Chapter 4

Setting Portfolio Objectives

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Today s put-off objectives reduce tomorrow s achievements. - Harry F. Banks

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Outline
Introduction Why setting objectives can be difficult Portfolio objectives The importance of primary and secondary objectives Other factors to consider in establishing objectives Portfolio dedication
Prof. Rushen Chahal 3

Introduction
Setting objectives is important for every person and institution that uses financial planning
Too many investors have a casual attitude It is easy to be imprecise in communicating with the portfolio manager Gallup survey finds 39% believe stocks will return 15% annually for next ten year

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Introduction (cont d)
Pension and Investments article states importance of setting portfolio objectives:
Two factors contribute to a sponsor s successful investment program:
Suitable investment objectives and policy Successful selection of the investment managers to implement policy

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Why Setting Objectives Can Be Difficult

Semantics Indecision Subjectivity Multiple beneficiaries Investment policy versus investment strategy

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Semantics
Growth, income, return on investment, and risk mean different things to different people
E.g., a savings account provides income only; it has no growth potential There must be a clear understanding of the terms when entrusting money to a fund manager

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Semantics (cont d)
Interpretation of Principal and income
One interpretation is that principal is the original amount (accumulated interest is not included) Another interpretation is that accumulated interest is included in principal following the initial year

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Indecision
The client s inability to make a decision E.g., a bank customer wants to have interest compounded but have the interest send home each month

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Subjectivity
Investing is both an art and a science
There are inevitably shades of gray that involve subjective judgments E.g., which stocks are considered growth and which are considered income?

Prof. Rushen Chahal

10

Multiple Beneficiaries
Investment portfolios often have more than one beneficiary
E.g., an endowment fund has a perpetual life

It is possible to increase current income from the portfolio

Benefits today s beneficiaries May be at the expense of futures beneficiaries E.g., Social Security and federal unemployment insurance

Prof. Rushen Chahal

11

Investment Policy Versus Investment Strategy

Investment policy deals with decisions that have been made about long-term investment activities, eligible investment categories, and the allocation of funds among the categories
E.g., a pension fund decides never to place more than 30% in common stock

Prof. Rushen Chahal

12

Investment Policy Versus Investment Strategy (cont d)

Investment strategy deals with short-term activities that are consistent with established policy and that will contribute positively toward obtaining the objective of the portfolio
E.g., a managers may be required to maintain at least 30% equity by policy but decides to put 50% in the stock market because of a belief that the market will advance in the near future

Prof. Rushen Chahal

13

Portfolio Objectives
Preconditions Traditional portfolio objectives Tax-free income generation Portfolio objectives and expected utility

Prof. Rushen Chahal

14

Preconditions
Questions to be answered before setting objectives and formulating strategy:
Assess the existing situation
What are the current needs of the beneficiary? What is the investment horizon? Are there special liquidity needs? Are there ethical investing concerns established by the fund s owner or overseer?

Prof. Rushen Chahal

15

Traditional Portfolio Objectives

Stability of principal Income Growth of income Capital appreciation

Prof. Rushen Chahal

16

Stability of Principal
Emphasis is on preserving the original value of the fund
The most conservative portfolio objective Will generate the most modest return over the long run

Prof. Rushen Chahal

17

Stability of Principal (cont d)

Appropriate investment vehicles:
Bank certificates of deposit Other money market instruments

Prof. Rushen Chahal

18

Assessing Tax-Exempt Bonds

Prof. Rushen Chahal

19

Income
No specific proscription against periodic declines in principal value
E.g., a Treasury note may experience a decline in value if interest rates rise, but the investor will not experience a loss of he holds the note to maturity

Prof. Rushen Chahal

20

Income (cont d)
Appropriate investment vehicles:
Corporate bonds Government bonds Government agency securities Preferred stock Common stock

Prof. Rushen Chahal

21

Growth of Income
Benefits from time value of money
Sacrifices some current return for some purchasing power protection

Differs from income objective

Income lower in earlier years Income higher in later years

Prof. Rushen Chahal

22

Growth of Income (cont d)

Often seek to have the annual income increase by at least the rate of inflation Requires some investment in equity securities

Prof. Rushen Chahal

23

Growth of Income (cont d)

Example
Two portfolios have an initial value of $50,000. Interest rates are expected to remain at a constant 10% per year for the next ten years. Portfolio A has an income objective and seeks to provide maximum income each year. The portfolio is invested 100% in debt securities. Thus, Portfolio A generates $5,000 in income each year.

Prof. Rushen Chahal

24

Growth of Income (cont d)

Example (cont d)
Portfolio B seeks growth of income and contains both debt and equity securities. Portfolio B has an annual total return of 13%. In the first year, Portfolio B provides $3,500 in income (a 7% income yield) and experiences capital appreciation of 5%. The income generated by both portfolios over the next ten years is shown graphically on the following slide.

Prof. Rushen Chahal

25

Growth of Income (cont d)

Example (cont d)
$7,000 $6,000 $5,000 $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 $6,180 $5,000 Portfolio A Portfolio B

Prof. Rushen Chahal

26

Capital Appreciation
The goal is for the portfolio to grow in value and not to generate income Appropriate for investors who have no income needs

Prof. Rushen Chahal

27

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

A major benefit is tax savings
Unrealized capital gains are not taxed Dividend and interest income is taxed

The investor can defer taxes for many years by successful long-term growth stock investing

Prof. Rushen Chahal

28

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example
Consider two $10,000 investments. Both investments have a 10% expected rate of return annually on a pretax basis. Investment A involves the purchase of 500 shares of a $20 common stock that does not pay dividends. Investment B involves the purchase of 500 shares of a $20 common stock that has a constant dividend yield of 7%.

Prof. Rushen Chahal

29

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example (cont d)
Consider an investor in the 28% tax bracket. The investor will hold both investments for four years. The projected cash flows over the next four years for both investments and the corresponding IRR calculations are shown on the next slides.

Prof. Rushen Chahal

30

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Investment A (no dividends) 10% Pretax Annual Return
Year 0 Price Dividends - Tax (28%) Cash Flow $20.00 --$0 1 $22.00 0 0 $0 2 $24.20 0 0 $0 3 $26.62 0 0 $0 4 $29.28 0 0 $29.28
31

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example (cont d)
If the investor does not sell Investment A after four years, his after-tax internal rate of return is:

29.28 20 ! (1  R ) 4 R ! 10.00%
Prof. Rushen Chahal 32

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example (cont d)
If the investor sells Investment A after four years, his year 4 cash flow is reduced by capital gains taxes of $2.60 and his after-tax internal rate of return is:

26.68 20 ! (1  R ) 4 R ! 7.47%
Prof. Rushen Chahal 33

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Investment B (7% dividend yield) 10% Pretax Annual Return
Year 0 Price Dividends - Tax (28%) Cash Flow $20.00 --$0 1 $20.60 1.40 0.39 $1.01 2 $21.22 1.44 0.40 $1.04 3 $21.85 1.49 0.42 $1.07 4 $22.51 1.53 0.43 $23.61
34

Prof. Rushen Chahal

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example (cont d)
If the investor does not sell Investment B after four years, his after-tax internal rate of return is:

1.01 1.04 1.07 23.61 20 !    2 3 4 (1  R ) (1  R ) (1  R ) (1  R) R ! 8.04%

Prof. Rushen Chahal 35

Capital Appreciation (cont d)

Example (cont d)
If the investor sells Investment B after four years, his year 4 cash flows is reduced by capital gains taxes of $0.70, and his after-tax internal rate of return is:

1.01 1.04 1.07 22.91 20 !    2 3 4 (1  R ) (1  R ) (1  R ) (1  R) R ! 7.29%

Prof. Rushen Chahal 36

Tax-Free Income Generation

Accomplished by investing in municipal securities
Free from federal tax and may be free from state and local taxes

Invest directly in municipal bonds for an income strategy Invest in a mix of municipal bonds and common stock for a growth-of-income strategy

Prof. Rushen Chahal

37

Tax-Free Income Generation (cont d)

Invest in a municipal bond mutual fund for a stability of principal strategy Tax-free income generation is unrealistic for a capital appreciation strategy

Prof. Rushen Chahal

38

Portfolio Objectives and Expected Utility

Utility is one of the most useful of all economic concepts
We seek out satisfying things and avoid things that cause discomfort

Utility comes from quantifiable and nonquantifiable sources

E.g., an investor may choose his own stocks rather than investing in mutual funds for the thrill of the hunt

Prof. Rushen Chahal

39

The Importance of Primary & Secondary Objectives

Introduction Possible combinations of objectives

Prof. Rushen Chahal

40

Introduction
The secondary objective indicates what is next in importance after specification of the primary objective
E.g., an investor chose income as the primary objective, but:
Does not want to take a lot of risk with the invested money (stability of principal) Wants to keep up with inflation (growth of income)

Prof. Rushen Chahal

41

Possible Combinations of Objectives

Primary Objective Secondary Objective Stability of Principal Income Growth of Income Capital Appreciation Stability of Principal X Income Debt and Preferred Stock X Varies: often > 40% equity ? Growth of Income Unacceptable Goals At least 40% equity X At least 75% equity Capital Appreciation ?

Short-term debt Unacceptable goals Unacceptable goals

? At least 75% equity X

Prof. Rushen Chahal

42

Other Factors to Consider In Establishing Objectives

Inconsistent objectives Infrequent objectives Portfolio splitting Liquidity The role of cash

Prof. Rushen Chahal

43

Inconsistent Objectives
Certain primary/secondary combinations are incompatible
Primary: stability of principal Secondary: capital appreciation
I want no chance of a loss, but I do want capital gains

Prof. Rushen Chahal

44

Infrequent Objectives
Certain primary/secondary combinations are infrequent
Primary: capital appreciation Secondary: stability of principal
Could invest in low coupon bonds selling at a substantial discount from par and hold the bond to maturity

Prof. Rushen Chahal

45

Portfolio Splitting
A fund manager receives instructions that require that the portfolio be managed in more than one part
E.g., endowment funds

Components will have different objectives A more convenient way of administering the fund than trying to establish a single, overall objective

Prof. Rushen Chahal

46

Liquidity
Liquidity is a measure of the ease with which something can be converted to cash Clients may desire some liquidity
Options: invest a portion of the portfolio in money market mutual funds or cash management accounts at brokerage firms with check-writing privileges

Prof. Rushen Chahal

47

The Role of Cash

Investment management firms routinely prescribe portfolio proportions for:
Equity securities Fixed-income securities Cash
Arrives in portfolios naturally though the receipt of dividends and interest

Prof. Rushen Chahal

48

The Role of Cash (cont d)

Cash contributes to portfolio stability, especially during periods of rising interest rates Cash includes:
Currency Money market instruments
E.g., Treasury bills

Short-term interest-bearing deposit accounts

Prof. Rushen Chahal 49

Portfolio Dedication
Introduction Cash matching Duration matching

Prof. Rushen Chahal

50

Introduction
Portfolio dedication (liability funding) involves managing an asset portfolio so that it services the requirements of a corresponding liability or portfolio of liabilities
Overlays the primary and secondary investment objectives The two principal methods are cash matching and duration matching

Prof. Rushen Chahal

51

Cash Matching
The most common form of portfolio dedication A manager assembles a portfolio of bonds whose cash flows match as nearly as possible the requirements of a particular liability

Prof. Rushen Chahal

52

Duration Matching
Involves constructing a portfolio of assets that pays the bills associated with a liability or stream of liabilities Duration is a measure of interest rate risk
The higher the duration, the greater the fluctuation in the price of a bond due to interest rate changes
Prof. Rushen Chahal 53

Duration Matching (cont d)

In a duration-matched portfolio:
A rise in interest rates results in a decline in the portfolio s value that is approximately offset by additional income earned from the higher reinvestment rate A fall in interest rates results in a decline in income from reinvested funds that is approximately offset by the increase in the market value of the portfolio

Prof. Rushen Chahal

54

Duration Matching (cont d)

There are two keys to duration matching
The duration of the asset portfolio must match the duration of the liabilities The present value of the liabilities to be paid must equal the market value of the asset portfolio

Prof. Rushen Chahal

55