Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Where Do We Stand?
2009 WSSPC Annual Meeting
February 12, 2009
Earthquakes and Existing Buildings
Guidelines for SR
(FEMA 273, 274)
Prestandard for SR
(FEMA 356)
Handbook for ASCE 41
Seismic Evaluation
Prestandard for
(FEMA 178)
Evaluation
(FEMA 310)
ASCE 31
ng ic ) g
m 94 in ab
on p e n i
r S R e is
1 7 2
19 n e n
e eh
h op
c ti sho e
cr ) fo o
S
r MA nd )
P la e
cr da
t
ic
R
ks
A rk S t s ) f E 2 S p m r
B al 154 os 156 es (F a l( gic 15 al ) U e is 5) o 1
E /W o u
s A l C i u
q tio n 1 u r e 3 u
s 54 S 39 P W 7
i a A n 4 t t A i a l
an
V M
id (FE y pic FEM ech ilita 1 29 tru
c
t ra M i
V
d A1 ent EMAHR TC
P l p T ( T ab S S F E p M m (F E A
Ra eh EO o n Ra (FE c re N
R N In
Who are our partners? How can we find common objectives and
strategies to improve progress toward earthquake risk reduction
in existing buildings?
FEMA Existing Buildings Program
Next Steps – ATC 71
NEHRP Workshop
Action Report
Implementation
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
NEHRP Workshop
Participants-Stakeholders:
• Earthquake/Structural Engineering Practitioners
• Regulatory (Building Officials)
• Public Policy/Social Science experts
• Research/Academia (ATC 73)
• Building Owner and Manager/Developers
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
NEHRP Workshop
Workshop Framework:
• Open Forum, Discussions and Electronic Voting
• Breakout Sessions
• Identification of Issues and Impediments and
priorities:
Technical
Research
Practical
(ATC 73-NSF)
Regulatory/Public Policy
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
NEHRP Workshop
• Mandatory programs
California URM law (SB 547)
California SB 1953 – Hospitals (State Legislation)
City of Berkeley, (Soft Story Ordinance
City of Los Angeles, (Tilt Up Ordinance)
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
Status Report
• Midwest
No experience with major earthquakes (New Madrid, 1811)
Seismic design has not been a significant consideration -
practitioners in the region report that there is strong reluctance to
acknowledge the potential seismic risk.
Many practitioners today do not consider earthquake shaking to
be a significant
Some voluntary rehabilitation occurs on a voluntary basis for
industrial facilities and hospitals – work generally driven by
concerns about Business Continuity
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
Status Report
• East Coast
The eastern U.S. possesses the oldest building inventory in U.S.,
much of which was constructed without consideration of seismic
design
Generally (with exception of Charleston, SC) most of the east
coast seismicity is low to moderate
Where seismic rehabilitation does occur, it is largely triggered by
changes in use and occupancy in a building renovation or
addition and is met with significant resistance
Some voluntary rehabilitation occurs on a voluntary basis– work
generally driven by concerns about Business Continuity.
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
Status Report
Potential Strategies:
REGION
Method of FEMA WEST
Existing BuildingsMIDWEST
- ATC 71 Project EAST
Initiation Status Report
Potential Strategies
• In general, plans or programs that rely on voluntary
evaluations and rehabilitations have the greatest potential
if they are effective in communicating seismic risk in
market terms.
• Programs with the next highest potential for success are
those that are triggered by building regulations.
• Resistance will be greatest to Mandatory programs,
especially where there hasn’t been experience with
earthquakes.
FEMA Existing Buildings - ATC 71 Project
Action Report