You are on page 1of 8

vol. cxxii, no.


Job board sees surge in student submissions
By DAviD rosen Staff Writer

the Brown

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Since 1891

Egypt still too unstable for study abroad program

By ALison siLver Senior Staff Writer

Though recruiting season is far from over, the number of applications submitted through the Center for Careers and Life After Brown Student Job and Internship Board has already surpassed last years total. The number of applications submitted from Aug. 1 to Feb. 1 of this year represents a 57 percent increase from last years total, said Andrew Simmons, director of CareerLAB. The number of unique students applying students who have submitted at least one application is also up 19 percent, Simmons said. He did not have data for each individual class. It probably means that students are more aware of the resources than they have been in the past, he said. The surge could also be due to the rise in on-campus recruiting. Though he did not have exact numbers, Simmons said the number of recruiters visiting the University has increased. Many of the companies that formally recruit at Brown are in the finance, consulting and engineering fields. As The Herald continued on page 2

Courtesy of Alexa Stevens

instability in Egypt prolongs study abroad program suspension.

Students can now study abroad in the Middle East through a newly approved program at the University of Jordan in Amman. The creation of the program, coordinated through Middlebury College and launched in the fall, comes after a study abroad program in Alexandria, Egypt was placed on hold following last years outbreak of civilian protests against the government. Two Brown students were par-

ticipating through the approved program in Egypt also coordinated through Middlebury when they were evacuated from Alexandria last January. Middlebury decided to postpone its Egypt program until further notice because the situation is still too unstable in Egypt right now, said Michael Geisler, Middleburys vice president for language schools, schools abroad and graduate programs. Amanda Labora 12.5 was continued on page 3

R.I. budget proposal targets eateries

By sonA MkrttchiAn Senior Staff Writer

NE wS iN bRiEF
Rattner 74 settles with Quadrangle
The arbitration case between Steven Rattner 74 P10 P13 P15, former fellow for the Corporation, the Universitys highest governing body, and the private investment firm Quadrangle Group has ended in a settlement, the New York Times reported Tuesday. The case had been amicably and conclusively resolved, Quadrangle executives wrote in a Feb. 1 letter to investors. The letter did not specify if a monetary agreement was reached, the Times reported. Rattner, who co-founded Quadrangle, had filed claims for an unspecified amount of money he said the firm owed him when he left in 2009. Shortly after Rattners departure, the Securities and Exchange Commission and then-State Attorney General and current Governor Andrew Cuomo launched an investigation against Quadrangle, alleging Rattner participated in a ploy to generate kickbacks for the company from a state pension fund. After settling with the SEC in 2010, Quadrangle issued a statement calling Rattners conduct inappropriate, wrong and unethical. Rattner, a former Herald editor-inchief, admitted no wrongdoing. At the end of 2010, he paid $10 million to settle with the SEC and attorney generals office. He was temporarily banned from the securities industry and from appearing before a public pension fund. Last weeks Quadrangle letter thanked Rattner for substantial contributions to the firm over the years. Neither Rattner nor Quadrangle representatives returned requests for comment. sahil luthra

A week after Gov. Lincoln Chafee 75 P14 released his budget proposal to the General Assembly, Rhode Island residents are ex-

city & state

pressing their distress over its proposed tax increases, which Chafee himself called controversial during his annual State of the State address to legislators last week. The almost $76 million of tax hikes in the proposal include a four-cent increase to the state tax on cigarettes, as well as an ex-

pansion of the taxable base for the lodging tax, extending it to certain bed-and-breakfasts and rental properties. The sales and use tax would expand to include services such as limousines and taxis, moving, storage and car washes. A new tax would also be applied to clothing and footwear purchases exceeding $175. The most controversial measure in Chafees tax plan is the 2 percent increase to the meals and beverage tax, raising the total tax to 10 percent a proposition that does not bode well for local restaurant owners. They should roll (the tax rate) back to what it was 10 or 15 years ago, said David McAllister, owner

of Meeting Street Cafe on the corner of Meeting and Thayer streets. Measures like this are making it more difficult for students to dine out. McAllister added that while he does not believe the tax increase will drive customers away, his customers the majority of whom are students will definitely be affected by the increased cost. The tax increases represent Chafees attempt to rectify a $120 million budget deficit from last year, said Sen. Daniel DaPonte, DEast Providence and Pawtucket, who chairs the Senate Committee on Finance. continued on page 5

UCS proposes constitutional change

By MArgAret nickens Senior Staff Writer

The Undergraduate Council of Students passed a proposal at its general body meeting Wednesday night recommending an amendment to its constitution that would give the council the power to control its own funding. Under the current system, the Undergraduate Finance Board must approve the councils budget. The proposal will now go to a referendum on MyCourses and the student body will have until this Sunday to vote either in favor or against the change. We give you the power to fund, but you dont really fund us that well, said UCS-UFB liaison Daniel Pipkin 14 to UFB. Pipkin said the amendment would help clarify the relation-

ship between the council and UFB, which was created in 1984 to help oversee the distribution of funds to student groups. UFB later became a subsidiary of the council. The proposed change will help eliminate this power struggle that seems to occur when UCS and UFB dont agree on something or dont get along, Pipkin said. The councils budget would need to be approved by the general body as well as by a member of the Student Activities Office under the proposed change, he said. UCS President Ralanda Nelson 12 said contentions between the council and UFB have previously affected the councils funding, impacting the councils effectiveness and discouraging the group from continued on page 3

Corrine Szczesny / Herald

UCS President Ralanda Nelson 12 spoke about amending the Councils constitution.


news....................2-5 editorial............6 opinions.............7 city & state..........8

First-class site

students rank favorite classes on new course review site

News, 2



t o d ay


eats wasabi macarons, strips naked

Post-, iNsiDe

27 / 47

32 / 48

2 Campus news
TODAY 12 P.M. Quaker Meditation, Campus Center Memorial Lounge 7 P.M. Mid-Year Activities Fair, Campus Center 6 P.M. Folk Music Night, brown bookstore FEbRUARY 9 TOMORROW 12 P.M. Get Crafty, The Underground FEbRUARY 10 By neeLkirAn YALAMArthY Staff Writer

the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

New site showcases best classes

A new online course review tool, whose number of users has climbed to 600 in under two weeks, may make future shopping periods a little less hectic. Best of Brown, a website created by Jonah Kagan 13 and Liz Neu 14, displays a list of the most popular courses at Brown that are submitted to the website. Students can submit their three favorite courses and, in return, view a list of the most recommended classes. Kagan, a computer science concentrator, said they started Best of Brown to help his suitemate, Chris Fitzsimmons 13, find the perfect fourth course. The site has now been visited 1,800-2,000 times, Kagan said. In addition to ranking courses, the website filters out courses not currently offered and ranks professors teaching the same course. Kagan said they may add a feature allowing students to update their top three choices. The site has received mixed student feedback, with the main criticism being that the sites rankings are biased, favoring large, introductory courses over smaller ones. CSCI 0150: Introduction to Object-Oriented Programming and Computer Science and CSCI 0310: Introduction to Computer Systems are currently the leading courses. Kagan said this bias was interesting but added that he plans to add course enrollment numbers to normalize the data. The Critical Review, another student-run course review, avoids bias by using a three-stage editing process that averages ratings from student evaluations, said Charis

SHARPE REFECTORY Pork Teriyaki, Grilled Ham and Swiss Sandwich, Vegan Tofu Ravioli, Sweet Potato Fries VERNEY-WOOLLEY DINING HALL LUNCH Grilled Cajun Chicken, Vegan OvenRoasted Tofu, Minestrone Soup, Oatmeal butterscotch Cookies

DINNER Roast Turkey with Gravy, Cheese and Corn Strata, Chocolate Cherry Upside Down Cake Lemon broiled Chicken, Fried Rice bowls, Cauliflower Au Gratin, Vegan Six bean Soup, Dijon Pasta Salad

Courtesy of brown University


The new best of brown site allows users to see other students favorite courses.


Loke 13, the Critical Reviews executive editor. Though based on a similar premise, the Critical Review does not feel threatened by Best of Brown, Loke said, since no other site compiles as much course data as it does. But Loke added that there is always room to be more relevant, noting that the return rate of Critical Review surveys has declined in recent semesters, with only 35.8 percent of evaluations returned last spring. In the past, the percent of student evaluations returned was higher, at roughly 38 percent. Kagan said his site fills a gap in the Critical Reviews data, since Best of Brown rates courses relative to each other, rather than independently, as the Critical Review does. He said he intends for the site to supplement other course review

sites and does not want it to take over the course-shopping field. Students have also complained about having to use Facebook to submit their favorite courses on Best of Brown, which prevents multiple entries by the same user, Kagan said. He added that though many people said the website is cool, few said it influenced their course selections. Irene Rojas-Carroll 15 said she used both Best of Brown and the Critical Review during shopping period. She learned about Best of Brown through Facebook and found the site to be helpful in finding course ideas. But she said she was not too influenced by the site, since only a few people have submitted their top three courses. She added that the Critical Review was more useful in narrowing down courses to shop.

Student career choices stay consistent

continued from page 1 reported last fall, out of 90 recruiters at the annual job fair in September, only 24 were there to provide careers in the common good even though 75 percent of students expressed interest in that area in a 2010 CareerLAB survey. But Simmons said CareerLAB was not worried by the dominating presence of financial and consulting companies, adding that they are only part of a small universe of companies that do this type of recruiting. He said other fields are equally accessible to students, but they might have to use a multi-faceted approach that is less structured than the on-campus recruiting process. Simmons said he did not expect the increase in on-campus recruiting to affect where students apply. Though data is not yet available for the class of 2011, the distribution of students across career fields has been relatively constant over the past five years, he said. The only thing you can tell about Brown students is that they are interested in a wide variety of fields, Simmons said. Abigail Cain 15 visited CareerLAB for the first time before the start of this semester for sessions about interviewing and the internship search. Its nice to know that Brown has so many resources for you to use, such as a network of alums, she said. Cain said she planned to bring her resume to a career advisor for a closer look. But some students use alternate pathways to get summer opportunities and explore life after Brown. By using the Fellowships@ Brown website, Maddie Johnston 13 was able to receive a grant from the Watson Institute for International Studies for research last summer. This year, she said she is applying for an Undergraduate Teaching and Research Award. Though Johnston has never used CareerLAB, she said many of her friends have found it very useful. Still, it was no surprise to her that many students have not yet used its resources. You have an hour, she said. Do you want to go to an internship fair or hang out with your friends?


the Brown 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I.

Danielle Marshak, Treasurer Siena DeLisser, Secretary

Claire Peracchio, President Rebecca Ballhaus, Vice President

The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement and once during Orientation by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Subscription prices: $280 one year daily, $140 one semester daily. Copyright 2011 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.

(401) 351-3372


(401) 351-3260


the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

Campus news 3
semester, worked extremely well, Geisler said. Academically, its very strong. But the non-academic aspects of the program were not at all what students expected. We totally lived in a brothel, said Alexa Stevens, a junior at Tufts University. There was a secret passage from our dorm building to a coffee shop next door where women would work, she said. She described seeing women wearing long black body coverings and high heels and make-up. We would wonder whats going on, she said. They were most likely prostitutes. The cafe on the first floor of the dorm is in all likelihood a front for prostitution, Middlebury wrote in a letter to the parents of participating students mid-way through last semester. Some of these prostitutes may well be living in the same building as our female students. We never felt unsafe per se, but there was a lot to be aware of in that part of town, Stevens said. Jordan has a comprehensive secret police force and stable security system, which helped ensure foreign students safety, she said. The building, which was privately owned and not affiliated with the University of Jordan, was located in a red-light district, according to Ayane Ezaki 13. It was an uncomfortable place, she said. It took two weeks before Middlebury moved the students to a different building in the same redlight neighborhood. Ezaki said students were sexually harassed and that she personally had experienced blatant solicitation. Before they moved buildings, there was a robbery, an intrusion and a dog-killing outside their dorm. At no point did I feel that my safety was at risk, Ezaki said. Despite unexpected complications related to their housing, Ezaki and Stevens said they learned a lot while studying in Jordan. Ezaki said her Arabic improved considerably, and the Jordanian faculty was fantastic. But because of the language requirements, she said she had little choice in selecting her courses. In hindsight, she said she was ultimately glad she did not study in Alexandria especially given the turmoil in the city last November. I had a crazy experience, she said, but Im glad I had it.

U. approves study abroad in Jordan Funding changes would

continued from page 1 one of the two Brown students evacuated from Egypt last January. Upon returning to Brown, Labora was in a weird situation because the study abroad program was over but second semester had already started. She decided to take a leave of absence because of her untimely return. Labora said her time in Egypt was not wholly positive or negative. Her experience was very humbling, she said, because she realized how little control she had over the events that transpired. Theres a dogma at Brown that its always better to be somewhere else, but real effective change, like the radical societal change that happened in Egypt, cant come from the outside, she said. Her advice to students studying abroad is to take every opportunity and obstacle as it comes, rather than trying to impose ones own expectations on a given situation. Michael Dawkins 12 also did not immediately return to Brown after the evacuation. When I got back, it was extremely difficult adjusting, he said. There was this sensation that anytime something could explode or go off, or everything could go into chaos. He has not yet resumed studies at Brown and has been working in Louisiana for several months. The transition was too difficult and too abrupt, and we werent really given a lot of time to process, he said. Geisler said Middlebury is monitoring the situation in Egypt daily, watching the news and receiving country briefings from the U.S. State Department and Global Rescue, the provider that helped airlift students from Alexandria during their evacuation. Since last November, Egypt has been on the State Departments travel alert list, a list that includes countries whose conditions pose significant short-term risks to the security of American citizens, according to the Departments website. Anytime you send students to a foreign country, there is a certain risk involved, no matter how much due diligence you do, Geisler said. Four years ago, Middlebury was considering implementing a program in Syria, but we had information that made us hesitate, he said. Prior to the protests that sprang up across the Middle East last year, Middlebury had already been looking to add an extra site in Jordan because the Egypt program was so successful, Geisler said. Everybody is looking at this with the understanding that the situation in Egypt is fluid, said Kendall Brostuen, director of international programs and associate dean of the College. Uprisings continue to occur across the Middle East, particularly in Egypt, Tunisia, Syria, Yemen and Libya, said Melani Cammett, director of Browns Middle East studies program and associate professor of political science. Even in countries like Jordan, which are not mentioned as much in the headlines, political unrest is still an issue, she said. Jordan is less of a concern at the moment, Cammett said, due to its different government dynamics. Jordan has a monarchy in addition to multiple political parties, and its monarchy has been very astute at managing politics, she said. Protests are ongoing in Egypt, largely around the issue of the militarys current role in government. Cammett said the protests have been successful in terms of ousting former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and holding elections not rigged by the state. But many key features of the system have not yet changed, she said. Other universities are currently less restrictive in terms of current study abroad options. Boston University, for instance, currently offers programs in Lebanon and Syria. We would like to go back, Geisler said of Egypt. But we have to be assured that its safe for the students, and right now we just dont have enough information at this point. Middlebury will decide within the next several weeks whether to reinstate its program in Egypt for fall 2012. Students who applied to study abroad in Egypt for fall 2011 were notified last May that Middlebury was not going to run its program in Alexandria. Applicants had been told ahead of time that they would be automatically accepted to the Jordan program if Egypt was not an option. The Jordan program, which took place for the first time last continued from page 1 tackling more projects. We dont even dream big anymore, because we know we are not going to get funded for things, she said. Pipkin said the council receives significantly less funding than do student governing bodies at Penn, Cornell and Dartmouth and has only received an average of 37 percent of requested funds over the past five years. In response, Raaj Parekh 13, a UFB-at-large representative, said the student governments at these institutions have many more responsibilities than does UCS and noted that nearly all student groups at the University are underfunded. Last year, UFB was only able to meet two-thirds of the budget requests, UFB Vice Chair Michael Perchonok 12 told The Herald. The proposal that they are putting forth prioritizes UCS needs over the needs of every other student group because theyd be first in line, perpetually, to the student activity fee, Parekh said. While Nelson contends UCS will not be irresponsible with the funds, Perchonok noted that UCS does not have the intimate knowledge of student groups afforded to UFB, who review the budget of over 200 groups around campus. In essence, it will mean even less money for student groups that are already chronically underfunded, Perchonok said. Perchonok said he thinks students deserve more time to con-

allow UCS to dream big

sider the proposed amendment, which would be the first UCS constitutional change since 2003. He said the change seemed sudden, though Nelson said in the meeting that she has unsuccessfully been attempting to begin a conversation with UFB for the past four months. Nelson also said in the meeting that she values student opinion on the issue, explaining that she decided to propose a constitutional amendment rather than a code change as the former requires student approval whereas the latter does not. It is trying to make a statement about valuing the work that is done here, Nelson said in the meeting. After a lengthy discussion on the topic, the proposal passed with only a few general body members voting against it. Our projects reach the greatest number of students, but we cant get our own funding for that, UCS Communications Chair Sam Gilman 15 told The Herald. We have to go use outside sources of funding for that which is both inefficient and, especially with the state of Browns finances, very difficult, to find discretionary funding for those projects. At the meeting, the council also passed a statement encouraging the University to incorporate student input when deciding on tenure promotions and announced next weeks discussion with Marisa Quinn, vice president of public affairs and University relations, on the Universitys contribution to the city of Providence.

Join The Herald!

Info sessions at 195 Angell St. Sunday, February 12 @ 7 p.m. Monday, February 13 @ 7 p.m.

4 Campus news
New parking spaces added to Thayer St.
By coLBY richArDson Contributing Writer

the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

The block of Thayer Street between George and Waterman streets has been permanently made one-way with parking spaces added to both sides of the street. This is the finishing touch on an overhaul of the block, which included repaving the road, repairing the sidewalks and planting trees along the sidewalks. These changes occurred in connection to the recent renovation of Metcalf Chemistry and Research Laboratory. Before the Metcalf renovation, this portion of Thayer was twoway. Northbound drivers sometimes continued past Waterman onto a one-way portion of the street, posing a danger to drivers and pedestrians. The University worked together with the citys Department of Public Works to conduct a thorough traffic analysis. The study concluded that converting this portion of Thayer Street to one-way would increase safety by eliminating the confusion that was occurring at the intersection, wrote Michael McCormick, assistant vice president for planning, design and construction, in an email to The Herald. This change also allowed the addition of much-needed parking spaces. The addition of the park-

Courtesy of Gordon Morton

Students participated in a networking fair hosted by the School of Engineering.

Greg Jordan-Detamore / Herald

The section of Thayer Street outside the Sciences Library will remain one-way. Parking spaces were also added following the streets repaving.

Engineering students, alums connect at job fair

By hAnnAh ABeLow Senior Staff Writer

ing spaces serves Thayer Street merchants, and the change to a one-way street makes sense, said Allison Spooner, president of the College Hill Neighborhood Association. She added that pedestrians and drivers will not be inconvenienced by the change. Many Brown students agreed the transition was a wise decision. Its clearly a lot safer with a one-way street, said Coco

Schoeller 15. Ana Olson 14 said the overhaul of the street is a welcome compliment to the Metcalf renovation. The changes in space are lovely, she said. But she expressed concerns about parked cars blocking drivers views of pedestrians. She added that a car barely missed her when she tried to cross the street earlier that day.

The School of Engineering hosted its first networking and career fair Sunday. The event was organized in response to student complaints that engineering didnt do a very good job of helping them find jobs and internships, said Christopher Bull, senior research engineer and senior lecturer in the School of Engineering, who helped organize the fair. Normal career fairs held on campus for everyone have a lot of consulting and are geared towards (international relations), math or economics majors. The (computer science) department also has a lot of their own recruiting, said Alice Leung 13, an electrical engineering concentrator. In the past, engineering hasnt had a lot of engineering companies coming to recruit at Brown. Leung said some engineering students have attended career fairs elsewhere or found jobs and internships online. The School of Engineerings move toward more aggressive oncampus recruitment for concentrators comes two years after the school was formed. While Bull said there was no direct line between the schools creation and the decision to host the career fair, he added that the new Dean of the School of Engineering Lawrence Larson enthusiastically supported the idea. It was the right time, and we had the right push, Bull said. About 20 alums representing nearly 15 companies attended the event, for which about 150 students registered, said Karen Haberstroh, assistant professor of engineering. Companies and labs represented at the fair included Google, Microsoft, a Californiabased start-up called CouchSurfing and Draper Laboratory. DPR Construction, a company that has been actively recruiting on campus for some years, was also represented. The fair began with a discussion in the morning between pro-

fessors and alums regarding the Universitys evolving engineering program. The afternoon was devoted to interaction between students and alums. This included several panels, a speech about collaborations between neuroscience and engineering and time during which students could move from table to table to network with alums from the represented companies, Bull said. It was great hearing specific stories from alum(s) who have gone through very different paths in their careers, said Ryan Sailor 13. It helps a lot because without guidance from alums, its difficult for us to really know whats going to happen after school. Sailor said the fair could have put more emphasis on mechanical and chemical engineering. Most of the companies were for electrical and computer engineers, although the other fields might have been underrepresented due to the job market, he said. He also said he would like to see more companies represented in coming years and that, ideally, alums such as those employed by Draper Laboratory and Lincoln Laboratory would come as recruiters from their companies rather than informally networking through alums. Melissa Loureiro 07 GS 08, who now works for Hamilton Sundstrand, attended the event because she was looking for ways to give Brown students opportunities to find jobs and to connect back to Brown. She said she hopes the event continues in the future and lauded the professors for organizing the event. Professors also said they viewed the fair as a success. Haberstroh said she has high hopes the event will be held for many years to come and that the companies involved will be encouraged to recruit through outlets like the CareerLAB. CareerLAB helped to plan this event, she said. The fairs organizers will reconvene this week to discuss ways to expand and improve the fair next year.

the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

Campus news 5
continued from page 1 No one wants to deal with higher taxes, Daponte said. But when you have a $120 million hole to fill, there are only two ways to do it cuts or additional revenue. According to the Chafee administration, revenue from the tax increase will also be used to finance public education expenditures and greater state aid to cities and towns a high-priority measure for the Chafee administration coming into 2012. Some of our cities and towns are facing some significant financial challenges and some of them have really begun to dig in and cut costs, DaPonte said. But there is still a lot of work that needs to be done the solution is not just to throw money at them. We need real reform. DaPonte added that the state itself is under financial strain. Were not in any position to just write a check to any community that is having problems, he said. Gary Janczynski, owner of Ugly American, a restaurant on Ives Street, said he understands the state is experiencing financial difficulties but the current situation is unfortunate because it will affect tourism. Any time especially in this economy you raise the price of anything, people notice, and it absolutely affects their choices, Janczynski said. But not all local restaurateurs are concerned about the tax hike. Andrew Mitrelis, owner of multiple restaurants on Thayer Street including Andreas, Paragon and Viva, Better Burger Company and Spats said he does not think the tax increase will significantly affect the business community because it is not extreme. Five dollars this way or that way doesnt make that much of a difference, Mitrelis said. Were not making the same money we used to make 10 years ago, but we have to keep working. Chafees proposal represents a decrease in overall spending for the state, as the cumulative budget for the 2013 fiscal year stands at $7.9 billion a notable decrease from last year, largely due to $40 million worth of cuts. Many of these cuts, such as the elimination of dental services for adults on Medicare, are directed at the health and human services portion of the state budget. After deliberating, the General Assembly will vote on the proposal, which Chafee formally introduced Feb. 1. Approved changes will be implemented before July 1, the official beginning of fiscal year 2013.

TWC appoints new assistant directors Proposed tax increase worries business owners
By cAroL kiM Contributing Writer

After an intensive search conducted by Mary Grace Almandrez, director of the Third World Center and assistant dean of the College and student committees, Shane Lloyd MPH 11 and Joshua Segui have been selected to serve as assistant directors for the Third World Center starting this semester. Lloyd will serve as assistant director for firstand second-year programs and Segui for co-curricular activities. As assistant director for co-curricular activities, Segui said his goal is to ensure that academic rigor is not restricted to the lecture hall but is also reflected in student events. Segui, whose academic background is in critical race theory, queer theory and gender studies, said when he was a student he felt courses were focused on thinking at the expense of doing. I never fully identified with being an academic, and I felt that academics are thinking about communities but not doing anything to help these communities, he said. Out of his desire to put his academic perspective to the test, he interviewed various activists, including Occupy Wall Street protesters in Zuccotti Park, prior to starting at the TWC. But he added that theory is just as important as action, saying the Occupiers he met had the action, but they didnt have the theory. He said his goal is to bridge the classroom and the community. Almandrez, who began her tenure as the TWC director last fall, said Segui will build the intellectual capacity of the center by coordinating with various student programs.

Paige Gilley / Herald Shane Lloyd MPH11 and Joshua Segui hope to put learning into practice at the TwC.

Though they hold different positions, Segui and Lloyd will co-supervise first-year students and work to cultivate relationships with graduate students. They are also working on aligning existing seminars with the Third World Transition Program, so the classes can serve as forums to continue conversations students started in the pre-orientation program. During his time as a Brown graduate student, Lloyd said he wanted to foster relationships with the Minority Peer Counselors. He was attracted to the TWC because of its focus on student activism and the role he could play in the development of student leadership. Lloyd is very approachable and has developed solid relationships with the MPCs, said Hisa Hashisaka 14, an MPC who served on one of the student search committees and has worked with Lloyd. He communicates regularly with them

and gives feedback on their weekly reports, Hashisaka said. Lloyd also handles the major aspects of programs for first- and second-year students of color, which include TWTP and the ALANA Mentoring Program, which connects students with graduate students, medical students, alumni and staff members of color. Lloyd was involved in the University community prior to his appointment as an assistant director. He worked as a Graduate Advising Fellow for the Office of Residential Life, served as vice president of the Samuel M. Nabrit Black Graduate Student Association and sat on the TWC Director Search Committee. Most recently, he served as interim program coordinator for the TWC. Whats great about Shane is that hes familiar with the TWC but is still new enough to bring a fresh perspective to the MPC program and to the TWC, Almandrez said.

Dreadful Cosmology | Dario Mitchell

6 editorial
Last Thursday, the state Board of Regents for Elementary and Secondary Education voted to establish two Achievement First charter schools in Providence. Though the supporters of this proposal argue that Achievement First will bring academic success to a school district plagued with low expectations and substandard performance, we remain skeptical. Achievement First schools present a substantial fiscal burden for the city and may also have a negative impact on the English Language Learner population of Providence, which makes up about 20 percent of the student population. For these reasons, we do not support the establishment of Achievement First schools in Providence. Providence is a diverse community and the ability of Achievement First to fulfill the citys needs is questionable. The Achievement First Bushwick Charter School in Brooklyn, N.Y. lacked a formal ELL program and instead, possibly in violation of federal law, treated its English language learning students as special education students. In the other six Achievement First schools in New York City, English language learning students comprise only 1 to 2 percent of the student body, a disproportionate number considering that they make up 14 percent of students in New York City. Though the student populations of Achievement First schools typically include at least 10 percent from outside the AfricanAmerican and Latino communities, according to a Providence City Council Education Subcommittee report, we remain concerned that Providences Achievement First schools will leave English language learning students behind. Another point of concern is the financial impact of Achievement First schools on Providence, where public schools have been hit hard by the recession. A subcommittee of the Providence City Council issued a report stating that the opening of Achievement First schools would cost the system somewhere between $3.1 million and $8.7 million. They projected that this would result in the closing of an elementary school and the need to reduce the number of teachers in an already struggling system. This consequence is a result of the recently instituted fair funding formula, which causes education money to follow the student. In other words, educating a student in Providence costs around $14,000, but when a student transfers to an Achievement First school, the public school he or she came from is not $14,000 cheaper to run. The per-student cost of education has been calculated to be around $10,000 to $11,000. This extra $3,000 or $4,000 is spent on certain resources for students on which schools will inevitably have to cut back. Considering the school closures and program cutbacks in the past few years, and the fact that Providence is on the brink of bankruptcy, establishing an Achievement First school is a luxury Providence cannot afford. While the opponents and proponents of charter schools have debated the effectiveness of Achievement Firsts curriculum and approach, certain details about how the system would affect Providence are less ambiguous. The financial burden of the schools, paired with Achievement Firsts questionable ability to educate English language learning students, leads us to the same conclusion that many organizations, representatives, public officials and community members have voiced: The Board of Regents should have rejected Achievement Firsts application. editorials are written by The heralds editorial page board. Send comments to

the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

EDiTORiAL A luxury we cant afford


by a n d r e w a n ta r

t h e b r ow n da i ly h e r a l d
Editor-in-chiEf claire Peracchio ManaGinG Editors rebecca Ballhaus nicole Boucher sEnior Editors tony Bakshi natalie villacorta BuSIneSS GEnEral ManaGErs siena DeLisser Danielle Marshak officE ManaGEr shawn reilly edItorIAl arts & culture editor sarah Mancone arts & culture editor emma wohl city & state editor elizabeth carr city & state editor kat thornton Features editor Aparna Bansal Features editor katrina Phillips news editor David chung news editor Lucy Feldman news editor greg Jordan-Detamore news editor shefali Luthra science editor sahil Luthra sports editor ethan Mccoy sports editor Ashley McDonnell assistant sports editor sam rubinroit editorial page editor Jonathan topaz opinions editor charles Lebovitz opinions editor Jared Moffat Graphics & photos eva chen emily gilbert rachel kaplan glenn Lutzky Jesse schwimmer olivia conetta kyle Mcnamara Julia shube neal Poole Graphics editor photo editor photo editor assistant photo editor sports photo editor copy desk chief design editor design editor web producer

we totally lived in a brothel.


Alexa Stevens, Tufts University student see egypt on page 3.

dirEctors Julia kuwahara samuel Plotner nikita khadloya Angel Lee sales Finance alumni relations Business development ManaGErs Justin Lee kaivan shroff gregory chatzinoff Mahima chawla Matthew hill Alison Pruzan elizabeth gordon David winer Human resources research & development collections collections Finance operations alumni engagement Fundraising social Media & Marketing

CORRECTIONS POLICY The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication. C O M M E N TA R Y P O L I C Y The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR POLICY Send letters to Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the authors identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed. ADVERTISING POLICY The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.

PoSt- mAGAzIne sam knowles editor-in-chief


BloG dAIlY HerAld Jennifer Bloom Matt klimerman editor-in-chief Managing editor

the Brown Daily herald thursday, February 9, 2012

opinions 7
handed down by UFB. As a result, Daniel Pipkin 14, the UCSUFB liaison, introduced an amendment to the UCS Constitution yesterday to formally delineate the relationship between UCS and UFB. UCS elected to propose this delineation of powers as a constitutional change, not a change in the Code of Operations, in the interest of student involvement, clarity and transparency. rently stipulates that UCS empowers UFB as an ancillary body to fund student groups at Brown. The two additional clauses proposed by the council serve to further clarify the relationship between UCS and UFB. The first sentence in Article V, as amended, would read, The council shall fund its own operations and those of its subsidiary with money from the Student Activities Fund. A new senof checks and balances, one of which requires the director of student activities to approve the UCS budget after it has been authorized by a 2/3 yea vote by the council. In the fall, UCS commissioned Pipkin to investigate structural reforms to improve the transparency and service that Browns student government provides to its community. Over the course of the first semester, Pipkin reviewed the governing documents of the two bodies and consulted with other student leaders across the country. During the 2011-12 school year, the council received a budget of $3,500, which was thoroughly insufficient to fund its operations. Currently, it must seek funding from other sources, such as student groups and administrative departments, to pay for its projects and operations. With the inherent limitations of seeking outside funding from student groups and departments with their own agendas, this funding mechanism is predictably inefficient and inadequate. Under this amendment, UCS would strengthen its charge to manage student groups and grant seed funding to emerging groups with ambitious community-focused agendas. UCS urges all students to vote yea in the referendum. It will be administered on MyCourses Feb. 9-13. if you have any questions about the proposed changes, feel free to email us at

Vote yea to UCS-UFB role amendment

For the past 27 years, the Undergraduate Council of Students and the Undergraduate Finance Board have collaborated to serve the Brown community by formally categorizing and funding student groups. While the two bodies have served the community admirably, we admit there is room for improvement. Compared to other student governments that fund student activities under a similar mechanism through a subsidiary finance board UCS is severely underfunded, especially when compared to its Ivy League peers. Penn and Cornells undergraduate assemblies both have budgets about 10 times larger than Browns. And Dartmouths assembly, one that represents a smaller student body than Browns, has a budget 21 times the size of UCSs budget. Under the de facto structure, UCS requests a budget from UFB to fund its yearly operations. UFBs budgetary power over UCS obscures the institutional relationship between the two bodies. Discord between UCS and the finance board often hinders the councils ability to adequately and efficiently fund projects that enhance student life, as interrelational strife can, at times, influence the funding decisions

Under the de facto structure, UCS requests a budget from UFb to fund its yearly operations. UFbs budgetary power over UCS obscures the institutional relationship between the two bodies. Discord between UCS and the finance board often hinders the councils ability to adequately and efficiently fund projects that enhance student life.
Constitutional changes require the approval of Browns student body. UCS urges all students to approve this constitutional amendment in the online referendum, which can be found on MyCourses. The passage of the referendum would ensure that Browns student government could increase its ability to meet the needs of the student body in a timely manner and with adequate resources. Article V of the UCS Constitution curtence at the end of Article V would read, UCS reserves the right to review and amend the constitution of its subsidiary. As inherent in this right, supplementary regulations put forth by the subsidiary could thus be deemed a violation of its own constitution. UCS guarantees that changes in the Code of Operations will ensure that there is no abuse of funding power. The changes to the Constitution have built in a set

Playing it safe and the risks of student life

opinions Columnist
robberies, armed and unarmed, and assault cases have taken place on College Hill. This is in comparison to the annual 8,403 property crimes and 1,217 violent crimes that occurred in the city of Providence. Take a few seconds to assess your personal investment in your safety. How many outdoor emergency phones are installed on the University campus? Do you know the number off the top of your head? If necessary, would you know where to look if you needed to direct yourself to one of the phones without delay? According to the DPS website, there are approximately 134 outdoor Self-Defense Course or Self-defense Awareness and Familiarization Exchange (S.A.F.E.) Program? I fear that the real danger lies in a lack of conscientiousness and awareness. In spite of the potentially dangerous situations in which I have found myself, I rarely take advantage of friendly safewalkers company and have never programmed DPS services into my cell phone to ensure my own safety. Furthermore, although SafeRide vans circulate around the campus on a timed schedule, many SafeRide vans travel without any passengers between midnight and 1 a.m., a time Alert statements, I realize that in the five reports that specified victims genders, eight victims were male-identified. This leads me to wonder if the gendering of safety has negatively impacted the nature of security at the University. Many of the self-defense workshops and programs like the aforementioned R.A.D. Course or S.A.F.E. Program are designed for female-identified students. And while female-identified students are often encouraged to keep their eyes open for little signs of danger, male-identified students do not receive nearly as many warnings. In a discussion about the recent assaults and robberies on College Hill, one of my male classmates admitted, I really dont know what Id do if I someone suspicious approached me. Ive never really had to think about it. As students living away from home, it is our responsibility to look out for ourselves and for each other. It is, however, the responsibility of the University to keep us aware before and after the safety of any or all students is jeopardized. Streets that lead to dorms and off-campus housing away from the Main Green can be better lit and more DPS programs can be accessible to students regardless of gender. DPS and student groups can work conjointly to facilitate more workshops and programs to bridge the gap between true security and student life. There is no need to live in fear at your home away from home. We cannot stop criminality, but we can put an end to needless vulnerability. Helen McDonald 14 is armed with a flashlight and can be reached at

How safe do you feel as you walk to your dorm room? Once the sun has set, do you walk around the campus alone or with a friend? When heading from the Olney-Margolies Athletic Center to the Main Green or from Keeney Quadrangle to Perkins Hall or Young Orchard, have you ever taken a stroll with some friendly safewalkers or hopped aboard a SafeRide? Because of statistics that inform us that Providence has been listed as among the cities with the highest property crime rates, ensuring the student bodys safety is one of the Universitys most urgent priorities. The University has established quite a few different means to guard the safety of its students, but do these measures really suffice? Are we safe enough? During my freshman year, I lived in Keeney and though I was always careful to pay attention to my surroundings, I never felt vulnerable or unprotected. Now as a sophomore who lives quite some distance away from the Main Green in Machado House and who must trek occasionally from one end of the campus to the other, I realize that I have mastered the art of throwing glances over my shoulder and of walking in large groups. I have also become more aware of the number of reported Crime Alert statements issued by the Universitys Department of Public Safety within the last year. Since March 6, 2011, nine

Since March 6, 2011, nine robberies, armed and unarmed, and assault cases have taken place on College Hill. This is in comparison to the annual 8,403 property crimes and 1,217 violent crimes that occurred in the city of Providence.
emergency phones located on or near the exterior of all residence halls and most university buildings. They are also located on the campus walkways, at the parking garage, and additionally there are 45 elevator phones in various campus buildings. Have you installed the Rave Guardian service, which allows DPS to respond to panic calls or precautionary timer calls, on your cell phone yet? Are you aware of programs such as the Rape Aggression Defense (R.A.D.) Systems Basic frame when many students are making their way out of the libraries and heading to their rooms. Streets north of Waterman and south of George are rarely well-lit, but few students carry around flashlights or other objects to make themselves and their path visible, while others can be seen fumbling in the dark for keys and ID cards. The prospect of being attacked or robbed hardly seems a reality to many Brunonians. Furthermore, as I examine DPS Crime

Daily Herald City & State

the Brown
thursday, February 9, 2012

At celebration, state leaders discuss R.I. black history

By ALexA Pugh Staff Writer

As legislators and local community leaders gathered at the State House for the third annual Joint Legislative Black History Month Heritage Celebration, Corey Walker, associate professor and chair of the department of Africana Studies, distilled the spirit of the night to a single question: Is America possible? The event, sponsored by the Rhode Island General Assembly and the Rhode Island Black and Latino Caucus, featured performances by the Rhode Island Gospel Chorale Society and remarks by Gov. Lincoln Chafee 75 P14, state House and Senate leaders and Walker, who spoke about the importance of ensuring the American dream is accessible for people of all races. After a brief introduction by Rep. Anastasia Williams, D-Providence, Chafee opened the event with a short speech. He traced the history of blacks in Rhode Island from the First Rhode Island Regiment of the Revolutionary War to the naming of President Ruth Simmons as the first black president of an Ivy League university in 2001. We have to remember the history because it empowers us to continue to fight, because black

history is American history, said House Speaker Gordon Fox, DProvidence, in a speech at the event. Fox the states first black and openly gay speaker is one of seven legislators belonging to racial minorities currently serving in the House and Senate. He cited disease, crime, poverty and lack of educational opportunities as issues more prevalent in non-white communities. While much work has been done, there remains much work to do, Fox said. While we have our debates and our legitimate differences in point of view, we have worked between the legislative chambers and the executive branch and across party lines to bring about true progress for our state in recent years, said Senate President Teresa Paiva Weed, D-Jamestown and Newport. I am pleased that (the celebration) has become an annual tradition that both chambers observe together. Providence and Rhode Island are at the vanguard of recognizing black history, Walker told The Herald. He stressed the importance of reexamining the past in his keynote address. It was not and is not an option to continue with the myth of the American nation as a

Alex Tin / Herald

At the State House, Rhode island leaders paid tribute to black History Month with speeches and celebrations.

fully realized possibility, he said. His speech urged the audience to consider black history as a way

to live out the founding ideals of the nation. Yes, he said. America is pos-

sible when we look at it through the eyes of those who were deemed less than human.

Legislation spotlights domestic abuse

By MAthiAs heLLer Senior Staff Writer

Harvard junior Nicholas Alahverdian is not your typical lobbyist. Lobbyists often have long-standing connections with lawmakers and years of experience working in legislative corridors to advance their agendas. But beginning as a teenager, Alahverdian, who is now 24, saw lobbying as a necessity. Alahverdian was born to abusive and alcoholic parents and ended up in the custody of the Rhode Island Department of Children, Youth and Families. But Alahverdian said DCYF, which provides services to children who came from troubled backgrounds, deprived him of medical care and ignored his reports of abuse. Alahverdian resorted to political activism and became a legislative aide in the Rhode Island House of Representatives at the age of 15. I was always fascinated by the political process and its ability to be a net for Rhode Islanders to force social justice, Alahverdian said. A bill recently introduced in the House last month by state Rep. Roberto DaSilva, D-East Providence and Pawtucket, would give children the ability to contact physicians, attorneys and others who work for child welfare while in the care of DCYF. DaSilvas bill also sets standards for ensuring that children receive humane and dignified treatment while in state custody. DaSilva said the bill is necessary to provide for a better quality of life for children in light of the abuse suffered

by Alahverdian. As a teenager arriving at the State House covered in bruises and cuts, Alahverdian said he notified lawmakers of the treatment he had received while in state custody. But neither the legislators nor DCYF responded to his accusations of negligence, instead transporting him around the state in a night-to-night placement program a common practice at the time, Alahverdian said. Alahverdian found himself sleeping at different facilities in Providence, Cranston and Central Falls on a nightly basis. DCYF did not take into consideration that I desired a stable home, Alahverdian said. But when I appraised lawmakers of what was going on in these households, I began to be looked at by some as a lobbyist. In response, Alahverdian resigned from his job as an aide at the State House and became a lobbyist. He founded a group called NexusGovernment to champion reforms to Rhode Islands child welfare services. But he said political authorities did not react to his activism favorably. In 2002, DCYF placed him in Nebraska and then in Florida. During this time, Alahverdian said he was not allowed to contact the police, attorneys, courts or anyone else. Both out-of-state facilities were subsequently shut down for abuse and neglect. Alahverdian returned to Rhode Island when he aged out of the childrens welfare system at 18. He has since filed suit against state officials for knowingly allowing instances of

abuse to continue and for conspiring to prevent him from working with lawmakers to reform the system. DCYF did not return The Heralds requests for comment. DaSilvas bill would force courts to go through a step-by-step process to ensure children are kept in Rhode Island facilities before resorting to out-of-state placement options. The way theyve been doing the placement of children outside the state, I think, is fundamentally wrong, DaSilva said. The bill is currently under consideration by the House Judiciary Committee but has not moved to a floor vote. I have no idea why this bill hasnt made it out of committee, DaSilva said. It doesnt cost us a dime. In fact, itll save us money. With more children kept at instate facilities, millions of tax dollars will be saved from outsourcing services to contractors, and more Rhode Islanders will keep their jobs, DaSilva said. Alahverdian said a primary obstacle to the bills passage is the view of some union officials that the legislation portrays social service employees as inept and incapable of meeting their responsibilities. He said he feels DCYF employees are trying to do their jobs but are overburdened, which he hopes will no longer be the case if DaSilvas bill clears the State House. Alahverdian said he hopes DCYF makes the changes necessary to ensure the things that have happened to me wont happen to anyone else.



Taveras seeks state assistance in ongoing budget negotiations

Providence Mayor Angel Taveras announced last week that the city may be forced to file for bankruptcy unless the budget deficit $22.5 million for this year and $30 million for the 2012-2013 fiscal year is closed by June. He called for large nonprofits like the University to increase their voluntary contributions to the city and for retirees to renegotiate their benefits packages. That afternoon, Gov. Lincoln Chafee 75 P14 arranged a meeting between Taveras, President Ruth Simmons and Chancellor Thomas Tisch 76. The citys negotiations with the University regarding its payments to the city allegedly stalled at the end of last year when Taveras requested that the University increase its annual payments to the city by $4 million per year and rejected the Universitys counter-offer of $2 million per year. A day after the press conference detailing the citys budget crisis, Taveras enlisted the aid of Robert Flanders Jr. 71, who served as state receiver for Central Falls last year when the city was facing bankruptcy, according to an article in the Providence Journal. Taveras hired the law firm of Hinckley, Allen & Snyder to advise the city after meeting with Flanders Friday. Taveras met with Chafee Monday to brief him on the citys budget crisis. He said concessions from tax-exempt institutions and retirees would provide $15.1 million, but this would still leave a significant hole in the budget, the Journal reported. After hearing arguments from both sides yesterday, the state Supreme Court is slated to release a ruling today that would decide whether the city can force hundreds of retirees to move from the citys blue Cross health insurance plan to Medicare, according to the Journal. Taveras has said the change could save the city $8 million. Taveras is slated to meet with retirees in March to discuss freezing cost-of-living pension adjustments for the next 10 years. He called recent 5 and 6 percent payment increases unsustainable, according to the New York Times.