Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract— The performance of power systems decreases with Fixed Series Compensation (FSC) is widely used to
the size, the loading and the complexity of the networks. This is improve the stability and to increase the transmission capacity
related to problems with load flow, power oscillations and in long distance transmissions. A huge number of these
voltage quality. Such problems are even deepened by the applications is in operation. If system conditions are more
changing situations resulting from deregulation of the electrical complex, Thyristor Controlled Series Compensation (TCSC)
power markets. The power systems have not been designed for is used. TCSC has already been applied in different projects
wide-area power trading with daily varying load patterns where for load-flow control, stability improvement and to damp
power flows do no more follow the initial planning criteria of the
existing network configuration. Large blackouts in America and
oscillations in interconnected systems. Special FACTS
Europe confirmed clearly, that the favorable close electrical devices are UPFC (Unified Power Flow Controller [3]) and
coupling might also include risk of uncontrollable cascading GPFC (Grid Power Flow Controller [8]). UPFC combines a
effects in large and heavily loaded interconnected systems. shunt connected STATCOM with a series connected
FACTS (Flexible AC Transmission Systems), however, STATCOM (=S3C, Solid State Series Compensator) which
provide the necessary features to avoid technical problems in the can exchange energy via a coupling capacitor. GPFC is a
power systems and they increase the transmission efficiency. special DC back-to-back link, which is designed for power
and fast voltage control at both terminals. In this way, GPFC
Index Terms—Blackout, FACTS, FSC, HVDC, Increase of is a “FACTS Back-to-Back”, which is less complex than the
Transmission Capacity, Parallel Operation of FACTS and
UPFC at lower costs.
HVDC, Short-Circuit Current Limitation, Stability
Improvement, SVC, System Interconnection, TCSC For most applications in AC transmission systems and for
network interconnections, SVC, FSC, TCSC and GPFC/B2B
I. FACTS TECHNOLOGIES - OVERVIEW are fully sufficient to match the essential requirements of the
grid. STATCOM and UPFC are tailored solutions for special
In the following sections, solutions for system 400 kV became the highest voltage level, in Far-East countries
enhancement, for Blackout prevention and for system mostly 550 kV, and in America 550 kV and 765 kV. The 1150
interconnection are presented and their advantages are kV voltage level has been anticipated in the past in some
explained. Examples of large project applications in Asia, countries and also some test lines have already been built. In
America and Europe are depicted, including hybrid China for example, AC voltages of 1000 kV are actually
configurations with parallel operation of FACTS and HVDC. under discussion with regard to very long transmission
distances between generation and load centers and for
II. TRENDS IN POWER SYSTEMS supplying strong AC links between the different systems of
2
3
neighboring grids are too weak for such a large additional III. LARGE BLACKOUTS 2003
power infeed. By means of two HVDCs in combination with
four SVCs, the energy can be “bundled” and then transported A. Probability of Blackouts
point to point to the load centers in the middle of the country. Fig. 7 shows, that the probability of large Blackouts is
The off-shore connection to the main grid will be done by much higher than calculated with mathematical modeling,
high power GIL (Gas Insulated Lines), in order to avoid huge especially when the related amount of power outage is very
numbers of cables nearby the coasts, as it is indicated in the large [2].
figure. The benefits of this “remote infeed solution” are:
• load sharing and
• generation reserve sharing
Both are essential for the safe and reliable operation of the
power system.
If power should be transmitted through the interconnected
system over longer distances, transmission needs to be
supported. Actual
Expected
This is for example the case in the West-European UCTE Source:
system (Fig. 5), where the 400 kV voltage level is actually too
low for large cross-border and inter-area power exchange.
Bottlenecks are already identified (NTC - Net Transfer Fig. 7. Reasons for high Probability of Blackouts
Capacity, Fig. 6), and for an increase of power transfer,
advanced solutions need to be applied. The reasons for this result are indicated in the figure. This
means, that, when once the cascading sequence is started, it is
… Zone 1 & 2 “resynchronized” since 10.10. 2004 mostly difficult or even impossible to stop it, unless that the
direct causes are eliminated, ref. to the figure.
NORDEL
B. The Events in North-America
Options for Grid The Blackout sequence started on august 14, 2003, around
Interconnection noon [2]. Reactive power and voltage problems have been
IPS/UPS reported, but no major ones.
Giant Loop Flows
2.2 - 4.8 GW
UCTE - 1
UCTE - 2
Turkey
Fig. 5. A View on the European Scenario - with further Options for Grid
Interconnection to UCTE
Source: National Transmission Grid Study;
Source: UCTE - 5 / 2003 U.S. DOE 5/2002 – “Preview”
Bottlenecks
in the UCTE Fig. 8. Comparison of Study Results 2002 with the real Blackout 2003
System Scenario
3
4
collapse. This led to further disconnections of lines and large IV. ELIMINATION OF BOTTLENECKS IN TRANSMISSION –
amounts of generation capacity, with significant voltage and LESSONS LEARNED
frequency fluctuations, up and down. A full voltage collapse
and the final Blackout was the consequence. The affected area A. Use of Power Electronics for System Enhancement
out of supply is shown in Fig. 9. Fig. 10 gives an “Application Guide” for transmission
enhancement by means of Power Electronics (ref. to the
system in Fig. 8).
Fig. 9. The Area of the Blackout [2] Depending on the grid structure, there are four basic cases:
Approximately 50 million people in 7 states were out of • load displacement in case of parallel lines by
supply for hours or days. A total amount of 62 GW customer impedance variation (FACTS for series compensation)
loads was lost (this corresponds to half of the installed • fast load-flow control in meshed structures with
generation capacity in Germany) of which 49 GW have been B2B/GPFC or UPFC (or very slow with phase shifting
reconnected within 16 hours. transformer)
• voltage collapse: reactive/active power injection by
C. The Events in Europe
means of FACTS/HVDC
These events can be summarized as follows: • excess of allowed short-circuit level: short-circuit
Great Britain (August 28): current limitation (FACTS/HVDC)
1 Transformer out of service due to Buchholz Alarm and
a wrong Protection Relay Setting. However, only a P
limited Area (South London) was affected V1 , δ 1 V2 , δ 2
Denmark-Sweden (September 23):
G~ G~
A large Collapse in the Synchronous Area due to
Power Station Outages in Combination with a double X
Busbar Fault (storms and wrong “construction”)
V1 V2
Italy (September 28): P= ( 1 - δ 2)
sin (δ
X
Outage of 2 major Transmission Lines; Overload on the __
remaining Lines – Full Blackout – very similar to the US-
Canada Event Power-Flow Control
The Italian Blackout was initiated by a line trip in Parallel Compensation
Switzerland. Reconnection of the line after the fault was not
Series Compensation
possible, due to a too large phase angle difference (about 60
degrees, leading to blocking of the Synchro-Check device). 20 Fig. 11. Power Transmission – The basic Equation
min later a second line tripped, followed by a fast trip-
The basic equation for power transmission (Fig. 11)
sequence of all interconnecting lines to Italy due to overload.
explains the solutions for system enhancement in a clear way.
It is one of the key-consequences of deregulation, that the
power transfer across the systems is nowadays much more The power transmitted between two subsystems depends on
wide-spread and fluctuating than initially designed by the voltages at both ends of the connecting line, the line
system planners. The system elements are going to be loaded impedance and the phase angle difference between the
up to their limits, with risk for loosing the n-1 safety criteria. connecting points. Power electronics can actively influence
System enhancement will be essential in the future, in Europe one ore more of these parameters and control or direct the
too. power flow through the interconnection.
4
5
As mentioned before, also Phase Shifting Transformers are 1000 km 500 kV AC interconnection between North and
suitable for load-flow variation, however with major South systems has been realized. In the interconnection two
constraints regarding the controllability in case of transient TCSC devices have been installed at both ends of the line
and emergency conditions: which damp the inherent oscillations that occur between the
systems. Additionally, 5 FSCs have been necessary to reduce
Phase Shifting Transformer the transmission angle. The recordings from on-site staged
Designed for Steady-State Conditions: fault tests during commissioning show that the interconnection
The principle is Voltage Source Injection is unstable without the damping function of TCSC. If only one
TCSC is in operation, the interconnection becomes already
However, Tap-Changing is very slow:
stable, and with both devices acting the inter-area oscillations
5 - 10 s per Tap, in total 1 min or more for a Full- are quite well damped, and redundancy is provided. From site
Range Operation
experience, it has been reported, that under increased load
Remedial Action in Emergency Situations: conditions, the TCSC damping function is activated up to
Reaction Time must be ≤ 100 ms (e.g. for Voltage Collapse) several hundred times per day, thus saving power transmission
and keeping the return on investments constantly “running”.
This requires FACTS or HVDC
2 TCSCs - Redundant
V. USE OF FACTS FOR SYSTEM ENHANCEMENT 1000 km Line Job sharing
0 MW
c) shows the very effective power oscillation damping (main -880 MW -880 MW
Results of Dynamic
System Tests:
Fig. 13. 500 kV TCSC Furnas/Brazil – Essential for Transmission
a) No SVC Connected
b) Both SVC in
Voltage Control Mode Significant Increase DE CZ
Source: PTD
SE PT 1998
5
6
1500
360 km
Loads
3~ 1200
400 MW
900
Anshun
Anshun HVDC GuiGuang
FSC
Hechi
Guangdong
Baise Luodong
Pingguo
Zhaoqing
Yunnan HVDC TSQ Gaomin
Yulin Zhaoqing
Guangxi Conv. Stat.
Nanning
Fig. 18. Pingguo TSC, commissioned in June 2003
6
7
were unforeseen right of way restrictions in the neighboring As a consequence of “Lessons learned” from the large
area, where an initially planned new tie-line to the strong 400 Blackouts in 2003, high voltage power electronics will play an
kV network for connection of the HVDC was denied. Hence, important role for the system developments, leading to hybrid
with the existing reduced network voltage of 110 kV (see the AC/DC systems with better controllability of the power flows
dotted blacks lines in Fig. 19), only a limited amount power and to assist in prevention of cascading disturbances.
transfer of the DC link was possible since its commissioning
in 1994, in order to avoid repetitive commutation failures and VII. REFERENCES
voltage problems in the grid. In an initial first step for power [1] D. Povh, D. Retzmann, “Development of FACTS for Transmission
increase, an additional transformer for connecting the 400 kV Systems”, The IERE Central America Forum, Nov. 23-28, 2003, San
HVDC AC bus with the 110 kV bus (see the figure) was José, Costa Rica.
[2] G. Beck, D. Povh, D. Retzmann, E. Teltsch, “Global Blackouts –
installed [7]. Lessons Learned”, POWER-GEN Europe 2005, June 28-30, 2005,
Finally, 10 years later with the new SVC, equipped with a Milan, Italy.
fast coordinated control, the HVDC could fully increase its [3] FACTS Overview, IEEE and Cigré, Catalog Nr. 95 TP 108.
transmission capacity up to the design rating of 600 MW. In [4] V. Gor, D. Povh, Y. Lu, E. Lerch, D. Retzmann, K. Sadek, G. Thumm,
“SCCL – A new Type of FACTS based Short-Circuit Limiter for
addition to this measure, a new cable to the 220 kV grid was
Application in High Voltage Systems”, CIGRE Report B4-209, Session
installed, to increase the system strength with regard to 2004.
performance improvement of the HVDC controls. [5] Kirschner, L., Bohn, J., Sadek, K. “Thyristor protected series capacitor -
Part 1 Design Aspects”, IEEE-T&D Conference 2002, Sao Paulo,
Initially planned Connection Brazil.
[6] Y. Jing, X. Wu, Z. Du, X. Jin, Y.Wang, D. H. Zhang, J. Rittiger, “Digital
Simulation of AC/DC Hybrid Transmission System”, PowerCon, Oct.
2002, Kunming, China.
[7] H. Waldhauer, “Grid Reinforcement and SVC for full Power Operation
Grid Access
denied
2 of Baltic Cable HVDC Link”, The 38th Meeting and Colloqium of Cigré
Study Committee B4 ”HVDC and Power Electronics”, Technical
Colloqium Sept. 25, 2003, Nuremberg, Germany.
1 [8] M. Mohaddes, D.P. Brandt, M.M. Rashwan, K. Sadek, “Application of
Now, the HVDC the Grid Power Flow Controller in a Back-to-Back Configuration”,
2 can operate at
full Power CIGRE Report B4-307, Session 2004.
Rating
VIII. BIOGRAPHIES
Final Solution: new Lutz Kirschner (1963) received his BSC in Electrical
2 SVC with TCR & TSC 1 Initial Step for Grid Access Engineering 1992 from the University of Aachen,
100 MVar ind. Enhancement Germany. He joined SIEMENS company, and worked
2 and a new 220 kV Cable
200 MVar cap. in the HVDC department as a system design engineer.
He is involved in technical and commercial design of
Fig. 19. The Problem – no Right of Way for 400 kV AC Grid Access of Baltic HVDV converter stations. Since 1995 he is
Cable HVDC Link – and the Solutions [7] responsible for Series Capacitor Design carrying out
the basic design studies. His special field are time
In Fig. 20, a photo of the Siems SVC in Germany is given. domain simulations and system studies. Since 1998 he
is member of IEEE.
Dietmar Retzmann (1947), Cigré, VDE, graduated in
Electrical Engineering (Dipl.-Ing.) at Technische
Hochschule Darmstadt/Germany in 1974. He received
Dr.-Ing. degree from the University of Erlangen-
Nuremberg in 1983. Dr. Retzmann is with Siemens
Erlangen, Germany since 1982. Currently, he is
director for Technical Marketing & Innovations
HVDC/FACTS in High Voltage Division, Power
Transmission Solutions. Dietmar Retzmann is author
of numerous technical publications. In 1998, he was
appointed guest-professor at Tsinghua University,
Beijing, and in 2002 at Zhejiang University,
Hangzhou, China. Since 2004, he gives lectures on
Fig. 20. A view on the Siems SVC HVDC/FACTS at University of Karlsruhe, Germany.
Gerhard H. Thumm (1951) received his Dipl. Ing.
VI. CONCLUSIONS degree in electrical Engineering 1977 from the
Technische Universitaet Stuttgart, and the Dr. Ing.
Deregulation and privatization is posing new challenges on degree in Electrical Engineering 1991. He joined
the high voltage transmission systems. System elements are Siemens in 1982, where he worked in the system
going to be loaded up to their limits, wide-area power trading planning department and in the department for
with fast varying load patterns will cause congestion, because reactive power compensation. Since 1985 he is
involved in the design of Static Var Compensators,
the systems are not designed for such conditions. System since 1992 he is repsonsible for the design of Series
enhancement will be essential to keep the supply reliable and Compensation Systems, also with Thyristor Control.
safe.