Dalisay-Fabrero Reflection Assuming you were given by a scientist/inventor friend a highly innovative, complicated newly invented machine, aside from saying thank you what do you think the most appropriate thing to ask or do regarding said machine? The answer is simple. Follow his instructions. Follow the machine manuals instructions and the machine will work.
A manual is one required to know how this machine can work properly and appropriately. It contains the INSTRUCTIONS the every user needs.
How can the human machine this strange, lovable and complex machine called Man, with its mortal body and its eternal soul be made to function well? The answer is also simple: Follow the instructions of its Maker. Unless this is done, the human machine will become futile, senseless object, utterly incapable of fulfilling its destiny. These instructions from the maker we call the LAW Law defined on its Most Generic Sense Law may be defined in its most generic sense as an ordinance of reason promulgated for the common good by HIM who is in-charge. Law as defined in the Widest/Comprehensive term The term law means any rule of action or any system of uniformity.
Thus law in general determines not only the activities of men as rational beings but also the movement or motions of all objects of creation, whether animate or inanimate What is law? A definition: law is the system of control (i.e. a set of rules) through which society operates (i.e. citizens must obey or suffer a penalty) Law declares how we must behave and consists of those rules which are enforced through the legal system (particularly the courts) The system is more complex in reality as the rules are affected by social, economic, political and international considerations General Divisions of Law 1. Law (in the strict legal sense) which is promulgated and enforced by the STATE Example STATE LAW 2. Law (in the non-legal sense) which is not promulgated by the State Example Divine law, natural law, moral law and physical law
General Divisions of Law State law, divine law, natural law and moral law are comprised in the definition of law as RULE OF ACTION. These laws apply to rational beings only.
Physical law operates on all things including men without regards to the latters use of Will power and intelligence. It is Called law only in figurative sense. DIVINE LAW This law refers to the law of religion and faith and focuses with the concept of SIN.
It is under the field of philosophical theology DIVINE LAW Law is promulgated by GOD and revealed to mankind by means of direct revelation.
The sanction of divine law lies in the assurance of certain rewards and punishment in present life to come. Example: Divine law under the Old Testament is embodied in the Ten Commandments. To the Mohammedans, divine law is embodied in the Quoran. NATURAL LAW Natural law may be defined as the divine inspiration in mans sense of justice, fairness and righteousness not by divine revelation but by mans internal dictates of reason alone.
There is in every man a basic understanding of right and wrong based on an understanding of the fundamental standard or criterion of good and evil. NATURAL LAW There are some acts or conduct which man knows in his heart and his conscience not by theorizing by dictates of his moral nature are simply good or bad or evil. Natural is impressed in man as the core of his higher self at the very moment of being or perhaps even before that, It is regarded as the reasonable basis of STATE LAW and belongs to the field of METAPHYSICS.
MORAL LAW Moral law represents the totality of the norms of good and right conduct growing out of the collective sense of right and wrong of every community.
The mores or ways of life were then evolved which were always considered right and correct and obedience to them may be demanded by the group. MORAL LAW Moral law has no definite legal sanction. If a member of the community disregards the moral norms, a spontaneous social reaction is produced in the form of public displeasure, contempt or even indignation. Moral law is not absolute as it varies with the changing times.
Moral law, to a great extent, influences or shapes STATE LAW and under the field of ETHICS. PHYSICAL LAW A physical law or scientific law is "a theoretical principle deduced from particular facts, applicable to a defined group or class of phenomena, and expressible by the statement that a particular phenomenon always occurs if certain conditions be present. A property of a physical phenomenon, or a relationship between the various quantities or qualities which may be used to describe the phenomenon, that applies to all members of a broad class of such phenomena, without exception. PHYSICAL LAW Over the years, one thing scientists have discovered is that nature is generally more complex than we give it credit for. The following laws of physics are considered fundamental, but many of them refer to idealized, closed systems, which are hard to obtain in the real world. Also, some are altered slightly in different circumstances. The laws that Newton developed, for example, are modified by the findings of the theory of relativity, but they are still basically valid in most regular cases that you'll run into. Other examples Newton's Three Laws of Motion Law" of Gravity:
CONCEPTS OF LAW Considered as a cause derecho is the abstract science of law; considered as an effect, it is the given.
Ley is a specific law.
Example : A student of law (derecho) studies specific laws (leyes).
STATE LAW State law means law that is promulgated by the State Other terms used POSITIVE LAW or HUMAN POSITIVE LAW, MUNICIPAL LAW, CIVIL LAW OR IMPERATIVE LAW As a rule of action, only the state can enforce it. STATE LAW IN ITS GENERAL SENSE State law is defined by the late Senator Arturo Tolentino (Also a civil law expert of the Philippines) as the mass of obligatory rules established for the purpose of governing the relations of persons in the society. Examples of use of law in these sense: rule of law and not of men; equality before the law STATE LAW IN ITS SPECIFIC SENSE State law in specific sense has been defined as a rule of conduct, just, obligatory, promulgated by legitimate authority and of common observance and benefits. (Sanchez Roman) State law or human positive law is a reasonable rule of action, expressly or indirectly promulgated by proper human authority for the common good and usually but not necessarily imposing a sanction in case of disobedience. STATE LAW IN ITS SPECIFIC SENSE Elements/Characteristics of State Law a. It is a rule of conduct comprising of reasonable rules of action b. It is obligatory there must be positive command imposing it as a duty. Usually but not necessarily carries with it sanctions to ensure obedience and compliance. STATE LAW IN ITS SPECIFIC SENSE c. It is promulgated by legitimate authority. Meaning the persons promulgating the law have the power to bind. While competency is ideally expected from person promulgating the law, this is not strictly the requirement for validity and enforceability of the law. d. It is of common observance or benefit It is one intended to serve man. It regulates relations of men to maintain harmony in the society. Why study law? To become a more effective business operator by: recognising and managing risks being aware of the law and the legal environment and how they impact on decision making To become a more resourceful consumer Everyone is presumed to know it, so it will be beneficial to know the basic concepts The law is a reflection of community values (Do you agree?) Law not only shapes the business environment, but is shaped by business Law, order, morality & justice Preservation of order within the community (e.g. road rules) Societys values: changing competing victimless crimes Fair treatment The rule of law NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW Is law necessary? 1. The Harm Principle Laws created under the Harm Principle are written to protect people from being harmed by others. Laws against violent crime and property crime fall into this category. Without basic Harm Principle laws, a society ultimately degenerates into despotism--the rule of the strong and violent over the weak and nonviolent. Harm Principle laws are essential, and every government on Earth has them.
NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW 2. The Parental Principle In addition to laws intended to discourage people from harming each other, some laws are written to prohibit self-harm. Parental Principle laws include compulsory attendance laws for children, laws against neglect of children and vulnerable adults, and laws banning the possession of certain drugs. Some Parental Principle laws are essential to protect children and vulnerable adults, but even in those cases they can be oppressive if they are not narrowly written and sensibly enforced.
NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW
3. The Morality Principle Some laws are based not strictly on harm or self-harm concerns, but also on promoting the personal morality of the law's authors. These laws are usually, but not always, grounded in religious belief. Historically, most of these laws have something to do with sex--but some European laws against Holocaust denial and other forms of hate speech also appear to be motivated primarily by the Morality Principle.
NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW 4. The Donation Principle All governments have laws granting goods or services of some kind to its citizens. When these laws are used to control behavior, however, they can give some people, groups, or organizations unfair advantages over others. Laws promoting specific religious beliefs, for example, are gifts that governments extend to religious groups in hopes of gaining their support. Laws punishing certain corporate practices are sometimes used to reward corporations that are in the government's good graces, and/or to punish corporations that are not. NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW 5. The Statist Principle The most dangerous laws are those intended to protect the government from harm, or to increase its power for its own sake. Some Statist Principle laws are necessary--laws against treason and espionage, for example, are essential to the stability of government. But Statist Principle laws can also be dangerous--laws restricting criticism of the government, such as flag burning laws that prohibit the desecration of symbols that remind people of the government, can easily lead to a politically oppressive society full of imprisoned dissidents and frightened citizens who are afraid to speak out.
NECESSITY AND FUNCTION OF LAW Functions Law secures justice resolves conflict orders society protects interest controls social relations
IN OTHER WORDS, NO SOCIETY CAN LAST AND CONTINUE WITHOUT MEANS OF SOCIAL CONTROL, WITHOUT RULES ON SOCIAL ORDER BINDING ON ITS MEMBERS Characteristics of the law: certainty People in both their personal and business lives should be able to: form relationships with others enter into contracts, such as those relating to marriage and the acquisition and disposal of property reasonably secure in their knowledge of what they are doing and their understanding of its effects Characteristics of the law: flexibility The law must be able to respond without undue delay to the challenge of change at all levels of society
Characteristics of the law: fairness The effectiveness of law depends upon its acceptance by members of society and that will not be available where a law is inequitable, unfair or unreasonable Characteristics of the law: accessibility All should have access to knowledge of the law, either directly or through intermediaries. [T]o bind the citizen by a law, the terms of which he has no means of knowledge, would be a mark of tyranny.
Sir Garfield Barwick, Watson v Lee (1979) 144 CLR 374 at 379 SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILIPPINES 1. Constitution the fundamental law of the law being deemed to be promulgated by the people themselves. All other legislations of the country must be in consonance with the Constitution. Present Constitution is the 1987 Philippine Constitution Define Constitution: written instrument by which the fundamental powers of the government are established, limited and defined and by which these powers are distributed among the several departments for their safe and useful exercise for the benefit of the people ( Malcolm and Laurel, Philippine Constitutional law) SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. 2. Legislation the legislative department of the Philippine is the CONGRESS comprising of the house of senate and the house of representatives. The laws passed by Congress are known as statutes or laws. Those laws passed by legislative bodies of the local government units such as Sangguniang Panlalawigan, Sangguniang Panglusod are known as ordinances
SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. 3. Administrative or executive orders, regulations and rulings Law making power legislative exercise Rule making power administrative exercise. If laws are passed by Congress, the executive body is mandated to enforce these laws. To guide the executive body in enforcement of these laws, the executive is duly empowered to pass rules and regulations governing the implementation of these laws. This is an exercise of its rule making power. Rules and regulations passed by the by, executive body are intended to clarify or explain the law and carry into effect its general provision. They must not be contrary to laws and the Constitution. SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. 4. Judicial decisions or jurisprudence SUPREME COURT it is the highest court of the law and is empowered to interpret the laws of the land. Jurisprudence refers to decisions of the Supreme Court on a particular case which are binding to all lower courts, meaning it must be made as guidance and applicable in rendering decision on cases of similar facts and circumstances to ensure uniformity in interpretation of the law. Decision of the Supreme Court on a particular issue is part of the legal system of the country. Decision of SC being binding to all lower courts is based on the doctrine of PRECEDENT or STARE DECISIS.
SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. Decision of the lower court binds only the parties of the case and not binding upon other courts rendering similar facts or circumstances. What is binding to lower courts would be the jurisprudence of the SC.
Be it noted that rulings of the SC is pro-active and dynamic. Meaning SC may reverse or modify its previous rulings and for this reason, judges and lawyers must be abreast of the changing character of the law and jurisprudence from time to time.
SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. 5. Customs- it consists of those habits and practices which through long and uninterrupted usage have become acknowledged and approved by society as binding rules of conduct. It has the force of law when recognized and enforced by law. A custom must be proved as fact according to the rules of evidence. (Art. 12, Civil Code)
SOURCES OF LAW IN THE PHILS. 6. Other sources Principles of justice and equity Decisions of foreign tribunals Opinions of text writers and religion. They are however only supplementary, that is, they are resorted to by the courts in the absence of all the other sources. They are, however, not binding on the courts.
RULES IN INTERPRETATION Our Civil Code provides that no judge or court shall decline to render judgment by reason of the silence, obscurity or insufficiency of the laws. (Art. 9, Civil Code)
In case of the doubt in the interpretation or application of laws, it is presumed that the law making body intended right and justice to prevail. (Art. 10)
In our country, courts are not only courts of law but also of justice. ORGAN OF SOCIAL LAW
Law is not an end in itself. It may be viewed as a means of SOCIAL CONTROL- the control of social behaviour that affects others.
SUPREME COURT ORGANIZATION OF COURTS COURT OF APPEALS COURT OF TAX APPEALS SANDIGAN BAYAN REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS JURISDICTION OF THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS/MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS Civil (1) Exclusive (EOJ) o Actions involving personal property valued at not more than 300K/400K o Actions demanding sum of money not exceeding 300K/400K Includes admiralty & maritime cases o Probate proceedings where gross value of estate does not exceed 300K/400K o Actions involving title/possession of real property where assessed value does not exceed 20K/50K o Provisional remedies in principal actions within their jurisdiction
o Summary Procedure Forcible entry and unlawful detainer Irrespective of amount of damages or unpaid rentals sought to be recovered Other cases where total of the claim does not exceed 100K/200K o Inclusion and exclusion of voters
JURISDICTION OF THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS/MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS (2) Delegated o Cadastral and land registration cases No controversy or opposition, and Contested lots valued at more than 100K
(3) Special o Petition for Habeas Corpus In the absence of all RTC judges
JURISDICTION OF THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS/MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS B. Criminal (1) Exclusive o Summary Procedure Violations of traffic laws, rules and regulations Violations of rental law Violations of city/municipal ordinances committed w/in territorial jurisdiction Offenses punishable with imprisonment of not more than 6 months, or a fine not exceeding 1K, or both Regardless of other impossible accessory or other penalties and civil liability arising therefrom Offenses involving damage to property through criminal negligence where imposable fine does not exceed 10K o Offenses punishable with imprisonment of not more than 6 years Irrespective of fine Regardless of other impossible accessory
JURISDICTION OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS CIVIL 1) Exclusive o Other cases where demand or value of property in controversy exceeds 300K/400K o Actions in admiralty & maritime jurisdiction where demand/claim exceeds 300K/400K o Probate proceedings where gross value of estate exceeds 300K/400K o Actions involving title/possession of real property where assessed value exceeds 20K/50K o Actions not capable of pecuniary estimation o Cases not falling within EJ of any court, tribunal, person or body exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions
JURISDICTION OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS o Under Securities & Regulation Code Devices or schemes employed by the board of directors, business associates, its officers or partnership, amounting to fraud or misrepresentation Controversies arising out of intra-corporate partnership relations Controversies in the election or appointment of directors, trustees, officers, or managers of such corporation, partnership or association Petition to be declared in a state of suspension of payments o Application for issuance of writ of search and seizure in civil actions for infringement of intellectual property o Violations of Anti-Money Laundering Act
JURISDICTION OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS B.Criminal (1) Exclusive o Not within the EJ of any court, tribunal, or body Offenses punishable with imprisonment of more than 6 years irrespective of fine Offenses not falling within EOJ of Sandiganbayan None of the accused is occupying a position corresponding to salary grade 27 and higher o Only penalty provided by law is a fine exceeding 4K o Jurisdiction to impose the maximum and most serious penalty imposable for an offense forming part of the complex crime
JURISDICTION OF THE COURT OF APPEALS A. Exclusive (1) Annulment of judgments of RTC (2) Petitions under Rule 65 involving an act or omission of a quasi-judicial agency
JURISDICTION OF SUPREME COURT A. Exclusive Petitions under Rule 65 against: o CA o COMELEC o COA o Sandiganbayan o CTA en banc o Ombudsman in criminal and non-administrative disciplinary cases
Classification of Law As to purpose a. Substantive law creates and defines rights and duties either public or private in character b. Adjective (procedural) law prescribes the manner or procedure by which rights or duties are enforced. Classification of the law: public law and private law Public law regulates the interaction of citizens with the state (e.g. criminal law, constitutional law, administrative law) Private law regulates the relationship between individuals within a state (e.g. Obligations and contracts law, tort law, property law) Public law administrative law constitutional law criminal law International law
Private law - CIVIL LAW (law on Obligations and Contracts, Property etc) - COMMERCIAL OR MERCANTILE LAW - CIVIL PROCEDURE Classification of the law: criminal law and civil law criminal law generally aims to punish
civil law generally aims to compensate
Classification of Law According to FORCE or EFFECT Mandatory ( absolute, imperative) and/or Prohibitive laws those which have to be complied with, because they are expressive of public policy; disobedience is punished either by direct penalties or by considering an act or contract void. Permissive (or suppletory) laws those which may be deviated from, if the individual so desires. ( In the case of hidden treasure the finder gets 50% and the owner of land on which it is found gets 50% (See 438) However by agreement the proportion can be changed. Civil law in the Philippines Most of our civil laws are found and codified in the Civil Code of the Philippines (REPUBLIC ACT NO. 386) which took effect on August 30, 1950.
The civil code contains 2270 articles.
Prior to the R.A. No. 386, the civil laws in the Philippines were based on the Old Civil Code of Spain of 1889 Civil law in the Philippines Meaning of Civil Law It is that branch of law that treats of the personal and family relations of an individual, his property and successional rights and the effects of his obligations and contracts. The word civil is derived from the Latin term civiles a citizen as distinguished from a savage or barbarian. Civil law in the Philippines While most of our laws are found in the Civil Code still the Civil Code is not the only place where we can find our civil laws. The Civil Code is a compilation of existing civil laws, scientifically arranged into books, titles, chapters and sub-heads and promulgated by the legislative authority. From time to time, legislations are added, modifying, amending or abandoning previous civil law(s). BOOKS OF THE CIVIL CODE OF THE PHILIPPINES Book I Persons ( as amended by the Family Code of the Philippines E.O No, 209) Book II Property, Ownership and Its Modification Book III- Different Mode of Acquiring Ownership Book IV Obligations and Contracts Other Parts 1) Preliminary Title 2) Human Relations 3) Transitional Provisions 4) Repealing Clause LAW ON OBLIGATIONS AND CONTRACTS This law is found in Book IV of Republic Act No. 386 or the New Civil Code of the Philippines. ARTICLES 1156 TO 1304 Law on Obligations (149 articles) ARTICLES 1305 TO 1422 Law on Contracts (118 articles) ARTICLES 1423-1430 - Natural Obligations (8 articles) Total of 275 articles to be taken up excluding law on damages ( 41 articles -Arts. 2195 to 2235) and new FRIA law (Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act)
LAW ON OBLIGATIONS AND CONTRACTS
Law on Obligations and Contracts: It is the body of rules which deals with the nature and sources of obligations and rights and duties arising from agreements and particular contracts. APPLICABILITY OF LAW Ignorantia juris non excusat or ignorantia legis neminem excusat (Latin for "ignorance of the law does not excuse" or "ignorance of the law excuses no one") It is a legal principle holding that a person who is unaware of a law may not escape liability for violating that law merely because he or she was unaware of its content. Under the Philippine laws, there is conclusive presumption that everyone knows the law. This is to give effect to the so called FORCE OF LAW.