 80000 85000 85000 90000
Average Dwelling Unit(in sq. ft.) 600 600 600 600 600 600
Average Unit Rate in Rs per sq. ft 0.8 0.8 1 1 1.5 1.5
House Tax Demand in Rs in Lakhs 360 384 480 510 765 810
Collection in Rs in Lakhs (Current) 216 307.2 408 459 726.75 769.5
Collection in Rs in Lakhs (Arrears) 100 144 76.8 72 51 38.25
Total House Tax Collection in Rs in
Lakhs 316 451.2 484.8 531 777.75 807.75

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


100
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

Water/Sewerage Tax
2006 - 07 2007 - 08 2008 - 09 2009 - 10 2010 - 11 2011 - 12
Recovery % of O&M through user
charges/metering 20% 30% 50% 50% 70% 80%
O&M Costs to be recovered 973.42 1890.07 2627.345 3110.345 3389.12
Collection 0 292.026 945.035 1313.673 2177.242 2711.296

Water/Sewerage Charges
2006 - 07 2007 - 08 2008 - 09 2009 - 10 2010 - 11 2011 - 12
Estimated Dwelling Units 75000 80000 80000 85000 85000 90000
Coverage 20% 30% 40% 50% 70% 80%
Average Annual Charges per
Dwelling unit in rupees 500 500 750 750 1000 1000
Total Water Charges Collection per
year in Rs in Lakhs 75 120 240 318.75 595 720

Other Assumptions – Income


1. Other Tax and Non tax Income increase by 20% annually. Non tax income would
include the enhanced water charges as per the detail calculation above from fiscal
year 2006-07.
2. Other Income has been assumed to grow at 10% annually.
3. Government Grants remain constant. However they are after adjustment of
installment against outstanding loans from the State Government.
4. Income from New Projects has been assumed from projects which will be with
Private Sector Investment.

The following assumptions have been made for projecting future expenditure
1. Establishment & O&M (Existing) has been assumed to increase by 10% annually.
2. Salaries have been assumed to increase by 2% annually
3. O&M of assets created under JN-NURM has been assumed as assets that will be
the responsibility of the Municipality and it increases with the influx of the
investment.
4. Other expenses have been assumed to increase by 5% annually
5. Since the Municipality is able to improve its financial portion they are able to
undertake enhanced capital expenditure which has been assumed to increase by
15% annually.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


101
City Development Plan of Mathura Final Report

G2. CASH FLOW MATHURA NPP

Based on the above assumptions, the cash flow for Mathura NPP, based on actuals for the
period starting in F.Y. 2002-03 and ending in F.Y. 2005-06 and projected for the period starting
in F.Y. 2006-07 and ending 2011-12, is presented in tabular form below:

Rs in Lakhs
2002- 2003 - 2004 - 2005 - 2006 - 2007 - 2008 - 2009 - 2010 - 2011 -
Income 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
Opening Cash
Balance 48 165 64 19 28 606 580 629 30 438
Property Tax 130 113 109 154 316 743 1430 1845 2955 3519
Other Tax 7 5 6 6 7 8 10 12 15 17
Surcharge on stamp
duty 0 16 77 174 174 174 174 174 174 174
Non Tax Income 28 17 38 43 127 182 314 408 702 848
Premium from Sale of
Property 40 0 1 123 0 0 0 0 0 0
Other Income 50 21 68 113 124 136 150 165 182 200
Government Grants 669 446 542 714 714 714 714 714 714 714
Loans 65 5 304
Loan from revolving
fund for NURM 800 700 800
Income from New
Projects 81 276 368 460 460 460
Total Income 1036 789 1207 1346 2371 3540 4540 4407 5231 6371
2002- 2003 - 2004 - 2005 - 2006 - 2007 - 2008 - 2009 - 2010 - 2011 -
Expenditure 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
Establishment 71 58 61 98 98 108 119 130 143 158
Salaries 683 592 656 1035 756 771 787 803 819 835
O&M 28 24 25 37 41 45 50 55 60 66
O&M New Projects 973 1890 2627 3110 3389
Others 14 13 187 52 54 57 60 63 66 69
Capital Expenditure 76 38 258 97 111 128 147 169 194 223
Municipalities
Investment in NURM 704 798 710 300 171 124
Repayment of Loan 80 150 230 230 230
Total Expenditure 871 725 1188 1318 1765 2960 3912 4377 4794 5095
Balance Cash 165 64 19 28 606 580 629 30 438 1276

Conclusion

By undertaking prudent fiscal measures and reforms the NPP is able to enhance its revenue
from the current level of Rs.1376 lacs to Rs.6371 lacs in 2011-12, out of which income from own
sources amounts to 86%. In this scenario it is able to meet the O&M cost of the assets created
under NURM.

Infrastructure Professionals Enterprise Pvt. Ltd.


102
Annex A
List of key officials, Institutions, NGOs, Citizens were consulted for Mathura CDP :

Sr. No. Department / Position Name of the Official


1 Elected Representatives x Sh. Pradeep Mathur, MLA
Mathura Vrindavan Constituency
2 Mathura Vrindavan x Pramanshu (Vice-Chairman)
Development Authority x Hriday Shankar Tiwari (Secretary)
(MVDA) x R.K Upadhayay (Chief Accounts Officer)
3 Nagar Palika Parishad x Pradeep Narian Sinha (EO JNNURM Mathura)
Mathura x D.K Shukla (Former Executive Officer)
x Nahar Sigh ( EO- Present)
x Damber Singh (Junior Engineer,PWD)
x D.K Satsangi (Junior Engineer, Water Works)
x Ashutosh Gupta (Revenue Superintendent)
x L.K Sharma (Chief Sanitary Inspector)
x Vikas Garg (Accounts Officer)
x Ram Kumar Sharma (Light Inspector)
4 U.P Jal Nigam x Lokendra Dev (Assistant Engineer)
x S.P Sharma (Assistant Engineer)
5 Public Works Department x Zubair Alam (Executive Engineer)
(PWD) x C.V Singh (Junior Engineer Technical)
x A.M Srivastava (Draftsman)
6 U.P Roadways x Babu Lal (Station Incharge)
7 C.O Traffic, Mathura x Pankaj Kumar Pandey (C.O Traffic)
x A.K Yadav (Traffic Sub-Inspector)
8 District Urban Development x Anju Singh (Project Officer)
Agency (DUDA) x Arunoday Tyagi (Junior Engineer)
9 UP Tourism Corporation x D.K Sharma (Assistant Tourism Officer)
10 Government Museum, x R.C Tewari (Director)
Mathura x Shatrugan Sharma (Gallery Assistant)
11 State Pollution Control Board, x Kuldeep Mishra (Regional Officer)
Mathura
12 Directorate of Industries x D.C Pandey (Manager, Credit)
13 Information and Public x Sarvesh Kumar Dubey (Assistant Director)
Relations Department
14 Local Builders x Sudeep Agarwal (Shree Group of Developers)
15 Department of Economics and x S.P Sharma (District Economics and Statistical
Statistics Officer)
x R.P Sachdeva (Statistical Officer)
16 District Magistrate x T.N Singh (District Magistrate)
17 Administrator, Nagar Palika x Shailendra Kumar Singh (Administrator, Nagar
Parishad Mathura / City Palika Parishad Mathura / City Magistrate)
Magistrate
18 Bharat Sanchar Nigam x A.K Bajpai (General Manager)
Limited, Mathura
19 INTACH x Dr. Deepak Goel ( Co. Convener, INTACH) and
his key members
20 Ward Committes / Citizens x Ward level citizens, CBOs, RCVs
21 Braj Foundation x Mr. Raghav Mittal and his key members
22 Groups / others x Rotary, JayCees, Lions Group, press media
Annex B
Press cuttings and media coverage – Mathura CDP
Annexure – C
Heritage priorities for Mathura by Braj Bhoomi Chapter of INTACH :

Mathura district spread over 3780 sq km with population of over a million. A historic city at the cross
roads of important ancient trade routes extending westwards to West Asia & the Roman Empire,
northwards, via Taxila, Pushkalavati and Purushapur to Central Asia & Silk Route & eastwards to China
stands today at the junction of modern India's major road & rail routes connecting north to west, south &
east.

Mathura - the birthplace of revered Lord Krishna, manifestation of Lord Vishnu, 5000 years back is part of
Brajbhoomi region. The Braj area is a loosely defined geographic region with its distinct culture, language
& heritage considered to be playground of Lord Krishna. Located approx 150 kms from the national
capital Delhi on way to Agra, Mathura is the epicenter of Brajbhoomi. Other areas include Gokul,
Mahavan, Baldeo, Vrindaban, Goverdhan & Nandgaon etc located within 30-50 kms of Mathura. The
language spoken is Hindi with a distinct Braj dialect.

The capital of Surasena Kingdom, during the times of Buddha, in 5th century BC, Mathura was ruled by
Kushanas - Kanishka, Huvishka & Vashiska. During Emperor Ashoka's reign in Mauryan era(3rd century
BC) Mathura witnessed economic & cultural revival. Subsequently ruled by Shunga dynasty(2nd centu~
BC), Indo-Greeks(180 BC) Indo-Scythians(1st century BC) & Gupta dynasty(4t century AD). Xuanzang,
Chinese explorer, visited Mathura in 634 during his travel through India ..

The relics of history are scattered all over the brajbhoomi region. Temples, forts, ponds (sarovars),
statues of Lord Buddha (from Kushana period) & thousands of sculptures (3rd century BC to 12th century
AD) in Mathura museum etc. Mathura draws millions of tourists every year.

Mathura has a lot of heritage sites which has prompted a steady flow of tourists in the city. These tourists
mainly visit religious and cultural places. International Tourists are intrigued by the sculptures and other
art forms in the Mathura Museum and in the Krishnajanmabhoomi where a beautiful temple stands at the
birthplace of Lord Krishna. Mathura, today is an important place for pilgrimage and receives thousands of
religious tourists every year. The Dwarkadhish Temple built in 1814, with its temple carvings and fine
paintings is Mathura's most visited shrine.

Mathura has contributed a lot towards Indian Culture through its rich heritage. The ethos of Mathura, and
in fact the whole of Braj, is centered on Krishna and his tales. Mathura sees heightened activities during
the major festivities dedicated to the lord.

The Braj culture has been expressed widely through various practices.

Sanjhee is the colourful art of decorating the ground with flowers.

The Raaslilas of Mathura have become an integral part of Indian Folklore. According to popular belief,
Shri Krishna had danced the Raas with the gopis on the banks of the Yamuna. When the gopis felt
slightly conceited about Lord Krishna dancing with them, he disappeared from their midst. In the pain of
separation from Lord Krishna, the gopis enacted his liIas (divine episodes of his life) which in course of -
time came to be known as the Raaslilas. The childhood pranks of Shri Krishna constitute the main theme
of these dramas.
Rasiya too is a tradition that is integral to Mathura's Culture. It is the tradition of folk-songs that describe
the love of the divine couple Radha and Shri Krishna. It is an inseparable part of the Holi celebrations and
all other festive occasions at Mathura.

Charkula is a traditional folk dance of the Brij. In this dance a woman balances a column of deepikas on
her head and dances to the accompaniment of Rasiya songs by the men folk.

The language spoken in the Brij district is mainly Hindi which is spoken in a different dialect. This dialect
is characteristic with the Brij region and has come to be known as Brijbhasha.

Mathura is steeped in Hindu tradition, which is visible everywhere. The temples, riverfront and ponds are
all centres of religious activity. From early morning till dusk devotees throng the holy places. In their quest
for salvation, the numerous Brahmin priests who conduct prayers guide pilgrims.

The renewal of this city steeped in history & cultural heritage has to be all encompassing for effective
development & tourism promotion-

Heritage Preservation-
All heritage cities around Mathura to be identified including old city in Mathura, Vrindavan, Goverdhan,
Gokul, Barsana, Nandgaon etc to preserve their identity.
All development activity should be governed by a centralized body with representation from
INTACH,cultural bodies etc.

Areas within old city shall be converted into pedestrian zones & only pollution free vehicles be allowed to
operate.
Waterfront of the city shall be developed to provide for smooth flow of pilgrims. Riverfront can also
become a tourist attraction.
Identification, preservation & development of heritage structures including temples, ponds etc shall be
undertaken.
Activities at religious places of worship shall be regulated to prevent harassment & exploitation of
devotees.
Orientation & training of tourist guides .

Cultural Preservation -
Promotion of local cultural activities including Raslila, dances etc - Training schools can be set up - this
kind of activity can be self-sustaining as it can generate employment & can be a major tourist attraction.
Promotion of Brajbhasha - An institute for brajbhasha research with library for preservation of manuscripts
can go a long way in this effort.

Infrastructure Development-
Development of neo-urban areas to reduce pressure on old city.
Development of world-class infrastructure including road network, water supply, drainage etc.
Tax incentives for development of boarding facilities for tourists from all economic strata .
. Adequate signage display for directions, historical significance etc at all relevant sites.

Mathura's significance in Indian Culture is parallel to that of Jerusalem and the Vatican in the Western
world. It is a seat of India's cultural and religious history. Therefore, the tourist's current Golden Triangle
consisting of New Delhi, Agra and Jaipur ought to include Mathura & be called the Golden Quadrangle.
Thanking you,
Deepak Goel,
Convener, Brijbhoomi regional Chapter-INT ACH Mathura – 3
Mob. 9359508690
Annex D1
Slum Zones in 45 wards - Mathura NPP
The slums in Mathura city has been categorized into 18 zones within 45 wards and comprises 68 slum pockets. There are around
4-6 slum pockets in each zone.
Sr. Name of the Slums Number
No. of Slum Total SC/ST
Pockets Population Population Infrastructure Details
Sewer Line Storm Water
Drain
1 Radheshyam Colony, Avagadh Farm, Concor Tila 3 14600 8250 56.51 No No
2 Jaysinghpura, Mohannagar Ashanagar, Kanhaiya 6
Kunj 4250 2260 53.18 No No
3 Chamunda Colony, Saraswati Kund, 4
Govindnagar, Azampur 3760 1900 50.53 No No
4 Sanjaynagar, Aumnagar, Ramnagar 4 5650 2950 52.21 No No
5 Mallpura, Govind Ashram 2 1500 850 56.67 No No
6 Ambedkarnagar, Rambarosi colony, Bodhnagar, 6
Sukhdev Nagar, Navneet nagar, Rajiv Gandhi
Nagar 12300 6800 55.28 No No
7 Janakpuri Mohali Road 2 2350 1620 68.94 No No
8 Devnagar, Gopalnagar, Nagla Chandrabag, 4
Shankarpuri 3550 1850 52.11 No No
9 Narayanpuri, Dholipiyau 3 5250 2850 54.29 No No
10 Baadpura, Sadar, Dadra 3 2860 1450 50.70 No No
11 Antapada, Ambakhar, General Ganj, Roti Godam, 7
Menagarh,Compughat 12150 6560 53.99 No No
12 Vankhandi, Khatothi Kua, Baesbhori, Chaganpura 4
10250 5150 50.24 No Yes
13 Bharatpurgate, Thakela Gali, Machli Mandi, Haiza 5
Hospital 15650 8260 52.78 Partial No
14 Manoharpura, Goalkua,Matiyagate 3 13450 6560 48.77 No No
15 Arjunpura, Rani ki Mandi,Theknarnol 3
5720 2950 51.57 No No
16 Mayatila, Halanganj, 1 2820 1850 65.60 No No
17 Naya Nagla, Ghingurpura, Bahadurpura, Khatik 4
Basti, Choki Chandmari Gate 12650 9850 77.87 No No
18 Yamuna par, Laxmi Nagar, Shehzadpur, Shivpuri, 4
Sonie Tappa 14780 7960 53.86 No No
68 143540 79920
Sr. Name of the Slums
No. Infrastructure Details Existing Status of Buildings Land
Ownership
Road & Drains Piped Street Pukka Partially Juggi & BPL
Water Light Buildings Constructed Jhompidies Families
1 Radheshyam Colony, Avagadh Farm, Partially
Concor Tila covered No No 1026 494 58 1165 Private Land
2 Jaysinghpura, Mohannagar Partially
Ashanagar, Kanhaiya Kunj covered No No 348 157 27 455 Private, Govt.
3 Chamunda Colony, Saraswati Kund, Partially
Govindnagar, Azampur covered No No 362 175 302 Private, Govt.
4 Sanjaynagar, Aumnagar, Ramnagar Partially
covered Partial No 316 154 8 321 Private, Govt.
5 Mallpura, Govind Ashram 60% No No 94 48 95 Private, Govt.
6 Ambedkarnagar, Rambarosi colony, Water Logged
Bodhnagar, Sukhdev Nagar, Navneet Area
nagar, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar No No 742 398 9 745 Private, Govt.
7 Janakpuri Mohali Road Partially
covered No No 198 97 159 Private
8 Devnagar, Gopalnagar, Nagla Partially
Chandrabag, Shankarpuri covered No No 325 120 238 Private
9 Narayanpuri, Dholipiyau Old No No 386 198 376 Govt.
10 Baadpura, Sadar, Dadra Old Dilapidated No No 198 87 116 Private, Govt.
11 Antapada, Ambakhar, General Ganj,
Roti Godam, Menagarh,Compughat Old Yes Partial 166 69 12 188 Private
12 Vankhandi, Khatothi Kua, Baesbhori, Old Dilapidated
Chaganpura Yes No 742 336 545 Private
13 Bharatpurgate, Thakela Gali, Machli Old Dilapidated
Mandi, Haiza Hospital Yes No 1098 547 998 Private, Govt.
14 Manoharpura, Goalkua,Matiyagate Old Dilapidated Yes No 986 447 878 Private
15 Arjunpura, Rani ki Mandi,Theknarnol Old Dilapidated Yes No 422 196 355 Private
16 Mayatila, Halanganj, Old Dilapidated
Yes No 242 114 162 Private
17 Naya Nagla, Ghingurpura, Old Dilapidated
Bahadurpura, Khatik Basti, Choki
Chandmari Gate Yes No 838 421 8 787 Private, Govt.
18 Yamuna par, Laxmi Nagar, Partially
Shehzadpur, Shivpuri, Sonie Tappa Covered Yes No 1075 426 25 836 Private
9564 4484 147 8721
Annex D2

Slum Pockets in 45 wards - Mathura NPP


The slums in Mathura city has been categorized into 18 zones within 45 wards and comprises 68 slum pockets. There are around
4-6 slum pockets in each zone.

Slum Zone Name of the Slum Ward No. Household Population BPL
Pocket Population
No.

1 1 Radhesham Colony Push Vihar 25 1665 12525 1410


2 1 Avagadh farm 25 230 1825 210
3 1 Kankor 25 160 1250 145
4 2 Jaisinghpura 24 270 2450 252
5 2 Mohan Nagar 24 360 2875 315
6 2 Asha Nagar 24 60 575 54
7 2 Laxminagar Kishorinagar 26 472 3825 435
8 2 Ahalyaganj 26 44 350 44
9 2 Bangali colony 24 68 620 66
10 3 Chamunda colony 24 82 645 60
11 3 Saraswati kund 25 135 1075 124
12 3 Govindpur 25 120 965 115
13 3 Azampur 25 280 2460 250
14 4 Sanjaynagar 9 157 1250 140
15 4 Omnagar, Puja Enclave 17 460 4100 420
16 4 Ram Nagar 9 495 3850 435
17 4 Shastri Nagar 9 965 7650 720
18 5 Mallpura 28 215 1550 180
19 5 Govind Ashram 28 75 610 62
20 6 Ambedkar Nagar 12 435 3775 400
21 6 Ramborose colony 12 60 540 55
22 6 Bodhnagar 20 325 3150 306
23 6 Sukhdevnagar 20 1080 8650 822
24 6 Navneetnagar 20 210 1675 193
25 6 Rajiv Gandhi Nagar 12 134 1065 120
26 7 Janakpuri 36 132 1050 108
27 7 Mohali Road 35 165 1300 115
28 8 Dev Nagar 39 198 1775 178
29 8 Gopal Nagar 32 170 1350 135
30 8 Nagla Chandrabhan 32 225 2020 214
31 8 Shankarpuri, Nagla Shivji 32 210 1675 160
32 9 Natwar Nagar 32 293 1735 147
33 9 Narayan Puri 27 88 785 76
34 9 Dhaulipiyau 27 312 2670 250
35 10 Sadar 13 130 1147 93
36 10 Baadpura 35 78 620 63
37 10 Dandra, Kasaipada Mukherian 8 122 1093 105
38 11 Antapada 18 235 1850 212
39 11 Ambakhar 35 345 2675 318
40 11 Generalganj 18 532 4250 457
41 11 Rotigodam 35 175 1575 161
42 11 Mainagad 35 112 870 103
43 11 Compughat 16 135 1080 120
44 11 Bankhandi 7 410 3250 374
45 12 Khatothikuan 7 308 2475 283
46 12 Bhains bhahora 7 330 2885 267
47 12 Chaganpura 14 405 3640 306
48 12 Bharatpur gate 1 665 5371 605
49 13 Takhela gali 1 395 3475 340
50 13 Machlimandi 1 289 2687 254
51 13 Dharesi road 2 272 2442 248
52 13 Haiza hospital 2 210 1675 185
53 13 Manahpura 3 578 4620 515
54 14 Goal Kuan 23 485 4055 445
55 14 Matiagate 37 530 4775 505
56 14 Arjunpura 15 298 2685 268
57 15 Rani Ki Mandi 6 205 1840 188
58 15 Thek Narnol 40 150 1195 115
59 15 Maya Tila 31 205 1845 184
60 16 Halan Ganj 31 108 975 88
61 17 Naya Nagla 11 398 3590 362
62 17 Ghingurpura 11 484 3875 402
63 17 Bahadurpura 11 420 3380 357
64 17 Choki Chandmari Ghatekthek Basti 11 201 1605 192
65 18 Yamunapar Brij Kshetra 5 232 1860 196
66 18 Laxminagar Pratapnagar 5 865 7705 762
67 18 Shivpuri, Ramnagar 4 305 2375 222
68 18 Sonitappa 5 315 2760 284
Annex E

Detailed Income Expenditure Details of Mathura NPP, 2002-06

Sr. No. Description / Category ACTUALS


Income from various sources 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06
1 Opening Cash Balance 48 165 64 19
2 Property Tax 130 113 109 154
3 Other Tax 7 5 6 6
4 Surcharge on stamp duty 0 16 77 174
5 Non Tax Income 28 17 38 43
6 Premium from Sale of Property 40 0 1 123
7 Other Income 50 21 68 113
8 Government Grants 669 446 542 714
9 Loans 65 5 304
Total Income (Rs. lakhs) 1036 789 1207 1346

Sr. No. Expenditure on various heads 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06


1 Establishment 71 58 61 98
2 Salaries 683 592 656 1035
3 O&M 28 24 25 37
4 O&M New Projects
5 Others 14 13 187 52
6 Capital Expenditure 76 38 258 97
Total Expenditure (Rs. Lakhs) 871 725 1188 1318
Balance Cash 165 64 19 28
Annex F

Zone wise population projection for waste water generation in MLD for the year 2039

Name Population Water Waste Other waste generation Total Existing Balance
of in design requirement water MLD waste capacity Quantity
Zone year 2039 in MLD @ @ 80% of water of STP required
Railway Industrial MES Other Total
135 lpcd + water generation available
15% requirement in MLD
I 106849 16.59 13.27 - 0.32 - - 0.32 13.59 13.59 -
II 140257 21.77 17.42 - - - - - 17.42 - 17.42
III 76576 11.89 9.51 - - - - - 9.51 14.60 -
IV 72000 11.18 8.94 - - - - - 8.94 - 8.94
V 256463 39.82 31.86 1.20 1.25 - - 2.45 34.31 - 34.31
VI 60228 9.35 7.48 - - 1.0 - 1.0 8.48 - 8.48
VII 107627 16.71 13.37 - - 3.50 - 3.50 16.87 - 16.87
Total 86.59 28.19 58.40

You might also like