ASN (RDA)

CHIEF ENGINEER

Naval CEE
Presented to
WMA INCOSE

14 May 2002

Dr. Harry E. Crisp

Director, RDA CHENG Naval CEE
 Topics
 Naval CEE Purpose
 RDA CHENG Website
 Collaborative Engineering Data Resource
 Integrated Engineering Environment
 Summary

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 2 11/04/21

 Naval CEE Purpose
 To provide an integrated digital
environment that:
– Enhances the cooperation and exchange of
data, information, and knowledge among
Naval stakeholders engaged in ------ activities
directed toward assuring integrated and
interoperable Naval force systems.
– Enables the integration and interoperability of
Naval force systems across the spectrum of
the Naval acquisition process.

Based on Both E-Business and E-Systems Engineering Capabilities

Naval CEE Terms of Reference,
4 January 2001
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 3 11/04/21
 Collaboration Capabilities
Activities Alternatives

Formal Reviews Markups

Formal Comment Documents
Interactive Electronic Comments

Discussions and Interactions Telephone

Meetings
Video Teleconferences
Threaded E-Discussions
Data Transfer Mail (Documents, Briefings, Reports)
E-Mail
Centralized Repository

Technical Manual
Standalone Tools
Enterprise Environment

Security Enforcement Physical

Electronic
Access Control
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 4 11/04/21
 Naval Collaborative Engineering Environment

OPNAV ASN RDA LiveLink

CHENG
PHASEConcept
DRIVERS Exploration
Engineering
Demonstration Production
/
& Manufacturing
Validation Upgrade
&
Deployment
and
Definition & Development Replace
nt

10
1000
100 MGMT

Joint
Jan Apr Jul Oct

Outlook
SYSCOMS Services
ServerPHASEConcept
DRIVERS
Engineering
Demonstration
Exploration
Validation
Definition
/ Production
& Manufacturing

100 MGMT
1000
10
Deployment
& Developmentand
&
Upgrade

nt Replace

Jan Apr Jul Oct

DSC

Integrated Decision
PEOs/
Engineering
Environment PMs NAVAL CEE Fleet Support
Environment
Coalition CINCs
• Classified/Unclassified
Partners • Leverage Existing
Connectivity Infrastructure
• Information Assurance • NMCI Reliance
Existing Distributed
Requirements
Database
Information Repository
Interoperability Data
REQ

Repository
Logical Structural / HME
SPEC REQ
CONCEPTUAL SPEC Logical Structural / HME

CONCEPTUAL

Other
Repository
REQ
Logical
Management and Analysis
SPEC Structural / HME

CONCEPTUAL

Classified and Unclassified Connectivity to Enable Stakeholder Collaboration

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 5 11/04/21
 Naval CEE Website “Portal”
User Workspaces

Netmeeting

Livelink
Tool A
Interchange Tool B
Tool C
Database A
CEDAR Database B
Database C
Mix of Web-Based and Client/Server Technologies
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 6 11/04/21
 RDA CHENG Website

Keep team members

informed Share information
Collaborate

Keep track of upcoming

events

Access data
and tools

Monitor status of team

action items

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 7 11/04/21

 Collaborative Engineering Data Resource

User
• Answer a Question
Space
User

• Browse Repositories

INFORMATION
Graphical User Environment
NCEE Functional Space

Work Space Exploration Layer Toolbox User Access

CHENG DB • Per user, project Meta Data Cross Reference • “plug-ins” Support
• Provides export Index • Interchange
• Includes local DB Graphical Navigation Aid • MS Office On-Line
• Share Data
Help

Web Interface : Web Pages with Content on Resources

DATA
NAVAIR (IDR) NAVSEA (AMPS) MARCOR (MSTAR) SPAWAR (VPO)
Web Interface Web Interface Web Interface Web Interface
Data Resource

Web pages Server pages

Web pages Application Server pages
•Navigation
Space

•Navigation •Navigation •Navigation •Structure

•Structure •Structure •Structure •Access
•Access •Access •Access
•Content
DB (Oracle) DB
Word (.DOC) Files Excel Spreadsheets

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 8 11/04/21

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 9 11/04/21
 IDR Overview

Authorita-
tive Data

Program
Links

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 10 11/04/21

 IDR - Authoritative Data

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 11 11/04/21

 IDR - Authoritative Data (cont.)

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 12 11/04/21

 IDR - Program Links

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 13 11/04/21

 Integrated Engineering Environment

Requirements Functional
Analysis Analysis Object
Modeling CORE Analysis
DOORS
& Simulation ROSE
NSS

Sharepoint
Existing Server
Database
Engin eering
PHASEConcept oDemonstration
Explo ratiVal /Producti
n & Manufacturi Upgrade
on &
n go yment
DRIVERS Defi

Object
n ition id atio&nD eveloDepl
pment and
nt Repla ce

1000
100 MGMT
10

Server
REQ
Jan Apr Jul Oct

LiveLink
Logical Structural / HME
SPEC
CONCEPTUAL

Server
PHASEConcept
DRIVERS Explo ration
Defin itioVal
Enginoeering
Demonstrati nProducti
/ n g oUpgrade
& Manufacturi
n id atio&nDevelDepl oand
o pment
n&
yment
Repla ce
nt

100 MGMT
1000
10
Jan Apr Jul Oct

Human
Systems
Risk Analysis Integration
TRIMS Physical IPME
Cost Analysis
Design
VAMOSC
ENVISION/ERGO
COMET

Provides for a Seamless Flow of Information Between Tools

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 14 11/04/21
 Interchange Overview
Agent Repository Schema
Viewer Builder Query Builder Administration Editor

 An Object Oriented Information

Infrastructure Engineering Tools
 Integrates tools and processes
into a central engineering
repository
Cost Tools

Tool Plug-in
 Provides access to a common Interchange
system design representation Server
 Facilitates data sharing and design
configuration management Project
Management
 Interrelate data between
applications in different domains

The Power To Integrate, Coordinate and Collaborate

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 15 11/04/21
 C4ISR Architecture Framework
Guidelines and Process for Developing Architectures That
Are Consistent, Comparable, and Integrable

Operational Technical
Identifies Warfighter Identifies Standards
Information Needs and Conventions

Framework Standards
Standards and
Criteria
and
High Level Op Concept
Systems Technical
Technical Forecasts
Forecasts
Command
Command Relationships
Relationships
Overlays Capabilities and
Activity Model Characteristics on Requirements
Information Exchange
Matrix
Matrix Overlays to NCD
Required
Required Capabilities
Capabilities
Matrix System Element
Matrix
Interface Diagram
Node Connectivity
Diagram (NCD) System Performance
Parameters
Parameters
System
System Evolution
Evolution
Diagram

Decision
Decision Makers
Makers and
and Operators
Operators are
are Critical
Critical Elements
Elements
of
of the
the Overall
Overall Architecture
Architecture
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 16 11/04/21
 Using Architectures in Systems
Engineering
Operational Concept OV-1 High-level Operational Concept Graphic
Lesser
OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity Description
DRM The Role of Engineering and Technology OV-3 Operational Information Exchange Matrix
OV-1 OpSits OV-4 Command Relationships Chart
OV-5 Activity Model
OV-4 Greater
OV-6C Operational Event/Trace Description
TTP OV-5 SV-1 System Interface Description
SV-2 Systems Communication Description
SV-3 Systems Matrix
System Functional Mapping SV-4 System Functionality Description
1st Order Analysis: SV-5 Operational Activity to System Function
Traceability Matrix
SV-3 OV-3 Functionality--
SV-6 System Information Exchange Matrix
SV-4 SV-7 System Performance Parameters Matrix
SV-8 System Evolution Description
SV-5 SV-9 System Technology Forecast
SV-10 System Activity Sequence & Timing
TV-1 Technical Architecture Profile
System Interface Mapping TV-2 Standards Technology Forecast
2nd Order Analysis: FoS/SoS Evolution
OV-2 SV-1 TV-1 Static Interoperability
M: Design Reference Mission
Sit: Operational Situation
SV-8
P: Tactics, Techniques, Procedures TV-2
S: Family of Systems OV-3 SV-2 SV-6
S: System of Systems SV-9
Note: There are dependencies between the Architecture
products that are not shown in the System Architecture Performance
Engineering flow. Many of the products are and Behavior
developed concurrently.
OV-6C
Architectures SV-7 3rd Order Analysis:
Architectures Provide
Provide the
the Framework
Framework for
for Executable Dynamic Interoperability
FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition
FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition SV-10
Model
Rev 4 * 22 Apr 02
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 17 11/04/21
 Integrated Engineering Environment
SE Process & Products
Requirement Architecture
Documents Information
SPG Requirement Authoritative Experimental
MNS Analysis Tool Data
ORD Data Bases System Data Architecture
SPD Structured
Interface Representation
Data
Requirements
CEDAR
DOORS Operational
View
Rational System View
Rose
Technical
Function
Project DIAD
Information Function JMAAT
View

Activity Analysis Tool Repository Interchange

Model
Functional
(Server) Mission Analysis
Functional
Model Baselines
Simulation
Model
CORE
• Life Cycle Traceability NSS
• Change Agent Notification
• System Representation LSSE
• Configuration Management Analysis
Physical • Tools Integration
Implementation Design COPAT
Information
Synthesis RAB
RCA
Systems Spec

Resource TRIMS
Constraint M&S
Interchange COST MODELS
Client HSI
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 18 11/04/21 CAD/CAM
 Application of Architecture Views & Tools to
Systems Engineering
Operational Model
Requirements
• Requirement Documents
Analysis • Activity Timing, Inputs & Outputs
OV-1 OV-3 OV-5
(DOORS, CORE, • Activity Resource Utilization
CEDAR) • Execution Logic
OV-2 OV-4 • OV-6a, OV-6b, OV-6c, OV-7

Functional Model
Interchange

Functional • Control Logic

SV-4 SV-5 • Functional Resource Utilization
Analysis • Functional Timing & Data Flows
(CORE) • Conditional Logic (Failure
SV-7 Conditions, Fault Detection)
• SV-10a, SV-10b, SV-10c

Physical (Design) Model

Design Synthesis • Interface Design/Control (SV-11)
SV-3 SV-1 TV-1
(CORE) • Effectiveness Models
• FMECA/RAM Analysis
• Dynamic Reconfiguration
SV-2 SV-6
• Ownership Cost Analysis

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 19 11/04/21

 Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow
Current
Operational Systems Architecting Systems Engineering
Architecture

Capstone Executable
Requirements Operational OV-1, OV-2, OV-3, Operational
Operational Concept OV-4, OV-5, OV-6
Document Model
Analysis

System ORDs
Navy Standard System Functional Establish
Functional Mapping SV-4, SV-5 Activity Time-
Requirements Hierarchy line (Budget)
Analysis

Functional Models
Data Calls
Logical Allocate
System SV-1, SV-7 Activities to Sys.
Functional
Specifications, Interface Functions
ICDs Mapping
Analysis (Budget)
Physical (Design)
Systems Models
Interfaces SV-1, SV-2, SV-3,
Mapping SV-6, SV-11, TV-1 Develop System
Design Alternatives
Synthesis Assess (Perf. Budgets)
Technology SV-9, TV-2
Roadmap
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 20 11/04/21
 Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow
(Continued)
Systems Interfaces
Mapping Systems Architecting Systems Engineering
Assess Technology
Roadmap
Architecture Executable
Performance and SV-10
SOS Model
Behavior
Interoperability
Analysis
Systems Program Plans,
Analysis Budgets,
Assess Alternative
Milestones
Cost/Effectiveness

OV-1 SV-8
Establish Capability Finalize Design
Evolution Roadmap SV-8
Capability Solution(s)
Strategic
Planning
Program Alignment

Update Capstone
Requirements
Document
Recommended
Acquisition Strategy
(CV-6)
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 21 11/04/21
 SE Data and Products
Information Naval CEE Function Outputs/ Integrated Database
Integrated Force CRD
Systems Requirements
Force Systems
Operational Objectives
Force Systems C4ISR
Arch. Framework CRD/SRD
Capture Force Systems Views
Force Systems Information in Data Base
Characteristics Integrated Force
Management System Systems Performance SPD
Specifications
Force Systems Interchange Force Systems
Performance Profile (Server) SPD
Operational Functions

Platform/System O&M Platform/System SPD

Cost Interfaces/ICDs
Profile
Platform/System
Manning & Task SPD
Platform/System • Life Cycle Traceability Profiles
Manning • Change Agent Notification
Profile • System Representation Platform/System
• Configuration Management Ownership Costs Over CED
• Tools Integration Time
Platform/System
C4ISR Info. Force Systems
Views Effectiveness & TEMP
MOEs/MOPs
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 22 11/04/21
 Data Integration Flow
DOORS
InterchangeSE Repository

Requirements Model

Operational Model (OVs)

Word,
PowerPoint, Functional Model (SVs)
Excel, DIAD, ..

Behavior Model

Physical Model

CORE
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 23 11/04/21
 Naval CEE Infrastructure Overview
NAVAIR NAVSEA Conferencing Tools
NUWC
MARCORP

Outlook
Existing Server ConceptDemonstrati
PHASEExplo ratiVali
DRIVERS Defini
Engin eerin g
o n Producti
/ n g Upgrade
o n & Manufacturi
t io n d atio&nD eveloDepl
on &
oand
yment

Object
pment
nt Repla ce

Database 100 MGMT

1000
10

REQ
SPEC
Logical
CONCEPTUAL
Structural / HME
LiveLink
Jan Apr Jul Oct

Server
Server PHASEConcept
DRIVERS Val
Defin ition
Enginoeeri
Demonstrati
Explo ratio nidati / n g Upgrade
nProduction
& oManufacturing
&nDeveloDepl oand
pment yment
&
Repla ce
nt

100 MGMT
1000
10
Jan Apr Jul Oct

CHENG
Document & Object
Server Remote Access
SPAWAR
NSWCDD
JHUAPL
Engineering Tools Management Tools

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 24 11/04/21

 Summary
 Modern Information Technology Provides Capabilities
to Deal with Force Systems Complexity.
– Configuration Management and Control of Force Systems
Architectures and Their Evolution Over Time.
– Support for Geographically Distributed Teams Involved in
Acquisition Management and Engineering Analysis.

 Processes, Methods and Tools are Available to Move

Network Centric Warfare Off the View Foils and Into
Acquisition!

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 25 11/04/21

 Discussion

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 26 11/04/21

 DOORS Overview
• Requirements management tool
• Capture text requirements
• Track requirement changes
• Documents-to-document linking
• Inter-project linking
• Easy to use and access
• Web-access utilizing DOORSnetTM
• Drag-and-drop linking that create relationships
• Built-in graphics for display of statistics and metrics
• Filters on all data for faster access to specific information
• Color-coded change bars
• Imports/Exports
• Microsoft Word
• RTF
• Interleaf
• Framemaker(R)
• Text
• Spreadsheets
• HTML

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 27 11/04/21

 CORE Overview
OPERATIONAL MODEL  Allows system engineers to capture, analyze and
verify design integrity before problems embed
themselves in the system
FUNCTION HIERARCHY  Support C4ISR architecture framework
 Extensive behavior modeling notations representing
control flow, function flow, data flow, resource
BEHAVIOR MODEL utilization and interface-link capacity
 System simulations automatically synchronized with
IMPLEMENTATION behavior models
(PHYSICAL) MODEL
 Comprehensive traceability
 System documentation generated directly from the
database as a by-product of the engineering effort
SIMULATION RESULT

RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 28 11/04/21