t

SENATOR IOHN I. FLANAGAN LEGISLATIVE OFFICE BUILDING

Room 817
2nd DISTRICT
Albany New york 1224?
Chair THE SENATE l5t8t 455-2A71
Ccrporaticns, Authorities Fax (tlE) 426-6904
g Commiss'ons
STATE OF NEW YORI(
Commlttees DISTRICT
260 Midd!e Country Road
Agtng
Suite 203
Consumer Protectron Smrthtown, l.Jew york I1767

Hlgher Educatiorl \6311 36t-2154

Fax 163l I 36t ,536j
lnsurance

t,aDor INTERNET
\ffi Senatorllana€an com
Transportation
February 7,2008 flana€an@senate state.ny us
Veierans. Homeland Secutity
6 N'ljlitary Affairs

Carol Ash
Office of the Cornmissioner
NYS Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation
Empire State Plaza, Agency Building #l
Albany, New York 12238

Dear Commissioner Ash:

Thank you for your letter of January 23,2008. While I appreciate your brief cover letter
and press release, as well as pages from the proposed parks capital budget, this is an insufficient
and incomplete response to the specific questions and infonnation requested in my January I l th
and I 8th correspondence to you.

As you can see from the January I lth letter, I specifically asked for ,,an itemized list of
all proiects identiJied for the Long Island Region along with the estimuted costs
for each
proiect," not just those capital construction and design projects that will be advanced by your
department in FY 2008-09. As you recall from your confirmation hearing, you mentioned more
than $300 million (which was then subsequently adjusted upward by you to $600 million) in
capital construction projects that remain outstanding throughout the State. Given this figure, I
assulne that the Long Island Region has significantly more construction and design projects that
have been identified beyond 2008-09. Therefore, I again respectfully ask that your office provide
a list and cost estimate for all of those projects.

In addition, please reference the January lSth letter in which five (5) bulleted items were
clearly set out for your office to address. Based upon your most recent response, at least three (3)
of those bullets remain unanswered, including:

* An explanation of all factors and/or criteria used to establish the distribution formula
for spending the $100 million in new capital funding (i.e., population; need; etc.),
* A description and/or mapping of what constitutes the Upstate and Downstate regions
for purposes of distributing this new capital funding; and

al
 (Page 2)
Commissioner Ash
February 7,2008

* An explanation of horv and why $80 million of the new capital funding was allocated
for Upstate and $20 million was allocated for the rest of New York State (or
Downstate),

I am sure you can appreciate how helpful it is to have specific responses to the questions I
present to you in order to clear up any misunderstandings that may exist, particularly when I am
called upon to answer the exact same questions from the people I represent. As you know, a
critical component of being a public servant is to build on one's existing knowledge by asking
important questions on subjects where I may not directly have all the necessary information.

It is my hope that your off,tce will work cooperatively with me in gathering this
'information on behalf of the people I represent. Thank you in
advance for your consideration and
attention to this matter.

Flanagary
Enclosures