Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in Emerging markets
F&C: Pioneering experience in emerging markets
Expect excellence
“ You would not ignore an economy the size of the US when
“
constructing an investment portfolio so it is a surprise that
so many investors, from the largest to the smallest, seem
to overlook the potential of the emerging economies.
“Emerging
Richard Wilson, Head of Equities, F&C Investments.
markets still
offer us vast
potential”
“
“Emerging markets represent 30% of
the Group’s profits and generate
two-thirds of its growth” The changes underway are seeing
countries such as China, India
and Brazil shifting from agrarian or
resource based economies, tied to
the economic cycles of the developed
‘western’ economies, to genuine self
“
sustaining industrial powerhouses.
Jeff Chowdhry,
Head of Emerging Equities,
“Our centre of gravity will shift to the F&C Investments.
developing markets”
F&C Investments 01
Long-term thematic opportunities behind a large part of the increase in economic activity in the
Differentiating the emerging markets in the current last decade. Building, steel and cement companies have all
environment are long-term thematic drivers of growth. The benefited from increased investment as a result.
most important of these and from which other things lead, is
The next phase of the process of urbanisation, which will
demographics.
drive economic growth in the next decade, will be the
Emerging economies have faster growing and younger growing consumer appetite of the rising urban population.
populations than their developed peers. “If you look at where
Wang estimates spending attributed to urbanisation could be
the labour supply is increasingly coming from over the next
as high as $1trillion over the next 10 years.
20 to 30 years, it is really coming from emerging markets,”
says Michael Wang, Global Emerging Markets Strategist,
Morgan Stanley. “This has implications not only for the world Rising standards of living
but also the emerging countries themselves.” In the next decade the popular perception of emerging
markets as a supplier of goods and services to developed
What it implies is that there will be a higher share of the local countries should be comprehensively knocked on the
population in employment. This, in turn, means there will be head as the rapidly growing working and middle classes
more people in receipt of an income. The wealth created will increasingly become the end purchasers of the goods and
drive an advance in living standards and consumption and services they are producing.
increase domestically focused employment.
Taking the automotive industry as an example, the per capita
Share of global nominal US$ GDP car ownership in China is set to reach 59 per 1,000 people in
2010, while the equivalent figure in the US is estimated at 826
35
� EM (incl Middle East) � US per 1,000. This huge disparity translates into an enormous
30
investment opportunity as the gap between developed and
25 developing market consumers closes.
0
The number of cars on the road
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
02 F&C Investments
The role of leverage An important aspect to remember is that we are just coming
Consumption financed by the newly earned salaries of a out of a global recession and in the first year of a recession
rapidly growing labour force, would create a phenomenal the p/e multiple always gets re-rated because earnings are
wave of demand but when you are also bringing into the depressed and so investors buy the market in expectation
equation the possibility of leverage, in the form of loans and of an earnings recovery, making the p/e look artificially high.
mortgages, that potential is magnified. Once genuine earnings growth starts to become effective,
however, valuations should move back to more normal levels.
Leverage is not an emerging markets concept. In these
countries consumption is normally saved for. As a result, Wang believes that within markets there are some quite big
the international financial crisis did not have quite the same differences, however. “Amongst the BRIC countries, Brazil,
devastating impact on developing market consumption India and China seem to have attracted disproportionate
patterns as was witnessed in the developed world. The liquidity flows and those three markets seem rather more
‘top- end’ analysts’ estimate about 10% leverage exposure highly valued than Russia, which we think looks cheap by
among consumers in developing markets compared with comparison”. Outside of the BRIC group there may be even
100% leverage in the UK. While the very conservative greater value potential, in countries such as Indonesia, Egypt
approach to debt of most emerging market consumers and Turkey.
means they are unlikely to ever approach the UK’s level of
He forecasts a strong earnings recovery for emerging Europe
leverage, there is still potential for leverage to play a role in
next year because of a steep contraction in earnings in 2009.
driving demand. This will be both by individuals increasing
In Asia, the rebound is likely to be more modest as these
their levels of debt and through an increase in the number
economies saw less of a correction in 2009.
of consumers accessing debt finance.
Corporate leverage is not quite so restrained, but is still very Outside of BRIC
low compared to the developed markets. Mexico is closely locked into the US economic cycle and
was left behind in 2009 as a result. A more robust upswing
Valuations in the US than is presently expected could catch investors by
The bull market seen since 2000 has witnessed a superior surprise and lead Mexico higher in its wake.
return on equity (ROE) from companies within emerging
In EMEA, while Russia is an obvious beneficiary of a rising
markets, driven by the more efficient use of capital at the
oil price, the region as a whole has lagged. If the oil price
micro level. In the years ahead rising consumption will be
continues to accelerate and the Russian economy gathers
another positive element in the mix. The ROE can then be
further momentum this will have spill over benefits for
expected to increase further.
neighbouring economies.
Valuations in aggregate have potential for improvement.
As an example, Hungary is another country that has perhaps
Using parameters like price/earnings (p/e) or price-to-book,
been overlooked. It has been a casualty of macro economic
they are in line with historical levels. On a trailing earnings
policy, operating a big current account deficit, which left it
basis they are actually at about a 20% discount to developed
exposed to the global financial crisis, causing the exchange
countries, trading at around 17.5 times p/e, (16x is the long-
rate to come under downward pressure, forcing interest rates
term average). “With the 40% growth in earnings that we are
to be raised. But looking ahead, Hungary is well positioned
expecting for 2010,” says Wang “that multiple will drop down
to take advantage of the cyclical recovery expected in
to 14x.”
developed Europe, especially Germany, which is the recipient
MSCI EM vs. MSCI World of a high proportion of Hungary’s (mostly manufacturing)
exports. Hungarian interest rates are still quite high (a base
40 40
MSCI WORLD trailing PE rate of a 6.5%) but inflation is quite well contained, so there
35 is a good
35 possibility of rates coming down and boosting
MSCI EM trailing PE
30
domestic
30
consumption also.
25 Technology
25 sector earnings have been depressed in 2009
P/E Multiple
20
and if the
20
global economy recovers as expected Taiwan
could be one of the fastest growing markets in Asia in 2010
15 15
given its big exposure to technology as companies start to
10 increase10 their IT investment.
F&C Investments 03
Technical drivers
In 2002 emerging market economies accounted for just 4%
“The short-term risks are
of the MSCI World equity index, today they make up around
13%. This contrasts sharply with their contribution to world
cyclical not structural”
GDP, which is over 30%. In time, their weighting in the index Sam Mahtani, F&C Investments
will increase to catch up and reflect their importance to the
global economy. The flow of privatisations is also a trend set The robustness of the public finances of many emerging
to continue as governments increasingly look to the capital economies means that the risk of default is probably lower than
markets to raise funds, which further increases the pool of it has ever been. This is reflected in narrowing spreads and
companies available to investors and the weighting of the improving sovereign debt ratings based on favourable views
emerging market companies to the total market cap of the taken by various ratings agencies (S&P, Moody’s and Fitch).
global economy. After the recent upgrades to Brazil, more than 50% of the
standard Emerging Bond Index is now rated investment grade.
Emerging markets as a % of MSCI All World Index The range of opportunities within emerging market debt also
continues to expand. In the past exposure has primarily been
15 through government issues, but there are now a growing
number of corporate issuers as well, illustrating an improving
12 maturity and depth to the market as a whole.
EM as % of total
% 9
Emerging Debt Yield vs. US Treasury Yields
16.0
6
14.0
EMBI+ Yield UST 10-year Yield UST 2-year Yield
12.0
3
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
10.0
% 8.0
0.0
Dec-99 Dec-00 Dec-01 Dec-02 Dec-03 Dec-04 Dec-05 Dec-06 Dec-07 Dec-08 Dec-09
Emerging Market Debt
Many of the positive arguments above, particularly those
Risks and pitfalls
around fiscal and monetary discipline apply equally to
Investing in emerging markets is a long-term commitment
emerging market debt. Indeed, this is probably an asset
and investors should be prepared for more volatility
class with an even lighter representation within most
compared to the more developed markets. Political risks
portfolios than emerging market equities.
tend to be greater during the process of development and
The emerging debt universe, small and largely fragmented short-term issues may arise from time to time.
in its infancy, received a boost by the implementation of the
At the present time the most obvious risks are more short-
Brady Bond program implemented by the US Treasury in the
term and generally more cyclical than structural. One risk
1980s. The program was designed to help emerging market
is that growth in the US is actually quite a bit stronger than
economies (mostly Latin American at the time) restructure
the markets are assuming. This could result in a rise in the
their debt, and eventually helped boost overall debt issuance
dollar and US interest rates rising sooner than expected,
that was primarily US dollar denominated. However, despite
dampening liquidity flows into the emerging economies.
a spate of crises and the odd default episode, the advent
Conversely, if US growth retraced and a double-dip
of globalisation, accelerating growth in emerging markets
recession ensued, this would result in a weaker export profile
and implementation of structural reform programs eventually
for emerging markets.
played a key role in firmly establishing the asset class. The
exponential growth in currency reserves also helped mitigate More specifically, the emerging markets have enjoyed a good
currency devaluation risk and helped boost issuance in run over the last 10 years, even rebounding more strongly
local currencies as well. Local currency debt is in increasing than many expected from the international credit crisis of
demand today as developing countries find themselves 2008. It would not be out of character for there to be some
favourably placed relative to developed countries in terms of increased volatility in 2010. But it is the medium to longer-
growth outlook and fiscal positions. term structural drivers that should underpin investment
decisions. So a strong uptrend looks set to continue.
04 F&C Investments
Commodity prices n They are underpinned by long-term structural drivers
For Russia and Brazil, a change in the value of the dollar n They will lead global growth for years to come
would impact the price of commodities and hence economic n This is not an export driven cyclical upswing, though
prospects from export earnings. exports should recover at some stage
India too would feel the effect of a change in the oil price. n The domestic economies have increasingly taken over
High oil prices would hit it disproportionately hard as it is from export markets as the drivers of growth
a net importer of oil and while a country like China with its n Falling risk of default amongst bond issuers
high fiscal surpluses can afford to subsidise its users, India’s n Mature markets are likely to deliver more muted returns
fiscal position would not afford it such an option. On the flip as the fall out from the credit crunch and financial crisis
side, however, we also need to remember that most of the continues to take its toll
increase in demand for oil, which leads to a rise in the oil
price, stems from growth in emerging economies. Diversification is the key to any successful investment
strategy and adding or increasing emerging market exposure
will improve the diversification of most portfolios. This
Rising interest rates
will provide a portfolio with increased growth potential to
If interest rates in the US were raised sooner than expected,
compensate for the more muted returns expected from the
that could hurt emerging economies as the US acts as
mature markets, while they deal with the issues facing their
the benchmark for global rates, and especially for
economies and seek a return to a more normal
emerging markets where currencies are frequently pegged
growth footing.
to the dollar.
There is also the possibility that Europe could tighten interest Conclusions
rates before the Federal Reserve, impacting consumption Emerging markets have rebounded strongly as investor
and imports from developing countries, although with an sentiment recovered from the lows of 2008. This is also a
already strong Euro they may be more cautious about clear reflection of the fundamental changes that have taken
doing this. place within emerging market economies in recent years
and indicates the strength and robustness of the investment
Viewed in context, however, there are no signs yet that US
case, be it in emerging market equities or debt.
growth is accompanied by a build up in inflationary pressure.
Furthermore with US rates at virtually zero when they do Positive structural factors now underpin emerging market
start to rise they would only be starting a journey back to economies and they should no longer simply be regarded
‘normal’ levels. as a geared play on the cyclical swings of the US, Europe
and Japan.
Other pitfalls
Recent events in Dubai were a reminder that investing in “It is the positive, long-term,
emerging markets is not without risk. However, Dubai is not
a typical emerging market, and its lack of transparency is in structural factors that
contrast to many emerging economies that have more long
standing disclosure investor relations. Contagion from Dubai should underpin investment
should be viewed as overreaction, given that most emerging
markets investors have little exposure to the market. decision making.”
Jeff Chowdhry, F&C Investments
The Investment case
Traditionally many investors have avoided investing in In the coming years global growth is set to be driven by the
emerging markets due to the greater risk and higher volatility emerging economies and those of China, India, Indonesia,
they have demonstrated historically when compared Egypt and Latin America. Importantly, even when the mature
against the mature developed markets. Consequently, most developed economies re-establish their normal patterns of
portfolios are underweight to emerging market equities and growth, emerging markets will continue to play an important
probably even more so to emerging market debt. role in the development of the world economy. As such, they
also have an important role to play in driving the returns from
As we can see from the discussions above, the investment any investment portfolio.
landscape has changed significantly in recent years and
there are now sound and fundamental reasons why investors
need to consider increasing their exposure to the undoubted
potential of emerging market assets.
F&C Investments 05
“
Eight of the world’s
ten largest cities are
in emerging economies.
F&C Investments.
“
“In 2009 China overtook Germany
as the world’s largest exporting
economy ”
F&C has over 2000 relationships investing in emerging markets for over 140 years, which
means they are part of F&C’s DNA.
in over 20 countries and manages Our experience started with fixed income securities and
evolved rapidly to include equity investments in 1905.
money for over 3 million people.
F&C Emerging Market Milestones
F&C has over 2000 relationships in over 20 countries and n 1868 Foreign & Colonial Investment Trust launched
manages money for over 3 million people, and with over n 1868 first investments in Europe, South America, the
£97.8 billion under management*, is a broadly diversified Middle East and the US
global investment manager. n 1881 first investments in Asia and Australia
n 1883 first investments in Africa
n 1932 first investment in Taiwan
n 1934 first investment in Hong Kong
n 1952 first investment in Israel
n 1961 first investment in Japan
n 1984 first Ethical Fund launched
F&C Investments 07
Managing emerging
market equities
F&C’s current Emerging Market Equities team was
Years in Years at
established in 1993. Jeff Chowdhry and Sam Mahtani have Name
industry F&C
been instrumental in devising its strategy and have worked
together at F&C since 1994. Jeff took over as Head of Research & Portfolio Construction
Emerging Markets Equities in December 2005 and the team
was strengthened adding Urban Larson and Gareth Morgan, Jeff Chowdhry 27 15
two key senior individuals, to the team. Sam Mahtani 16 17
The current team of 12 professionals, with an average Urban Larson 15 4
experience of 14 years in the industry, has a great depth
and breadth of experience of investing in global emerging Gareth Morgan 15 4
markets through all market cycles.
Martha Reyes-Hulme 11 2
The team is London based and combines a detached
Claire Franklin 6 3
assessment of emerging markets with regular research
trips to obtain a closer hands-on feel of the drivers in these Research
dynamic economies. Sitting alongside our other equity and
fixed income investment teams provides a resource and Mike Hanbury-Williams 25 19
alternative viewpoint to aid decision making.
Ben Akrigg 14 4
As the table to the right shows, we combine the roles of
Peter Dalgliesh 15 3
research and fund management our emerging markets team.
Anthony Linehan 5 5
Performance Jorry Noeddekaer 9 2
Delivering investment performance that meets or exceeds
the expectations of clients is the key to our approach. A June Lui 11 3
significant restructuring of the emerging markets process in
2006 and the recruitment of additional resources has seen a Average years of
14 7
experience
strong and consistent recovery in investment returns.
Country responsibility
Emerging China
Europe Korea
Taiwan
India TIMP*
Africa
Latin
America
Jeff Chowdhry n n n Gareth Morgan n n Mike Hanbury-Williams n Jorry Noeddekaer n n n
Sam Mahtani n n n Martha Reyes-Hulme n Ben Akrigg n n n June Lui n
Urban Larson n n Claire Franklin n Peter Dalgliesh n n n n
*Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines
08 F&C Investments
Investment process
Our investment process has been designed to deliver such as ‘value’ or ‘growth’. All companies are therefore
outperformance throughout the cycle by being active and potential investments. Our style is not a driver of our process,
pragmatic and not bound to a single investment style but a result.
Country
Co
research
un
n
w
try
do
ra
p
nk
To
in
g
Investment Investment Portfolio
themes construction Portfolio
universe
g
in
Bo
nk
ra
tto
Company
k
m
oc
up
research
St
Our process can be broken down into three key 3. Stock selection - All members of the team are involved
components. in company analysis, with specific countries assigned to each
individual. Considerable emphasis is placed on one-to-one
1. Country research – The cornerstone of our approach
company meetings and we have around 800 each year, both
is that the superior economic growth taking place in in our London offices and during research trips to the various
the emerging markets is most clearly discernible within regions. We also use broking and industry research to get a
individual countries as they embrace free market principles comprehensive view of each company we are analysing. We
and begin investing in both human and physical capital. address the following issues in the diagram below.
Country analysis is therefore our starting point because the
political and economic reform processes are the drivers of The fund managers draw upon this pool of research to
change. We also believe that individual stock markets have a construct a portfolio designed to meet the investment needs
tendency to become mispriced as a result of sentiment and of our clients. Flexibility is key to our approach but with
liquidity flows on their fundamental valuation. flexibility comes accountability, and our managers are fully
accountable for all investment decisions made in respect of
2. Investment themes - We assess investment themes their portfolios.
that could have a country, regional or global impact and
how they may offer investment opportunities. Themes We also use an advanced risk modelling tool Sunguard APT,
are regularly discussed across the team to ensure that to monitor risk within our portfolios. This ensures that the
they remain valid and new ones are also considered. areas of greatest risk match up with those of our highest
These investment themes direct the focus of company investment conviction.
analysis within each country. Examples of themes include
infrastructure spending, the rising power of domestic
consumers and low penetration of financial products
F&C Investments 09
Managing emerging
market debt
F&C’s Emerging Market Debt team has been in place since We operate a top-down fundamental process designed
1991 and they developed the F&C Emerging Markets Fixed to identify relative value primarily between countries,
Income philosophy and process in its current form in 1995, and highlight market distortions of country spreads and
a development in which Helene Williamson, now Head of currencies. The process makes the optimum use of the in-
Emerging Market Debt, was instrumental. The six-strong depth knowledge and expertise of the Emerging Market Debt
team has an average of 14 years investment experience, team and builds research into the investment process as a
which also means experience in managing assets across the whole. Our investment approach is unique in its emphasis on
economic cycle. identifying ‘country value’, through the systematic, research-
based process we have developed.
Within the emerging market debt team, the fund managers
also undertake research as we believe this delivers a We believe that emerging bond markets are often priced
flatter structure and improves communication across the inefficiently and undergo spread and currency fluctuations
team. There are also three dedicated research analysts that have a weak relationship with the actual political,
who support the fund managers due to the breadth of the economic and repayment risk of a country. Our three stage
countries to be covered. investment process therefore starts by researching these
aspects.
10 F&C Investments
1
Stage 1: Research and spread forecast
Stage 1 We start with an analysis of the market environment,
Analysis and spread forecast including the outlook for global GDP growth, liquidity, risk
appetite, commodity prices and global bond markets. We
n Analysis of the market environment and then undertake a forward-looking analysis of individual
forecast of market spread
country fundamentals and it is the country selection and
n Country risk analysis and forecast of allocation stage that produces the majority of our expected
individual country spreads
outperformance. Our analysis focuses on six primary
n Analysis of individual country yield curves factors that tend to drive asset prices and a scoring matrix is
used to quantify and systematically compare each country
assessment:
2
Forecast 2) Structural reform process and growth
4) Fiscal policy
Stage 2
5) External sector (e.g. balance of payments)
Portfolio construction
6) Technical (new issuance, repayments) and other market-
n Definition of interest rate spread duration and specific factors (investor base, investor positions, etc)
beta of the portfolio
The composite score of each country serves as the basis
n Individual country allocations in the portfolio
for forecasting the likely change in the spread at which the
n Bond selection individual country’s bonds would trade over US Treasuries in
the absence of market factors. Emerging market corporates
are used as complementary positions to existing views on
the sovereign credit. The outcome of this analysis is then
used to derive a model portfolio for emerging market debt.
Portfolio
3
Stage 2: Portfolio construction
We define the spread duration, interest rate duration and
beta of the desired portfolio, assess the required country
Stage 3 weightings and then select the individual bonds. This is
based on a model portfolio over which the whole team have
Portfolio analysis ownership through their research input and investment
recommendations. The model portfolio is implemented
n Risk analysis
as far as possible in each individual client’s portfolio; any
differences principally reflect mandate differences, especially
n Performance attribution with regards to risk tolerance; country and issuer limits;
n Performance measurement
turnover limits; minimum credit rating specifications; and
restrictions on local currency and corporate exposure.
F&C Investments 11
Accessing
emerging markets
At F&C we are committed to providing the vehicles to enable our clients to
access the potential of the emerging economies from pooled vehicles to
bespoke segregated mandates. We also provide a range of fund solutions
from global and regional mandates to single country funds. Listed below are
the fund capabilities currently available. Alternatively, through constructing a
segregated portfolio, we can provide you with a bespoke investment vehicle
to meet your own specific needs.
Pooled Segregated
Global Emerging Markets
- core 4 4
Latin America 4
Russia 4
Emerging Asia 4 4
India 4 4
12 F&C Investments
Winning gold with Products
F&C F&C offers a wide range of investment opportunities for pension funds,
Delivering highly effective investment charities, financial institutions, corporations and other organisations.
strategies is just one part of the We offer segregated and pooled portfolio management through a range
service we provide. As principled asset
of onshore and offshore vehicles. These cover developed and emerging
managers, we are determined to lead our
industry in all aspects of our business. markets in equity, bond, cash, property and alternative investment funds.
In 2006 – 2008, F&C were voted Please contact us for further details or visit our website at
winners of the ‘Gold Standard’ in the or visit our website at www.fandc.com
Fund Management category. Only a few
companies have been privileged enough
to win a Gold Standard award, and as
such, this is an exceptional achievement.
Financial strength
Ability to meet and exceed customer
expectations
Capability
Outstanding expertise and aptitude as a Contact us
fund manager
Head Office Institutional Business
Service Tel: +44 (0) 20 7011 4444
Ability to maintain and grow an effective Email: institutional.enquiries@fandc.com
post-sales relationship
Global Wholesale
Fair value Tel: +44 20 7011 5111
Assessing whether customers receive Email: mail@fandc.com
great value for money
Broker Support
Trust Tel: 0845 799 2299
Ability to instil confidence in consumers Email: adviser.enquiries@fandc.com
Netherlands Portugal
Tel: +31 (0) 20 582 3000 Tel: +351 (0) 21 003 3200
France Germany
Tel: +33 (0) 1 78 42 40 92 Tel: +49 (0) 69 308 55 098
Sweden
Tel: +46 (0) 850 901276
Expect excellence