You are on page 1of 25

Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Study on ‘reasons of
dropping out from schools’
A study with children who dropped out from Mother Project of Tomorrow’s Foundation

A study by Tomorrow’s Foundation


Study conducted by: Atasi Nanda Goswami
September, 2009

1
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Background happening due to multiple factors. The


present study is being initiated to know the
reasons behind dropping out of students
KMC schools have their own set of unique from TF Mother Project.
problems. Despite being under the
jurisdictions of state Sarva Shiksha
Abhiyan, the schools are being managed
Objectives of the study
primarily by the local authority, the
Kolkata Municipal Corporation. Officially, 1. Understanding the reasons behind
the KMC is supposed to provide books, dropping out from primary,
uniforms, mid-day meal and free secondary and higher secondary
education. But these services, excluding level.
free education and books, do not reach the 2. Understanding the relationships
students. Interestingly, the mid-day meal between different factors behind
at KMC schools only serves rice instead of dropping out from primary,
cooked food. The books are usually secondary and higher secondary
supplied late, sometimes even after level.
September. As a result, private coaching 3. Understanding the views of
becomes necessary for each student as students, parents and teachers on
they hardly learn anything at the school. probable measures to be taken in
The KMC schools have been suffering from future for reducing dropout rate.
these problems for a very long time and
unfortunately, students of these schools Definitions
continue to face more or less the same
problems today despite large allocations
under SSA. Dropped Out Children: Students of Mother
Project who dropped out from their
Considering the problems faced by respective schools and as a result stopped
students coming from Kalighat and availing services of Mother Project.
Lockgate area, TF started a collaborative
intervention 1994 – 1995 with KMC. The Mother Project: Tomorrow’s Foundation
strategic partnership as based on a ‘win- Mother Project which provides educational
win model’. Under this, TF offered need- and other supplementary facilities to the
based manpower support, quality students enrolled in the project.
enhancing teacher training, free mid-day
meal for the students and increased The Universe: All dropped out children
involvement of the community to reduce from Mother Project from 1998 to 2009.
drop-out rates. Other than providing these
facilities TF followed up with the students Sample: All dropped out children (1998-
who graduated from DTMS (Dharmadas 2009) who could be contacted. Under this
Trust Model School), brought them to the study 105 such children could be contacted
evening remedial classes and provided and interviewed.
educational sponsorships.

Despite these efforts many children


dropped out both from primary and
secondary and higher secondary level. It
has been a realization that like other
places here too cases of dropping out is

2
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Executive Summary 36% of all respondents who dropped out


due to school-college related problems said
they faced poor environment in their
The study was conducted to understanding respective schools or in mother project
the reasons behind dropping out of classes. 50% of these respondents said
children from schools and as a result from they used to get regular punishments,
Mother Project of Tomorrow's Foundation. including the respondents who faced poor
environment in mother project, without
A total of 105 children who dropped out in any valid reasons.
last 10 years were interviewed and focus
group discussions were held with 40 14.3% children dropped out as they got
mothers for this study. married while studying - all of them were
girls.
There is a considerable gap between
number boys and girls who dropped out 16.2% children dropped out due to
(girls 58.1% and boys 41.9%). teaching learning problems 88.2% were
boys, 47% of these children said they did
More girls dropped out while they were so as they could not pass examinations.
studying in secondary and higher
secondary level than the boys. There is a very strong inter-relationship
between lack of interest, school
45.8% children dropped out due to environment and economic reasons.
economic and poor school environment.
In FGDs mother’s identified low/lack of
After economic and poor school income for mothers, family related
environment, the other significant reasons problems, love/romantic relationships,
for dropping out were educational drug addictions and peer group influence
problems, marriage and family related as the main reasons for dropping out. were
problems (16.2%, 14.3%, and 13.3% most important problems for the older
respectively). children and bad influence of family
environment, excessive disciplining by
24.8% children dropped out due to parents and fear of teachers were the main
economic reasons – 61% of them were causes for dropping out for the younger
boys. children.

80.8% of the children who dropped out Mothers expressed that children are falling
due to economic reasons said they left in love at a very young age and getting
schools to work and supplement family married. The mothers also expressed that
income. environment in the school should also be
improved to achieve better retention rate.

3
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Methodology from the mothers. The participants of the


focus group discussions were asked to
identify the main reasons and rank the
Questionnaire: A close ended reasons as per their importance for
questionnaire was prepared collect data younger children and older children
from the dropped out children (Annexure separately. The FGDs were facilitated by
I). All individual interviews were taken by the researcher and PRA Team of TF helped
the researcher herself. her.

Focus Group Discussion: Two focus Data Collation: Data collected from
group discussions (FDGs) were held with in questionnaire was entered in spreadsheet
two different slum locations with 40 and analyzed according to the objectives of
mothers. Most of the mothers had children the study. Notes and photographs were
who dropped out from schools. Ranking taken during FGD.
method of PRA (Participatory Rural
Appraisal) was adopted to collect data

4
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Profile of the respondents 2005 12 11.43


2006 14 13.33
2007 8 7.62
2008 17 16.19
Year wise number of 2009 3 2.86
respondents Total 105 100.00

No of As stated above all dropped out children,


Year Respondents %age
who could be contacted, were interviewed.
1998 1 0.95 Obviously, many recently dropped out
1999 6 5.71 children could be contacted. It should be
2000 6 5.71
noted that from 2003 to 2006, a steady
2001 7 6.67
number of children dropped out.
2002 7 6.67
2003 14 13.33
2004 10 9.52

Area wise distribution of respondents


Area Male Female Total %age
Tollyganj 6 19 25 23.8
Chetla 5 5 10 9.5
Lockgate 2 2 4 3.8
Kalighat 22 16 38 36.2
Masjid 5 11 16 15.2
Sarat
Bose 4 8 12 11.4
Total 44 61 105 100.0

Like year wise distribution of respondents, Kalighat and Tollyganj had more than half
for obvious reasons, maximum number of of the respondents. Mother Project children
respondents (36.2%) was contacted from come from 7 areas, except Hazra area
Kalighat area. The Mother Project is dropped out children were contacted for
located in Kalighat and most of the this study from other 6 locations. Despite
children of this project belong to this area. prevailing perception of many children
dropping out from Lockgate area, only 4
Tollyganj is the nearest area and 23% respondents from this area could be
respondents were from there. So, together contacted.

Gender distribution of the respondents


%of %age
Level Boys Girls Total boys of girls
Primary 24 25 49 49.0 51.0
Secondary 19 32 51 37.3 62.7
HS 1 3 4 25.0 75.0
Graduation 0 1 1 0.0 100.0
Total 44 61 105 41.9
%age 41.9 58.1 100

5
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

There is a considerable gap between


number boys and girls who dropped out
(girls 58.1% and boys 41.9%). This is
despite the fact that many girls who
dropped out migrated to the places where
they were married off. ... the types of work children
are carrying out (paid,
More girls dropped out while they were household-unpaid, agricultural);
studying in secondary and higher
secondary level than the boys. At the household structure, educational
secondary level this difference was more access and work; whether child
than 25%. Almost same number of boys work hinders or helps access to
and girls (49% and 51% respectively) schooling; the gendered and
dropped out from schools in the primary
level. locational aspect of working and
access, etc. (Dropping Out from
School: A Cross Country Review
of Literature Frances Hunt, 2008)

6
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Reasons for dropping out

Class wise - reason wise no of dropout children


Total Econo Educati
no of Distanc mic Family School onal Lack of
dropou e to reason proble Enviro Proble Marria Migrati interes
Level ts/level school s ms nment ms ge on ts Others Total %age
Primar
y 49 2 12 8 13 7 3 0 1 3 49 46.7
Secon
dary 51 0 13 5 8 9 11 2 3 0 51 48.6
HS 4 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 4 3.8
Gradu
ation 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1.0
Total 105 2 26 14 22 17 15 2 4 3 105 100.0
%age 100 1.9 24.8 13.3 21.0 16.2 14.3 1.9 3.8 2.9 100

It is clear from the above table that most


of the children (a total of 45.8%) dropped Distance to school:
out due to economic and poor school
environment. As stated above, only two respondents
dropped out due to distance to school –
Excluding in the case of 2 children both of them did so while they were
‘distance to school’ was not a reason to studying in the primary level – both of
dropout from schools. them said that income of their parents was
low and they could not afford traveling
After economic and poor school expenses.
environment, the other significant reasons
for dropping out were educational On the other hand, though there were
problems, marriage and family related other schools near their house but (their
problems (16.2%, 14.3%, and 13.3% parents) had poor opinion regarding those
respectively). schools.

All the respondents who dropped out due Economic problems:


to marriage were females. 11 out of 15
respondents who dropped out due to A total of 26 respondents (24.8%) dropped
marriage did so while they were studying out due to economic reasons – 61% of
in the secondary level. them were boys. Girls who dropped out
due to economic reasons did so while they
3.8% respondents said they lost all were studying in the secondary level.
interest in studying and drooped out.
Further discussions with them revealed it Among these 26 respondents 21 (80.8%)
was due to peer group and environment said they left schools to work and
(living place) related influences. supplement family income.

Only 1 respondent said ‘cost of the books’


was high but he did not ask any help from
TF. two respondents said ‘admission fees’

7
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

were high but they too did not ask any Only 1 respondent said he opted for
help from TF to support them with working than studying due to reasons
admission fees. other than supplementing family income.

Family related problems: sports facilities was a reason for them to


drop out.
Unlike in the case of economic reasons’
more girls (57.1%) dropped out due to 2 out of these 22 respondents accepted
family related problems than the boys. that they used to fight with friends and
create disturbances in the classes. Only 2
Interestingly, 42% respondents who of these respondents said they did not like
dropped out due to family related the teaching learning in their respective
problems cited other reasons and did not schools and another 2 respondents said
opt for most common reasons like divorce they faced age gap (they were much older
of parents, fights amongst parents, sibling than other classmates) and that’s why
fights, separation of parents or small living dropped out.
places. The other reasons cited by the
respondents were – ‘I was angry with my Interestingly, 18.2% of these respondents
father’s behavior and tried to help my were of the opinion that they dropped out
mother by earning money’, death of as they felt their teachers disliked them.
father, imprisonment of father, father left
home etc.

The respondents who dropped out due to


small living place were both girls.

Four respondents (28.5%) dropped out


due to fights amongst parents – 2 of them

Research indicates that
were boys and the other 2 girls. vulnerable households can
withdraw children from school as
School-college related problems: part of their coping strategy to
59% respondents who dropped out due to deal with shocks to income, often
school-college related problems were boys. in order to work, save on costs or
to free other household members
36% of all respondents who dropped out
due to school-college related problems said
up to work (Boyle et al, 2002; de
they faced poor environment in their Janvry et al, 2006; Jacoby &
respective schools or in mother project Skoufias, 1997; Gubert &
classes. Robilliard, 2006; Sawada &
50% of these respondents said they used
Lokshin, 1999 cited in Ersado,
to get regular punishments (including the 2005)
respondents who faced poor environment
in mother project) without any valid
reasons. 75% of these children (who faced
poor environment) were boys.

37.5% of these respondents (who faced


poor environment) said lack of games and

8
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Marriage: Among all respondents who dropped out


due to teaching learning related problems,
15 out of 105 respondents (14.3%) 47% said they did so as they could not
dropped out as they got married while pass examinations – 3 of them said the
studying. It is already stated above that all questions were too difficult for them and 5
of these respondents were girls. said there were other reasons.

90% of these respondents accepted that Lack of interest:


they themselves choose to marry and only
1 respondent said she was forced into Only 4 respondents (3.8%) dropped out
marriage. due to lack of interest. They could not
remember their learning related subjects,
Most of respondents who were married especially in mathematics. so they could
themselves said they lost interest in not pass examinations year after year.
studying and did not try to continue. 2 of
them said they were shy to face the
teachers after marriage. Only 1 said her
in-laws put restrictions on continuing
studies.

Relocation/migration:

Only 2 respondents (1.9%) said


... A number of researchers
relocation/migration caused dropping out indicate that a buoyant job
from schools. Both of them did not like the market and the ability to earn
environment of the new place where they
migrated – according to them, no one used
good money is a motivating force
to go to school there. behind decisions to leave school
(e.g. Dachi & Garrett, 2003;
Education (teaching learning) Duryea, 2003). Duryea (2003)
related problems: highlights the pull of the labour
A total of 17 respondents (16.2%) dropped market (as opposed to the push
out due to teaching learning problems of poverty) as a main factor in
88.2% were boys. children dropping out of school in
urban Brazil.

9
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Matrix: Relative importance and interrelations of different reasons for


dropping out from school

One of the assumptions of this study was that of relative importance) and 9 as 3 (3rd
dropping out from school happens due to a in the order of relative importance).
combination of reasons. There could be a main
reason for dropping out for a child but along These responses were given weightage as
with the main reason there must be other per the following formula:
reasons influencing the main reason.
Reason 1/ Reason 4 = (%age of
To explore the above mentioned phenomenon, respondents who choose reason 1 as the
the questionnaire was designed as per the main reason + %age of respondents who
following logic: ranked reason 4 as 1 + + %age of
respondents who ranked reason 4 as 2 +
I. There are 9 main factors identified as + %age of respondents who ranked reason
reasons for dropping out. 4 as 3 + %age of respondents who ranked
II. Each respondent selected one reason. reason 4 as 4 + %age of respondents who
III. Then the respondent said whether the ranked reason 4 as 5 + %age of
reason selected by her/him is the respondents who ranked reason 4 as 6 +
main reason. %age of respondents who ranked reason 4
IV. If they said yes (under III) then they as 7 + %age of respondents who ranked
are supposed say what were the other reason 4 as 8 + %age of respondents who
reasons (8 or less) and rank those ranked reason 4 as 9)
reasons as per relative importance.
V. They did the same if the said no Accordingly the matrix on ‘relative
(under III) importance and interrelations of different
VI. In both the cases the respondents reasons for dropping out from school’ was
ranked the other reasons as per the prepared.
relative importance of those reasons
to them. The following table shows not only the
VII. So, the respondents choose 1 main relative importance of different reasons for
reason, then choose few other related dropping out but their interconnections
reasons and ranked the relative too.
importance of the reasons.
VIII. For example, one respondent Ramesh While ranking, many respondents choose
choose reason 5 as main reason then ‘other reasons’ and ranked those reasons.
choose 3, 6 and 9. He then ranks 3 as It is suggested that the following matrix
2 (2nd in the order of relative should be reviewed on the basis of the
importance), 6 as 1 (1st in the order main 8 reasons.

10
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Educati
Distanc Econom Family School onal Lack of
e to ic problem Environ Problem Marriag Migratio interest
school reasons s ment s e n s Others
Distanc
e to
school 6.0 44.4 61.1 26.0 27.4 13.2 11.3 63.0 51.6
Economi
c
reasons 28.9 67.3 84.0 48.9 50.3 36.1 34.2 85.9 74.5
Family
problem
s 17.4 55.8 72.5 37.4 38.8 24.6 22.7 74.4 63.0
School
Environ
ment 25.1 63.5 80.2 45.1 46.5 32.3 30.4 82.1 70.7
Educati
onal
Problem
s 20.3 58.7 75.4 40.3 41.7 27.5 25.6 77.3 65.9
Marriag
e 18.4 56.8 73.5 38.4 39.8 25.6 23.7 75.4 64.0
Migratio
n 6.0 44.4 61.1 26.0 27.4 13.2 11.3 63.0 51.6
Lack of
interest
s 7.9 46.3 63.0 27.9 29.3 15.1 13.2 64.9 53.5
Others 7.0 45.4 62.1 27.0 28.4 14.2 12.3 64.0 52.6

The data above was put in a bubble diagram to understand the same ‘relative importance and
their interrelationships’:

11
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Note: EP = educational problems, ER = economic problems, FP = family related problems, LOI = lack of interest and SE
= school environment.

The above bubble diagram shows lack of interest, family problems and economic reasons are
strongly related with each other.

Reasons having stronger relationships with each other:

Reasons having strongest relationships with each other:

12
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Opinion of the mothers

Two focus groups were conducted with the The mothers then wrote the reasons (in Bengali)
mothers - one at Kalighat slum area and on floor of the meeting place. Then they were
another at Chetla slum area. The mothers were asked to rank the identified reasons as per their
asked to identify the reasons for which the relative importance for younger children (below
children from the locality drop out from school. 9 years) and older children (above 9 years).

Ranking of reasons of dropping out by mother - Kalighat


Rank for older Reasons of dropping out – as identified by Rank for younger
children mothers children
1 Low/lack of income for mothers 1
2 Family related problems 2
7 Lack of interest in studies 8
13 Lack of interest among parents 7
8 Urge to earn from younger age -
4 Influence of TV, films 6
3 Influence of peer groups 9
10 Helping the mothers in earning 5
5 Love/romantic relationships -
6 Marriage -
9 Older age in comparison to other classmates -
11 Fear of teachers 3
12 Inefficient teachers 4

Ranking of reasons of dropping out by mother - Chetla


Rank for older Reasons of dropping out – as identified by Rank for younger
children mothers children
11 Helping in household works (girls only) 5
2 Influence of peer groups -
12 Excessive disciplining by parents 2
- Fear of teachers 3
9 Income related problems 4
1 Drug addiction (boys only) 7
5 Insecurity (only girls) -
6 Urge to become economically self dependent -
3 Love/romantic relationships -
4 Marriage -
7 Bad influence of family 1
8 Lack of interest 6
10 Sibling care -

The results of these two FGDs were different. Chetla drug addiction of boys, influence of peer
Mother’s in Kalighat identified low/lack of groups and love/romantic relationships were
income for mothers and family related problems most important problems for the older children
as the most important problems behind and bad influence of family environment,
incidents of dropping out for both older and excessive disciplining by parents and fear of
younger children. Whereas, for mothers in

13
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

teachers were the main causes for dropping out


for the younger children.

Mothers from both the places expressed that the


children were not getting proper environment in
the surroundings – they were getting easily
attracted to drugs and unsocial activities. On the
other hand the parents are unable to provide
required support.

In both the places mothers expressed that


children are falling in love at a very young age
and getting married themselves.

The mothers also expressed that environment in


the school should also be improved to achieve
better retention rate.

... Hunter & May (2003) draw on


research by Tanner, Krahn &
Hartnagel (1995) which indicates a
higher number of boys (than
girls) leave school in South Africa
because earning money and attaining
adult status is more attractive to
them.

14
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

Annexure I: Questionnaire

1। inu
  -   

2। inu  
- n 

3। inu   
- n 

4। p ! "  -

5। ut  -

6। ut  &!-

7। !    s )
 *o
 n ! ?

8। ! k    s)
 /! )я *o
 n ! ?

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
XII 1st yr 2nd yr 3rd yr
12 13 14 15

9   s )

o
 n !   !? s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
a8"9 ! 6 2
:! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

15
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

10   E 8 ! s)
 /! ) я 4t 1-2 ! ) 1
! ? 2-3 ! ) 2
3-5 ! ) 3
5! )   4

11   E !! a6 !  =F 6 1 12


s) @  !?  2 14

12
 @  = ) !     " =F 6 1
=
 )?  2 13

13 !       " =o ? s)


  ) 
1
&!  TC :i 2
 "  :Gk
: ! : 3
 "  я6 a ! ! ! ) 4
 " =o
 @g= =
H ) 5
  @ ! @ s )  " ! I
 6
a66(u l 6) 99 21

14 4tя ! 6 )? =F 


o
 m 
1 15
&! 
=  6 2 17
 KE E  :  3 19
 KE E  I
 4 20
a66(u l 6) 99

15 =F  s )

o
 m )  !?   )
=F  !L = 1
G! p n!  2
  s :    3 16
a66(u l 6) 99

16 !   s :   s


@ ! : !я = 1
? KE E 6 ) 2
a66(u l 6) 99

17 *=  6 ! O  )? := 6s a 1


I =) := 6s 2
a
 := 6s 3

 :k := 6s 4
a:
k := 6s 5
a66(u l 6) 99

18 := 6s a:


k ) !? @ G! p n!  я6 1
am G E я6 2
:= 6s  O  6 я6 3
a66(u l 6) 99

16
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

19 !       s)


   @
 ! ) 1

 
  I  :  ? P  I  E *o

2
* 
  I a !  ) 3
a66(u l 6) 99

20 !       s)


  I
@ P  я6 @
! 1
* 
  I  Ii  ? @ ) :E 6:    !  @g= i 2
 I
@   !я ! 3
a66(u l 6) 99

21   !   ! 4ti   s)
 =F 6 1 22
E e!t !?  2 23

22 * =F 6 =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )  *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

23 *  =
= ) @ ! ! !  s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
  s)
  E  eP i ! K) a8"9 ! 6 2
@ :k! Kt4 a  яo :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

24 !G O  a8"9 ! 6 я6 :E i e a !  1 25


  ! :E  E =)? s)
 /! )я * 
  I G 2
n6 s) (DTMS)Eo ST  ! ) 3 27
 "  :Gk ! @ !  4 30
@
!  : ! =*6 ! 5
a66 !  @
! 6
a66(u l 6) 99 34

25   ! i ! 6:  TF e =F 6 1 26
=*6 I
 )?  2

26 * I
8! = ) TF e :k @ ! i o
 @U o
 =
) 1
8 ! ! ) =
)? @ ! i o
 !8 o
 = )o o
 =
 2
@ I
) !n4 @ ! o
 =
 3

17
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

a66(u l 6) 99

27 !   DTMS e n6 !I  n6 !IP-e    ) :E  =


 1
i  Su  Ii ? n6 !IP-e  )  =
 2
n6 !IP-e  
 k! i 3
n6 !IP @ :n 
4
n6 !IP-e @) !  :E 
o
 =
5

n6 !IP-e :  @  ) ) K 6
n6 !IP e n 
 @ :n 
7
a66(u l 6) 99

28   ! TF e   !  i  =F 6 1 29
!IP o
 !8  ) )?  2

29 * =F 6 =
= ) TF e :k 8 ! i  !IP o
 !8  ))  1
! O  =*6 :
 )? i  !IP o
 @U o
 = )o o
 2
=

@  )) !n4 o
 =
 3
a66(u l 6) 99

30   !  "  /:Gk   я6 =F 6 1 31


TF e ! 8 ! =*6 :
 )?  2

31 * =F 6 =
= ) TF e :k 8 !  "  /:Gk   6:  TF e :k 1
! O  =*6 :
 )? 8 ! @U o
 =
)
 "  /:Gk   6:  TF e :k 2
8 ! @U o
 = )o o
 =

 "  /:Gk   6:  @  )) 3
!n4 o
 =

a66(u l 6) 99

32   !   :  я6 @


:  @
 !। 1
! =
!?
  I
P   @
=! 2
a6 i   :E  я6 @
! =
3
* @
!  @
n =
K  4
* @
!   K  5
* @
!  @) =
K  6
  o
 a6  я6 E ! 7
o
 n !  

a66(u l 6) 99

33 a6 @ ! ! !  я6   ! @ @ ! = I ! 1


@
! = ? i) H   I я6 ! 2
@ !  @
!  @!G
) 3
= я @
!  *K :
K 4
! я  = яi :
) 5
a66(u l 6) 99

18
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

34   !   ! a8"9 ! 6i =F 6 1 35
  s) E pO !?  2 36

35 * =F 6 =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s)
 /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )  *o
 n !   eP
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? a8"9 ! 6 2
:! 6 3
s) /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
snW 7
a66(u l 6) 99

36 *  =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )
 *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
snW 7
a66(u l 6) 99

37   s) E :  ! O    e =  c 1 38


:! 6 )?   e kW YKE 2 39
i    Z  3 40
  e @) @) 8! 4 41
    :E я
K a 5 42
a66(u l 6) 99 43

38     =  c !G   @ :E I яK :  1


  ! s)
 E O6 !)? i   @ !i  = 2
@  E u&
a6 я
K

*o
 3
=
)
:  :E 8 ! a6 !  pO6 4
:
a66(u l 6) 99

39     kW YKE i   @ !i  = 1


!G    ! s)
 E O6 a66  I  E K) 2
!)?   :E  
t )  3
E YKEYS я6 :E  a O =c) 4
:t a O !) 5
a66(u l 6) 99

40 i    Z  !G    I


 @ :E  ! 1
  ! s)
 E O6 !)? :t a 2
YKE   ) K 8!
:E  4

19
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

! a O =c)


:E 
  *K  :   5
a66(u l 6) 99

41     e @) 8! @8"! = *6 a 1


!G    ! s)
 E O6  t
:t a 2
!)? :  :E  ) a6 ! ! pO6 o
 3
@ ! ! !  8! i 
Y ) 4
я6
8! я
K  ) *o
 5
a66(u l 6) 99

42 :E я
K a !G    !  a6  d k =o
 1
s)
 E O6 !)?  ! я  O6 *k 8! 2
\/  я
K a 3
:E  я
K i 5
a66(u l 6) 99

43   !   ! :! 6i =F 6 1 44
  s) E pO !?  2 45

44 * =F 6 =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )  *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

45 *  =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )
 *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

46 s) /! )я !nd! 6 ! e s )


 k 6s  )" ) 1 47
) * я6   ! s) /! )я @ s )
 :  :n 
2 48
E =
)? @ k  n
 @ !  3 49
@ k  n @ 8 ! @ !   4 50
@ k!  :n !   5 51
@ k! @ ! :n !  6 52
@ k! @ p я   7 53

20
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

@ :Gk
: ! : 8 54
a66(u l 6) 99 55

47 )" k 6s !    ! s)


 &!  k =  1
E O6 !)?  
k! )  2
e!i   a !K ) k = 3
:E  : ) 
  4
:Gk 6s  ) )  5
a66(u l 6) 99

48   ! s )
 :  :n ! s )
  )O ) 6s )  1
? n  @ ! :n !  2
s )
 I:  a ! : !я! = 3
k!  я   O6 YKEYS ! 4
a! W @  s o
 = 5
a66(u l 6) 99

49 n 
  Z  !    o p  @ !  1
s)
 E !W =
u])? @ !  ! )o @ ! s : = 2
F 
яi @ я  E 3
k! @ ! k  i   !   4
 ! я6 @ ! s)
 8 ! TC 
5
o
 =
)
a66(u l 6) 99

50   n
   8 !   o @ ! 
== ! 1
=o
 !  !   s)
 E )? o @ !   2
@ ! !u :E 
=*6 !  3
@ ! o  : :   ^! 4
@ a      )   Z :E )jя 5
!
a66(u l 6) 99

51     s )
 k!  :n k! @ !  O !  1
!  !? @ ! e! o я    2
a!  s   3
:E   : ) @ ! a !kW k  4
i  F E
8! =
a66(u l 6) 99

52   !   k! :n !  &! :E  :   1


 !? k  L я6 2
n 
  Z  3
k!  P K YKE 4
n  SH 
o
 5
a66(u l 6) 99

53   k!    p я  @ :E я K ) @ !  )    1

21
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

o
 !    ! s)
 E @ E a O )  to @ !  2
O6 !)?  
:E !  K )o :     ) :E O  3
k! я  o

s )
 *  ) )K 4

k! я  o

:E 
:
5
8! 
a66(u l 6) 99

54 !   :Gk
: ! : G : 8!
&!  :Gk  : 1
? p  !& =
) 2
E a O 8!
&!  :E  ! 3
:
a66(u l 6) 99

55   !   ! k!    =F 6 1 56
p a *K i   s)
 E  2 57
pO !?

56 * =F 6 =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )  *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

57 *  =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )
 *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7 67
@g=я 6 8 65
a66(u l 6) 99

58 = !    s)


 E @ :E :E 
=
K
) 1 59
!W =
F E)? 
 :  UE 8 ! :E 
 2 60

 : @  я :E  I)
* 3 61
i c !  
@ sG @ ! i  O ! 4 62
@ ! ) ! E !я ! = 5 63
sn eP i я6 s )   =o

a66(u l 6 99

59   :E :E 
=
K) @  яi 
!  
 1

22
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

!? @   я !  @ 




 2
@  K  ) 3
@ :Gk
: ! :  ) 4
@ @ :E ) )K)   ) 5
a66(u l 6) 99

60 
 :    UE 8 ! @ ! E  !я ! = 1
:E 
 !? o E u  ) :E ! :n !  2
o ! :  ) )  3
@ nm =
: E) 4
o  8 ! s )
 t a !  ) 5
a66(u l 6) 99

61 
 :   @ :E  n @ ! 
 == ! 1
I)
* i c !  !? k!  !  )jя ! 2
s )
 :E ! 
:   3
   =
) : E @ !G =  4
a66(u l 6) 99

62   !   sG   !? p   !  E H 1


@  : E 8 ! : W !  :  2
 )
:E Ii   ) 3
&! !я!" ! :    ) 4
a66(u l 6) 99

63 
 :    ! ) ! E !я @ sG яK )  1
! = !? P I)   I я6 2
EG   8 ! !G ! 3
!я ! @  ) ) K 4
@ @ ! ! )  5
a66(u l 6) 99

64   !   ! =   s)
 =F 6 1 64
E pO !?  2 65

65 * =F 6 =
= ) a6 ! ! !  s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
s )
 *o
 n !   eP i a8"9 ! 6 2
! K) @ :k! K4t !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

23
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

66 *  =
= ) a6 ! ! !  s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
s )
 *o
 n !   eP i a8"9 ! 6 2
! K) @ :k! K4t !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

67 sn !    s)


 E    я
K :   ) )K)  1 68
!W =
F E)?    s )
  " = : 2 69
o   K
@ @ :E  ) ) K  3 70
   я
K
K
@ ! !я ! =
) 4 71
a66(u l 6) 99

68    я
K :   ) )K)  E 8 !   )i  S!  = 1
!? :E
 : !я!" = 2
o   !ui p
s )  *  3
i p
a=-= lE I) @ :  4
a66(u l 6) 99

69    s )
  " = : !?  "  :k
: ! :  ) 1
@ / я  =o

2
 "  !  :  ) 3
   Y  " = K
)  ) 4
a66(u l 6) 99

70 o   K
  @ :E  ) o   e!o n =
 1
) K  !? a ! s :
=F  * = 2
s)
 @ e!  ) ) K  3
k! &! я    4
a66(u l 6) 99

71    я
K
K
  ! !я @ /  as =
:E
1
! = !? P  @
 ! ) 2
i/  :E I I)  я6 3
/ я !  @ ! ! я b !

) 4
a66(u l 6) 99

72   !   ! sn   s)
 =F 6 1 73
E pO !?  2 74

73 * =F 6 =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s)
 /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )  *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3

24
Study on ‘reasons of dropping out from schools’

s) /! )я !nd! 6 4


k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

74 *  =
= ) @ a6 ! ! s) /! ) я 4tя 6 1
!  s )
 *o
 n !   eP a8"9 ! 6 2
i ! K) @ :k! Kt4 !? :! 6 3
s)  /! )я !nd! 6 4
k !nd! 6 5
= 6
sn 7
@g=я 6 8
a66(u l 6) 99

25

You might also like