Ethical Consequences Of Accelerating

Urbanization
Group 3
Bussiness Ethics, Law and Sustainability

15/01/2018 MBA ITB

Group members
Akhsanul amin 29117228
Astri Yuanita Herry P. 29117014
Fitriyanti 29117052
Unityasa Saleh 29117047

by
 Contents

Group Members Case Background Cost – Benefit Analysis Ethics Approach Conclusion

1 2 3 4 5

*This slide is using Font Awesome

your date here större - a multipurpose PowerPoint template 3

 CASE
BACKGROUND
 CASE BACKGROUND

Tragedy = terrorist
Government needs = Information from Apple’s
smartphone, that has to unlock
Apple Commitment that they don’t want to unlock

your date here större - a multipurpose PowerPoint template 5

COST – BENEFIT
ANALYSIS
Unlock : Unlock:
1. Reduce trust Unlock The 1. Help the investigation
worthiness Security process faster
2. Make the consumer feel 2. Government can gain
insecure the information to
anticipate the other
3. Think to using another crime
brand
3. Government will get
4. Decrease Apple’s COST – appreciate from the
revenue COST BENEFIT BENEFIT citizen
5. Decline Apple’s stock ANALYSIS 4. Apple will have good
value relationship with the
6. Reduce Apple’s market Government
share 5. Apple can work
7. Apple will break their together with the
commitment Government to open
new business market

your date here 7

Not to Unlock : Not to Unlock :
1. The investigation take Not to Unlock 1. Secure the consumer
more time to be solved the Security privacy
2. The company will have
bad reputation with the
government
3. There is a perception
indicates that Apple has
relation with the COST –
terrorist COST BENEFIT BENEFIT
4. Terrorist will be take the ANALYSIS
benefit from Apple
Policy

your date here 8

 ETHIC
APPROACHES
 ETHIC APPROACHES
ETHICS RELATIVISM:
A SELF – INTEREST APPROACH
Apple doesn’t have to
unlock the security code,
your date here större - a multipurpose PowerPoint template
UTILITARIANISM: A UNIVERSALISM: A
CONSEQUENTIALIST DEONTOLOGICAL (DUTY-
(RESULT-BASED) BASED) APPROACH
APPROACH
Both of Apple and Government can choose
Government have their other third parties to get
own right, we need to information they need
choose where the cost is legally and transparently,
less than the Benefit. instead of push Apple
*This slide is using Font Awesome
10
 Conclusion

Pemerintah tidak harus memaksa apple untuk unlock, karena

pemerintah dapat mencari informasi dari pihak yang lain. Sebagai
contoh dari pihak provider.
Akan tetapi jika pemerintah harus meminta apple untuk unlock, maka
apple harus membatasi informasi yang akan diberikan kepada
pemerintah.

your date here större - a multipurpose PowerPoint template 11