Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION TO
ACCOUNTING THEORY
A152
BKAF3083
1
1
BKAF3083
2
3
3
4
4
Not only was the name of buyer or seller recorded, as well as the
description of the goods with its weight, size or measurement, price and term of
payment
The receive or disburse, the record was shown of the kind of currency and its
converted value.
BKAF3083
5
5
Development of accounting
BKAF3083
6
6
Pragmatic Accounting
18001955
General scientific period
theory based on observations of practice rather
than deductive logic that is critical in current practice.
Overall framework to explain why accountants
account as they do
Wall Street Crash (1929), lead to creation of Securities
& Exchange Commission
Lead to improve financial regulation & reporting
1930s give rise to several notable accounting
publications (A Tentative Statement of Accounting
Principles affecting corporate reports)
BKAF3083
7
7
Policy
Better understanding on accounting problems & their institutional context as
well as the formulation of the public policy
Practice
Better assessment of the existing practice by a comparison method used in
the past.
BKAF3083
8
8
BKAF3083
9
9
10
11
11
Definition of Accounting
Belkaoui (2004);
Accounting is the art of recording, classifying, & summarizing in a
significant manner & in terms of money, transactions, & events which are,
in part at least, of a financial character, & interpreting the result thereof.
(AICPA)
Quantitative information;
Accounting is a service activity. Its function is to provide quantitative
information, primarily financial in nature about economic entities that is
intended, to be useful in economic decisions, in making resolve choices
among alternative course of action.
12
12
13
14
14
Definition of Theory
Popper, K (1968) ,The Logic of
Scientific Discovery-emphasizes
empirical nature of the theory rather
than logicalTheories are nets cast to catch what we
call the world, to rationalize, to explain
and to master it
15
15
15
Hendriksen (1970):
1the coherent set of hypothetical,
conceptual and pragmatic principles
forming the general framework of
reference for a field of inquiry.
2logical reasoning in the form of a set
board principles(1) provide a general
framework of reference by which acctg
practices can be evaluated and guided
the development of new practices and
procedures.
16
16
16
17
17
17
Belkaoui (2000)
..a set of interrelated constructs
(concepts),definitions, and propositions
that present a systematic view of
phenomena by specifying relations
among variables with the purpose of
explaining and predicting the
phenomena.
18
18
18
19
19
BKAF3083
19
A. Theory as Language
As language as business
Three question that should asked
about language, word, phrases
What effect will the words have on
listeners?
What meaning, if any, do the words
have?
Do the word make logical sense?
20
20
20
21
21
21
i. Pragmatics
This relation pertains to the effect of words
or symbols on people
How acctg concepts, and their real world
corresponding events or objects, affect
people behaviour.
How people react to the same message in
different way-acctg standard-support &
lobbying
The relation of signs to users of those
signs
22
22
22
23
23
Pragmatic theories
Descriptive pragmatics
observe behavior of accountants
no logical assessment of actions
does not allow for change
Psychological pragmatics
observe reactions of users
24
24
ii. Semantics
25
25
Premise 1:
Premise 2:
account.
Conclusion:
balance.
26
26
27
27
28
28
B. Theory as Reasoning
The debate whether the theory is
argument flow:
General to specific (deductive).
Acctant usually deduce acctg principles
or postulates to provide concrete
applications or rules
Specific to General (inductive).
Acctg principles are induced from the
best current practice.
29
29
29
i. Deductive Reasoning
Example,
P1: All asset accounts have debit
balances.
P2: The cash account is an asset account
C : The cash account has a debit balances
31
31
32
Example,
P1: The cash account is an asset account and has
a debit balance.
P2: The Vehicles account is an asset account and
has a debit balance.
P3: The land account is an asset account and has
a debit balance.
C : All asset accounts have debit balances
P1, P2, &P3 is so specific for each account. C is
generalization from all P.
33
33
C. Theory as Script
The theory may be
To set forth and explain what and how
financial information is presented and
communicated to users of acctg data
(descriptive or positive)
To prescribed what data ought to be
communicated and how they ought to
be presented. (prescriptive or
normative)
34
34
i. Normative (prescriptive)
1950s & 60s
Explain more on what should be
done rather than what is i.e.
analyzing & explaining accepted
practice
Attempts to discover the best way of
accounting for a transaction & useful
in making decision.
35
35
36
TESTING A THEORY
Criteria of truth
Dogmatic basis
believe what we read
Self-evident basis
Reasonableness
Scientific basis
Syntactic
(logical reasoning)
and
induction (refer
to empirical evidence)
37
37
Criteria of truth
Scientific basis
Popper (try & error: hypothesis & proposition) and
falsification (all hypothesis must be capable of
falsification, if no; there is no informative & doesn't not add
to scientific progress)
Research programs
(encourage discovery of
solutions, involving try & error, able to change)
Feyerabends approach
38
38
39
39
40
40
41
42
43
44
45
1
2
3
4
5
46
The
The
The
The
The
Traditional Approach
Regulatory Approach
Positive Approach
Behavioral Approach
Paradigm Approach
46
47
48
48
49
49
50
However;
The approaches have been largely
unsuccessful in reaching satisfactory
conclusions in their attempt to construct
an AT.
For example; balance sheet approach &
profit-oriented; pragmatic & authoritarian
approach absence on theoretical
foundation.
51
51
52
52
53
54
54
55
56
Note;
The general proposition formulated
through inductive process
Principles & technique from deductive
process
e.g.; Paton (deductive theorist) &
Littleton (Inductive theorist)
57
57
58
For example:
59
59
60
61
62
63
63
CONTINUE TO SECOND
APPROACH..
64
64
THE REGULATORY
APPROACH
65
65
66
67
68
69
69
70
70
71
72
73
74
76
77
77
78
79
79
80
81
81
82
Disadvantages
The AASB lacks statutory authority and
faces the challenge of being overridden by
government
The AASB has been accused of lacking
independence from dominating interests,
such as the accounting profession
The AASB has often been accused of
responding too slowly to major issues that
are of crucial importance to some of its
constituents
83
83
Arguments in favor:
The ASIC acts as creative irritant and as a
catalyst for change, since the private sector
and market forces do not provide the
leadership necessary to effect such change
The structure of securities regulation
established by the 1991 Corporations Law
serves to protect investors against perceived
abuses
84
84
85
86
Arguments against:
There is a high corporate cost for
compliance with government regulation of
information
Bureaucrats have a tendency to maximise
the total budget of their bureau
There is the danger that standard setting
may become increasingly politicised
Government regulation backed by police
power may hinder the conduct of research
and experimentation of accounting policy
and is not essential to achieving
standardisation of measurement
86
87
88
88
90
90
93
98
98
Income smoothing
Propositions on income smoothing
1. The criterion a corporate management
uses to select among accounting
principles is the maximisation of its
utility or welfare
2. The utility (effectiveness) of management
increases with:
job security
the level and rate of growth in
managements income
the level and rate of growth in the
corporations size
99
99
100
100
101
101
102
102
103
103
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
104
adequacy of disclosure
usefulness of financial statement data
attitudes about corporate reporting practices
materiality judgements
linguistic effects of alternative accounting
procedures
104
105
106
106
113
114
114
LAST.COMBINED ANY 1
TO 4
11
5
115
Accounting Paradigms
116
121
The
The
The
The
The
Conclusion
12
7
127
As a conclusion;
No single governing theory of acctg is rich
128
theory)
3. Survive of various test
4. Demands from practice
.No necessarily adopt the same steps;
theorists ???
129
130