You are on page 1of 22

Literary Criticism

Lecture one:

Classical Literary Criticism


PLATO

Literary Criticism
Literary criticism is the study, discussion, evaluation,
and interpretation of literature.
It includes the classification by genre, analysis of
structure, and judgement of value.
It asks what literature is, what it does, and what it is
worth.

Lecture One: Plato

Literary Criticism
In other words, literary criticism is the method used to
interpret any given work of literature.
The different schools of literary criticism provide us with
lenses which reveal important aspects of the literary
work.
Literary criticism helps us to understand what is
important about the text: its structure, its context (social,
economic, historical), what is written, and how the text
manipulates the reader.
Lecture One: Plato

Literary Criticism
It helps us to understand the relationship between
authors, readers, and texts.
The act of literary criticism ultimately enhances the
enjoyment of our reading of the literary work.

Lecture One: Plato

Classical Literary Criticism


The story of Western literary criticism begins in ancient
Greece with the great tragedies of Euripides, Aeschylus,
and Sophocles, and the comedies of Aristophanes.
During this time, poets, philosophers, rhetoricians,
grammarians, and critics laid down many of the basic
terms, concepts, and questions that were to shape the
future of literary criticism.
These terms and concepts evolved all the way through to
our own century.
Lecture One: Plato

Classical Literary Criticism


The first recorded instances of criticism go back to
dramatic festivals in ancient Athens.
A particularly striking literary critical discussion occurs
in Aristophanes play The Frogs, first performed in 405
BC.
By the time of Plato and Aristotle, poetry had achieved
considerable authority and status.

Lecture One: Plato

Classical Literary Criticism


In this course we will study two major Greek
philosophers and critics:
1. Plato
2. Aristotle

Lecture One: Plato

Plato
Plato was the student of Socrates.
He was the Greek philosopher who laid the foundations
of Western philosophy.
It is stated that Western philosophy is a series of
footnotes to Plato.
Plato gave initial formulation to the most fundamental
questions of literary criticism.
Most of Platos philosophy is expounded in dialogue
form.
Socrates is usually the main speaker in these dialogues.
Lecture One: Plato

Plato
Plato levels four accusations against poetry.
A.The falsity of the claims and representations of poetry
regarding both gods and men;
B. Poetry appeals to the weaker, inferior side of our
mind/soul (or psyche).
C.Poetry has a corruptive effect on character.
D.Poetry is a kind of madness or contagion
Lecture One: Plato

A. The falsity of the claims and representations of poetry


regarding both gods and men;
In the Republic, Plato views poetry as a falsifying
rhetorical activity and a danger to his ideal city.
In this text, Plato introduces his theory of Forms.
According to Plato, the physical world is not independent
or real.
It is dependent upon another world, the realm of pure
Forms or ideas.
Thus, any object in the physical world are derived from
the ideal Forms.
Lecture One: Plato

10

A. The falsity of the claims and representations of poetry


regarding both gods and men;
For Plato, our physical world is but a shadowy reflection
or imitation (mimesis) of the unseen world.
Plato metaphorically expresses his theory of Forms in
the seventh book of the Republic.
He recounts the myth of the cave where people have
lived all their lives watching shadows of reality cast by a
fire, with their backs to the true light of the sun.

Lecture One: Plato

11

A. The falsity of the claims and representations of poetry


regarding both gods and men;
Plato makes it clear that the cave in which men are
imprisoned represents the physical world, and that the
journey toward the light is the souls ascension to the
world of Forms.
Thus, everything in our world, from objects to ideas, is
but a pale copy of the perfect, unchanging originals
(Forms) of these objects and ideas that dwell above in
the unseen world.

Lecture One: Plato

12

A. The falsity of the claims and representations of poetry


regarding both gods and men;
When a poet describes a chair or writes a poem about
love, he is not imitating the Form of the chair or of love,
but the earthly imitation of this ideal Chair/Love.
Poetry, therefore, is twice removed from reality (the
Forms) because it imitates what is already an imitation,
Thus, it is an unreliable source of truth and can only
lead astray those who study it.

Lecture One: Plato

13

B.

Poetry appeals to the weaker, inferior


side of our mind/soul (or psyche).

In the Republic, Plato attacks poetry for being fanciful.


Philosophy or math engages our rational powers.
Unlike philosophy or math, poetry, being fanciful,
engages that part of our psyche that is both illogical and
irrational.
This irrational part of the soul is not only unreliable in
matters of truth but is disorderly unstable, inducing us
to partake in public displays of emotion.

Lecture One: Plato

14

C. Poetry has a corruptive effect


on character.

In the Republic, Socrates, the speaking persona, stresses


that poets must not present the gods as deceitful since
there is no lying poet in God.
Thus, Plato concludes that only hymns to the gods and
praises of state heroes will be allowed; all other forms of
poetry must be censored.

Lecture One: Plato

15

D. Poetry is a kind of madness or


contagion
In Ion, Socrates cross-examines a rhapsode (a singer and
interpreter) called Ion on the nature of his art.
Plato asserts that poets do not write nor rhapsodes
speak by art or skill, but by divine possession.
Socrates points out that the rhapsode, like the poet
himself, speaks not with his own voice which is merely a
medium through which a god speaks.

Lecture One: Plato

16

D. Poetry is a kind of madness or


contagion
The Muse inspires the poet, who in turn passes on this
inspiration to the rhapsode, who produces an inspired
emotional effect on the audience.
Socrates likens this process to a magnet, which transmits
its attractive power to a series of iron rings, which in
turn pass on the attraction to other rings, suspended from
the first set.
The Muse is the magnet, the poet is the first ring, the
rhapsode is the middle ring, and the audience the last
one.
Lecture One: Plato

17

D. Poetry is a kind of madness or


contagion
In this way, the poet conveys and interprets the utterances
of the gods, and the rhapsode interprets the poets.
Hence, the rhapsodes are interpreters of
interpreters.
Poetry, according to Socrates, is irrational and inspired

Lecture One: Plato

18

A Response to Platos Accusations


of Poetry:
Platos accusations levelled against poetry can be refuted.
A.Mimesis does not have to pull us farther away from
truth;
B. Poetry does not arouse the irrational side of our
psyche, but it purges it;
C.If poets are indeed possessed, so the gods are trying to
speak to us through them;
D.Plato is himself one of the greatest of poets.

Lecture One: Plato

19

A Response to Platos Accusations


of Poetry:
A. Mimesis does not have to pull us farther away from
truth;

Perhaps, poets do not imitate an imitation.


they capture in the physical form of the poem the invisible essence of the
Forms.

B. Poetry does not arouse the irrational side of our


psyche, but it purges it;

Our emotions are an essential part of our psyche;


So, it is best to release those emotions in a controlled, public
setting;
Thus, poetry can serve a therapeutic function to cleanse us of
excess emotion.
Lecture One: Plato
20

A Response to Platos Accusations


of Poetry:
C. If poets are indeed possessed, so the gods are trying
to speak to us through them;

The divine possession of poetry can be another way to rip away


the veil of ignorance and misperception in order to reveal truth.
Therefore, the poet can be as much a prophet as the philosopher.

Lecture One: Plato

21

A Response to Platos Accusations


of Poetry:
D. Plato is himself one of the greatest of poets.

Platos dialogues are themselves recognized as a unique literary


genre.
His dialogues are imaginative metaphors.
He presents his philosophical ideas metaphorically as in the
myth of the cave in the Republic, and the allegory of the
horseman in Phaedrus.
Platos ideal republic is itself a great poetic construct based on
fancy and imagination. It does not exist nor was it ever meant to.
It is merely a parable writ large: a way to uncover the nature of
justice.
Lecture One: Plato

22

You might also like