Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Liability Insurance
• Product Liability
• Professional Liability
• Arises if there is a violation of a person’s legal
rights or a failure to perform legal duty owed to
certain person or to society as a whole.
• Classes of legal wrong
– Crime
– Breach of contract
– Tort
Categories of torts
• Intentional torts: assault, battery, trespass, false imprisonment,
fraud, libel, slander and patent and copyright infringement.
• Strict Liability: Rylands vs.Fletcher If a person brings on his land
anything which is likely to do mischief if it escapes, he will be prima
facie answerable for the damage caused by its escape though he
had not been negligent.
• Absolute liability: liability is imposed even without negligence or
fault. Examples
– Occupational injury and disease
– Blasting operations
– Manufacturing of explosives, medicines, food products eg. M C Mehta
vs. Union Of India
– Owning wild or dangerous animals
– Crop spraying by airplanes
• Negligence: failure to exercise standard of care required by law to
protect others from an unreasonable risk of harm.
Defences against negligence
• Contributory negligence
• Comparative negligence
– Pure rule
– 49 percent rule
– 50 percent rule
• Last clear chance rule
• Assumption of risk
Imputed negligence
• Employee employer relationship Vicarious
liability
• Family purpose doctrine
• Joint business venture
Res ipsa loquitur
• Meaning the thing speaks for itself. Injury or
damage establishes a presumption of
negligence on behalf of the defendant.
• Requirements
– The event doesnot happen except in case of
negligence.
– The defendant has exclusive control over the
instrumentality causing the accident.
– The injured has not contributed to the negligence in
any way.
• Muncipal Corporation of Delhi v. Subhagwati
Specific applications of the law of
negligence
• Property owners
– Liability in case of trespasser
– Liability in case of licensee
– Liability in case of invitee.
• Attractive nuisance doctrine : a condition that can attract
and injure children.
• Owners and operators of automobiles
• Governmental liability
• Charitable institutions
• Employee employer
• Parents and children
• Animal owners
Special Tort Liability Problems
• Products Liability: liability of retailer or manufacturer
(privity of contract doctrine)
• Solutions:
– State of the art defense
– Alteration of the product defense
• Professional liability: A genuine error of judgement by
doctors, lawyers, accountants, architects, insurance
brokers, actuaries etc. Spring meadows hospital v.
Harjot Ahluwalia
• Employer’s liability/ workmen’s compensation insurance:
insurance compulsory, ESI Act
• Directors and Officers Liability:
Public Liability Insurance
• For individuals
• Third party insurance
• Business risks
• The public Liability Insurance Act,1991:
mandatory for installations handling
hazardous substances.
Characteristics of liability insurance
• Liability may be by litigation, arbitration or
agreement.
• Loss is the sum finally determined by law. Law
means both statutory as well as common law.
• Potential liability is open-ended.
• Claimant is not the insured but a third party.
• Two stages of claims processing.
– Whether the policy covers the claim or not;
– Whether the insured is legally liable to pay or not. If
yes, how the amount is to be determined.
Origin and development of liability
insurance in India
• Enactment of Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923, Motor
Vehicles Act,1939 and compulsory third party insurance.
• Bhopal Gas Tragedy in 1984.
• Environment Protection Act,1986, Public Liability
Insurance Act,1991.
• Consumer Protection Act,1986
• Employees State Insurance Act,1948
• Supreme Court decision in the case of Shriram Food &
Fertilizer Industries (vide M.C Mehta vs, Union of India)
ruled that civil liability of corporation for torts also
attached to directors and other officers.
PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE
• Coverage :
– Liability to a person and his dependants for death or injury,
– Liability for damage to property,
– Liability for legal costs involved in defending the case irrespective of
whether the case gets decided for or against the insured.
• Add on benefits by paying additional premium
– Liability due to Pollution
– Liability during transportation of material including hazardous ones
outside factory premises
– Liability because of effluents discharge through pipelines
– Earthquake risk
– Technical collaborators liability.
• Target Group: A whole range of industries starting from a humble
bakery or a beedi rolling unit to hi-tech aircraft hangers, chemical
manufacturing plants, hydroelectric power stations and ship building
units.
What is the Amount of Cover
Available?
• AOA (any one accident) limit and AOY (any one year)/AOP (any
one period) limits.
• But there is a restriction that only four ratios are permitted for AOA
to AOY, i.e., 1:1, 1:2, 1:3 and 1:4.
• So, if an AOA limit of Rs. 50 Lacs is selected, the AOY limits can
either be Rs. 50, 100, 150 or 200 Lacs.
• It is also important to remember that these limits are inclusive of all
legal costs likely to be incurred.
• Factors to be considered for deciding the premium:
– Risk group of the industry
– Limit of AOA
– Ratio of AOA to AOY
– If more than one unit is to be covered in the policy, number of units
– Turnover of the business
– Additional covers opted for
What Risks are not Covered in
the Policy?
• Excess: The first 0.5% of the AOA limit (subject to a
maximum of Rs. 2 lacs) for each claim is deducted from
the claim
• Liability assumed by any specific contract
• Loss of goodwill, market, etc.
• Punitive or exemplary damages
• Specific liabilities covered elsewhere such as liability due
to the use of a motor vehicle, aircraft, watercraft,
hovercraft, etc.
• Liability covered under Public Liability Act of 1991
• Liability arising due to war, civil war, etc.
• Liability due to radiation or contamination from
radioactivity.
What is the Claims procedure?
• Liability claims are said to have a “long tail”, i.e., an incident occurring at
one point of time can produce an effect much later. Claims made vs.
occurrence coverage.
• So, the policy provides for special relaxations to the insured to register and
get claims from an Insurance company much after the first incident has
occurred provided the policy has been kept in force and all premiums paid
on time.
• Normal steps for making a claim are as follows:
– Inform Insurers as soon as possible of any incident, which may produce
a liability claim at a future date.
– The rule is to settle claims through the legal channel only. However, if
the liability is clear, the insurer may prefer to compromise the claim out
of court.
– The basic assessment is of actual monetary loss suffered due to the
incident. Some component of pain and suffering as well as loss of future
earnings also are considered.
– The peculiarity of a liability claim is that the insured does not have to do
very much except providing the Insurer the information asked for.
Insurer does the final settlement with the affected party.
Directors’ and officers’ Liability
Policy
• Coverage: ‘Loss’ shall mean legal liability of the directors or officers to pay
damages or costs awarded against them and costs and expenses incurred
by the directors or Officers with the written consent of underwriters in
respect of investigation, defense or settlement of any claim.
• A wrongful Act shall mean actual or alleged breach of duty, breach of trust,
neglect, misstatement, misleading statement, omission, and breach of
warranty of authority or other act done or wrongly attempted by any Director
or Officers.
• Claims : Any writ or summons issued against or served upon any directors
or officers for any Wrongful Act, or,
• Any written communication alleging a wrongful Act communicated to any
Director or Officer.
• Loss arising from claim first made against the Directors or Officers where
company is required or permitted to indemnify the Directors or Officers
pursuant to the law, common or statutory, or the Memorandum and Articles
of Association
• Company reimbursement provision shall be applicable if such an obligation
is expressly mentioned in the Company’s Articles of Association or in an
agreement between the company and the concerned director or officers.
Exclusions
• Legal action or litigation brought in a court of law within the Excluded
Territories
• Indemnity or payment is available from any source, other than the policy.
• Any actual or alleged bodily injury, sickness, disease or death of any person
or any tangible property, including loss of use thereof arising out of, any
actual or alleged seepage, pollution or contamination of any kind . (This is a
subject matter of public liability policy)
• Made by any third party based upon breach of any professional duty owed
to such third party. (This is a subject matter of a professional indemnity
policy).
• Brought about by any circumstances existing prior to or at the inception date
of the policy and which the directors or officers or the company knew or
ought reasonably to have known could give rise to a claim.
• For tax or fines or penalties or punitive or exemplary or multiple damages or
any claim deemed uninsurable under law.
• Based upon, actual or alleged libel, slander, infringement of copyright,
infringement of patent (separate policies can be availed of)
• Directly, resulting from goods or products manufactured or sold or supplied
by the company (this is a subject-matter of products liability policy).
Professional Liability Insurance
• Also referred as Malpractice policies or errors-and-
omissions policies.
• Professional vs. other liability contracts
• Insurer needs consent of insured to settle claims out of
court as it may damage the reputation of the
professional.
• Limit of liability not by per accident but in terms of per
claim.
• The act that gives rise to the claim is not accidental but
deliberate.
• The policy responds to suits based on professional’s
error, mistake or malpractice but not to warranty
successful results.
Commercial General Liability and
Commercial Umbrella Policy
• Under CGL one can insure general products and completed
operations liability; personal injury; advertising liability; medical
payments; and liability for damage to premises rented to the
insured. Two options for events that trigger coverage: claims made
and occurrence.
• Commercial umbrella policy is purchased to pay for catastrophic
losses. In this case the insurer will require primary insurance in form
of CGL, a business auto policy, workers compensation policy etc.
• Coverage under the umbrella includes property in the insured’s
care, custody and control, worldwide products coverage.
• Umbrellas are written with few exclusions, and endorsements are
used to limit coverage. However, in primary policies, endorsements
are used to broaden the coverage.
• For higher liability coverage, excess umbrella policies may be
purchased.
Property Insurance- Non Life
Insurance
• Marine Insurance
• Motor Insurance
• Fire Insurance
• Health Insurance
• Project and Engineering Insurance
Marine Insurance
• Ocean marine insurance
– Hull insurance
– Cargo insurance
– Protection and indemnity insurance
– Freight insurance
• Inland marine insurance
• Hull Insurance deals the Loss associated with
floating crafts, Cargo insurance provides cover
in respect of loss or damage to goods during
transit by rail, road, sea or air.
TYPES OF MARINE INSURANCE
POLICIES
• Voyage Policy
• Annual policy
• Open cover
• Duty policy
• Marine Cum Erection Policy
MARINE CARGO SALE
CONTRACTS - TYPES
TYPE OF CONTRACT RESPONSIBILITY
•MARINE PERILS
•EXTRANEOUS PERILS
Age
of
S-Curve of
Insurance Market Nascent Transitional Fully Mature
Development Market Market Market
Insurance
Penetration
(Premiums /
GDP)
India US
China Japan
UK
Brazil
South
Korea
Economic Strength
Regulatory Environment
Competitive Environment
Consumer Demand
Established Distribution
20%
4.0%
16% 3.5%
3.0%
12% Insurance Density increased
2.4%
2.3%
8%
12.9%
15.7% by a 5-year 18% compound
11.7%
4% 7.6% 9.1%
annual growth rate
0%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Life Premium Per C apita Nonlife Premium Per C apita
3.5%
3.0% 0.67% 0.65%
2.5% 0.62%
0.55%
0.56% Insurance Penetration can
2.0%
1.5% be described as “embryonic”
2.59% 2.26% 2.52%
2.15%
1.0% 1.77% at this stage
0.5%
0.0%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Life Premium % GDP Nonlife Premium % GDP
India 20%
India 18%
Brazil 10%
Brazil 8%
Russia 33% Russia 34%
China 25% China 25%
2004 Penetration
4
3.5 High growth and low penetration
3 0.65 position India, Russia and China for
1.05
2.5
1.63 unlimited market development
2
2.21
1.5 potential. India has put in place the
2.53 2.21
1 liberalization and regulation process
1.36
0.5 0.62 to make it happen.
0
India Brazil Russia China
Life Premium % of GDP Nonlife Premium % of GDP
Insurance Penetratin
3.26 3.17
2.71 3.14
2.32 2.88
1.93
Insurance Penetratin
Insurance Density
(% of Premium to Total Population)
Market 2003 2004 2005
22.7
Insurance Density
14.7 19.7
16.4
9.9
11.5
8.5
Insurance Density
Financial Services-Still a long way to
go
• Savings accounts 30
• Insurance Policies 04
• Shares and Mutual Funds 02
• General Insurance 2.5
• Health Insurance 0.2
• Credit Cards 03
• Debit Cards 5.6
• Small Overdrafts 3.6
• Entrepreneurial Credit 02
Figures in % of population
Government-owned Companies
Privately-owned Companies
Sources: Swiss Re/sigma
* government-owned
Booming Insurance Industry
4000.00
Total Premium ($)
3000.00
2000.00
1000.00
0.00
1999-00 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06
Year
52.89
47.25
No of New Policies sold
43.56 41.73
35.46
(million)
28.63
25.37 26.21
16.91
Companies (No. of New
Market Share of Private
Policies Issued)
10.81 10.91
7.91
8.52
3.85
5.79
3.25
70000
64720.33
60000
50000
million)
40000
30000
20000 18818.6
10000 0.01
4220.77
0 664.77 0.48 1.76 5.31
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06
Year
• Economy of operations
• Better returns
• Service Excellence
Regulator as Developer
• Shouldering the responsibility of developing
nascent insurance market
• Striking a right balance between developing
and regulating the industry
• Protection of Policy holders’ Interests – Mission
of IRDA
• Interests of policy holders prime objective while
framing regulations
Regulatory role - consumer
protection
• Insurance Advertisement and Disclosures
regulations, 2000
• Protection of Policy holders’ interests
regulations, 2002
• Maintenance of Minimum Solvency Margins
• Introduction of cashless transactions – TPAs
Regulatory role - consumer
protection
• Widening of Distribution Channels – Increased
Insurance accessibility
• Regulatory norms for intermediaries
– Licensing of Insurance (individual) Agents – 2000
– Licensing of Corporate Agents – 2002
– Insurance Brokers – 2002
• Entry of Banks under ‘Bancassurance’ model
• Mandatory Training, Pre-recruitment exam before
licensing
• Accreditation of Training Institutes – Upkeep of
training standards for intermediaries
Regulatory role - consumer
protection
• Monitoring of underwriting policy through File
and Use
• Constitution of Grievances Redressal Cell
– Indication of operational inadequacies – triggering
regulatory intervention
• Committee to study existing grievances’
mechanism to formulate uniform guidelines
Development Oriented Regulations
Spread of Insurance to all sections
• Press Releases
Role of Insurers