HUL's Pureit took on the competition in 2009 inviting a reprisal from Eureka Forbes. Hostilities were suspended only after HUL threatened to sue Eureka Forbes for running a commercial that denigrated its product. Kent RO has sounded the bugle claiming it will soon overtake Eureka Forbes to become market leader. It provoked Eureka Forbes into an all-out brawl by alleging that its products are prone to leakage and technical snags. Kent is the second largest water purifier brand in the country, and claims leadership of the RO (reverse osmosis, a water purification technique) segment with over 40% market share. It will have you believe Eureka doesn't possess reliable international certifications such as NSF and WQC. "They did try to get certification, but their product couldn't meet the parameters," says Mahesh Gupta, managing director, Kent RO. Besides, Kent claims Eureka Forbes with its focus on UV based purifiers, is not future ready. Says Gupta, "Kent will be an undisputed leader in next few years as the UV segment is fast declining. Eureka Forbes has hit back, claiming undisputed leadership of RO and UV categories. "That Kent is a leader in RO is absolute hogwash," says Marzin Shroff, CEO (direct sales) and senior VP (marketing), Eureka Forbes.
Eureka Forbes in turn claims to sell water purifiers in a more responsible manner, not pushing the more expensive RO models on consumers who don't need them. According to Shroff, Eureka Forbes has a 44% share in RO segment and 71% in UV segment. Overall its market share is 53%. "So, is their UV more effective or are they just minting money by selling an obsolete technology? The fight between Kent and Eureka Forbes is set to intensify as the water purifiers become a Rs6,100 crore category in the next four years, according to a recent report by research firm Market Pulse. The report titled 'Opportunities in the Water Purifier Market in India' said that the market for RO purifiers would grow to more than 3 million units in 2017 from its present size of 7,86,000. Kent is clearly pursuing a challenger brand strategy, according to marketing experts. "Kent is the Pepsodent of the water purifier market," says Harish Bijoor, who runs an eponymous brand consultancy firm. "It's now confident enough to fight Eureka Forbes on its own turf."
There are two highgrounds to occupy in any brand fight. One is advertising imagery, and the other is in terms of distribution and service. Both these brands have one high-ground each, says Bijoor. "While Eureka Forbes is a frontrunner on sales, distribution and service, Kent is the fore-runner in the realm of advertising blitz and imagery."
When Eureka Forbes created the category, its model was built around direct contact. Kent contested this conventional wisdom, say experts. Sometimes knowledge and experience that help create success turn out to be a big weakness when market realities change.