PRINCIPLES AND OTHER APPROACHES a. Teleological Approach • Telos (Greek) – goal or end
• “The right thing to do is the good thing
to do.”
• AKA: “act utilitarianism”
• Under act utilitarianism, the good resides in the promotion of happiness or the greatest net increase of pleasure over pain. JOSEPH FLETCHER • Proponent of “situational ethics” • Good is agape – the general goodwill or love for humanity • HUMAN NEED determines what is or what is NOT ETHICAL. ACT THAT HELPS PEOPLE = good act
ACT THAT HURTS PEOPLE = bad act
Fletcher’s Guidelines in Making Ethical Decisions • 1. consideration for people as human beings.
• 2. consideration of consequences.
• 3. proportionate good to come from the
choices. • 4. propriety of actual needs over ideal or potential needs.
• 5. a desire to enlarge choices and reduce
chance and
• 6. a courageous acceptance of the
consequences of the decision. b. Deontological Approach/Duty Oriented Theory • Deon (Greek) – “duty”
• Basic rightness or wrongness of an act
depends on the intrinsic nature rather than upon the situation or its consequences. IMMANUEL KANT • German philosopher. • “A person is a rational human being with freedom and social worth.”
• A moral person acts on a sense of “duty
and reason”. • Only through dutiful actions that people have moral worth.
• Even when individuals do not want to fulfill
their duty, Kant believes that they are required to do so. Kant’s CATEGORICAL IMPERATIVE
“Act only on that maxim by which you can at
the same time will that it should become a Universal law.” c. Virtue Ethics Approach • AKA: aretaic ethics • ARETE (Greek) – excellence, virtue
• FOCUS: traits and virtues of a good
person such as COURAGE, TEMPERANCE, WISDOM and JUSTICE. ALSO INCLUDES: • 1. right motivation • 2. right disposition • 3. right traits for being good • 4. doing right: courage, magnanimity, honesty, justice, beneficence. d. Divine Command Ethics • Based on the theory that there is a “Supreme or Divine Being” that sets down the rules to provide guidance to moral decisions.
• Religion based: Bible, Koran, Torah,
Bhagavad Gita END • QUIZ 1 (12/15/2018) • • 1. Define Ethics. How is ethics relevant to your future goal of becoming a nurse? (10 points) • 2. Explain Fletcher's Situational Ethics. Provide samples. (10 points) • 3. Explain Kant's Categorical Imperative. (10 points)