Copyright 2005 South-Western. All rights reserved. Organizational Change
Over past two decades, most organizations
have undergone change initiatives Success rate of change initiatives has been startlingly low; according to European execs: 20% of change initiatives were successful 63% produced some change that was not sustained 17% had no result at all
Copyright 2005 South-
Class Note: Organizational Change Western. All rights reserved. 82 Why Is Change So Hard? Human nature Organizational inertia Unanticipated consequences: Complexity of organizations (strategic designs, political systems, cultures) Interdependencies of structure and process, power and influence, values and identity
Copyright 2005 South-
Transparency 8.1 Western. All rights reserved. 83 Why Is Change Difficult? (contd)
Meanings of organizational change:
Change in organization design Organization chart, integration mechanisms, systems for motivating people Change in power structure Changes in who makes decisions, which individuals and groups influence decisions, what interests are served Change in culture Change in norms, values, mental models, shared assumptions about the organization and its environment
Copyright 2005 South-
Class Note: Organizational Change Western. All rights reserved. 84 Stage Models of Change Processes
Kurt Lewins model of organizational change:
Three-stage sequence: unfreezingchange refreezing Lewin saw organizations as social systems highly resistant to change because of: Human nature Organizational inertia Lewins work laid foundations of field of organizational development (OD) and other stage models Copyright 2005 South- Class Note: Organizational Change Western. All rights reserved. 85 Stage Models of Organizational Change
Copyright 2005 South-
Class Note: Organizational Change Figure 8.1 Western. All rights reserved. 86 Dimensions of Change Initiatives
Copyright 2005 South-
Figure 8.2 Western. All rights reserved. 87 The Myth of the Hero-CEO
Significant change only occurs when it is driven
from the top There is no point in going forward unless the CEO is on board Nothing will happen without top management buy-in
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. Readings: The Leadership of Profound Change 88 A Different View of Executive Leadership
Little significant change can occur if it is driven
only from the top CEO proclamations and programs rolled out from corporate headquarters are a great way to foster cynicism and distract everyone from real efforts to change Top management buy-in is a poor substitute for genuine commitment and learning capabilities at all levels in an organization
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. Readings: The Leadership of Profound Change 89 The Integrated Learning Process
Involve and engage all your employees, as well
as customers, partners, and suppliers Identify and transfer best practices from inside and outside the company Integrate these initiatives with key human resource practices Set stretch goals
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. Readings: Culture Change at General Electric 810 Lou Gerstner, Former CEO of IBM
Nobody likes change. Whether you
are a senior executive or an entry- level employee, change represents uncertainty and, potentially, pain. Who Says Elephants Cant Dance? p. 77
Copyright 2005 South-
Transparency 8.2 Western. All rights reserved. 811 Phillip Carroll, Former CEO of Shell Oil Company
Organizations are often less resistant
to change than people expect. Most managers and employees have the drive and capacity to put their ideas into action. But they get frustrated if their freedom to act and speak out is stifled. The Dance of Change, p. 205
Copyright 2005 South-
Transparency 8.3 Western. All rights reserved. 812 Acme Minerals Extraction Company: Underlying Causes of the Problems Strategic design What is the formal organizational structure? Political What is causing the conflicts among the internal stakeholders? Cultural How would you describe the organizational culture?
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 813 Acme Minerals Extraction Company
Copyright 2005 South-
Transparency 8.5 Western. All rights reserved. 814 What Steps Did Karen and Her Group Take in Wichita? Step 1: Monthly problem chats (voluntary) Step 2: SPITS teams (Select a Problem and Implement a Tailored Solution), cross-functional teams of 1215 Step 3: Baseball games between the brains and the brawn
Copyright 2005 South-
Transparency 8.6 Western. All rights reserved. 815 Why Were the Action Steps Successful?
The presence of Bill Keller as the local project
head The sequencing of the change initiative Patience Sense of crisis in Wichita facility Sense of shared ownership of problem solving Luck
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 816 Lubbock: Different Results
No one showed up at the monthly problem
chats, so the change team made them mandatory No one showed up to play baseball until they provided food and beer, but people seem to be coming to eat and drink with their own in-group, rather than getting involved They have formed cross-functional teams, but the results are disappointing
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 817 Lubbock: Different Problems
Different performance Lack of effective
issues localization Different expectations Goal displacement No Keller Karen No local stakeholders Daniels NIH (not-invented-here)
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 818 Actions Jimenez Should Take at Lubbock
Persuade Keller to move to Lubbock
Move other veterans of the Wichita initiative to Lubbock Find a Keller equivalent for Lubbock Build a local coalition Send some of the Lubbock operators and engineers/technicians to Wichita Set up a Change Day either at Wichita or at Lubbock Copyright 2005 South- Western. All rights reserved. 819 Actions Jimenez Should Take (contd)
Set up an advisory committee of locals to work
with the change team at Lubbock Replace the external consultants at Lubbock with an internal team Karen should go to Lubbock Daniels should go to Lubbock and support the initiative
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 820 Fostering Long-Term Change
Recognizing what needs to be localized and
what can be generic in the change initiative at each site Building a shared mental model of the change initiative among corporate management Identifying ways to leverage learning across the sites using a pull system to initiate information transfers and interactions
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 821 Closing Note: The Three Lenses
Strategic design lens
Performance and measurement Political lens Power and influence Cultural lens Meaning, trust, and identity
Copyright 2005 South-
Western. All rights reserved. 822 Stages in the Change Process at General Electric